14 ms·
$35 sculpture found at an Austin Goodwill was looted from a museum during WWII
- IAmGraydon 5y agoShe paid $35 for a piece of art that was stolen by Nazis and felt that she had the right to “negotiate” the terms of its return? How about just give it back?
- phs318u 5y agoGive it back to whom exactly? How does she know who the "rightful" owner is without knowing its provenance? Possessing looted art is not a good look and neither is transmitting (wittingly or not) to a party that isn't the rightful owner. She did the smart thing.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoThe article clearly states it was from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pompejanum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pompejanum
- robonerd 5y agoThat wiki page and the article clearly state this museum was built in the 1840s. So what is your basis for asserting this sculpture was stolen by nazis?
- elliekelly 5y agoFrom the article it sounds like it was stolen from the German people by an American soldier.
- rdtwo 5y agoThe German people stole it from someone else so why does it matter
- IAmGraydon 5y agoYou’re basing this statement on what?
- robonerd 5y agoYou don't know that. The German museum it was in was built in the 1840s, a hundred years before this sculpture was looted from it. It may well have been legally purchased a century or more before nazis existed.
- asdff 5y agoI could not imagine that whatever this process must have looked like in the 1840s was completely bilateral for all parties. This was the era where you just sent an archaeologist and got some local day laborers to dig where you heard there might be good stuff, and took whatever you wanted back no questions asked.
- DaedPsyker 5y agoRoman artefacts are dug up all over western Europe and even further. Is your premise that only one country is the allowed descendants of the Empire and that other constituted parts of the Empire aren't allowed their shared legacy?
- robonerd 5y ago> I could not imagine that whatever this process must have looked like in the 1840s was completely bilateral for all parties Then let me help your imagination: A rich Bavarian king frequently goes on holiday in Italy, as was the fashion in Europe at the time. There, he regularly meets and intermingles with rich Italians who share his interests in antiquities. He purchases numerous artifacts from them, at a price both agree is fair.
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- O__________O 5y agoOdd, why is this Roman sculpture being returned to Germany? It’s obviously not a German artifact and while I might be wrong, I assume it was “looted” from Italy.
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> It’s obviously not a German artifact Why is it "obviously" not? The subject was named Drusus Germanicus, after all. The Roman Empire covered everything from Great Britain to the Persian Gulf. Artifacts produced anywhere in that (very large) region could be described as "Roman".
- conk 5y ago“Another auction house managed to find the head in a catalog of items from a German museum in the 1920s and 1930s.” Per the article it was looted from a German museum. How the german museum acquired it originally is anyones guess. But it’s possible it was legally acquired at some point over the past 1900 years.
- jart 5y agoIt was legally acquired by the woman who just paid $35 at Goodwill. The thing is two thousand years old. Why do people care who owned it during the Weimar Republic?
- shadowgovt 5y agoPeople get funny of the provenance of things that were taken by military force, go figure. I'm trying to remember which state it is that periodically asks for their Confederate flag back from the Union state that acquired it on the battlefield.
- jlund-molfese 5y agoInteresting! I hadn’t heard of that issue before. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/28th_Virginia_battle_flag https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/28th_Virginia_battle_flag
- tpmx 5y agoBack at home, Young had a problem: She was in possession of a looted piece of ancient art. She couldn't keep it. She couldn't sell it. And giving it back to its rightful owners was a lot harder than it sounds. “At that point, I realized I was probably going to need some help,” Young says. “I was probably going to need an attorney.” So she hired a lawyer in New York who specializes in international art law, Leila Amineddoleh. I don't really understand why it would be hard or complicated, unless she wanted a payout.
- throwanem 5y ago> I don't really understand why it would be hard or complicated Why would you expect a priori to understand? Or have you dealt in the past with a meaningfully comparable problem, and found it easy and simple?
- pigtailgirl 5y agoUnder the 4th Geneva Convention - looting is a war crime. If you know you're in possession of ill gotten gains - one should always obtain legal advice -
- tpmx 5y agoOr you could just keep the receipt from Goodwill and use your money in more better ways than paying a lawyer.
- 650REDHAIR 5y agoBut that’s not how the real world works. She 100% did the right thing here. And frankly she deserves a payout for all of the legwork.
- tpmx 5y agoShe deserves a payout because she spent money a on lawyer to get a payout? That seems circular.
- tomcam 5y agoWhat amazes me about all these stories is the ridiculously low prices the thrift store charged. Here in the Seattle area, everything seems to grossly overpriced in thrift stores.
- Arainach 5y agoGoodwill in particular moves items between markets and prices them based on the local economy. Gone are the days of 2010 when you could walk into the Bellevue Goodwill and find lightly used designer clothing that some retired Microsoft engineer was tired of. Now everything's priced higher than eBay and there's no reason to stop by. Everyone else wants to be a "Boutique" and charge high end prices for used goods. Blame Macklemore?
- dleslie 5y agoI suspect that it's largely because Goodwill and Sally Ann became unofficial suppliers for vintage clothing stores. They probably upped their prices in response to that market. And now Facebook neighborhood free groups are (often unknowingly) supplying such stores; as well as folks simply turning around and relisting on Facebook marketplace.
- pessimizer 5y agoThey've been that for at least 30 years. When I was a kid a friend of mine had a vintage shop in Portland, OR, and they got first crack at what came into a couple of local thrift stores. This was official - vintage shop people would show up at a specific time while the stuff was still in bins and pick through it before it went into the store.
- alimov 5y agoA lot of people that I know and know of shop at goodwill and then resell the items on places like Depop (marked up). I also know of some boutiques that have a similar tactic. It’s worth it to some people to buy marked up items from these places and individuals because going and finding something at goodwill can be a pain and there’s no guarantee you will find anything worthwhile anyway. I think goodwill has caught onto this and has decided to raise prices on some goods.
- Ansil849 5y ago> She was in possession of a looted piece of ancient art. She couldn't keep it. I don't understand. Museums in the West are full of looted ancient art [1]. Why are they allowed to keep it, but this woman cannot keep this one item? [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/16/learning/should-museums-return-looted-artifacts-to-their-countries-of-origin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/16/learning/should-museums-r...
- anitil 5y agoCan I recommend a podcast called 'Stuff the British Stole' by Marc Fenell (aka 'That Movie ... Guy'). It looks at exactly this, including situations where an artefact only exists _because_ it was stolen. http://www.marcfennell.com/stolen http://www.marcfennell.com/stolen (Sorry I couldn't find the RSS feed)
- Ansil849 5y ago
- Cerium 5y agoUnfortunately a lot of the old art in the world only exists because by modern reconing it was stolen. Consider the fabulous collection at the palace museum in Taipei. Much just like it was destroyed in the cultural revolution.
- Ansil849 5y agoAgain... > That sounds like an a posteriori justification for stealing, like saying "see, that building ended up being bombed, so it's a good thing I stole all these Ukrainian paintings from the country last year". The logical fallacy here is using one unrelated bad event to justify another unrelated bad event. Taken to its logical conclusion, this argument would be that we should constantly keep looting art left and right, because who knows where and what is going to be destroyed at any moment.
- jdonaldson 5y agoOne problem with NFTs is that it's harder for them to be stolen. And once lost, they can never be recovered.
- toxicFork 5y agoScreenshot. The art is not the NFT. The person only "owns" a hash code that points to the art.
- jandrese 5y agoIt's harder to steal them because there is nothing to steal. The "art" is programmatically generated and can be instantly created by anybody at any time. It is like having someone steal your grocery store receipt and then worrying that you're going to starve even those the food is still in your fridge.
- Tepix 5y agoThere's nothing stopping you from creating a NFT that the original author can mark as invalid.
- i386 5y agoNo. Just no.
- purple_ferret 5y ago>Finally, they got a deal: The Germans would take Dennis back. The exact terms of the deal are confidential, Wished they at least said what it would go for on the open market, so we could get a hint of how much she banked!
- smiddereens 5y ago
- ada1981 5y agoI don’t think Germany gets to reclaim “looted” art.
- LA-resident 5y agoElon Musk wants his bust back!
- ryan_j_naughton 5y agoThe Germans don't really have any more right to it than she does. The most likely story of this bust is from the 5th century until the 18th or 19th centuries, it was buried in the ground somewhere in Italy or former Roman empire. The person who dug it up and sold it didn't really have an inherent right to it. They just found it. I say all this not from a legal perspective but from an inheritors of history and culture perspective. We all inherit humanity's history and culture. While cheesy, Indiana Jones was right: "It belongs in a museum" so it is accessible to humanity. But is that museum inherently this German one?
- golergka 5y ago> The person who dug it up and sold it didn't really have an inherent right to it. They just found it. I don't get it. Why wouldn't a person who found it have a right to it?
- ricardobeat 5y agoIf you travel to Pompeii right now, “find” a Roman vase and bring it home, did you have a right to it?
- theshrike79 5y agoIf I go and dig up a fresh grave right now and steal all the valuables, do I have a "right" to those? How old does the grave, in your opinion, have to be for me to get that right?
- hef19898 5y agoIn most places, you don't. Even if the land is yours, the state has the ownership rights. You can get a decompensation so. Which sucks in cases were they find some roman ruins when digging the basement of your house... But then you can also find WW2 bombs were I live, luckily, they didn't find neither under our house.
- rhplus 5y agoNot Italy, but as an example, the legal process for the UK is described here: https://www.gov.uk/treasure https://www.gov.uk/treasure I'd assume other European countries have similar laws and processes.
- m463 5y agoBut how did the german museum get it?
- robonerd 5y agoThe article doesn't say and I haven't been able to find any information about that online. However it seems likely that it was purchased in Italy by Ludwig I of Bavaria, sometime in the early 19th century. Ludwig I made the museum in 1840, and was known for buying art and antiquities in Italy.
- jaapz 5y agoJust here to note that "kut.org" is a pretty funny domain name if you speak Dutch
- rambambram 5y agoJust here to note that I also had a little smile about this.
- fziz 5y agoTry reading the about page without chuckling: https://www.kut.org/about https://www.kut.org/about