12 ms·
At one company I worked at only one thing mattered: the yearly bonus
- GoOnThenDoTell 5y agoIve never really understood bonuses for engineers, just provide more base pay
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoSince it's so hard to fire people, it's better for the company to have 50% of your salary as a bonus. Even most people that are doing nothing can probably do nothing somewhere else for 100% or their salary. If you do nothing at the company, they can pay you $0 bonus and hope you get mad and quit and go do nothing somewhere else instead.
- Agingcoder 5y agoIt's cheaper for the company, essentially trading mean for variance. Bad years, you have a trivial pay cut (no to low bonus), good years people get money. If you have very high base pay, bad years you lose money. If you're young, volatility is ok. If you're getting older and have kids, then you value certainty a bit more and want higher base pay, but you might make less money overall (say 2 dollars bonus is equal to 1 guaranteed dollar, but this is obviously highly dependent on the company/sector)
- exdsq 5y agoPart of the fun of the Web3 startup scene is that tokens can be liquid out of gate and are basically just a variable in a file to begin with, so trivial to make out of thin air for new hires. There's stories of 20-somethings getting 7 or even 8 figure pay days after 6 months work from a successful launch.
- coliveira 5y agoIf they give a base pay increase, then they can't take it from you next year! This is how FAANG companies work, give you a lot of incentives in the form of one time bonus, so if they don't like you they will take most of your future compensation in the next year. They also keep you working as a dog to keep your total compensation from falling.
- joshgachnang 5y agoI agree. My view is if I don't get 100% bonus, I'm leaving to find a company that will pay me 100%. It seems like a good way to lose your best engineers.
- b8 5y agoHedge funds are an example of the bonus impact because most pay out the majority of their employees TC via bonuses and from what I've read tends to lead to a high stress work environment. I can understand how bonuses could be intended to be for incentives to deliver work and perhaps as golden handcuffs (RSU bonuses that require a couple of years to vest etc), but yeah there's pitfalls etc.
- lordnacho 5y agoBut the bonus is just an incentive mechanism. The question really is what things influenced the bonus award? Sensible things or not so sensible things? Did they tie the bonus to things that the company wanted or not?
- t_mann 5y agoNo matter which measures you choose, as soon as you tie financial incentives to them, people will find ways to pervert what they're supposed to measure. That observation is so general that there's even a name for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- masklinn 5y ago> But the bonus is just an incentive mechanism. Sure. It's an incentive mechanism to be seen as better than your peers. > The question really is what things influenced the bonus award? Sensible things or not so sensible things? Did they tie the bonus to things that the company wanted or not? They tied the bonus to "being a top performer": > Then tie the bonuses to some shadowy and illusory "peer review" system and watch the sparks fly. But frankly any time bonuses are involved the risks shoot up exponentially. For instance sales are commonly highly bonus-based, and as a result at least in software they will promise any and everything to the client so they can close and get that sweet, sweet bonus, and let everyone else hold the bag when the client finds out there was only a very tenuous relationship between their promises and reality.
- Mr_P 5y agoIf you replace the word "bonus" with "promo", then you unfortunately get an eerily-accurate reflection of the state of FAANG companies.
- sombremesa 5y agoYep. The best time to get a promotion is as you interview. The second best time is now...at another company. Thankfully, at a large company with plenty of hard problems to solve (and smart folks to work with), you can grow quite a lot whether or not the company chooses to recognize said growth.
- wbl 5y agoI worked at a company where promotion was not on the table. So I left. No matter how much work I did or how good I got, it would not get rewarded and people who wanted to get good and who I could learn from would also leave. Rewarding people is hard. But you can't shirk from it unless you want people to leave.
- mabbo 5y agoGood God yes. Once my team owned a service that did X. Among it's functionality, it had an API that, as a side effect, stored some data that could be retrieved. Sadly, this service had no validation that the data being input made any sense in the context of what this service did. A developer on a neighboring team had a big promo project on the go. As a simple hack, and as a way to save time, his project used our service as a basic key value store database. They already called this service for the correct functionality, so they had access keys. The stuff he was storing could be argued to kind of make sense, but as the owners of this service we said "no fucking way, we aren't your database". He escalated to management who knew he was going to quit if he didn't get his promo. They overruled and last I heard that service was still being used as that asshole's database. He did promise to fix it right after the project launched, but the second he had his promo he changed orgs. For some reason, Amazon is full of this sort of terrible tech debt and they can't figure out why everyone has to be on terrible on call rotations.
- Jasper_ 5y ago
- t_mann 5y ago6-7 figure bonuses for mid-20's, or the story of how we got a global financial crisis in '08. Seems to work wonders in tech too.
- mistrial9 5y agoconflating symptoms and carriers here
- t_mann 5y agoBonuses were not a symptom of the crisis, if you look at what products were at the heart of things like the Lehman Brothers collapse, who created, traded and sold them, and what incentives they had individually, you'll see that those bonuses go right to the heart of the problem.
- lr4444lr 5y agoThe smartest piece of advice I ever got on bonuses: they are part of your salary that your employer reserves the right to discretionarily not pay you. I consider bonuses of absolutely no account in a comp package. If they are given, I happily accept. If not, I have no disappointment. I give the company my diligent efforts because I care about my responsibilities and my colleagues regardless. A carrot on a treadmill isn't going to change that.
- t_mann 5y agoYou say that now, but once you actually are in such a position and you realize that you could pay off your college debt plus your mortgage in 2-3 years, things might change in your mind.
- lr4444lr 5y agoAt the companies where the bonuses could reasonably be that high, I'd probably rather have stock options - because those are contractually mine.
- ipaddr 5y agoWhen you count on that bonus that came last year it could mean that mortgage goes under. Making a lot of money is great until it doesn't come for whatever reason.
- m12k 5y agoA tech company in Bellevue Washington with a "shadowy and illusory "peer review" system" - this is Valve we're talking about, right? (fits his Twitter bio)
- exdsq 5y agoJust coming to say that - he's not the best at keeping things secret lol.
- daenz 5y agoThere's a difference between keeping a secret, and avoiding legal trouble by not specifically naming an employer.
- nindalf 5y agoIs Valve really going to file a lawsuit against him and argue in court whether this actually happened or not? They're not. Do they even have grounds to file a lawsuit? Likely not, American courts aren't that sympathetic to libel claims. But let's assume for a minute that what you're saying has some merit. Maybe Valve does have grounds to sue. And maybe they're interested in suing. In that case, is this lousy attempt at being coy helpful? It's clear from his bio that he's only worked at one such company. So it's abundantly clear to everyone who he's working for. In reality, this pattern ("worked for a large software-advertising company with a double O in it's name") is fucking annoying. It's designed to make the reader curious and more likely to read the rest of what's written. It's similar to clickbait in that sense. And I wish to God it would stop. I'd request people to please just name names, or keep it yourself.
- devwastaken 5y agoAmerican civil system is not based on merit or reason. Anyone can file for any reason, any decent lawyer can make some claims that will require you to argue against, else they be automatically defaulted to true and you lose. It doesn't matter if the big corp wins or not, the toll it takes on you is threat enough. This isn't about civil disputes anyways. No employer wants to see a prospective new hire trash talking their previous company. Doesn't matter if it's deserved or not, it's seen as a liability.
- 300bps 5y agoAnother thing that happens that I didn’t see mentioned is that people at higher levels will only allow incompetent people to be promoted to their level. If they allowed the best people to get promoted to their level, it would adversely impact their own bonuses and career. So instead they fight to get incompetent people promoted to their level so they have no competition.
- t_mann 5y agoHe does mention it at the hiring stage.
- otikik 5y agoReferral bonuses are ok. The rest of the bonuses… naah not for me
- krasin 5y agoSmall peer bonuses work well for "going above and beyond". But they are not common.
- tayo42 5y agoI don't get why you need to sabotage others? Does your bonus size shrink if others get a bonus or something?
- randyrand 5y agoyes. that’s pretty typical. managers get a lump sum to distribute among the team, at least at Apple.
- solenoidalslide 5y agoAll those managers seem to think it's a good enough motivator to keep it around.
- masklinn 5y agoIt's certainly a good way to have a lot of monkeys jumping when you say so.
- cornel_io 5y agoThat's not even stack ranking - managers being assigned a fixed pool of $ to give out for raises and bonuses across their reports (or their branch of the org tree if director or above) is pretty standard at any big company. It's pretty reasonable if you "ship your org chart" and can easily measure each team's contribution. It's much trickier and more prone to unfair allocation when people switch teams a lot or contribute outside their team, i.e. if one of my engineers went above and beyond and boosted some other team's profits by a bunch, I'm probably not going to get extra money to allocate to my people as a result since the higher level execs don't usually follow credit assignment at that level.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoBonus pool competition is typically zero sum. For you to get more, someone must get less.
- cornel_io 5y ago
- lesgobrandon 5y ago
- Justin_K 5y agoBehavior follows compensation
- daenz 5y agoMany people are highlighting the zero-sum nature of bonuses. I wonder how much of this problem goes away if bonuses are no longer zero-sum. In theory, it shouldn't even cost the business more money, because everyone who meets the bonus requirements should get a bonus, in either system.
- throwawaysleep 5y agoI think a large part of the problem is that bonuses are often based on comparables, so the bonus requirement is being in the top 10% of people. That is technically a requirement, but still zero sum.
- doktorhladnjak 5y agoAt the end of the day, there’s a bonus budget which makes bonuses more or less zero sum.
- __derek__ 5y ago> If you want to see how crazy and mental tech people can get, start making the bulk of their income dependent on 6-7 figure bonuses. This is unrelated to "tech" people. It's a common trope for shows about bankers, attorneys, consultants, etc.
- t-writescode 5y agoValve has been known to pay… as much as(?) 10x the person’s salary in bonuses.
- krallja 5y agoThe only bonus I have ever received which didn’t make me feel scummy was profit-sharing. Most companies don’t do it because profit is for the owners. Everything else just feels like a way to decide whether or not to pay me what I’m worth after I’ve already done the work
- t_mann 5y agoHow is that different? Somehow we have to measure what your individual contribution to the company's profits was, which, unless you work in sales maybe, is going to involve a lot of judgment.
- jameshart 5y agoAt Wrox Press during the dotcom era editorial staff were comped with direct sales-derived royalties. Was the most connected I have ever been to a metric that clearly mattered to the business. There were some perverse incentives - people wanted to work on bestsellers, there was jockeying for credit for carryover work from previous editions, but in general it promoted a creative energy around trying to publish hit books, editors had a good deal of direct ownership that could actually impact the product they were shipping, and the scheme even helped align you on the same team as authors, whose compensation is also royalty driven - where for many other publishers author royalties are almost in conflict with what the publisher wants from the deal. Such a direct unit sales driven profit share is hard to imagine engineering into many other businesses but it’s always stood out to me as a remarkably powerful model.
- t_mann 5y agoYeah, everywhere that's close to sales it's usually possible to attribute revenue shares directly. But even in those organizations a lot of people will be doing work that can't be directly measured (IT, accounting,...), so either you cut those people out of bonuses or you find some metrics to include them.
- jameshart 5y ago
- uncomputation 5y ago> Programmers will purposely subtly sabotage key utility functions, methods, or systems to prevent their bonus competitors This seems like a potentially self-destructive way to accomplish this. Not sure what company he is referring to, but at all I have worked at, this would be filed as a bug report and a quick git blame tells you all you need to know. Over time, if your name keeps coming up in that commit log, you'll get a bad reputation and your code in particular will acquire a smell ("Oh Bob, wrote this code... better be careful here," etc.)
- nraynaud 5y agoI was thinking of subtle stuff when I read it. Like not providing a list function for the front people to pre-fill a combo box, forcing them to display a crappy open ended text field.
- hedora 5y agoBy the time that happens, Bob has been promoted out of the team, or transferred somewhere where people don't read his code.
- SEJeff 5y agoBig end of year bonuses are par for the course (in addition to a nice salary) in finance. I've worked as an engineer in the industry for close to 15 years.
- hahaxdxd123 5y agoFinance (I'm thinking prop trading) seems different from Valve. You eat what you kill - if you're sabotaging team members you're not making money. If you're at Valve, you can count on your monopoly still printing money while you carve out pieces of the pie for yourself. Any negative effects from your work will be felt years later when you're long gone.
- SEJeff 5y agoI in fact work in prop trading. Our owner was once asked about more people joining the team as we grew making the bonus pool smaller. He (rightfully) said that the team member should focus on making the pie bigger than getting a bigger slice of a small pie. It’s worked out very well for us.
- zuhayeer 5y agoThis reminds me of the structure used at many high frequency trading firms today. The nature of the work in quant work is different and likely much easier to tie to financial output. But the bonuses can sometimes even go up to 5x the base: https://www.levels.fyi/company/Hudson-River-Trading/salaries/Software-Engineer/ https://www.levels.fyi/company/Hudson-River-Trading/salaries...
- moron4hire 5y ago
- daenz 5y agoAd hominem attack.
- moron4hire 5y agoNo, it's evidence that he over reacts to minor issues, marking his criticisms in general as not particularly trustworthy.
- daenz 5y agoI don't know either of you, so I don't have a dog in a fight. But when you start a post off with " so and so is a phenomenal asshole", You should know that a reasonable person reads that as an ad hominem attack, regardless of how you intended it.
- filoleg 5y ago> But when you start a post off with "so and so is a phenomenal asshole", You should know that a reasonable person reads that as an ad hominem attack I would expect a reasonable person to read through the entire comment and not just the first sentence, before assessing the validity of the point the author was making.
- daenz 5y agoThe rest of the comment supports the first sentence.
- moron4hire 5y agoYes. Without a supporting statement, it's ad hominem. But I provided a supporting statement. This is the issue I'm taking about: https://mobile.twitter.com/richgel999/status/1464435786808504332 https://mobile.twitter.com/richgel999/status/146443578680850... Which links to here: https://github.com/phoboslab/qoi/issues/35 https://github.com/phoboslab/qoi/issues/35 It got so bad even John Carmack told him he was out of line: https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1464639553046728709?s=20&t=cLeah7KdXrz0TGaU4iOsNA https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1464639553046728709... Where everyone agrees, yes, the image should be removed. They didn't know about its history. Would he please stop being a gigantic asshole about it. So if that's not blowing things out of proportion, I don't know what is.
- agumonkey 5y agoOh this is fascinating to me. Since I joined the workforce back 5 years ago (non IT and IT) I've witnessed so much bs on every side. Everything he describes I've seen. People spend more time tricking the game than I'd ever thought possible. That said I'm shocked devs are playing too since they have a comfy life. I guess it just taps into the same primitive reptilian brain reflexes.
- rootusrootus 5y agoWhen we have gotten to the point where 5 years of bonus might very well give you an entirely feasible retirement nest egg, I'm not surprised people go to great lengths to game it. Most of us go our entire careers to build the retirement fund that some people get in 5 years at Google.
- pizza234 5y ago> That said I'm shocked devs are playing too since they have a comfy life. I guess it just taps into the same primitive reptilian brain reflexes. An interesting firsthand view on the dynamics of the motivations comes from HN post from some times ago (https://frantic.im/leaving-facebook https://frantic.im/leaving-facebook). Some excerpts: > The salary is high. Facebook aims to pay top 5% compensation in the market (we’ll get back to that). This makes a lot of other things very comfortable: you can go to a restaurant without worrying too much about the bill, get a nicer car, a nicer house, better stuff. > The benefits are top notch. Almost every doctor I visited said “wow” when looking at the health insurance. It’s very comfortable to know that you are likely not going to receive a huge bill for doing an ultra sound for a routine checkup. > Then there’s the Prestige. Facebook gets a lot of blame in media lately, but in everyday life it’s still very prestigious place to be working at. Getting a mortgage or a car loan is easy, saying you work for Facebook gets you on the fast line. All the benefits above, in one way or another, are relative¹ ("niceR" car, not "nice" car) so ultimately, it's a matter of aspiring because aspiring, rather than aspiring to reach a certain level. So unfortunately, being a developer with a comfy life tends not to have an effect on ethics. Note: the above statements give an unfair image of the author/full article; the extracts are only meant to give an idea of certain dynamics. ¹=with bottom limits; being too poor certainly hurts.
- alkonaut 5y agoSounds like bonuses were based on individual rather than company goals. That sounds absolutely mental. Why would anyone create a setup like that?
- mruniverse 5y agoWhat's the best incentive system for both employee and company?
- M2Ys4U 5y agoSurely it has to be profit sharing - split a healthy chunk of profit between employees as an equal percentage of their base salary. Everyone is incentivised to make the company more profitable, no individual/team/department/division can siphon bonuses from anybody else.
- mruniverse 5y agoDo you think giving RSUs is about the same?
- Rastonbury 5y agoNot so easy in practice, let's say a company has to make a big investment (acquisition/enter a new market/new product), employees are generally more risk averse and care about consistent year to year income, maybe they have an average tenure of 3-4 years. In this example, employees may not be incentivised to take bonus hits now for income 5+ years down the road, especially if bonus is a high proportion of total comp.
- Vladimof 5y agoonly the bonus mattered because they were paying your weekly salary on time?
- cramthatgraham 5y agoWorking Backwards. Best Amazon content you will ever find.
- falcolas 5y agoThe idea of a six or seven figure bonus for a software developer is - no matter what level of their career they're in - absolutely bonkers to me. Completely beyond my ken. Separate from that, who in their right mind would enter into a contract to make so much of their salary optional for their employer to pay them? And yeah, if you set them up as the reward for a prisoner's dilemma, of course you'll see insanely bad behavior.
- mbrodersen 5y agoI have seen bonuses work really well when given to the whole team (or the whole company) instead of individuals. It emphasises that success depends on the whole team/company not arbitrary management favourites.
- eternityforest 5y agoThat's amazing. Paying people more than I've made lifetime total... to actively sabotage things.... When I was just starting out, I probably wouldn't have thought of tech as a money-focused business, or that there would be any real competition. I just kind of thought once you were successful, as long as you still had a job, you were effectively way too rich to bother actively seeking higher pay, and that nobody would ever want to do something like this kind of sabotage. I also thought that people would be generally excited about the future of tech and everyone on all levels would want to do what they can to keep innovation going.... But as it turns out, programming is in fact just a job, most people seem to be largely in it for the money, they don't think Tiles and AirTags are as cool as I do, and game dev especially seems to be very businessy and DLC driven and even NFTful and not exactly managed by artists. What happened to the dot com era vision of what tech should be? I would have thought management at the billion dollar places really would run things well, but it seems like there's plenty of dysfunction even at the top companies.
- alar44 5y agoThe 80s and on into the .com boom was all about money. For the first time, the world saw that programmers and software could generate insane amounts of money. Nothing has changed, you were just young and naive.
- eternityforest 5y agoAll the beginning programmers were. I don't think it was just about money for the average lay programmer. Everything everywhere is always about money for the business guys, but a lot of people got into coding with no real thought to money besides just wanting a normal comfortable living.
- AndrewDucker 5y agoThe problem here isn't "bonuses are important" it's "the total bonus pot is fixed, so you getting more means your co-workers get less". Reward people for adding value. If everyone has added value then reward all of them.
- isitmadeofglass 5y ago> This is a very bad idea and the perfect way to run your tech corporation straight into the ground. I always wondered what it was that caused valve to be “run straight into the ground”. Great to have this former disgruntled employees inside perspective. I’m sure it’s objective and aligns with reality.