13 ms·
You can now ask Google to remove your phone number, email or address from search
- fibers 5y agoIsn't this good? What's the downside?
- rosndo 5y agoKrebs’s doxing posts will get removed from Google?
- rotexo 5y agoThis is really good, imho. The downside is that the information is of course all still out there for a sufficiently motivated person to find.
- _jal 5y ago> What's the downside? I did reconnect with someone I lost track of a long time ago via google-stalking, found their email address. I'm pretty sure they agree that it was nice to reconnect, we talk regularly again. (Neither of us are FB users, so no, it doesn't substitute.)
- notafraudster 5y agoFor this to be a downside, you have to believe that the person expressly wants to remove their email address from your view, but nevertheless wants to reconnect with you. That's possible, but I don't think a sane thing to build around.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lupire 5y agoIt's a downside, not a "build around".
- Teandw 5y agoThe possible downside is that it could allow scammers/fraudsters to get their details removed.
- tyingq 5y agoLooks like perhaps a loophole to deindex any page from google that allows comments. Just sneak in some doxxing looking info, like a bank account number and name like "John Doe 99874848383".
- rosndo 5y agoWho needs such a “loophole”? It’s already very common to take down pages with fake DMCAs, fake legal process and fake court orders. Anyone wanting to deploy dirty tricks to remove things from Google can do so very easily already
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 5y agoIt has the advantage of being a little more stealthy than taking those kind of actions against the page itself.
- ranger_danger 5y agoNow Google knows exactly who and where you are.
- andrewgioia 5y ago> Google says a removal request will be considered if the search result in question includes the presence of “explicit or implicit threats” or “explicit or implicit calls to action for others to harm or harass.” Apparently they've always had a process for bank account info and other related things, but I can't get some of the newly included items, like login credentials, removed unless I can show actual or implicit threats of harm?
- no-dr-onboard 5y agoI wonder what the standards are to verify this. Can I just sockpuppet a twitter account calling for my harassment and then use that as proof of targeting? IMO there should be as few barriers to entry as possible with something like this.
- stult 5y agoCool new business model, harassment as a service. We‘ll get your info off google for the low low price of $1.99 per fake death threat
- reaperducer 5y agoI hear ads on the radio for "reputation management" companies that, in part, use similar methods.
- vlunkr 5y agoI'm implicitly threatened by a multi-billion dollar corporation making my personal information available publicly and refusing to remove it unless I have evidence of explicit or implicit threats.
- Teandw 5y agoTechnically they haven't made your personal information available publicly. It was already public if Google managed to get their hands on it. They've just made it easier to find.
- rhexs 5y agoHere's a direct link to the removal process: https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 Really neat.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- unwind 5y agoMeta: The title is truncated ("Search" at the end turned to "Searc") which doesn't look very nice. I would suggest maybe s/Remove/Drop/ or just s/from Searc//.
- deadbunny 5y agoWhy is this dependant on receiving threats? By that point people already have your info. Why can't I remove it without jumping through hoops?
- throwaway0220 5y ago> Why is this dependant on receiving threats? It is not. From the form [1]: "...that has POTENTIAL to create significant risks of identity theft, financial fraud, harmful direct contact, or other specific harms..." (emphasis mine). The requirements section states that you may request removal due to the page having "personally identifiable info" OR doxxing content "used in implicit or explicit threats". Now, there's exceptions to this (e.g. public records, newsworthy content), but nowhere it says you have to receive threats first before requesting removal. disclaimer: Googler, but no relationship with the team, and have no other knowledge of this policy other reading the public blog post. [1] https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 5y ago>It is not. >... nowhere it says you have to receive threats first before requesting removal. Oh come on now, this is taken directly from your link: >Requirements to remove doxxing content >For us to consider the content for removal, it must meet both of these requirements: >1. Your contact info is present. >2. There’s the presence of: >- Explicit or implicit threats, or >- Explicit or implicit calls to action for others to harm or harass. So, yes. To remove doxxing content, you are required to show proof of explicit or implicit threats. If you think about it, the way the requirements are set up are pretty damn backwards. Are you just requesting your personal info to be removed just for the sake of having it removed? Sure, as long as it's your CC/bank account/SSN/whatever else on that list, they'll remove it. But if you tell them you're being doxxed? Well fuck you, they won't just up and remove the data like they would've before, now you have to prove you're being targeted, too. It's like it'd be easier to have the doxxing content removed if you didn't tell them you're being doxxed.
- pawelkobojek 5y agoIt's great but a related question: if Google processes phone numbers how is it GDPR compliant? They definitely don't ask every person in the EU whether they can process their personal data and yet it is possible to find EU citizens' phone numbers using their search engine.
- Teandw 5y ago'Technically' Google only lists websites in their search engine that a website owner has authorised them to scrape/crawl. Part of Google's TOS is that if you allow them to crawl your website, you're following all legal responsibilities in the countries you serve your website to. That in theory means that if your details are on a website, you've already given consent for it to be shared with Google. Does that happen in reality? Most of the time I doubt it. But it pushes the liability onto the website owner.
- wumpus 5y agoHave you ever met a lawyer who thinks that kind of TOS is valid in any way?
- digitallyfree 5y agoUh, you don't really "allow" them to visit your website. All you can do is disallow them from visiting by blocking them using robots.txt. If you don't have a robots.txt stating otherwise they will crawl and index your site. UPDATE: I suppose if you specifically allow the Googlebot via robots.txt, then in that case they could probably argue that you gave them permission to access the site.
- sumthinprofound 5y agoonce a month I google my PII and then either opt out through the hosting website or go through the google removal request process. After I saw this news article about phone # removal I went to look for the search results that I had previously found on Google but apparently Google had already delisted them. Good stuff.
- qiskit 5y agoDoes this remove it from search results only or from google's databases? I'm assuming google keep all the data internally for themselves and just filters it out for the users.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoYou're doing data verification for them too, confirming those details. That will make the data Google have available to sell use of to other companies more valuable.
- beyondd 5y agoThis is great, but removing the info from Google does nothing to remove it from the source. People search data brokers are one of the most common sources of unwanted posting of home address, phone number and email. If that's the info you want to remove, you can use Google as a tool for discovery to figure out who is posting the info, and then opt out at the source to have it removed. For more coverage you can use Optery's free crawl / scrape / scan of the people search data broker sites for you, and use that to have the listings removed from the source. Wherever possible, removing the info from the source is much better than just removing it from Google.
- KarlKemp 5y agoMeh… If some data about me is listed on a website nobody ever sees, I don’t care what sound a tree falling in the wood makes. This isn’t a binary issue. Removing data from Google will usually have 90 % of the effect of removing it everywhere.
- willis936 5y agoData brokers aren't "websites no one uses".
- bobbygoodlatte 5y agoThat all changes if you have a stalker / bad actor going after you online. Once your address hits one of these sites, it's on every one of them. And you'll be playing a constant game of whac-a-mole if you want them removed. The amount of hoops you need to jump through to protect your privacy / shield your address in the US is quite incredible. And if you don't do it correctly from the start (use an anonymous land trust, etc), you're hosed. Privacy should be the default. People's home addresses shouldn't be public info
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> hoops you need to jump through to protect your privacy / shield your address in the US is quite incredible The U.S. has a decentralized land registration system. The downside is it usually cannot provide indefeasible title [1]. The upside is it's tremendously robust. That robustness comes, in part, from publicly-verifiable records. > People's home addresses shouldn't be public info Confidential property ownership has its own issues. It's less stable. In the event of a dispute you only have the registrar's and disputing owners' records to consult. It's also associated with embezzlement, money laundering and tax fraud. (The set of societies where a public home address puts one at risk and the set that have problems with embezzlement and laundering overlap in their institutional weakness.) (For tenants, on the other hand, there are fewer compelling reasons to publish residence.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torrens_title#Indefeasibility_of_title https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torrens_title#Indefeasibility_...
- recuter 5y agoDo humans really review these requests manually? How would that scale?
- Teandw 5y agoThey do get reviewed manually. I would imagine in the grand scheme of things, not many people would ever submit it. Scaling it wouldn't be hard regardless, this would be very basic task based work, that they would hire out to India or via companies that handle this sort of work.
- JadeNB 5y ago> Do humans really review these requests manually? How would that scale? A slow and frustrating process to stop displaying your private information does Google no harm, so the answer from their side is likely "who cares?"
- Lapsa 5y agoaka google collects your phone number, email and address
- mikepechadotcom 5y agoSounds great, however I am scared that when I do this, Google will flag my account, and if I need to use their other services, like Google Ads, Gmail, YouTube etc. my account is suddenly blocked because of [insert arbitrary ToS violation]
- Teandw 5y agoThat's a random thing to be worried of. That's not going to happen.
- ceroxylon 5y agoI am fairly sure I was banned from AdSense for saying "don't forget to subscribe if you liked this post" on blogspot, although they never told me why so I can only guess since it happened soon after I started ending my posts with it. It was my only source of income as I had just graduated and losing it completely pivoted my life. Now I see Youtubers say it daily and it still reminds me.
- bduerst 5y agoWhat makes you think you were banned from Adsense for saying something that common?
- dannysullivan 5y agoI work for Google Search. And no, we won't. Moreover, the form doesn't require anyone to be logged into to file a request.
- voakbasda 5y agoI have asked Google (repeatedly) to remove roads on my private property from their Maps. Those roads still appear there, so I find it hard to believe they will honor these types requests either.
- Teandw 5y agoFrom previous experience they will virtually never 'remove' a road as the road is there and it should appear for 'accuracy' purpose, so if you're trying to get them to do that, that will be the reason why it's staying up. Instead you have to submit an edit and state in there that it's a private road and on private property so should not be used for navigation purposes. It will then be removed from navigation etc.
- texasbigdata 5y agoDo your roads appear on any government maps? I believe the mapping agency for road is called…shucks I forget. They’re sometimes ahead or behind Google maps.
- dylan604 5y agoIf it is a private road on private property, I don't care if it is on a gov't map or not. It should not be listed as a route on any publicly available map service. In fact, it should be required to be explicitly labeled as private property "violaters will be prosecuted" type of thing.
- mvgoogler 5y agoWhere I live in semi-rural Maine, probably 90+% of the houses are on private roads on private land. If they weren't listed as routes in map services nobody would be able to find us.
- kube-system 5y agoThere are plenty of reasons to map roads on private property, and presumably it is visible in satellite imagery, so I don't see that as a compelling argument by itself. If we're not counting oceans, most of what is on a map is private property.
- distrohopper 5y agoif your email, phone number or address shows up in Google search you are doing it wrong
- ge96 5y agoHa the other day I found this site truepeoplesearch has all my addresses/phone numbers, relatives... like cool It probably came from resumes or something but still
- kzrdude 5y agoNo access to this site here. It's probably GDPR-blocked for me, which is fair.
- belter 5y agoDo you mind if I send your application to a few jobs? :-)
- kube-system 5y agoAssuming you're in the US, it is probably from financial data. The whole market for data brokering has deep roots in financial services like credit reporting.
- praveenhm 5y agoRemoving from google doesn't go far enough, the big culprit is the data broker. Displaying your age, is the biggest worry, among your friends circle. John oliver recently made a late night show on data brokers, threatening the congress members, must watch for anyone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqn3gR1WTcA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqn3gR1WTcA
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe headline is extremely misleading. They will only remove the information if you are being targeted by a doxxing campaign, and they make it incredibly onerous to remove the information - you have to provide screenshots, the URLs that generate the search results, and then, bizarrely, you must also separately provide the search terms. The whole thing feels like a /r/maliciouscompliance post.
- dannysullivan 5y agoI work for Google Search. We're working to clear this up. Threat is not required to remove the listed PII. I'll repeat what I shared in another comment here: There is NO requirement of threat to remove anything listed as personally identifiable information on this page (such as personal contact info, medical records, login credentials, etc): https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 Beyond those things listed, in some cases someone who is being threatened might feel there's additional information that someone might feel is somehow personally identifying. This is where the doxxing/threat option can be used, for something not on the list where no threat is required. Appreciate this is confusing to some; we'll be looking at how to clarify that.
- slvrspoon 5y agoIndeed it's complex to do the submission but I understand why Google needs some of the details to process with fidelity and consideration. Sadly, simple privacy is now complex to achieve. We have to start unraveling 25 years of unfettered data collection somewhere. Google here is no worse than the data brokers red tape processes and corporations hiding behind consent managers with ID verification etc.
- y-c-o-m-b 5y agoWell I filled it out. Let's see what happens. A lot of these websites have no way to remove personal info or make it very difficult to do so, so this is a minor step in the right direction. For me it's a matter of safety. I used to have a best friend about 15 years ago that got busted for sex crimes with minors and he's due to be released next month. The first thing he's going to do is look me up and find where I live, I guarantee it. I have kids that are around the same age as the minors he violated, so it's a serious concern knowing he can so easily find where I live and potentially harass us or worse.
- slvrspoon 5y agosend a support ticket into DeleteMe - we'll help pro bono.
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoIt took me about 10 minutes to figure out that the link provided from the Google article really just leads to a workflow where i have to answer just the right questions to get to the actual form (https://support.google.com/legal/troubleshooter/1114905?rd=1#ts=1115655 https://support.google.com/legal/troubleshooter/1114905?rd=1...). And, then go through a second workflow, which puts you to... the first workflow. I have yet to reach a page where I can submit the URLs to be removed. I consider myself a neophyte technologist, since I just started a few decades ago with punch cards. I doubt most of the general public will figure out how to perform this process. I will give some grace, and come back in a month.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> I have yet to reach a page where I can submit the URLs to be removed. I consider myself a neophyte technologist, since I just started a few decades ago with punch cards. Internet literacy is probably unrelated to punch card literacy. I followed the link in the article (from kreb) to the google blog post announcing it: https://blog.google/products/search/new-options-for-removing-your-personally-identifiable-information-from-search/ https://blog.google/products/search/new-options-for-removing... That linked to this form: https://support.google.com/websearch/troubleshooter/9685456?hl=en https://support.google.com/websearch/troubleshooter/9685456?... First you tell them what the info it (eg address Pcture SSN etc). Assuming it matches what is in the announcements as a supported type, you get an inline form asking for your name/email, then a URL to the offending site(s), query terms on google search that yield the site(s), and then optionally screenshots of the content. After, you click a button saying you’re legally the person you’re saying you are. I don’t have data to submit in the form so i don’t know what happens next but it looks like the end. Are you sure you didn’t just submit a successful request and they redirected you to the landing page? Disclosure: I work at G but didn’t know this existed until I heard from Kreb.
- CharlesW 5y ago> Internet literacy is probably unrelated to punch card literacy. The parent commenter was using self-deprecating "humor", which I understand can be confusing for Lumon Industries innies. Your outie will appreciate it!
- formerkrogemp 5y agoWhy wasn't this done sooner?
- leowoo91 5y agoI tried this feature for a public record before, unfortunately they don't consider it as PII and make it so easy for people to get everything about you. I wouldn't have concerns this data appearing on gov websites, however this kind of easy reach is bit inconvenient to be in a single search.
- gunapologist99 5y agoThis initially seems like great news, but here is the link to the article that's actually posted as a screenshot in TFA: https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 From that article: > We evaluate each request based on the criteria listed below, and evaluate the content for public interest. As a result, we may...deny your request. With the exception of email addresses below, can anyone provide a circumstance when Google might legitimately find that not removing the following would be "in the public interest"? * Confidential government identification (ID) numbers like U.S. Social Security Number (..) etc. * Bank account numbers * Credit card numbers * Images of handwritten signatures * Images of ID docs * Highly personal, restricted, and official records, like medical records * Personal contact info (physical addresses, phone numbers, and email addresses) * Confidential login credentials It seems there's quite a bit of wiggle room in this policy to remove some search results and not others.
- shitlord 5y agoI can't think of a good reason to remove ID docs, mugshots, court records, and other personal information of convicted child molesters. There's a reason we have sex offender registries, even if they go too far sometimes. You should be able to look up why a person is on the registry using a search engine, and criminals shouldn't be able to hide their past. Some of them probably will get harassed for it, but I'm fine with that.
- apatheticonion 5y agoStill can't ask them to remove a legacy YouTube account you had access to though.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoPut the content on a server you control; call in a copyright strike against the account; ...; Profit!?
- mig_ 5y agoTwo theories. 1. Google already does a good job of filtering out email addresses. I remember searching email addresses I was curious about 5ish years ago and getting results. Today, I get far fewer hits. So my theory is that google is already attempting to sort of scrub peoples email addresses from their searches. Us filling out the form is feedback to the machine learning. 2. Google wants to corner the market on this information and this is how they bleed the companies out. (I don't they have _actually_ devoted enough resources to this to bleed the other companies out) The business motive? There isn't a particular offering this data is good for besides selling to 3rd parties besides the business Google is already in. This data could enhance other data sets for other offerings. As simple as "auto-complete" for phone number after you have entered your name or address fill after entering your phone number.
- jollybean 5y agoThis is a good start. And it should be easier. And somehow by default.
- suyash 5y agoHere is the actual link to request removal : https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730 https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9673730
- colechristensen 5y agoI have gotten information removed from Google like this and found it replaced within about a month
- emodendroket 5y agoI remember the good old days when Google offered a reverse phone lookup. Now trying to do that just leads to pages and pages of spam.
- c3534l 5y agoSweet. This should finally get rid of that sex story I accidentally posted from my regular email account.
- kappattack 5y agoI did this a few months back, and i was very happy with how easy it was to remove my information from Google. At that time though I had to get the content removed from each site, and then i had to notify google that the excerpts had changed due to my requests for the websites to remove my personal information. Its really nice to see that Google is now moving towards supporting a request to remove PII from results, without having to deal with individual websites, who almost always are scam sites who will try to get you to 'subscribe for premium profile control to hide specific content'. Never give these people a dime. Google processed my requests very quickly and the content just can't be found using their search engine anymore. Bing, on the other hand, was an absolute nightmare. After emailing for around a month with MSoft support, they claimed they removed content that was still showing up, and still is showing up to this day. This content doesn't even exist on the pages that Bing is showing excerpts from, and hasn't for around a year now. It became very clear to me that Bing had no effective process in place to carry out content removal requests, so I eventually gave up. Unfortunate, because alternative search engines like Ddgo and Brave show results from Bing, IIRC. I guess you can't place all the blame on these sites. I also found out my state releases the entire registered voter database for anyone to download online, without any reason or identification required. So if you're a registered voter, it is possible that the information you provided to register is public and available online anyways. This includes full name, email, address, and phone number - if I remember correctly. It's been some time since I looked through the database though. I found my entire family within it, and it receives quarterly updates. I would not be surprised if the government was at least one primary source of information for PII scam sites in the first place.
- gzer0 5y agoI am not advocating for or against this practice; but in the United States the voter record has always been part of the public domain [1]. The National Conference of State Legislatures breaks out a by-state view of what info is available and how it can be used [2]. There's another good article [3] doing a state-by-state analysis of voter file privacy. The public file should only contain: Name, address, year of birth. The following should be kept confidential: DL number, last 4 of SSN, month and day of birth, phone number, information that a person declined to register to vote, the office that received a registered voter's application, digitized signature. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/u-s-voter-info-has-always-been-public-now-it-n1244901 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/u-s-voter-info-has-alw... [2] https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/access-to-and-use-of-voter-registration-lists.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/access... [3] https://www.comparitech.com/blog/vpn-privacy/personal-voter-data-study/ https://www.comparitech.com/blog/vpn-privacy/personal-voter-...