14 ms·
Jack Dorsey’s $2.9M NFT dropped 99% in value
- adoxyz 5y agoNFT's are a scam.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway42000 5y agoAbsolutely agree. Nothing more to add than I tell everyone I know who mentions NFTs this so they do not get scammed.
- medymed 5y agoAs has been said, NFT stands for Non-Fungible Token Scam. The S is silent.
- citrusybread 5y agoNo Fuckin' Thanks!
- djbusby 5y agoNice Financial-literacy Test
- akomtu 5y agoSure. But bundle them into CDOs, give them the AAA rating, start selling options on them and suddenly that's a legit business. NFTs are missing this thick layer of complexity that obfuscates the nature of the core financial "product".
- elil17 5y agoCDOs are groups of bonds. Bonds are debts, so they produce real value in the form of interest. If the debtors stop paying, the CDO can recover value in bankruptcy court. CDOs may misrepresent the risk of the underlying assets, but those assets are still there. An NFT is more akin to a baseball card - it’s value might go up, but that would just be because someone wants to buy it. It’s not producing any income on its own and the owner is no right to recoup the money they paid for it.
- throwmeariver1 5y agoIt was a tongue cheek quote from The Big Short… can’t wait for synthetic NFTs.
- Ekaros 5y agoHmm can I buy derivatives of NFTs? Like credit default swaps?
- akomtu 5y agoThen sell payment plans for NFTs, so every NFT would have a debt associated with it, and a payer. There is a risk the payer will default, but all debts have this risk. Now that we have these NFT bonds, we can bundle them into CDOs...
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoNot surprisingly given the nature of crypto markets in general, NFTs have been financialized to various degrees. You can, for example, put a popular NFT into a pool where individual NFTs are traded back and forth and you receive a slice of the trading fees. See https://nftx.io/ https://nftx.io/
- ralusek 5y agoThey're a scam in the way that anything for which its value is mostly a function of its scarcity; the scarcity is still always just a modifier on the demand for it. I would be more inclined to call it a scam if the technology was a failure or the purported scarcity of the asset being sold was being misrepresented. Neither of those are true. Instead, what is being traded are extremely scarce assets for which the demand is unimaginably overestimated. In 10 years will anybody actually care that there's a signed entry in a particular blockchain saying that this asset belongs to you? Probably not. I think if technologies like video games hook into a blockchain and let the owners of an NFT artwork for example use it as a character skin or put it up in their virtual house as a painting, maybe they'll have some value amongst people...but the demand is still probably extremely overrated. I'm guessing the value of something like that would be more on the order of <$100. TL;DR I don't think scam is the right word. I don't think Beanie Babies or IPOs are scams just because people severely overestimated the future demand for the thing that they're buying.
- elil17 5y agoNothing inherently scammy about posting a JPEG and auctioning of some cryptographic link to it. The part that feels scammy is people trying to convince others (often people who are financially illiterate) that NFTs will gain value.
- eric_cc 5y agoNFT bag holders may actually believe what they’re saying in which case they aren’t scamming. I think to scam you must be operating under nefarious intentions.
- jug 5y agoI think their best use I’ve seen yet is for money laundering.
- cupofpython 5y agoThere are a lot of prolific scam's in the NFT medium* and not a lot of other current uses for NFT* NFT's themselves are actually a really neat piece of technology imo. I can imagine some uses for them. My imagination hasn't stumbled onto how those uses produce appreciating assets, though.
- simpsond 5y agoJust like baseball cards. That said, there are some interesting use cases where the NFT is paired with off-chain cash flow. See royal.io, where IP rights for music are represented by NFTs and the owner of the NFT receives royalties. I think having a liquid market for that kind of investment is more tractable than a jpeg without real IP rights.
- boopboopbadoop 5y agoIn regards to the music royalties example, what’s the benefit of using NFTs over whatever systems already exist?
- simpsond 5y agoI would say the NFT market places make it easy to buy/sell (liquid). Since contracts are composable it could be sold to a contract with distribution properties so there can be fractional ownership. Programmable money flows.
- throw_m239339 5y ago> Just like baseball cards. You can certainly see baseball cards (or stamps, Magics cards, whatever) as worthless. The difference being that when you buy a baseball card, (yes a reproducible good, so its value is anybody's guess), you're not buying a link to a baseball card powered by Ethereum, you're buying a tangible product at the very least. To me the NFT is so intangible as a product that clearly its market is already set to die, the question is who will be holding the bag and who will make millions.
- charcircuit 5y agoWho cares if an asset is tangible? There's really not that much difference between being able to own and show off a CSGO skin vs a baseball card. For stocks most people prefer owning an intangible version of it. Very few people want an actual certificate saying they own it.
- 5y ago
- babyshake 5y agoNot exactly. They are indeed non-fungible tokens. But that doesn't mean they are worth anything.
- jdrc 5y agoThere might be some use of the mechanism one day, but almost everything that is being 'traded' now is Monopoly properies for people who use monopoly money
- eric_cc 5y agoNFT art pointers are a scam. There are use cases for unique tokens that aren’t scams. However, such use cases have nothing to do with investing or attempting to get rich.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI believe NFT's primary utility is that of tax avoidance and/or money laundering. It is very similar to how multi-millionaires and billionaires buy art pieces for tens of millions of dollars.
- anm89 5y agoI feel like a scam would imply that an effort to conceal the nature of NFTs is occurring when in reality they are just throwing it out pretty transparently and saying buy it anyway, it's cool and there will be a greater fool, and then people just buy them. That's just stupidity on the part of the buyer IMO, not really a scam.
- outside1234 5y agoThe right question to ask is "was it ever real?" I suspect we'll discover it was all wash trades and money laundering in short order.
- malka 5y agoThis comment could be talking about all art.
- spamizbad 5y agoYes. That too.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI will make a bold prediction and say we won't find out all art is money laundering and wash sales soon.
- jjoonathan 5y agoThe high art scene is the evolved form of this. It knows to maintain enough legitimate artistry jammed in the crevices between the tax avoidance, money laundering, fraud, and flexing to cement the whole thing together and weather the occasional public ire. NFTs will be gone next season, but the high art grift will endure.
- tshaddox 5y ago“All art” is obviously a hyperbole, but my impression is that it is widely known that high-end art auctions are used for money laundering. There are plenty of news articles about various governments making big busts and attempting cracking down on this.
- j4yav 5y agoYou’ll be excited then to learn that I’ve both bought art and sold art I’ve made, and it was all actually used for decoration and priced reasonably for that utility - no scam involved!
- 5y ago
- dvt 5y agoKevin Rose just raised $60M+ this weekend[1], so unlikely that the NFT market is "crumbling." [1] https://cryptobriefing.com/moonbirds-set-to-bring-in-66m-as-nft-drop-mints-out/ https://cryptobriefing.com/moonbirds-set-to-bring-in-66m-as-...
- throw_m239339 5y agoYes, at some point too ICO were raising hundreds of millions of dollars. Can you point me to a single ICO were "investors" actually made money on the long run?
- dvt 5y agoMost NFTs are probably a scam, but I was just arguing against the specific point of the article that the market is "crumbling."
- renewiltord 5y agoI believe the BAT ICO was a positive for the investors.
- sequenceA 5y agoI guess this is just the usual hate-posting... But up until today; Ethereum (ico: $0.3, now: $2912) Basic Attention Token (ico: ~$0.03, now: $0.74) Avalanche (ico: $0.5, now: $74.28) Fantom (ico: ~$0.04, now: $1.09) Terra (ico: $0.8, now: $84.89) Cosmos (ico: $0.10, now: $23.27) To name a few of the big winners. You said long-term so I assumed you meant someone was bag-holding since the ICO until now... so I omitted that all of these topped out at way higher prices. Just because a lot of the ICOs were dogshit doesn't mean that all of them were
- lucasmullens 5y agoI think you shared the wrong link, that's just the link to the article.
- dvt 5y ago
- VHRanger 5y ago99.9999% to be precise At least it's a tax writeoff for the person selling it, I guess?
- ok123456 5y agoJust in time for the tax deadline.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThat's not how taxes in the US work. If he sold it now he'd only be able to take the loss on his 2022 taxes, and even then he better hope he has a lot of gains or else he'll need to carryover the loss.
- mywittyname 5y agoMore importantly: losing actual money to save on taxes is hugely inefficient. If he was doing this to save on taxes, he would have taken a paper loss via depreciation -- meaning, not actually selling it, just changing the book value of it -- with the intent of paying capital gains tax at some future date (well, more likely, borrowing against its "true" value indefinitely).
- ok123456 5y agoBut it's not actual money? The NFTs space seems to just be an extension of the old art appraisal scam: the asset can have whatever value happens to be convenient at a given time.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoYou're obviously unfamiliar with corporate loss carry back. Anyone buying an NFT for $2.9M is almost certainly doing so as a business.
- 0xfeba 5y agoSo was it a NFT pointing to a hosted image, or a URL to the actual tweet permalink? The latter being marginally less ephemeral than the former. But neither would encompass any kind of "ownership".
- ineedasername 5y agoAnd is what's out there the actual tweet? I'm sure their data is distributed & duplicated across many regions. Does the NFT encompass all of them? Are any of them even original? It's possible that the first bits & bytes on a server that hosted that tweet are long gone, tossed out after twitter scaled beyond its humble beginnings. The original could be a slagged hard drive, a cooled molten lump of metal & silicon. Actually, that would be much more interesting to own than the NFT.
- drexlspivey 5y agoThat's why usually NFTs point to IPFS addresses which are just hashes of the content and it doesn't matter where they are hosted.
- ineedasername 5y agoSeems like a very lossy form of compression. Not to mention that hashes usually aren't reversible. Not a great stand in for the real thing, especially when the real thing might be a widely available jpeg. There's really something I don't understand about how an NFT, apart from cryptographic foundation, is different enough from, say, a UUID in a traditional database. Also it would be funny if there was a (very highly unlikely) hash collision between two different valuable NFTs.
- dlubarov 5y agoWhoever owns an NFT can prevent the pre-image from being lost by just personally storing it. If they wanted to ensure the pre-image is easily accessible to others, they could additionally host it on IPFS.
- ryanbrunner 5y agoI genuinely don't know since most of my knowledge of NFT stuff comes from people commenting it vs. primary sources, but are there very active markets for NFTs in general beyond initial offerings? Like is there an active, healthy and functioning market for BAYC, or was it more about an initial rush and now a bunch of people have tokens that have value on paper but no market to realistically sell them?
- adoxyz 5y agoI would safely assume the latter (minus the value bit).
- gonehome 5y agoThere’s an active market, but it’s mostly winner takes all and ones that establish a brand/community (helped by the tokens gating access to merchandise or events). Also good when token includes IP. BAYC/MAYC is the biggest, milady seems to be getting traction (not sure why). These specific ones are also easy to liquidate for now because of opensea bots willing to sell ~10% below “floor” so they can flip later. I made this bet with a MAYC a while back to play with and understand what was going on (bet was MAYC price would climb because of BAYC community and future ape token). It worked out, but it can be a bit stressful for sure. The interesting bit is gated community access/easily verifiable ownership of membership. The art is a meme-ish way to signal this status, but the ability to verify easily is the new capability (urbit uses it well imo - costs can be low, but verification and non-zero cost make spam no longer economical) The Jack tweet style nft and ones like that seemed like a dumb bet to me. The value is in the community, access, or (maybe) in IP rights for a certain sports clip or something. NFTs of stuff like Jack’s tweet or a meme without IP rights have no real value beyond hype imo. This topic is also squarely in the class of things the median HN comment is dumb about so it’s rare to find info here, usually just sneering dismissals.
- nradov 5y agoWhy would anyone want to be a member of an organization composed of people stupid enough to waste money on NFTs? That seems like something I'd want to actively avoid. Like I'd pay money to block those losers from my life.
- tablespoon 5y agoFrom another article on the same topic https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/apr/14/twitter-nft-jack-dorsey-sina-estavi https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/apr/14/twitter-n...: > Man who paid $2.9m for NFT of Jack Dorsey’s first tweet set to lose almost $2.9m > ‘This is the Mona Lisa of the digital world’, says crypto entrepreneur Sina Estavi who bought the NFT in March 2021 This is a good example of why so many people don't take cryptocurrency seriously. It full of hype men who spout transparent BS like the above quote, though most don't have millions to blow to get into the news like this.
- ALittleLight 5y agoA Peter Thiel quote - "The something of somewhere is often the nothing of nowhere."
- greesil 5y agoHindsight is 20/20, which is why you never see the crystal ball flying at your head until it's too late -- also Peter Thiel, probably.
- eli 5y agoA lot of people had the foresight to see that an NFT of an old tweet was a bad investment at the time.
- greesil 5y agoThe grift could have gone on for much longer.
- xiphias2 5y agoHe made a great talk at the Bitcoin conference last week: https://youtu.be/wmBieQpuysM https://youtu.be/wmBieQpuysM
- giraffe_lady 5y agolmao what
- seanalltogether 5y agoNFTs have made a little more sense to me since reading a comment on here or reddit effectively claiming that crypto is easy to get into, but hard to get your money out of. Especially depending on your age or where you live. As a result there's a lot of money floating around the space that people can't effectively extract, so instead they just speculate wildly on whatever they think will increase their virtual hoard. It's just a big game.
- golergka 5y agoNFTs of jpegs are scams. NFTs that are linked to real-world assets (through intermediaries that you have to trust, yes — unlike everybody else on the blockchain) like stock, real estate or anything else are not.
- cj 5y agoCan the people downvoting this explain why this comment is not valuable?
- colinmhayes 5y agoDespite originally being called deeds, I have never seen an NFT used to show ownership of a physical asset. Not really sure how well that would work anyway, since usually courts are the final judge of ownership, and when they figure out they can't order NFTs to be transferred they'll just say they don't actually show ownership.
- thot_experiment 5y agoSure, there's no difference between an NFT of something in the real world and a contract that you write on paper and mutually agree to. If you had the NFT of a jet nationalized by Putin well, you'd still be screwed.
- SahAssar 5y agoBecause real world assets already have frameworks governing their ownership, and those frameworks generally do not take NFTs into account. If the NFT actually grants you ownership of something tangible (like stock, IP, real estate, etc.) then to make that legally enforceable you need to also sign a traditional contract which makes the NFT pretty pointless. If I bought your house and in addition to all the legal paperwork you also gave me a handwritten note saying "house is yours now, promise!" do you think I'll care about the handwritten note? If you only gave me the note and not all the normally required paperwork do you think I'd pay you?
- alberth 5y agoWhat's the story here? This is normal market dynamics for collectibles where people paying what they perceive the value to be. I'm sure there are plenty of Beanie Babies (and other Collectibles) that are nearly worthless compared to what someone payed for them previously. Note: I'm not for or against NFTs. I'm just trying to point out the dynamics of the Collectibles market.
- manholio 5y agoA NFT is not a collectible, it's a pure vehicle for financial speculation. The object being collected no longer exists in any meaningful sense.
- ineedasername 5y ago> The object being collected no longer exists in any meaningful sense. Depends on whether or not you set the thing on fire. But in the case of a tweet, that's rather difficult. Of course the literal original tweet might long ago have hit the bit bucket, scrubbed off an old original server that was dumpstered long ago, and now even the "real" one that showed on twitter was still just a copy. Not that an NFT with an abstract pointer to the dumpstered server would be any more meaningful.
- riyadparvez 5y agoThe only valid use for NFT I can think of is a pure vehicle for financial speculation. It's better people do wild speculation on NFTs than housing market.
- rurp 5y agoNFTs aren't even the best option for pure financial speculation, stocks are much better. At least there the money being gambled can be put towards something productive. Plus it's much better for the gambler. Random stocks don't routinely lose 99.999% of their value in a matter of months.
- eric_cc 5y agoThere is functional value to NFT’s. Think beyond JPEG NFT’s. If you’re a software engineer, consider building a decentralized system with unique instances of a model. Unique tokens make a lot of sense to me and certainly there is utility to them. I agree that JPEG NFT’s are ridiculous though.
- srvmshr 5y agoPardon me. I never understood NFTs and never planned to be on board. But from my nascent understanding of what NFTs comprise, I couldn't understand why first tweet ever is a real NFT. The tweet is publicly available so there is no exclusivity. Anyone can look far enough & find it. The second being ownership. The tweet was always time stamped & in Jack Dorsey's name. Buying it as NFT will not really change its attribute. Then again, the copyright law also is contradictory to NFT ownership. It was written by Jack Dorsey, so he automatically has its copyright - unless he signs it away as a legal document (just as academics do for their journal papers. Even then, it doesn't change authorship). AFAICT, Jack Dorsey hasn't & a blockchain purchase doesn't really legally transfer copyright. I am still confused how this will be a NFT. If there is a better explanation, I am glad to learn more about it. Edit: It seems my understanding was not only nascent but incomplete. It makes more sense with the extra details.
- dannyw 5y agoJack Dorsey sold it; it's not like some random made a jpeg and tried to sell it.
- manholio 5y ago> Jack Dorsey sold it So what? If Jack Dorsey took a dump, preserved in resin and sold it as an abstract representation of his first tweet, how would that be different, more genuine or less genuine than this NFT?
- maerF0x0 5y agowell for one, you could have exclusive access to that specific dump. Ironically there's more scarcity in what you described than an entirely publicly accessible NFT Pointer to a file with unrestricted access on the open internet.
- otikik 5y agoEverything old is new again https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artist%27s_Shit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artist%27s_Shit
- cs702 5y agoWile E. Coyote could relate: \\ __(o) ___ / /\/ ___ /\ `/_/\__, ___ \_/ \ | / ____________ \ ____/ _/ ___/ /
- connor4312 5y agoWow, amazing ASCII art! Are you selling an NFT of it?
- elforce002 5y agoFirst bid: $2.9m. Take it or leave it!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 5y agoHere is the link and its sha256 checksum: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31072303 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31072303 b7595f7540b06686a8c810ca2bfbbb967bb355929e2ddeb2aa5e2d062f2a07ba You can say it’s yours if you upvote one random blog post from Paul Graham.
- teachrdan 5y ago
- xrd 5y agoIs there anyone out there promoting NFTs as inflation resistant?
- belter 5y ago“A great man who is vicious will be a great example of vice and a rich man who is not generous will be merely a miserly beggar, for the possessor of wealth is not made happy by possessing it but by spending it, and not by spending it as he pleases but by knowing how to spend it well.” ― Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra, Don Quixote
- _fat_santa 5y agoI feel like for NFT's like these, it's all pure hype on potential future value. Take a Bored Ape NFT, a bored ape is pleasant to look at, you can set it as your profile picture or hang up on the wall as digital art. That's why I think that BAYC was so successful, you had the NFT hype combined with actually good looking art. Now this on the other hand, you won't really want to set it as your profile picture and hanging it up as digital art looks dumb. No one is buying it because they like the NFT, they buy it because they think it will go up in value.
- fl0wenol 5y ago"[...] a bored ape is pleasant to look at [...]" Is it really, though? Maybe the word you're looking for is striking or distinctive. Possibly-- competent. But pleasant is not the first word that comes to mind. BAYC had first-mover advantage, there isn't anything particular about them that wasn't done better by a project that came later. That they are uniquely fugly made them stand out as a novelty.
- unmole 5y ago> a bored ape is pleasant to look at Respectfully disagree. > you can set it as your profile picture You can do that even without buying the NFT.
- Smoofer 5y ago> a bored ape is pleasant to look at Subjective of course, but couldn't disagree more. These things are hideous and frankly epitomize, to me, that hype and not artistic value is driving value here
- ejj28 5y agoI find it hard to believe that BAYC is successful because of the art, personally I think they're rather ugly and I know that a lot of people would feel the same. I think a more likely reason for their success is that they're an easily recognizable series that's known to be expensive; people buy them for the clout. NFTs are fundamentally about clout, and one-off NFTs just don't have the same clout value when used as a Twitter profile or whatever, regardless of the art quality.
- jdasdf 5y agoThe value is the same as always. The price is whats changed.
- rdiddly 5y agoRight, and the price is (inevitably) approaching the value!
- cosmiccatnap 5y agoWell, yea, it was a pump & dump. Most NFTs are.
- a_shovel 5y agoI have the feeling saying an NFT can be worth 2.9 million dollars is misleading, since it doesn't really apply to article's audience. An NFT has only ever, and maybe will only ever, be worth that much to at most two people: The person who paid 2.9 million dollars for this specific NFT, and the person who sold it for 2.9 million dollars. And I'm only really sure about the second one.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoMost NFT transactions are wash trades - so often they are one and the same [= https://cointelegraph.com/news/chainalysis-report-finds-most-nft-wash-traders-unprofitable https://cointelegraph.com/news/chainalysis-report-finds-most...
- partiallypro 5y agoNFTs tied to physical goods (to help solve counterfeiting or sorting membership) makes sense. NFTs that are purely digital in nature and offer nothing else, seems very silly to me because a digital space has no scarcity. An infinite amount of digital goods can be produced.
- Nextgrid 5y agoTying a blockchain record to a physical object is impossible. This stupidity has been tried many times by various conmen with no success. Here's just one of many failures: https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2018/06/how-i-became-leonardo-da-vinci-on-the-blockchain/ https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2018/06/how-i-became-leonardo-da-vi... The reason blockchain works for cryptocurrencies and NFTs (that is the token itself, not the art that the token claims to represent) is because the entire source of truth is on the blockchain. When it comes to physical objects, the source of truth is now split between the physical world and the blockchain. If your token must represent a physical object then you need some way for the real-world state and the blockchain state to always be kept in sync. That is impossible. The best approximation is to rely on a trusted authority for this, but then you don't need a blockchain anymore and can just have that trusted party maintain its own database.
- recursive 5y agoSo if you have the NFT, and I have the physical good, how do you get it back? Take me to court? How is this better than a regular contract?
- izzydata 5y agoI feel like the general response to things like this in the recent past were "A fool and his money are soon parted". What happened to make this particular method of losing money or making a bad investment get regarded as such an evil? I've seen a lot of people give actual death threats and are angry whenever NFTs are brought up. It find it kind of baffling how this sentiment came to be so quickly. What happened?
- moonbug 5y agohahaha.
- disruptalot 5y agoThe conceptions of what happened is so completely removed from reality and it's disheartening to see commenters blinded by the hate for crypto stuff to the extent that they don't even bother to concern the details Let's look at some facts. The _first_ *Offer* made on this NFT was $280 The current top bid for this $29,000 It is not sold, so to say that its value has actually dropped is just silly. If you imagine this in the context of a bid/offer market, this is like when market opens and a price hasn't been established because there wasn't a taker yet.
- ripper1138 5y agoIdk, at this point it seems pretty safe to say that the value has dropped.
- ffggvv 5y agookay so whats the cutoff that we can establish a price? a month with no high offer? at the very least it shows how illiquid the market is
- Finnucane 5y agoIf Sotheby’s put a Picasso on the market and the bids were less than 1 percent of the asking price, many would say, wtf is going on.
- testcase_delta 5y agoAre you sure your account is accurate? According to the Forbes article below, bidding at the end of the auction closed with a high bid of approx. $270. Since the auction closed people have made additional offers, the highest so far is $29k (which is a 99% drop in value). I think I found the Open Seas page (lots of scam looking clones of the page, so I'm not sure this is the real one), but unfortunately the interface doesn't give much information on what activities around the NFT have occurred. At least to a lay person like myself. https://opensea.io/assets/matic/0x28009881f0ffe85c90725b8b02be55773647c64a/20/ https://opensea.io/assets/matic/0x28009881f0ffe85c90725b8b02... The difference is a 99% drop in value, or a 99.99% drop in value. I don't follow the NFT scene closely, so apologies if I'm wrong here. Forbes article: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ronshevlin/2022/04/14/jack-dorseys-first-tweet-29-million-nft-gets-277-bid-at-auction https://www.forbes.com/sites/ronshevlin/2022/04/14/jack-dors...
- syzygyhack 5y agoNFTs as a technology are novel and useful. Unfortunately the way anything new first gets adopted is through the low-hanging fruit, where the proposed value is dubious and most entrants are cashing in on FOMO or operating straight up scams. I hope that eventually more people will look beyond that and a little deeper into the potentials here. Especially for anyone that is dissatisfied with the status quo of capitalism, which seems to be the majority of people I meet? It's frustrating to watch peers fall victim to knee-jerk outrage and miss the forest for the trees. If you wanted a way to fight back, you could start by not hitting yourself in the face. Monopolies do not benefit from decentralization.
- paulpauper 5y agoThere is no community or meme value for a tweet NFT. Apes and Punks at least have a community and celebrity fandom. That's probably why they have done far better ,and also the collectability aspect. You cannot collect tweets like you can collect Apes, which have a finite supply.
- molticrystal 5y agoAn NFT purchased in the initial offering is the fun sticker/t-shirt/mug/toy you get for contributing to a cause or person you like. Especially when they can be used as tickets for special events or other exclusive things hosted by the aforementioned entity. Thinking of it in the terms of a long term financial instrument you can always sell in the second hand market or purchase as an investment in the second hand market may work, but it is a gamble and seems more and more likely to leave you disappointed in the long term.
- carlosdp 5y agoSomeone spent a lot of money on something, speculating that it would be worth more later, and they were wrong? This never happens outside of crypto. /s
- daenz 5y agoI knew some very respectable people who were shilling NFTs with all of their might. These were not crypto people with any kind of understanding of the technology or implications, but they were high level people in their fields. It was sad to see so many people get taken in by it, and even more, to transform into the hosts through which this idea spread. It was like watching some kind of mind virus. It was a short period of loud obsession, but they haven't mentioned it since.
- boopboopbadoop 5y agoYa, on one hand I understand people trying to monetize their work, and trying to be on the forefront of how that’s done. On the other, it feels a bit dishonest if the seller doesn’t believe in the tech enough that they too would buy in. Kind of reminds me of MLMs.
- otikik 5y ago> after Dorsey’s NFT went up for auction again this past week, no one bid higher than $280 That's still $280 too high.
- fallingfrog 5y agoYeah, I don't get the whole NFT thing at all. They're supposed to confer "ownership", but ownership in what sense? If I own a house, I have rights like the right to tell someone else not to enter, or the right to make modifications, or whatever. "Owning" an NFT of a monkey conveys no rights that I can see. It's literally meaningless.
- bckbyunpopulard 5y agoNFTs are extensions to the ideas of CCs with subtle fallaciousness and much hype. Most forms of CC should only be used as a transactional currency to exchange value, never to store it, because of the inherent lack of stable or intrinsic value in CCs. NFTs are basically the programming equivalent of pointers or references to things, not actual things. They're meaningless when no one else values them and there's no marketplace for them. You can make money by selling shovels in a goldrush, but you have to know when to exit before peak hype.
- echlebek 5y agoThat's one way of looking at it. The other way of looking at it is that the NFT still fetched $280 more than its real vaue, $0.