38 ms·
M1 Thunderbolt ports don’t fully support USB 3.1 Gen 2
- mlindner 5y agoMy initial suspicion would be the user used bad cables. There's many cables that say they're capable of a speed when they are not in fact capable.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoIf that was the case, the front non-thunderbolt ports would not be faster, but they are.
- mlindner 5y agoIf the cable is wrecking signal integrity, the port could absolutely change things if the ports have slightly different hardware that's generating the signal. RF does weird things. Just as a very simplistic analog DC example, if you have wires that are both sitting at 3V but one can only drive 100 mA while the other can drive 1A. If you only draw 50 mA they'd look near identical but as soon as soon as you tried to get close to 100 mA they'd both diverge heavily. You could advertise both at 50 mA for sales purpose but if they were hooked up with a bad high resistance cable they'd look very different.
- nottorp 5y agoAs a less technical anecdote, I bought one of those usb "sound cards" and it had noise when plugged into the front usb ports but worked fine into the back ones on the same PC. The sound was transmitted digitally and didn't need that much bandwidth, so the only explanation is "dirty" power on the power wires, I think?
- brigade 5y agoGetting USB 2.0 speeds strongly suggests that the cables somehow had horrendous signal integrity... Anyway I grabbed a 3.1 gen2 SSD and plugged it directly into my 16" M1 Pro (Sandisk Extreme), and I got 850 MB/s read/write with his tool. And that's supposedly one of the exact drives and laptops he tested. So something is going wrong for him, and it's 90% likely to be cables.
- daenney 5y agoIt doesn’t seem particularly likely to be the cables when the same cable plus same external drive but with an Intel Mac results in the expected performance numbers. In your test, did you use a TB4 cable or a USB data cable?
- brigade 5y agoJust because a marginal cable works on one machine doesn't mean it'll work on another. I used a USB cable, but I retested with an active TB4 cable with the same results. And again with a passive TB3 cable to the same results.
- berkut 5y agoWhy did they work with the Intel Mac then?
- chrisandchris 5y agoI really like (careful, sarcasm) that about USB-C and HDMI. You have a port, you have a cable. But if you're not a Syadmin you have no idea why it does not work as you think it should. I can't understand why they did not put some kind of capability mark for cables/ports into the spec.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> I can't understand why they did not put some kind of capability mark for cables/ports into the spec. You're talking about a completely different thing from cables that claim to handle a certain speed but aren't built well enough to actually do so.
- PBondurant 5y agoThe issue is not a cable thing. I have experienced the same behaviour on both a 2020 intel MBA and a 2021 M1 Pro; a 10GB/s rated Samsung T5 SSD only connects to either Mac at 5GB/s, despite being rated for 10GB/s. The same SSD (and cables) connects to Linux & Windows boxen at 10GB/s. Equally, a Crucial X8 SSD rated for the same 10GB/s connects to both Macs at its rated speed. This behavious has persisted across OS updates since Big Sur. My current thinking is that there's some undocumented quirks in place in MacOS that scales speeds down with certain USB controllers.
- mlindner 5y agoSounds pretty clearly like Apple thinks certain devices are non-standards compliant. And just because it works at full speed on Linux & Windows doesn't mean it's standards compliant.
- goosedragons 5y agoAlternatively Apple is not standards compliant. Or it could just be a bug in their driver or controller. Not sure why it makes more sense to assume Apple is doing it right and everyone else wrong.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoWhy bother reading the article when you can just slam out hot takes? > Cables used included a certified Thunderbolt 4 model, and the USB-C (data) cables provided with the cases. Again, each was verified by establishing SuperSpeed+ 10 Gb/s connections to an Intel Mac.
- jsjohnst 5y agoBecause we all know unnamed brand / model “certified” cables with drives that are also unnamed brand / model could surely not be the problem? Edit: I did read the entire article. Like others have said here, it doesn’t match with my experience. But because nothing is clearly specified as to what’s used, the article is useless because nobody can compare to see if their setup is the same or different.
- scoopertrooper 5y ago
- jsjohnst 5y agoJust because it works on an Intel Mac does not mean the cable isn’t the issue! Happy to demonstrate in a live video along with oscilloscope readings to prove it is in fact the cable to blame.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoWhat's your theory as to why the cable would be at fault, despite working perfectly well in a different machine? Seems like the simplest counterpoint would be to demonstrate a M1 mac transmitting at the full data rate using a different cable.
- jsjohnst 5y ago> Seems like the simplest counterpoint would be to demonstrate a M1 mac transmitting at the full data rate using a different cable. Which I’d be happy to do assuming I knew the exact specs (brand/model) of the drives OP was using. If you’d like me to demonstrate that MacOS on Apple Silicon correctly supports USB 3.2 gen 2 devices at 10Gb/s using multiple brands of drives/models, happy to do as well.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> In normal testing, 5 Gb/s should yield around 500 MB/s Wow 90% overheads?
- jon_adler 5y agoBits to bytes means dividing by 8.
- tjoff 5y agoJust to add for clarity, b is used for bits and B for bytes. Though they are often mixed up. (... and a byte is not always 8 bits)
- mccorrinall 5y agoI believe the byte changed its meaning like many words did in the past. To a lot of younger developers a byte is synonymous with an octet.
- JadedBlueEyes 5y agoIn the CS tests for every UK exam board, a byte is always 8 bits
- jon_adler 5y agoA byte has been synonymous with an octet for as long as I can remember. I found a Wikipedia article [1] that describes the transition of a byte meaning the number of bits to encode character of text to an octet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Units_of_information https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Units_of_information
- woodruffw 5y agoThe inability of the USB standards body to stick to a versioning scheme beggars belief: what in the world could "USB 3.1 Gen 2" possibly mean? Versions are free, why not simply name it "USB 3.2" and make the next one 3.3? "Gen 2" strikes me as the "Essay FINAL (final version 2).docx" of standards revisions.
- smarx007 5y agoI don't think it's an accident. I think manufacturers pressured the body to ensure they can always claim compatibility with the latest standard. For that purpose, version number became irrelevant and the profile name ("Gen 2") became important.
- WithinReason 5y agoSame thing happened with HDMI 2.1, all new features were defined as optional so everyone who only supports the 2.0 feature set can claim HDMI 2.1 compliance
- xattt 5y agoThere’s gotta be some lobbying or consulting firm hired by manufacturers that’s using the same strategy between the two standards. The consortiums don’t seem to realize that short-term profits are coming at their expense of their brand.
- als0 5y agoWhen you're the only game in town, brand doesn't matter so much.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agodisplay port?
- deleted 5y ago
- nikanj 5y agoUSB went from being the universal bus, to just being the universal connector. There are never any guarantees that your device (or cable!) actually supports the operation you’re trying
- fock 5y agoI'm fine with devices offering different capabilities. But the cables should be marked clearly... I have one of the chinese drawing tablets, which has a convoluted "to USB-C" adapter. Apparently you can also drive it with USB-C directly, however only a manufacturer-provided cable (supershort) fits the port. Noone know what cable you can use alternately...
- maccard 5y ago> But the cables should be marked clearly... How about by using different ports? Imagine if instead of playing whack a mole with 4 usb-c ports on my laptop, 2 usb c ports on my monitor and a bag of cables, I could plug a cable that fits into the port it fits into?
- masklinn 5y ago> How about by using different ports? That would just be worse: the port being backwards compatible is a feature, being able to plug a 5Gbps device into a 20G-capable-port is a good thing, so is being able to plug a self-powered device into a PD-capable port. The issue is the difficulty of matching the cable with the device (and port) to ensure the upper bounds match. Obviously you could get the highest-rated cables but there are tradeoffs in length and flexibility, using a 2x2 PD 3.1 cable to plug in a keyboard is just a waste of money and simply results in lower convenience (as the 2x2 PD 3.1 cable will be shorter and more rigid than a USB 2.0 low-power cable). That could be an argument for "different ports" being backwards-compatible "poka-yoke" (mistake-proofing) ports, but historically these have had really shitty design (e.g. m.2 tabs are plain misdesigned) and they would have required significantly increasing the size of the plugs to make room for the hardware features.
- jeffbee 5y agoWell it isn’t anything physical, because connecting an m1 Mac to another Thunderbolt device delivers the advertised speeds.
- jeroenhd 5y agoApple seems to lack the connectivity options competing chips offer, as seen with the limit on external screens on some M1 models and these USB options. It's easy to underestimate the amount of work that external connectors need the chip to do in order to work optimally. It makes sense, of course, as the M1 evolved from a mobile chip with at most one port (USB C if you're lucky) and not a lot of host traffic. I hope Apple fixes these issues soon, or at least acknowledges them. More likely than not Apple will just ignore the problem and tell their customers to buy Thunderbolt devices instead.
- Aaargh20318 5y ago> as seen with the limit on external screens on some M1 models (…) I hope Apple fixes these issues soon It’s only the base M1 used in the low-end devices that has limited support for external screens. A MBPro with M1 Max can drive 3x6k (DP1.4) plus 1x4k(HDMI2.0). That seems like more than enough for a laptop. Sounds to me like these issues have already been fixed.
- Alatrix 5y agoHow can you call a 2000$ mb pro or a 1700 imac low end devices?
- Aaargh20318 5y agoWhat are you talking about ? Both the 13" MBPro as well as the iMac start at $1299. The $2k MBPro with M1 Pro can drive 2 external 6k monitors, which seems reasonable. If you're the kind of user who needs 4 external displays, you're probably going to want the M1 Max anyway.
- Alatrix 5y agoSorry i used conversion from prices in euros, the base m1 imac is around 1630$ converted here. That's not by any mean cheap or entry level pricing and no it's not ok even for the 2k MBpro to only support 2 monitors at maximum. The kind of user who needs 3 displays doesn't need an m1 max anyway. I'm that user.
- ramijames 5y agoThe fact that I can't connect more than one monitor to my M1-based iMac is a fucking travesty.
- matja 5y agoWere you expecting to be able? The tech specs say "One external display".
- harha 5y agoNot sure this is fair to the consumer. Apple was advertising usb-c as one port to rule then all. When the device has two of these ports, why should the user expect not to connect two displays? Especially since this restriction didn’t apply to the previous models that looked exactly the same and are now advertised as less powerful. It would be natural to not explicitly look for how many displays it can handle.
- post_break 5y agoBack in 2011 you could use a second iMac is a monitor in target display mode, that went away, why should the user expect not to be able to use target display mode for every iMac? Things change unfortunately and the single display restriction of M1 was advertised heavily online and can be a pain point but it's listed online as a spec.
- harha 5y agoGood point, though I’d argue more people use two screens on a MacBook than an iMac as a screen, since it already provides a computer.
- eddieroger 5y agoIt must be to have posted the same comment twice. Did you do any research in to it before buying it? Apple was never misleading about how many monitors it could support. The "Tech Specs" product page says it can power its internal display and one extra external one. Just because you want it to do something doesn't make it a travesty when it can't.
- superkuh 5y ago
- legalcorrection 5y ago
- jeffbee 5y agoMy M1 Mini is the best computer I've ever owned, bar none. Most of that junk you are whining about is irrelevant niche stuff. Nobody GAF if they can replace the internal SSD, or if there's any difference between replacing the SSD and replacing the entire motherboard. It has two USB ports, two USB-C/TB3 ports, HDMI, ethernet, bluetooth, wifi, and a headphone barrel jack, like any other computer. WTF are dongles?
- aenis 5y agoI think the guy was just trolling. Esp that TLB stuff thats quite speculative and if true means memory hopping, write heavy, gpu bound apps can't squeeze all of the fastest, niche version of m1 ultra. I mean, thats just ridiculous. Its obvious to any programmer that squeezing all from a processor requires optimizations, usually for rapidly diminishing returns. My m1 max laptop is so good that if it broke today, I'd lament having to wait for a replacement, but wouldnt hesitate. Felt the same way about m1. And thats coming after three decades of low level programming work on dos, windows and linux x86 with the best hardware money could buy.
- paulmd 5y agoIf you've hung around some of the previous M1 threads, I really don't think he is trolling. That's actually how some people feel about it. I gotta say it's been really wild watching "epistemic closure" in action. There are clearly two different sets of facts and two different realities based on them that have emerged at this point, one where M1 is slower than x86 and requires everything to be emulated and USB doesn't work and you can't use external displays and it's a closed and locked-down system that is NEVER going to get a linux port, and one where it's got massive IPC and great battery life/etc and everything basically Just Works and the linux people are thundering along and have a basically workable system. People are living in like totally different worlds, one where it's just more apple trash and one where it's the best thing since sliced bread and actually better than the x86 alternatives. I dunno if it's people who just haven't used it, or people who are ideologically opposed to apple's designs, or just super hate macos, or what, but even in the benchmark space it's become completely bimodal, you've got Anandtech where it's showing up to 3.5x the IPC at 0.7x the clock of competing designs in SPEC cpu benchmarks suites, and you've got Hardware Unboxed where it barely edges out current designs at iso-power even in ARM-native builds of Cinebench. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/5 https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0bsjUMz3EM&t=726 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0bsjUMz3EM&t=726 tbh I've been thinking something similar in general - the synthetic stuff seems amazing, but it does seem like it has some problem actually putting power to the ground in real applications. Cinebench is native, so that shouldn't be a factor, and it should be something that makes great use of that absolutely wild FP32 IPC, so why isn't Apple running away with it anywhere near as much as SPEC shows it should? There's something weird there and I can't quite puzzle it out.
- mmastrac 5y agoI find it amusing that every single one of our high-speed standards (ethernet, HDMI, PCIE, displayport, USB) are basically just the same high-speed differential pairs under the hood with different framing. I don't know exactly what we can do about this situation, but at some point it probably makes sense for all of them to converge into a multi-lane, differential-pair standard (or just support nesting each other arbitrarily).
- madeofpalk 5y agoIIRC Thunderbolt essentially is "PCIE but in a cable"
- mmastrac 5y agoThat's my understanding as well.
- paulmd 5y agoThunderbolt actually includes a lot of other stuff that isn't just "pcie" in a cable - like USB and DisplayPort streams in addition (at the same time) to the PCIe links. There is also U.2 for shorter links. There are relatively trivial risers (not sure if it needs a chip or not, but either way they're under $30) that let you turn regular PCIe x4 or M.2 x4 slots into U.2 cables. It's intended for the enterprise space but if you just want "pcie in a cable" that's what it does. ExpressCard actually also was a PCIe 1.1x1 or 2.0x1 link as well, and people used risers to break out to external GPUs just as people do with thunderbolt. There are various eGPU setups "GDC Beast" is one I remember?) that are still available for ye olde thinkpad if you want more/better display connectors. Also obviously miners use those shitty USB-based riser cables (they aren't USB, but use USB wiring?) with x1 connectivity. I dunno whether any of those are "legal" according to the PCIe signalling requirements but in practice you can get short runs pretty reliably especially at lower speeds, and good PCIe riser cables can even do 3.0x16 or 4.0x16 capability.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LeanderK 5y agoI wonder whether it's a software or hardware problem? Let's say you have the thunderbolt connector, shouldn't all those supported standards (esp. the usb) then just be software problems? This does not make it easier for apples side, it might still be a huge undertaking, but then it would be upgradable in principle.
- WhyNotHugo 5y agoI'm wondering the same thing. I guess someone would have to run the same tests on a Mac running Asahi Linux and compare results. Any ideas of what software to use to measure this on Linux?
- TwoNineFive 5y agoThe article makes it pretty clear that they think this is a hardware problem.
- LeanderK 5y agoHmm where do you get that? I don't get the impression from reading the article.
- cosmiccatnap 5y agoThe apple apologists are in full swing in this comment section. $2000 laptops should do exactly what they claim, full stop.
- bfgoodrich 5y ago
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoI have two USB 3.2 drives that don’t work at all on my M1, but work fine on my Intel Mac. On the M1 they show up in Disk Inspector but any attempt to read from them, or even eject them, gets the bouncy ball.
- dev_tty01 5y agoIs this perhaps just a file system formatting issue? Disk Utility (there is no Disk Inspector) should tell you how they have been formatted. You mentioned reading from them. Can you erase them? Tried different cables?
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoAgain: works fine on Intel Mac.
- dev_tty01 5y agoSorry, missed that. Looks like lots of others are having issues, especially with the new Studio. https://www.macintouch.com/post/23506/m1-mac-port-problems/ https://www.macintouch.com/post/23506/m1-mac-port-problems/
- ThePhysicist 5y agoUSB-C seems to be hit & miss in general, it not only depends on the connector but also the cable and what's on the other side. I use my M1 with a Lenovo USB-C dock an theoretially it's capable of piping 4k at 60 Hz to my monitor, but in order for that to work I'd need to buy cables that cost half as much as the dock, so I just plug the HDMI cable directly into the Macbook (and am thankful they included an HDMI port at all). Also, you have to know which USB-C port to plug stuff into as they don't seem to be equal in terms of functionality, or maybe it's just the cable? In any case they're not marked differently. But yeah, first world problems.
- CharlesW 5y ago> I use my M1 with a Lenovo USB-C dock an theoretially it's capable of piping 4k at 60 Hz to my monitor, but in order for that to work I'd need to buy cables that cost half as much as the dock… In case it's helpful, have you looked at Monoprice? They sell great USB-C 3.2 Gen 2 cables for $10 (0.5m). https://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=27923 https://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=27923
- cyounkins 5y agoThe block size used isn't specified, and that has a significant impact on performance. The exact model drives used aren't specified, but elsewhere in the comments someone references the Crucial X8. With 32KB block sizes, the transfer speed is ~520 MB/s. https://www.anandtech.com/show/16186/crucial-portable-ssd-x6-and-x8-2tb-review-qlc-for-storage-onthego/3 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16186/crucial-portable-ssd-x6...
- TwoNineFive 5y agoThe author is a dev who publishes multiple high-end storage applications. I'm not sure why you though questioning his judgement over something so basic would be a good idea.