18 ms·
FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'
- jl2718 5y agoWhat specific document or witness mentions “affluent neighborhood”? Without that information, this article is about a judge making an political statement.
- testemailfordg2 5y agoJust as light bends under the influence of gravity....Looks like rule of law also bends under the influence of capitalism...
- seibelj 5y agoIn the Soviet Union the high level apparatchiks lived in better housing, away from the common people. There will always be elite people. At least in capitalism you become rich by providing value to other people. In socialism you become elite by stealing from your comrades and forcefully eliminating the competition.
- eesmith 5y agoWhat value did John T. Walton provide that was worth US$18.2 billion? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_T._Walton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_T._Walton
- sdoering 5y agoAs much as I agree with your sentiment, I think you could just as easily quote from the first paragraph of the linked Wikipedia article to find a counter point to your (seemingly) rhetoric question: > Walton cofounded the Children's Scholarship Fund, providing tuition scholarships for disadvantaged youth.
- oblio 5y agoThat's not worth $18.2tn, knowing charity it was probably worth a few tens of millions, at best, and was used for tax write-offs. Plus knowing rich people, he evaded/avoided taxes (probably hundreds of millions, if not billions) that regular Joes making $36.4k a year would never be able to.
- lovich 5y agoHe did that with money he already had, unless he somehow managed to turn a profit off a charity which would be a different concern
- settrans 5y agoThat's obviously not how property rights work. Sam Walton was entitled to bequeath his wealth to his heirs however he saw fit, subject to any applicable estate and inheritance taxes.
- 8note 5y agoOn death, what right do you retain to that property? Under a more capitalist system, your children could not inherit, and instead have to start from the bottom like everyone else.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThat’s not capitalism. That’s some kind of meritocratic (anti?-)utopia. Capitalism is when you can do with your property whatever you want including giving it away to whomever you want.
- oblio 5y agoCapitalism ideally means ideal free markets, free of distortion. Starting with market distorting money from birth by definition... distorts markets.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoA mere change in market equilibrium doesn’t constitute a market distortion.
- oblio 5y agoYou can label anything "a mere change in market equilibrium", apparently even someone inheriting more money than the GDP of an average sized country ...
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThe magnitude doesn't matter, it is a qualitatively different phenomenon. This provides a definition of a market distortions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_distortion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_distortion This may help understand why it is defined this particular way and why it excludes inheritance and other wealth transfers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_theorems_of_welfare_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_theorems_of_welfar... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_efficiency
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoKids have obvious value to their parents. That’s like one of the most basic evolutionary instincts.
- eesmith 5y agoSure. But then you have to argue that John T. Walton provided $18 billion of value to his parents. And if Sam Walton were taxed at 100% for all wealth over $100 million, so John Walton were only worth $20 million, then would John have provided less value to his parents? My parents spend several $100,000 on my upbringing. Does that represent my value to my parents? The children from the world's poorest families also provide value to their parents. From this I conclude that "obvious value" of evolution and capitalism's "monetary value" aren't the same.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoValue is subjective and dependence on your circumstances.
- eesmith 5y agoThe current circumstances are from seibelj's comment "you become rich by providing value to other people", where "value" is specifically something which provides economic wealth. Gaining wealth by being the child of a wealthy person is not something specific to capitalism, certainly happened in feudal monarchies, and almost certainly also happened with the children of high level apparatchiks in the Soviet Union.
- sdoering 5y agoWhile I agree with the Soviet part (or any political system for that matter) I doubt the pro capitalist generalization would stand to scrutiny: > At least in capitalism you become rich by providing value to other people. One could easily find examples that counter these points. I doubt pyramid schemes (think Madoff's schemes) or crypto scams are the only counter-examples possible. These more often than not come from an imbalance of information. People (or the market) could make better decisions with all information being accessible at the time of the decision. But all too often one side has more information than the other. Giving this side an edge. > In socialism you become elite by stealing from your comrades and forcefully eliminating the competition. In capitalism it is basically the same as long as you can get away with it. I know it isn't a popular opinion, but without regulation capitalism is in now way better than other systems. Their excesses would all need to be reigned in. Because no unregulated system would be acting in the common good. The system may be organized in a way to slightly enable more or less perdonsl freedom. Or more or less societal freedom. But in the end - for average Joe - uncontrolled capitalism boils down to the working and living conditions of the early industrialisation or (in case of socialism) towards the living and working conditions of late soviet times.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoIt can be trivially shown to be not true by considering that some people are a toxic drain on a company, costing them immense amounts of money, torpedoing productivity, ruining morale and yet continue to draw a salary for years and years.
- drekipus 5y agoYes, the point of capitalism is that people can do that, but shouldn't. And it should work in tandem with whatever social system that's set up, (justice, laws, morals, ethics, etc) Pyramid schemes steal a great amount of wealth, and should be regulated. Regulated capitalism is the good thing. The thing is, pyramid schemes aren't run by the state (or shouldn't be) and you don't have a gun to your head forcing you to participate. I almost feel like "unregulated capitalism" is just a straw man argument that others get tricked into trying to defend.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 8note 5y agoI'm sure plenty of Soviets became rich by providing value to other people today. The main way to become elite regardless is to be born that way, capitalism or not. The rest is noise
- babyshake 5y ago> At least in capitalism you become rich by providing value to other people. You become rich by capturing value. Often times, as Silicon Valley and its investors like to remind the world, a lot of value is also being provided so it is indeed a win-win. But you don't become rich by providing value.
- csallen 5y agoTrue. However, there are two points worth making: 1. The purpose of many laws and regulations that support capitalism is to make it very difficult to capture value without creating it. (When compared to a world without these laws.) 2. It's generally much easier to capture value that you create than to capture value that others create. The result is that there's a massive incentive to create value for others, and a great deal of rich people and organizations are creating value, even if it's not all of them. IMO this is under-appreciated and taken for granted in the modern era, as if it couldn't be any other way.
- nicoburns 5y ago> It's generally much easier to capture value that you create than to capture value that others create. I think that's probably true in general, but that over the course of ~100 years of capitalism the edge cases where this isn't true have been exploited sufficiently that it's starting to become a big problem. The clearest illustration of this being real estate. There are a lot of people getting rich by doing nothing other than buying and holding onto to real estate, often at the expense of others being able to make use of that resource.
- csallen 5y agoHomes are interesting to think about. Arguably, every time something is bought in the physical world, it comes at the expense of others being able to make use of that resource, not just homes. So I wouldn't say this is relevant to what makes the housing market exploitative. For example, if I buy a standing desk, I've taken it off the market and you can't buy that exact desk I bought anymore, until I want it sell it. And just like I use my desk most of the time, most property that's purchased is either lived in or rented out. Sure, some properties sit empty, but I think it's the vast minority, I'd guess < 15%. The owners don't get rich by merely holding. They have to actually sell before they make money, which means others are making use of the resource both before the sale (via renting) and at the point of the sale (via becoming the new owners). Plus, many owners do create value via renovations, which makes the property better. But at the very least, you're on the hook as an owner to repair and maintain the quality of the property so it doesn't lose value. You're a steward. That's expensive, and it does create/preserve value. When it comes time to sell, the vast majority of the sale price is just recouping the original amount you paid, anyway. Still, when we look at the profits on top of that, it is true that much of it doesn't come from people working to create value. Houses tend to appreciate in value due to demand outstripping supply, because more people are moving to (or being born into) a location than there are houses being built there. However, I wouldn't call this exploitation. When this dynamic is at hand, everyone sells their homes for a profit by default, no nefarious or exploitative deeds required. Even if you're buying up properties for the express purpose of selling them later, you're not selling them for any more than they would've eventually been sold by the people you bought from. Sure, people are creating rich here without creating value, but they're not doing nefarious things. If there's any villain here, imo it's restricting the housing supply, which fucks with the market's ability to provide more supply and keep prices affordable. IMO there are better examples of nefarious things happening under capitalism. Usually they're monopolistic and anti-competitive: unfair practices to limit supply, to keep competitors out of the market, etc. Buying up patents (artificial monopolies) and then jacking up prices on a drug, for example. Non-competes or unethical collusion between companies to not hire each other's employees. Stuff like that. But it's worth noting that all of this is decided uncapitalistic, because it's anti-competitive. So even these aren't great examples. I'd say the worst aspects of capitalism that are actually capitalistic are… 1. Creating negative public externalities, e.g. polluting rivers to create your products, then reaping the profits privately but making the costs public. There is always incentive to minimize costs in a capitalistic system, and so it's a natural challenge for governments to identify these externalities and make companies pay. 2. Accruing too much power as a result of having money. Basically, the influence of money on the political and legal system. More money should get you a better life in terms of access to more goods and services, but it shouldn't allow you to lobby for laws, win elections, or win court cases. This is a hard problem to solve, however, and therefore a natural disadvantage of capitalism. 3. Serving the rich. It generally pays more to create products and services for rich people, because they have more money to spend. That's just how the physics of capitalism work out. The result is that poor neighborhoods, cities, and countries have worse infrastructure, fewer stores, etc. Innovative companies simply have less incentive to sell there. I think this is intrinsic to capitalism, and it's a problem, because it means the rich get richer.
- lordnacho 5y agoIt's a common refrain that people get rich by providing value to others, and I used to think that way as well. Unfortunately I don't think it really stands scrutiny. First of all, there's no proper idea of what value is. It's a super deep conversation so I'll just leave that headline for now. Second, even without a clear explanation of what value is, we can distinguish between value created and value captured. You can easily come up with cases where multiple people have done more or less the same thing but one guy gets more out of it than others. Is that the system we want? Third, even without an explanation of what value is, we can see that there are people who provide no value but get paid a heck of a lot. Heirs, scam artists of various sorts. Not just straight give-you-nothing for something thieves, but also plenty of way overpaid people who live in the space between totally honest trading and totally dishonest thievery.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoValue is a self defining concept. It's what an individual want. The value of a society is the weighted sum of values based on individual power. Amazon is creating a lot of small value to a lot of people by delivering goods next day. People on wall street are creating a lot of value for wealthy and powerful people. An engineer can automate a lot of value creation that was previously done by a large number of people, allowing companies to have a shot at making a lot of money, hence why they're paid more. Some of those powerful and wealthy people got rich by providing value, some of them got rich by exploiting the government's centralised power, its corruption and the possibility of stealing value from all the taxpayers. A scam is a crime on par with stealing or charging taxes. Stealing doesn't create value, it just transfer wealth.
- Retric 5y agoValue isn’t what people want. People want drinking water more than just about anything else, but that’s cheap to provide so the cost stays low. Gold on the other hand is rarely something people consider or want, but it’s rare therefore it has high material value.
- 5y ago
- watwut 5y ago> In the Soviet Union the high level apparatchiks lived in better housing, away from the common people. Tho, after USSR fell, inequality in Russia went up by a lot. And it gave rise to what are now oligarch - the mix of very powerful mafia and business with very little constraints on them at the time. And that situation made Russians appreciate Putin, going full circle back to authoritarianism and imperialism.
- sumedh 5y ago> At least in capitalism you become rich by providing value to other people. Or you inherit your wealth and politicians. Or you break the rules to get to the top and then pay a small fine if you get caught.
- drekipus 5y agoI get so tired of comments like this, such low effort brain drainage.. Yes yes we know the glorious Soviet society that was the pinnacle of fair and just. It's almost like justice and rule of law are separated from the economy and wealth. "But it is not so" - well it should be so, don't ask for further coupling of economic systems. For law and justice to be fair, liberties need to be given. Not taken.
- arcticbull 5y ago> Yes yes we know the glorious Soviet society that was the pinnacle of fair and just. The opposite of end-stage capitalism isn't Stalinism. It's very American to view the opposite of "capitalism" as the Soviet Union, but the truth is there's a whole spectrum in between socialism and capitalism, totalitarianism and libertarianism. In my opinion this criticism is just as low-effort. > It's almost like justice and rule of law are separated from the economy and wealth. I respectfully disagree. Societies with less inequality tend to be more peaceful. Economic policy and social policy are very much intertwined. > For law and justice to be fair, liberties need to be given. Not taken. Law and justice is by definition the restriction of liberties to support a functioning society - not the giving of liberties. You begin with the full universe of liberties and law/order is all about choosing which ones are sacrificed by whom to optimize along a certain axis.
- drekipus 5y ago> Societies with less inequality tend to be more peaceful. Yes absolutely, but that's not what we're talking about. We are talking about "justice". > Economic policy and social policy are very much intertwined. Cause and effect, yes, but economic policies don't (or shouldn't) affect the notion of justice. Laws should not be written as "if you own X amount or produce y units" as they were in the Soviet union. >Law and justice is by definition the restriction of liberties I don't agree but I can see the argument. If I were to never throw rubbish over my neighbours fence, then whether or not the law is there doesn't affect my liberty. Neither if there was a law forbidding the dumping of oils in the water supply.. this isn't a "restriction of liberties" but rather the guarantee of protection to the water: or I would put it as "giving liberty to me and others of the quality of the water" I understand that this is all subjective and slippery arguments so I'll digress from that.. what else are we meant to do in HN comment sections.. But I do hold to my judgement of "little to no brain use" for anyone who tries to support communism or similar measures. People need to be free, free to succeed (and unfortunately, free to fail). Laws and justice should protect people from each other, not enforce someone's failure to understand mathematics or entropy.
- imgabe 5y agoFYI the neighborhood is Kalorama in DC, where a lot of diplomats and high-level government officials live. Maybe the agents didn't want one of the neighbors to call the director of the FBI to have them chewed out for "making the neighborhood look bad", which is not an impossible thing to happen there considering who the neighbors are. I imagine if you're an FBI field agent, the last thing you want for your career is for the director to be getting angry calls from other high level officials because of you.
- sitzkrieg 5y agothanks for pointing something out that is in the article?!
- imgabe 5y agoThey briefly mention it, but quickly move on to "the FBI doesn't knock down rich people's doors". In this case it's more likely these particular rich people (i.e. well-connected people in the US government) than a blanket policy of "don't knock down doors in affluent neighborhoods".
- ALittleLight 5y agoAre there many neighborhoods packed with unconnected rich folks?
- imgabe 5y agoNot in the DC area, but in plenty of other cities sure. It's not that they're particularly rich, as far as rich people go, it's that the neighbor is like, the chief of staff for the Senator who's in charge of the committee that sets the FBI's budget. Imagine you're a low to mid level employee of a company, and you go do something that makes all of the CEO's friends, business partners, and investors pissed off at him. Do you think that's going to be good for you?
- 5y ago
- ncmncm 5y agoMaybe we should be asking why they are so eager to break down other people's doors, instead of harassing them for not breaking down just this one.
- watwut 5y agoThe very same people who are pointing out this were complaining about aggressive police tactic for years. It is not instead.
- croes 5y agoSo why not use the same tactics for both, rich and poor? Or is violence reserved for poorer people?
- praptak 5y agoDoes a bear shit in the woods?
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoUsually some rich old guy won't shoot at cops, when they come knocking at the door. Those people use lawyers, not guns.
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago"No Knock" usually implies that they don't announce that they are police before they kick the door down. I'm not sure I could confidently say that a rich person is less likely to draw a gun when someone kicks their door down in the middle of the night. Maybe they are more likely to have a panic room, or just long corridors that provide enough time for the situation to become clear before they have a gun held in their face by someone claiming to be the FBI.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoI mean... let's be real... a rich person will answer the knock, follow the police peacefully to the police car, and the only thing they'll say and do is "i want my lawyer"
- 88840-8855 5y agoPeople with money and power have it better. Yes, clear, thanks for yet another confirmation. This is why I could never enjoy NYC. As a normal middle class dude you always feel everywhere that you are a nothing: no fame/no power/no money = people are rude, aggressive, hostile to you. I never felt that in London, which is a quite comparable city to NYC. I felt welcome in most places despite not being rich or famous.
- alephnan 5y ago> no fame/no power/no money = people are rude, aggressive, hostile to you. No, some New Yorkers, rich or poor, are rude, aggressive, hostile regardless of who you are. Unless you work for Axe capital. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lF46Cel3EUo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lF46Cel3EUo
- kingkawn 5y agoNYC gives you the city you look for in it
- jollybean 5y agoNYC as assertive, that's just the way it is. And most rich and famous people are not identifiable as such. This is a non-story. If you don't have gang relations, no criminal record, no violence, no gun ownership ... there's no reason for the cops to bang down the door. That said, I think cops are too aggressive in general about this. That also said - the cops do have a policy of 'bang down the door' because I think it's actually safer for the cops (I loathe to find that data sorry). So, like everything, it's complicated. Definitely policing, like everything else has to be 1) 'smart' i.e. materially proportional, use force where required and 2) we have to accept at least some wiggle room. No matter what, the cops will be wrong some time. So, like everything, we have to be smart about it.
- spacemanmatt 5y ago> we have to be smart about it. We could start by prohibiting IQ caps enforced by police departments. No, really, they went to court to ensure they could continue to refuse candidates who exceed their own intelligence or any other arbitrary intelligence limit they want to enforce. https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/st...
- alephnan 5y agoWell if the suspect was wrongly accused, they'd have to reimburse the damages. Does the FBI have a budget for such things? Does it involve extra paperwork if it passes a certain threshold? Is the issue here profiling of the demographic or the risk ( in terms of cost ).
- MegaButts 5y ago> Well if the suspect was wrongly accused, they'd have to reimburse the damages. Do they? I'm honestly asking, but I would be surprised if most of the time the police (or any 3 letter agency) reimbursed victims for their negligence.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoNobody ever brought Breonna Taylor back to life for her wrongful shooting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt doesn't happen. You could have your car torn to shreds by cops looking for drugs that don't exist and they won't owe you a dime for the damages.
- theshrike79 5y agoWe have cases of just regular-ass police in the US breaking through the door, shooting the family dog and dragging people out in their underwear. Wrong guy? Whoops. Sorry. No reimbursement.
- pstuart 5y agoWell, when there is reimbursement (via lawsuits) it is the city that pays for it. The police should be self-insured, backed by their pension fund. They are granted incredible power with no real accountability.
- exogeny 5y agoAmerica is much more racist than you think, and if you don't think so, you should probably talk to more POC.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoYeah, that certainly sounds like an issue of race and not of class. I guess in racially homogenous societies wealthy people don’t get any preferential treatment by police in any way whatsoever.
- exogeny 5y agoThey're inexorably linked in this country. That shouldn't even need to be pointed out.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> shouldn't even need to be pointed out Perhaps our greatest failure is the generation that takes any contest to this claim as heresy.
- ss108 5y agoI agree that a lot (though not all) of the issues people want to pin on race are really just about class, but would you deny that there is at least a correlation between race and class? Or that law enforcement has a bad racism problem? To be clear, I don't think most cops are racist or bad (in our current culturo-political moment, I probably err on the more pro-cop side), but it's certainly a problem that hasn't been given any real thought or attention by most police departments.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoBut is it reasonable to derail every discussion about wealth into a discussion about race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, height, diet and god knows what else merely because those things are linked in some way?
- mangoTangoBango 5y ago
- Icko 5y agorun for office, you seem to know what to do
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lostlogin 5y agoUS aid is huge and vastly exceeds other countries. As a percentage of GDP or when divided by head of population, its rather less impressive than what other places achieve. I don’t think the budget will be balanced by further disadvantaging the disadvantaged. However reducing arms exports as a form of aid could help, but that gets complex fast. Does Israel need billions of dollars of arms? Ukraine? Couldn’t it all depend on some basic human rights being met? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_development_aid_country_donors https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_development_aid_coun...
- mangoTangoBango 5y agoDoesn’t matter. We should care more about people who are dying on the street (I have seen this firsthand), have seen this myself in Seattle and SF, and giving everyone healthcare before giving Ukraine or any other country aid. This is something that both Democrats and Republicans seem to ignore because they want to pursue their own self-interested agendas.
- DoctorOW 5y ago> We should start over, get rid of those parasites, move the capital to the center of the USA like Lebanon, KS out of the swamp. The physical location of the capitol has been irrelevant since airplanes, cell phones, and the internet. The swamp is a metaphor, not a physical place.
- 5y ago
- fareesh 5y agoSo in this case the agent says they went through the rear entrance instead of knocking down the front door Is it common for poorer neighbourhood houses to have a rear entrance? Genuine question - I don't know what the typical USA poor neighbourhood house has
- DFHippie 5y agoThe fire code typically requires that homes have two egresses so if one is blocked by fire the occupants can still escape.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoyeah if you have a house as opposed to an apartment you probably have a rear door, and even lots of apartments have other ways of getting out than the door depending on lots of factors.
- _Nat_ 5y ago> "I can tell you that is not protocol. The problem is there are two justice systems: 1 for poor people and minorities and 1 for rich people and generally white people. You see it when you are one of the few black agents. Everyone is not equal." Was "Tarek Abou-Khatwa" not a minority? [The surname "Abou" appears to be most commonly associated with either Niger or Egypt](https://forebears.io/surnames/abou https://forebears.io/surnames/abou ), while ["Khatwa" appears to be most commonly associated with Egypt](https://forebears.io/surnames/khatwa https://forebears.io/surnames/khatwa ).
- aliswe 5y agoWait, no ... Abou in arabic means "father of ...", so it's in a possessive construct. It needs the other word to make sense. The "ou" is just an approximation, other spellings include Abo, Abu, Aboo, Bou, Ba ... Whole of North Africa is filled to the brim with Abou-xyz family names, even first names (Abu Madyan "Boumedienne" in Algeria for example) and also many many such names in the other parts of the arab world.
- zarzavat 5y agoYes, Abu X is a kunya[0]. It could mean that your child’s name is X, or X could be something more abstract and figurative like a nickname. The “ou” spelling of و is French style and would usually indicate a French speaking country or an former French colony. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunya_(Arabic) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunya_(Arabic)
- aliswe 5y agoTarek Abou-Khatwa, my guess on that name (i didnt even read the article, lol) is Morocco? wdyt?
- ss108 5y agoCould be anywhere from North Africa. The possibility that the person is from the Levant from among a family who decided to spell their name in a Francophone way cannot be eliminated.
- tomohawk 5y agoWhat's actually disturbing is that more than 90% of the time this would be a "no knock" raid with paramiliterized police smashinng down the door, tossing in flash-bang grenades - the works. No knock should be reserved for extreme situations, not the norm.
- pooper 5y ago> No knock should be reserved for extreme situations, not the norm. At this point, I'd say no knock should be unlawful.
- withinboredom 5y agoNot knocking implies that you live there and have a right to utilize the residence which flies in the face of Amendment #3. The fact that they’re geared like the military, etc just makes this even more obvious to me. Add to the fact that police will be stationed there over multiple days to investigate the domicile… sounds like quartering to me.
- pooper 5y agoIt sounds to me that the US Congress is the only body that can ban these atrocities nationwide. Is this true? > Use of no-knock warrants has increased substantially over time. By one estimate, there were 1,500 annually in the early 1980s whereas by 2010 there were 60,000–70,000 no-knock or quick-knock raids conducted by local police annually, the majority of which were looking for marijuana. > Currently, Florida, Oregon, Tennessee, and Virginia ban no-knock warrants; however, state-level bans do not affect federal law enforcement. Thirteen states have laws explicitly permitting no-knock warrants, and the remaining states issue them based on a judge's discretion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-knock_warrant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-knock_warrant
- shadowfacts 5y agoThe Supreme Court could rule that no-knock warrants are unconstitutional, but that's not going to happen with this court, so yes, practically speaking, it's on Congress.
- jollybean 5y ago? The FBI have information about the people they are nabbing and already have a risk profile. If the people the are grabbing have zero history of violence, no gun ownership, no gang association, there's no reason to smash down the door. Even judging by neighbourhood: It's probably unfair but my bet is diplomats don't generally get into shootouts with the cops. They could probably safely do the same in middle class neighbourhoods as well. It's not a nice statement about equity, rather my belief that the 'risk' to police is probably entirely from specific kinds of problem areas which are probably poor. If you look at a map of violent crime in cities, the delineations are pretty clear. Some neighbourhoods have almost zero violent crime, two blocks down, it's Caracas. 'Zip Code' profiling might actually be just, but I don't see why they could not do it on a case to case basis.
- YawningAngel 5y agoI'm going to take a guess that lots of the subjects of no knock raids have no history of violence or gang association. Gun ownership, stupidly, is legal in the US, so it seems like poor grounds for a police action
- lalopalota 5y agoThere is a perfectly valid reason for law enforcement to break down a door that does not have anything to do with risk profile: they have a search warrant and no one with a key is available to open a door (like in this article).
- belter 5y agoFought Experiment: Lets say law enforcement was given the task to examine the affairs of 100, randomly selected, poor/medium income households and 100, randomly selected, very wealthy households. Statistically, where would they find the most amount of criminal activity? Has any similar research been done, and would you care to share the data?
- Etherlord87 5y agoI'm surprised by the reactions to your comment, because the first thing I thought was "obviously the very wealthy households, because of drugs present".
- belter 5y agoAnd your analysis is corroborated by waste sewage analysis around areas like Wall Street :-)
- Thorentis 5y agoThese types of statistics are politically inconvinient and will never be reported on.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoWhy is this on HN?
- irisman 5y agoSame here. Reddit exists for posts like these. I look forward to the day this place becomes tech only. Or another place similar.
- jmyeet 5y agoLet's compare this experience to that of Amir Locke [1]. To summarize: the Minneapolis PD was executing a no-knock warrant in a homicide investigation. Locke was not the target of the warrant but was sleeping on the couch. He was licensed for the firearm and it was completely legal. When startled awake, he reached for his gun (natural reaction) and the police shot and killed him. You'd think the NRA would be all over this: a legal gun owner killed in his home by police? Nope [2]. I wonder why. Let's also compare to Kyle Rittenhouse. Attorneys wanted to use the fact that one of his victims was a sex offender as a defense [3]. There are two possibilities here: 1. Rittenhouse didn't know of this, in which case it's immaterial; and 2. Rittenhouse knew, in which case this was a targeted killing (ie murder). No one is arguing Rittenhouse knew. The whole point here is post facto justification. This is for the court of public opinion and to give the jury something to hang their hat on with an acquittal. That's it. I bring this up because I want to highlight the different worlds people live in when it comes to law enforcement. Yet you can't bring the above up without some (predominantly white) people getting offended at the mere suggestion that the system is inherently racist. Think about that. [1]: https://abcnews.go.com/US/amir-lockes-death-prompts-ban-knock-warrants/story?id=83958251 https://abcnews.go.com/US/amir-lockes-death-prompts-ban-knoc... [2]: https://www.newsweek.com/where-nra-gun-rights-group-slammed-silence-amir-locke-1695717 https://www.newsweek.com/where-nra-gun-rights-group-slammed-... [3]: https://www.kenoshanews.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/kyle-rittenhouses-attorney-wants-to-show-victim-was-sex-offender/article_c02a0810-de8b-11eb-9a39-53d6e055571f.html https://www.kenoshanews.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/kyle...
- imgabe 5y agoThe suspect in this case was Tarek Abou-Khatwa, who, maybe I’m making assumptions here, doesn’t sound like he’s white. Are you saying that the super-racist FBI agents decided to cut Mr. Abou-Khatwa a break because he’s a member of the good ol’ boys club?
- Epiphany21 5y agoThe way people of a certain political persuasion are talking about race recently reminds me of this scene from an old Family Guy skit. https://i.imgflip.com/2oxj8k.jpg https://i.imgflip.com/2oxj8k.jpg
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AniseAbyss 5y ago
- popotamonga 5y agoSidenote is doors are really soft in US. Over here armored doors are a thing and they would basically need explosives or just demolish the reinforced concrete wall. Or just call the lockpickinglawyer
- mkl 5y agoWhere is "over here"?
- erellsworth 5y agoThis just in: D.C. Circuit judge somehow shocked to learn elites get special treatment in our society.
- shadowfacts 5y agoNo, a DC Circuit Judge is shocked to learn that an FBI agent was explicitly stating that they were treating residents of an affluent neighborhood differently.
- boredumb 5y agoPeople screaming systemic racism in this thread because the FBI didn't knock down "Tarek Abou-Khatwa's" door, doubtfully read the article. If the system is racist than I can either guess they didn't read this or I imagine that they are implying the system is racist by protecting Arabic men. Also this man committed insurance fraud, a non-violent crime with no history of violence so the need to catch them off guard before they can begin a shoot out with law enforcement was simply not a requisite. If he was selling illegal drugs and hoarding cash that required him to have fire arms and defend against possible home intruders trying to rob his black-market products/cash than this story would be different, and then the 'systemic racism' people could race bait the story, fortunately not the case, unfortunately the comments persist.
- projektfu 5y agoThe article says the person raising the issue didn't think they were doing Abou-Khatwa a favor per se, but rather protecting the aesthetics of a tawny, mostly white neighborhood.
- pessimizer 5y ago> It's not clear whether the FBI agents who searched Abou-Khatwa's house were doing him a favor by eschewing a front-door entry. The agent's testimony makes it sound as if the main concern was the impact that knocking down Abou-Khatwa's front door would have on his wealthy neighbors. From the article that you definitely read.
- boredumb 5y agoI definitely did. And none of what you pasted has to do with race or is for certain. It is a single agents testimony and has to do with the fact it's a neighborhood full of wealthy politicians and nothing to do with race or systemic racism at all. My original point was also that if they had performed a no-knock raid on this minority in an affluent area it would be a sign of 'systemic racism' to people who are race baiting. To elaborate further, law enforcement is now in a kafka-esque story of having to figure out the wealth of the suspect, racial demographics of the neighborhood, and race of suspect and his crimes before performing a warrant to decipher the level of force that is allowed and will regardless be the villain according to vocal minorities and journalists. Truly progress.
- rob_c 5y agoAnd now we get to it, but people are more concerned about pro-nouns and fighting over hurt feelings among themselves and other groups to realise the problem here. Aside from the observation that the rich class is made up of mostly white people the problem is 1 rule for them 1 rule for the rest. Look at the lockdown parties in the UKs political capital whilst idiots were fighting over face-masks in shops. I applaud the FBI for being raked through the mud for this, they bloomin well deserve this. They will no-doubt counter with the cost of restoring a building and public money as if often the get-out. Either stand-up/speak-out to all of the oppression or don't, picking and choosing is just enabling fighting amongst those who are also being trodden on.
- dudul 5y agoThe constant outrage around pronouns, systemic racism, and others is specifically engineered and pushed forward to hide the rich vs poor problematic and keep people busy and with the feeling that they are fighting the system.
- 1123581321 5y agoStruggling to find something worth discussing in this article: my takeaway is that we can preserve the life and property of our neighbor by making our homes look nicer. :) This principle plays out in small ways, too. Be diligent about picking up trash in your neighborhood and over time, the rate of littering will decrease. Park carefully on your curb and fewer will park haphazardly or on the wrong side. And so on.
- after_care 5y agoNah. No one gives a shit about a nice suburb in Dallas. I’ve seen feds execute warrants in very nice neighborhoods. The FBI canceled because the neighborhood was a nice one in DC, where people with external influence live.
- 1123581321 5y agoI don’t live in Dallas so I’ll take your word for it. When you and your neighbors get together, does it seem hopeless or are there any other strategies being tried to prevent destructive raids?
- asah 5y agowealth = empowerment = fight back = personal/career risk
- nfriedly 5y agoThe FBI absolutely deserves all of the flak they're getting, but I think it's somewhat misdirected. It seems that a lot of folks believe the FBI should have knocked down the door. I'd argue the opposite - I'd prefer they gave people in poor neighborhoods the same level of respect that they showed this time. If the normal policy was to prefer to avoid property damage, then this situation would have just been business as usual and there wouldn't be any outrage.
- rak 5y agoRelevant Chappelle Show skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeOVbeh2yr0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeOVbeh2yr0
- bacan 5y agoThis happens all over the world. Poor people are treated worse than the rich treat their animals