19 ms·
Drone footage of Tesla factory
- rdoherty 5y agoOriginal from Tesla YT channel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-4yOx1CnXE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-4yOx1CnXE
- KerrickStaley 5y ago+1. Mods, I think this is a better link (first hand source, also easier to view full screen)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mwint 5y agodang - mind changing this link to the original above?
- tintinmovie 5y agoAlso kudos to the drone pilot - https://www.instagram.com/ferdigrapher/ https://www.instagram.com/ferdigrapher/ https://www.youtube.com/c/SkynamicNet/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/SkynamicNet/videos
- mgdlbp 5y ago(^ the Skynamic channel has a short behind-the-scenes video)
- stevenjgarner 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpIuoxMSFeQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpIuoxMSFeQ
- smoovb 5y agoWith some basic commentary from Sandy Munro - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvNxvm6aQI4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvNxvm6aQI4 The Giga Press as seen in the video. https://www.idragroup.com/index.php/en/solutions/machines/gigapress https://www.idragroup.com/index.php/en/solutions/machines/gi...
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoSandy Munro is a high quality commentator here, IMO people should not downvote this. Also the Giga Press is a fascinating piece of engineering.
- bombcar 5y agoIt is very instructional to watch his early commentary and compare to now - the speed of changes and improvements is phenomenal.
- sidibe 5y agoWell in any case the change in his enthusiasm for and devotion to Tesla is phenomenal.
- panick21_ 5y agoWell he said he has been pitching large casting to OEM for a decade+ and then he sent a free suggesting excel table to Tesla after their analysis. Within less then a year Tesla was pushing hard into that technology and invested many 100s of millions into it. We don't of course know if Tesla did that because of his suggestions but they did 'the right thing'. He also just bought a Rivian so he clearly is happy for all well engineered products.
- recuter 5y agoHe didn't add that much to the original video this time but the Munro teardowns are fantastic and I can't believe they are posted for free. Sandy is awesome. People who don't know should check out the rest of the channel.
- megablast 5y agoAll that wasted on a car.
- turing_complete 5y agoWow, you're edgy.
- ryandrake 5y agoUgh... I get that the purpose of the video is to stylistically look cool and not to convey information, but only half way through and my head hurts and I think I have motion sickness from all the spinning, tilting, speeding up, slowing down and rapid cuts. Whatever happened to just taking a slow, stabilized drone tour, dwelling/focusing on the important/interesting parts? If you have a weak stomach, don't watch while eating breakfast, you're likely to lose it.
- DIVx0 5y agoI assume this was done with a FPV piloted drone. I just got into FPV flying and this was pretty impressive! My stomach lurched a few times recalling times I've tried to squeeze into tight spaces only to drift where I shouldn't be.
- laurent92 5y agoAren’t they using 3D? inside the first machine for example, a human can’t monitor, and the pieces falling off seem to have lunar gravity.
- floober 5y agoI definitely had some uncanny valley vibes watching it, but I think it might be a combination of the camera's perspective (distorting distances away from center) and the footage being sped up/slowed down.
- throwra620 5y ago
- saidinesh5 5y agoMore like footage being stabilized in software like Reelsteady / Gyroflow . Typically fpv videos are a little more "jerky" and these software remove the lens distortion and then stabilize the footage. here's a sample: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EA6ntosoZYs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EA6ntosoZYs
- smallerfish 5y agoThere's lots of cuts and morphs, so it's not continuous. Also lots of speed adjustments. Many of the shots were probably done very slowly and sped up after. No reason that it needs to be FPV - if they have a 3D model of the factory they could have created a path for it to fly. I don't think Ardupilot or Betaflight is up to that(?), but a small team of engineers working for a couple of months would be able to make it work.
- pedrogpimenta 5y agoThink about this. Think about where we got, as a people. This is out of this world. I don't want to get into if you like it or not or think it's good or not, no. Anyway you feel about Tesla, Musk, mass production, automation, whatever, just stop for a moment and think how the heck did we get here? I was amazed. I know some folks are used to these kinds of environments, but me? It looks straight from a 80s or 90s big sci-fi movie. It's mesmerizing.
- amelius 5y agoStill, there is no robot that can take a LEGO instruction booklet, a pile of bricks, and build the actual model.
- throwra620 5y ago
- SteveNuts 5y agoIs that because the instructions are meant for human consumption or because of a shortcoming in the robots themselves
- dymk 5y agoThe robot itself. One could build a gripper meant specifically for LEGO pieces, but a general grasper like the human hand is still out of reach (ha) of robotic design (for now).
- bombcar 5y agoI believe the hard part would be the reading of the booklet - operation robots or similar should be able to build with LEGO given that simple LEGO robots can build simple LEGO sets.
- drooby 5y agoThis is pretty cool though https://nerdist.com/article/brickit-app-scans-lego-builds/ https://nerdist.com/article/brickit-app-scans-lego-builds/
- david422 5y agoPretty awesome footage. I see the level of automation in these types of factories and I'm blown away. And then it always makes me wonder - sometimes you see people at stations - why are they there? Too hard to automate - (what scenario could be too hard to automate given all the insane automation already)? Or, haven't had time to automate? The ingenuity all around is crazy.
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoIt's basically too hard to automate, yes. These may be mundane sounding tasks like checking if a screw is properly secure, we're still far from full automation, the robots simply do preprogrammed tasks, they have no sentience or intelligence.
- bitexploder 5y agoI was kind of worried. Maybe Tesla had a general AI but kept it to themselves?
- rootusrootus 5y agoChecking things like bolt tightness is a hybrid automation. There are machines which know where all the bolts are within a given area, and can test each one and adjust as necessary to make sure they are torqued. But that machine is itself handled by a human that gets it to the right spot.
- bombcar 5y agoProbably lower on the cost/benefit ratio of automating, or something that requires a decision to be made.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoThe more automation, they more you need humans to check if it works.
- reportingsjr 5y agoTypically not worth the cost of automation. Automated tasks need parts with certain levels of precision, among other requirements. That precision can some times make parts excessively expensive, heavy, etc etc. One example of this that you don't see mentioned often, is that stamped door assemblies frequently need "adjustment", aka bending and beating, in to position to make them fit properly. You can see some examples of it in this video: https://youtu.be/iPhwBUnR_XA?t=216 https://youtu.be/iPhwBUnR_XA?t=216
- sorenjan 5y agoAnyone know how this compares to other factories? It's a brand new factory by the highest valued car company in the world, so I expect it to be cutting edge. Is it far ahead of others, or just catching up? My uneducated opinion is that it's really cool.
- noipv4 5y agoYou can see a legendary version of the Mitsubishi Lancer being made in Japan. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2l6NoxgSTXM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2l6NoxgSTXM Process is very similar; stamping, welding, painting, wiring, assembling, shipping.
- rootusrootus 5y agoNice, I hadn't seen that one before. And as you say, not just any Lancer, but the Evo.
- jerlam 5y agoIt seems pretty similar. The only interesting aspects were the perspectives of the drone zooming through the assemblies, and Tesla's use of very complex castings; but I grew up around manufacturing/factories and was also lucky enough to see the NUMMI factory (Toyota/GM, now Tesla) before it closed. And that was over a decade ago, in a factory that was already decades old. Here's a similar video from Honda: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCuclAl9AGo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCuclAl9AGo What's missing from the Tesla video is arguably the most important part: the batteries.
- throwra620 5y ago
- Semiapies 5y agoIt's funny how much PR gets done by this company that Musk says doesn't do PR or have a PR department.
- revscat 5y agoThis gets brought up every time. Tesla has never said they don’t do marketing, or have a PR department. They have said they don’t advertise. If you have evidence saying otherwise please do share.
- clouddrover 5y ago> They have said they don’t advertise. Then they lied. This video is an ad. Here's another Tesla ad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9id7BSPttGs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9id7BSPttGs And here's another Tesla ad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uz394aKhfLY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uz394aKhfLY
- trixie_ 5y agoOh you're right, how much do you think they paid to broadcast those advertisements?
- clouddrover 5y agoHow much do you think they paid to make those advertisements?
- tempestn 5y agoThey paid for this marketing, obviously, but by definition an ad is a paid placement.
- clouddrover 5y agoIt's an ad, plain and simple. Here's some more advertising. Tesla offers you the exciting opportunity of a religious experience at a live infomercial: https://www.inputmag.com/culture/tesla-cyber-rodeo-rabid-elon-musk-cult-gigafactory-cybertruck-model-y-electric-vehicles https://www.inputmag.com/culture/tesla-cyber-rodeo-rabid-elo...
- walleeee 5y agoincredibly slick drone piloting generally re: Tesla, I hope we can manage to throw similar enthusiasm and expertise behind promethean engineering projects slightly more imaginative than the self-propelled carriage and a bit more pragmatic than a mars colony
- panick21_ 5y agoMars colony involves all space technology, much of it is pragmatic. Self-propelled carriages involve battery research/production and transitioning from ICE to EV. So its really far better then you make it seem. What problems would you like solved? For me, I would like nuclear energy to get attention but the world has decided to be dumb and its not changing its mind anytime soon.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoThere's hope yet: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-61010605 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-61010605 Only about 30 years late (and might be too late anyway). And who knows if it'll even happen, this government is famously u-turny.
- walleeee 5y agoon board with space technology in general, agreed also on energy storage, no qualms with these mars colony however seems untenable as an economic enterprise barring unforeseen developments, and makes no sense as an existential hedge until we demonstrate the capacity to reliably shape and maintain natural and artificial life support systems on this planet I would love to see more nuclear energy Gigafactory is a name for a place that builds mega- up to gigawatt (micro-)reactors fit for any municipality or mobile habitat, not some car
- windowsrookie 5y agoI wish the footage wasn't sped up so much. I know they speed these videos up to make it more "interesting" but honestly it's so fast I lost interest because I couldn't focus on anything. It a cool to see the inside of the factory tho, hopefully we can get a more detailed look sometime.
- andrewmutz 5y agoIf you watch it on the youtube version you can slow it down 4x and admire every detail
- panick21_ 5y agoThere are tons of walk threw of the factory where people film every station.
- kcb 5y agoStill blows my mind that Germany didn't stop the acquisition of KUKA.
- cwkoss 5y agoI'm in awe of the skill of the drone pilot/photographer's skills.
- zwaps 5y agoceteris paribus that is some pretty good drone video footage
- munk-a 5y agoIt's a fun watch but flying a drone through currently operating heavy machinery seems like a terrible idea... The video gamer in me though did want to mash the forward key when they waited for the second machine to finish a round before continuing though... you could've made that jump!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoI mean, what's the worst that can realistically happen? I assume the presses, for example, would completely ignore the drone. You might want to scrap that one part just in case but I doubt it'd damage the press. The cost of a few spare drones is likely negligible compared to the overall production cost of the video.
- atom058 5y agoWorst case is probably a lithium battery fire, which could become a big problem and would at least stop the line for a time (which would be expensive)
- xwdv 5y agoThe way drone pilots these days fly around so skillfully makes me wonder if there’s any black market for a sort of corporate espionage program where a pilot can sneak in to a factory through some small gap, quickly fly around gathering footage and as much sensitive details as possible, and then escape back out, before anyone has a chance to even do anything or maybe even realize what has happened.
- senbrow 5y agoFPV drones are incredibly loud and dissonant, especially in an enclosed space. You'd have to have a lot of very consistent and loud background noise for this to go unnoticed.
- sangnoir 5y ago> The way drone pilots these days fly around so skillfully makes me wonder if there’s any black market for a sort of corporate espionage program where a pilot can sneak in to a factory through some small gap It's far easier to have people with impressive resumes interview at the victim organization and directly ask questions. Fishing for information isn't difficult "I designed the Foo process and know to work around the disadvantages, and can apply that knowledge here", "Oh, we don't do that here, we have Bar, which is superior..."
- sho_hn 5y agoHaving been to many other car factories professionally, this one looks rather strange to me. It's dirty and ramshackle, things are standing around randomly, you see parts falling off during production steps where it's weird (to me), some status displays seem to be down, the density of the space usage is very low. Even for a barely operational plant with much to come it feels rushed together. Edit: Quite surprised/curious why this is getting downvoted so aggressively ...
- rpmisms 5y agoYou haven't seen entire subframes being molded before, so it would be strange to see that much mold flash falling off. > dirty and ramshackle That's... an opinion. > some status displays seem to be down Perhaps to protect information?
- sho_hn 5y agoIt's all an opinion, of course. I think I maybe wrote it in a way that came across as incendiary, but I was mostly wondering if this was shot weeks ago during trial or calibration runs and just doesn't represent a line working at full pace. Re dirty and ramshackle, there's just a lot of stuff standing around in what seems like temporary locations, including discarded packaging materials. Things also do frankly look a bit dusty and bruised in ways I'm just not used to seeing in these high-end factories. It may not be to levels of functional relevance, but I think it's interesting. The factories I'm used to are nearly antiseptically clean and the people who run them take great pride in them being so. > You haven't seen entire subframes being molded before, so it would be strange to see that much mold flash falling off. Is this what happens at 1:09?
- rpmisms 5y ago> Is this what happens at 1:09? Yep. That's a front (I think) subframe, fresh off the presses. A little mold flash is to be expected, it's operating around 5,600 to 6,200 tf, more than any industrial mold on the planet. I am friends with an excellent moldmaker, and he's in awe that it works at all. > It may not be to levels of functional relevance, but I think it's interesting. This makes more sense, and doesn't fit with your original tone. > wondering if this was shot weeks ago during trial or calibration runs Likely. This video was leaked several weeks back.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 5y agoI’m not a manufacturing person at all, but I was surprised to a bit falling off a larger bit (at 1:10). Guessing that’s an intentional part of the process, not a whoopsie?
- Tossrock 5y agoLooks like mold flash (unwanted material that's squeezed out from the narrow gap where the pieces of a mold fit together due to the high injection pressure) and it's normal for some to come off. There's doubtless a cleanup step later where any leftover material is removed.
- davidhyde 5y agoThat footage is just … jaw dropping. Congratulations to everyone involved in that piece. Amazing!
- Shared404 5y ago...and then I installed Steam and Portal 2 yet again. Jokes aside, that's really cool flying and great footage!
- jliptzin 5y agoReally amazing seeing it in action
- memish 5y agoVery cool. Elon said "raw materials go in, cars come out" at the GigaTexas opening yesterday. What's included in the raw materials and how does that compare to other car factories?
- rtkwe 5y agoThe only thing they really show manufactured on site in the video is the frame and body. I'd expect most other things to be shipped in from elsewhere. At the very least the electronics and motors are going to come from elsewhere. It doesn't look much different from most other car factories to be honest.
- onedognight 5y agoTesla normally winds their motors themselves on site. They didn’t show it here, but they have before.
- panick21_ 5y agoIt depends, lots of variation. Thinks like interior components (plastics, fabrics), seats, battery cells are often not made on site. Or sometimes its on site but by a supplier directly integrated in your factory. Some companies make the battery packs in different location then the cars. Sometimes electric motors are made of site as well. One difference is that Tesla uses aluminum castings on a large scale. So they basically get raw aluminum melt it down and then cast it. But that is not so different the stamping parts locally. The real difference will be in terms of batteries. Texas and Berlin both have battery cell production on site. In Texas its literally in the same building. No other manufacture has that yet as far as I am aware. Tesla is also doing cathode and anode manufacturing in house. They seem to even be moving cathode materials production in house as well but I am not sure if that's already included in the current buildings. I think Tesla Texas will be the most complete end to end car done in one building. Stamping, casting, plastics, seats, fabrics, glass, panting, battery cells, battery packs, motors and more besides in on big building. Thins that are still missing is of course computer chips, electronics. If they actually do cathode materials manufacture there nobody else is even close.
- jerry1979 5y agoThat is so amazingly cool. That is exactly how I imagined a Tesla factory would look like.
- dangus 5y agoIt’s a really cool video. But I think there’s always room for criticism: - We shouldn’t look to cars for the future of transportation. They don’t scale especially in large cities (Dallas, Atlanta). Fly me a drone though a bus or train factory! I’m not saying for everyone to stop using cars completely, but city and suburb design shouldn’t make cars the only option…and Elon’s tunnels are the opposite of a transit solution. - Tesla is potentially getting its lunch eaten by competitors like the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and BMW i4. They need to improve their interior fit and finish to compete. Tesla’s advantage will evaporate very quickly when faced with motivated and giant rivals. Hyundai and VW in particular should scare the crap out of them.
- gibolt 5y agoConsidering both of them are still around 1/20th the scale and not profitable, while Tesla has 30% margins on vehicles, I don't think there is much fear. The goal was always to cause the transition away from ICE, not stop competition. Every EV is one less ICE car
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- macintux 5y ago> Tesla’s advantage will evaporate very quickly when faced with motivated and giant rivals. I'm relatively indifferent to Tesla, but I'm fairly confident that people have been making this prediction for many years now.
- panick21_ 5y ago> Elon’s tunnels are the opposite of a transit solution. A high capacity electric bus threw a tunnel is theoretically as efficient and far more dynamic, cheaper and easier to maintain and upgrade then any Subway. Its a mistake to draw conclusion from first generation products. Really its just like a subway but each subway-car is a bit shorter and has its own propulsion system. Each car is no longer forced to stop at each station (clearly highly ineffective) and the network can do far more complex routing and more point to point transport. You take advantage of the millions of EV battery and motors produced to get low cost and you make the tunnels cheap and dumb. I don't understand why people are so resistant to this. > Tesla is potentially getting its lunch eaten by competitors If I had a penny for every-time I have heard this since 2014 I literally be a millionaire right now. Its a complete misunderstand of the EV business and what it takes to scale EV production. Had other companies gone all in on this in 2014-2016 range it might have been true. VW who is one of he two biggest manufactures and was pushing for EV far earlier and harder then all non-Tesla competitors has clearly stated they hope to overtake Tesla in 2024 at best. Others like BMW or Hyundai simply don't have the battery capacity or secured battery supply-chain to produce the number of vehicles to 'eat Tesla lunch'. You can look at those companies own projects for the next few years, even the optimistic projects are not close to those of Tesla. > evaporate very quickly when faced with motivated and giant rivals. Actually the major advantage that these 'rivals' have, having a profitable ICE business to subsidies their EV buildup is about to disappear faster. And if you pay attention to Tesla growth you will see that they are really not that much smaller anymore. Tesla is on track to produce about 1.5 million vehicles this year and all of them pretty premium priced. BMW Group is aiming to produce like ~2.6 million vehicles. And of course they have a massive legacy ICE business and are nowhere near able to invest what Tesla is in EV and Battery technology. Its very likely that in 2023 Tesla will outsell BMW already. And in terms of being 'giant' what matters is how many EV you make. That dedicates of how large you can make your supply contracts with the large battery materials producers. Tesla is both the largest buyer of batteries but they are also dealing with the raw supply of materials themselves, having major contracts with the largest lithium, nickel and cobalt producers that other companies can only dream. Tesla buys more lithium then the rest of the German and US industry combined. Tesla is the largest battery consumer of Panasonic and also one of the largest costumers of CATL and LG (ie largest manufactures of Japan, Korea and China). Plus Tesla themselves are on track to be largest battery producer from Europe/US themselves. Given the Gas prices now, EV demand in general and Tesla demand in particular are constrained by production. Hyundai will sell ever Ionic they can make but they simply can't make enough even if it was 10x more popular then Tesla (and they are not based on any measure). You also only mention interiors (matter of taste) while ignoring far more important things like charging that is far more relevant when it comes to EV sales. Don't get me wrong, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 is a great product. But the idea that because of that they are gone eat Tesla launch anytime in the next couple years will simply not hold up. The reality is 98% of the market is still non EV and every additional EV produced will not be one less EV produced by a competitor but one less ICE produced by a competitor. The companies who you need to be afraid for is those that don't have large supply of battery and supply chains locked up over the next 4-5 years. The depreciation of ICE vehicles will be incredibly once EV hit a critical point and those manufacturers with lots of ICE exposure will be the once suffering the most.
- chubot 5y agoWow I'm impressed ... I've heard the claim that big pieces of software like an operating system, web browser, or maybe Google search are the most complex things that humans have created. I have no idea how to judge those claims, but various factories creating cars, aircraft carriers, submarines, or space shuttles certainly seem like they should be candidates. Especially since they're software-controlled! Any other candidates? ---- As an aside, I find this a lot more impressive than the Dall-E 2 illustrations on the front page right now. Because at the end of the day the cars being produced here have to run, and be sold. In contrast, I believe our minds are largely "filling in the blanks" for the images generated by Dall-E 2. They don't have to "work" or make money ... just be sufficiently "interesting".
- madengr 5y ago
- CamperBob2 5y agoIf you like this sort of video, there's an even slicker recording filmed in the 911 GT3 factory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1YXhlNDcP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1YXhlNDcP0 Another from the Macan production line at Leipzig: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F3FUH9fVC_M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F3FUH9fVC_M
- imglorp 5y agoThis is a hard question. An OS kernel alone like Linux is around 28 million lines of code, plus around 30,000 packages available, each with thousands or more LOC. All hand written and interacting. A vehicle might have only a few thousand physical parts, but if you start counting the computing hardware on board you might count transistors on its computers which are now in the billions; plus to be fair you'd count all its software as well.
- Ansil849 5y agoHow is a factory like this designed? Who has the knowledge to put all of these machines together into a seamless process?
- mdorazio 5y agoLarge groups of manufacturing engineers. It's a specific discipline, and they work closely with the design engineers of the vehicles to make sure the vehicles can actually be manufactured efficiently at scale.
- sidcool 5y agoTesla made manufacturing sexy.
- aspenmayer 5y agoMore info on the drone footage and its cameraman, and also the pilot: https://electrek.co/2022/04/01/drone-whips-around-teslas-berlin-gigafactory-in-new-fast-paced-video/ https://electrek.co/2022/04/01/drone-whips-around-teslas-ber...
- seu 5y agoToo bad it doesn't manage to fly inside Berghain...
- hendrikrassmann 5y agoThis is just a way to SEO away the shorty airforce! (see https://www.reddit.com/r/RealTesla/comments/9t5f8c/latest_fremont_pictures_from_shorty_air_force/ https://www.reddit.com/r/RealTesla/comments/9t5f8c/latest_fr...)
- saos 5y agoThats so satisfying. Bene thinking of drones as a new hobby.
- hericium 5y agoLooks super cool but watching this I recalled how car detailer Jessica Tran joked[1] that > the job requirements to be a Tesla assembly person were that you're blind with no hands [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgjVvetGPak https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgjVvetGPak
- imtringued 5y agoI once had a dented car door and it has had better tolerances than that.
- chasd00 5y agothe drone pilot's skills are pretty impressive. Some of the racing drone pilots are incredibly good.
- jodrellblank 5y agoThere's a drone flythrough of an Australian Plywood Factory from a year ago on YouTube[1], and it made me think: why would managers Segway around a factory in future[2] when they could have FPV drones with cameras and speakers and microphones to oversee everything that's happening from above, from the comfort of their office far away? Drones could have pre-set waypoints to fly to the interesting places or supervisor stations automatically, come back to charging stations automatically, do hourly flythroughs of preset routes for regular audit and inspections of production lines or warehouses, like CCTV cameras that can move. It's going to be a no-fun future for a lot of people. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zP-gTCp5Kac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zP-gTCp5Kac [2] or golf cart, scooter, drive, walk. Segway was that kind of 'futuristic transportation'.
- sokoloff 5y agoBecause the primary purpose of managers walking of the floor isn’t observation and control, but rather understanding, communication, and very rarely changing something. There’s nothing wrong with automated QC activities, but it’s not going to replacing walking the floor (assuming the floor isn’t a lights-out facility.)