8 ms·
Mexican cuisine in the USA is wayy past the point where people can criticize it for being inauthentic. Tex-Mex and Cal-Mex both have their own histories going b
by paxys 5y ago
Mexican cuisine in the USA is wayy past the point where people can criticize it for being inauthentic. Tex-Mex and Cal-Mex both have their own histories going back hundreds of years.
In general, whenever there are debates about the authenticity of a certain dish, I can guarantee that people of the native country are doing even crazier "non-traditional" things with it, and no one cares.
- bombcar 5y agoAuthenticity is always a point in time authenticity anyway, as everything is changing constantly.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd even when scoped to a specific place and time, definitions get fuzzy and the whole discussion gets a bit too navel gaze-ey for my tastes.
- bombcar 5y agoI mean it always boils down to “what I like is good and authentic and better than what you like which is fake and bad and you should feel bad.” And if you can’t argue it as authentic just call it fusion.
- dragonwriter 5y agoIt really doesn’t. American-style tacos can be wonderful food. (The mass-market commercial ones aren’t, though the mass-market commercial shells themselves–basically, U-shaped tostadas, are a fine starting point.) They just aren’t authentically Mexican food. Good, and authentically <national origin> are orthogonal concerns.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Authenticity is always a point in time authenticity anyway American-style tacos are not authentically cuisine of Mexican origin of any time. They are authentically American food, developed in America, by Americans.
- em-bee 5y agoauthentic food is what my grandparents made.
- bobthepanda 5y agoI remember once hearing a critic describe “food like grandma made” as not necessarily a good thing, since grandparents of people alive now would’ve been making food during the initial popularity of microwaved and canned foods. Not to mention the weird things from previous eras like aspics and jello salads.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> grandparents of people alive now would’ve been making food during the initial popularity of microwaved and canned foods. Those two things weren't even roughly contemporary.
- Dylan16807 5y agoYou can make a pretty good argument that the popularity of canned foods really came post-WWII.
- barry-cotter 5y agoCanning was invented in 1809. One plausible reason British food was legendarily bad for such a long time is that it was the ground zero for processed food. It got the first, worst version of everything and people got used to eating it. > The main market for the food at this stage was the British Army and Royal Navy. By 1817, Donkin recorded that he had sold £3000 worth of canned meat in six months. In 1824, Sir William Edward Parry took canned beef and pea soup with him on his voyage to the Arctic in HMS Fury, during his search for a northwestern passage to India. In 1829, Admiral Sir James Ross also took canned food to the Arctic, as did Sir John Franklin in 1845.[7] Some of his stores were found by the search expedition led by Captain (later Admiral Sir) Leopold McClintock in 1857. One of these cans was opened in 1939 and was edible and nutritious, though it was not analysed for contamination by the lead solder used in its manufacture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canning
- munk-a 5y agoMexican cuisine is also a derivative cuisine itself like every other cuisine ever - chefs borrow techniques all the time and mexico, as we know it, has only existed for about 500 years (503 years ago is about when Cortez first started interacting with the region). Authentic is an extremely hard thing to define - one of the more celebrated "authentic" native north american dishes is fry-bread which was innovated when America relocated a whole bunch of Navajo and basically just handed them bags of flour and lard to sustain themselves on during the march - it's spread across reservations to be a pretty common offering even in haudenosaunee gatherings (though "more authentic" things like strawberry water and venison stews are still more prevalent).
- not2b 5y agoExcept that corn tortillas and enchiladas predate Cortez, going back to the Mayans and before, perhaps 2000 years.
- Maursault 5y agoDon't forget the tamale. The origin of the tamale dates back 7k - 11k years. They were eaten by the Aztec and Maya civilizations and previously as well by the Olmec and Toltec. And tamales were sacred, food of the gods. I've always loved tamales. They're a treat and good for you, too.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Don't forget the tamale. The origin of the tamale dates back 7k - 11k years. This doesn't sound like a claim for which there could be good evidence.
- bsedlm 5y agoon that note, if tomatoes were taken to europe only after Colon's famous trips... how come Italian cuisine is famously known for it's tomato-based pasta sauces? also, what did they irish eat before potatos were taken over there from south america??
- Rapzid 5y agoHaha, yeah many don't realize that TexMex isn't "knock off" Mexican food. It's "Truly Texas Mexican" food. Most of what's available outside south Texas (and here and there through southwest) is knock off TexMex though lol.
- nemo44x 5y agoAt this point California has distinct regional styles. I’m guessing Texas too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bushbaba 5y agoTomatoes originate from the americas. Italian food only relatively recently had access to the tomato. After learning this fact, I stopped caring about a foods heritage. Who cares.
- taeric 5y agoSpicy food, as we know it today, also originated in the americas. Which similarly blows my mind.
- hef19898 5y agoI think India might have a word here as well. Reminds me of the origin story disputes of pasta.
- kurthr 5y agoAs I understand it, chilis were brought (first to Goa) from the Americas by Portuguese traders. Similar to tomatoes in Italy these are hundreds of years ago shortly after Columbus failed to find the spice route (to Asia) he was looking for... but finding another spice, silver, and tobacco route.
- smcl 5y agoI think the issue here is that the word "spicy" is overloaded, meaning both "hot" and "of or containing various spices". India has long used the sort of of spices that give its food the characteristic rich, interesting flavours. I guess the hotness part comes from chili peppers from the America (I hadn't heard that before, I'm taking another comment at face value)
- thaumasiotes 5y agoIndia was the commercial source of (black) pepper; that's why Columbus' stated aim was to get to India. Tomatoes, potatoes, and chili ("red pepper") are all New World plants foreign to India.
- krageon 5y ago> going back hundreds of years. Really? Hundreds?
- croon 5y agoAgreed, and not only on that point. Al pastor for example came from Lebanese immigrants. Almost all food was fusion at some point, and that's what's great. I was making tacos one day and didn't have any tomatillos. I did have gooseberries, and they're the same genus and work fine. Another time I used kiwis because they're both sweet and tart and brings similar things to a salsa. I won't make any claims about my abilities, but I do really love trying to understand the basic concepts of food, so that I can figure out with why certain components are used, and what you can play around with to mix it up (both literally and figuratively).
- ricardobayes 5y agoWell I don't think lebanese made pork dishes though.
- croon 5y agoIndeed, it was originally lamb, but that's another point for fusion, I'd say.
- FerociousTimes 5y agoMost of the first wave of the Lebanese diaspora in Mexico were Christians. So, I don't see any dietary religious restrictions to their choice of going kosher and presumably forgoing pork in their commercial recipes for that dish.
- genocidicbunny 5y ago> I did have gooseberries, and they're the same genus and work fine. Did you mean family? Gooseberries and tomatillos are different genuses, though the same solanaceae family. With that said, this is an interesting observation, and now I want to do a side-by-side comparison between tomatillos and gooseberries.
- croon 5y agoYou are of course correct. And to straighten another record, it was specifically cape gooseberries I used (they're not called either here), which might be relevant to your future comparisons.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Mexican cuisine in the USA is wayy past the point where people can criticize it for being inauthentic. American-origin Mexican-inspired food is authentic American-origin Mexican-inspired food (or, simply, authentic American food.) Its not authentic Mexican food. (Tex-Mex and Cal-Mex encompass some things that are Mexican in origin and some things that are not, just as Mexican food includes some things that are of Aztec origin and some things that are not.)
- bumby 5y agoI mean, look at how much pork is included in true Mexican cuisine. But pigs are Eurasian species. Would we claim none of those dishes are truly Mexican? At some point, it’s all an arbitrary classification of convenience.
- TMWNN 5y ago>Mexican cuisine in the USA is wayy past the point where people can criticize it for being inauthentic. Tex-Mex and Cal-Mex both have their own histories going back hundreds of years. The classic Taco Bell taco is genuine southern California Cal-Mex cuisine. <http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/02/dining/north-of-the-border-its-everyones-mexican-food.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/02/dining/north-of-the-border...>