18 ms·
The cult of Amiga and SGI, or why workstations matter
- dark-star 5y agoTalking about "the cult of SGI", and then using the new logo instead of the old cube logo, that's blasphemy! :-D
- PaulHoule 5y agoMost of my memories of SGI machines from the 1990s are not so good. As I remember SGI seemed to value looks and performance on paper to "it works". There was the professor who bought an SGI machine but didn't put enough RAM in it, plugged it into the AC power and Ethernet, couldn't do anything with it, and left it plugged in for a few years with no root password. There was the demo I attended up at Syracuse where a pair of identical twins from eastern Europe were supposed to show off something but couldn't get it to work, Geoffrey Fox's conclusion was "never buy a gigabyte of cheap RAM" back when a gigabyte was a lot. When SGI came out with a filesystem for Linux I could never shake the perception that it would be a machine for incinerating your files.
- tyingq 5y agoI saw some of that happen too, but it wasn't appreciably different from other expensive Unix workstations in that respect. That is, while there were people getting actual value from them, there were also people buying them that didn't need them.
- technothrasher 5y ago<shrug> I had an SGI Indigo back in the mid-90s, and it functioned fine as a Unix workstation, as well as being very useful for the weather satellite imagery work I was doing. It ran circles around the Sun machines I had access to at the time.
- usefulcat 5y agoMy first job was at a company that made visual simulation software, and literally everyone had an SGI on their desk (the Indy), and there were also a few refrigerator-sized machines in the server room. I did development work on the Indy and a much larger 8(!) CPU machine daily for several years. I remember there were some complications related to shared libraries (which, IIRC, were a relatively new feature at the time), but overall I remember those machines working quite well. The Indy was a great daily driver for the time.
- lallysingh 5y agoIn the mid 1990s I was at a military research lab doing VR research. SGIs all around, working quite well. The indy on my desk worked well as a workstation, and the larger machines (High/Max impacts, Indigo2s I think) blew me away with their hardware-accelerated GL (IrisGL, still, I think) apps. They worked very well for what we bought them for, and I was sad to see the company get eaten away by competition that had much, much, much cheaper solutions to the same problems, but none of the pizazz or desktop UI. Intergraph on NT, mostly.
- zozbot234 5y agoLet's be clear, those workstations were hella expensive. (The Amiga was not in the true workstation range, but rather more of a glorified home computer. Their workstation equivalents would probably be the stuff from NeXT.) Their closest modern equivalent would probably be midrange systems like whatever Oxide Computer is working on these days. A workstation was simply a "midrange" level system that happened to be equipped for use by a single person, as opposed to a shared server resource. The descendant of the old minicomputer, in many ways.
- notreallyserio 5y agoNo kidding: https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/12/17/sgi-workstations https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/12/17/sgi-workstation... > The Octane line’s entry-level product, which comes with a 225-MHz R10000 MIPS processor, 128MB of memory, a 4GB hard drive, and a 20-inch monitor, will fall to $17,995 from $19,995. Really makes the M1 Ultra look affordable.
- usefulcat 5y agoThe Indy, which predated the Octane, started much lower ($5k according to Wikipedia, presumably in mid-nineties dollars), but yeah your point very much stands.
- twoodfin 5y agoThe Indy, though, was notoriously underpowered. Very much the “glorified home computer” the GP described, albeit running MIPS. Still, sure did stand out in the MIT computer labs!
- Epiphany21 5y agoIndys weren't truly that slow. The problem was the base models were memory constrained to the point where IRIX could barely boot. 16MB was not enough, and IRIX 5.x had memory leaks that made it even worse. An Indy with 96MB+ will run IRIX 6.5 pretty well.
- KingOfCoders 5y agoHad an Amiga (500/A4k40), always wanted an SGI. We were on several CEBITs asking SGI for selling us a machine for the 3d graphics, but didn't happen (we bought lots of monitors at CEBITs though). Later worked with SGIs in the 90s for at my first developer job <3
- unixhero 5y agoYou can emulate a machine with Qemu and run Irix there to enjoy the GUI. The killer apps on the platform were the various proprietary high en graphical and 3D suites. These are much better on modern computers now anyways.
- AlbertoGP 5y agoFrom reading about it, I was under the impression that the emulation was painfully slow, so I did not even try it. Is it possible to get close to a real machine under emulation with a current computer?
- unixhero 5y agoReal experience for what workloads? Clicking around in the colourful purple GUI and typing commands in the terminal? Yes. Running Hollywood-level graphical software, perhaps no. But I never tried.
- mst 5y agoMy favourite thing about my Indigo2 (bought second hand for relatively cheap in the early '00s) was that unlike all the x86 kit I had running, it survived power brownouts with a line logged to console mentioning it had happened. When the area I was living at the time was having periodic power issues I'd check the console any time I got home, and if there was a new log message I knew I'd need to bring all the x86 kit back up once I'd had a coffee or three.
- jasoneckert 5y agoI remember the SGI machines well. IRIX was easily my favorite graphical UNIX. We used SGI Indy systems for network administration at the university, and SGI Octanes for niche graphical applications and databases, but they were always considered an expensive luxury for both of those use cases. Nearly every other UNIX system at the university back then was Sun Microsystems.
- yvsong 5y agoThe UI of SGI's IRIX was better than the current macOS on some aspects, e.g., sound effects. Wish there are more competitions in computer UI.
- jart 5y agoHave you seen how many desktops Linux has?
- unixhero 5y agoI started buying all workstations and Amigas I could find. To be honest the Amigas are annoying because each and every one need some kind of upgrade or repair in order to work. And then it is the illogical AmigaOS and Workbench where purists are the only ones who truly get it. I prefer Unix workstations instead and play retro games on my MiSTER.
- zozbot234 5y agoWhat's so illogical about Workbench/AmigaOS? It seems very intuitive to me, even by modern standards.
- unixhero 5y agoSure the GUI is okay you are right. But when you are repairing and when you are tinkering you need to shim in drivers and make stuff work. Google-fu is not enough to find solutions in my experience. That aspect of it.
- vidarh 5y agoThere are a handful of sites to go if you need help repairing: https://amigaworld.net https://amigaworld.net https://forum.amiga.org/ https://forum.amiga.org/ https://amigans.net https://amigans.net https://eab.abime.net/ https://eab.abime.net/ (English Amiga Board) You'll be able to get help there much more easily than via Google.
- unixhero 5y agoThanks a lot for these resources. I will surely look into these when I get any further on the 1200 machines or 600 vampire accelerated or something.
- blihp 5y agoIt's only illogical in retrospect now that Unix/Linux 'won'. Back then, every platform had its own quirky OS and hardware. Of the bunch, I found the Amiga running AmigaOS the among the least quirky and illogical.
- bitbckt 5y agoI still boot up my maximum-spec Octane2 (2x600MHz R14k, 8GB RAM, VPro V12, PCI shoebox) every so often to bask in the good ol’ days. After nekochan went offline, there isn’t really a central gathering place for SGI fans anymore, but we are out there.
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoThat's a beast of a machine! In my home office I have a little mini museum that consists of display of esoteric 90's workstations: * Apple Quadra 610 running A/UX (Apple's first UNIX) * NeXT NeXTstation Turbo * SGI Indigo2 IMPACT10000 * Sun Ultra 2 Elite3D * UMAX J700 (dual 604e) running BeOS * HP Visualize C240 All working and all fun to fire up and play around with from time to time. Tracking down software to play with is a challenge at times. Since most of what I want to fiddle around with is proprietary and long since abandoned (Maya, CATIA, NX, etc.). If by some chance we were to end up on a conference call, you'd see them displayed in the background. :-)
- em-bee 5y agoneat, here is my museum: * Apollo Domain 4500 * HP 9000 * m86k/25 NeXTstation * NeXTstation Turbo * NeXT Cube with NeXTDimension card * SPARCstation 5 * SGI OEM machine from Control-Data with mips R2000A/R3000 * SGI Indy * IBM RS6000/320H * IBM RS6000/250 * Cobalt Qube 2700D * Sun JavaStation1 * Sun Ray1 * SPARC IPC * Alpha-Entry-Workstation 533 they are in storage at my grandmothers now, and i don't know if any of them still run. some of these i was using actively as my workstation at home. some where just to explore. as i got more and more into free software, dealing with the nonfree stuff on those machines got less and less appealing. though i was also running linux on machines that were supported.
- NexRebular 5y agoMy museum is quite small in comparison: * HP 9000 712/60 * SUN Ultra 1 Creator (With SunPC DX2) * Mac Quadra 610 These are still working, albeit waiting for recapping. The Gecko is running NextSTEP for the original id Software DooM map editor and the Ultra and Quadra are on the original OS they came with. Would love to get more SUN and SGI hardware but the prices are getting quite out of hand...
- graupel 5y agoI spent many years working on high-end TV weather graphics on SGI Indigo, Onyx, and the O2 (toaster over shaped) boxes; they were remarkable for their time and the hours and hours it took to render graphics made for really nice downtime at work letting me say things like "sorry, can't do anything, graphics are rendering". The best source for hardware ended up being a local university surplus shop where we could get the big SGI monitors for pennies on the dollar.
- peatmoss 5y agoWhat is old is new again. I am running a query against a very large datalake since yesterday. Only thing is, with the elasticity of resources in the cloud, I have no plausible reason to not be doing other work :-/
- sherr 5y agoIn the mid-nineties I worked for Parallax Graphics in London, doing support for their SGI based paint and compositing software. One application, Matador, was heavily used in the video and film industry - also for TV and things like weather forecast graphics. Feels like ancient history. I loved working on my SGI and learning a bit of Irix.
- rbranson 5y agoI love all the nostalgia, but the post doesn't really answer the most interesting part of the title: why do workstations matter? I was really hoping there was some revelation in there!
- corysama 5y agoAlan Kay attributes a big part of the advances of PARC to the custom workstations they built for themselves. They cost $20k(?) but ran much faster than off the shelf high-end machines at a time when Moore’s Law was accelerating CPU speed dramatically. He says it let them work on machines from the future so they had plenty of time to make currently-impossible software targeting where them common machines would be when they finished it.
- buescher 5y agoIt also helps if you are Alan Kay or the other talents that were at PARC back then. What future would you create if you had a custom $100K (2022 dollars) workstation?
- pavlov 5y agoThe NVIDIA DGX Station A100 has a list price of $149k, I believe. It's a workstation that's advertised as an "AI data center in a box": https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/dgx-station-a100/ https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/dgx-station-a100/
- buescher 5y agoThat looks like it would be an absolute hoot to experiment with, but I don't know what I could possibly do with one that would generate a return on $150K. What would you do?
- sbierwagen 5y agoIn some circumstances making a hedge fund model 0.001% better would return 10x that. John Carmack tweeted about buying one a while back. I'm not sure if a DGX on your desk does anything for working with ML at the bleeding edge, though, since those all run on megaclusters of A100s or TPUs.
- toddm 5y agoI have fond memories of the SGI machines - workstation and larger - I worked on in the 1990s and early 2000s. Octanes, O2s, Origins, Indigos, and so on. They were best-in-class for visualization, and when used with Stereographic Crystal Eyes hardware/glasses, 3D was awesome. We also rendered high-quality POV-Ray animations on an O2 in 1996, when the software was barely 5 years old! My last big computing efforts were on a SGI Origin 2000 (R12000) in 2002, and the allure of that machine was being able to get 32 GB of shared RAM all to myself.
- reaperducer 5y ago3D was awesome Around 1990 or 2000, I was able to see how some of the big energy companies in Houston were using SGI machines' 3D capabilities. They'd have rooms about 10 feet square with projectors hanging from the ceiling that would take seismic data and render it on the walls as colorful images of oil deposits and different strata of rocks and gas and water and such. Using a hand controller, the employees could "walk" through the earth to see where the deposits were and plot the best/most efficient route for the drilling pipes to follow. Pretty much today's VR gaming headset world. Except, without a headset. And this was almost a quarter of a century ago. I can't imagine what the energy companies are doing now, with their supercomputers and seemingly limitless budgets.
- sleepybrett 5y agoI saw a driving simulator built with an actual car and a couple of reality engines driving projectors that were projecting on screens all around the car. It was a pretty impressive setup. Now you can probably build that out of forza, a decent gaming pc, and some hobbiest electronics.
- lasereyes136 5y agoSGIs were the first Unix systems I used. We had a lab of them in school. They worked wonderfully for me and I never lost any files on them. There was also a really good Unix Sysadmin that maintained them and was available if you had any questions.
- postexitus 5y agowhat kind of low bar is that "never losing any files" - what files did you lose in other systems?
- sgerenser 5y agoThe contemporary consumer OSes of the time, MacOS 8 and Windows 95/98 were pretty crash prone back then. If you weren’t religious about hitting command-S as your worked it definitely wasn’t unusual to lose your work.
- postexitus 5y agoOk more like, never using unsaved work. I was horrified thinking some old school OSes ate files from FS left and right.
- peckrob 5y agoI remember seeing an SGI Octane [0] at Comdex. I think it was 1997 or 98? I was still in high school, but I remember thinking that it was just the absolute coolest thing ever. When my home computer could barely play DOOM, this thing was just blowing up over here with beautiful video animations that didn't stutter at all. Things my PC wouldn't be capable of until a few years after that. Not to mention it just looked cool. In an era of beige boxes, you had this striking blue cube. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Octane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Octane
- tannhaeuser 5y agoActually, SGI released he first affordable, decent flatscreen monitors in 2001 or so (the 1700sw TN monitors that Apple rebranded with translucent cases at the time).
- giantrobot 5y agoMonitors that required a special video card to use with a PC. At least the 1600sw did. IIRC it came with a Revolution9 card or some such.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoYou could order an external DVI-to-LVDS converter (or whatever the native connector/signalling was) later when it became clear DVI was set to become the standard.
- giantrobot 5y agoIt was several years after the 1600sw came out that I had a machine with DVI. I've still never seen one in person. The industrial design looked really nice but I have no idea if the panel quality was decent.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoThe TN panel, especially the black level, was crap compared to modern IPS let alone OLED LCDs, but was decent enough that SGI guaranteed a reference color garmut, with compensation algorithms over the panel's lifetime. I bought mine towards the end of the product's lifecycle at a good price with converter included, and ran it with high-end (at the time) nvidia cards on Linux without problem.
- giantrobot 5y agoI'm glad to hear the panels were nice or at least not the same crap as early VGA panels. My first desktop LCD panel was a G5 iMac. I had a big Trinitron monitor for a long time and lusted after a 1600sw.
- jeffbee 5y agoMost of what I remember about 90s RISC workstations is how unbelievably slow they were. On an SGI Octane in 1998 was giving integer performance about the same as 1996-released Pentium Pros. And that's why RISC died: not because it was cheaper but because it was both cheaper and faster. Sometimes dramatically faster. The idea that RISC was somehow elegant turned out to be a myth. The complexity of x86 mattered less as cores grew in size and sophistication, but the code compression properties of CISC continued to benefit x86.
- buescher 5y agoIt depends. Before peecee memory architectures got gud in the early oughts, the Octanes were sufficiently better for big finite element codes than Intel based machines that you'd still see them used for that. But it didn't last, and you're right that the writing was on the wall already in the mid nineties. I got a Pentium 90 running Slackware running some less demanding scientific code faster than a pretty loaded Indigo2 in that era.
- anthk 5y ago>I got a Pentium 90 running Slackware running some less demanding scientific code faster than a pretty loaded Indigo2 in that era. Well, FVWM and URxvt were lighter than MWM and Irix' setup for Winterm.
- panick21_ 5y agoRISC is better if you have finite money and want to build a chip. The simple reality is that Intel had the Wintel monopoly and they had gigantic volume and absurd amounts of money to invest. If you compare the size of teams working on SPARC to what Intel invested its totally clear why they ended up winning. > The idea that RISC was somehow elegant turned out to be a myth. No, it didn't. The reality is a bunch of literal students made a processor that outperformed industry cores. Imagine today if a university said 'we made a chip that is faster then i9'. The early RISC processors with pretty small amount of work very incredibly competitive. So yes, its was actually amazing and revolutionary and totally changed computing forever. That this advantage would magically mean 'RISC will be the best thing ever for the rest of history' is pretty crazy demand to make for it to be called revolution. > code compression properties of CISC continued to benefit x86. Not actually that much, code density of x86 for 64 bit systems isn't all that amazing. Its certainty not why they won.
- mobilio 5y agoWhy SGI failed: https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-chapter-1/ https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-cha... https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-chapter-2/ https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-cha... https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-chapter-3/ https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-cha... https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-chapter-4/ https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-cha... https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-chapter-5/ https://vizworld.com/2009/04/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-cha... https://vizworld.com/2009/05/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-epilogue/ https://vizworld.com/2009/05/what-led-to-the-fall-of-sgi-epi... It's a long story...
- ulzeraj 5y agoAlso Itanium.
- oppositelock 5y agoOh, it's a lot longer story than that. I worked as SGI from just around its peak, to its downfall, seeing the company shrink to a tenth of its size while cutting products. At the time, I was a fairly junior employee doing research in AGD, the advanced graphics division. I saw funny things, which should have led me to resign, but I didn't know better at the time. Starting in the late 90's, SGI was feeling competitive pressure from 3DFx, NVIDIA, 3DLabs, Evans and Sutherland (dying, but big), and they hadn't released a new graphics architecture in years. They were selling Infinite Reality 2's (which were just a clock increase over IR1), and some tired Impact graphics on Octanes. The O2 was long in the tooth. Internally, engineering was working on next gen graphics for both, and they were both dying of creeping featureitis. Nothing ever made a deadline, they kept slipping by months. The high end graphics pipes to replace infinite reality never shipped due to this, and the "VPro" graphics for Octane were fatally broken on a fundamental level, where fixing it would mean going back to the algorithmic drawing board, not just some Verilog tweak, basically, taping out a new chip. Why was it so broken? Because some engineers decided to implement a cool theory and were allowed to do it (no clipping, recursive rasterization, hilbert space memory organization). At the same time, NVIDIA was shipping the GeForce, 3DFx was dying, and these consumer cards processed many times more triangles than SGI's flagship Infinite Reality 2, which was the size of a refrigerator and pulled kilowatts. SGI kept saying that anti-aliasing is the killer feature of SGI and that this is why we continue to sell into visual simulation and oil and gas sector. The line rendering quality on SGI hardware was far better as well. However, given SGI wasn't able to ship a new graphics system in perhaps 6 years at that point, and NVIDIA was launching a new architecture every two years, the reason to use SGI at big money customers quickly disappeared. As for Rick Beluzzo, man, the was a buffoon. My first week at SGI was the week he became CEO, and in my very first allhands ever, someone asked something along the lines of, "We are hemmoraging a lot of money, what are you going to do about it"? He replied with, "Yeah, we are, but HP, E&S, etc, are hemmoraging a lot more and they have less in the bank, so we'll pick up their business". I should have quit my first week.
- smm11 5y agoI never saw an SGI in "personal computer" mode until the sun was setting - they were always being banged on by departments, or rendering 24-7. I'm jealous of anyone who had one to themselves when they were still a power. The Amigas were something else, though, but every time I ran into one it was getting its lunch eaten by the nearby Mac. Only for a year or two, in TV production environments, did I see an advantage with Amiga. Now, with both among my collection, the SGI is the one I turn on most frequently (when the power grid can handle it).
- ido 5y agoYou were probably seeing the amiga too late in its life - it was only really impressive in the 80s, but it was really impressive in the 80s (especially when it was competing with 286, EGA & PC-speaker).
- geocrasher 5y agoThe movie "Hackers" prophesied that RISC was going to "change everything". And it did, but not in these workstations, but rather in smart phones, raspberry pi's and other projects that have made RISC viable again.
- Cockbrand 5y agoAs an aside, I kinda find funny how Apple flip-flops from CISC (68k) to RISC (PPC) to CISC (x86) back to RISC (ARM). Let's see whether RISC is here to stay now.
- pjmlp 5y agoARM is very CISCy in their instruction set.
- mst 5y agoSo far as I can tell, people still call ARM RISC because it's load/store and x86 isn't (feel free to correct me on this, I'm not a CPU person), and ARM's instruction proliferation gets glossed over. I do remember writing asm for the arm26 (arm2) chip in my Archimedes and that was definitely actual RISC, but obviously these days not so much.
- pjmlp 5y agoMost likely, however load/store alone doesn't make a RISC.
- sgerenser 5y agoMy favorite “CISCy” instruction on ARM64 is FJCVTZS: Floating-point Javascript Convert to Signed fixed-point, rounding toward Zero.
- happycube 5y agox86 from Pentium Pro and K6 on are basically hardware x86->RISC recompilers. (This is a good bit of why Transmeta failed in the end, the last good bits of Moore's Law ensured that the recompiling became cheaper/more efficient in hardware)
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoMy late dad was a huge Amiga fan back in the day. I was just a little kid at the time and didn't see what the big deal was. Looking back at what it was capable of though...they were doing 256 colors and sampled audio at a time when x86 was still pushing 16 colors and could only produce generated tones through the speaker built into the case. There was some really good music on the Amiga, too. Some of my favorites: Hybris theme: https://youtu.be/Siwd7b0iXOc https://youtu.be/Siwd7b0iXOc Pioneer Plague theme: https://youtu.be/JSLcN6GBzO0?t=17 https://youtu.be/JSLcN6GBzO0?t=17 Treasure Trap theme: https://youtu.be/n5h_Wu7QRpM https://youtu.be/n5h_Wu7QRpM And of course, you can't mention Amiga music without also mentioning Space Debris: https://youtu.be/thnXzUFJnfQ https://youtu.be/thnXzUFJnfQ
- reaperducer 5y agothey were doing 256 colors and sampled audio at a time when x86 was still pushing 16 colors 4,096 colors. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hold-And-Modify https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hold-And-Modify
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoI knew it could do 4,096 colors and I played around with it in Deluxe Paint, but I don't recall any games that used it. Being a kid at the time, the games were all I cared about.
- vidarh 5y agoGames span a bit of a range. With the copper you could change the palette while the screen updated, so you could do more than 256 on AGA or more than 64 on ECS Amiga's, but even on AGA Amiga's (A1200, A4000, CD32) it was rare for games to even reach 256 because of memory bandwidth. 32-64 was a more common range. Even that often used copper tricks, because using fewer bitplanes meant less memory bandwidth used, and so it was often worthwhile using copper palette tricks. A handful of games did use HAM for up to 4096 colours, but mostly for static screens (there's somewhere in the region of half a dozen exceptions total)
- 5y ago
- meerita 5y agoI was a 16 years old kid back then when I bought PC Magazine only too see the new models of SGI workstations. I drooled so much and I remember the crazy prices back then +30k for small workstations. I loved the style of the PC cases, the colors and the OS and then I hit 19 and started working with a Mac and my desire to acquire SGI have gone
- markus_zhang 5y agoAs a side note, back in the 90s I dabbed into the hobby of FPS level design. Some tasks, for example, calculating light for Quake I maps could take a lot of computational time to complete. I fondly remember that people back then discussed a lot about purchasing powerful gigs, or even workstations to build very large maps for games such as Quake, Unreal and such. Typical machine at the time IIRC only has around 32-128GB(sorry MB) rams which were good enough for gaming but fell short for level designing tasks. Even opening large levels for Half-Life requires a good machine.
- vidarh 5y ago32MB-128MB, not GB, presumably. Our desktop workstations in '95-'96 had 16MB. Our servers had 128MB and it was extravagant (and cost way too much - we should have made do with half that or less).
- markus_zhang 5y agoYeah you are absolutely right. I'll correct.
- sleepybrett 5y agoI want to say that iD was cooking BSPs on SPARCs or SGIs at one point.
- markus_zhang 5y agoThey did have the big bucks :D. I'm wondering what's the setup for modern game designers such as Skyrim.
- jart 5y agoI don't want to come across as disrespectful to my elders but in many ways I feel that certain kinds of nostalgia like this are holding open source back. One of my favorite pieces of software is GNU Make. Having read the codebase, I get the impression that its maintainer might possibly be a similar spirit to the OP. The kind of guy who was there, during the days when computers were a lot more diverse. The kind of guy who still boots up his old Amiga every once in a while, so he can make sure GNU Make still works on the thing, even though the rest of us literally would not be able to purchase one for ourselves even if we wanted it. It's a pleasure I respect, but it's not something I'll ever be able to understand because they're longing for platforms that got pruned from the chain of direct causality that led to our current consensus (which I'd define more as EDVAC -> CTSS -> MULTICS/CPM -> SysV/DOS/x86 => Windows/Mac/Linux/BSD/Android/x86/ARM). My point is that open source projects still maintain all these #ifdefs to support these unobtainable platforms. Because open source is driven by hobbyism and passion. And people are really passionate about the computers they're not allowed to use at their jobs anymore. But all those ifdefs scare and discourage the rest of us. For example, here's a change I recently wrote to delete all the VAX/OS2/DOS/Amiga code from GNU Make and it ended up being 201,049 lines of deletions. https://github.com/jart/cosmopolitan/commit/10a766ebd07b73404e2926cc6975e49581f98b7d https://github.com/jart/cosmopolitan/commit/10a766ebd07b7340... A lot of what I do with Cosmopolitan Libc is because it breaks my heart how in every single program's codebase we see this same pattern, and I feel like it really ought to be abstracted by the C library, since the root problem is all these projects are depending on 12 different C libraries instead of 1.
- pjmlp 5y agoA example of holding on to old stuff is still making use of a system programming language designed in 1972 in 2022.
- jart 5y agoI agree. That's why the Cosmopolitan Libc repository includes support for C++ as well as a JavaScript interpreter. It has Python 3. You can build Python 3 as a 5mb single file Actually Portable Executable that includes all its standard libraries! Then you put your Python script inside the executable using a zip editing tool and it'll run on Mac, Windows, Linux, name it. You can also build Actually Portable Lua too. More are coming soon.
- pjmlp 5y agoIt was thanks to SGI hosting of C++ STL documentation (pre-ISO/ANSI version) that I learned my way around it. Being graphics geek, I also spent quite some time around the graphics documentation. For me, one of the biggest mistakes was only making IrisGL available while keeping Inventor for themselves. To the subject at hand, this is one difference I find with most modern computers, the lack of soul in a vertical integration experience blended between hardware and software.
- Keyframe 5y agoI still power up my amigas and Indigo2 10k Max Impact occasionally. Just to think of how much that purple computer cost back then (I worked on them, VFX). Anyways, here's desktop for linux to mimic IRIX 4dwm/motif https://docs.maxxinteractive.com/ https://docs.maxxinteractive.com/ if you're into that sort of thing.
- panick21_ 5y agoIf anybody has podcasts or very good video resources about the 80/90s computer industry I would be interested. I couldn't find very much, lots of bits and pieces.
- protomyth 5y agoLook up the Computer Chronicles https://archive.org/details/computerchronicles https://archive.org/details/computerchronicles
- retrocryptid 5y agoThis is going to sound weird... but I really loved my 43P. And now I have a flood of nostalgia about it (and AIX).
- twmiller 5y agoI have a hard time taking anyone seriously when they drop something like this: "MacOS felt a kind of dumb, and does so ever since" ... I mean...MacOS is just *nix these days and has been for 20+ years. I jump back and forth between it and linux pretty much all day long and I see nothing that indicates that macOS is any dumber than linux.
- tombert 5y agoI used to be in that camp until I actually used a Macbook. For some reason I was convinced that it wasn't "real" Unix, unlike Linux. It was a naive perspective.
- snek_case 5y agoIt's definitely more locked down, less open than something like Linux or BSD and less developer-friendly (signed software, etc.), which takes away from the Linux/Unix hacker ethos IMO. I respect that Apple makes good quality hardware, but I wish there was an equivalent that was more developer-friendly. System76 is almost that but not quite.
- em-bee 5y agoon the commandline it's a decent unix, sure, but no proprietary unix can measure up with linux nowadays. they all suffered from lack of packagemanagement and old versions of commandline tools. you almost always had to manually install better tools like GNU. i did use a macbook for some time, but the only reason i managed was that most of my work is on remote servers, so most of the terminals on my mac were running linux anyways. yet, when i switched back to a linux machine as my main workstation i just immediately felt better, and didn't miss the mac at all. and now when i use the mac i really just want to go back to linux.
- tombert 5y agoI ran Linux for a decade full time, and I feel like the latest version of Gnome are actually very good, but sadly the lack of software support is what keeps me on macOS, particularly for media. FinalCut Pro is, in my opinion, a much better video editing suite than Lightworks (the best editor I'm aware of on Linux), and there really isn't anything even comparable to ToonBoom on Linux [1]. The media scene on Linux is definitely improving (Blender and Lightworks and Krita have gotten good) but I think it still has awhile before I'm fully able to abandon my Mac setup. Honestly I just wish Darling would improve [2] enough to where I could just run everything I care about within Linux. [1] I actually did google and apparently there is an OpenToonz Snap package, so I could be wrong on this. I'll need to play with it. [2] No judgement to the Darling team, I realize it's a difficult project.
- fomine3 5y agoIrrelevant knowledge: "SGI" is actually an abbreviation of a top cult organization in Japan.