19 ms·
What happens if you try to download and install Firefox on Windows
- mhitza 5y agoI see, so they only had to give EU users a choice up to (and including) Windows 7 https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/eu-resolves-microsoft-ie-antitrust-case/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/eu-resolves-microsof...
- maverick74 5y agoI really don't understand how this is allowed under the EU law... But then again... Google uses a lot of dirty tricks as well and the EU doesn't do much either so...
- darkwater 5y agoIt is not, as proved by the EU case against Internet Explorer what? 15 years ago? I hope they will get fined again as well. Is Ballmer CEO again?
- jacquesm 5y agoThe idea that Nadella is somehow a saint vs Ballmer's evil is really testimony to the fantastic PR exercise that MS has been engaging in. But ask yourself where Nadella was working when Ballmer was at the helm of MS and you'll see that he isn't as much of a change at all, it's just a nicer package.
- darkwater 5y agoI totally agree with you, I was being ironic :)
- goosedragons 5y agoApple pulls this crap too. Use a different browser on Mac and get a "helpful" notification telling you to try the new Safari. Only place you're safe these days is a fully FOSS OS like Linux and FreeBSD.
- baal80spam 5y agoI don't use Apple products but I don't think this is outrageous or something. Why shouldn't a company that sold me a refrigerator be able to point out that it produces ovens as well? Of course I despise what Microsoft does, it's absolutely over the top.
- nicce 5y ago”Helpful” notification is much less than Microsoft is doing indeed. After all, Mac is commercial OS and Safari is their product so at least a little bit is allowed. But Microsoft is closer and closer banning anything they don’t want.
- goosedragons 5y agoBecause its annoying and ridiculous? They also do it WHEN you open another web browser. Imagine if your Acme fridge had a camera that noticed every time you opened your non-Acme oven and bleated out "Try the new Acme Oven! You'll love its efficiency and design!". Is that okay?
- playpause 5y agoMaybe they do that once? They definitely don’t do it every time you open Chrome. That would be ridiculous.
- goosedragons 5y agoYou're right thats its not actually every time but neither is this Edge install thing. If you click "Later" I think it won't do it for 3 days according to this blog post [0] and I think that's still accurate. If you hit Try Now I think you get a little more time to whenever Apple updates Safari/macOS. [0] https://www.ctrl.blog/entry/how-to-osx-try-safari-promotion.html https://www.ctrl.blog/entry/how-to-osx-try-safari-promotion....
- nicoburns 5y ago
- itronitron 5y agoand if you don't set up an MS account you can't install Firefox at all, at least with a non-Pro license of Windows
- car_analogy 5y agoYou can't? Explain.
- jotm 5y agoI'm guessing the need to create a MS account when installing Windows?
- itronitron 5y agoThere is some OEM version of Microsoft Windows that comes preinstalled on some computers, and if you create a local account instead of a 'Microsoft account' when setting up the machine then Windows will block you from installing any application that isn't in their app store. Two of my family members are now happy users of Ubuntu.
- Macha 5y agoS mode is the name of this restricted variant. Comes on surface and low end devices mostly. You need to do the "add microsoft account, go to the microsoft store to leave S mode, go through what is effectively a OS reinstall, create local admin account, remove MS account" dance if you want to convert to a regular windows install from it.
- causality0 5y agoI don't understand how this kind of petulant child behavior isn't the first topic for any journalist in contact with a Microsoft representative for any reason. It's as if Jeff Bezos was walking around with his weiner hanging out but somehow only got asked questions about Amazon's fourth quarter numbers.
- goosedragons 5y agoProbably because if they offend them too much they lose access to review samples, representatives, previews, events etc. which puts them a curve behind competitors that play nice so they get less clicks after the initial story.
- hotpotamus 5y agoI never really understood the parable of "The Emperor's New Clothes" until the last few years, but at the deepest level it's about the ability for the powerful to create their own reality and enforce it on others. When do you think Bezos last heard the word "no" in relation to any question he's had?
- ryandrake 5y agoThis is probably an urban legend but I read somewhere that when Jeff Bezos uses Amazon, behind the scenes it actually routes him to a separate special instance that has all his feature requests in it, so nobody has to say “no” to him. It’s just believable enough that I remember it. The higher up on the corporate ladder one is, the less possible it is to tell him “no.”
- jotm 5y agoDo they do it for Chrome, though? At the very least they could steal some market share from Google heh
- jefftk 5y agoThey do it for Chrome as well, which makes sense. Doing it for Firefox feels a bit petty, though?
- praash 5y agoYep. Their argument is "it's already based on Chrome, but improved™ by Microsoft". Obviously, they want to add their own telemetry, advertisements, and "helpful suggestions" like this.
- sorry_outta_gas 5y agoyes
- isoprophlex 5y agoChemotherapy again this malignant bullshit: open cmd.exe with admin privileges > cd %PROGRAMFILES(X86)%\Microsoft\Edge\Application\[SOME VERSION NO.]\Installer > setup --uninstall --force-uninstall --system-level Prevent recurrence with some registry editing: > create new key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft/EdgeUpdate > create “DWORD (32-bit) Value” and call it “DoNotUpdateToEdgeWithChromium" (Source: https://www.tomsguide.com/how-to/how-to-uninstall-microsoft-edge https://www.tomsguide.com/how-to/how-to-uninstall-microsoft-...)
- Liquix 5y agoIt's also worth trying an OS which respects you as a user (such as GNU/Linux)
- dylan604 5y agoUseless platitudes. It's a bit of victim blaming. Yes, I believe any Windows user is a victim. However, do you really think this person on HN would not switch to Linux if they did not have compelling reasons for having to use Windows?
- nerdponx 5y agoI actually love Windows (although I haven't used 11 yet and probably never will). Maybe it's just what I grew up with, but all the native widget interactions feel perfect, even after the Win 8 style transition. The mouse acceleration is exactly what I expect. The taskbar behaves precisely how I want a taskbar to behave. The filesystem layout is refreshingly straightforward compared to the Unix/Posix FHS. Windows Defender does its job and gets out of the way (remember Norton/McAfee and Spybot?). And there are a ton of nice graphical "power user" applications available. Part of the reason I like KDE so much is that it feels so Windows-like. But every time I boot into my Windows desktop, I feel a bit sad knowing that there is nothing quite like it in the GNU/Linux world. There is that one Windows-API-compatible OS, but I have no idea if that will ever be viable as a daily driver.
- 5y ago
- Eduard 5y agoOn the other hand, I find Firefox 's behavior annoying as well. On one of my Firefox installations, when I start it, it always asks me to become the default browser. Which I don't want, so I set the "don't ask me again" checkbox. Yet it will ask me again. The Firefox support forum mentions several workarounds, none of them working. Also, there are additional random /modals every once in a startup, asking me to try out new design feature X. I'm never interested, I just want to use a web browser. All in all, I'm more annoyed by Firefox than other browsers.
- mstipetic 5y agoYou’re more annoyed by ff than Edge embedding a buy now pay later feature?
- alan-hn 5y agoDifferent smells, same fecal matter
- mmastrac 5y agoNot even in the same ballpark, sorry.
- Spivak 5y agoWhy? They’re both nagware using the same patterns to get users to make them the default browser. The only difference is that MS can put the notifications in the OS and Google can put the notifications on Search. Same game, Firefox is just in the minor leagues because they don’t have valuable digital real estate in addition to the browser.
- brynjolf 5y agoThe year is 2022 and everything is now equal. The human race has decided to never use nuance again. Worlds biggest corporations trying to stop you from installing a free community built browser is the same as it asking you nicely once to become the default
- haunter 5y agoWell just tried it. Edge > opened Bing > "Firefox" > Click on first Firefox hit > Download. And nothing like that happened. No pop up or nothing. And I'm using a Windows 10 PC with an MS account logged in for Office365 + Gamepass This is what I don't like about social media sites like HN either where only the rage will reach the front page Edit: screen recording https://streamable.com/wpjv2h https://streamable.com/wpjv2h
- pete_nic 5y agoAgree, I just downloaded Firefox onto my windows PC this week, experienced none of these things, and the process was really easy. I am in the US, so that could be an explanation.
- haunter 5y agoI'm in Hungary, Europe so not even an EU thing
- jauco 5y agoI got that message recently when I downloaded chrome on a windows machine. (Maybe two weeks ago) I’m within the eu
- denton-scratch 5y agoHungary is in the EU. You're there, but you didn't know?
- lucb1e 5y ago(I am not the downvoter; misreading things happens to me a lot as well...) I think u/haunter meant that it's, thus, not an EU-wide thing, not that Hungary is not EU
- denton-scratch 5y agoOh, OK. I did misread it. My bad.
- jmkni 5y agoThe really stupid part is that the new Edge is actually great. Letting people figure that out for themselves word spread organically would be more effective than trying to shove it down everyone’s throats.
- Supermancho 5y ago> The really stupid part is that the new Edge is actually great. Stupid eh? As a developer, I confidently place Edge below Firefox in terms of usability and customization for my purposes.
- flatiron 5y agoIt’s literally chromium. I’m also a developer and have had 0 regressions on edge. If it works in chrome, in my experience, it works in edge.
- Supermancho 5y ago> It’s literally chromium. The engine is just one part of a browser. Edge is not the same as Chrome.
- eps 5y ago...and that's without considering its always-on telemetry.
- blibble 5y agohow is it great? it's a shittier version of Chrome laden with more telemetry, ads, coupon bullshit and abusive "pay later" schemes standard Microsoft
- rejectfinite 5y agoThe vertical tabs are great and are actually native. Only browser that does 4k Netflix. Fast and least resource/battery use on Windows. Ublock origin still works. Yes, Firefox is my first choice. But Edge is actually good.
- ht85 5y agoI play a couple games that only run on Windows, which I boot a few times a month. I'm not even mad. The feeling is more like sadness, remembering the XP days.
- drexlspivey 5y agoI recently bought a Windows laptop for gaming (the only reason to still get one imo). The first thing I installed was a network inspection tool and proceeded to spend the next 3 hours trying to get back some control of my computer by: * Uninstalling tons of crap (Xbox Live, Edge, McAfee, Cortana etc) * Blocking network access for many processes (Windows Defender Smart Screen, GamingServices, Search etc). The latter sends all your search queries to bing * Fiddling with telemetry & privacy settings After uninstalling Edge I still find places where functionality is broken because the OS doesn't respect the default browser setting.
- pDiddlyDoRight 5y agoI haven't taken the chance to dig into Win11 to know, but before Edge? Internet Explorer was bundled with Windows' Widget Kit. Uninstalling IE would break how applications would present to the user. Microsoft makes very weird, deeply hurtful decisions, at a depth very few people understand.
- judge2020 5y ago> Uninstalling IE would break how applications would present to the user. It makes sense for developers to use the native html renderer when they don’t want to have to include a big binary blob (Electron/CEF) to do so in their application.
- pygy_ 5y agoThe WebView API and the browser app are not the same thing. Uninstalling the latter shouldn't touch the former, nor should it break the OS.
- can16358p 5y agoYup. At worst, the bundled browser may use the built in web renderer if applicable for whatever reason perhaps. But it definitely shouldn't be the other way around.
- easton 5y agoOpen a shell. winget install -s winget firefox Done.
- forgotpwd16 5y agoSo `winget` is now installed by default. Nice to see that not everything is about making Windows a worse experience.
- jpeter 5y agoI think it's time for another multi billion dollar fine for microsoft. They learned nothing
- Nemo_bis 5y agoUnfortunately the European Commission is always playing catch up (when it even tries) and it takes 10 years in court to get a fine enforced (if it's not struck down). If you believe the hype, the Digital Markets Act (DMA) will change things. (Or, I guess, Microsoft will need to spend a bit more to buy compliance from the regulators.) https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20220315IPR25504/deal-on-digital-markets-act-ensuring-fair-competition-and-more-choice-for-users https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20220315IP...
- n4bz0r 5y agoIs that surprising to anyone at this point? Big companies have proven times and times again that they absolutely can treat their customers the way they do. Whining won't cut it. Spill all the shit you can on Windows, people still won't stop using their only daily driver. More shocking posts about bad Windows and predictable comments about Linux to the entropy god.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kibwen 5y agoI've used Windows nearly my entire life, save for brief dalliances with Kubuntu in my teens and Mac as an adult. Even though I'm happy to see that Microsoft is giving back more to open source than they were twenty years ago, I'm done with Windows as of this year. Between the loss of control, the advertisements, and the dark patterns, I can't stand using it anymore. Just picked up a System76 for my new daily driver and it's been a great experience. Windows is racing to the bottom as fast as it can. It reeks of desperation.
- mattl 5y agoA system76 what? Desktop or laptop? My experience with their desktops has been pretty great. Their laptops however are terrible.
- kibwen 5y agoLaptop, the Gazelle. My only complaint is that the keyboard makes too many sacrifices in order to fit in a full numpad, an inclusion that I find unnecessary (laptop keyboard designers, a full-sized right shift key is more important than full-sized up/down keys, and both are more important than a numpad!). Software-wise it's been great; Bluetooth works better on this than it did on Windows, and I only had to do minor configuration to get the UI to my taste (and it was quite easy).
- mattl 5y agoYeah the keyboards are terrible. How’s the trackpad?
- kibwen 5y agoTotally fine, I use the trackpad exclusively all day, with no external mouse. It's not as lusciously-buttery-waxy-smooth as my old Dell XPS, with the same sort of occasional rubbiness as my Macbook (though I'm sure someone will quickly appear to tell me why a PC can't possibly have a touchpad comparable to a Mac). Palm detection is flawless and multi-touch gestures support is miles ahead of Windows, with a friendly GUI for configuration that even works on a per-app basis so e.g. I can tell it to make three-finger-swipe-left pass Alt+Left when in Firefox. I don't like its pointer acceleration as much as Windows', but that's probably a matter of me not bothering to fiddle with it.
- rejectfinite 5y agohttps://ninite.com/ https://ninite.com/ A tip. Collects installers in one exe. Great for new installs to grab software in one go.
- SECProto 5y agoI've heard of that service before, but I don't personally trust it. As an alternative, you can just download the installers before reformatting. Personally, I keep a folder ready with up-to-date installers: any time a program updates on my current install, I copy the installer into a folder on my second hdd. Whenever I reformat, the folder on that secondary hdd is there ready to go.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoOk, I realize this is my fault for scrolling down in the comments in the dumpster fire that is Twitter. That being said, I have a question: What's with the Mozilla Firefox being leftist/Communist propaganda thing? Is it a meme or flat out ignorance? It seems to based solely on their logo, which is ridiculous. I do apologize for being off topic.
- Nemo_bis 5y agoMight be the "If you're so smart, why aren't you rich?" syndrome in USA. Because Microsoft is very rich, some people will automatically side with it and think that people who oppose Microsoft must be losers (which is then equated with whatever is a loser in their mind). https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/03/01/144958/if-youre-so-smart-why-arent-you-rich-turns-out-its-just-chance/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/03/01/144958/if-youre-...
- AlexandrB 5y agoI think they're mad because Mozilla used imagery similar to old communist posters[1]? But I find so many inscrutable claims on Twitter that I generally just ignore them. A lot of them are either axe grinding from decades ago or strange culture war positions that make no sense unless you're already steeped in those communities. [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/othala__/status/1510613812554174472 https://mobile.twitter.com/othala__/status/15106138125541744...
- adam0c 5y agoi mean this is nothing new, it's quite simply one brand aka microsoft trying to keep its share of the market, nothing more :/
- wly_cdgr 5y agoWell, it's true....you don't need Firefox...and Edge is better. In fact, now that they've switched to Chromium, it's better than Chrome Anyway, Firefox is just a de facto Google subsidiary that's allowed to continue to exist to preserve the illusion of competition in the browser space, so who cares
- sidewndr46 5y agoThe last time I installed Windows 10 and then downloaded all the updates, the default behavior was simply to block the download of any .exe files. This includes Firefox & Chrome, so I didn't run into this issue at all. I just couldn't download any executable files. After navigating a few mazes of menus I was able to disable all this behavior.
- funstuff007 5y agoI guess MS under Satya isn't as OSS friendly as the press have led us to believe. hmm...
- gtf21 5y agomacOS does something similar -- when I was setting up my parents' machines I discovered that if you start using not-Safari it starts sending notifications telling you how great the latest Safari is, which is very irritating.
- warning26 5y agoWhile both are bad (and should probably be illegal), I would argue that Microsoft's are much more insidious, wrapping everything in a language of "accept the default trusted option?"
- gtf21 5y agoAgreed that the MS example is more egregious and that both should be illegal, but moreover, these tech companies need a massive culture shift -- both MS and Apple invest an extraordinary amount of effort in reducing user freedom / ownership (which is basically why I went back to Linux after 15 years on a OSX/macOS).
- ulimn 5y agoI’ve only seen such things after updates. Maybe I just missed it - where am I supposed to look for this? (I’m honestly curious) I always browse with Firefox (apart from the occasional Safari when I want Apple Pay) and don’t use Chrome at all.
- travisgriggs 5y agoInteresting. I don’t see these. I brew install brave-browser, select it as my preferred and have never been bothered by any of these prompts. I’m curious what’s different in the mechanisms. The repeated prompt that goes drive me nuts in macOS is the encouragement to get some more iCloud backup. Why can’t it detect I have a time machine backup running on an external SSD and leave me alone?
- worik 5y ago> macOS does something similar -- when I was setting up my parents' machines I discovered that if you start using not-Safari it starts sending notifications telling you how great the latest Safari is, which is very irritating. It grates to defend Apple, but that is not my experience. I cannot recall ever running Safari on the Mac I use. I use Firefox only. I cannot recall being harassed by he MacOS to switch. FLW
- jdrc 5y agothis happens in english windows as well, it s not some local version. i just got a new laptop and noticed that MS has become a lot more aggressive: i couldn't complete install without logging in to some MS account and it kept chasing me with all those prompts when installing chrome.
- thunderbong 5y agoGoogle started doing this with their search. And still does, regardless of how many times I say "I'm not interested". And as someone else mentioned here, Safari does the same. And Microsoft follows suit. Irritating as all hell, but complaints hit HN front page only when it comes to Microsoft. I do wish, though, that Microsoft would take the moral high ground.
- paxys 5y agoI have seen more and more that it is Apple that usually starts these practices, and since their users generally give them unlimited leeway towards these things (happening right now in this very thread!) it becomes the new standard. Then Microsoft, Google and others follow suit. The "try Safari" notifications when opening Chrome or Firefox have been a thing in macOS forever. Same with advertising and upsells built into the OS.
- fay59 5y agoFor a while, there would be a macOS notification suggesting that you try Safari after updating. This notification should be gone with the latest macOS. Are you talking about something else?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoApple may have started the latest round of this. But Microsoft was aggressively pushing their browser clear back in the 90s, and I don't think Apple was.
- Derbasti 5y agoOn the one hand, WSL has made Windows truly viable as a developer platform. But on the other hand, this sort of aggressive marketing bullshit makes it such an unfriendly place to be. I want my computer to treat me as an adult. Since it increasingly doesn't, I did the adult thing and walked away. If a relationship turns abusive, one must leave. I would love to be able to pay for "Windows Professional" or something to get rid of this bullshit. But I guess my eyeballs are more valuable than my dollars. In that case, MS will get neither. I moved back to Linux two months ago because of shit like this. Good riddance. Thankfully wine acts as the WSL for Linux, and makes the migration possible.
- lucb1e 5y ago> I would love to be able to pay for "Windows Professional" or something to get rid of this bullshit. That's kinda what I felt this Pro version was for, back in the good old days that would get you extra features useful for power users, but then recently they pulled this: > New Windows 11 Pro installations will require Microsoft account -- 2022-02-18 https://tweakers.net/nieuws/193418/windows-11-pro-installatie-gaat-microsoft-account-vereisen.html https://tweakers.net/nieuws/193418/windows-11-pro-installati... Basically the last credibility they had with me, with all the linux and open source things they've been doing since ballmer is gone. So uh yeah thanks microsoft, imma stay with Debian+Cinnamon a bit longer here o/
- chrisseaton 5y ago> New Windows 11 Pro installations will require Microsoft account I don’t really understand why this is a problem for you, let alone such a major problem. Takes two seconds to set up an account. I don’t even use Windows and I already have one!
- PeterisP 5y agoIt's perfectly natural to not want to have an account even if it's trivial to make, and even if you already have one, it's a basic privacy desire to refuse to link your computer to this account. It's also a reasonable desire to have your computer local authentication be completely separate any from Microsoft service, ensuring that the events are private and don't even get communicated to Microsoft, much less being able to circumvent local authentication by anyone who is in control of that cloud account.
- mt_ 5y agoWhy is the first search result Brave Browser?
- DoctorOW 5y agoMy theory was they bought an ad on Bing to counteract this messaging. I'm unable to recreate the results in Bing on Edge so I can't confirm.
- gurjeet 5y agoTake note of these anti-competitive practices, @mozilla and @firefox. Defend yourself. Your users' and customers' rights are being trampled upon. /cc @EFF https://twitter.com/0xGurjeet/status/1510678289404207106 https://twitter.com/0xGurjeet/status/1510678289404207106
- tobr 5y agoWhy are you crossposting your own tweet here?
- hgomersall 5y agoSo more people see it?
- MichaelDickens 5y agoI've been using Windows for about two years. Just this morning, when I booted into Windows, the boot loader (or whatever you call the part before Windows is fully loaded) prompted me saying I need to finish setting up. The only options were "accept" or "remind me in 3 days", so I accepted. Then it asked me to change my default browser to Edge. Apparently "finish setting up" means "we don't like that you are using Firefox".
- EvanAnderson 5y agoIt sounds like you got a major Windows 10 update. They're, basically, an in-place OS reload.
- gordaco 5y agoThis happened to me last week as well. I assume that this shit came with any of the recent updates. It really infuriated me, especially the usage of the word "need" and the fact that the dialog doesn't offer an option like "no, and don't bug me with this ever again". Fortunately, after hitting the "remind me in 3 days" button, I looked a bit and found an option that does make it go away forever. My Windows is in Spanish, so I don't know the exact name of the configuration settings in English, but you can find it in the Win+I configuration dialog. Look for "notifications and actions" (or something very similar), and there, look for a checkbox whose text reads something like "suggest ways to finish device configuration to get the most out of Windows". In fact there are six checkboxes in that screen and every single one looks like an annoyance, so I disabled them all.
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoWindows forces some kind of setup flow with major updates now it seems.
- amelius 5y agoAt least you didn't get a "Windows needs to restart and update" in the middle of a presentation ...
- josephcsible 5y ago
- alkonaut 5y agoThe DevDiv (or whatever they are called) people are very visible and accessible at Microsoft. "This is our vision for the product", "This is why we make this change" etc. Even people who implement individual features can let people know in advance. Have dialog on Twitter about an upcoming change to a .NET api or a VS feature. I'd like to see Microsoft be open with that sort of thing for Windows. I'd like to see the people who make these decisions. I'd like to hear their motivations.
- jdeaton 5y agoOn Android if you disable the youtube app then apps like messages start complaining with popups if you receive a youtube link "you need to enable the youtube app in order for this app to work correctly"
- chronogram 5y agoNot on my Pixel. YouTube links open in the browser.
- nicbou 5y agoNot if you use the google search bar on your home screen
- jdeaton 5y agoOn my pixel youtube links also open in the browser but still there is a popup every time I open a chat in messages that contains a youtube link. I literally go and delete the youtube links people have sent me to stop it.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoYou can use an alternate SMS app that doesn't try to load YouTube videos.
- homerhomer 5y agoI don't even care at this point. I used to advocate for Firefox and Chrome on Windows platform but it just seems silly to try to force Microsoft's hand to make their platform neutral to competitors. It's like walking into a Ford Dealership wanting them to support Toyota Trucks. The better choice is to leave Windows. Mac, Chromebook and Linux a all very good options.
- oh_sigh 5y agoI think a more appropriate analogy is you have a Ford car, and you tell the GPS system to navigate you to a Toyota dealership. Instead of doing that, it prompts you multiple times if you really want to go to a Ford dealership instead.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoNah. Does Android complain if you switch the default browser away from Chrome? I wouldn't complain about favoring Edge by just having it pre-set as the default when you install Windows. That's fine and reasonable to me, you want some kind of default browser anyway, if nothing else, to install other browsers. But the OS complaining about it when you switch is stupid. Whereas you can argue that having some kind of browser built into the OS is a reasonable necessity for user convenience -- and you could argue this for other app types too, like image viewers and video players -- having the OS try to convince users to not switch is explicitly anti-competitive.
- Silhouette 5y agoit just seems silly to try to force Microsoft's hand to make their platform neutral to competitors. Many places have laws, under headlines like "monopolies" or "anti-competitive behaviour", that have evolved precisely because of the danger of allowing a business entity that has achieved a dominant position in one market to exploit that position to gain an unfair advantage in another market (even if the former position was achieved entirely on merit). Many places have evolved a regulatory environment for services, particularly those considered essential, where commercial providers of those services are restricted from freely performing certain acts that would harm a user of their services even if it makes business sense to do that. We evolved these rules because there is a huge imbalance of power in these situations and we learned from experience that allowing the big guy to exploit that imbalance to the detriment of the little guy is bad for society. The need to apply similar principles to modern technologies and communications services is abundantly clear. The legislators and regulators are just a decade or two behind the technology, as so often happens. Now we're starting to see the pendulum swing back and it will probably go too far the other way, with technologically illiterate political appointees seeing potential power and/or revenue that can be generated from applying heavy-handed control to the big tech firms and doing their own kind of damage to the societies they supposedly serve. Witness the current wave of laws and regulatory actions in basically everywhere in the West that isn't the USA.
- sdeframond 5y agoDoes it do anything similar when trying to install Chrome?
- durnygbur 5y agoMicrosoft is like Russia. Just in the moment you thought they chilled, you discover they've been plotting something vile, nasty, and violent.
- lizardactivist 5y agoI'm happy to use Edge on my Windows machine, because the browser works really well. But... if I ever notice that Microsoft changes my Edge privacy settings behind my back then I will ditch it in a second for Firefox, and never go back. And I'm genuinely curious if just me deciding to use Edge is enough to make Microsoft happy. Also, what happens if you try to install Chrome, or Vivaldi, or some other browser?
- lvs 5y ago
- shreddit 5y agoJust today i took the initiative to replace windows 11 with ubuntu on my laptop. Turns out there is a touchpad bug under wayland/gnome which makes it almost impossible to “two finger” scroll (it’s way too fast). There are plenty of bug reports, but no fix in sight. There are some workarounds, but they bring their own problems. 2h later i was back on windows 10 (yes 10, not 11), and wsl…
- fartcannon 5y agoWhich laptop? Is it just with Ubuntu? You know there are other options, right? You don't have to give up on your rights and dignity because of one tiny hiccup.
- grnmamba 5y agoSoftware that cannot properly handle scroll inputs is broken.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ravel-bar-foo 5y agoTry Ubuntu-MATE, not GNOME. Scroll speed is in a settings dialog.
- userbinator 5y agoOn a recent version of Windows , to be precise. Microsoft used to be far less abusive than this. You installed it and it would just stay silent. I think things changed starting around Windows 8, then got much worse with 10, and the trend continues with 11.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI found the forced full screen start menu in Windows 8 incredibly user-abusive to be honest. Windows 10 started out pretty nice but all the tie-ins with their services and telemetry have become way too heavy.
- dark-star 5y agoI see these kinds of stories from time to time. I'm using Windows 11 since a few months, been using Windows 10 before, and Windows 7 before that. The prompt in question comes up exactly once, when using Edge to download Chrome/Firefox. Then there is only one additional prompt when you set your default browser to Chrome/Firefox. After that, Windows gives up and shuts up. Even if you update it, it won't bug you again, ever. At least I have never seen that prompt come up a second time since then. I'm using Windows 11 pro though, it might be that the consumer versions (home, educational, whatever they're called) are different in that regard
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoOk? It is still all more than is necessary.
- x0n 5y agoThe same shit happens if you visit Google web properties in a browser other than Chrome. Who gives a shit.
- yakorevivan 5y ago
- eggy 5y agoWhenever I use Edge to open my Gmail account, Google puts in a popup to switch to Chrome. I realize Gmail is a Google product, but I still find it annoying, because I have chosen Edge. I have to see how to turn off this notification.
- nokya 5y agoThis is exactly the reason why I dislike Microsoft. Their products and services are okay, and they are more than successful already without engaging in these shady scare tactics with their users. The fact that they can't see that is very worrying because it indicates a higher probably that they do/will engage in unethical behaviors to reassure themselves.