30 ms·
CDC warns of a steep decline in teen mental health
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- eganist 5y agoI'm not sure the pandemic is solely or even largely responsible. Zoomers are the first generation with nearly unrestricted access to social media essentially from birth (access that probably should've been restricted early on, but that's water under the bridge). Couple that early and frequent exposure with artificial echo chambers created by apps to boost engagement, and impressionable minds end up soaked in endlessly-amplified negative perspectives. The test case for this was 4chan incubating incel/redpill culture and Reddit later amplifying it among late-millennials. Today, EDs, ideation of self harm, etc are all mercilessly reflected back at people on just about every social media platform rather than just the niche ones. The pandemic only made it worse by preventing people from spending time with each other in person, but kids are glued to their phones anyway. $1 Bet: millennial parents will probably learn from this with their own kids. Or if not, legislators probably will. Late Gen-α and the generation that follows will hopefully see a rebound from these trends with parenting habits that benefit from these learnings.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- version_five 5y ago> I'm not sure the pandemic is solely or even largely responsible I agree that the pandemic is probably not a root cause: I think the global reaction to the pandemic could have a related root cause (social media, outrage / attention culture, the breakdown of normal human discourse, polarization) as the mental health problems. Blaming "the pandemic" fails to acknowledge that covid was as much or more about our collective reaction as it was about the actual virus. It's the "powder keg" thing - the conditions were there, and inevitably something would come along to set it off.
- briHass 5y agoI'd add 'collective overreaction', at least from a fear perspective. I know plenty of adults that lost their rational minds during the pandemic: believing all the media-driven fear porn that never once honestly explained the true risk to the < 70 year-old crowd. Older children/teens watched those same news programs and also picked up on their parents' fear, and they had even less wisdom and ability to think clearly than the parents.
- quickthrowman 5y ago> I agree that the pandemic is probably not a root cause: I think the global reaction to the pandemic could have a related root cause I keep seeing the argument that the pandemic and the response to it are distinctly separate phenomenon. They are not. The pandemic response is explicitly part and parcel of the pandemic, you don’t have a pandemic without a response, and there’s no response without a pandemic. This is not hard to grasp.
- version_five 5y ago> This is not hard to grasp It must be for me, can you rephrase your point please, I can't understand what your comment means
- throw93232 5y agoMost kids I know, think social media are lame. They use it complement for their hobbies and activities. It was pandemic that glued them to their phones, not the other way around. But must protect meh narrative!!
- easrng 5y agoHere, have an anecdote: I always spent a lot of my time online (I got Discord at 12 or 13 I think, I never got Twitter or any FB/Meta apps, but now I'm on the fediverse which is nice) and the pandemic didn't really change much other than me not having to leave the house to go to school.
- bee_rider 5y agoThe undergrads I work with don't seem to ever mention Facebook, but Discord seems pretty popular. Social media is like everything else: There's the "bad" product which has been ruined by old people and the "good" product that the hip young crowd likes. This treadmill will continue as people join networks, settle in to their preferences, and then age.
- csallen 5y agoKids have been exposed to multiple consecutive years of social isolation due to the pandemic. They haven't been going to school or seeing their peers in person. That's kind of the obvious hypothesis. To just completely write that off, you really have to have axe to grind against social media. As you said, "kids are glued to their phones anyway." That was already true before the pandemic. Which, again, suggests to me that the extreme factor here is the isolation, not the phones. Not that social media is good or healthy. But the way it's scapegoated reminds me of the way television and video games were demonized when I was a child growing up in the 90s. It was over the top.
- vkou 5y ago> They haven't been going to school or seeing their peers in person. I'm not sure there's a single family in the continental United States that has spent the entirety of the past two years keeping their children locked up in their basement. Even when school is closed, nobody has been stopping children from seeing their peers in person outside of school. And if our society can't figure out a way to make that a priority, then that may be the problem with it, not the school closures.
- formerkrogeremp 5y agoAnecdotally, yes, some children do get abused and neglected. Some are still locked up for years.
- Aerroon 5y ago>Even when school is closed, nobody has been stopping children from seeing their peers in person outside of school. Why do people always treat friction as something that is irrelevant? Shutdowns and kids being unable to hang out when they choose to creates a situation where they just lose touch with one another. You can't just deliberately flip a switch to turn it all back on. Social connections don't work like that. Social connections involve a whole series of spontaneous events. If those events don't happen, then social connections fall away. Adults have a hard time making friends, because they have a lot fewer opportunities for those spontaneous events that create friendships. Rolling the dice less often will give you fewer successes. Some amount of those successes is required for upkeep of a friendship.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoKids have less freedom today than they eve did - my parents roamed the city freely, i only walked to school by myself, kids today hardly leave the house alone
- a9h74j 5y agoI can't find a contour plot to reference, but I saw one once to this effect: Every few decades in the US, the roaming range for kids decreasing by a factor of three or more IIRC -- over generations. My father as a kid was setting animal traps all over the county, and for him a rifle, technologically speaking, was his PC.
- akira2501 5y agoI'm always entertained by the idea that 4chan did something to people as opposed to it revealing what was always there. We're social animals, we're more defined by our environment than we'd like to believe; but similarly, we have the capability to generate and manipulate that environment ourselves. I would suggest that the basic human feedback loop just got more tightly coupled and that mass personal communication was always going to lead to this.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoIt gave them a positive feedback loop and gave them a safe space to become more extreme and weaponize their own stupidity. You can easily see this to a lesser extend by going to any sports team subreddit and then going to the subreddit of the league that team plays in. The voices will be much more uniform and arguments more minor in the team subreddit for the most part... and views that are freely expressed and thought to be factual in the team subreddit may not be at all popular in the league subreddit.
- twoxproblematic 5y ago
- spookthesunset 5y ago> kids are glued to their phones anyway. In many places this was actively encouraged during the last two years. Virtually every other activity was banished. Playgrounds, schools, extracurricular activities, pools, museums, you name it... closed. In many places you literally couldn't go outside without some kind of government issued hall-pass. We absolutely, shamefully fucked over kids the last two years. And so many people cheered it on despite kids being the lowest risk group out there.
- BlargMcLarg 5y ago>The test case for this was 4chan incubating incel/redpill culture and Reddit later amplifying it among late-millennials. 4chan did not incubate redpill. Reddit was the primary spot for redpill to congregate, until Reddit started cracking down on TRP and related subs. Cherry on top, Reddit has not acted against the highly similar FDS and many other subs. Incel culture is also skeptical at best. Yes, 4chan did have the famous Elliot case, and several boards were famous among them. However, Reddit also banned several subreddits related to them which made them flock towards 4chan. This doesn't change the issue (rampant media exposure is bad for the human psyche). It just puts into perspective things have been going downhill since the masses got access to social media and unlike 4chan, the darker corners of Reddit, Twitter, Facebook and whatever else aren't nearly as taboo and may even sneak onto the homepage feed randomly. 4chan was mostly the place where the extremists would congregate, but extreme cases don't explain why the number of moderate or higher cases would increase. To put things further in perspective: 4chan started in 2005. Twitter founded in 2006. Reddit, 2007. Smartphones took off somewhere late 2000s/early 2010s. The "average" kid did not have access to these platforms 24/7 before 2010. Those that would likely didn't spend the little PC time just browsing the darkest corners of the net on a single monitor.
- regpertom 5y agoI’ve been wondering about “mid phase” internet a bit recently. The time where it opened up to “nerdy” people, after tech professionals, and before general masses. There was a pushback against the internet being serious business. All someone has to do was turn off the computer and it all went away. Could it be that even back then it was somehow known what would happen with the influencer marketing engagement stuff that is a known problem now? Unwarranted self importance? Superman vs Goku and Star Trek vs Star Wars as training in not only how to leverage conflict for engagement (or your personal internet points) but also in how to see through it as being bait? That if you let the general masses make the internet real life then you open pandora bawks? Not sure that’s why it’s all questions. My awareness of TRP MRA ETC was only after internet feminists started complaining about it loudly, for whatever that’s worth. As a tangent: how often do we rediscover what the ancients already knew? Can anything survive touching the general masses?
- erdos4d 5y ago> I'm not sure the pandemic is solely or even largely responsible. The article is literally reporting a major change in mental health metrics in teens as of a year into the pandemic. You honestly think social media/4-chan/reddit is the culprit? I think I'm starting to see why a million Americans are in a box today. There is a disconnect here.
- BlargMcLarg 5y ago>Concerns about adolescent mental health were rising before the pandemic: Teens had been reporting poor mental health at higher rates. Between 2009 and 2019, the percentage of teens who reported having “persistent feelings of sadness or hopelessness” rose from 26 percent to 37 percent. In 2021, the figure rose to 44 percent. I assume this is the line you're talking about. So in the span of a pandemic, it increased by 7% as opposed to the 11% between 2009 and 2019. While the premise "the pandemic didn't matter" might not be valid, it is a good question to ask which things that are now returning to normal had an effect, and whether the trend is still continuing up otherwise. It has been between 2009 and 2019. It's not difficult to find sources showing correlations between some mental health issues (in this case depression[0]) and internet usage. Several other aspects have not gotten any better either, and do not seem to be getting better anytime soon. Things these teens will inevitably have to deal with in the next 5 years unless things change drastically. So the pandemic did matter, but I'd also be skeptical of what long term effects the pandemic caused which would not have happened otherwise, and which effects are caused by other trends which quietly continued or were amplified by the pandemic and will plateau or continue growing after. [0]: https://ifstudies.org/blog/six-facts-about-screens-and-teen-mental-health-that%20a-recent-new-york-times-article-ignores https://ifstudies.org/blog/six-facts-about-screens-and-teen-...
- erdos4d 5y agoAgain, we are talking about an effect that has been showing a 1.1% increase year over year up to 2019. If we assume that 2019 was much like previous years, then the 7% rise reported from 2019 through the first six months of 2020 would result in approximately a 6% rise in those first 6 months alone. That is an astounding increase in the overall metric in a very short period of time coinciding with the beginning of pandemic lockdowns. I posit to you that this is due to the pandemic; that is, to social isolation, economic disruptions to households, fear of death to self and loved ones, actual deaths of loved ones, etc. I think that is a much better explanation for what has been observed than screen time or social media.
- tomrod 5y agoI am seeing that kids are less and less interested in online-only bubbles. They use social media, whatever the current popular platform, as ways to enhance connections if they use it at all. There are many who are addicted to their devices. But there are many that are not. Why?
- hammyhavoc 5y agoNot like the adults are doing much better.
- sebow 5y ago"We" as adults at least have the mostly-capable ability to discern good from bad, whereas a child until the age of 14-18 (depending on the topic at hand) does not have the sense of responsibility, especially about the crucial aspect which is his/her own health. Therefore you could expect an adult to be able to take care of him/her-self after the ~age of adulthood, whereas a children is very rarely expected to do so, because most of the times they're not even fully aware of it (consciously speaking, not talking about almost instinctive reactions).
- manuelabeledo 5y ago> "We" as adults at least have the mostly-capable ability to discern good from bad Do we? Suicide rate among adults in all age ranges is way higher than in teens and pre-teens. Anecdotally, there are plenty of day to day examples of adults not having their crap together. The historical state of the world is one of them.
- bawolff 5y ago> Therefore you could expect an adult to be able to take care of him/her-self after the ~age of adulthood I used to believe that as a kid... then i became an adult and met other adults who do not remotely have their shit together.
- CPLX 5y ago> "We" as adults at least have the mostly-capable ability to discern good from bad You’re going to be shocked when you find out what Facebook did to the Boomer generation.
- refurb 5y ago"Idle hands are the devil's workshop" I couldn't think of a worse situation than being isolated from classmates and friends, cooped up at home, having extra time on my hands and unlimited access to social media.
- wccrawford 5y agoAnd parents that think it's someone else's job to raise their kids.
- lookalike74 5y agoThe influence of this cannot be overstated. George Carlin said it best... https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u-ryuJDTpEc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u-ryuJDTpEc
- vkou 5y agoIt's always been someone else's job, it's just that 'someone else' used to be called 'grandma'. In the nuclear family of 2022, grandma no longer lives with you - or within half a mile of you - so she's no longer an option. We've built our society such that it's impossible to go anywhere without a car, and then we wonder why children don't get enough socialization, or why the only caretakers they have access to are their direct parents, and their teachers.
- refurb 5y agoWe haven't really built that society, that was just the trade off people made. I have several friends who made the trade off the other way. They live with extended family, kids can wonder around and explore the neighborhood on their own.
- spookthesunset 5y agoIt takes more than somebody's parents to raise a kid. It takes a community to raise a kid.
- h2odragon 5y agoSurely this can be fixed by lowering the standards, like for speech development, right?
- Thorentis 5y agoSocial media and pornography are the two biggest enemies of teenage mental health, and both of them have been available for almost the entire Gen-Z person's life, delivered straight to their bedroom via high speed internet, and follows them everywhere they go on their smartphones.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoBoth social media (in some form) and porn has been around for far longer than this has been a problem. I'm a card carrying "Starcraft and DeusEx defined my teenage years"-millennial, and these things have been around most of my formative years as well. I think I was like ten when a friend showed me you could type "boobs" into altavista and get whitehouse.com, which back then was a porn site alluding to Clinton's affair with Monica Lewinsky. I think the big difference now is smartphones, and being always online. It's much easier to have your entire world view informed by the Internet now than it was twenty years ago. It's a stark contrast. If you look on twitter and reddit, everything is always burning, the sky is falling every day for a hundred different reasons, the bees are dying, the Russians are about to trigger a nuclear apocalypse, there's indignant outrage and injustice everywhere. If you look out the window, there's literally none of that going on. Like it's almost all speculation, or happening somewhere else. Twenty years ago, a lot of bad things were happening as well, but they weren't up in your face in nearly the same way. For some things, you had the dotcom bubble, 9/11, the invasion of Iraq. While they made a prominent impact on the news, the news was only on while you watched them. They didn't follow you around everywhere you went like they do today.
- riedel 5y agoThe problem is IMHO not that things change, but that parents and teachers have difficulty adapting to that change and prepare their offspring for life. We are trying to establish a protected physical world that does not really teach you much about that "other" life and helps kids to develop resilience.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago
- drno123 5y agoCDC isolates teens for two years, CDC keeps them in fear for two years, and CDC is now surprised.
- ImaCake 5y agoA lot of people would, and did, isolate even without being told too until they were vaccinated. They would have done so out of fear. All that governments really did by mandating lockdowns was enforce it on the part of the population that wouldn't do it with the hope that it would stop the spread of COVID. In some countries it worked, in others it didn't. All this is to say there is no causal relationship between the government lockdowns (mandated at the state level in the USA, no?) and the CDC reporting on mental health. Both occured independently. There are however plenty of plausible arguments to make for lockdowns being causal on mental health though.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> In some countries it worked, in others it didn't. You cannot say this for certain. It will take much calmer heads before anybody can say these restrictions were worth their incredible costs. > Both occured independently. There are however plenty of plausible arguments to make for lockdowns being causal on mental health though. Kids were not allowed to go to school for more than a year. You don't need any research to suggest that isn't good for kids. Seriously. Claiming these lockdowns and restrictions didn't have a significant impact on children is being willfully ignorant.
- ImaCake 5y ago> You cannot say this for certain There are dozens of countries that held off the pandemic for over a year. They mostly had the advantage of being islands. > Claiming these lockdowns and restrictions didn't have a significant impact on children is being willfully ignorant. Im not disputing this because I do think they had a serious impact. I do dispute the argument that the CDC mandated lockdowns and then were surprised when it wrecked mental health. They weren’t, and they would have examined mental health anyway.
- tomohawk 5y agoIt's not like the CDC wasn't warned that their policies would be harmful. Oh, wait, they were! Unfortunately, the CDC policies were captive to the teacher's unions, who are anti-child and anti-parent. https://nypost.com/2021/05/01/teachers-union-collaborated-with-cdc-on-school-reopening-emails/ https://nypost.com/2021/05/01/teachers-union-collaborated-wi...
- manuelabeledo 5y agoSo a teacher’s union pushed to protect teachers during a pandemic. Shocking, especially after ~1000 teachers died from COVID-19.
- tomohawk 5y agoThanks for agreeing that the teacher's union pursued an agenda contrary to the needs of our children. It won't be shocking given this activity to undermine our children's health that parents will work to re-orient the teacher's union to a mission that is actually useful to society.
- manuelabeledo 5y ago> Thanks for agreeing that the teacher's union pursued an agenda contrary to the needs of our children. That’s the (far) reaching conclusion from the NYP, that not going to school made kids depressed. The reality is that the only obvious consequence was that schools were closed during the pandemic for health reasons. Now, children mental health treatment have been on the rise for the past 30 years or so. Teen suicide grew by 60% between 2007 and 2018. I doubt that you can blame that to the pandemic too. > It won't be shocking given this activity to undermine our children's health that parents will work to re-orient the teacher's union to a mission that is actually useful to society. Here’s the thing: teachers didn’t sign up to be expendable babysitters. They are supposed to teach, not to risk their lives or keep your kids under supervision. If you would like that, schools may be as well served by the National Guard.
- hotpotamus 5y ago
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThese trends have been happening for decades and it tracks quite well the gradual breakdown of stable family structures. Psychologically for example, kids experience their parent’s divorce as worse than a parent’s death.
- VerminOctopus1 5y agoDo you have a source for that claim? It sounds like nonsense. My parents divorced when I was 6 or 7 years old, and I’m pretty sure it would be unimaginably more traumatic if one of them had died instead.
- replygirl 5y agoJust anecdotally, my parents divorced and one of my parents took their own life, the divorce was harder
- barry-cotter 5y agoIf you compare children of divorce with children who have a parent die the children of divorce look worse on basically every measure, sure. That doesn’t mean divorce is worse for children than the death of a parent. Divorce is a choice. The king of person who gets divorced is different from the kind who doesn’t. By way of example Asian-Americanc college graduates who get married in their 30s have a divorce rate around ~2%. Most people who get divorced remarry. The kind of person who marries a divorcee is not the same king of person as those who don’t. Correlation isn’t causation.
- Cpoll 5y agoI've read some takes that divorce can be positive for a child. The theory was: parents having time away from their child gave them a break, and also helped them value their time with the child more. There are also theories that living in a divorced family is better than living in an unhappily married one. AFAIR there are studies looking at families with different cultural stances on divorce (but good luck controlling for other factors there). Also they tend to measure more easily measurable outcomes in the child than mental health, such as grades, which don't necessarily correlate.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> Regardless of any internet-level understanding or resentment, the millennial/zoomer understanding of mental health is completely destroying people's lives. > I work and have worked in mental health for my entire adult life (late 20s now). I have my own mental health diagnoses. I was diagnosed with severe OCD when I was 11. Since then I've gone through periods of generalized anxiety, agoraphobia, panic disorder, you name it. It has destroyed my life once every three or four years without fail. Losing jobs, friendships, my grades in college, everything. Just utter ineptitude and catatonic inability to take care of myself. I have been blessed with the most supportive family anyone could ask for. I do not fail to see the differences between myself and those who I now serve. But there is an intense illness that is permeating through our younger generations that is destroying the possibility of recovery for these people suffering through legitimate mental health issues. > I have met and helped and treated numerous individuals now who are my peers in age - anything from 18-early 30s. And so many have internalized a generational "understanding" of mental illness that is toxic and worthless beyond condemnation. Our youngest generations' understanding of mental health enables, encourages, and at worst glorifies mental illness. I can not understate the number of times I've met a young woman who has made being mentally ill, and polysexual, and queer, and autistic, et cetera, their identity. https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/a-broken-model-of-brokenness?s=r https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/a-broken-model-of-broke...
- gilrain 5y agoWhoa, I was with that until the huge hit of bigotry at the end. Being queer or polysex is not at all a mental illness.
- jt2190 5y agoThe data for the CDC Adolescent Behaviors and Experiences Survey (ABES) are here: https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/data/abes/tables/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/data/abes/tables/index.htm The survey was conducted in the first half of 2021
- kurofune 5y agoBlaming it all on the pandemic is an absolutely hilarious misdiagnosis. Everything seems to be on the brink of collapse all the time, housing prices are absolutely bonkers in most cities and wages are, in the best scenario imaginable, same they were 20 years ago for your average professional who lives paycheck to paycheck. Politicians have no vision, they are just parasitic entities that benefit electorally from violent asinine confrontation between voters on pointless cultural issues that never find any satisfactory or permanent resolution. Mass media are fully immersed in a two decades long psychic war against the general public that only seems to be accelerating. There are too many structural weakness in our society to point out without having to write a full essay, but this mental health decline is the direct result of our failing political and economic systems and our apparent impossibility to challenge them in any productive way.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y ago> Everything seems to be on the brink of collapse all the time, housing prices are absolutely bonkers in most cities and wages are, in the best scenario imaginable, same they were 20 years ago for your average professional who lives paycheck to paycheck. Personal income per Capita went from ~$30k to ~$63k in the last 20 years [1]. REAL weekly earnings are at an all time high [2]. Debt service reached an all-time low during the pandemic [3]. Even for new buyers with house prices at their peak, with interest rates where they WERE, mortgage payments were historically quite low. Now that interest rates have gone up, payments are ~20% higher. But unsurprisingly, the insatiable demand has also dried up. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A792RC0A052NBEA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A792RC0A052NBEA [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q [3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TDSP https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TDSP I honestly feel sorry for all the people like you who can't see how manipulated prices are and realize that it's a good deal. The market shouldn't be this manipulated (by our government) and confusing. It's screwing over so many people who think common sense still applies.
- Aeolun 5y agoI really don’t understand what you are trying to say. Are you arguing the buying a home is within reach of the average man anywhere outside of the middle of nowhere?
- Friday_ 5y ago
- juanani 5y ago
- frankohn 5y agoThis situation if the result of the destruction of the social network of relations due to the modern lifestyle. To have meaningful social relations with our peers is extremely important for humans and even more so for teenagers I guess. First the modern lifestyle mostly destroyed the small communities where people know each other and spend a lot of time together. People began to stay in their house all the time with no contacts with a community. At this first stage, as the local community was eliminated, the remaining pillars of social relations were school, for young people, and work for adults. I some case adults were able to maintain some degree of additional social life by having some friends and inviting them regularly to create the opportunity to meet. Later it come all the smartphones, tablets, computers, social networks that captivated all the attention, especially of young people so even more so people were pushed to stay more at home and meet less people further increasing the social isolation. The final blow came from the COVID-19 confinement were people were forced to stay at home reducing social contacts only to the close family members. This situation created an unsustainable isolation raising serious mental health problem especially for teenagers but also for adult people. Modern society got it all wrong. We think having more goods and entertainment to consume make us happier but this is not how it works. Not if the social life and the social network around us is poor or non-existent. Scientific thought that they know all and can say people what to do and they give us instruction just to avoid that people dies. The problem is that people doesn't just need to stay physically alive, we need to be also happy and fulfilled by our life. We need to radically change modern lifestyle and stop with all the bullshit coming from politicians.
- Aeolun 5y agoNot sure I agree with everything you say, but having social contact is absolutely gratifying. The lack of community in current times is absolutely a negative.
- t0bia_s 5y agoYet we still collectively prefer conformity behavior shaped by media and politics. Decentralisation and community is future.
- 5y ago
- xwdv 5y agoAnother factor may be that many people that teens look up to today talk openly about mental health problems, to the point that now it seems almost trendy to struggle with mental health. Perhaps this encourages teens to let their mental health deteriorate for attention, which is the social currency of today’s society. Remember they are not entirely rational beings.
- standardUser 5y agoOr if we want to be less mind-blowingly cynical about it, we could simply assume that the increased openness to discussing mental health is itself helping previously unnoticed mental health issues to come to light.
- thenerdhead 5y agoSure the pandemic may have accelerated or been the catalyst, but let's be honest here. TV/Internet/Video game addiction is a serious thing that nobody is paying attention to. I struggled with this personally for the last 25 years of my life and I'm 30. I now have two kids and have to ensure I moderate their usage in responsible ways as they grow up. I was a generation before the iPad, but the current teenagers struggling have likely had a smart device from as early as 2. My smart device was a TV and nintendo. The guidelines the CDC even has for responsible device usage is reasonable, but nobody follows it. Most people are picking up their devices up to a hundred times a day or every 10 minutes. The average screen time is close to 3 hours. That's an average by the way... We need to bring awareness to this problem like Nicholas Carr did over a decade ago. We can't let big tech companies convince us this isn't a problem with their sponsored studies to control a narrative.
- notacoward 5y agoIf you really want to see how bad it has gotten, try finding a therapist for a teen. Even in communities where supply is high and demand is (relatively) low, they're all absolutely overwhelmed. When I went looking, ~75% of them were explicitly not taking new clients. Working through the rest, through multiple directories and services, I was denied or simply ghosted ~20 times before I finally found someone. Naturally it was the newest, youngest member of a large practice. She has been great, but the struggle to find her was a real eye opener.
- aaomidi 5y agoGlobal warming Economic forecasts being shit Social media Realizing the injustice in the world and seeing adults do nothing about it Hyper competitive schooling Lack of support during the pandemic Yeah all of this has an impact.
- prepend 5y ago> Economic forecasts being shit Aren’t we in the longest economic boon ever? This might be the first bear market in over 10 years. Schools didn’t require sats and other exams and were actually easier to get into during the pandemic. The past two years were like a glorious time for school admission.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoThe distribution of "rewards" from this economic boom has been a bit one sided taking all factors into account.
- prepend 5y agoI don’t think so. Low home interest rates have helped first time home buyers. Stocks benefit pensions and 401k. Low interest rates help for credit card debt, auto loans, etc. Lowest unemployment in the history of the stat helps with all job seekers. Of course it helps billionaires more because they have more stocks. But bull economies are pretty good for everyone and there’s a whole generation pretty much that’s never experienced a down year of s&p.
- mellavora 5y ago> Low home interest rates have helped first time home buyers. I hear it is almost impossible to buy a house in the US these days, what with private equity firms bidding cash for everything. > Stocks benefit pensions and 401k. nice if you have them, but it is hard to invest if rent is 50% of your take-home (and not because you are living large, but because that's all that was available)
- ck2 5y agoBefore 2000 or so, every stupid thing you did as a kid wasn't recorded on a phone or online somewhere permanently that you could forget it. Maybe at school but bullying wasn't possible 24/7 online like now. You had no idea what the latest news or political drama was as a kid before 2000 because it wasn't in your hand 12+ hours a day. No twitter/facebook or whatever they are using now. Now being a kid is as depressing as being an adult and you are wired-in to a world that's overwhelming you. Sure they don't have jobs or rents to pay but everything still feels fatalistic to them, like they can't escape the world defines them, not the other way around.
- tsoukase 5y agoSolid and deep points. At era around 2000 things-culture started to decline. No coincidence global IQ and many qualities (eg music, education, human relations) started to decline at that time too
- johnold 5y agoAs a high school teacher(14-18 year olds) who actually spends a lot of time trying to interact with students and get to know them, I keep hearing this kind of statement: There is no room for mistakes. Students cannot miss a homework assignment, fail an exam, not achieve an A, make any kind of faux pax on social media, etc… And then you combine this with many adults in their lives telling them, I got into UCLA, why can’t you? Just work harder, or just not caring about their mental health. They see this never ending cycle of turn the assignments in and then go to sports practice(where again the competition is at such a high level) and also, get a job, because they want or need money. Many are going to bed after midnight every night. Something has to give. This is really disturbing to me. How are they doing living up to this? Many are living up to it but the cost is substantial, and the others that have no hope of being this are giving up.
- holoduke 5y agoI am glad this is not the case in Europe (with the exception of the UK). Here we do not only look to performance and pride and you need to win everything. Individual development is very important. Hope it will remain like that.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Individual development is very important. Not sure if you’ve misread the thread - the whole problem is too much importance on individual development and the pressure this brings.
- toxik 5y agoThis is a funny reply because “individual development” isn’t something you schedule in European eyes. You just hang around with friends and learn to be a good person, and specifically not a tight wound asshole.
- chrisseaton 5y agoNobody does anything like learn an instrument or play a sport in Europe? That's what we're talking about.
- trhway 5y agoAs I said to my psychologist at the beginning of the pandemic - what is done to the children as supposed pandemic fighting measures will generate as much work for him for many decades to come as he can take as naturally nobody cares about long term.
- sdoering 5y agoThe quality of the discussion is in parts abysmal. Assertions are thrown into the world without even mentioning a source. A substantive discussion is therefore not possible. It is just 'opinion porn' imho. Regardless of whether the pandemic, social media, (real) porn, industrial food, excessive demands at school, any combination thereof or other anecdotes are used as the cause. Nothing is substantiated by linking sources. Or at least naming them. Whatever is claimed can only be questioned, not refuted, as there is no substantive point of attack. Thus, in the end, everyone feels good because they were able to express an opinion. But unfortunately we have learned nothing.
- mlyle 5y agoYou know, opinions are valuable here for hypothesis generation. No one knows and there is no consensus why this is happening. I have a few opinions as a middle-and-high school teacher. But talking about this is important to help wrap our heads around it. If a definitive understanding or reason were easy to acquire, we'd have done it already. So, the toil continues: for researchers, policymakers, laymen... and those of us in the trenches trying to do something about it with not enough information.
- sdoering 5y agoThere are for quite some time already studies happening so I doubt that random people on the internet sharing opinions help much in generating valid (or interesting) hypotheses. Also how would you validate those? Just examples: - https://www.cmaj.ca/content/192/6/E136.short https://www.cmaj.ca/content/192/6/E136.short - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34406494/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34406494/ - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34333404/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34333404/
- mlyle 5y agoA few observational studies are fairly meaningless-- they don't establish causation, etc. Your meta-analysis highlights as such. Discussion, speculation, and reasoning about problems are valuable-- even if the process does often lead us astray. Do you ever talk about things that you are not an expert on or that aren't settled? E.g. You made some comments about team culture a few days ago-- ignoring the massive body of literature about conflict in teams and engaging in speculation based upon personal opinion. I'm a teacher at a school where neither COVID "lockdown" nor excessive social media use would be a great explanation for poor student mental health, but still there has been a significant increase in problems in the past few years. Should I just ignore the problem and hope research pins it down and solves it? I need to make reasonable guesses and act upon them.
- lumb63 5y agoIt astonishes me to see people defending the idea that the pandemic is not a notable component of this. I agree that social media, internet porn, competitive school environment, economic conditions, etc., are all negative influences on teenage mental health. However, to propose that forcing (or, at the least, very strongly encouraging) an entire populace into self-isolation would not have negative impacts for a group in one of the most social and formative times of life, is absurd. Imagine you spent half the time you were in high school, alone. I cannot imagine any rational person is capable of believing this to not be a major factor to their mental health. Anecdotally, I am a reasonably strong introvert, and I switched teams at my job during the pandemic after nine months of work from home because it did not feel healthy to my mental state to not have interacted with anyone in so long. I felt that my social abilities had atrophied, and that I had lost sight of a lot of the important things in life that derive from social interaction. I can only imagine that the impact is far greater to someone who can't choose to change their life to obtain the social interaction they are missing, and who (I am generalizing a bit here) probably requires mental/emotional guidance and support from their peers, elders, etc.
- PathOfEclipse 5y agoPeople may rationalize these things because the alternative is to admit that one may have been wrong and/or caused harm to others in the process. People would rather downplay the harms caused by the pandemic to avoid guilt.
- rjh29 5y agoI've used that argument and the counter is: depression due to lockdown can heal once lockdown is over. People dying because hospitals filled up and cases climbed is permanent.
- henrikschroder 5y agoSuicidal ideation among kids in the US is up 100%, suicide attempts are up 50%, actual suicides are up 20%. Dead kids are also pretty &¤#&%#!" permanent. And this is the thing that's been missing for the past two years: A sensible cost/benefit discussion. Hell, we haven't even acknowledged that every single pandemic rule and restriction and measure has a cost in human life. Instead, we've been getting shitty platitudes about how "kids are resilient", or "it's just two weeks", or "your surgery is non-essential and therefore postponed".
- Animats 5y agoNote the date: "survey of a nationally representative sample of 7,700 teens conducted in the first six months of 2021."
- rossdavidh 5y ago1) how am I missing the link to the actual CDC study? or did WaPo not even post the link to the survey results they were discussing? 2) disappointing not to see any comparison to other advanced economies. Is this happening everywhere with high internet usage? Did the severity correlate at all to how severe the pandemic was or what the responses were? Does it correlate to income levels or political polarization or religiosity or any of the other things that vary (at least somewhat) between different advanced economies? Maybe the CDC study looked at this, but if so WaPo said nothing about it. Hard to know what to do with this information with nothing but a WaPo text wall talking about it.
- rossdavidh 5y agoFound the CDC link, at least: https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/mental-health/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/mental-health/index.htm
- tzs 5y agoThat seems to just cover 2009-2019. The article is talking about a study from a survey conducted in the first half of 2021.
- rossdavidh 5y agoRight you are; here's the CDC press release from the new one: https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2022/p0331-youth-mental-health-covid-19.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2022/p0331-youth-mental-h... ...but it still doesn't link to the data, or do any comparison to other countries.
- stakkur 5y agoMy wife's a middle school teacher for over 22 years. If you want an unvarnished view into just how bad things have gotten since the pandemic begain--for mental health, school engagement, and all things related--talk to a teacher. It's unprecedented, and the long tail of the damage will take decades to understand.
- ccbccccbbcccbb 5y agoWhen CDC warns about society as a whole being subjected to total and deliberate menticide and discloses all means towards that end, it is only then that there will finally arrive some substance to discuss. Otherwise it sounds like researching the swaying of trees without ever mentioning the wind.
- evocatus 5y agoI've already walked this path of self-isolation. The pandemic, quarantine, none of it are new to me. This was my life for years. I feel for this upcoming generation, in the most real way possible. They are fucked.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 5y ago> “When you make schools less toxic for the most vulnerable students, all students benefit — and the converse is also true,” Ethier said. Who is making schools more toxic for the least vulnerable students? I need a hit, baby, give me it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dadjoker 5y agoI'm not sure what you expect when you instill constant fear of simply getting sick, take away all of their social structure, and isolate them in front of a screen, all for a virus that doesn't affect kids barely at all. Per the CDC there is a 0.003% chance of someone under age 20 dying from COVID; they have greater risk driving to school. It's no wonder their mental health is so poor, even if the trend was starting before the pandemic.
- aedocw 5y agoThe point was to limit the spread of the virus throughout the entire population, and an attempt to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed by the infected.
- vinyl7 5y agoWhatever helps you rationalize that we basically destroyed the younger generation in hopes of saving the old/dying generation
- spookthesunset 5y agoToo bad you'll never really know if any of it worked. Kinda would have been nice to stick with proven mitigations we had planned out for decades instead of chuck it all out of the window in search of a miracle cure. If you read pre-covid pandemic planning, virtually everything they suggestion you dont do society decided to do. Everything they suggested you should do, we ignored.
- Apocryphon 5y agoSweden's low-restrictions approach exists as an alternative case study: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Sweden
- heyoni 5y agoAnd if we (the US) are going to take example on Europe for anything, let's do universal healthcare first before taking the laissez-faire approach to a pandemic. Seems like a good pre-requesite.
- pcarolan 5y agoI am helping a family member recently diagnosed with ADHD during the pandemic. I looked up this google trend and my jaw dropped. Clearly the world has yet to come to terms with the social, emotional and psychological effects of this pandemic. If anyone here knows anything about what's causing the rise in adhd specifically, I'd love to hear about it: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=today%205-y&geo=US&q=adhd https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=today%205-y&ge...
- elcritch 5y agoYou don't really "get" ADHD as it's generally lifelong. Symptoms can wax and wane over time though and can be exacerbated. Combine that with diagnosis getting better, especially for women and non-hyperactive subtypes.
- pcarolan 5y agoRight, so why did the trend explode during the pandemic?
- elcritch 5y agoIt’s possible there was a rise of incorrect diagnosis where lockdown stresses gave rise to ADHD-like symptoms. Alternatively more people WFH and not having other distractions could’ve led more people to figure out their existing ADHD. Likely more people also sought mental health care given the stressors of lockdowns and media coverage of COVID. Just hypotheses.
- phil21 5y agoDrug seekers as well for performance enhancers like adderall or ritalin. If you're somewhere on the spectrum it's pretty trivial to present ADHD with some practice to a clinician who doesn't care much, especially if remote. I heard of a couple instances of this throughout my extended social network - largely from people who found it very hard to focus at home and get work done (they required work/home separation for mental health), but certainly did not have ADHD.
- indymike 5y agoThis coincides with about seven months of going back to school. My kids did so much better when they were not in school. They got plenty of time with other kids, but none of the toxic middle school culture.
- sammalloy 5y ago> Although young people were spared the brunt of the virus — falling ill and dying at much lower rates than older people — they might still pay a steep price for the pandemic, having come of age while weathering isolation, uncertainty, economic turmoil and, for many, grief. The honest truth that most people don’t want to face is that there is a direct relationship between economic turmoil and mental health. Instead, we will get politicians and community leaders blaming everything else for the problem, when all you have to do to address it is to pay people a living wage and provide an adequate social net to fall back upon. Our leaders will never admit this.
- phs318u 5y agoI'll post my own anecdote regarding this topic. Not drawing global conclusions but perhaps providing a different perspective. This will probably be a long read. I am almost 57. I have two daughters aged turning 25 and 23 this year. Before COVID here were our various diagnoses. Me: clinical depression, poor impulse control (addiction, in long-term recovery). "High functioning". Eldest daughter: borderline personality disorder, depression, anxiety, poor impulse control (addiction). Relatively "high functioning". Youngest daughter: ADD, anxiety, depression. Not "high functioning". My wife: "doesn't need to see a psychologist". During COVID, my eldest who had moved out, moved back in with us. Despite the difficulties of COVID, being together probably helped in that we were able to support each other and any deterioration in mental health was moderated. It helps that I totally lifted my game as a practicing stoic during this time and led by example (not bragging, but that's how it played out). I earn a VERY good living in IT. I also have a pre-diagnosed heart condition (growing aneurysm on the ascending aorta, not yet at "needs surgery" stage) and hyper-tension. Otherwise in reasonable fitness (another area I lifted my game in during COVID). I'm one of the category of people that lockdowns protected. If I had gotten (or get) COVID, there's a decent chance things won't go too well for me (am fully vaccinated and boosted). Because I make a good living, I was able to pay for a two week stay in a really good private rehab/mental-health retreat (multi-dimensional professional care) for my eldest - during one of the many lockdowns. We're talking decent 5-figure cost - not covered by our insurance (I should point out that we live in a country with national health insurance, though there's a vast gulf of difference between private and public systems when it comes to mental health). Of all the help she's gotten during the last ten years she's been battling her issues and addictions, it was the single most effective thing she's ever done, to the point that I feel I've gotten her back. She's the best "her" she's ever been. She's now moved out again and living with her boyfriend (a lovely kid, also with pre-COVID mental health issues). They are making a good fist of it, and are both doing really well and feeling very happy despite living largely hand-to-mouth. I'm about to send my youngest to the same place my eldest went to. If I had gotten COVID and died, chances are very high that both my daughters would have had worse outcomes. The reality is they wouldn't have been able to afford the help they need. And this is help that they needed before COVID. I'm not saying that COVID hasn't made it worse. It has. But to those who are looking at some kind of naive calculus as if there's an inverse correlation between "protecting old folks from death" and "protecting young people's mental health" - I say the world isn't that simple. Listening to my kids and understanding both what makes them happy and hopeful, and depressed and anxious, I'd say that the former is primarily related to connection, love and focusing on what they can control vs what they can't. The latter, seems to a great degree related to focusing on what they can't control - the state of the world, its politics, climate change and "the fact that everything is turning to shit". This is where I encourage them (by example and through discussion) to adopt stoic philosophy as a way of living and being. It's been what kept me sane during COVID and helps me deal with the shittiness of life while focusing on the beauty that life still holds. My 2c (probaly $20 going by the length of this post. Apologies).
- tastysandwich 5y agoThe entire pandemic felt like screaming in an empty room sometimes. My wife is a teacher in a low-SES area, and my sister-in-law is a psychologist dealing specifically with at-risk youth. From the start they could see first-hand the detrimental impact lockdown had on the poorest and most vulnerable. For many of these kids, school is a sanctuary from a dysfunctional and/or abusive home life. They don't have quiet places to study, let alone the means (laptop, internet). Just a little example here, based on a close friend's upbringing. A young teen can't sleep because her degenerate father is blasting music from 11PM to 3AM. Fortunately, her grandparents live up the road, and their house has become a bit of a safe-haven. So she runs down there, and gets a good night sleep. When things are tough at home, she knows she can always stay there a few nights. In lockdown world, that option is totally removed. The father, now out of work, is verbally abusive and blasts music all night. How do you think she's going to fare with "remote learning"? 2 years cut off from their peers, stuck in toxic environments, these kids have come back terribly damaged. My wife says she has never seen so many fights at school. My sister-in-law says they are so short-staffed right now they're having to turf kids because they're not "at-risk" enough. Of course, politicians kept assuring us this was not the case, that there was no data showing any negative impact. Of course there was no data yet - it was still being collated! But talk to any person on the frontline and they could tell you. But I suppose politicians' kids go to pretty nice schools, with supportive family environments and the means to support remote learning (laptops, fast internet, a quiet place to study). A more disconnected, clueless lot, I have never seen.
- alar44 5y agoOk, well my sister is a doctor and she got to watch bodies get shoveled out of her hospital for 2 years. Who wins? Did I do it right? Do I win?
- tastysandwich 5y agoThat's a little fatuous, and it does disappoint me a bit how we devolve to this immediately. I guess we're all a bit on high-alert when it comes to politics? It's not really an either/or. I don't advocate for zero measures. More like, there's a range of different measures we could have taken, with varying of positive vs negative side-effects. We should of course take measures that have lots of positive side effects, and relatively few negative side effects. Things like contact tracing, and the vaccines of course. Masking early on was a good idea when we didn't know much. However it's a little silly to deny that there's some measures taken that didn't have so many clear positive benefits, but definitely had negative ones. For example, in my state they closed all the playgrounds & skate parks, even though there was no evidence of transmission there. For some kids, blowing off a little bit of steam by riding their bike at the local skate park is a huge deal, and not at all trivial. Similarly, my sister-in-law had to conduct all her appointments remotely. She's dealing with traumatised kids that struggle to maintain eye contact, let alone human connection. That face-to-face time is really crucial for establishing rapport with these kids. Not to mention the fact that many just didn't bother dialling in. These aren't kids presenting with anxiety btw. These are kids with some of the worst trauma imaginable.
- tonymet 5y agoBefore you blame circumstances, remember that even people with seemingly perfect lives (money, fame) still suffer. I can think of a wealthy public figure who's full time job was to travel and enjoy great food, yet still abused drugs and committed suicide. Suffering is part of life. Until recently, poverty, starvation & disease were universal. We certainly have it better than that, even with "social media", "bullying", "college acceptance" threatening teens. The bigger problem is that we haven't given young people a solid sense of purpose. If their only purpose is money and fame, they will certainly fall apart, even if it goes well. You can never have enough. No amount of money, anti depressants or therapy will make up for a lack of meaning. Sure we should work to improve circumstances, but unless we give people a reason to live, it won't matter.
- wolverine876 5y agoI worry that it is the expected result of taking away hope. Powerful actors try, and have succeeded - with our unwitting help - in spreading a highly reactionary message of despair, disabling those who might challenge their power. You have no power; only the wealthy and large corporations, and all that matters is profit. Progress; the equal value of individuals from any class, status, ethnicity, gender, etc; the power of any individual to change the world through hard work; - the things humanity has worked for since the beginning of the Enlightenment, with incredible success - are derided, even here in the heart of innovation and entrepreneurialism, which fundamentally depend on those notions. The garages of Silicon Valley defeated IBM. Younger generations now believe they have no power, that humanity is fundamentally evil and corrupt, that progress isn't possible. Look at climate change: most believe not that, 'the people, united, can never be defeated', but that nothing can be done. We have the tools, the knowledge, the need is clear, but the powerful have created despair. That's not what I grew up with; I grew up with hope, and people who changed the world, from George Washington to Dr King, from Isaac Newton to Albert Einstein, from Edison to Jobs. Even the left-of-center and many progressives have adopted this message. Somone - that means you - needs to start spreading one of hope. I think they would be incredibly popular.
- YATA1 5y ago
- atoav 5y agoThis is unsurprising. There are no good prospects — war, climate change, a divided society — in all of this: You, a teen with a digital mirror, that keeps you updated on how much more you seem to suck than all the others you have to compare yourself against. Your parents who constantly tell you your generation has to fix and/or safe the planet, while you wonder if you will even be able to fix and/or safe yourself. Meanwhile even people who you see as adults have given up of ever being able to retiring, but you know it is quite definitly going to get worse for you.
- phil21 5y agoI think this is a great underappreciated comment. I often feel my development went... much different than most in my peer group due to my much earlier access to the Internet/on-line services and me being a "curious hacker" getting into places and reading things I definitely should not have at that age. Seeing how utterly incompetent "powerful" institutions were (combined with teenage arrogance) that I was raised to deeply respect is still something I have difficulty processing. I can't imagine being bombarded not just with 100x more information about how the future is f*cked and how incompetent those running the show are, but also it being amped up to 11 by hucksters selling "engagement" and ads. The content is coming to you now. I think a lot of early adulthood is just brazen naivety. For example, I'd never have started the company I did at 17 at age 37, there would be too many reasons I know it'd fail. If you lose that naivety too early, at least personally I would have utterly lost any motivation to "try" since the odds were so astronomically against me. When a generation collectively believes they will have it worse than their parents I'm not entirely sure what to expect the outcomes to be.
- atoav 5y agoI think it is our responsibility as older generations to show them that the world can be changed, even if it is just on a small scale. Too many people view everything around them (including themselves!) as immutable. What people are trying to do is getting a better spot on the sinking ship. Happyness defined as drowning just a little bit later than your neighbour (but focus, you could slip at any moment). The pumps that could easily keep the ship from sinking are mounted only by a few idealists, which are called names by those with the most fear in their eyes. Some, with their feet already in the water vehemently insist water is not real — their anger directed at those busy pumping the water. Those higher up the ship tell those stories, because they hope it will keep them dry till some divine help arrives. In the end, everybody dies, but those on top die a little bit later.
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago