4 ms·
Physicists: loves simplicity Biologists: loves complexity Wonder how much this affects what field students chooses to study?
by Jensson 5y ago
Physicists: loves simplicity
Biologists: loves complexity
Wonder how much this affects what field students chooses to study?
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoThe state of your average physics lab does not lead me to imagine physicists love simplicity in all things.
- anyfoo 5y agoSort of treating a funny comment seriously here, but I imagine that it's exactly like it is for EEs, which are also using lots of pieces of test equipment (sometimes the exact same, even). It's not so much that messy labs are desirable or even okay for everyone, it's just that often it's pretty much impossible to keep your test bench "clean" and organized with so many devices, probes, and their cables, interconnected with each other. Or that even in the cases where you could achieve it, iterative changes to your setup mess that up immediately. Personally I often like it, it feels like actual work getting done. %)
- yesenadam 5y agoNot to mention Delbruck's principle of limited sloppiness. I don't know the best single place to read about it, but reading around the top google results you get the idea. https://www.google.com/search?q=delbruck%27s+principle+of+limited+sloppiness https://www.google.com/search?q=delbruck%27s+principle+of+li... The prototypical story is Fleming's nose dripping into a petri dish enabling the discovery of penicillin. If he was less sloppy that wouldn't have happened. But he was unsloppy enough that when something unexpected happened he paid attention and knew what it meant.
- adhesive_wombat 5y ago> feels like actual work getting done The absolute best bit about a test rig setup that's starting to evolve it's own sentience is that any time you are stuck, you can spend a whole day tidying it up, neatening cable routing, putting redundant things back in parts bins, mounting things to brackets, labelling stuff nicely, and so on. Not only will you feel like you're "getting stuff done", but anyone watching will see only a buzz of industrious activity, marvel at your pristine setup, and, moreover, at the end of the process, nothing will work and you get to spend another day debugging to get back to where you were at the start. The good news is that somewhere along this route, your brain will probably have concluded you have obviously lost the plot and figured out the original problem all on its own. But now it's Friday evening, so write that thought down before you go or you'll forget it by Monday! Oddly specific? Maybe, but I can't be the only one.
- dekhn 5y agoMy PhD is in biophysics, which is a combination of these fields. We spend a fair amount of time trying to simplify the complexity (and place it in a more quantitative context). We spent a lot of time looking at beautiful crystal structures and cells growing.
- Jensson 5y agoWhy was this downvoted? That physicists and biologists likes different things is literally a result discussed in the article.
- harry8 5y agoWe are all the victims of physics...
- amelius 5y agoAnd software engineers?
- stackbutterflow 5y agoDream of simplicity. Settle for complexity. Implement spaghetti.
- _Nat_ 5y agoIt may not be a straight comparison, if professionals in Physics vs. Biology are considering those concepts in the context of their fields. Biologists can handle complexity more easily, because things grow. This is, biologists can do their work and admire the complexity unfolding in front of their eyes, without it derailing their ability to do research. Physics is different: they're straining against their computational-limits, struggling with intense-complexity beating down on them. Physicists often imagine being able to calculate macroscopic phenomena through sufficient modeling of microscopic dynamics, though the complexity constrains them. For physicists, it can be a relief to find something simple enough to be understood. A good analogy might be with respect to scientists doing Astronomical research on stars: biologists would be like astronomers who catalog massive amounts of stars, trying to find neat ones, while physicists would be like astronomers who try to create physical-models to simulate/predict stellar-dynamics. In the first case, one might admire a huge diversity of complex behaviors; in the latter case, one may be elated to find a simple explanation for something that seemed complex. In other words, if you're working from the top-down, then you might admire the inner-complexity of the systems you get to work with; but if you're working from the bottom-up, then you might cherish simpler explanations that enable you to do more.