13 ms·
'Children of Men' is happening
- analog31 5y ago>>> The upside is that — and this is admittedly a strange time to suggest it — the world is going to be a lot less violent. This only makes sense if the population declines faster than the habitability of the earth does.
- rob_c 5y agoI don't think that's even cost to where we are...
- drorco 5y agoAnd the same claim is void if warfare will turn to be drone/remote-based.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sitkack 5y agoAt least you can still WFR (work from rubble).
- w-j-w 5y ago
- helloworld11 5y agoYou refer to nuclear war? It would be awful, without a doubt, especially at a full scale, but even a full scale nuke exchange would not come close to rendering the world uninhabitable. Many of the 50's scenarios on nuclear winter were exaggerated. (a good thing overall if it helped prevent people from pushing certain buttons or turning certain keys)
- analog31 5y agoNah, just global warming and environmental destruction.
- xondono 5y ago“in Catalonia around the time of that province’s comical attempts at independence in 2017[…]” If the author wanted to look like an asshole, I guess mission accomplished? Also, it’s quite ridiculous to claim this was somehow just a matter of age, since there’s a reason for only finding old people at Port bou, most young people from Port Bou are in Barcelona, where colleges are… Even young people didn’t want war, because here there’s an ingrained distrust of the military, since twice in Barcelonas history the canons built to protect it were turned around and used to raze it to the ground by the people sworn to protect it.
- FerociousTimes 5y ago> a comfortable lifestyle without the huge stress of mixing child-raising and a modern economy. Can someone please tell what does he mean exactly by that sentence?
- rob_c 5y agoOther than a rambling rant is there a real connection to the book amongst all of the verbiage?
- woodruffw 5y agoAs a corollary to this: it's perhaps not surprising that the remaining conflict we do see is spearheaded by our increasingly aged heads of state, men and women who grew up in the shadow of WW2 and the peak of the Cold War.
- simonh 5y agoYet in the article he says “ The upside is that — and this is admittedly a strange time to suggest it — the world is going to be a lot less violent”. Saddam Hussein was hardly a teenager when he invaded Kuwait, and Putin is no spring chicken. I don’t know what the answer is, but I suspect this guy doesn’t either. It’s a shame though, since the collapse of the Soviet Union the share of the worlds population dying in warfare has collapsed. It was already on a strong downward trend after the end of WW2. Let’s hope Ukraine is an outlier.
- ilammy 5y agoI think woodruffw meant that the conflict in the Old World might be spearheaded by those people who still have a romantic infatuation by war, which has been steadily declining since like WW1 but manages to hold on in some capacity to these days. Eventually we'll get to the point where people – contemporary young people, future born people – would not see physical violence as a means of settling political disagreements. Partly because they would know how precious life is in a low-fertility environment.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoEver heard of a Second Congo War? Of course, not. Who ever cares about what happens in Africa, right?
- simonh 5y agoYes I have, it was horrible with millions dead. Few wars are not horrible whether in Africa or anywhere else. The fact remains that globally deaths per 10k people due to war was in serious decline at that time.
- 5y ago
- 01100011 5y agoWhat are the countries and cultures bucking the trend? It might be useful to understand what the world will look like in 50 years.
- w-j-w 5y ago
- vidarh 5y agoSome parts of sub-Saharan Africa still have high fertility, but those who have seen increased economic development have also seen at least the start of the same demographic transition. Last time I checked population growth forecasts, the models mostly predict worldwide population contraction within a century. Substantial increases in longevity could delay that, but avoiding it entirely would take fairly substantial efforts to encourage more children. As someone with a single child, I'd say substantially improved childcare provisions would be necessary, but insufficient - I could afford a lot of childcare, but having a child is still a lot of work. Efforts to normalise more help, might help, but some of the options that might help in that respect (e.g. more au pairs, live in aid) are actively countered by high house prices.
- 54534534 5y agoFertility is declining rapidly across Africa: https://www.afd.fr/en/actualites/dramatic-drop-fertility-across-africa https://www.afd.fr/en/actualites/dramatic-drop-fertility-acr...
- jeffbee 5y agoChina must be delighted. They can easily make use of the vast, almost completely depopulated, and resource-rich Russian far east.
- pyuser583 5y agoThe US has a vast, almost completely depopulated “west Midwest” filled with resources: Nevada, Idaho, Wyoming, Alaska etc Something like 45% of the US geography is essentially unpopulated - with tons of resources. It’s nice, I guess, but America’s economic growth comes from the overpopulated areas: Silicon Valley, Manhattan, Austin, etc. I’m not directly disagreeing with you. Obviously both America and China can be happy !
- pragmatic 5y agoI guess it depends how you define resources. The severe droughts in that area mean limited water and grassland for grazing. I can’t see any major development beyond what’s there already with limited water. Some minor growth comes with the cyclical oil booms but coal is politically dead.
- vidarh 5y agoChina's population growth is about to flatline too.
- candiodari 5y agoChina's one child policy means China has had a particularly low fertility rate for decades. Even now, it's "up" to 1.6. That's lower than Russia, which is far from replacement level. Child policy only takes effect after something like 20-25 years. So China's population will be well into decline before the first effect of canceling the one-child policy will be observed, in 2030-2035 (2010 - 2015 + 20 years). Additionally Health services in China don't match those in the West, so they will lose people far faster. China is in a much worse state than even Eastern Europe when it comes to population. It doesn't look like it, but China went into decline 3 years ago and will not stop declining until at least 2060. And it will be quite a steep decline starting in 2030 or so.
- innagadadavida 5y ago>> Russia is dying. Fertility rate worldwide has plummeted and the population has peaked. Including these as war relate statistics is disingenuous. On a different note, population reduction is good for the environment and long term survival of the species but terrible for the economy and wealth - especially of some countries.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoIs it bad for wealth? I had read that the Black Plague that took out 1/3 of the European population actually made people (the survivors, of course) wealthier.
- xeromal 5y agoThat was a very temporary effect due to lords competing for workers. Eventually the king stepped in and stopped it. 'The same thing would probably happen now too. See: California and other states prevent rent increases during the pandemic.
- FpUser 5y ago>"but terrible for the economy and wealth" If the economy is based more and more on automation maybe it is possible to keep smaller population at even higher living standard and UBI. We might loose few by then trillionaires in a process but who really gives a shit about those.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoPopulation has not peaked, it is still expected to continue rising to 10 Billion.
- vidarh 5y agoThe point is that Russia's fertility rate is particularly low, and Russia can't really afford a long term compounding effect of their already low rate, with the loss of a significant number of young men. While that is unlikely to affect their thinking about the war in the short term, the article has a point that the perceived impact may well be higher when families are generally smaller.
- throwaway984393 5y ago
- _dain_ 5y ago
- Apocryphon 5y agoSmith?!
- JKCalhoun 5y agoTo be sure. Nature being nature, no doubt another "invasive species" would evolve along.
- thriftwy 5y agoTo whom is ecology 'worth' in absense of humans?
- throwaway984393 5y agoWorth is a measure of value and value is a measure of usefulness or importance. Ecology is a self-perpetuating system that depends on itself to produce itself. Everything in it depends on everything else in it, so its value is to be able to continue itself. Ecology is valuable to ecology. What's really funny is that humans don't even seem to respect their own worth, as humans depend on ecology to survive, yet they seem hell-bent on destroying it so that they can't survive anymore. An abnormal growth that spreads until it kills its host.
- thriftwy 5y agoYou did not answer the question.
- throwaway984393 5y agoYou're asking a nonsense question. If humans didn't exist, the concept of worth wouldn't exist either, other than in the context I described in my first paragraph.
- Yuioup 5y agoI don't understand why people are always panicking about negative fertility numbers and declining populations. Surely it's a good thing, right?
- dash2 5y agoMany theories of economic growth say that it is fundamentally generated by new ideas. When you have fewer people, you have fewer new ideas. So innovation might slow: in some models it even reverses.
- antisthenes 5y agoNew ideas just aren't generated uniformly at a rate of say, 0.001 per person per year. They are generated by highly educated people with genetic ability, who also have the means for a stable adulthood and at least a modicum of free time to develop their curiosities. Not to mention the means to go into science. Very frequently another industry will pay more, and that person never becomes a scientist/researcher.
- CogitoCogito 5y agoIs innovation slowing necessarily a bad thing?
- xeromal 5y agoI don't have any articles to back this shower though up, but I assume people fear becoming the English post pax-romana. Being in a world where you can't even conceive to rebuild something your ancestors built is a bit disturbing. If you're not progressing, you're backsliding.
- Yuioup 5y agoInnovation exists because of a need to find a way to support a growing population. We don't need to be continuously innovating. It's OK to take a break.
- 5y ago
- Tepix 5y agoWill the population decline fast enough to save the planet? Seems doubtful. We use far too many resources and the population will increase for a while until it will start decreasing.
- HorizonXP 5y agoHave more children. Have them early if possible. I’m a first-generation child of immigrant parents. So is my wife. In our families, we have a lot of cousins around our age. Many are childless. Similar story amongst our circle of friends. In Canada, we’ve supplemented our low birth rate and labour force with immigration. We’re small enough that it can continue to work for a while. But given the investment made by our immigrant parents and by our government, it behooves us to work hard, contribute to society and pay back that debt. Yet, with fewer children, we’re losing the opportunity for those returns. If our parents came for a better life, we should keep making more smart children, with the capacity for new ideas and innovation, in an environment that fosters and promotes that. Given all of the places in the world, we won the genetic lottery. Makes little sense to squander it. I also reject the notion that humanity is a cancer on the planet. Growth is the route to solving our problems.
- nostromo 5y ago> Have them early if possible. The two most important factors in having successful children are: 1. having two parents and 2. having older parents at child birth. There’s a ton of data on this. Maybe it’s correlation only, but it also makes sense. Parenting is too difficult for a single person. And waiting until you’re established and stable will give your kids a better environment for growth.
- ilammy 5y agoThe age might very well be correlation, not causation. Wealthy 50-years-olds having their firstborns, then promptly leaving them vast inheritance — boom! you get “successful” children merely because they got quite a boost. Meanwhile, you don't see not-so-wealthy 50-years-olds having new kids because they had them already at 25 and that was enough. Also, there is a whole host of implications from having kids earlier. Like, you being just 30 when they go to school — or young adults having 65-year-old parents to care of when they'd be rather establishing their own life.
- nostromo 5y agoI’m not just talking about wealth… Look at our prison population and you’ll find people raised by a very young single parent. Look at people that graduate from university and you’ll see the opposite. It strongly correlates with just about any measure you can think of. And it is true across race, gender, immigration status, etc.
- whatshisface 5y ago>Russia is dying. In just the first week of Putin’s war, the country lost somewhere between 2,000 and 6,000 men, according to western sources, an immense and needless tragedy for the poor families left behind to grieve. >country does not have enough men to spare. 144 million people live in Russia. This war is a terrible tragedy but it will not depopulate the country. It won't even depopulate Ukraine through casualties, although it's having a fair effect due to refugees (44M population, millions of refugees). Putin does not care about the families of the fallen, he is playing Civilization and you can't expand your borders without moving your pieces.
- giorgioz 5y agoThe article fails to mention France which is managing the low children crisis better than most. Macron moved down the compulsory school age start from 6 (primary school) down to 3 (kindergarten). Governments should help families by providing easier access to daycares and kindergartens. Helping young parents get some rest with their first child(ren) will encourage them having more children. I'm a parent of two young children, a 3 years old and a 6 months old. This is the hardest period of my life since high school. I'm 34 and in our circles I'm the youngest dad. Most of other dads' are in their late 30s all the way to early 50s. Yet I do feel I'm making a difference, especially considering that I'm Italian (high longevity + few children). I've been also inspired by my choices of parenthood by the movie IDIOCRACY:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBvIweCIgwk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBvIweCIgwk I was delighted when I red in the Elon Musk biography that he had also saw the movie and that was also one of the reasons for being a parent of multiple kids.
- whatshisface 5y ago>Macron moved down the compulsory school age start from 6 (primary school) down to 3 (kindergarten). Governments should help families by providing easier access to daycares and kindergartens. How is compulsory use easier access?
- rbanffy 5y agoBecause now government know exactly how many kids it has to fund daycare for and where the facilities should be. I’d even go as far as parental leave should be completely covered until there is government provided daycare, so as the decision to have kids doesn’t carry too much of an economic burden.
- lvass 5y agoDisheartening to see software people praising removal of options using among all things incompetence as justification.
- 5y ago
- Glyptodon 5y agoIn a sort of backwards way, it's almost like people in their 30s need to be offered a secure mini-retirement to feel like it's reasonable to have kids. (Not to mention housing being a pain.)
- rbanffy 5y agoKids are frighteningly expensive. If I had none, I’d live in a bigger house, have more free time and would be much more free to move to pursue better opportunities than I am now. In many places your first consideration when looking for a house is which school your kids are going to.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI explain it to people of reproductive age as such: Kids cost roughly $270k (2022 inflation adjusted from earlier USDA data) to raise from birth to 18. Each child. Can you afford a Supercar or a fancy boat? If not, how can you afford a kid? And more than one? Good. Luck.
- digisign 5y agoCould probably afford one with a 18 year installment plan. ;-) Also, hand-me-downs.
- eigen 5y ago> Kids cost roughly $270k (2022 inflation adjusted from earlier USDA data) to raise from birth to 18. Each child. Can you afford a Supercar or a fancy boat? If not, how can you afford a kid? an 18 year auto loan sounds like a bad idea. but $15k (nominal) per year is less than state university tuition.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoBack out from current housing, healthcare, food, fuel and other non discretionary costs to what wage/income you’d need to be in the black including the cost of children. Last I checked, the math doesn’t pencil out until you’re hitting ~$50k-$60k/year, a bit below median income ($67k/year), and you’re cutting it really close. Reasoning from first principles is depressing sometimes. https://www.zippia.com/research/should-i-have-a-baby/ https://www.zippia.com/research/should-i-have-a-baby/
- DangitBobby 5y agoWarning: whining ahead. What are countries really doing to promote "fertility"? The impression we get is that it's difficult, tiresome, thankless, expensive, and opens you up to systemic abuse from schools (especially pre-schools and post-secondary education), healthcare providers, and various other institutions designed to suck money from your pockets. You get to live isolated in single-family single-generation households with little to no help from family and friends; the only help you get is what you can pay for. Anything that goes wrong is Your Fault. And no one cares if you are struggling. It's Your Fault for choosing to have children. Why should your elite hyper-intelligent childless megabrain coworkers take on any burden to accommodate your needs? Children are a luxury, after all. Isn't it a wonder why we can't get fertility rates up?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- polski-g 5y agoWestern governments attempting to raise birth rates are like fat people trying to lose weight: "We've tried nothing and it didn't work!"
- bwanab 5y agoWhile I found things to like in the article, the comparison to ‘Children of Men’ is very strained. In the book women couldn’t get pregnant for unspecified reasons, but they desperately wanted to. The world the article refers to is one in which people choose not to have children generally for economic reasons.
- hedgehog 5y agoI'm not sure the two motivations are that different in effect. If you can't have kids for medical reasons vs you can't because it's ruinously expensive what really is the difference?
- unmole 5y ago> you can't because it's ruinously expensive Crudely speaking, birth rates in poor countries are higher than in rich countries. An within countries, birth rates amongst the poor tend to be higher than the rich.
- hedgehog 5y agoA country having high GDP or personal income doesn't mean that things like housing, healthcare, childcare, or education are more affordable. For things like that where the buyer tends to have low leverage in the transaction costs tend to climb with ability to pay. In countries with strong lending infrastructure that goes past the limits of cash and into what buyers can borrow. This decomposes to local communities too, in my city incomes are high relative to most of the US but cost of labor and all of the above services are also expensive. Median household income isn't enough to afford a 3 bedroom place to live so you can imagine that's causing some problems.
- kelnos 5y agoThat's not really the point the parent is making. People who are infertile do not bear children, period. People who are poor often do have children, and in greater numbers, due to a variety of factors. The fact that they have trouble supporting those children is besides the point. The children are still born. This is where the Children of Men analogy gets a bit strained. Today, fewer people have children because fewer people want to, not because they're biologically unable.
- nickdothutton 5y agoThe West has already made its choice. We have chosen to do nothing about declining birth rates among the native population and have instead chosen to supplement the population with immigration from developing nations, or whatever term you wish to use for those countries where birth rates are still high. The numbers are plain to see. Where once an extended family was the norm (it takes a village…) now families are atomised. 2 parent or increasingly 1 parent families. Even when an extended family exists (grandparents are still alive, everyone is still married and on friendly terms) it is common for people to move to where the work is. This may be many minutes or hours away from the new offspring.
- Server6 5y agoThere really isn't much of a choice, and even then it's not a long term solution. From the article: "Morland talks of the trilemma facing ageing nations, whereby you can have two of the three: ethnic continuity, a thriving economy or a comfortable lifestyle without the huge stress of mixing child-raising and a modern economy. Israel has sacrificed the latter, Japan has chosen to take the economic hit, while Britain’s leaders have given up its ethnic continuity. But that, alas, was a short-term solution, since young immigrants don’t magically avoid the fate of Father Time any more than the rest of us do."
- ir123 5y agoWhat's wrong with immigration as a solution to birth rates
- ffwszgf 5y agoIn homogenous societies like japan, Sweden, and Denmark it usually leads to a lot of ethnic contradictions once the immigrant population passes a certain threshold. Once has to wonder whether it’s healthy when more than 50% of your population feels alienated by the country and often has more loyalty and love for the homeland he or she fled. The immigration system of most European countries is also very broken. More than 60% of immigrants to France don’t even have a high school education and gun crime in Sweden is now among the highest in Europe (despite being the lowest in the 90s) due to Somali gangs. People are tribal and not every country was birthed as a “melting pot” like the US or Canada. These days the words integration and assimilation are considered racist when talking about immigrants so societies in these countries will simply further polarize.
- pasabagi 5y agoMy gut feeling is that there's a strong correlation between rent prices and fertility rates. You can't have kids if you can't work out where to put them. That said, I'm generally quite relaxed about the population trend: the 18th and 19th century had ballooning populations in Europe, and collapsing populations everywhere else. I don't think it's going to get to the point where there are serious overpopulation problems in the global south - at least, nowhere near what we already have in Europe.
- nikanj 5y agoThe opposite is also true: you’re competing for housing with childless people, who can afford higher rents. Less kids=more disposable income=higher tolerance for rent increases
- Server6 5y agoThis article actually addresses this, and is one component of the larger problem: "Older people tend to vote for their own self-interests, and in the case of Britain, end up controlling the government in power; voters with pensions and homes opt for lower growth and restricted housebuilding, further raising the cost of home ownership for the young and so pushing down the fertility rate still further. If we’re playing a generational blame game for the lack of children…"
- YorkshireSeason 5y ago> strong correlation between rent prices and fertility rates. I assume you mean a positive correlation. When the Soviet Union collapsed, many of the former Eastern Block countries experienced both, a reduction in fertility and too much housing. The latter because so many left for the west. So many buildings were empty that quite a bit of housing stock was removed, see e.g. [1]. [1] https://www.eisenhuettenstadt.de/Leben-Wohnen/Wohnen-und-Bauen/Stadtentwicklung/Stadtumbau/R%C3%BCckbau/ https://www.eisenhuettenstadt.de/Leben-Wohnen/Wohnen-und-Bau...
- marvin 5y agoI agree with your gut feeling, and I disagree quite strongly with most of the sentiment found in the comments of this article, stating that the lack of children stems from selfishness or responsibility towards the planet. High rents and other features of contemporary society make it difficult and expensive to have children. These things also make it difficult to get enough time for children, with the amount of income-generating work that's required. Then, most of the care is offloaded to professional caretakers, as this gives a significant improvement to the budgets of time and money. My suspicion is that many who state that they skip kids due to the environment or personal reasons, actually just need a fig leaf to cover the fact that they're financially unable to support kids while maintaining a lifestyle that makes children net positive for their own quality of life. For most, this would be a pretty painful admission to make, but there's plenty of observations indicating it's true for many. In contrast to most people here, I believe that this is actually a pretty big problem. It's not as bad as having a birthrate of 4 and sprinting into a demographic catastrophe, but economic growth in the sense of making all aspects of life better and cheaper is critical if we want to make civilization sustainable. Balanced demographics and kids raised with love, care, plenty and care from capable parents are a very important part of that. This is one of the things I actually believe the conservatives get right.
- yobbo 5y ago> they must shudder at the thought that in the average week the country loses another 2,000 through population decline Anecdotally, it seems a surprising number of these young men are already fathers (of children they could barely support). Furthermore, there is a male surplus built into birth rates, and the number of men is not the limiting factor in population growth. It's quite obvious the reason is economic. Establishing healthy families is really difficult. > that there is almost no civil war in countries where 55 per cent or more of the population is aged over thirty.’ Correlation, not causation.
- rbanffy 5y agoThe articles hint at some strong factors for causation.
- mulmen 5y ago> ‘While it cannot be said that youthfulness “causes” war,’ he writes, ‘or that maturity “causes” peace, a society’s age structure creates background conditions against which other things either do or don’t spark conflict.’ Literally the next sentence.
- sudo_rm 5y ago> ‘While it cannot be said that youthfulness “causes” war,’ he writes, ‘or that maturity “causes” peace...
- Flatcircle 5y agoWhat consequences will this have for real estate?
- paulcole 5y agoMany people who bought a house in their 30s thinking they’re going to flip it in 30 years for 4x their purchase price are going to be in for a surprise.
- ruaraidh 5y agoOh no, a trend! I bet it carries on forever no matter what!!
- tgv 5y agoBirth rates have been declining in the West since the late 1950s/early 1960s. Of course it won't carry on forever, because there is a point where you must have children in order to survive. And survive is what people do best.
- Teever 5y agoI'm not too worried. Just like how mRNA vaccines were a technology that was mostly ready for prime-time and was just waiting for a pressing scenario I think that artificial wombs are mostly a solved problem and are the solution to this situation. I think that the development of artificial wombs with a dash of genetic customization will lead to a new baby boom in the next 10-20 years.
- bjourne 5y agoThe high fertility rate in Israel is almost entirely due to the country's Haredi ultra-Orthodox Jews. Among them women are tightly controlled, abortion is murder and birth control is taboo. Consequently, the average fertility rate per woman is 7.1. That's one way of solving the fertility crisis, but perhaps not a good one.
- tsol 5y ago>Among them women are tightly controlled, What does this actually mean? You say this like women have no agency. They may not follow a typical set of rules, but to reduce their choices to 'the result of being tightly controlled' is very insulting. There are actual reasons many of these communities intentionally have many children
- bjourne 5y agoIt's not either or. People who grow up in fundamentalist communities may have their own agency but still be tightly controlled.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThere's also the matter of the government paying them welfare, permanently, to engage in religious studies. Israel is barreling toward religious extremism.
- ffwszgf 5y agoThats a feature, not a bug. Israel will probably become the first democratic country were “outbreed them” was a successful political strategy. The ultra orthodox are a solid voting block That currenty controls 15 out of the 120 seats in the Knesset. they almost always align with the far-right religious zionists or the right-wing Likud. Right wing governments encourage their growth while working to decrease that of Muslims. And it has worked very well. The Israeli left, which dominated politics until the 80s has been decimated since their voter base is not having children. The country is going right, fast. The ultra-orthodox also secure the Jewish majority in Jerusalem and Israel, an added bonus.
- sharadov 5y agoOlder men declare war, but it is the youth that must fight and die.
- nine_zeros 5y agoAt least for me and my spouse, we need stability. It is impossible to raise 2 children when you know you are going to be a slave to the bank for 30 years and have no guarantees of job and healthcare. If healthcare alone would have been taken care of, we might have considered 2 kids. But for now, I hesitate to have even 1.
- brewtide 5y agoIt's not impossible to raise children in these conditions. I just turned 40 and have an 8 1/2 and 6 1/2 year old in the living room next to me reading books to each other. There are 2 of them, and one of me. I am 'enslaved' to the bank for the next 20 something years. I am self-employed in the trades. I have very solid foundation in fixing and building things, which seems to survive many economic downturns as things that are needed to be done, are needed to be done regardless if a booming market or not - You just may face a bit more competition at that point. Not ranting against you, or picking on your decisioning - Obviously it is a super-personal choice, and I'm glad thoughts have been put in place about many factors involved. That being said, I've heard "I'm going to wait until I am 100% fully stable and secure to do **" my entire life. While I will agree that there are certain conditions and 'times of lives' that are extremely bad* ideas to do large things, especially when it comes into involving other dependents, I really don't think 100% stability is ever achievable. You or your significant other could be taken out by a car tomorrow, or be caught in a fire, or even hit by lightening. Obviously I had my first child when I was in the lower 30's -- for me, I'm finding this to be a very nice timeframe that worked in my life. I was far less stable than I am now, in the conventional sense of having a savings account, or owning a house, and I've managed to both purchase a house, and while hardly rich by any conventional notions of the world, when the car(s) break, or the house needs a roof, I am able to have those things done by either paying $ outright, or using prior life skills to offset the labor charges of those things making them more financially easier to swallow. My point is, now I am 40. They are still pretty little, and yeah, children require an insane amount of work and energy input to not only 'maintain', but 120% of what you have to offer to really enjoy the experience. I, personally, wouldn't want to be any older than I am now while having children at the ages they are - Advil is frequently consumed by now, part of growing up rolling around on a skateboard, part doing manual trades for (most) of my working life thus far, and part just being 40 and out of the 'Spring Chicken' age. Time goes by, and with it, we get older. There is no way of changing that. The other factors in modern life, the money, the housing, the 'stability' can ebb and flow both by actions of your own and by actions too varied to even account for -- But time goes one direction. I wish you the best, and strongly suggest if you want to have a child, and it's not 'the worst time possible' to do as such (drug addictions, homeless, uh, similar things) then perhaps ditch some of the fear of 'stability' (that truly very few have; none if you acknowledge life can end at any time for any of us) and get to doing the living! Hard times happen to many; Even us single parent folk (and yeah, it makes things a bit harder, that's for sure) but I can promise you, if you care and you're willing to put the effort in, boy, it's worth it!
- sometimeshuman 5y agoRelated, a few months ago Dr. Brickell provided a fascinating discussion about this topic.[1] A minor note, when I was in Japan I heard the term obachan as mildly derogatory slang for old people (e.g., the old lady who throws elbows if you are in her way). I hadn't heard of the similar term rougai referenced in this article. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNqCRvDbCVI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNqCRvDbCVI
- alexklark 5y agoIt fun how golden billion’s boomers, after grabbing whole planet wealth and creating a globalised totalitarian system to brainwash its own people and squeeze resources from peripheral nations are now expect less violent and calm future with new kids playing on streets (among 7 usd/hour workers who can only repay out 2 meters of lands they presumablyown.
- ed_balls 5y agoI think there will be more war. In the future wars will be fought with drones - you don't sacrifice many young people. One could make an argument that fertility rate of 1.8 is a good thing. There is a better control of the labour market using immigration. Automation won't hurt that much.
- mwattsun 5y agoThis is why I'm flabbergasted by people who oppose immigration to the United States. We are lucky to be a country that young people want to move to. Additionally, I've road tripped 100k miles all over North America. One surprising thing was just how empty the place is, especially the Western US of course, but also places like Western Pennsylvania. Outside the major cities, the US is sparsely populated. I know it doesn't feel that way to people living in major metro areas or at least it didn't to me until I drove around and had a look.
- chmod600 5y agoDesire for immigration doesn't imply that you want completely uncontrolled immigration. Maybe you want to bring in mostly educated non-criminals? Or mostly people who generally agree with the governing philosophy and our notion of freedom, so that it might not be voted away?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYou realize that most of those areas don't have enough water to support large populations don't you? And it's getting worse as the west is currently experiencing a drought that could last a century or more given historical precedence and the added complications of climate change.
- duped 5y agoYou shouldn't be flabbergasted, racism isn't new or surprising in America.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoRacism is everywhere, don't act like it's unique to the USA.
- nnnnnande 5y agoStrange take. Saying that racism is not new in the US (because the discussion was about the US) is not the same thing as saying that racism is a uniquely US problem.
- qqtt 5y agoDeveloped societies seem to be shifting into a more "selfish" paradigm, where the question of the day is "what can this situation really do for me?". Day to day actions are framed in these terms, and the result is that raising children becomes a harder and harder question to justify in this paradigm. Even in this thread, having kids is seen through this odd eugenics-style paradigm of - well, I have to counteract the balance of idiocracy style effects and have a responsibility to carry on my family's genetic material. Children are expensive. Children take away a lot of your otherwise "free" time (although spending time with them can hardly be considered an objective "waste"). Grandparents don't want to put in the time either, they want to go on cruises and fully "enjoy" their life (along the paradigm of "what can this really do for me?"). Ultimately we end up with parents who want to offload their kids, stuffing them into (expensive) daycares earlier and earlier (despite what research says are negative effects of such early child separation). We have lost the traditional support system of older generations being around, living with new parents, and helping in a meaningful and impactful way with child raising. We have prioritized large inefficient housing, mostly as an investment vehicle, and have discounted the less economically-linked investment and rewards that come from raising children. In any case, this is a perfect storm for dropping fertility rates, and it seems at this point these factors are so ingrained in developed economies that it can be considered a natural consequence of a population who has pivoted towards wealth building and economic priority. Despite this shift towards selfish economic efficiency, is anyone really happier? Really really tough to say. I can say that despite the cost, the career impact it had, and the completely changed dynamic of how I spend my time - raising kids has been the highlight of my life. I've never really been one for considering pure economic and personal efficiency though, and I've noticed I'm more and more of an outlier among my social circle.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Developed societies seem to be shifting into a more "selfish" paradigm, where the question of the day is "what can this situation really do for me?" I think that's not well supported as the source of the problem, even to the extent it may arguably be true: developed societies tend to have adopted strong social support mechanism, so that having lots of kids so that you have a chance that someone will be willing to support you in your old age is no longer necessary. That's also why some very rich countries are seeing less of the dropoff in natural population growth for their level of development; they also happen to be the ones with weaker social support systems.
- mtgx 5y ago
- Isamu 5y ago“Britain Stands Alone”
- stakkur 5y agoNo, it's not. 'Children of Men' is about infertility; this article is about voluntary population decline (people choosing to have fewer children, an entire subject on its own). This is a bit of clickbait, of course.
- hotpotamus 5y agoThe reality seems grimmer than a post apocalyptic movie then - in that imagined future, there is no choice; in actual reality, it seems that individuals have chosen not to reproduce in spite of having the biological ability to do so.
- almog 5y agoIt is more than just a click bait, to me it reads as a deliberate attempt to draw a conclusion that a decreased population size in certain countries is linked to biological fertility. Really it is but a step away from reading like some Alex Jones crazy talking and selling bone broth.
- yc-kraln 5y agoReading the article through and through, it seems that it is a given that the world's currently huge population should not be allowed to shrink, for the good of the economy. This is an .. amazingly shortsighted take, especially when taking into consideration the resource (over-)utilization and flat-out exploitative extraction which was required just to get us this far. 1/13 of all people that have ever lived are alive right now. Maybe--just maybe--it's a good thing that the world's population will shrink over the coming decades, and quite possibly we need to disconnect our economies from unbounded growth while we're at it.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYeah there are enough humans. We will reach an equilibrium point. Right now that looks to be between 8 and 10 billion and that's a hell of a lot of people on a increasling resource limited planet.
- rwmj 5y agoThis was also my main problem with the article (I submitted it!). However this does raise the issue that we haven't found the economic model which allows population to age/decline while maintaining living standards. I guess the answer is going to be "robots".
- brightball 5y agoHonestly, the model where families stayed together longer and aging parents lived with their kids as they got older is probably the closest thing to sustainable out there. The alternative is going to be a huge amount of caretaking career opportunities.
- robjan 5y agoI don't know if that is the answer either. I live in a society where kids are duty bound to provide care for their parents and grandparents as they age. The result is many single people pushing into their thirties who never got to live their own life. When their parents pass they risk living a life devoid of meaning and with nobody to look after themselves.
- sitkack 5y agoThis is excellent news! We are already over the carrying capacity for the Earth. We just have to figure out how to structure our economies. "fixing" fertility is fixing the wrong problem.
- rsync 5y agoThese demographic figures - both their severity and their broad, global reach - are why I believe deflation and not inflation is what we should expect from our economies. I don't doubt that in the near term all manner of inflationary paroxysms will be employed in a desperate attempt to stave off this inevitable result ... but the big picture, globally, is deflation.
- nickpeterson 5y agoThey can dress it up however they want, but we used to have a world where women would stay home with children and teach them life skills and a near army of moms available to keep an eye on neighborhoods. Now we have both parents working full time and side hustles while their kids play Roblox. We have so many problems and a system (in the US) that just seems bought and paid. I’m starting to think my time would be better spent trying to raise a small army than spend time fighting this system from the inside.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- russellbeattie 5y agoThere's hyperbole and then there's the idea that 7,000 deaths - or even 10 times that amount - is going to have any permanent effect on a population of 145,000,000 people. There are 785,000 18 year old males alone in Russia. There are 748,000 17 year olds. They could lose all the 18 year olds and replace them next year. I understand there is a real discussion to be had about population growth and Russia as a whole. But the basic premise is a bit exaggerated.
- OtomotO 5y agoIt's the time and age of antinatalists. ;)
- cercatrova 5y agoChildren are expensive and take time to raise. It's no wonder that much of the world asks "why even have kids," where being childfree is positively correlated with increases in education and income. As the world population gets more educated, I don't really see this trend reversing. Even if people were given free healthcare, pre/post-natal care, childcare, etc, I doubt this would incentivize enough people to have enough kids, as the money and time required to raise kids still does not change. If you really want to get into unethical ways to increase the birth rate, you would ban abortions (which China seems to be toying with [0]) and provide no sex education, effectively forcing people to have children. I wonder if we'll see more countries push towards something like that as the birth rate continues to decline. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_China#cite_note-auto2-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_China#cite_note-au...
- yung234 5y agoA problem that will solve itself. Since parental preference is now the primary determinant of family size it will come under Nature's lens. There will be huge negative selection pressure exerted against non-breeders and their genes will be swept out of the gene pool en masse. Fertility will recover, likely within less than 10 generations or 300 years and we will be back to growth - and to ravaging the planet like never before.
- 54534534 5y ago[dead]
- alangibson 5y agoI often recall a quote, the author of which I've forgotten, when I read about population decline. "There were around 1B people in 1900, and few would say the world was empty back then." No doubt it will be a hard adjustment, but those that are around could enjoy a better quality of life than we do as long as you don't define quality as 'inexpensive junk'. More natural resources and open space per capita is pretty nice in itself.
- leke 5y agoRussia will then have the opportunity to welcome the climate refugees in the next 10 years. I think Russia will be more temperate and there will be opportunity for lots of farming work.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoIts not Children of Men thats happening, its Elysium (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIBtePb-dGY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIBtePb-dGY). Nobody wants to go backwards in terms of tech, creature comforts and things like that so you wont see people returning to farm the land and live off the land like you used to see just a hundred years ago. Everyone here is almost certainly playing their part in building the future and that means less people are needed on the planet. Brains appears to be beating brawn, which is why you get paid high wages.
- daoismyname 5y ago> I reflected on why the referendum had become a footnote in history rather than the trigger for violent conflict Because all the propaganda around catalan independence is bullshit. It gas nothing to do with gray hair, which, BTW, are mostly tourists, mostly from UK, people that can afford to travel in autumn and that don't enjoy the same climate, if not much better, of catalonia at their homes (or if they can afford to travel go somewhere else, because they are not old!) https://www.thenewfederalist.eu/i-have-never-supported-catalan-independence-here-s-why https://www.thenewfederalist.eu/i-have-never-supported-catal...
- t0bia_s 5y agoI'm glad the author mention Czech Republic. We have baby boom here. Well lockdowns affect births quite a lot a guess. I personally know about ten families with 2-3 children (oldest 5y) that are our close friends and we meet regularly. We are able to make home kindergartens quite easily (many parents prefer it over regular kindergartens with nonsense covid restrictions). Our gonverment supports mothers financialy 4 years if you choose lower monthly pays. Usually it is 30 months. Also we are quite ignorant to trends like "having children is not ecological" or "there are more than 2 genders" or "same rights for same sex couples". At the end it doesn't matter. Those ideologies just support death, no life and eventually die with time. Which is exactly the problem that is described in article.
- cyberpunk 5y agoIt's much the same in Germany. We get similar benefits (well, for the mother) and the other points are largely non-issues. Not much to complain about.
- mabbo 5y agoRight now, having children is a nightmare financially. Most of my friends simply can't afford it, and are wise enough not to. If the government wants to avoid disaster, they need to make changes to fix this reality. Example: add a k% tax on everyone, and a x% tax reduction per child you are the legal guardian of, up to y children. Use the money raised to subsidize day cares, public schools, etc. Make the idea of having a kid less awful and people will do it. (That wasn't meant to be a double-entendre but I'll take it).
- 1e-9 5y agoHumans have an instinctive drive to optimize genetic survival. Without it, we would not exist. One of the control mechanisms for this is our instinct for reproduction. We constantly access future availability of resources, attractiveness to high quality mates, and probability of a new child surviving to bear children of their own with high quality mates. The industrial revolution, with its massive increase in productivity and technological advancement, dramatically altered the survival cost function that humans must now optimize. A measly 200 years has not been enough time for our instinctual optimization algorithm to adapt. As a result, I believe we are seeing over-compensation for higher resources and lower mortality, which is most apparent in countries with the highest per-capita GDP (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate#/media/File:CIA_WFB_TotFertilityRate-GDP-Population_-_Simplified_2016.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate#/media/Fi...) where parents are over-delaying childbirth because they perceive an opportunity to improve their economic standing, improve their mate selection, and take better care of a smaller number of children. We even see this happening with immigrants from low-GDP countries who move to high-GDP countries and converge towards the lower fertility rate of their new country. I expect we will eventually adapt, but it will likely require a conscious override of instinct if we want to avoid a massive population decline in the process.
- bondolo 5y agoI remember something I read from the 1970s which suggested that the Earth’s carrying capacity was about 2.1 billion. That number of humans could be sustained indefinitely. Going higher than that would result in environmental degradation that would reduce the carrying capacity. We are now at that point and the population will go higher in spite of the the low birth rates. Every day we diminish the environment and de-terraform the Earth. I am fine with the population declining naturally over time. I wish the Western countries could do more to absorb additional immigrants. This would have a positive effect for their own aging demographics but also worldwide as money flows to home countries. I will probably die about the time population reaches the peak. I have always felt that that peak will be a difficult time because of poverty and demographics. Nothing we are doing now is preparing well for that time.
- thayne 5y agoI would argue that increasing the retirement age is in the best interest of the aging population. Because if too much of the population is retired, then there won't be enough workers to provide the goods and services for those retired people.
- screye 5y agoThe developed world seems to be trapped in cultural values that are incompatible with children. Emergent culture is downstream from incentives, and the incentives are all wrong. The west broke the entire 'family' equation by nationalizating elder care (social welfare, retirement homes) and introducing the concept of a nuclear family. People still spend the same on elder care (in taxes instead of in person), but without any personal connection to those they contribute to. Children = retirement was a big part of the incentive. Kids took care of you once you reached 60. The last 20-30 years of your life were glorious. "Respect your elders" meant that you get served food, chauffeured around and enjoy being an angel in the eyes of your grandkids. This same thing made being a parent easier, because the grand parents helped out. Moving away from this has made being a parent harder and worsened the long term incentives. American infrastructure and the 'nuclear-ness' of upbringing also plays a role. It forces parents to invest an insane number for hours into their kids for even the most basic shit. The soccer mom meme is a direct result of unsustainably built suburbs and separation of responsibility. I grew up in dense communities, where all my friends lived within a 5 minutes walk from my house. I didn't even need to leave my building. The playgrounds were within eyesight of at least 1 parent, who would periodically peek to make sure the kids were still there. This allowed my parents to leave us unsupervised at a much younger age. The elder kids would walk the younger kids home from school. Younger grandparents were happy to be babysitters for kids from the entire community for free. Moving away from wide-social-webs and towards nuclear units has destroyed all of this. This put burden of parenting entirely on the shoulders of 2 (sometimes single) working parents who're working more than 40 hr/each. Ofc having children sounds unappealing. Then there are the impossibly high standards of being a parent as portrayed in the western media (especially educated circles). Your job as a parent is to make sure your child doesn't become a total loser. That's it. Anything more is extra. Kids are expensive because every parent is expected push their child into Harvard. Let kids be kids, most of them are going to have mediocre careers and no amount effort is going to change that fact. Today, other people's children as seen as 'their burden'. Society needs to start seeing children as the total societal advantage that they are. The young are the ones who do the heavy lifting and keep the $$ coming for an economy. Their taxes subsidize the lifestyles of the old. They create new art and media that most amazes us. They are an endless source of optimism and liberal (in terms of being liberated), unlike the cynical and conversative (in a sort of jaded failure averse resignation) ways of the old. Not everyone enjoys being a parent, but a majority enjoy being the cool uncle/aunt. At a societal level, children bring joy that is obvious to everyone who chooses to look. But, as long as we encourage the 'everyone outside my tiny circle of concern is a chore' mentality borne from nuclear thought, the incentives will continue to discourage tolerating children in society as a whole.