5 ms·
Thing is if people start hoarding medicine then new companies can pop up and fill in the gap, or existing ones can increase production, making the whole thing p
by paxys 5y ago
Thing is if people start hoarding medicine then new companies can pop up and fill in the gap, or existing ones can increase production, making the whole thing pointless to do. Same goes for every other "necessary to life" product. Temporary disruptions will be handled by the market in the long term, and in the worst case government can step in and regulate. Housing is probably the only sector where all the laws and regulations work the other way – to actively stop you from building more of something that everyone needs.
- andrepd 5y ago>Temporary disruptions will be handled by the market in the long term This is the sort of gospel/dogma that free market absolutists like to propagate, but plainly reality proves this wrong. Markets are a tool, but not a universally useful one.
- darkerside 5y agoNot so plain to the rest of us. Can you explain what makes this so evident?
- tshaddox 5y agoOkay, but how deep is the appetite for buying medicine as collectibles? What if doubling the production of medicine just means that now the wealthiest 2% collects all the medicine instead of the wealthiest 1%? Not to mention, how long will it take to ramp up all this medicine production?
- mistrial9 5y agono, no - this is a real-estate Zillow thread BUT.. search for "pharma bros" and you will see this is not a fanciful example
- briHass 5y agoYeah, but much like housing shortages, the classic cases of 'pharma bros' (Shkreli, et. al) is due in large part to the government. He, specifically, was able to jack prices because his company owned the patents (gov issued and controlled) and manufacturing license (gov issued) to rare but important drugs.
- cma 5y ago> Housing is probably the only sector where all the laws and regulations work the other way – to actively stop you from building more of something that everyone needs. The patent system does this in medicine.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe patent system does that everywhere. That's its purpose. The FDA does it in medicine.
- jjav 5y ago> Thing is if people start hoarding medicine then new companies can pop up and fill in the gap, or existing ones can increase production, making the whole thing pointless to do. Hoarding medicine isn't a trend and even so, this market correction doesn't happen. Look at all the medicines with insanely high prices because there won't be any competition.
- chii 5y agoSome medicines are high price because of market intervention by gov't (or regulatory capture) - like epi-pens. Some medicines are high priced because noone really needs it, and the few remaining bear the brunt of the cost (or society subsidize the cost via taxation). How come aspirin or penicillin isn't expensive? They are more commonly used, and so if the hoarding method works, it would've been even more profitable!
- tempestn 5y agoHow come insulin is expensive?
- 3np 5y agoThis is missing the point that land is a finite resource and homes aren't fungible. It doesn't help most Californians that more homes can be built in rural Arkansas.
- pj_mukh 5y agoLand is a finite resource but housing units are not. Once America gets over it’s love affair with single family homes, we could undercut most speculators by just building up.
- tmp_anon_22 5y agoSingle Family homes have the benefit of more autonomy where as building up means you're living on-top of your neighbor, its not binary but we should acknowledge the clear QoL tradeoffs of condensed living. Maybe its inevitable and necessary to force more people into condensed housing, maybe the societal benefits really outweigh the tradeoffs.
- davidw 5y agoNo one's "forcing" anything. Legalize the housing, and if no one wants it, it won't be built. The problem is that it's not legal in so many places.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- greesil 5y agoThe invisible hand is sometimes a fist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chii 5y ago> clear QoL tradeoffs of condensed living. and that's why single family homes should be more expensive, because it is better. People continue to bid it up, because they still believe that the price is worth and hasn't reached a ceiling yet. In asian hubs like hong kong or shanghai, they've reached a certain ceiling on land, and so building up is now what most people could buy and so they do that. The cities in countries like canada, australia and the west coast of the US, it hasn't reached that point due to large available land mass, and people prefer commute (or WFH now!) over living densely. Of course, regulation plays a part - i think there's unnecessarily large amount of red tape in making taller denser buildings, as well as a lobby of existing owners who don't want it near themselves.
- pandemicsoul 5y ago"Thing is if people start hoarding medicine then new companies can pop up and fill in the gap" That's not how the market works. That's not how patents work. That's not how medicine works. That's not how any of this works.