12 ms·
Kharkiv Rubyist during the war: We are still here
- redwood 5y agoIt is amazing how this inspiring willingness to fight for the bare essentials that the West has for so long forgotten the need to be ready to be fight for has transformed the West and given it meaning again. Reminds me of Leo Strauss, a philosopher often cited by the neoconservatives and therefore of course dismissed by most of us but I think there's more nuance in his understanding of the world and this feels to me like a very Straussian moment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_Strauss https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_Strauss You are amazing, Ukraine! Fighting for freedom of thought in a world still half led by visions of totalitarianism. Visions that were not shed decades ago as we falsely believed.
- toyg 5y ago> Visions that were not shed decades ago as we falsely believed. Who is "we" exactly...? Because the GWB presidency was very much an embodiment of such a vision, and it was only stopped by a literal hurricane.
- redwood 5y agoIt's interesting to me to hear you say that. I would say that about Trump but not GWB in hindsight. At that time I was of the opinion you share and I remember feeling that GWB was essentially everything that was bad in the world… but in hindsight I realize how narrowly scoped my vision was and the spectrum is so much bigger and in fact I now believe it's important to be willing to find common ground with conservatives who at least believe in the free world. Trump I genuinely do not believe believed in the free world and the rule of law and in the value of our institutions
- ethbr0 5y agoAs someone probably of similar age to you, my views on GWB have definitely changed as I've aged. When I was younger, I actively protested, saw his presidency as the antithesis of my values, etc. At my current age, I believe more that there is no pure "good" in the world. What is good in one way, is by definition tinged with evil in others. And that pursuing one good requires doing (or at least allowing) some evil. And that what's probably most important is being honest about the evils you do, in pursuits of your goods, and constantly re-weighing the balance on your moral scales. Biden abhors war and the employment of US offensive military power. That is a good. But it creates evil by providing space for unresponded-to aggression. Shipping weapons to Ukraine to defend its sovereign territory is also a good. But it creates evil by escalating battlefield lethality and depending on the service (and often sacrifice) of brave Ukrainians. The real world sucks, and there should be no easy answers that let us sleep soundly at night.
- hnhg 5y agoIt seems to me more like Arendt's banality of evil is mostly at work (in many cases, anyway. There are certainly some people on this planet who I would say are truly evil but they are relatively uncommon): https://aeon.co/ideas/what-did-hannah-arendt-really-mean-by-the-banality-of-evil https://aeon.co/ideas/what-did-hannah-arendt-really-mean-by-...
- notafraudster 5y agoMy own views sort of shifted but not in the same way. I was 17 when the War in Iraq started. My view at the time was of very skeptical support; having lived through the 90s I had an engrained view that the world needed to use force to help prevent ethnic cleansing. We didn't intervene early enough or strongly enough in Rwanda, and that particularly bothered me. After the beginning of the war, I pretty quickly became anti-war when it became increasingly clear to me that the pretexts (WMD, Saddam is going to attack the Kurds again) were not justified. I would say by about mid-2004 I was pretty comfortably anti-war. When Bush called for the "surge" I was definitely all the way against the War in Iraq. Today if you asked me what I thought about it, I would say Iraq was the worst and least justified misadventure America embarked on that had some ostensible humanitarian pretext. So I guess my position would be that I still wish we could prevent genocide, but I'm increasingly convinced it's difficult to tell justified reason from pretext in time to intervene, either as a country or as as individuals trying to hold our leaders to account. I guess I would say is that Bush struck me as a person who embodied the way in which misguided motivations could lead to terrible results. But with Trump, there was no misgivings. He had terrible motivations. His view on the use of force was two fold: (1) I don't give a fuck about any other country, why should I? (2) We're number one and I'll blow you up with my bombs. I think it's tempting for many to look at his isolationism as a repudiation of Clinton-Bush-Obama era, but it was a repudiation only of the duty to care about others. His frequent verbal escalations and tactical willingness to disregard collateral damage (in Iraq/Syria), as well as his weird outbursts like threatening to use tactical nuclear weapons, and his constant constant constant remarks expressing praise and respect for violent autocrats justified by admiration of their will to power make it clear that he was just as willing to use force, just as militaristic, just for somehow even worse reasons. I am very thankfully that none of the bubbling tensions ever came to a true head under him.
- cik2e 5y agoToo many people have let their vision become consumed by the fact that Trump was an insufferable asshole. A nuanced discussion can be had about his time in office and his actual actions, without giving undue weight to the shit that comes out of the man's mouth. Just as an example of something most democrats would applaud, he signed an executive order to keep federal unemployment assistance flowing, while congress was happy to keep bickering and holding millions of Americans hostage. I'm not trying to break down the man's presidency here, but I would say that this provided more good to the average American, in a time of great need, than anything any recent president had done. I do feel compelled to mention the following in regard to the comparison with Bush. The man, Cheney's puppet as he was, started an illegal war that killed a few hundred thousand people. Using the intelligence apparatus to manipulate Congress and the American people, in my view, is much worse than anything Trump had done. Same with enabling the domestic spying apparatus with the Patriot Act. If that's not undermining our institutions, I don't know what is. I guess I should preempt the obvious counter argument about Trump's allegation that the election was stolen. The Democrats did the same exact thing with Russiagate. Both in terms of the accusation and pursuing it through legal channels, all based on fictional evidence to boot. We should not allow us to miss the bigger picture while falling for the manufacrured distraction of "my party vs their party." But rather look to understand the special interests that are amplifying our division, and benefitting from it.
- dc-programmer 5y agoI think it’s too soon to make an assessment. Trump spent his whole presidency casting aspersions on NATO, and tried to cut defense aid to Ukraine. If this situation escalates further, he may be viewed as a James Buchanan figure. And I do think things may get worse. Currently a sovereign country is being invaded and civilians are being targeted. The second order effects might be even worse * If Russia pulls resources from Syria then the civil war might come to a head. The regime leans heavily on Russian air support * Russian paramilitary provides defense for unpopular governments like Tanzania’s. If they got pulled these countries might go into civil war * Ukraine and Russia are two of the worlds largest exporters of grain. Countries like Egypt are big importers (Egypt actually subsidizes the purchases heavily). If grain costs go up (and other commodities like oil) this could cause unrest * Nuclear war * Cyber war targeting key infrastructure. The possibility of massive collateral damage is high (see Not Petya) Some of these things are not intrinsically bad (I have no love for despotic governments for example) but the potential sum total of events could throw the world into chaos. The War on Terror was a massive mistake. America needs to keep the crazy evangelicals who want to bring on the end times by attacking the Middle East far from the oval office. But taking on an isolationist position in response to the 2000’s would be a massive mistake. It’s clearer than ever that power vacuums have to be filled
- psandersen 5y agoNot an American but similar view of GWB. However... I feel leaders should be judged by the direction they tried to move things; and the Bush Administration did not move the USA in a more lawful, democratic and humanistic direction to say the least. There are many steps to move a democracy to a totalitarian state, and the time to hit the breaks is at earliest signs of fascist behavior. Abstractly, the people who excused and weakened institutions may have done more to create an eventual totalitarian state than the asshole who moved the final 1% and seized power.
- baybal2 5y agoGWB's great sin is he gave China, and Russia time. The 15 years USA spent running after imaginary boogeymen sowed the seeds of what we are dealing with today. There are many aspects to this folly, but most bad were: 1. Okaying what Russia, and China were doing 2. Wasting trillions on completely pointless war 3. Squandered overnight the enormous goodwill USA carried from successful 199X 4. Stalled the wheel of democratisation around the world
- octopoc 5y agoYeah it seems like the globalist mindset that much of the west adopted blinded it to the geopolitical realities that still govern international relations. Remember the "Russian reset"[1]? It was a big red button that was supposed to reset Russian relations. Remember when Obama criticized Romney for saying the biggest threat in the future would be Russia? Obama laughed it off because "this isn't the cold war anymore." Remember when Clinton gave China the NAFTA deal? GWB was cut from the same cloth as these other globalist-minded presidents. The western globalist attitude involves giving power to our rivals in the hopes they will become our friends. Guess what...they're still our rivals. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_reset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_reset
- toyg 5y agoThat's a confrontational mindset. In reality, there was a window post-1990 in which we (the US, Europe, China, Russia, India, Pakistan, and the most stable African countries) could have created the means to resolve global conflicts peacefully, or at least in a shared manner. The real victory of Desert Storm wasn't the military annihilation of a regional power in a matter of months, but the fact that it was achieved under a UN mandate. That practice should have become the norm. The major crisis right after (Yugoslavia, the first post-WW2 war in Europe which we try so hard to forget every day) still had some UN legitimacy - NATO acted somewhat unilaterally but it was arguably as protection for a UN peacekeeping operation. The Russians had to follow suit - begrudgingly, but on shared terms. Then 2001 happened and all that strenuous effort to keep powers together was just thrown out of the window, in pursue of simple and pure vengeance - the oldest and most tribalistic instinct for violence, the biblical an-eye-for-an-eye. Even then, there was still a chance to forgive it as a temporary aberration of a young country that had never been seriously attacked on its mainland before. Instead, the US literally decided to conquer Iraq on a whim in 2002/2003. At that point, anybody who had ever seriously considered cooperation had to change course, or lost massive amounts of political capital. Areas that were slowly moving towards softer stances (Iran, China, Russia, etc) predictably reacted by rushing back to the safety of oppositional competition. And now it's what it is. Escalating competition further and further is not the answer, and will lead the world to darker and darker places.
- notsureaboutpg 5y ago
- keybored 5y agoIt would be horrible if this war would end up reinvigorating neoconservative thought or any kind of ideology that sees geopolitics in terms of good vs. evil or ideology1 vs. ideology2 (e.g. freedom vs. totalitarianism).
- redwood 5y agoWhy?
- keybored 5y agoBecause geopolitics cannot be explained by some "clash of values" or good vs. evil conflict. That stuff only happens in fiction.
- redwood 5y agoI see it as a useful simplification. To be more long winded about it is fine but the bottom line is we have to be willing to fight for what we have
- scrose 5y agoOn the topic of helping, does anyone have ideas/tips on how to help refugees attempting to communicate with the embassies in another country for refugee status/assistance? I have extended family from Ukraine that speaks very little English and also can’t communicate in the countries native language that they fled to, but my partner and I cannot call those embassies to help relay information because we’re in the USA and our numbers don’t work. We have a few roundabout ideas to try(ie call the family on WhatsApp and be on speakerphone), but we’re wondering if anyone has experience doing this or knows of any agencies on the ground that are providing help around this?
- dimitar 5y agoLook for established and older Ukrainian diaspora groups in the country in question. Also many of the countries have established portals for refugees. Try to vet any helpers, unfortunately there are criminals that prey on refugees
- komuher 5y agoYou could just contact Polish organization (if they are in Poland) if u want i can link few organizations. Right now we have about 2milion UA refugees in Poland and about 2-3 million immigrants so they should be able to have normal life for a short period of time and communicate in Russian/Ukrainian in most places cause of enormous polish efforts otherwise they should go to Poland and from there you could start supporting them.
- JusticeJuice 5y agoWhat countries? If you've got fast internet, I've used skype international calling quite successfully before. Supported in quite a few places. Used it when I had to 'locally' call NZ from Japan once. https://www.skype.com/en/international-calls/ https://www.skype.com/en/international-calls/
- davidzweig 5y agoIf it's any help, I am helping to organise for the parents of my Ukranian friend to move to Bulgaria. And possibly a few other friends. It's picturesque in the mountains and Russian is widely spoken. Renting an appartment here is about 150 EUR/mo. If they are Russian speakers, they will have a bit easier time here than Poland, language-wise. Call me if I can help: +359 879 340194.
- pantulis 5y ago"(...) returned to Kharkiv to do something useful for the city. With no military experience and even no driving license, I do things on a very small scale" The sense of due duty to your community beyond your family and your own life. I am not really sure I would have the courage to do that. To Zverok: respect and good luck. To the rest: support Ukraine.
- noir_lord 5y agoI think I would. I wouldn't fight for my country in an offensive war, it's an arbitrary construct that means little to me to but I would fight for my family, my friends and the people around me in a defensive war. This is what shines through when you see things about the Ukraine in the news, these people are fighting for everything - it's about the maximum level of motivation that a people could have.
- throwaway-m3232 5y ago
- derriz 5y agoSeems that Russian forum trolling/disinformation spreading is about as sophisticated and effective as their offensive military capability.
- dragonwriter 5y agoI particularly like that it brings up what Russia has promised to citizens if they submit, as if it didn't promise, repeatedly, that it wasn't going to invade (both immediately before the 2022 escalation, and in binding treaties that were in place at the time of the initial 2014 invasion.) Russias promises are worth less than nothing, at this point.
- mambru 5y ago:'D You can do better than that!
- saiya-jin 5y ago> There is a rumor that Putin had recently made a personal order to damage as much of Kharkiv as possible, to retaliate for breaking the hope of being “pro-Russian.” And however absurd it might sound, I am close to believing it because there seems to be no other point in doing what they do now. I have the same impression, just old bitter fart and shadow of a man he once was, entrenched in his untouchable position, throwing childish deadly tantrums on a nation that decided to stood up to him as one. An idea - even if they laugh on ICT in Haag, what if there would be international arrest warrant on all those sanctioned persons including him, no diplomatic immunity? Meaning they can't travel most of the world, forever. Just a nuisance maybe. but proverbial death by thousand cuts starts somewhere. And remove russia from permanent UN security council for the duration of 'special operation', since they just veto everything now.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoIt still seems illogical. Kharkiv had a huge Russian population. I had some friends from there who sighed "finally!" when they heard Putin started the invasion. They truly believed he would end the years-long conflict and finally they will live in peace on a territory more or less Russian. Today, there is no single Russian in Kharkiv who would support Putin or even believe what he says. He betrayed his own people.
- _bhjy 5y agoThe entire invasion is illogical. There was arguably some sense to Crimea - there is no sense in this invasion.
- tgBax 5y agoThere certainly are reasons (not a value judgement), some of them cynical: - Crimea wants to control the canal from the Djnepr, which had been shut off by Ukraine. - Russia wants the coast line to control more gas fields in the Black Sea. The U.S. of course also want to control them by proxy (see Burisma/Biden). Snake island also controls some of the fields. - Rightly or wrongly, Russia is scared of NATO expansion. I think it may be the case that the great Russian empire theory is a pretext that is put forward by Putin for his own population and eagerly taken up by the West for propaganda. Attacks on Kyiv (stalled) and Kharkiv could be diversions from the south. As noted above, the Kharkiv attack does not make sense though.
- throwaway-m3232 5y ago[flagged]
- VictorPath 5y ago
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoThis. It's sad that many people in the West are ready to sacrifice the whole country only to weaken its arch-enemy.
- moneywoes 5y agoKeep fighting and take care
- nathell 5y agoLike every other day, I was shopping this morning at my local bakery in Warsaw, Poland. As I was packing my purchases, a woman next in line after me ordered coffee in Ukrainian. (We have it lucky. Polish and Ukrainian are mutually intelligible to some extent, which enables basic communication even without knowing each other's languages.) I said, to no one in particular, "Do widzenia, слава Україні" as I was leaving. She reciprocated the customary "Героям слава" in an obviously moved voice. Small things matter. We need to support each other in every possible way. Donating helps, so does showing solidarity, and so does spreading the word. Будь в безпеці, zverok. Our thoughts are with you all.
- xwdv 5y agoHe roughly said “See you, glory to Ukraine” and she replied “Glory to the Heroes!!” Be safe!!
- ilyich 5y agoThe modern response "Heroiam slava!" (Glory to the heroes!) appeared in the 1930s among members of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN). [0] The greeting "Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!" became an official slogan of Stepan Bandera's Nazi allied OUN-B in April 1941. OUN actively participated in holocaust and other atrocities during WW2. [1] In other words, he roughly said "See you, Heil Hitler!" and she replied "Sieg Heil!" Be safe!! Take care of yourselves!! [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glory_to_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glory_to_Ukraine [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organization_of_Ukrainian_Nationalists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organization_of_Ukrainian_Nati...
- thrw-awy0010010 5y ago
- chupy 5y agoIt's quite ridiculous but are you trying to insinuate that she was a Nazi? By the same logic you are applying does it mean that everyone that uses the phrase Allahu Akbar (God is great) is also a terrorist?
- mfontani 5y agoElReg's interview: https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/17/ruby_ukraine_zverok/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/17/ruby_ukraine_zverok/
- pabs3 5y agoHN post for that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30715307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30715307
- tgz 5y agoCan you explain me what the "Alley of Angels" in Donetsk is?
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoFrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alley_of_Angels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alley_of_Angels: "The Alley of Angels in Donetsk, Ukraine is a memorial for children of Donbas killed during the War in Donbas." Unfortunately, even the reporting of victims of war is quite selective. Hope that everyone responsible for killing children, regardless where they come from, will be punished appropriately.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ystad 5y agoStay strong, be safe
- JSeymourATL 5y ago> Make us seen. Just to let you know, We see you! And yes, donations sent. Keep up your spirits and good work. Please take care!
- jmnicolas 5y ago
- oldiphone 5y agoRepost, print & post in real life: https://m.imgur.com/a/cTepNuC https://m.imgur.com/a/cTepNuC