13 ms·
This is misleading. The copyright office simply needs the work to be registered under a human name, since a machine or AI cannot hold copyright. The process use
by paxys 5y ago
This is misleading. The copyright office simply needs the work to be registered under a human name, since a machine or AI cannot hold copyright. The process used to create it is irrelevant.
- ghaff 5y agoThis is essentially a stunt. If he used an AI to help him, even substantially help him, and copyrighted it himself, that would be a non-story. Just as it would be a non-story if he used Photoshop to substantially alter something.
- im3w1l 5y agoYes, this paradigm makes a lot of sense in the present moment. In a hypothetical future where there is a long-lived AI agent, acting autonomously over multiple years or even decades it will become less and less seen as a tool used by a human person. But, no need to update policies until then.
- nextaccountic 5y agoBut we already have multi-generational non-person entities: companies. Copyright may be assigned to companies instead of persons. They are just registered under a bunch of people's names, which act as owners (shareholders), and can change over time. In the future, AI entities will probably be registered as companies themselves (or maybe they will be just company assets), and will be owned by people. Which doesn't bode well for strong AI, but I suspect that even after we reach strong AI people will still grasp at straws for many decades or centuries, denying them personhood because they are just software that run on computers.
- dgreensp 5y agoThe amount of autonomy that makes something a “person” has only ever been drastically understated in these sorts of discussions, I find. Like saying a future self-driving taxi would own its own business and keep its profits. That’s like giving a self-driving tractor the deed to the farm. It’s easy to personify things that demonstrate some amount of “agency” (moving around on their own, making decisions), I guess, but lots of things do that and it doesn’t make them legal people who can own property and the like. Even if it made sense to give a deed to a tractor, no one would do it.
- ineedasername 5y agoYou're making me regret my decision to setup my Roomba as the sole asset of a corporation owned by the Roomba itself. It seemed like the moral, ethical thing to do, but it doesn't even cash its paychecks.
- cupofpython 5y ago>Even if it made sense to give a deed to a tractor, no one would do it. I mean... we both know people would if they could, right? If a tractor approaches me with a QR code to a smart contract that will give me enormous money in exchange for my deed.. I'm going to do it
- TillE 5y agoWhere did the tractor get the money? I mean, people can probably give stuff to an "AI" the same way they leave stuff to their cats, but we are an absurdly long way off from developing an artificial intelligence with real agency. These are questions for science fiction authors, not actual legal scholars.
- ineedasername 5y agoThe legal and theoretical framework already exists somewhat for artificial entities in the form of corporate law and corporate personhood.
- cupofpython 5y agotheoretically? it operates on smart contracts, so farmers pay it and it goes and does tractor things on their farm for them. It has no user access to its wallet, and the only way to regain human control of the tractor is with a factory reset which will lose all the wallet details. So the tractor is the only one with access to the money, and it accumulates enough to try to buy a deed for whatever algorithmic reasons
- IncRnd 5y agoYea, in this analogy you already own the tractor, so you already own the tractor's money. I don't think I'm going on a limb by saying that isn't slavery. You already own the tractor and the money. There is no emancipation needed. If somebody else's tractor approached you with a smart contract, the owner of that tractor would have a case that the smart contract was not entered into in good faith, since a tractor cannot enter a contract at all. Maybe you'd even get charged with theft.
- tshaddox 5y ago> If he used an AI to help him, even substantially help him, and copyrighted it himself, that would be a non-story. Maybe a subtler story, but I wouldn't say no story. It's still worth pondering how it works if a human can creatively develop an AI system that can then output essentially endless unique works. Can the human just submit applications for those works endlessly? Even in purely practical terms, will the copyright at some point just ban the human for excessive submissions? And what if the AI system is open source or otherwise freely available? Can any human generate a new unique work and submit a copyright application for it? Is the mere curation work that the human applies to the AI system's output sufficient to receive a copyright on the work?
- ghaff 5y ago>Can any human generate a new unique work and submit a copyright application for it? Is the mere curation work that the human applies to the AI system's output sufficient to receive a copyright on the work? The short answer is that they don't need to submit anything. If they put their name on it, they're the putative copyright holder and it's up to someone else to prove they aren't. Copyright registration isn't required and is mostly related to be able to collect damages from others who violate your copyright.
- tshaddox 5y agoIf the work can be shown to have been created by an open source AI system, then I suspect it would be difficult to argue that you have an automatic copyright for the work, especially if you hadn’t published the work.
- tshaddox 5y ago> If he used an AI to help him, even substantially help him, and copyrighted it himself, that would be a non-story. Maybe a subtler story, but I wouldn't say no story. It's still worth pondering how it works if a human can creatively develop an AI system that can then output essentially endless unique works. Can the human just submit applications for those works endlessly? Even in purely practical terms, will the copyright office at some point just ban the human for excessive submissions? And what if the AI system is open source or otherwise freely available? Can any human generate a new unique work and submit a copyright application for it? Is the mere curation work that the human applies to the AI system's output sufficient to receive a copyright on the work?
- frutiger 5y ago> Can the human just submit applications for those works endlessly? Even in purely practical terms, will the copyright office at some point just ban the human for excessive submissions? Copyright does not need submissions or applications. Copyright is automatic in most (all?) jurisdictions which respect copyright in the first place.
- zuminator 5y agoDamien Riehl and Noah Rubin, had a computer output[0] every combination of 8 notes in an octave, which came to approximately 68 billion separate “melodies ” that they have claimed copyright over. Their goal is to release these melodies into the public domain to prevent anyone else from asserting copyright over any of the note sequences in the future. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats-the-point-of-writing-every-possible-melody/607120/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats...
- dingrot 5y agoIn what way is it misleading? That’s exactly what I got from the headline and article.
- CamelCaseName 5y agoTo me, "US Copyright Office won't accept AI-generated work" implies that work generated by AI won't be accepted. However, it turns out that work generated by AI will be accepted, albeit under a human name.
- kube-system 5y agoBut, that is what they say: > [T]he Office will not register works produced by a machine or mere mechanical process that operates randomly or automatically without any creative input or intervention from a human author. This is a clash between the marketing BS that is contemporary "AI" and reality. "AI" is either sentient, or it's a human tool. The copyright office is requiring that people cut the BS and concede that just because you have particularly complicated tool, doesn't mean it's not just a tool. It's like someone attempting to register a book copyright to a typewriter, the Copyright Office rolling their eyes, and responding: "Well, smart ass, if the typewriter wrote it, then it's ineligible."
- jjulius 5y agoThe phrase "requires 'human authorship'" suggests that a human must have authored the submission. In reality, AI could author the submission but a human would need to use their own name when submitting it.
- sneak 5y agoAIs cannot yet author anything as they still require humans to execute the programs. AI software is just another tool. The human using it is still the creator of the work. Claiming otherwise is hype; we do not assign agency to software.
- 5y ago
- totony 5y agoThanks, saved me the read.
- narrator 5y agoSome person has to take responsibility for it in case their is some kind of fraud involved in the copyright claim. You can't just say no one is responsible because the computer did it all by itself.
- adolph 5y agoNot just "humans," corporations are legal persons too for copyright purposes: https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/copyright-ownership-content-business https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/copyright-ownership-content...
- joe_the_user 5y agoI just read the article and surprisingly, you're wrong. Key quote: "The Office will not register works produced by a machine or mere mechanical process that operates randomly or automatically without any creative input or intervention from a human author. The crucial question is “whether the ‘work’ is basically one of human authorship, with the computer [or other device] merely being an assisting instrument, or whether the traditional elements of authorship in the work (literary, artistic, or musical expression or elements of selection, arrangement, etc.) were actually conceived and executed not by man but by a machine." Machine generated works cannot be copyrighted. Edit: and gee, did you get hn to rewrite the headline on the strength of your false claim? Sigh...
- netizen-936824 5y agoThere is input from a human in the form of algorithmic programming and choice of training data
- joe_the_user 5y agoWhere the work in question would fall within the law is another question. But it's definite that the US Copyright Office won't copyright a work it considers machine generated, contrary to the gp's claim and the (apparently) rewritten headline. IE, the processed used is not irrelevant.
- netizen-936824 5y agoI understand, but I disagree with the copyright office's decision. Why is there a distinction made between methods of creation, say if someone used Photoshop to create art vs someone who programmed some ML thing to spit out art of a certain style or genre (ie thisanimedoesnotexist) Where, exactly, does the line lie that was crossed?
- joe_the_user 5y agoI'm not a fan of copyright generally and sure the line might seem arbitrary. But if you consider for second, just one of the problems with copyrighting machine-generated works is that a machine could generate so much text it make thing so any author would be bound to infringe on some part of it, especially if the text was generated cleverly. Plus: you've replied to some point other than what I actually said twice now, what's up with that?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]