10 ms·
In the spirit of the old saying, "the two happiest days of a boat owner's life are the day they buy a boat, and the day they sell it." The best advice I got st
by hinkley 5y ago
In the spirit of the old saying, "the two happiest days of a boat owner's life are the day they buy a boat, and the day they sell it."
The best advice I got starting out was, "be indispensable."
The best advice I got four years later was, "don't be indispensable."
In a growing company, the indispensable people may find themselves being left holding the bag while new initiatives are undertaken. I very quickly learned the meaning of 'working your way out of a job' after the first time this happened to me.
I'm sure there's some min-max game I'm not playing with regards to how easy I am to lay off, but once I learned there are worse fates that being laid off, I stopped looking for them. Being "stuck" with responsibilities is unpleasant when things are going well, but it's miserable when things are going badly. If you aren't the one who got laid off, then someone you used to trade off with doing onerous tasks certainly was, and now you're stuck doing it every single time.
If given the choice between "my company would be just fine without me" and "everything would fall apart if I didn't show up to work," the latter feels very good for a brief period when you're young, until the weight of that responsibility sinks in. "My company would be just fine without me," can mean "my work here is done," and you can ride off into the sunset with a clear conscience.
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> "My company would be just fine without me," can mean "my work here is done," and you can ride off into the sunset with a clear conscience It also makes it way easier to take your vacation time. If your employer is harmed by you taking vacation, they will find ways to make you miserable for it.
- gumby 5y ago> If your employer is harmed by you taking vacation, they will find ways to make you miserable for it. Ouch, I know this one well and it almost cost me my marriage.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cik2e 5y agoI have been in this situation myself, but my former boss has a conscience, as it turned out. My wife and I were on a vacation that was timed to celebrate an important birthday. I had spend days during the preceeding week training up two people on my team, and maybe one or two others, on various processes and contingencies. Yet still, when push came to shove, I was asked to get online to put out a fire. Luckily it only took an hour or two. A few days later I was surprised to find $1000 bucks deposited into my account from my boss as a thank you. This system that I had hacked together, built out and maintained, kept on growing in size, complexity, attributable revenue and potential compliance liabilities. Within the year, I had to call the execs into a meeting to drive home the point that this wasn't a tenable way for us to operate. Everyone had known as much but it was still a tough pill to swallow. I let them get too spoiled at a huge cost to my own mental health. I had to paint a dire picture to make my case that the system had to be rebuilt from scratch in order to be integrated into the main infrastructure. I ended up leaving a few months later as the rebuild was nearing completion. A couple of months down the road I was surprised to learn that they were still using a part of my system alongside the rebuild. Apparently their architecture couldn't support an algorithm that this component had relied on. What a mess!
- beebmam 5y agoSounds like this story is yet another reason people should regularly be moving to different companies
- ivraatiems 5y agoWhat's your goal, though? I'd like my company to not absolutely 100% need my constant presence, and I don't want to be in the author's position where he is not doing what he could be most valuable doing. But I do want my company to think "wow, that ivraatiems, we're sure lucky to have him." I would want them to think twice about firing me or laying me off if layoffs were happening. I definitely would not like to have to go look for a new job unexpectedly. So, I want to be personally valuable to the company - maybe more valuable than the average engineer - but I don't want to have indispensable knowledge that locks me in place. Surely there's a middle ground here?
- ip26 5y agoPresumably the goal is to be nominally replaceable, but just so all-around awesome they’d be sore to lose you. Easy, right?
- scarface74 5y agoI worked at 3 companies between 2014-2020. My goal going in was to solve the set of problems I was hired to solve by the then new manager and “put myself out of job”. Today working in a consulting department, I refuse to take on any work that may look like “staff augmentation”. I just do project based implementations with a definition of done and set aside time for training the customer.
- gowld 5y agoBe the best at two things, and train someone to do the less rewarding thing while you learn a new thing.
- bartvk 5y agoI think the middle ground is to have a huge stash of savings. That way, the original proposition isn't really relevant anymore. (That proposition being, I need to be valuable so I don't get fired).
- gautamdivgi 5y agoBeing indispensable to a team or a manager in a large company can actually be self-destructive to your career. I realized this the hard way a long time ago when my managers refused to let me move for a promotion because I was "indispensable" and "critical to the project". I've always made it a point to know who my back-ups are and have my supervisors assign them formally. In short, make it a point to share knowledge anyway. Keep a wiki, well written notes or documents, README.md's, whatever. Make it a point that people who are backing you up acknowledge and understand what you have and most importantly ask them to grow that body of knowledge.
- plutonorm 5y agoThat would be an instant resignation as a matter of principle for me.
- CapitalistCartr 5y agoPrinciples are a luxury not afforded the poor masses.
- kaba0 5y agoIf you are indispensable, then surely you have quite a leverage.
- teknopaul 5y agoThat argument does not solve the problem. You will stay or go from one project that fails to the next like that. Better to have worked on projects that are still good on your CV.
- pc86 5y agoNo. Scenario: There is a project your boss is wholly responsible for. You, from a technical perspective, are absolutely indispensable to the success of said project. Maybe it's a small team, or everyone is overloaded, but you can draw a direct line between you quitting (or doing a bad job) and your boss getting called out or potentially fired. Your boss, however, is not indispensable to their boss, nor is this project indispensable to the larger department. You ask for your raise because of your leverage. Your boss might be worried and try to get it for you. Their boss, not caring about this project that much in the broader context of their work, laughs and says no. You can absolutely be critical to the success of a project, and even important to your boss's future, but have no real leverage over your situation. That's absolutely a reason to leave but it doesn't mean you'll be able to squeeze any more money out of the place before you do.
- vikaveri 5y agoStarting in a new role, or new company, often means that there is a period when I'm hard to replace, but since I try to automate everything I can and make the rest simple enough for anyone to do, I'm actively trying to make myself useless and out of a job. Funnily enough, it doesn't seem world is running out of undone work anytime soon and there are always more interesting problems to solve.
- brtkdotse 5y ago> If given the choice between "my company would be just fine without me" and "everything would fall apart if I didn't show up to work, I found the problem. It’s not “your company”, it’s “the purchaser of your time and attention”. Act accordingly.
- sdoering 5y agoI remember reading "Anything you want" by Derek Sivers. There he describes, that he actually went towards "my company would just be fine without me" with his own company. So regardless of being an employee doing bodyleasing towards their employer, being an employee that identifies with "their" company or being a boss/founder/owner/manager these two sides of the axis exist and one needs to find the spot that fits for them within that range. I don't think there are "one size fits all" easy answers. Or at least if they are given imho and by my experience they are wrong more often than not.
- hinkley 5y agoIt's a fine line. If you want to stay employed, but not be pigeonholed, you need your company to see a future with you in it, rather than always thinking of you in the present tense, dealing with the latest problems du jour. I think for me these sorts of pre-emptions have always felt quite jarring, so the feedback loop for me is tighter than for some. If you bring me a novel problem to solve, I will happily stop what I'm doing and help you figure it out. For some reason I've only rarely had problems getting back into whatever you interrupted. Whereas with fire drills I have trouble spinning back up into what I was doing before. Perhaps to do with finite energy reserves. Ultimately I credit my early successes getting promoted to Lead to this pattern, because 'novel' problems either explain a wider portion of the overall architecture to me, or end up being all hands on deck when it turns out this issue is bad and is already in production. I cannot emphasize enough how much smarter you sound offering a solution you've had 30 minutes to an hour to think about instead of 10 minutes. The developer who triages an issue is two steps ahead of everyone else who is thinking on the fly. Doubly so if you have to wrangle everyone into a meeting room to discuss things. Unless the other people are vastly smarter or knowledgeable than you, you will hold your own in that conversation, even if you are somewhat junior. And if you're instead on a par, you will excel.
- Boritanian 5y agoi think the indispensable idea is from an era where job stability is important and you might be at one company for decades. The méthode en vogue of the current era is to jump ship every 2 years because that's the best way to get a raise/promotion. With that strategy being indispensable isn't that important because you will self-dispense in 2 years anyway.
- sdoering 5y agoI think one of the problems from "being indispensable" is the direction it takes. Being indispensable in regards to people "being left holding the bag while new initiatives are undertaken" means they are/were indispensable in regards to specific tasks/processes/skills or knowledge. Personally I feel being indispensable can also be seen as being able to be thrown at (nearly) any problem and finding a solution. Catching the ball and creating the basis for a stable project for others to take over/maintain. I am working at an agency and more often than not there is a first small initiative at a client where we just do not know what is expected/needed in terms of skills and in what direction this initiative might go/grow. So we often throw two people at the "problem". One more senior "jack of all trades" kind of person that can understand a lot of problems and knows how far they themselves can work towards a solution (and when to call in the subject matter experts). And one more junior person to support and learn by swimming in cold water together with said "senior" (can actually - depending on the problem be a junior/intermediate themselves - it depends). These "jack of all trades" persons, thinking on their feet, being able to improvise and get things done, able to understand and dig into problems ans find solutions - these kinds of persons are indispensable - but they don't get stuck in one specific problem/project. The processes around them are built in a way so that we free them for the next thing to come our way. And we do everything we can to create new people of that kind. I'm not really familiar with the military context, but it's almost how I envision an advance/special forces unit operating in front of the actual lines and first creating a beachhead that the regular troops can then build on and bring their strengths to bear. These types of individuals are indispensable - but ideally not each of the individuals on their own.
- gowld 5y agoTL;DR: Be indispensable for the role you want to be in. This may change over time.
- kqr 5y agoDeming sometimes used bus drivers as an example. Some of them might think it's not their job to smile and be nice to passengers. They're hired to drive the bus, and perhaps help out in emergencies, but not much beyond that. However, being nice to passengers (performing "caring labour" as Graeber would have put it) increases the chances that people choose the bus over e.g. the metro or something else. Deming concluded that it's always your job to do whatever increases the chances of the company you're working for staying in business. I still haven't found a good way to phrase it, but I'm starting to think that for knowledge/creative work, this can be specialised to something like, "it's your job to teach others to do what you think your job is." For knowledge/creative organisations to stay in business over the long term, they need to continuously innovate, and for innnovation you want people to be strong generalists. Not just because it lets them spot opportunities they otherwise might not, but also because it lets the organisation run more efficiently with less paperwork, and because it gives people the autonomy they need to think clearly about things.
- wanderingmind 5y agoIf the bus drivers were paid by the number of people who take the bus sure, but when are paid by the travel route distance, they have no obligation to do what they are not paid to do.
- mtsr 5y agoWhat a nihilistic view. Not every aspect that’s part of your job needs to be included in your variable compensation in order to be done, does it?
- iamacyborg 5y agoThey’re employed to do a specific job, if they’re not rewarded for bringing the company more money, why should they care?
- goodpoint 5y agoBecause human beings are not coin operated robots?
- nvarsj 5y agoThis happened in the first company I worked for. It was a big, well known engineering company, and when things started going south they had to negotiate with the state labor department to do large layoffs, which required giving financial cushions to let go employees. I was a star employee - so while everyone else was being laid off with nice, big compensation packages (like 6-12 months of salary), I was stuck in a company on fire that obviously had no future. I was, in effect, punished for being "indispensable".
- pc86 5y agoEthical issues aside it's easy to see how people in that situation can basically just stop working / start interview prepping while waiting for the layoff.
- gnz11 5y agoAfter about 20 or so years now, one of the main things I've learned is that you aren't as indispensable as you think you are. You might think the company will go under or otherwise degrade when you leave, but that never happens. The company will trudge along without you. That being said though, if you do believe yourself to be "indispensable" to a degree in which the burden of you leaving is large, then by all means, use that to your advantage in obtaining raises/promotions/etc.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoOr you are indespensible, and the company could go under, but you can charge them huge afternoon-consulting fees while working a new, better day-job elsewhere.
- NikolaNovak 5y ago"My Company would be fine without me" also means you can take vacation, medical appointments, heck even weekend (crazy concept!). "Being Indispensable" can also mean two years of no physical or mental time off; it was not fun! I am currently lucky that all my layers of higher management understand that if my team can function effectively without me for a period of time, that means I'm doing my job well . I was able to take 2 months of paternity without things falling completely apart, and it was a proud moment for me and the team (plus great chance to bond with family). Sure there were things to catch up on and new initiatives and some bad habits to work through, but it was overall a success. (In addition to "be indispensable" vs "don't be indispensable", one of the best pieces of advice I got and share is "The moment you get a new job/role/position, start looking for your replacement". I did not understand the value of that the first few years, but I now 100% do. I know a lot of HN SME/IC's believe "it's my boss's job to replace me / I'm in & out in a year or two", but if you are even remotely looking for a sustainable career in a company or small market/industry, it will speak VOLUMEs to your foresight, care and team&business responsibility if you have a trained, capable backup identified and positioned, for your times off as much as for your eventual ambitions).
- Terry_Roll 5y ago
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI'm not sure how that directly relates to my or original post; but let me try to engage: I don't understand first sentence; but based on second sentence, my interpretation of your key point is that you may have excellent technical or functional skills, but if your personality / behaviour / look don't fit, people may still find way to get rid of you. I believe that is true; and I believe that can be true in both positive and nefarious ways. I've been a hands-on pure techie for 15 years; I've been in leadership/managerial positions lately; and I cannot believe how positively ignorant I was to ever think my technical skills were the only or even primary consideration. A person knowing a technology is great. But a person then needs to: * Understand client's top down business goals and priorities (as opposed to bottom-up technical priorities) to prioritize their tasks and recommendations. E.g. As a DBA, you want to spend your time optimizing tables and indexes and access paths that you have; but business may well prioritize new functionality that will gain them market advantage or reduce cost more than optimizing a technical parameter will. And this tension goes forever in every facet of technology. * Be able to gather true requirements, eek them out of client and product owner and functional & business team. A person who builds exactly and only what a clueless functional person tells them to, is... OK. A fine junior resource. A person who's been around the block and cares enough about business to ask keen questions to identify needs client/functional wasn't fully aware, identify edge cases, danger zones, risks and discuss them in understandable language, is a worthy senior developer * Work with the team. Coach junior team members; at least consider feedback from everybody - junior, senior, client, management, functional, business, and integrate it appropriately to make yourself more valuable to them. Make their day better - through your work, yes, but also your attitude. Do you help inspire and motivate and get team members excited, or do you drag them down? Do you help move things along or do you get people stuck in some detail forever? * Communicate well. Strive to understand and be understood. Ensure your team mates and management know what you're doing, how you're doing, how well you're doing, the thoughts and plans, and risks/barriers/issues/constraints you're encountering (as much as they need/desire to). Be self-guided when you can; Ask for help when you reach your limits. (those two goals are a LIFEtime's work to improve and hone and fine tune:). Ensure everybody understands the plan and agrees to plan. Be at all times aware other people's context/background/assumptions/knowledge/perspective may be completely, wildly different than yours; avoid unspoken assumptions and ambiguities. * Understand your management's goals and help them succeed. It is stunning to me how few technical people (myself historically included!!:) didn't know, and did not want to know, what the management/business goals are. We have this duality of "Just tell me what to do, I don't want to deal with politics and business crap" and "I'm angry that we are not doing what I think we should be doing, how I think we should be doing it". etc etc etc. This is not to say that teams and companies don't abuse the "cultural fit" notion; or that north america isn't way too prescriptive about "being a team player to the point of being a yes-person"; or that there isn't racism/nationalism/personal preferences and bias in recruiting and other decisions. There 100% is negative and unproductive ways to people manager, and I see it all the time. But I think many of us would benefit from awareness that our technical/functional skills are a) not the only thing we are judged on and b) they are not the only thing we need/should be judged on, on vast majority of real world non-theoretical projects and teams.
- matwood 5y ago"You can't be promoted if you can't be replaced."
- pklausler 5y ago> you can ride off into the sunset with a clear conscience You can always do that.
- throwaway6532 5y agoThis was the big lesson I learned recently and I whole heartedly agree. It's can be very dangerous to your mental health to not have this perspective if you wind up emotionally trapped in a bad situation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 5y agoThere is actually no contradiction there. You want to be indispensable for the position you wish you have, and dispensable for any position you don't wish. If your interests change, your dispensability should change with it. But this is very hard to achieve, so you get a complex goal of optimizing for many things at the same time.