14 ms·
Uber funds new lobbying group to deny rights for gig workers
- wdb 5y agoDidn't expect anything else from this company
- bpodgursky 5y agoI don't really want universal healthcare but I would take it if it makes people stop talking about the obligation of employers to provide additional services and benefits for their employees that fundamentally have nothing to do with the labor/payment relationship. If it's a fundamental right, the government should do it directly or subsidize it. Not lump it on employers just because it's convenient.
- andybak 5y agoRemind me not to work for you.
- bpodgursky 5y agoDeal
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoYou just want to ride the horse until its tired, then shoot it and eat it.
- endisneigh 5y agoDatavant should strip away all of your benefits since it fundamentally has nothing to do with your labor/payment relationship indeed! Cash only.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt's strange for a site where most compensation is non-cash to hear people extolling their virtues of cash only for compensation
- neon_electro 5y agoI don't know about you, but in my 10-year career so far, the amount of cash compensation I've earned is orders of magnitude higher than the actual liquid compensation I've received from equity actually becoming worth something. tl;dr I got lucky and won the startup lottery, but it didn't pay out nearly as much as the cash compensation I've earned. Am I in the minority here? I doubt it.
- Cederfjard 5y agoThey’re probably talking about RSUs at Big Tech, rather than startup options.
- orangecat 5y agoRSUs are nearly as liquid as cash. Health insurance is very much not.
- HWR_14 5y agoRSUs are liquid after they vest. Health insurance vests pretty much right away
- bpodgursky 5y agoYes, I would much rather get more cash than a bunch of annoying FSA, life insurance, pet insurance, disability insurance, gym expense, home-office benefits.... all benefits I have to manually keep track of and optimize. This clown car of "perks" only exist because of a dumb tax regime that makes those benefits pre-tax, and that regime should end.
- richbell 5y ago> Yes, I would much rather get more cash than a bunch of... benefits I have to manually keep track of and optimize. I've worked at a few large financial institutions that pay technical employees significantly below market rate, but aggressively and publicly boast about how competitive they are because of "total compensation". It's absurd, and often results in large dysfunctional teams where they have to hire 10+ junior people, for ~60k each, because they're unwilling to hire 1-2 experienced people, for ~150k each.
- bogomipz 5y agoHave you actually asked your employer if they can do away with that 'clown car of "perks"' in exchange for more salary? I would think that would be something you could negotiate as part of any job offer. Accepting a company's employer healthcare and benefits is certainly not mandatory either.
- bpodgursky 5y agoIt's not advantageous to do this as an individual under the current tax code. I'd still rather take the perks than pay 35% of it as marginal tax. What I want is a revision to the tax code that stops making the benefits a tax-efficient vehicle.
- bogomipz 5y agoWho is Datavant? I'm not seeing it mentioned in the article or other threads in this post.
- renewiltord 5y agoGoogle the username of the guy he’s responding to.
- bogomipz 5y agoAh I see. Datavant is healthcare tech.
- HWR_14 5y agoYou know even if there is universal healthcare, you can pay private doctors yourself if you would like.
- sidlls 5y agoThat's not really different from care outside of insurance coverage that exists today, e.g., elective plastic surgery. Universal healthcare, done even as poorly as our government likely will, will go a long way toward decoupling basic needs like this from employment. If companies want to offer "luxury" plans to cover elective health procedures they'd be free to do so, but it would no longer be as effective a wage-depressing, servitude inducing cudgel as the current system is (however unintentionally).
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago> That's not really different from care outside of insurance coverage that exists today, e.g., elective plastic surgery. It is different, because in most countries where there is universal healthcare you can still cover that "private" care with a health insurance plan if you choose (e.g. BUPA or Nuffield in the UK) And then you can do the extra electives on top of that. So there are three tiers, rather than two. (In the UK there are a few situations where we effectively almost have only the US two tiers; opticians, dentistry, nutrition, physiotherapy all have much less NHS provision coverage, largely because the elective stuff is so easily upsold; professionals can leave the public sector for the private money. The worst being opticians; the idea that the market can provide that more cheaply has been proved wrong.)
- sidlls 5y agoIt isn't different: you can get insurance for those things in the US or pay for them directly (no employer or government subsidy). That's exactly the same as what the GP suggests. Plenty of companies even provide tiered insurance for executives and their families. So whether insurance is all employer-provided, private, government provided, or a mix, in the US one is almost certain to be able to buy something above and beyond the basics out-of-pocket.
- richbell 5y ago> I don't really want universal healthcare but I would take it if it makes people stop talking about the obligation of employers to provide * additional services and benefits for their employees that fundamentally have nothing to do with the labor/payment relationship. Employers don't provide additional services for altruistic reasons: having perks outside of the "labour/payment relationship" is a tool for attracting and retaining employees. That said, basic access to healthcare should not be contingent on employment (with a specific company) because it gives companies a significant amount of power over their employees. Many companies abuse this to trap employees into unfavorable working arrangements.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThere was a time when employers were happy to offer health care, pensions, and other enticements to get workers. It's an "employers' market" now as we are competing with the poorest nations on earth — a race to the bottom. Nice for shareholders I guess? People turn to their tax-paid, elected government for the things that Capitalism decides not to provide.
- richbell 5y ago> It's an "employers' market" now as we are competing with the poorest nations on earth — a race to the bottom. Ironically, many poorer nations have more affordable Healthcare than the United States. There's a whole "medical tourism" industry built around people from the US going to other countries for basic procedures and medication.
- bpodgursky 5y agoHealthcare was only ever offered as a perk because employers could pay for it pre-tax instead of post tax, but individual employees could not do the same with their own money. That was always stupid and didn't make sense, it's not because the labor/employment relationship used to be different.
- bogomipz 5y ago>"Healthcare was only ever offered as a perk because employers could pay for it pre-tax instead of post tax, but individual employees could not do the same with their own money." This is completely false. Employer-based healthcare was a consequence of World War 2. The US Congress passed 1942 Stabilization Act in order to combat inflation. As a result of this legislation employers could not compete for workers using wages alone. Employers then began to offer health benefits a perk and since that perk was not compensation it was not taxed. This fact is actually well-documented.[1][2]. It was offered in lieu of compensation and pre-tax vs post-tax status had nothing to do with the birth of this. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stabilization_Act_of_1942 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stabilization_Act_of_1942 [2] https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-obamacare-health-care-employers-20170224-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-obamaca...
- tzs 5y ago> I don't really want universal healthcare [...] Most common definitions of "universal healthcare" say it is a system that assures that all citizens of some political grouping (country, region, state) have access to healthcare without it being an undue financial burden. If you also use such a definition, then I'm curious what citizens you think should not be assured of such access? If you are using a different definition, then I'm curious what that is.
- bpodgursky 5y agoI would create a per-capita federal refundable tax credit which is commensurate with the average cost of "comprehensive" market health coverage for an individual, but not mandate people to buy anything other than catastrophic care coverage. Dunno what you'd call that.
- tzs 5y agoIf the tax credit based on comprehensive coverage was $1000/month, and catastrophic coverage cost $400/month, would someone who chooses to only have catastrophic still receive the $1000/month (giving them $600/month they could use on anything regardless of whether or not it is related to healthcare), or just receive $400/month, or receive whatever their insurance and medical costs actually are each month up to $1000/month? If the later two it would be universal healthcare. Not sure how the first would be classified.
- plasticchris 5y agoHigh deductible health plans are a thing, and fulfill the current (weak) insurance requirement in the US so the last half of that is here today.
- sokoloff 5y agoI’d wager that a lot of people using HDHPs are doing so in order to be allowed to use HSAs as a stealth (but best) additional retirement account. https://www.madfientist.com/ultimate-retirement-account/ https://www.madfientist.com/ultimate-retirement-account/
- TulliusCicero 5y agoI want universal healthcare, but otherwise I agree. It’s stupid that we’ve developed a model where healthcare is tied to employment. Imagine if the only sane way to buy groceries was through a food insurance plan because buying them a la carte was insanely expensive, but also food insurance was super expensive so you needed to get it through a job. “I can’t quit my job, I need my food insurance so I can eat!” That’s the situation we’re in today with healthcare.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt amuses me that our current health insurance situation traces pretty directly back to World War II era government price controls on labor. https://www.griffinbenefits.com/blog/history-of-employer-sponsored-healthcare https://www.griffinbenefits.com/blog/history-of-employer-spo...
- orangecat 5y agoAgreed. Either full socialism or an actual market in health care would be better than the idiocy we've gotten ourselves stuck with.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoEmployer based health insurance should be abolished. Same for things like 401k or pensions where a company decides what services the employee can get (and probably not the employee's benefit but for the company's benefit). Everybody should have access to the same plans when it comes to retirement and health insurance.
- cyberpunk 5y agoSeems to work okay in Spain and the UK, and even in Germany we have a kind of hybrid system. Americans hate their poor, vulnerable. It’s one of the many reasons I would never even visit there. Land of the free? Yeah ok.
- pessimizer 5y agoHealth insurance is associated with employment because originally, unions and other social organizations started providing it. They wanted to break the unions. So the government heavily subsidized employer-provided insurance through a tax break. It was not "lumped on" employers. It was another attack on working people. Tax it just like other wages, and I promise you'll start to see it disappear.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoEmployers offered perks like insurance to compete for workers because the feds foolishly made it illegal to offer higher wages during World War II.
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoHow long until web development becomes part of the gig economy, if it hasn't already.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fat_pikachu 5y agoUpwork
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agono, i'm thinking more the like of toptal who i am seeing increasingly more and more. i don't know their business model exactly but what i do know is that companies are increasingly seeing web dev as a commodity or to use the expression "code monkey" work. something to be outsourced, get people to work unpaid overtime.
- mathattack 5y agoThe difference between a good web developer (80th percentile?) and a median one is much greater than the difference between a good driver and a median one. And the inputs and outputs can be fuzzier. And bad output in tech lasts longer than the negative effects of a bad ride. That’s why it’s harder to hire anonymously like via an app.
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoI agree but just like uber it's not really "gig" work. You're essentially working full-time and even more (unpaid overtime) but you're classified as an independent contractor so you don't have any benefits or security under the false guise of "flexibility".
- dayvid 5y agoGig work is great for easily defined, repeatable tasks. Uber is going from point A to point B. This is something done for a long point of human history, and can be easily optimized through maps and routing algorithms. General software development can be more murky, because usually: 1. The person writing the requirements doesn't fully understand what's needed from an eng perspective 2. They need someone to describe tradeoffs of eng approaches 3. They'll probably need custom changes due to shifting business or client needs 4. They might need someone to guide them on a better framework or eng setup for their project Being able to actually complete a task well, on time or faster will get you a premium (it can be really hard to find). Being able to assist on a consulting side on top of that is very valuable and rare. I think the people who are really good on Upwork often get hired outright by contractors with more money or get higher paying side gigs (or they are outsourcing their work to other devs).
- ryeights 5y agoThis is the future tech workers are helping to build. I question my career choice more and more every day
- neon_electro 5y agoJust say no to Uber recruiters.
- nine_k 5y agoAre you working for Uber? Software development is like metalworking. It can be used to make a gun or a bicycle with equal ease, it's what you choose to build, not how.
- loudtieblahblah 5y agotechnology serves capital more than society.
- TOMDM 5y agoAll labor predominantly serves capital.
- nvr219 5y agoThat's deep
- mushbino 5y agoLabor creates all wealth.
- sershe 5y agoAt some point, maybe. Let's say we are subsistence farmers (as close to self sufficient, pure labor as it gets), and I spend extra time on the side to raise an ox. I cannot utilize the ox to its full potential myself, but I can lend it to others and massively increase their labor productivity without much increasing their labor input (or even while decreasing it). The ox is capital. What creates the extra wealth from others' work here and who deserves to keep it? I'd argue that if it decreases labor input I "deserve" 100% of the wealth differential, or close to 100% otherwise. That labor gets a lot of it is really unfair, although I do admit it's a necessary evil.
- stevehawk 5y agoyes so it's not just Uber > is backed by gig work mainstays including Uber, Lyft, DoorDash and Instacart.
- bogota 5y agoUber sells clicks. The others don’t.
- okareaman 5y ago> apps like Uber and Lyft don’t give her the details of a ride, such as its distance, expected time, and pay, until after she’s accepted it – at which point she has little choice but to follow through, even if it loses her money. > “I find out that it’s going to take me 45 minutes to go five miles, and I’m going to get about $5 for the ride. My only choice then is to either basically do volunteer work by accepting the ride, or canceling it. And we are disciplined, and threatened with being terminated, if we cancel it. >“So don’t call me an independent contractor, because that’s not what we are.” As a former Uber/Lyft driver I exaggerate when I say I've read a million words Gig jobs, but the above is a good summary of the problem. You're not shown in advance what the ride is and then you're penalized for cancelling it. One day you can't log in anymore but they won't say why, but you know from talking to other drivers that you get "fired" after cancelling too many rides. There are other problems, such as not being compensated when gas prices go through the roof, but there is a hidden problem that many drivers don't take into account: Every mile on your car decreases it's value and if you do the calculations you might find out you're taking equity out of your car and putting it in your pocket, so you're not making money and you might be selling your car bit by bit for pennies on the dollar.
- achow 5y agoOn the other hand, in India canceling of rides by drivers is creating huge pain to riders. Commuters are up in arms over the increasing number of cancellations on app-based services such as Ola and Uber. More often than not drivers, after accepting a ride, call up the passenger to ask about his or her destination before cancelling. They are unwilling to come to certain destinations and are not ready to pick up passengers in residential areas located away from main roads, said one regular user of Ola and Uber. https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/bangalore/bengaluru-commuters-get-tired-of-being-taken-for-a-ride/article65062548.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/bangalore/bengaluru-com...
- okareaman 5y agoIf they showed the driver the ride details beforehand, drivers could not accept the ride and passengers would never know. That's what would happen if drivers were truely independent. But by forcing the driver to cancel and irritating customers, Uber and Lyft are able to use this as a stick to discipline "independent" drivers. Note that drivers wouldn't cancel profitable rides, only rides that don't make them or cause them to lose money. I'm not sure why anyone has a problem with this.
- nemo44x 5y agoLabor law simply hasn’t caught up with the times. We have classifications for “employees” and “contractors” and gig work really does fall into both in many ways. A new classification with fair labor law applied to it is needed. Hourly employees have the FLSA for example. Arguing for either side here is impossible because they are both right in sone ways and wrong in sone ways. We need clear guidelines and classification.
- mchusma 5y agoI think we need to eliminate the "employee bundle" and just talk more directly about what we want for workers and legislate that. Most problems here relate to the bundle concept. For example, healthcare shouldn't be tied to employment, minimum wage laws could apply to all classes of labor, withholding for taxes could be for independent contractors, etc. A lot of this was shown in the AB5 bill in California, which was an attempt to create exemptions for employee classification for special interests. If you create a bundle that is wrong for a certain group, you can either do what we have been doing and make the bundle more complicated, or just get rid of the bundle.
- farmerstan 5y ago“I find out that it’s going to take me 45 minutes to go five miles, and I’m going to get about $5 for the ride.” This is a lie. Drivers get paid for distance and time. They will be making more like $20-25 dollars.
- okareaman 5y ago> They will be making more like $20-25 dollars Are you a driver? Because I don't think you know what you are talking about
- farmerstan 5y agoI’m pretty sure you actually have no idea what you’re talking about. Or you’re straight up lying. I have taken many 30 mins rides that cost me well over $30 and the entire cost is broken down in the app.
- c-cube 5y agoHave you considered that maybe, out of these 30$, only 5 might go to the driver? Sometimes even the tip is pocketed by the company — forgot if it was doordash which was found to do that a little while ago, and some people on HN were defending them.
- lhorie 5y agoHave you considered looking into statistics? As in, have you noticed how nobody's talking about the Uber drivers who pull in 100k+ per year? Or consider we're literally just taking a quote at face value here without questioning whether it's possibly hyperbole? The reality is that there's a huge amount of income variability for Uber drivers, both on the micro and macro levels, so it's very easy to paint whatever story you want by cherrypicking quotes from the side of the bell curve that supports your pet narrative.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThis is an incredibly biased article from Guardian journalists who are themselves unionized. Describing mandatory benefits, as "rights", is an entirely ideological position, that good journalism would not pass off as fact. Journalists using their platform to advance an ideological framework that advances their own narrow interests is a major cultural threat and deserves more attention. Here is one example of the perverse incentives in effect: Vox writers, who eventually unionized, spent years publishing articles arguing for laws limiting the gig economy, like this one: "The gig economy has grown big, fast — and that’s a problem for workers" [1] Three years after the above article was published, its agenda succeeded, and a new anti-gig-economy law, that was heavily supported by major unions, was passed in California. That law in turn forced Vox to let go of hundreds of gig economy freelancers, thus reducing competition to the full-time journalists who had, in articles like the above, used their media platform to lobby for the law: "Vox Media to cut hundreds of freelance jobs ahead of changes in California gig economy laws" [2] Circling back to my original point: the media being fully unionized means that it is extremely biased in its coverage of these kinds of stories. [1] https://www.vox.com/2016/10/26/13349498/gig-economy-profits-workers-desperate-services-labor https://www.vox.com/2016/10/26/13349498/gig-economy-profits-... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/16/vox-media-to-cut-hundreds-of-freelance-jobs-ahead-of-californias-ab5.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/16/vox-media-to-cut-hundreds-of...
- bildung 5y ago> the media being fully unionized means that it is extremely biased in its coverage of these kinds of stories. So? As with many societal topics there is no neutral position here, because all arguments eventually boil down to questions of ethics/morality. Biases only become a meaningful topic if they introduce factual errors into the content. Have you found factual errors?
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe neutral position is one that is presented without bias. Making excuses for this kind of bias, which is motivated by a major undisclosed financial conflict of interest, and which completely undermines journalistic integrity, is the irresponsible attitude that has allowed the culture of professionalism and ethics to degrade to this point.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI am thinking more and more that gig work is taking a huge toll on society and will contribute more and more to increasing inequality. It splits the economy into the people who run the services and can have traditional careers where you move up the ladder. And the other larger group are the gig workers that develop almost no marketable skills, have no bargaining power and never can move up in the company. They are pure commodities. The capitalists like and it has some short term benefits for some gig workers but in the long run it's are really bad deal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jstx1 5y agoFrom the recent terms update I got from Uber: > When you take an Uber ride, you will contract directly with Uber for the transportation services, rather than the driver - we’ve updated our User Terms to reflect this. I wonder what difference it makes, if any.
- smsm42 5y agoI'm not sure I get it, how can Uber drivers strike, beyond not accepting rides, not logging into the app, etc.? They can do it right now, so what exactly "right to strike" means?
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoThe right to strike refers to protections given to employees to collectively act without fear of punishment, which is part of the NLRA[0]. Since these are contractors, they are afforded no such protection. 0: https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-rights/nlra-and-the-right-to-strike https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-right...
- 1270018080 5y agoTheir entire business model is just underpaying their employees.
- MaxMoney 5y ago
- dainiusse 5y agoThis whole sharing economy is just a hack on labour law. Thats it.
- redstarpa 5y ago[dead]
- nso95 5y agoHow does this make money?
- ProjectBarks 5y agoLooks like they show you ads in the ride? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30611380 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30611380
- nso95 5y agoYikes, good luck with that
- ViViDboarder 5y agoI don’t need cheaper rides on another unsustainable platform. I want to pay a reasonable cost for reliable rides.