40 ms·
Israel passes law denying naturalization to Palestinian spouses
- pthread_t 5y agoSo, 21% of Israel's population has restrictions on who they could marry all so that they can maintain a majority of the favored demographic. This is apartheid.
- starik36 5y ago> favored demographic Right, because the purpose of Israel is to be a Jewish state with a majority Jewish population to protect its Jewish residents from genocides, pogroms, blood libels, and other things that have been done to them for 2 millennia.
- jfiowejf 5y agoThe same thing they did to the Palestianians. Weird how white supremacy is suddenly cool with a lot of people when you replace white with "Jew"
- edanm 5y agoWait, explain to me what we Jews should have done after the holocaust, and after many countries kicked out all their Jews. Doesn't starting a Jewish country make sense? There are dozens of other countries around different groups (whether religious or ethnic), how is it wrong for Jews to want the same thing?
- pavelrub 5y agoThe restriction applies to everybody, not just Israeli Arabs. However it is true that Israeli Arabs are the ones most affected by it.
- fredophile 5y agoLaws that make it illegal to sleep under bridges apply to everybody, not just the homeless. Does that mean a law against sleeping under bridges is not targeting the homeless?
- thinkcontext 5y agoThe law also affects Israeli Jews, Christians, atheists, etc that want to marry Palestinians.
- slim 5y agoand palestinian is considered an ethnicity in israel. as opposed to "people coming from the country Palestine". so it's an openly racist law
- pavelrub 5y agoIt targets people who sleep under bridges. If, for example, there is a major safety hazard associated with sleeping under bridges, it would make sense to prohibit it, and it would be bizarre to criticize the law just because it affects mostly homeless people. If, on the other hand, the law prohibits only homeless people from sleeping under bridges, it becomes clear that the intent is discriminatory, and this becomes a valid criticism.
- pthread_t 5y ago“There’s no need to shirk from the essence of this law. It is one of the tools to ensure a Jewish majority in Israel, which is the nation-state of the Jewish people. Our goal is for there to be a Jewish majority,” Lapid tweeted shortly before the law lapsed in early July. [0] [0] https://www.timesofisrael.com/months-after-citizenship-law-falls-ban-on-palestinian-spouses-still-in-place/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/months-after-citizenship-law-f...
- pavelrub 5y ago
- Danidada 5y agothey can marry whoever they want, they just won't be naturalized ie if a Palestinian marries an Israeli, the Palestinian won't get Israeli citizenship
- nebula8804 5y agoI have seen this talking point repeated exactly in this manner all over Reddit. Was this dispatched from one of those Israel apps that navigate supporters to social media sites to push pro-Israel talking points?
- dmitris 5y agowhat about their children?
- dundarious 5y agoIsrael has many laws dictating where you can live and between which areas you can travel, and they depend on its complicated notion of citizenship and nationality. You have far fewer restrictions as a "Jewish nationality, Israeli citizen" than as "any other kind of nationality, Israeli citizen". This is the meaningful difference people are referring to when they say that "Israel is an ethnostate" or talk about "apartheid", because in many instances, in practice you can only do certain basic things like live with your partner if you are a "Jewish nationality, Israeli citizen". Just to give a short (but relatively surface-level) proof that this distinction is real and meaningful in Israeli politics, you can read the most recent former PM's statements in the following link (and I would encourage reading a broad political spectrum of commentary on the various citizenship and nationality laws, in particular those passed in the last few decades, e.g., Nation-State Law): https://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/Benjamin-Netanyahu/Netanyahu-hits-back-at-Israeli-actress-after-she-criticizes-Miri-Regev-582959 https://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/Benjamin-Netanyahu/Netanya...
- borski 5y agoCan you provide an example of what restrictions non-Jewish Israeli citizens have? Because I’m pretty sure all Israeli citizens have the same rights (Al Aqsa mosque and other religious sites notwithstanding).
- bradlys 5y ago> This is apartheid. It’s been this way for a while. This is just one more thing on top of another.
- twofornone 5y agoIsrael is surrounded by Arab Muslims who outnumber Jews 100:1 and are overtly hostile to Judaism, as prescribed by their religion. I ask honestly, is it really so wrong for a nation to implement laws to preserve its culture, particularly when it's people constitute a tiny fraction of the global population? Or is support of cultural preservation only virtuous when the alternative is labeled "gentrification"?
- eli_gottlieb 5y ago>Or is support of cultural preservation only virtuous when the alternative is labeled "gentrification"? Well yeah. "Cultural preservation" is only good when the NGO class supports it. When they don't like it, it's racism.
- camel_Snake 5y ago> and are overtly hostile to Judaism, as prescribed by their religion As a biracial Jew from Pakistan I can assure you this is false. The modern enmity between Jews and Muslims began around the time of Israel's creation [1]. As far as 'preserving culture', this sounds a little to close to the Fourteen Words for my comfort. You can celebrate and keep alive one's own culture without the exclusion and denial of rights to others. I think the idea of ethnostates run counter to the core values of most modern, liberal democracies. [1] https://dailytimes.com.pk/97778/the-jews-of-pakistan/ https://dailytimes.com.pk/97778/the-jews-of-pakistan/
- twofornone 5y ago>I think the idea of ethnostates run counter to the core values of most modern, liberal democracies. But not to the core values of middle eastern Arab countries, which is the point to limiting the possibility of a sizeable proportion of immigrants imposing their incompatible culture onto host nations. >As far as 'preserving culture', this sounds a little to close to the Fourteen Words for my comfort. There is no reason to presume that the values of your "modern, liberal democracies" will be maintained if there is no effort to preserve them. The rest of the world is far less concerned with your ideas regarding women's or LGBT rights. Allusions to the fourteen words are effectively a false equivalence, there is a massive range between maintaining a liberal way of life and going on a multinational genocidal war campaign. >As a biracial Jew from Pakistan I can assure you this is false. The modern enmity between Jews and Muslims began around the time of Israel's creation [1]. The enmity is baked into the Koran and therefore approximately as old as Islam.
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoDon't people actually marry because they love each other, and not as a way to gain a favourable citizenship? How the naturalization law prevents a marriage?
- Siira 5y agoIt’s immaterial to the purposes of this law. They don’t care why it’s done.
- idop 5y agoMinority groups in Israel actually have less restrictions with regards to marriage than the majority. Minority groups have freedom of religion. I'm a jew by ethnicity but an atheist by religion. I do not have freedom of religion. If I wanted to get married, by law, I am forced to get approval from the Jewish Rabbinate and follow religious protocols that make my skin crawl. And my spouse must be Jewish too.
- SpelingBeeChamp 5y agoNot really. You could do what thousands of others do any take a quick trip to Cyprus, get married (regardless of your partner’s religion or sex), and have the marriage civilly recognized in Israel.
- idop 5y agoGee, thanks.
- sgregnt 5y agoRead the article again. You didn't understand it or check other comments to here, instead of throwing baseless accusations.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoDoes this law also need a yearly reauthorization? The makeup of the Knesset doesn't seem to have radically changed since the law failed in July, anyone know how this try suddenly got an overwhelming majority?
- buzzwords 5y agoI think anytime there is post on this lots of down voting and canned responses are posted. That's from both sides. I'm not sure what the solution is but I can't imagine any real conversation happening without one side or the other "keyboard warriors" derailing the conversation.
- someotherperson 5y agoA common tactic to suppress unfavourable situations is to create hostility so that moderation is forced to take place. In real life this includes sending people to start fights or riot during protests to allow police to enter and disband it, and online this involves starting several arguments so that the moderators find it pointless to let the discussion go on. That's why this happens. It's intentional and not accidental :-)
- buzzwords 5y agoBloody hell. Whoever engages in such behaviour is an enemy of open society. I wonder if there is a way to identify such accounts online and remove them from platforms.
- kif 5y agoIt's certainly interesting how an oppressed people became the oppressor.
- kergonath 5y agoIt happened time and time again in history. See Christianity in the Roman Empire, for example, or at least half a dozen revolutions. Or the Balkans. Oppressed people are not better because they are oppressed. They are still human and perfectly able to persecute others depending on the context.
- kif 5y agoIndeed. It's just sad that's the way it is. As much as we humans like history, we never seem to learn its lessons.
- colechristensen 5y agoTo the contrary, humans have never been nicer to each other or lived more pleasant lives at any point before the present.
- toyg 5y agoAnd that's precisely because we stopped pulling this sort of crap in more and more places. 300 years ago, the number of religions and ethnicities currently existing in US or Western Europe would have meant a constant state of civil war.
- colechristensen 5y ago>300 years ago, the number of religions and ethnicities currently existing in US or Western Europe would have meant a constant state of civil war. 300 years ago the Ottoman Empire was in full swing and quite religiously and ethnically diverse (probably more so than modern Europe or America). Not to say everyone had equal rights or was nice to each other, but historically a cornerstone for the success of many (not all) empires has been a significant degree of diversity and tolerance of both religions and ethnicity. It also wasn't new, Rome was also quite diverse and tolerant. (not always, not to everyone, but still quite so)
- _8j50 5y ago[flagged]
- rsstack 5y agoThis law has nothing to do with intermarriage for Jews. That's effectively prohibited by other existing laws. This law tries to prevent Muslims and Christians living in non-annexed occupied territories from marrying other Muslims and Christians living outside of Israel's effective control area.
- _8j50 5y agoYou're right. I disagree with the policy myself but others are making it look like this would be abnormal. If they didn't have to pander to western ideals they could maybe implement a clean and painless definition of a border. Taking decades to colonize an area helps no one. I support the right for Israel to exist and if they must expel the inhabitants of the land they have taken. But the mistreatment of palestinians is not acceptable by theirs or any other abrahamic faith.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- shephardjhon 5y agoI am totally ready to read rational discussions that in no way is colored by hatered of either side or belonging to a particular religion or political beliefs or consperacy theories you have read about either side. I am also totally expecting everyone here on HN to be expert historians and masters of international relations.
- veltas 5y agoThis post was #1 on hacker news yesterday for a bit, flagged, and now it's been unflagged many hours later. I wonder what's going on there. I didn't have to go "read" about a 'consperacy' online for that, I just saw weird stuff happening right here on this site.
- macinjosh 5y agoThe only thing worse than government is government used to enforce the whims of their imaginary gods.
- quelsolaar 5y agoThis is an apartheid regime. Plain and simple.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analo...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Qem 5y agoSouth Africa took a lot of flak for their apartheid. Wonder why the same doesn't happen with this apartheid in the XXI century. That's a shame.
- School-Cotton 5y agoSame reason Russia is getting flak for invading and occupying territory (including, even, from Israel!) when Israel has illegally occupied the West Bank for decades with no consequences. Western countries apply their moral principles differently to their allies.
- eatonphil 5y agoSouth Africa is/was a western ally. And the West did ignore apartheid for a long time.
- School-Cotton 5y ago> South Africa is/was a western ally. Maybe, but not one of nearly the same strategic importance (and lobbying/PR prowess) as Israel.
- deepsun 5y agoSouth Africa abstained to vote on UN resolution against Russian large attack on Ukraine. West didn't ignore apartheid, they quietly supported it, because USSR supported Mandela and anti-apartheid struggle. Kinda "enemy of my enemy is my friend". IMHO that was the stupidest position of the US, they should've "united" with USSR on anti-apartheid position.
- subliminalpanda 5y agoIsrael is a racist apartheid state at its core.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago
- roomey 5y agoThe outcome
- ibrahimsow1 5y agoThe outcome
- pthread_t 5y agoThe outcome
- Octoth0rpe 5y agoThe outcome
- hestefisk 5y agoThis.
- aerodog 5y ago[flagged]
- emptyparadise 5y ago>Proponents say the law helps ensure Israel's security and maintains its "Jewish character". What the fuck?
- xdennis 5y ago>>Proponents say the law helps ensure Israel's security and maintains its "Jewish character". >What the fuck? Why all the outrage? Should France not maintain it's French character?
- simiones 5y agoNo, and France does not have any laws whatsoever protecting its French character in this sense. The Jewish character of Israel does not refer to cultural character, but to ethno-relgious character. Israel very explicitly accepts democracy only insofar as it doesn't lead to Israel being led by people who are not ethnically and/or religiously Jewish. The only other countries on Earth today that have anything similar to this type of language and laws are Hungary and, to a lesser extent, Russia (which both offer passports to foreign nationals of hungarian/russian ethnicity, for example).
- 1337shadow 5y agoThis article fails to explain the reasons for which proponents believe that marriage with Palestinians would threaten security or Jewish character of the country, failing the supposed neutrality of the article or compromising the supposed quality of journalists in charge of investigating this.
- rjzzleep 5y agoThen please enlighten us, what's the rationale?
- 1337shadow 5y agoExactly my question.
- 5y ago
- clearcoat 5y ago> passed just before the Knesset disbanded for a holiday recess by a 45-15 majority vote Wow
- Beltiras 5y agoI don't know the first thing about constitutional law in Israel but western basic sensibilities would be that this violates the principle of equality under the law.
- rsstack 5y agoThis law has existed in different variations since 2002. This law is often challenged at Israel's Supreme Court, but the racist parties usually can get a majority vote in the Parliament to "tweak it" every time to get a few more months/years out of it before getting challenged again. Similarly to how several US states change abortion/voting/gun laws all the time, trying to see if they can beat SCOTUS. This law, by the way, is unconstitutional* for more reasons than just the race-based discrimination. It defines different criteria for "permitted spouse" by gender, and has exceptions for specific religions (e.g. Druze). *Israel doesn't really have a constitution, but there are certain "core laws" that the Supreme Court decided in the '90s that it can use as a basis to strike down other laws passed by the Parliament.
- nebula8804 5y ago>This law has existed in different variations since 2002. This law is often challenged at Israel's Supreme Court, but the racist parties usually can get a majority vote in the Parliament to "tweak it" every time to get a few more months/years out of it before getting challenged again. This is the same exact tactic used by the Anti-BDS proponents in the US. On the face of it the anti-BDS laws enacted in 35 states are blatantly unconstitutional. There are two issues that have allowed them to stick around. First is the fact that it is much easier to pass a new law (however unconstitutional) than to repeal it and secondly as you alluded to, the tricks that are employed after the law is struck down is to tweak and alter the law to keep it on the books for a bit longer until the second version gets challenged. For example in Abby Martin v. the State of Georgia the original law stated that for any contract up to 1,000$ there is an exemption to the law. While she won the ruling, the end result became that the law was amended to raise the certification exemption from $1,000 to $100,000. I am not sure if they are appealing the original ruling.
- throwthere 5y agoIf you’re trying to pacify a group wouldn’t you encourage integration, instead of banning it?
- bobthechef 5y ago
- Cthulhu_ 5y agolike what China is doing with the Uyghurs? Re-education and labor camps, forced migration, forced sterilization. (not saying that's what you're advocating, just that that is one approach in use today, and given Israel's transgressions against the Palestinians I wouldn't be surprised if they were capable of that).
- sudosysgen 5y agoThey do not want integration, because Israel is, according to law makers, only meant for one ethnicity that they aren't a part of. So integration is opposed.
- xdennis 5y agoIsraelis are just being realists. If most of Israel was non-Jewish they'd be wiped off the map. The amount of hate against Jews in this post is proof enough.
- throwaway2048 5y agoCan you point to any hatred against jews here?
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoCan we sanction Israel next, please?
- bobthechef 5y agoNot likely to happen, I think. It would be construed as "antisemitic". But even apart from sanctions, Israel receives foreign aid and grants from the US.
- moltke 5y agoNot to mention the disproportionate number of Jews in the federal government that are extremely loyal to Israel.
- kergonath 5y agoUnfortunately true. It’s been darkly amusing to see the total absence of outcry when boycotts, divestments, and sanctions were decided against Russia, but somehow exactly the same thing is a crime against humanity when it’s against a segregated theocracy.
- bobthechef 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 0x_rs 5y agoIf Israel has not been sanctioned for nuclear weapons I don't see it happening, ever, for routine Palestinians discrimination.
- joshbaptiste 5y agoUSA just passed omnibus 2022 $1.5T spending bill which has $250 Million for Israel iron dome upgrades.. there is a POWERFUL Israeli lobby in the USA that won't let such sanctions get off the floor.
- joshgel 5y ago“JAFFA, March 10 (Reuters) - Israel’s parliament on Thursday passed a law denying naturalization to Palestinians from the occupied West Bank or Gaza married to Israeli citizens, forcing thousands of Palestinian families to either emigrate or live apart.” Abhorrent but not about preventing marriages, at least not directly
- spacemanmatt 5y agoNot useful analysis.
- danielvf 5y agoIt is useful. Regardless of the virtue - or strong lack thereof - of the new law, the current headline here is misleading about what was actually passed.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoI disagree that the current headline is misleading. If the substance of the article does not justify the headline in your view that's fine, but understand that most families consider being forced to remain separated to be a prohibition on being a family.
- Arubis 5y agoDoes naturalization in this particular context confer citizenship with voting rights? I’m curious if blocking shifts in the electorate is a motive for this move.
- simiones 5y agoYes, that is precisely the reason. This is what the mention of "the Jewish character" of Israel boils down to. They will also claim it is about preventing terrorism, but that is an extremely transparent fig leaf.
- themaninthedark 5y ago
- CommanderData 5y agoNo shame, they don't even hide their racism. Where's the outcry.
- throwaway4good 5y agoThe outcry is right here, obviously,
- bitcharmer 5y agoYou will see no outcry in the media because that would be antisemitism. I hate 21st century
- moltke 5y agoI don't know if you've noticed but it's usually very difficult to criticize Israel outside of the darker corners of the internet.
- themaninthedark 5y agoI would not call HN a darker corner of the internet...
- moltke 5y agoThis thread is why I said "usually."
- denton-scratch 5y ago
- nidhalbt 5y agoWe see more and more similar laws being passed in recent years, laws that are blatantly discriminatory. This may raise the indignation of many people, but in my opinion, Israel is shooting itself in the foot by passing these laws, because it reinforces the argument that it is an apartheid regime. Israel is slowly losing its support in the free democratic world where people believe in the inalienable universal rights of individuals and are less and less willing to turn a blind eye to such institutionalized racism.
- dotancohen 5y ago
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y ago>”How would Europeans react to the import of Arabs with the explicit intention of making Europe an Arab continent?” Is this meant to be some theoretical gotcha? Firstly, anyone who believes in what you’ve quoted is soundly dismissed as a paranoid conspiracy theorist - a racist one at that. Secondly, this strikes me as “you guys would pass the same law if you could get away with it”. But the main reason why this kind of law would never get passed in Europe is because it’s wrong and goes against human rights and the virtue of not discriminating based on race.
- dotancohen 5y ago> anyone who believes in what you’ve quoted is soundly dismissed as a paranoid conspiracy theorist - a racist one at that The fine article mentions explicitly that this is the goal of the marriages in question.
- aaomidi 5y agoAnd how do they go and measure that? Did they somehow reach out to the thousands of couples and ask them "hey did you take part in this subplot?" Delusional shit.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- calewis 5y ago
- jonathan-adly 5y agoThis is how the Middle East works by the way. Interreligious marriages are a very big deal and banned in every single Middle Eastern country. The good countries will refuse to issue a marriage license to you, the bad countries will send the police to watch as a mob lynches you. If you see Israel as some kind of psuedo-western state, then yea, you should be shocked. But as a Middle Eastern country, this is just another Thursday. Personally, I don't see Israel any different than I see Turkey, Egypt, or Jordan.(Allies that get lots of money from the US with questionable behavior) edit: I think is wrong by the way, so not justifying. This is just how things work in the Middle East - where nations do terrible things in the name of preserving their "religious" identity. edit x2: Sources: 1. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/markaz/2016/06/20/what-egypt-under-sissi-is-really-like-for-coptic-christians/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/markaz/2016/06/20/what-egypt-... 2. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/02/persecution-driving-christians-out-of-middle-east-report https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/02/persecution-dr... 3. Any of the State Dept religious freedoms reports here: https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-report-on-international-religious-freedom/ https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-report-on-international-r...
- A7med 5y agonot true , trying to justifying the Israel action by saying false information
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- usaar333 5y agoThis isn't really about interreligious marriages; it mostly affects Muslim Arab Israeli Citizens marrying Muslim Palestinians.
- simiones 5y agoThis is not about inter-religious marriages - this is about Arab or Christian Israeli citizens marrying other Arab or Christian Palestinians (or Lebanese and and a few other countries). This is as if the USA denied the right to extend your citizenship to a Mexican spouse - in some ways worse than the inter-religious thing.
- saltmeister 5y ago
- nix23 5y ago
- ausbah 5y ago>Some Knesset members said it was intended to prevent a gradual right of return for Palestinian refugees who were driven from their homes or fled during the 1948 war surrounding Israel's creation absolutely disgusting
- 1337shadow 5y agoYep, talking about these times when arabs were with nazis, disgusting but interesting times to read about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relations_between_Nazi_Germany_and_the_Arab_world https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relations_between_Nazi_Germany...
- idop 5y agoWho said that? Why are these "some Knesset members" not named? Is this an actual explanation provided by proponents of the law, or hyperbole said by the opponents (e.g. Arab parties)? Or bullshit invented by the jounalist? Don't be disgusted by unsubstantiated claims.
- sgregnt 5y ago
- ausbah 5y agowhy, the creation of Israel led to the expulsion of thousands of established Palestinians
- docdeek 5y agoThis article doesn’t really provide much in the way of explanation for why this law is being enacted. Here [0] is a better article that quotes supporters and objectors to the law. It includes the (IMHO not very convincing) figures that "Between 1993 and 2003, around 130,000 Palestinians were given Israeli citizenship or residency through family unification, including children, according to court filings. The Shin Bet security service told the Knesset on Monday that between 2001 and 2021, about 48 were involved in terror activities.” 48 of 130,000 amounts to 0.037% being involved in terrorist activities which seems very low to be used as justification for a law around security. [0]: https://www.timesofisrael.com/after-coalition-battle-knesset-reauthorizes-ban-on-palestinian-family-unification/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/after-coalition-battle-knesset...
- fmakunbound 5y agoHow is it that you and user adielsa paste this same reply here multiple times?
- hombre_fatal 5y agoOther user is an almost empty account that doesn't seem like an alt-account, they probably copy and pasted it.
- docdeek 5y agoI suspect they copied and pasted my original comment for some reason.
- chmod600 5y agoFrom your source: "Israeli politicians say the law is both an essential security measure to prevent Palestinian terror attacks and a means of preserving a Jewish majority in Israel." Maybe it's more of an immigration policy than a security policy?
- vkou 5y agoIt's a policy of apartheid, which is motivated by both immigration and security. Fortunately, as we have learned over the past few weeks, sanctions are an effective means of pushback against archaic 20-th century statesmanship.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- worldvoyageur 5y agoThe book of Ruth in the Hebrew bible tells the story of ~5th century BCE Israeli refugees to neighbouring Moab. The story is repeated in the old testament in the Christian Bible. In Moab, the son marries Ruth, a local Moabite woman. Even though the son dies, when conditions in Israel improve, Ruth agrees to return to Israel with her mother-in-law. Another Moabite woman who marries another of the sons refuses the opportunity to leave Moab for Israel. As the Book of Ruth makes clear, Ruth herself was a formidable woman. From her descended famous Israeli offspring such as King David, King Solomon and, if you are Christian, Jesus Christ himself.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe Christian Old Testament is the Hebrew Bible, modulo some small differences in accepted canon which vary depending on one's specific denomination.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adielsa 5y agoThis article doesn’t really provide much in the way of explanation for why this law is being enacted. Here [0] is a better article that quotes supporters and objectors to the law. It includes the (IMHO not very convincing) figures that "Between 1993 and 2003, around 130,000 Palestinians were given Israeli citizenship or residency through family unification, including children, according to court filings. The Shin Bet security service told the Knesset on Monday that between 2001 and 2021, about 48 were involved in terror activities.” 48 of 130,000 amounts to 0.037% being involved in terrorist activities which seems very low to be used as justification for a law around security.
- apricot 5y agoFrom the article: « Proponents say the law helps ensure Israel's security and maintains its "Jewish character". » Which is eerily similar to the arguments in favor of the 1935 "Law for the Protection of German Blood and German Honour" (Nurenberg laws) in Germany, which forbade marriage between Germans and Jews.
- joshenberg 5y agoThe demographic difference between the two is staggering. If all Palestinians received right of return to Israel, Jews would immediately become a political minority. The Germans had no equivalent statistical reasoning other than racism. Think about the context before you compare people to Nazis
- sterlind 5y agosounds like an argument for the two-state solution, then? Israel can't have its cake and eat it too.
- simiones 5y ago> If all Palestinians received right of return to Israel, Jews would immediately become a political minority. Ok? If Russia wins their disgusting war in Ukraine, and then tries to prevent Ukrainian refugees from returning to the homes that they left, would you say that Russia is in the right, since otherwise Russians would become a minority in Ukraine? The right is called "right of return" because these people lived there before Israel waged war on them and threw them out. Most (but certainly not all) of those waging the war were recent immigrants to Palestine, and they performed an ethnic cleansing to create their own space - extremely similar to the "living space" concept of Germany, though more necessary. The parallels are in fact striking, not absurd.
- The5thElephant 5y agoAre you suggesting all Palestinians would somehow marry an Israeli citizen?
- pessimizer 5y ago
- hyperman1 5y agoWhile the eyes of the world are looking at Russia, they are not looking at the other nasty groups of the world. Expect a lot of these groups to quickly pass all kinds of nasty laws while they have a chance.
- superfunny 5y agoThe title of this post is mis-leading, or at least incomplete. Read the article. It's about denying automatic citizenship upon marriage. It's not about barring or banning marriage.
- croes 5y agoThe title of the post is the title of the reuters article
- jgmmo 5y agowhich is also, itself, inaccurate
- DecentAI 5y agoIf you were aware of the intricacies of the jewish israeli law, you would understand that this ban is equivalent to defacto barring a ethnic minority from ever having the same civil liberties as a normal jewish born israeli. Theres no "misleading" around it.
- cs702 5y agoHere's an interesting exercise: 1. Substitute "Israel's Knesset" for ANY other legislative body anywhere. 2. Substitute "Palestinian" for ANY other nationality, ethnicity, race, sexual orientation, or other adjective describing a group to which YOU belong. 3. See if you like how it feels: "[Legislative body] passes law barring spouses who are [like you] from becoming citizens."
- StreamBright 5y agoI am fine with that. Actually most of my life I have lived by these restrictions. I am not saying this is ok, but we should stop pretending this is not everywhere. For example US immigration system. Based on your nationality there are restrictions. As non-US immigrant my wife could not work in the US based on our nationality.
- ec109685 5y agoOnce you are a citizen of the US though, regardless of where your spouse is from, there is equal opportunity to become a citizen. That is different than Israel since Jewish spouses can become citizens while non-Jewish spouses can’t, even if the person they are married to is an Israel citizen.
- thatsmyfribble 5y agoThis law doesn't restrict marriages, it restricts citizenship through marriages for Palestinians. I'm not defending that but I am clarifying it.
- orange_joe 5y agoInterfaith marriage is illegal (people with money have interfaith marriages overseas), and if you have a child with a married partner of another faith the child will not have the father on the birth certificate.
- cs702 5y agoThanks! You're right. I changed my comment. FYI, I was trying to hew as closely as possible to the OP's headline, which isn't inaccurate.
- catchclose8919 5y ago...there was some sketch about a neonazi who gets a 23andme genetic tests and finds out he's of Jewish descent, and after the initial shock he's like: But wait, this means I already have that ethno-state I've always dreamed of!
- dotancohen 5y ago
- claviola 5y agoYou've mentioned "third- and fourth- wives" multiple times in this thread. Can you clarify? Israel doesn't allow polygamy, so how does that work? And do you happen to have proof that there's a conspiracy to increase the Arabic population? And even if somehow there _is_ one, isn't that something a democratic country should not care about?
- dotancohen 5y agoIn Israel, polygamy is forbidden to Jews. The Muslims practice polygamy, I have many friends with multiple wives.
- detaro 5y agoLegally recognized multiple wives? Because according to the sources I can find, that has been illegal for decades, regardless of religion.
- dotancohen 5y agoI don't know about internet sources or laws, but in general Arab affairs are left up to the Arabs. I just took a look through my telephone and at least four people in my address book have multiple wives. These are people that I know well enough to have in my address book. Two of them I'd call personal friends, one is an electrician, and another I buy my gas from. I could probably find more in there, and I certainly know of many more.
- estaseuropano 5y agoThis is still not answering the question whether these are legally recognized wives; whether they have residenve./nationality rights, right to work, etc
- dqpb 5y agoCan’t read the article. Is this a cultural/religious thing or a race thing?
- thatsmyfribble 5y agoYou can get by the Reuters paywall in an incognito window.
- credit_guy 5y agoIs there a chance that the Israeli Supreme Court act as a check and balance in this matter? Edit: Because if it doesn’t, this puts a question mark over the whole idea of democracy all around the world.
- ngc248 5y ago>>> Because if it doesn’t, this puts a question mark over the whole idea of democracy all around the world. When you say democracy, what exactly do you mean? Most democratic countries have representative democracy, where they choose representatives who pass the laws. This was passed in the Israeli parliament. This is democracy at work isn't it? There is no direct democracy in the world. I am not supporting the law just discussing what you mean by democracy.
- credit_guy 5y agoBy democracy I mean the system in place in the US or Western Europe and a number of other countries. In other words, a system with checks and balances. A system with tools in place to avoid injust outcomes due to the tyrany of the majority (or a minority). For example, if a majority of a country wants segregated schools, that does not make it right. A true democracy is not one where people just shrug and say “well, if this is the will of the people, that settles it”. A true democracy is one where “Brown vs Board of Education” can happen.
- jcranberry 5y agoTerrible title. >Israel’s parliament on Thursday passed a law denying naturalization to Palestinians from the occupied West Bank or Gaza married to Israeli citizens, forcing thousands of Palestinian families to either emigrate or live apart. The actual law is bad enough as is.
- sgregnt 5y agoCurrent Knesset coalition is supported by Arab parties... looks like Israeli Palestinian support this measure to a certain extend.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- talhof8 5y agoOff-topic: Calling the Second Intifada an "uprising" is hell of a unique way of whitewashing suicide bombings. Nothing rebellious about that, just sheer terrorism.
- ambrozk 5y agoWhat are you talking about? The fact that an uprising involves terroristic tactics does not make it less of an uprising. Trying to prevent people from calling the Intifada an uprising (which is the literal translation of the word) is playing word-games for rhetorical points, not discussing reality.
- talhof8 5y agoI’m talking about drawing a false romantic narrative of an uprising of the people, when the reality is it’s just terror. Lets call it a Terroristic Uprising, more suiting.
- ambrozk 5y agoI will repeat what I said, which is that this is rhetorical point-scoring, not discussion of reality. It's not helpful. Everyone with two neurons to rub together understands that both the Palestinians and the Israelis have engaged in terror against one another over the course of a century of inter-ethnic conflict.
- talhof8 5y agoNone of the comments here are helpful. You could call it however you like, rhetorical point-scoring or not, to the vast majority of people who read the word “uprising” it comes off as this romantic movement of liberation. As an Israeli this bothers me. Needles to say it bothers me even more when Israelis do this towards the other side. For me, this is very much a reality and not just a “words game”. BTW, this is not to say I agree with this law.
- thatsmyfribble 5y agoFirst of all, this isn't a ban on Israeli-Palestinian marriage, this is a restriction on the ability to gain citizenship through those marriages. I don't agree with that, but I do think it's important to clarify. Regarding comments I'm seeing here saying Israel is an apartheid state or that Israel is racist or that Israel the concept of a Jewish state is disgusting: Israel is the size of New Jersey. It is the only state on earth there is a Jewish majority. There are many places on earth where there is a Christian majority, and there are many places on earth where there is a Muslim majority. The Jewish people represent a tiny percent of the world's population in part because they have been expelled from their homes throughout history, and the majority of them were killed in the 1940s. Why does it matter to have a Jewish state? Because it is a measure of defense against what has happened countless times throughout history. The problem with a Jewish state in Israel: Obviously, Israel, and especially Jerusalem, is a holy state for multiple groups. Those groups have a justifiable interest in living in Israel and enjoying the same rights as Israeli citizens. The issue is that if citizenship is freely given, Jews become the minority in Israel and it is no longer a Jewish state. If you say "Good," to that, that is your opinion, and I will add that there are Jewish Israelis who agree with you. There is debate in Israel and abroad whether Israel should be a Jewish state of a state of the Jews. In the latter, there is more room for Palestinians--as it stands, this is not the policy of the current coalition. Israel was not built by its founders to be a melting pot, it was built as a home for displaced Jewish people. It was not built to be a place of equality, and unfortunately, by its nature it cannot be one and continue to serve its purpose. If you think that purpose is racist, you are entitled to that opinion, but there are many who believe what Jews have faced throughout history justify a Jewish homeland, and it is very difficult to have a Jewish homeland, at least in Israel, without maintaining a Jewish majority.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y ago"Israel was not built by its founders to be a melting pot, it was built as a home for displaced Jewish people. It was not built to be a place of equality, and unfortunately, by its nature it cannot be one and continue to serve its purpose. If you think that purpose is racist, you are entitled to that opinion, but there are many who believe what Jews have faced throughout history justify a Jewish homeland, and it is very difficult to have a Jewish homeland, at least in Israel, without maintaining a Jewish majority. " So it was built to be an 'institutionally racially segregated' state?
- eric_b 5y agoI don't condone this law, but I think people here are missing an opportunity for understanding. I see so much black-vs-white moral righteousness on HN lately when really, the world is a sea of grey. And understanding a thing does not mean agreeing with a thing. But a little empathy might soften the inflammatory rhetoric. Israel is proud of their Jewish heritage, and are generally surrounded by millions of people from other ethnic and religious backgrounds who hate them. I mean, it is very common to hear people in countries near Israel openly calling for death to the Jews or destruction of the Jewish state (essentially advocating genocide). Hell, I remember tweets from the Ayatollah promoting violence against Israel, and Twitter just let it fly. In light of all the historical context and current geographical situation, I can understand the motivation to have a law like this. Whether it's morally just, effective, or just openly racist is certainly up for debate, but to me it is not so clear-cut as others would say.
- Shadonototra 5y agoWhen you combine everything together, all of the geopolitical issues, the end game becomes pretty clear..
- veltas 5y agoWhy has this article been flagged?
- walkhour 5y agoMost comments here are attacking the decision, or just quoting the decision, and following it up by a "wtf". Just being shocked is not an argument. Jews are or have been persecuted in all middle eastern countries. What would happen if they were a minority in a democratic state in the Middle East? Why would it be different than in the other democracies in the Middle East? Laws like these lower the probability of Jews becoming a minority in Israel. Do you think the probability of them becoming a minority is zero? And the probability of them being persecuted provided they become a minority is zero? Unless you think both probabilities are very low you must understand their concerns. You may agree with their concerns or not, I don't, but this is what must be addressed when criticizing these laws. Saying this is apartheid means nothing because the situation is not analogous.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Just being shocked is not an argument. Most people don't feel the need to argue against openly legislated apartheid; we can just be shocked. If I see a car crash, I don't argue with it either. Everybody understands that laws like this are essential for building up an ethnostate, but most people don't think that's a defense.
- walkhour 5y agoDon't get me wrong, I'm shocked as well, I just think that's not enough, you have to at least be able to justify why the two probabilities that I mentioned before are small, which in my opinion, is a hard thing to do.
- mattnewton 5y agoI think most of us are so used to the principles of pluralism and minority rights, accepting it as an axiom, that it doesn't occur to argue that an ethnostate is desirable, necessary, and worth the cost to the displaced ethnicities. Doesn't occur is maybe the wrong word, it occurs as an alien and dangerous idea, like gazing into the maw of a tiger. Does it not feel dangerous to you, to even start weighing the needs of one ethnicity against the needs of another?
- adn 5y agoWhy was this post flagged?
- napmo 5y agoWhat do you expect from an apartheid regime, created on the ashes of another country, Palestine?
- hersko 5y agoWhen was Palestine a country?
- monkaiju 5y ago
- g8oz 5y agoThe parallels to the Jim Crow South and its borderline hysterical obsession with managing the ethno-racial balance are very strong.
- nec4b 5y agoIsrael would cease to exist if there was no Jewish majority anymore. Just one more Arab country instead. Would you be ok with that?
- DecentAI 5y agoYes! They can rightfully "go back" to where they came from, hows that sound?
- nec4b 5y agoThey are where they came from. What do you mean?
- g8oz 5y agoIf the "national vision" can only be realized by oppression maybe there is something wrong with it.
- nec4b 5y agoThere are plenty of countries where "national vision" is realized without an oppression to minorities. You think Israel shouldn't exist?
- sempron64 5y agoConsider the following word replacements. [Ukraine/Israel] is established as an ethnic state after the end of the [Soviet/British] regime. [Ukraine/Israel] passes laws to protect its language and national identity in the face of its neighboring [Russia/Arab states] [Ukraine/Israel] is persecuting its [Russian/Arab] minorities by enacting discriminatory laws. [Ukraine/Israel] does not recognize [DNR/Palestinian] statehood. Obviously the parallels are not perfect, but the key is to understand that the Israeli right wing views Palestinians as Arabs, not as an independent nation, and views the establishment of the West Bank as a Jordanian/Arab land grab. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Arab_Republic https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Arab_Republic I’m not trying to assign right or wrong here, but trying to say that these sort of actions are not about pure evil racism than the outcome of regional conflict, and are much less one-dimensional than they are made out to be. As essentially all conflicts are. Racism/apartheid is one-dimensional, and this is not the same. In other news, Israel appointed the first Muslim justice to its Supreme Court. https://m.jpost.com/israel-news/article-698154/amp https://m.jpost.com/israel-news/article-698154/amp Racism exists in Israel just as it does in America even though Barack Obama was elected president, and as it does in almost all countries. But its disingenuous to call Israel an apartheid state.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> [Ukraine/Israel] is persecuting its [Russian/Arab] minorities by enacting discriminatory laws The analogy doesn’t hold here. Ukraine shouldn’t persecute it’s Russian minority. (Hell, it’s Russian-speaking cities are lobbing Molotov cocktails at the invaders.) And Palestine isn’t mounting an invasion of Israel, though if they had the capability, it’s uncertain they wouldn’t—the Arab nations tried twice.
- sempron64 5y agoUkraine passed laws banning the Russian language, which was one of the excuses made by Russia to begin this conflict.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoLook I always encourage people to read the Israeli constitution. Jewish state. Fact. Not multicultural, not secular. Jewish. That was the founders design.
- belter 5y agoWhere does that leave non observant Jews?
- jl6 5y agoPresumably not a problem as Jewish is an ethnicity as well as a religion.
- belter 5y agoSo if a non observant Jew wants to operate a shop on the Shabbat...then?
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoThen their shop isn't certified as kosher and can't make food for religious customers, but otherwise, it works fine. I've gone to convenience stores, cafes, restaurants, movie theaters, etc dozens of times on Shabbat, in Israel.
- pthread_t 5y agoWere you able to take the trains? Buses?
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoYes, of course. I lived in Haifa, which kept its bus rapid-transit system and several bus lines running all through Shabbat. This was especially helpful for the nighttime bus lines, so I could go to the beach on Friday afternoon, eat dinner and see a movie at Lev haMifratz with friends in the evening, and then get home at maybe 1-2am, all with public transit.
- LightG 5y ago"Russia passes law denying naturalization to Ukranian spouses"
- sparky_ 5y agoWhat citizenship status do Palestianians have by default, if not Israeli? Given that Israel doesn't recognise Palestine as a state, doesn't that obligate them to confer Israeli citizenship to the residents, as they would otherwise be stateless?
- throwaway2048 5y agoThere is no obligation for any state to issue citizenship to anyone, unfortunately.
- martinflack 5y agoThere are UN conventions[1][2] on statelessness that do require the bound parties to provide citizenship under very narrow conditions, essentially to avoid a stateless person. IANAL so I don't know if they apply in this type of example. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Status_of_Stateless_Persons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Sta... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_the_Reduction_of_Statelessness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_the_Reduction_of...
- throwaway2048 5y agoNot only have most states not signed this, there is no meaningful penalty for ignoring it.
- s_dev 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Status_of_Stateless_Persons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Sta...
- bhouston 5y agoI believe that Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are essentially stateless. It is similar to the South African Bantustans where you put an undesirable population so that they have a little bit of self-government so that you can justify excluding them from the electorate of the main nation, but not enough to actually be their own country, so you can essentially still manage that land.
- karmafish 5y agoIsrael has lost my support. It has become an apartheid regime. Its treatment of Palestinians is morally and legally reprehensible.
- asah 5y agoOk this is about security... so what's the alternative? ...and the answer is easy: marry anyone you want, but there'll be enhanced background checks for some people.
- borski 5y agoJust to be clear: the law bans citizenship for Palestinians on the basis of marriage to an Israeli citizen, but does not ban marriages or naturalization in other ways that aren’t marriage, right? Or am I missing something here?
- starik36 5y agoBasically marriage doesn't grant one Israeli citizenship. That is all. You can still marry whomever you want.
- lozenge 5y agoAll weddings are Jewish in Israel so that would already prevent a Palestinian from marrying an Israeli. They can however marry in another country and Israel would recognise the marriage.
- idop 5y agoUh, no. Non-Jewish citizens are not required to have a Jewish wedding. Jewish citizens are.
- jmyeet 5y agoIsrael is an apartheid state, a claim now explicitly made by Amnesty International [1]. Pick any number of highlights: - Denying citizenship to Palestinians (and other Muslims); - The Palestinian residence card system. Families that cannot be reunited because of it; - Population quotas in Jerusalem. Palestinians who have it and leave to, say, go to college will be deemed to have abandoned their residency to maintain this quota; - Palestinians have separate roads to keep them away from Israelis; - Palestinian settlements are then further separated by Jewish settlements. These were once deemed illegal but any pretense of removing them has long since disappeared. So it may now take hours to go a mile because of all the new security checkpoints; - Denying Palestinians building permits and then demolishing anything they build because it's not permitted; and - Rampant use of collective punishment by the IDF. From the video as one example, kids throwing rocks lead to IDF setting up checkpoints with the explicit purpose of inconveniencing and delaying everyone as a (collective) punishment. Gaza is an open air prison [2]. Any criticism of these rampant human rights violation gets labelled as being anti-Semitic. It's anti-Israeli. There's a difference. In the present Ukraine war many have criticized the (illegal) annexation of Crimea by Russia in 2014. Where is the outrage over, say, Israel's annexation of the Golan Heights? Worse, Russia's annexation has been repeatedly confirmed by Western NGOs as being widely popular with the actual Crimeans [3]. You can legitimately criticize Russia for the Crimean annexation. That's a completely reasonable position. But if you're going to do that, how is the Golan Heights different? The same goes for any self-determination arguments, as an aside. If Ukraine has the right to self-determination with respect to, say, NATO membership, why don't Crimeans have the right to to join Russia? [1]: https://vimeo.com/674482282?embedded=true&source=vimeo_logo&owner=87399582 https://vimeo.com/674482282?embedded=true&source=vimeo_logo&... [2]: https://www.nrc.no/news/2018/april/gaza-the-worlds-largest-open-air-prison/ https://www.nrc.no/news/2018/april/gaza-the-worlds-largest-o... [3]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2015/03/20/one-year-after-russia-annexed-crimea-locals-prefer-moscow-to-kiev/?sh=2fb11f45510d https://www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2015/03/20/one-year-a...
- snird 5y agoFalse. Israeli government has Arab list in it, with Arab ministers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Arab_List https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Arab_List Not the parliament - the government itself. This is by definition not an apartheid state. This law denying citizenship is to block a loophole used by known terrorists to come into Israel and explode Jews on busses. Here are some examples for you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_HaSharon_Mall_suicide_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_HaSharon_Mall_suicide_bom... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sbarro_restaurant_suicide_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sbarro_restaurant_suicide_bomb... Why should Israelis allow a terrorist loophole in? Would you allow a way for terrorists to kill you and your family in your home country? I didn't think so.
- ngneer 5y agoWhat's the connection to technology? Why is this on HN?
- stiltzkin 5y agoNo surprise coming from Israel.
- diebeforei485 5y agoYeah but they're white people so it's alright.
- HeavyStorm 5y agoWhy is that an issue? Palestine is not Ukraine, after all.
- bjourne 5y agoTweeted by an Israeli minister after the law passed: https://i.imgur.com/gQOJFu0.png https://i.imgur.com/gQOJFu0.png
- sgregnt 5y agoIsrael government has Arab parties in its coalition, meaning that this law is supported by Israeli Palestinians. I think this is a strong indication that the issue is not as straightforward as some people trying to paint it, indeed Israeli Palestinians themself support this measure.
- frozencell 5y agoSoon: `Israel passes law denying naturalisation to Russian spouses`
- DuckyNY 5y agoI live in Israel, but I now want to move to HN land. I do have an opinion, but it is not really important here. I just want to say how touched I am to read this thread. Where else can you find such a polite, fact based, open minded discussion of a flammable topic.
- ethics13 5y ago