15 ms·
It’s time to admit quantum theory has reached a dead end
- jijji 5y agoThe author writes that he is "still waiting for a straight answer as to what the structure of the atoms that make up my body is". The answer to this is more of a biochemistry or molecular biology question than a quantum physics question.
- layer8 5y agoHe didn’t mean the structures between the atoms, but the structures within the atoms.
- jleyank 5y agoFrom the point of view of chemistry, QM “works”. It provides results that can be tested experimentally and predictions that can be validated. There are issues with computability but that’s more engineering than science. Determining structure, spectra and other physical properties is quite helpful. What was the cliche? All theories are wrong, some theories are useful. It needs to be rephrased from vector codes into massively parallel codes but people can work with that.
- jiggawatts 5y agoTo me, this always felt like programmers excusing abhorrent code with "but it works". Quantum theory isn't. It's not a single, cohesive, consistent theory.[1] There is no recipe you can apply, it's just a bunch of guessworks and heuristics that happen to produce the numerically correct equations if you keep trying long enough. This isn't secret or some sort of external criticism, you'll find this front-and-centre in the foreword of many a QM text! Schrödinger famously arrived at his equation basically through numerical methods. He just tried things until it "fit" the desired output. Now, there's nothing wrong with this, per-se. It's a perfectly viable approach for getting going, for getting something and using it as a starting point. But it isn't the endpoint, because approaches like this often have virtually no explanatory power. A similar example is collecting insects, categorising them, giving them Latin names, and putting them up for display in a museum. You can learn a lot, amass enormous amounts of information, but without a theory of genetics and natural selection you will always be blind to the underlying truth of it all. QM is just like bug collecting. We're collecting numerical equations that work, but we have essentially no clear understanding why. We've built a tree of life, and nobody has had the lightbulb moment that explains why it's a tree. [1] There was a paper published a few years back where a bunch of working quantum physicists were asked some simple multiple-choice questions about the fundamentals of the theory. There was no consensus opinion on anything! PS: You'll get similar results if you ask priests of a random Christian sects about the basics of religion. Conversely, you will get nearly zero disagreement if asking Chemists about the basics of their science.
- spekcular 5y agoCome on. We have plenty of good heuristics for why things are the way they are. Quantum theory is no more a bunch of "guessworks and heuristic" than Newtonian mechanics. Also, physicists disagreeing on interpretational issues related to quantum foundations is not the same thing as disagreeing about the fundamentals of the theory.
- mhh__ 5y agoThe things that Schrodinger tried are still valid physics, just for different systems. He didn't know that, but now we do, this has little bearing on modern physics. Also chemists have the luxury of agreeing because the fundamentals of their work (not the day to day act of doing chemistry) gets to assume the presence of physics i.e. it's stampkeeping (depending on who you ask).
- jleyank 5y agoNot quite stamp collecting, although botany or anatomy head in that direction. Call chemistry “just applied physics” as engineering is “just applied science”.
- mhh__ 5y agoI prefer to call engineering "physics ruined by philistines" (sometimes at least, engineers seem to have a unique ability to take beautiful physics and notate it in the most cumbersome "safe" way possible)
- dekhn 5y agoIt's a quote ascribed to Rutherford ("all science is physics or just stamp collecting"). I also heard it when studying protein structures in the 90s (the idea being, if you're just a crystallographer cranking out more structures, you're doing stamp collecting; the real reason to determine structures is to elucidate the general principles of protein folding and function). Note that protein structure prediction finally fell to machine learning and it was "mostly stamp collecting" (IE, the accurate predictions come from subtle analysis of rich protein sequence alignments, not from understanding the fundamental principles of protein folding).
- tus666 5y agoYes, but go back to philosophy not math. All the evidence suggests the "particle" interpretation of QM is simply wrong, that light or energy really is just a self propagating wave, which explains the double slit experiment cleanly, and is not incompatible with energy levels or quantization if formulated correctly. Experiments that claim to show light consists of particles need to be reassessed wearing a philosopher's hat.
- wpietri 5y agoCould you point to some articles on this? It's way outside of my field, but it sounds very interesting.
- tus666 5y agoIt is more than just interesting, it's the central unsolved conundrum in physics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_m...
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI thought GUT was at the core of modern physics studies?
- mhh__ 5y agoThe person you are replying to is either wrong or has stated it very badly. The idea of their being both a wave and particle based description of photons that don't mix well is basically physics as known in the 1920s. The modern theoretical framework of light is quantum field theory (special relativity + quantum mechanics, but actually not quite that for [insert qft textbook] reasons...), which doesn't fit into either of those old ideals particularly well because they are basically shadows of an underlying model projected at different angles. Edit (further detail): The way physics is taught in British secondary schools is a tragedy - ignoring that you don't even learn the fundamentals properly (no calculus!) - you aren't given a non-mathematical outline of these modern theories. In their eyes quantum mechanics has not really advanced beyond the photoelectric effect, which is where unhelpful weirdness like you'll see in this thread comes from.
- geijoenr 5y agoFor some time already we are in an "epicyclean phase" of physics, trapped by the extraordinary predictive success of Quantum Electrodynamics and still using mathematical methods devised in the 19th century (variational calculus). This has lead us to the current situation, with extremely complicated theories at the limit of human understanding that bear no new results. It will take a modern day Copernicus to come up with a new view of physics, that will result in simpler, more productive models, to take us out of the local maximum we are in.
- floxy 5y agoHmm, a new kind of science.
- aeternum 5y agoWolfram has a proposal, by that very name. Hasn't yet made useful predictions though.
- vba616 5y agoDue to the mixed reviews, I haven't bothered to read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_New_Kind_of_Science even though I assume that the target audience is more or less people who were fascinated with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos:_Making_a_New_Science
- OneLeggedCat 5y agoI read this humongous damn thing around 2004. It's not worth it.
- beaconstudios 5y agoAre more modern information-theoretic and dynamical models not used for quantum mechanics? They're both relatively recent and extremely innovative mathematical models. Granted, I'm not mathematically fluent enough to know if they represent a deviation from variational calculus!
- earedpiece 5y agoI get your point, how long do we keep digging before we reach the center of the earth? It is human nature to quit, most especially, when there is no foreseeable benefits. But think about it this way, science is like the human body. The head of science, are those scientists who make a new discovery by going through research articles of their predescessors, who were just 1 mm from digging up gold. The necks are those scientists, who almost made a new discovery, but couldn't see the light at the end of the tunnel. And the legs, are the early scientist like Galileo, who laid the ground work. Anyways, wherever you find yourself, it is imperative you don't lose faith in the process. Afterall, everybody mocked the Wright brothers, for building a plane. And most advanced scientist question, why they venture into this field called science, afterall it is a labor of love, and only the lucky few get glorified. But I get your point through and through, it is better scientists pour in their brains in more linear science, like things we can see and computate, instead of pouring brain power in abstract concept that has no current benefit in the present society.
- stevebmark 5y agoSigh, yet another Nautil.us article. One or two meaningful paragraphs buried in a clickbait title by someone bored with their own academic work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zem 5y agoI'm not sure what your complaint with this particular piece is. it seemed like a coherent and well explained argument that the current interpretations of quantum mechanics might just be a blind alley caused by starting from the wrong mathematical foundations - you needn't agree, and the author themself admits that most physicists wouldn't either - but it's not by any means clickbait; it delivers exactly what the title promises.
- jdrc 5y agoMaybe start connecting the structures in our brains with the structures in our math. The limited representational capacity of meat-based brains is probably constraining what can be understood. Even math may be too constrained to go beyond current level of detail. I imagine an AI doing its own experiments with the universe will have unbounded understanding, but i doubt we d be able to understand her when she tries to explain to us puny humans
- newsbinator 5y agoI'm surprised humans have gotten this far in understanding the rules of the universe and making accurate predictions. There's no evolutionary reason why we would have: our brains only hold like 7 ~ 11 things in working memory, we're almost always thinking about either food, entertainment, sleep, or sex, we can't conceptualize infinities, we're stuck living in linear time at 1 second per second, our long term memory is so full of holes it's practically non-existent, etc. Either we're unexpectedly capable at making the most of our wetware or the universe is unexpectedly simple to understand.
- jrapdx3 5y agoYou may be on to something. Sure human working memory (insofar as our measurement tools can tell us) seems to be limited to single-digit datasets, and long-term (that is, persistent) memory is poorly understood but research portrays that it's a pile of more or less random bits. It's a subject of professional interest to me for decades, what impresses me is how much isn't known about how our built-in "computer" actually works. Above all neurons are extraordinarily intricate structures, and beyond that the contributions of non-neurons in the brain appear to be considerable. Given that the brain contains at least 100's of millions of participating neurons organized in a complex hierarchical network, no wonder it's still not possible to adequately account for many relatively simple phenomena let alone the emergence of towering genius. Indeed our wetware is collectively both more capable (and more limited) than we generally appreciate. Definitely we can't predict where genius will arise, it always seems to surprise when it happens. To say it's a miracle may be naive, but perhaps that just expresses wonder and gratitude for a rare, random and highly fortuitous event.
- dzdt 5y agoOne avenue for progress that the author overlooks is distinguising between quantum mechanics interpretations where wave function collapse is considered part of the theory vs. where wave function collapse is considered to be a useful approximation. I expect as we see quantum computers increase in scale it will become more apparent and accepted that there is no such thing as "collapse": that is just the approximation for a large system including the observer becoming entangled with a smaller quantum system under consideration. I think even the disillusioned author here would have to take that as progress.
- henning 5y agoMost of the bright people who could potentially come up with a major breakthrough would rather make >= 10x the money working as quants for hedge funds, software engineers/data scientists/product managers at FAANG or other adtech, or developing copy-and-paste pump and dump shitcoins named after Elon Musk's dog.
- q-big 5y agoIn my experience, it is not really the money in the corporate job market that drives these people away from research: Not USA, but I know some really highly talented physicists who now work as rather badly paid software developers. Lesson: outstanding skills in and passion for physics not necessarily tranfer into high pay in the corporate job market. It is rather the politicization and lack of perspective in academia that makes these people leave academia: doing your PhD/doctorial degree in physics already bears a high opportunity cost, so you really do that because you have a deep passion for physics and not because you expect a high pay.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoEven on the macro level there are lots of tricky questions. A bar magnet is surrounded by magnetic flux lines. Apparently it takes no energy to maintain that magnetic field. If I heat the bar in boiling water for long enough, it becomes demagnetized. On the macro level there's no visible/measureable change in the bar. We need a lot of magnification to see that the 'particles are no longer aligned'. On the other hand, I move the bar magnet over a pile of iron filings, some of the filings will fly up against gravity to the bar, against the force of gravity. It takes energy to lift these filings. Where does that energy come from? (It never seems to be exhausted.)
- pshc 5y agoThe energy comes from the incredible magnetic force spent to align the atoms when the magnet was created, and it will be slowly exhausted over time.
- esteth 5y agoWhy would it be exhausted over time? When things come close to the magnet it uses its potential energy to pull them. When some force acts to remove those objects from the magnetic field, that energy is converted into potential in the magnet again. Are you claiming that the alignment of the magnet will fade slowly over time when the field is interacted with, more quickly than it would if it were left on a proverbial shelf for millions of years?
- pshc 5y agoYeah, that was my claim, that the atoms will slowly return to a chaotic high-entropy organization over time, and more rapidly as forces are exerted against the magnet. I guess I was wrong.
- hither_shores 5y ago> that the atoms will slowly return to a chaotic high-entropy organization over time, and more rapidly as forces are exerted against the magnet This is true, it's just not why magnets can lift things.
- yyyk 5y ago>But the researchers concede that the result will make no difference to anyone who believes in Many-Worlds, Copenhagen, or Pilot-Wave Theory. It only reduces the range of options by one, at most. This is a bit too pessimistic. There's the possibility their experiment will confirm local realist retrocasuality (by finding a result different from what typical QM would suggest) - at which point we will have reduced the options considerably.
- donutdan4114 5y agoDoes anything think Wolfram Theory is going to end up being the right approach to go deeper down the rabbit hole? Personally I think the theory is really interesting and intuitively feels like the universe at some core level may work as the theory suggests. But I’m not sure if many people are considering the theory to have serious promise in the long term.
- analog31 5y agoIt has to find the rabbit hole first. So far as I understand, Wolfram theory hasn't yet been testable against any experimental data. So it's 100 years behind quantum theory. And in the final analysis, even if it achieves the same exquisite accuracy as quantum theory, will it do any better with the problem that really bugs people, which is the ability to tell us what we're really made of? That's the problem stated at the beginning of the article: >>> But I’m still waiting for a straight answer as to what the structure of the atoms that make up my body is.
- bsedlm 5y agorelevant (but introductory level): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KunEYnIaGGc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KunEYnIaGGc
- fennecs 5y agoAmusing to see all the pessimistic comments form programmers who have zero understanding beyond high school maths thinking somehow there is a magic solution to all the problems in physics like you can just refactor everything. Quantum field theory is definitely not stuck in the 1920s. Modern physics has a lot more going on than 19th century mathematics. We understand quite a lot about the mathematical structure underpinning quantum field theories. Quantisation is a nearly well understood process, it’s not simply heuristics and guesswork. Unfortunately, it’s not like much smarter than anyone posting here haven’t considered lots of wild ideas, it’s just that a lot of them haven’t worked, and we have been funnelled into what we currently have. There are infinitely many more interesting mathematical objects and ideas possible than what is allowed. Quantum mechanics, or say quantum field theory, has really good predictive power. What ever comes next needs to at least be consistent. Unfortunately I think things are going to get more complicated. Don’t use your intuition developed from grinding out web crap to try and reason about the forefront of human knowledge.
- selfhifive 5y agoWhile I do get what you're trying to say, it has to be said that many CS people have been exposed to Quantum Physics. Quantum computing is an elective at every half-decent University. To think that programmers have zero understanding beyond high school math is just ignorant.
- ravi-delia 5y agoAt least for me and my classmates, we got a lot more wrong before we got right. Nothing is worse in this world than an undergrad fresh out of an intro quantum class with a neutered Schrodinger's equation and whatever nonsense pseudo-philosophy they picked up to deal with it. After taking a proper mathematical methods class you start to get the beginnings of an intuition for what's going on for quantum mechanics.
- selfhifive 5y agoI agree. EPR states and Quantum teleportation gave us a reality check during our QC course. The university I come from did however teach linear algebra, ODEs and PDEs, etc as mandatory courses.
- ISL 5y agoI disagree strongly with the author's pull-quote that "We know nothing more than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, and Heisenberg." There has been roughly a century worth of experiments since the quantum theory came into being. Those experiments have scythed through myriad attempts to explain the mechanism by which quantum theory apparently describes reality. Physicists can choose between interpretations of quantum mechanics according to "taste" precisely because there are no observable ways to differentiate between them. As soon as those ways become available to us, "taste" will give way to experimental tests. There is still ample room for cleverness. Experimentalists are pushing forward where we can, but another observation like Bell's might be sufficient to allow, pardon the pun, a quantum leap.
- shoyer 5y agoAs former quantum physicist, I find it little troubling to read "quantum theory has reached a dead end" in specific reference to the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Most quantum physicists could not care less about how quantum mechanics is interpreted when it makes highly accurate quantitative predictions, and there are still plenty of interesting open problems for quantum theory (e.g., related to the practical design of algorithms and hardware for quantum computers). This article also misses what is likely the leading interpretation of quantum mechanics by actual quantum physicists, namely that the measurment problem is solved by decoherence (the quantitative theory of how classical states emerge from quantum states): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem#The_role_of_decoherence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem#The_role_o... https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2011.0490 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2011.049...
- adriand 5y agoI read somewhere that quantum mechanics is the most tested of all scientific theories. And it has been shown to be right, every time. Hawking espoused this idea he called “model dependent realism”. The idea is that every human understanding of reality is model-dependent, that is, it is not “reality” that we truly understand (we can’t) but rather in every case we have some model of reality that is useful in particular situations. For instance, we know that Newtonian physics are not “real” but they are perfectly accurate in certain situations. So they are not “wrong” when they are used in those situations, in fact, they are right. The author of the article writes, “While Einstein won a Nobel Prize for proving that light is composed of particles that we call photons, Schrödinger’s equation characterizes light and indeed everything else as wave-like radiation. Can light and matter be both particle and wave? Or neither? We don’t know.” In model dependent realism, we can ignore this apparent contradiction. In some situations the model of light as a particle is the most useful, and in others, the model where it is a wave is the most useful. We have to accept that it is not “really” either of these models, but that no matter what we do, any model we come up with for it will still just be a model.
- colordrops 5y agoApparently Hawking coined this term in 2010. Robert Anton Wilson coined a similar term, "Model Agnosticism", all the way back in 1977 in his book Cosmic Trigger: "The Copenhagen Interpretation is sometimes called "model agnosticism" and holds that any grid we use to organize our experience of the world is a model of the world and should not be confused with the world itself. Alfred Korzybski, the semanticist, tried to popularize this outside physics with the slogan, "The map is not the territory." Alan Watts, a talented exegete of Oriental philosophy, restated it more vividly as "The menu is not the meal."
- mrfusion 5y agoAnyone can explain superdeterminism in a simple way? That sounds interesting.
- astrange 5y agoExplanation 0: QM, unlike classical physics, says quantum effects are truly random and unpredictable and we can only know their probability distribution. (Or something like that.) Explanation 1: The universe is not random and doesn't have cause and effect. All scientific experiments appear to work because the whole universe is actually a movie playing out where each new frame has been edited to produce the results we see, but for some reason the author decided to never violate QM. Explanation 2: Unlike what QM predicts (true randomness) there's a finite amount of randomness added at the beginning of the universe, enough that our experiments appear to follow QM, but eventually if we looked hard enough there would be a predictable result with finite entropy. So it's actually regular determinism. A few people claim #2 is true and doesn't imply #1. Everyone else thinks they're the same and doesn't like it for philosophical reasons. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ytyjgIyegDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ytyjgIyegDI
- zw123456 5y agoI agree, there are limits to our understanding right now. Whether it is QM, or Dark M/E, etc. A lot of these constructs feel strained to me at times. But. having said that, I am guessing, that back when the cutting edge was Maxwell, and Lorentz, and along came a burst of genius, named in the article, Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, and Heisenberg, and I would include Pauli, Godel and probably a bunch of others. My prediction is that there will be a burst of insight and innovation, these things tend to come in clumps, when a lot of people start "riffing" off of each other. There is no way to predict when, but I only hope I am still breathing to witness it!
- dfdz 5y agoThe quotes from scientists at the end of the article nicely summarize my opinion on this article: > Deutsch, too, seemed impatient with my dissatisfaction over our understanding of the nature of reality. “Someone might equally well say: We may know what dogs look like and how they behave, but we don’t know what a dog ‘actually is’,”
- jml7c5 5y agoYou are led into a room. The far wall is covered in levers, buttons, dials, flashing lights, oscilloscope displays, buzzers, and so on. The person who brought you there says "we need you to describe the mechanism behind this wall. You're not allowed to look behind the wall. Good luck!" They leave the room. You walk up to the wall and press a button. A few feet away, a light flashes green. You press the button again. The same light flashes green. "Aha!" you think. "I have figured out what this button does: it causes that light to flash green." On a table to the side of the room is a notepad and a pencil. You jot down your discovery. You walk back to the wall, and press a different button. Once again, the same light flashes green. You begin to wonder if all the buttons affect that one light. You press the original button to confirm your suspicions. The light flashes blue. --- Months have passed. You have covered the three previously unadorned walls with notes, with diagrams, with layer upon layer of discarded theory. But you're so close! The machine you've designed perfectly matches everything you've observed. It's so vivid in your imagination that you can practically see it through the wall. There's just a single lever you're unsure about; you can't decide if it's part of a complex mechanical linkage, or if it simply closes an electrical circuit. It would all work either way. You draw both options and place a question mark between them. You wander down the hall to an office, pop your head in and say to the person seated at the desk: "I think I've figured it out. Could you come take a look?" --- THEM: "So you're not sure which one of these it is?" YOU: "It could work either way, so I drew both. I couldn't find any way to determine the answer." THEM: "Well, that's not very satisfying. Are you sure you tried everything? What about this button, how many times did you press it?" YOU: "That one? Tens of thousands of times, cumulatively." THEM: "Have you tried pressing it repeatedly? Over and over again, I mean, without anything in between." YOU: "I have the notes over here... yes, one hundred times in a row to confirm my theory was correct." THEM: "Only a hundred? What if it does something different after a thousand presses? You should try that; it might solve your dilemma." YOU: "I... could, but that seems awfully time-consuming. None of the other buttons did anything different after more than a dozen presses." THEM: "Yes, but couldn't this button be different?" YOU: "Maybe, but there's a point where I have to assume I've got it right. After all, there's no way of knowing whether it does something different at ten thousand presses, or a million presses!" THEM: "All the same, we would really like to know what's behind that wall. It's a bit disappointing to only know what will happen but not know what's really going on back there. Could you try it the thousand presses? Perhaps twiddle some other widgets at random, see if that creates any discrepancy?" YOU: "But that might never end! If nothing comes up after a day of effort, you could ask me to do it for a week. If nothing comes up after a week, you could ask me to do it for a year. Can't you just accept that either option works?" --- The moral of the story: there's a limit to knowledge gained by inference. The problem is even worse than the story described, because even if you resolve the dilemma of the lever: -It's impossible to know that the 200 sextillionth press (and only the 200 sextillionth press) of that button does something slightly different. Your design is wrong, and you'll never discover the discrepancy. -It's impossible to know that the first time you pressed the button (and only the first time), it lit up a yellow light in the corner that you didn't see. Your design is wrong, and the information needed to resolve it is lost to you forever. In the real world, maybe we'll get lucky and produce a theory that has only a single interpretation. Maybe there is a discrepancy that rules out all but one solution. (And maybe we'll get extra lucky and it will be easy to visualize.) But even then, we can never be sure. I feel as though the author of the article isn't clear enough about this. You can never know what's behind the wall.
- scythe 5y ago>Another alternative is to suppose there are hidden factors that we can’t quite access. David Bohm influentially suggested that a particle is accompanied by a “pilot wave” that guides its trajectory through the double-slit experiment and creates the interference pattern. Most physicists will tell you that this kind of “hidden variable” interpretation of quantum theory has been ruled out by a combination of experimental results and mathematical proofs. This isn't the problem with Bohmian mechanics at all. Bohmian mechanics "solves" the EPR experiment by letting hidden variables jump around across spacelike separations. This cannot be disproven by Bell tests. The problem with Bohmian mechanics (which I have always heard called "Bohmian mechanics", and not "pilot-wave theory") is that it isn't truly relativistic; it doesn't happen in Minkowski space and nobody has to my knowledge extended it to Minkowski space in a way that is widely considered acceptable. If the author likes Bohm's approach so much, he should learn about the ongoing developments: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/de_Broglie-Bohm_theory#Relativity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/de_Broglie-Bohm_theory#Relativi...
- engineer_22 5y agoTl;Dr: quantum physicist in the midst of existential crisis articulating his dread.
- bee_rider 5y agoIt seems weird to me that somebody could get a physics PhD without a deep enough understanding of the philosophy of science to 1) understand why science avoids these 'what, really, is X' questions in favor of 'how does X work' 2) circumvent this existential crisis
- mrjangles 5y agoI come to HN to learn new things in fields I know little about, like tech and computers, I always find the comments to be authoritative and interesting. However, whenever I read the comments on any subject I happen to know something about, like physics, they are always completely nonsense from people who clearly have absolutely not even the smallest amount of experience in the area they are talking about. The worst part is, all these comments sound extremely authoritative, if I didn't know any better I would have believed they were experts. This makes me very worried about the Gell-Mann Amnesia affect. I'm very worried that all the comments I've been reading on here about tech and computer topics are also just from larpers who are pretending to be experts but actually don't know anything.
- xtracto 5y agoI feel the same when reading comments about medicine. I'm absolutely ignorant of that field, but I cringe at the authoritative sounding comments often found in HN.
- 0x1062 5y agoname and shame, so those of us non-experts can spot the bad comments.
- dang 5y agoPlease correct wrong information without shaming others. We're trying to avoid the online callout/shaming culture here. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=online%20shaming%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=a... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sam_goody 5y agodang, you read every comment on every thread? And you stay polite and interactive?! Are you sure you are human?
- meroes 5y agoI think a 100 years of now 17-decimal accuracy is fine. Maybe we do need a Copernican revolution. But how many areas of physics and science can we say that? A lot. I think for sure the idea of measurement as a passive activity revealing pre existing values is gone though. No matter what happens. How long was that a paradigm?
- credit_guy 5y ago> Copernican revolution The guy who did the hard work was Kepler. Copernicus's model of the solar system was just idle speculation. Also widely off the mark (it had epicycles, lots of thyem, twice as many as the Ptolemaic model [1]). Kepler sifted through the mountains of astronomical observations made by Tycho Brahe over many decades, and used the latest cutting edge math tools available (logarithms) to come up with his 3 laws. The true revolution is science was obviously Isaac Newton. But if he had some giants on whose shoulders to stand, they were Kepler and Brahe, not Galileo and Copernicus. [1] http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-ptolemaic-smackdown.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-ptolemaic-smac...
- analog31 5y agoIn my view the problem with interpreting physics theory precedes the quantum era. Nobody really knew what classical gravity or magnetism consisted of. The idea of the planets acting on one another instantaneously without contact in a vacuum was absurd on the face of it. Einstein was disturbed by this. The history of QM that I learned in school a long time ago, is that a few physicists endorsed adopting a purely mathematical formalism with no preferred interpretation in order to be free of preconceptions that might prevent them from making progress. They were still free to debate interpretation, but considered it to be separate from the problem of forming an experimentally testable theory. But in terms of finding a philosophically satisfactory interpretation, we don't know what to look for. No science has ever attempted to dig deeper than the level of analogies that are easy to grasp. And it seems reasonable that the interpretation should depend on the science. Otherwise we risk embracing an interpretation that becomes a barrier to progress, or that is overturned by new experimental evidence. I think the biggest problem with fundamental physics today, is that it's hard. As in, hard enough that it's not yielding answers at the rate that it was 100 years ago, and we don't know when it will: 10 years, 100, 1000? The big problem -- reconciling quantum mechanics and gravity -- won't be solved until we solve it. A theory that solves this problem will require one of those two things to be "wrong" in some sense, in which case its interpretation will have to be revised.
- ahmedsaad1977 5y agoHow is this: The electron loses its energy as it approaches the final destination, this energy (of wave nature obviously) passes through the slits and forms interference pattern. I know that for every problem there is a solution that is simple, neat—and wrong. And above proposition is most probably the same. But still I'll be glad to read the answers. (Disclaimer: I'm a novice)
- majewsky 5y agoYou're falling into the very common trap of assuming that "energy" is some kind of substance (like movies/series tend to depict it as for practical reasons), when really it is a mathematical property of a physical object. Like other similar properties (such as spin, momentum and angular momentum), energy is relevant because fundamental symmetries of the universe require it to be constant. Therefore "losing energy" in one part of a physical system (such as the electron) is only possible when another part of the system simultaneously gains the same amount of energy. When you say: > this energy (of wave nature obviously) passes through the slits The question then is what type of object would possess this energy as it passes through the slits and hits the screen behind it. Since the screen is specifically set up to detect electrons, the simplest explanation is that it is really the electrons performing the interference. (Footnote, just to be safe: Energy conservation can be broken on very very short timescales, but this is not relevant for the double-slit experiment.)
- drujensen 5y agoAs former amateur physicist, who read a couple books over the years :) To me it's quite simple. We haven't detected what is causing the waves that the particle of light is riding on. The particle of light is like a surf board, riding a wave and will always hit the shore in the interference pattern. Einstein and Bohr were both right. What has been the wrong assumption over the years is that the light is generating the waves. It seems obvious to me that something else outside of the light (that we haven't detected yet) is generating the waves. My amateur physicist guess is the waves are generated by the clock cycles of the computer simulation we are in. All computers require a clock to function. Why would our universe be any different?
- allisdust 5y agoAssuming that it is true, what is the clock/cpu speed?
- zuminator 5y agoNot saying you're wrong in the slightest, but why would our universe be like a computer? When our understanding of the universe was very primitive we thought everything was alive (animism). Then a little more technology and we thought the universe was like an orrery or a clock (mechanism)[0]. Then a little more and we think it was like a computer (turingism?) Occasionally you'll hear it's like a hologram, a simulation (what's it simulating?), a graph [1], or some other faddish concept. We just like to make metaphors to put this thing in a box that we can't understand. But perhaps at its most fundamental level it will defy comprehension or even definition. [0] In the philosophical sense; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanism_(philosophy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanism_(philosophy) [1] https://syncedreview.com/2020/04/17/stephen-wolfram-the-path-to-a-fundamental-theory-of-physics-may-begin-with-a-hypergraph/ https://syncedreview.com/2020/04/17/stephen-wolfram-the-path...
- ximile 5y agoI find it kinda hilarious that you all seen to be discussing some sort of cutting edge or controversial idea called "quantum theory" or "quantum physics", when I have to assume you're taking about century old theories of quantum mechanical systems like ones that continue to help design the electronics that you read this piece of shit article on.
- rndphs 5y agoWell yeah, there is still unresolved issue(s) with at the very least the interpretation of quantum theory, if not the math. Before decoherence things were even worse, and that was much less than a century ago. The fact that physicists still haven't reached a consensus on what the theory means is very intriguing to many people. Although it's true that people probably underestimate just how much this territory has been trodden. The current quantum computing hype likely plays a role in it seeming "cutting edge". It may just be flavour of the month.
- smaddox 5y agoThe most promising approach I've seen to answering the author's question: https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/finally-we-may-have-a-path-to-the-fundamental-theory-of-physics-and-its-beautiful/ https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/finally-we-may-h...
- rpz 5y agoMaybe it is time that we review the fundamentals? Could Planck and Einstein have made a mistake? I find this to be the simplest explanation of light: E=htf where h is in joules per cycle, t is measurement time and f is cycles per second. Every wavelength of light has the same energy, regardless of frequency. That energy is 6.26e-34 Joules. Every “photon” is actually 1 seconds worth of light energy at some frequency f. Once you see that the time variable was hard coded to one second in planck’s constant of action it starts to make sense. It’s not surprising that single photons cause diffraction patterns because photons aren’t real particles. forgottenphysics.com https://img1.wsimg.com/blobby/go/e266e5e7-739c-437c-89c3-eed60d3a9f3f/downloads/A%20Significant%20Question%20in%20Quantum%20Foundations..pdf https://img1.wsimg.com/blobby/go/e266e5e7-739c-437c-89c3-eed...
- lenocinor 5y agoI think the thing that honestly puzzles me is: before physicists learned physics, did their entire desire to be in the field spring from “shut up and calculate”? Or was there a time in their lives (especially when they were young) where they thought (or felt) a desire to get into physics to understand the underlying mechanisms that drive the universe? I feel like, at least for some people, the second thing must have been true. So, given that most quantum physicists seem uninterested in interpretations, where did this desire go? Did it disappear? Did the field get them to stop caring? Did it feel silly to them at some point? Did it feel hopeless? Or something else? I genuinely want to know.
- lambdatronics 5y agoThere are a broad range of motivations. In my case: - I wanted to work on nuclear fusion energy, for the future of humanity. - I was told that if I had a PhD in physics, I could do just about anything - it's a way of keeping options open. - I liked tinkering in the lab & learning new mind-expanding concepts in textbooks. - I viewed it as a test of my intelligence. (Turns out, it's more about perseverance.) I know at least one string theorist, and they seem to be motivated primarily by liking to mess around with abstruse mathematics. Some others seem to enjoy the 'nerd cred.' I think the ones whose sole motivation is 'getting to the bottom of the universe' probably burn out early, b/c there's so little of that to be had right now. (I've heard from several people who got their PhDs in particle physics who went on to do data science/programming, saying that the field is depressing and that's why they didn't pursue it further.) As for me, I found the 'shut-up-and-calculate' attitude a major turn-off to studying quantum physics. (Plasma physics uses little or no QM, so that worked out for me.)
- lenocinor 5y agoI never thought about all these other motivations. Thanks for responding with them! And it sounds like there may be at some physicists like I was describing that get burnt out or discouraged too.
- cevi 5y agoThe interpretations don't tell you anything that the calculations didn't tell you already (if an interpretation of quantum mechanics ever predicts something different from what quantum mechanics predicts, then it can be ruled out empirically by performing the appropriate experiment). Interpretations which don't give you a faster way to get to the results of those calculations just waste your time and get in the way of understanding. Theoretical computer science indicates that there is no significantly faster way to get the results of many of those calculations - no matter how elegant the interpretation feels, at best you have to do the same amount of work to get the same answers about what will actually happen in reality, and at worst you end up computing a million irrelevant details about things the interpretation invented which have no real-world consequence. Someone who is genuinely interested in understanding the way the world works ends up asking questions about what goes into the calculations - what's the Lagrangian, how many degrees of freedom (i.e. quantum fields) are there, what symmetries or constraints are satisfied by the laws of physics, how can we set up the math to avoid pathological situations where the results of our computations are infinite, and so on. Philosophically motivated interpretations of quantum mechanics shed exactly zero light on these questions. Well.. there is a caveat. If quantum mechanics was somehow incorrect - that is, if unitary evolution of a state vector in a Hilbert space didn't actually describe reality at all - then all of the above would be wrong. But in that case, every single interpretation of quantum mechanics would be wrong as well. Quantum computers would just flat out not work.