16 ms·
The Miseducation of Maria Montessori
- glial 5y agoThis echoes a (better) review in Harper's recently: https://harpers.org/archive/2022/02/every-child-an-emperor-on-maria-montessori/ https://harpers.org/archive/2022/02/every-child-an-emperor-o... In the New Yorker article, the author takes issue with the fact that there are very few public Montessori schools, but fails to suggest why this might be the case. I'd offer that perhaps this this is because a Montessori education is child-focused, while public educational institutions (like the ones I attended) tend to be institution-focused. Valuing the worth of the child is somehow antithetical to the structure and order they impose.
- aidenn0 5y agoI think it's at least partly that such institutions favor the appearance of doing the right thing over actually doing the right thing.
- avs733 5y agoit might make you feel less nihilistic to relabel the appearance with legibility. When I need for my work to be viewed as legitimate, I have to make sure it is first legible to those who decide on its legitimacy. When those people are parents or elected officials whos opinions are given deference but have no actual subject matter knowledge - legibility becomes hard.
- aidenn0 5y agoThat's exactly what I was trying to say, I just didn't know the right word.
- rp3 5y agoLarge systems, like a school system, need rules and procedures that help guarantee a relatively consistent outcome. The unstructured, exploratory nature of Montessori doesn't lend itself well to a a large-scale, systematic approach.
- 3np 5y agoFrom the point of view of the institution, a consistent approach is usually preferable. In general it’s not a given that it’s a desirable goal. Depending on your ideological and political stances.
- scythe 5y ago>Large systems, like a school system, need rules and procedures that help guarantee a relatively consistent outcome. But is that really true? For one thing, you can have a fail-over mechanism if something isn't working. For another, we already do: it's called special education. That's before we get to the part where "consistent outcomes" are not a feature of the current system, unless you impose a very low standard of 'consistency'.
- warble 5y agoYeah - I agree. Large centralized institutions do tend to work this way, but it's not a requirement, although it's always a struggle to keep the administration from pushing this route because it's easier even though it gives poorer outcomes.
- vanviegen 5y agoMy children attend a Montessori public school here if the Netherlands. So such a thing is certainly possible. Though the Montessori principles may have been watered down a bit to comply with state demands - I'm not really sure as I don't have any comparison points outside of our public system.
- rr808 5y agoOr it could just be that Montessori education really isn't that special and for most people a standard education is as good or even superior. If Montessori kids really were obviously more successful public education would change.
- pmarreck 5y ago> If Montessori kids really were obviously more successful public education would change. I know that this is false because functional languages have existed for decades and still occupy a vast underproportion of IT projects despite being superior in the vast majority of use-cases. Also, argumentum ad populum.
- noitpmeder 5y agoSimilar to Montessori schools being "obviously more successful", I think it's still very much up for debate whether functional languages are "superior in the vast majority of use-cases".
- Daishiman 5y agoHaving used functional languages in production systems, this is... just not true at all.
- pmarreck 5y agoWhich ones?
- EdwardDiego 5y agoI would need a few citations for "superior in the vast majority of use-cases". The fact that recursion can compile down to iteration when written in a tail-call manner, while other languages are just providing iteration as a core part of the system, kinda implies that FP isn't "superior in the vast majority of use-cases". Although, as the ol Verity Stob quote goes "Lisp is still #1 for key algorithmic techniques such as recursion and condescension". And you're really nailing the latter.
- manmal 5y agoIt’s a simple matter of economics. The level of attention a child is getting in a M school is not possible with the typical 20:1 or even 25:1 kids:teacher ratio. I‘d argue that you need a ratio of 10:1 or lower to give kids the level of attention and care usual in M schools.
- another_story 5y agoThis is probably the most important thing outside of the skill of the teacher. I can turn a dull curriculum into something interesting when a class is around a dozen students. I've taught the GCSE CS curriculum, which is staggeringly dull at times, but was able to make kids love it because the class size was small.
- vmception 5y agoMontessori schools are pretty interesting, another type that flies further under the radar are Sudbury schools I find the Sudbury model more fascinating because the student bodies I’ve seen came across as motivated, and other education models seemed demotivating except to a few students with a externality of a self motivating gene or environment. Sudbury specifically makes students part of a democracy for most operations and education. My skepticism was quelled by the outcomes. I would pay a premium for Montessori or Sudbury schooling. How about an article from people that can comfortably afford it? I would alternatively consider having my future child(ren) schooled in a non-US developed country. The public option isnt in the running.
- richardanaya 5y ago"outcomes"?
- throwawaygh 5y agoCombined with "_future_ child(ren)" ;-)
- vmception 5y agoWhy would that invalidate perception (or why would the gatekeeping be relevant) since the whole discussion is merely about being in a place to afford it, the trajectory of which occurs far in advance of having children The only other thing i could see is whether I wind up living close to one or the partner has their own restrictions Just seems like a much more privileged position to have an outside perspective than the people with kids who didn’t even know they can’t afford the choice, like the person in the article
- magpi3 5y agoHe probably means the students who come out of them. I feel the same about Waldorf schools myself. I have taught in a Waldorf school and have been frustrated by some of the methods (and don't get me started on Rudolph Steiner), but I had to admit that in the three years I taught there, the graduating grade 8 students all were remarkably kind, intelligent, curious and creative young teenagers. IOW ultimately you have to look at the fruit that is born from these trees to judge their ultimate worth. If you just walk in on one of these schools in the early years, you might be shocked/appalled at the lack of structure and discipline.
- oh_sigh 5y agoI don't know if I'm seeing a paywalled version or something, but this article is only 2 paragraphs. Why would this person go check out a school before even doing basic research like finding out how much it costs?
- JeffL 5y agoWhen I was looking at preschools for my daughter, there was no tuition info for the Montessori schools available until after the tours.
- oh_sigh 5y agoThat should seem like a hard no then? But maybe different regions operate with different standards and that is the norm in your area I just checked the 5 Montessori/Waldorf schools near me (Boulder) and all of them list their tuition very clearly.
- jreese 5y agoCar sales 101: don't talk price until after you show them why they want it.
- Galanwe 5y agoDoes someone have feedback on having kids in a Montessori school? Looking at the materials online, it looks like the overall idea makes sense, but somehow there is a _rumor_ that most Montessori childs struggle to adapt to a _normal_ curriculum after, and generally lean toward short studies and manual jobs.
- watwut 5y agoKind of depends I think. Some people praise it and those who continue into humanities tend to do ok. But, I know two kids who really struggle to caught up with math after. Out of three that I knew went into Montessori. There is however likely big variance in terms of which Montessori school exactly we talk about (literally which building).
- antasvara 5y agoI went to a Montessori school. I would say that adjusting to a "normal" curriculum took a little time. However, I think that learning independence and keeping my love of learning was worth that tradeoff. I was also happy going to school, something that I feel was beneficial from a developmental standpoint. For context, I don't currently work a manual job and successfully graduated college.
- duxup 5y agoOne issue is that anyone can claim to be a Montessori school. Many adopt a few ideas but really aren’t much different than other schools.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoMy only experience so far is myself. I received a great education overall but I’m not sure I would credit that to Montessori school specifically. I do remember enjoying the hell out of it. It was my only foray into private education. I had no trouble adjusting to regular school, attended a top tier university, and have worked as a software engineer for the entirety of my career. YMMV but I am planning to send my son to Montessori.
- jerrysievert 5y agoMontessori for 5 years, myself. I mostly learned how to learn, and the struggles later were that my education was well beyond that of my public school peers when I switched. I found learning by rote to be a waste of time, and continued to learn in my own ways. As a result, I had amazing test scores in public school, but bad grades overall because I felt that the homework was a waste of my time. I still appreciate my time on a Montessori school though.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoThe Montessori system is not a trademarked or patented. There's no authority governing the Montessori system. Every Montessori school implements their own interpretation of it, sometimes so they can charge more. Because of how inconsistent its implementation is in practice, the results will be completely random. There are many stories of Montessori system failures out there that you can read to understand when things go wrong.
- bigDinosaur 5y agoI suppose we can dismiss the traditional (public or private) school systems based on their many failures too? Actually, in many ways we probably can.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoYes, we can. The traditional system is a disservice for many people. Just like with any mass solution from the industrial age, the traditional system is not meant to suit your needs, but the needs of a hypotetical average person.
- brnaftr361 5y agoI once read a tale about a bureaucrat that was assigned to sizing military garb. He went out and measured everybody, he even did so accurately, to a tenth. He then used the mean average. Turns out very few people are actually 5'9" with a size 9 foot and etc... But if we really look at the human space, I'm pretty sure in terms of education nothing actually fits, except compliance and the willingness to accept highwaters and blisters.
- ungawatkt 5y agoThat doesn't even need to be a tale, it basically happened in real life https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22956832 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22956832
- ThePowerOfFuet 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jayski 5y agoMy son was in a standard non-montessori private kindergarten. Every day we dropped him off he would cry and throw a tantrum, and it would break our hearts, but you know... that's life. He was falling behind all his classmates, his speech hadn't developed, he didnt sing the songs, do the dances, etc. All the other kids were doing great. I attended one of his classes and noticed he refused to sit at his chair, all he wanted to do was stare out the window to try to spot airplanes. That's when we decided to switch over to Montessori, mainly because I wanted him to have more freedom, and at least enjoy school even if he didn't learn much. The change frankly has been incredible, after just one week he was waiting inpatiently at the front door of our home, anxious to go to school. The only crying when we dropped him off was from my wife, when he ran into the school without looking back every morning. His speech and abilities have normalized with the rest of his class after a year. Now I'm not saying everyone will have the same outcome,maybe he just grew and would've developed any way. I just wanted to share my personal experience in case anyone finds it useful.
- jjeaff 5y agoI think yours is a great example of how one size fits all programs are not necessarily what we need. Some children just respond differently to different things.
- goldenkey 5y agoI despise the middle paths fallacy however well intentioned it might be. Traditional education is just shit and evokes a poor response in most of everyone. And alternative methods are better, even for those who can tolerate the former. In this case there isn't an equivocal middle ground. Anyone who attended public schooling can tell you that our K-12 education system is a dumpster fire.
- eru 5y agoTotally depends on where you are. Eg from what I can tell, traditional German Kindergartens are just fine and most kids love them. (German schools are a different beast.)
- rudedogg 5y agoI bought a Montessori book, and while I'm only a few chapters in, it has some ideas I really like. I think it's important to remember that these techniques were defined in 1912 though. There seems to be a sort of worship of the Montessori method, and a "black and white" mentality about what is correct. Using a 100+ year old book/method without adjustments and chasing purity in following it seems misguided.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoHer basic message is the insight ‘just watch the child’ which in hindsight is obviously true. Our current messaging for education is ‘listen to the administration’ :)
- magpi3 5y ago"The Montessori Method" by Maria Montessori is available as a free pdf on the web and is also a free ebook on Google Play.
- pdamoc 5y agoI think that it is more important to remember that Montessori tried to bring education in the 20th century using the science that was available to her 100+ years ago. Most schools today are still stuck into the factory model of 200 years ago. They are still trying to take uneducated peasant children and discipline them to mindlessly follow a 9-to-5 factory work schedule. Applying Montessori principles would be an improvement to most. Regular people severely underestimate how outdated and unscientific the current model is. Everywhere. And we know about this for more than 50 years and we've done very little to improve things. One of my sisters made sure that my nephew was in a Montessori kindergarten. He went to a regular school afterwards but those Montessori years can still be felt. There is a kind of emotional stability that still permeates his behavior. A level of presence and calm that brings me joy and gratefulness.
- nouveaux 5y agoAre you reading Maria Montessori's book, The Absorbent Mind? If not, I highly recommend going straight to the source. There is a bit of a cult like mentality around the whole Montessori Method, which is odd to me. However, I do think Maria Montessori got most of it right.
- avs733 5y agoIf one wants to have a conversation about privilege and childhood education it is useful to look beyond labels for how one teaches and actually look at how schools change with social class. Jean Anyon's work is really the baseline[0] and describes just how fundamentally different the schooling process experienced by the privileged and less privileged is. She looked entirely at public schools. >In the two working-class schools, work is following the steps of a procedure. The procedure is usually mechanical, involving rote behavior and very little decision making or choice. The teachers rarely explain why the work is being assigned, how it might connect to other assignments, or what the idea is that lies behind the procedure or gives it coherence and perhaps meaning or significance. ...Work is often evaluated not according to whether it is right or wrong but according to whether the children followed the right steps. >In the executive elite school, work is developing one's analytical intellectual powers. Children are continually asked to reason through a problem, to produce intellectual products that are both logically sound and of top academic quality. A primary goal of thought is to conceptualize rules by which elements may fit together in systems and then to apply these rules in solving a problem. [0]https://www1.udel.edu/educ/whitson/897s05/files/hiddencurriculum.htm https://www1.udel.edu/educ/whitson/897s05/files/hiddencurric...
- estaseuropano 5y agoJust to highlight this book is 40(?) years old. If you want to see how an egalitarian education system reaches the best education system results in the world - Estonia and Finland are the countries to look at. Their education indeed follows the second model here. But rote learning is also included - the point is to challenge and support the child in manifold ways and keep in mind that they should enjoy themselves. My point is though while in some countries this might be a class difference, really it comes down to a quality difference. Good quality does not actually need to be very expensive/rare, you can reach it at system level as do Estonia and Finland.
- avs733 5y agoAbsolutely true and fair. Pardon the assumption of us contexts. And I was about to argue with 40 years old by saying i think it was written in the 1980s! And I caught myself
- hardwaregeek 5y agoHuh, it's rare that I wish a New Yorker article was longer, but I really would love a more thorough dive into Montessori schools today. I went to a Montessori school from pre-k to 6th grade. It was a very good experience overall. I learned at my own pace and got to do some pretty advanced math. But, I will confess, it was also a rather nice private school. I wonder how much of the benefits were from Montessori versus the small class sizes and indulgent teachers. It also ended right around when grades go from vaguely mattering in some abstract moral sense, to mattering in a very concrete, important sense, i.e. college admissions. I wonder how Montessori would have fared in that environment. Indeed I have the fun distinction of having experienced private school, homeschooling, and public school. All have their benefits and all have their downsides. Private school teaches you that anything can be changed if you make a big enough fuss, and that you are really special. It also puts you in an environment where everybody's paying 40k a year[1] or they're a scholarship kid. That gives kids a very warped worldview. You can get a really great education though and college admissions is a breeze if you charm your college councilor. Homeschooling, contrary to what people may think, is not sitting at home while your religious parents teach you the earth is 4000 years old. In large cities it's often closer to freelance school. Homeschoolers pool together and pay a teacher to teach a specific class. In some cases this works really well. Students get to develop specific interests and can take some classes that would be totally unavailable even to private school kids. If you're a child prodigy, homeschooling is almost essential. However, it is extremely isolating socially unless the kid is able to seek out friends on their own. It can also create kids who don't fully integrate into society. Pejoratively, they're weirdos. That's okay though! They'll find other weirdos in college and adulthood. A lot of successful people are weirdos. And one could argue I've got the correlation backwards and the kids are homeschooled because their weirdos. But if you want your kid to be comfortable within the mainstream of society, I wouldn't homeschool them. Finally, there's public school. It teaches the exact opposite of private school, namely that you are not special, you do not deserve special treatment and that you should put your head down and work. There's pros and cons to that lesson. For one, it does teach you how to get shit done with minimal self pity. On the flip side, if you do have any genuine differences, good luck surviving lol. I shudder to think about kids with learning differences like dyslexia or ADHD. I probably have a minor case of ADHD and it was certainly difficult for me. You also get no guidance whatsoever with college and life. I see that effect on my classmates, many of whom are following the same track of trying to get into the most prestigious college, followed by the most prestigious job, followed by idk, home ownership and death? It's a bleak path. With all this done, I've thought about what I'd want my kids to do for school. Truthfully, I have no idea. They all seem awful in their own ways. Fortunately that decision is quite a way's off. [1]: Yes, yes, these are absurd NYC prices but private schools are still pretty expensive everywhere.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.ph/aZGdp https://archive.ph/aZGdp
- kqr 5y agoMontessori is fundamentally based on one simple principle I wish people adhered to more often: first, observe the child. Taiichi Ohno called it genchi genbutsu in the context of manufacturing. First, go to the floor and look at the work that is being done. Edwards Deming said "Don't just do somthing; stand there!" in the context of data analysis. Allow the data to tell you something. If you meddle with it you destroy the signal. In other words. First, observe. Try to understand the problem before you rush in with a solution. This is like step 0 of the scientific method and yet we forget about it so often, in a hurry to just do something.
- blodkorv 5y agoMontessori only works if you are a gifted or diciplined child from the start. For those that lack that in their personality its a really bad match.
- oo0shiny 5y agoThis is not true. My wife has taught in a Montessori classroom for over a decade, and the children who get the most out of it are the ones who would be labeled as "problematic" in other environments.
- blodkorv 5y agoI went to a Montessori school in Sweden for 10years and while i never was a problem child. I have always had problems with learning things, taking long time and lack dicipline and organization. I never got the most from it, instead the school got the most of my will to do everything but learning school subjects.
- nouveaux 5y agoThere are bad Montessori schools and it sounds like the school you attended wasn't very good. It sucks that you never got the most from it.
- marcosdumay 5y ago
- legitster 5y agoMy wife works in a Montessori daycare that our son attends. What's really telling is that there have been a few preschoolers who have been gently nudged out of the school for having needs the school couldn't (or didn't want to) deal with. Still, I think there are two things Montessori gets right: 1. Giving kids a lot of structured self-direction. 2. Mixing kids of age ranges and having them instruct each other. In my experience, everything other than that is crunchy granola window dressing.
- jkestner 5y agoMy mother runs a Montessori school and takes in the “problem” children that other schools push out. (It only annoys her that parents look at standardized test results without considering growth year over year.) Montessori is not a trademarked name, and so you get a lot of schools that call themselves Montessori with various levels of fidelity to the principles. Getting AMI accreditation is the best way to verify you’re legit. Even so, I agree that many good Montessori schools cultivate a certain clientele. That teacher/student ratio and the materials aren’t cheap, and they have a reputation to uphold to keep rich people coming. As per the article, it’s unfortunate because Maria Montessori started her original program for disadvantaged children. We’ve decided for our own children that after a few years of Montessori they go to public school, to be around kids with a wide range of perspectives. Best way to make schools better is to be part of them.
- zoom6628 5y agoHave had now 3 kids thru Montessori and another starting next year. 2 of them did in New Zealand and younger 2 in HongKong. The kids have all excelled, want to rush to school every day, come home smiling. Can’t say anything like this of older kids experience of public or private( $$$) school system in either place. My own experience is that Montessori puts the kids years ahead of age group peers and the learning benefits last into adulthood. My eldest earned a PhD in spite of learning challenges and the second eldest senior manager in a Govt department. #3 taught herself a 3rd language at age of 3. To many things to attribute just to home life and DNA. Not familiar with other systems mentioned but I do see any environment where kids are respected and observed carefully seem to get similar and lasting results from their education.
- omniscient_oce 5y agoSimilar story here. I did Montessori for kinder + primary school in NZ (christchurch) before moving to Aus for high school. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I think it gave me a tangible leg up over a lot of my peers. Perhaps not a huge one, and everyone is different, but I think the 3hr work cycle concept + freedom to learn at my own pace - translating into not hating or getting frustrated at school/learning + the physical equipment you use to learn mathematics concepts were the most beneficial.
- tjansen 5y agoMy oldest daughter is going to a public Montessori elementary school, and my youngest daughter will start this summer. To understand the following points, you need to know that German elementary school is grade 1 to 4, usually starting when kids are 6, and in Montessori schools the students are in mixed-age classes. Some things I noticed: - there are kids who are doing really well, and there are other kids who (I think) have more trouble than I'd expect in a classic elementary school - a few kids are learning at a faster pace, like my daughter who skipped 2nd grade. - there is a shocking number of kids who are having trouble and have to repeat a grade, usually 3rd grade. Last year, 3 out of 6 third graders had to repeat third grade. Not sure how statistically relevant it is, and it feels closer to home as those three are my daughter's best friends, but it was quite surprising and made us wonder whether it's the right school for our younger daughter (who's a bit wilder and has less patience and discipline). - in addition to the usual ADHD stuff, there is a surprising number of kids who are diagnosed with dyscalculia. Not sure what's normal, and of course this is a small sample, but still makes us feel a bit uneasy. - a possible reason why some kids are struggling could be the student/teacher ratio. There are 27 kids per teacher. I think that's way too high to support kids who are having difficulties. - I should also mention that Covid interrupted Montessori schools more than traditional schools. Kids are supposed to work with Montessori materials, and they weren't available in home schooling. Teaching via video was difficult in mixed-age classes. Even today, kids do not experience the school as intended, as the class needs to stay together all day and they are not free to roam to other rooms, like workshops or the library.
- vmception 5y agoAn extremely heavy weighting to this experience is that there is serious developmental delays happening across all grade school children right now. Its really hard to validate any particular experience to any one system right now, I want your experience to be valid but before I sock it into my mind as something to watch out for I have to remember to check what how the non-Montessori options are doing and its struggling right now. All the kids are struggling. > I should also mention that Covid interrupted Montessori schools more than traditional schools Oof yeah thatll amplify this issue
- 5y ago
- tannhaeuser 5y agoWhen you get kids, you question whether they absolutely have to go through regular education, just to become fodder for the industry. That said, I've heard from several ex-Waldorfers that their school experience was rife with bullying and crime, because the school became a place for those who didn't make it elsewhere.
- ArnoVW 5y agoI have two sons. One of which went to a public kindergarten, hated it (crying before sleeping, etc) and we found a "école nouvelle" school (1) where he is doing fine. The other one, we ended up putting him in montessori kindergarten because of issue with the nanny, just because it was the only open spot we found. My conclusion, after having seen 3 schools: a huge part of the equation is the self-selection of the teachers. It's like comparing "SPA and microservices" with PHP as technologies, without taking into consideration that each attracts a different type of developer. 1: state curricumum, but with specific pedagogical philosophy, focusing on confidence, team-work, etc.
- madduci 5y agoThis is an American problem, like the general access to education and healthcare. In Europe, a lot of education is free and, believe it or not, also Montessori schools/kindergarten are.
- Toine 5y agoMontessori schools are expensive in France.
- picodguyo 5y agoParent of two long-time Montessori kids here. We have been through both public and private Montessori schools. Unfortunately, the public one did not work out because they were heavily constrained by the district's requirements, so the Montessori aspects were very watered down. What I like about Montessori is that if a child finds a "work" that interests them, they can really focus in on it until mastery instead of feeling pressured to follow a specific curriculum on a specific timeline. I also like the de-emphasis on grades and testing. These are distractions from learning IMO. As for academic progress, one of my kids picks things up early and the other picks things up late. It just depends on the child. We aren't yet to high school, so I can speak to that transition. I'd be lying if I said it didn't worry me a little, though, mostly because I think of high school as a stressful place and my kids are currently in a very low-stress place.
- pibechorro 5y agoI worked there as a swim instructor for their summer camp, by far, the best school system I have seen. Its like homeschooling meets institutions. Our publix school system is garbage (Prussian) compared to it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blodkorv 5y agoI went to a Montessori school during all of my schooling before gymnasium. It really was a super bad fit for me. Now when i look back at it, it is super obvious montissori is great for talented children and those who are able to have dicipline and organize them selfs, without much guidance. Me myself has always lacked that and always will. This made be fall behind so bad in school that the only way i was able to finish it was because of a private tutor my parents hired. Now its not _all_ because of the school, it also is my own abilities. I am simply not a smart learner nor very good at problem solving. But the lack of organization, clear learning paths and a mindset of letting a child try to learn all by him self was super bad for me. It was also clear it benefitted girls a lot more than boys. Today i really resent everything about montessori, it was a complete failure for me and only let my lack of dicipline/organization and insufficient problem solving skills run my schooling for ten years while everyone in the school thought i would just magically develop abilities i lacked on my own.
- koshergweilo 5y agoGreat to hear the perspective of someone who actually went through it rather than a parent. Seems like they can be very hit or miss depending on the particular school/student. Was your poor performance communicated to your parents at all? Seems like you should have been pulled out earlier.
- blodkorv 5y agoIt was communicated early, but my mom really believed in the montessori way and thought i would catch up naturally, which i never did without a major push. I performed much better when i entered "gymnasiet (late high school)" and had a more traditional and structured way of teaching, despite having learning and discipline issues. But i strongly think that if i had been put in that environment early on i would have developed that areas which i lacked naturally much better.
- JohnDeHope 5y agoMontessori education transformed my young daughter's preschool life. In a functioning society people pay for things that they feel have value.
- mbateman 5y agodusts off HN account I’m part of a now-large-ish Montessori startup and am a sort of Montessori scholar. The biography reviewed here is very good and worth checking out. Overall it’s the best of the biographies available, and is a significant improvement over Kramer’s from a few decades ago. Just an aside: the extended tangents in the review about Montessori’s entrepreneurialism turning her method into a classist privilege are, uh, really strange. The idea in the review seems to be that the rarity and expense of Montessori in the US is because she charged for trainings and tried to parent some materials. Purely as a matter of historical fact, this is a narrative in search of evidence that isn’t there, and a narrative that isn’t really face plausible. Montessori education is rare because the progressive intellectuals that built the US school system adamantly and vociferously rejected Montessori for pedagogical reasons. There are just way better explanations available for why her work didn’t take hold more widely. Glad to see Montessori and Stefano’s biography in particular getting coverage though. I’ve enjoyed reading the many comments here about people’s experiences with Montessori!
- warble 5y agoThanks - I'd be interested in your alternative explanations if you're willing to comment here? I know it's never simple, and often even just timing is a factor in markets. Sounds like you've given it a lot of thought though.
- mbateman 5y agoYes I think about it all the time, both presently and historically. It's mainly an intellectual issue. That is: it's a dispute about what is true in development and education. In the early 20th c., when American progressives and intellectuals were very interested in education, this dispute was explicit. The (nascent) educational establishment reviewed Montessori's works, attended her trainings and published criticisms, and held whole conferences on the problems with the method. She was very popular for about five years or so, but the popularity was grassroots. The intellectuals always thought she was wrong. Just as one example: the intellectual current in the US was to delay it until later for largely Rousseauvian reasons (reading is an adult imposition that children aren't naturally interested in). Montessori became famous in large part because she taught children how to read earlier. (This is mentioned in the review above.) There were dozens of issues like this. Montessori thought there should be "an education of the senses"—but progressives critiqued this idea as incoherent. Montessori thought there should be specific, synthetically designed learning materials. Progressives thought there should be more natural experiences and fewer, if any, truly curricular "learning materials". Some thought her approach was too rigid, others too anarchic. Despite widespread public popularity, Dewey, his students, the NEA, and many many many others were vocally critical of her method. By 1916 it had all but vanished from the country, and wouldn't come back for over 40 years. (There are modern versions of every single one of these critiques, but the overall educational scene is also just much less intellectual than it was a hundred years ago, so it's not as visible.) But the first half of the 20th century is also precisely when the US school system took shape! It became bureaucratized, and US progressive educators themselves flip-flopped between different pedagogical approaches—from "project based" approaches to "efficiency" approaches that were more vocationally directed. By the time Montessorians clawed back some influence in the US, the basic shape of the system was already in place, and the only outlet it could take was as a grassroots movement. Which meant: lots of entrepreneurial women starting small schools in scattershot ways. Which means independent schools. Which means tuition. The school system in the US is so badly broken that it also affects the nature and costs of independent schools. And Montessori schools are largely independent schools. So they are more expensive and less accessible. There's a very explicit narrative at play in the review above, one that concludes with completely unmerited swipes at Amazon/Day One. A frank look at current and historical school policy dynamics would conclude that the barrier to getting more Montessori education in the US is the public school system, and that philanthropic and entrepreneurial efforts to push Montessori forward are the only things that have kept it going at all. The idea that Montessori schools are expensive, rare, and inaccessible because Montessori pushed them to be this way is really ridiculous. It's belied not just by the above narrative, which is a better explanation, but by decades of work that she did that was strongly characterized by humanitarian and activist efforts for the very poorest students, by many attempted (and mostly failed) partnerships that she attempted to engage in with any national government would listen, by her work in India during WWII (which has tremendous and ongoing influence), and more. I wrote a Twitter thread (was a bit irritated when I banged this out, unfortunately) that makes some similar points here with a couple of specific citations, newspaper clippings, etc. https://twitter.com/mbateman/status/1499590385638821889 https://twitter.com/mbateman/status/1499590385638821889
- mensetmanusman 5y agoMother Theresa’s group of nuns teach catechesis using Montessori methods under the framework called ‘Catechesis of the Good Shepherd’ which in some ways is staying more true towards the original method as Montessori schools become secularized. This sentence from the New Yorker reminded me: “that children are, in their essence, methodical, self-directed beings with a strong work ethic“ The ‘spiritual’ adjective is something that would have been in this sentence had Montessori written about it, as she discusses the spiritual well-being of children often in her writing. That the upper-crust of secular society conveniently ignores this isn’t surprising, but I wonder if ignoring it contributes to the growing mental health crisis. I.e. if spirituality doesn’t matter at all, how can you actually convince children they aren’t being raised as economic cogs in a materialist world?
- steve76 5y ago
- jpthurman 5y agoWe tried Montessori with mixed results. We love the foundations and philosophy. My wife set up our house according to the Montessori approach of making everything accessible for the kids. Our oldest- She did fine at Montessori but we noticed that she would never push herself or be pushed - per the method. For example she would only go to the shelf with puzzles that she could easily master. It wasn’t a competitive environment and she thrives on that. She moved on to regular Kindergarten and is doing well. Our second- Same problem as the first - but this was a bigger issue because he was far behind his developmental milestones and needed speech and occupational therapy just to get to Kindergarten. Our third- She was born for Montessori. She loves independence and is the most capable two year old I’ve come across. She’s the only one who uses the Montessori set-up(s) at home that my wife made happen. Our fourth- Still a baby - we shall see
- rgod8855 5y agoOur kids went to Montessori schools and my daughter became a Montessori teacher, so I have a hundred stories about Montessori education. I read the story and not sure I understand the point. Yes, Montessori teaching is nearly always a private school education. Just like church schools, the parents pay for it and it isn't cheap. We were lucky and went to a public school system that had a Montessori program as a magnet school. Our daughter did go to private Montessori for two years because she wasn't old enough to go to the public school. She did go to the public school version when she was old enough. I say all this because both the private and public Montessori versions worked just fine. Much of it was the quality of the teacher - it means everything. The author of the article talks of how she bought the counting beads and blocks when she decided the Montessori program was unaffordable. The materials went unused. Well, they don't work in the hands of those that aren't trained as Montessori teachers. The materials are important, but the teaching methodologies to use those materials are more important. The biggest problem with Montessori teaching is that it doesn't mix well with public school methods. Most Montessori schools are ages 3-11 (5th grade or so). Some go to eighth grade. Very few secondary schools. So, at some point, the Montessori student must become a traditional school student. There will be some period of adjustment because the approach is so different. It is manageable, but it will create some frustrations. Is Montessori school worth it? I lean yes, but I'm not one of those that says traditional schools are trash. Montessori leverages the student to make their own education path with the guidance of the teacher. In the end, Montessori students are better at goal oriented learning and self-reliance through self teaching. I think most students in traditional schools are spoon-fed more because the learning standards are set up that way. To be fair, it is done that way to make sure there are no holes in the education. Montessori students can have some specific standards gaps. I don't see the Montessori schools becoming more populist just because it is difficult to set up a broad-based education system for it except possibly in a very small school system (which, is actually, the best alternative for small town schools given how grouping age ranges in single classrooms is a normal part of the Montessori system.) But public systems tend to agglomerate. Large schools are done to maximize tax dollar efficiencies. A niche school system like Montessori schools just don't fit with the public realm.
- kwere 5y ago>Bezos’s vow prompted some early-childhood education experts, including Mira Debs, of Yale, and Joel Ryan, the executive director of Washington’s Head Start program, to ask why a man possessed of two hundred billion dollars would elect to compete with existing, cash-strapped public preschool programs instead of simply giving them lots of money. The answer may be found on the Day One Fund Web site, which states, “The customer set this team of missionaries will serve is simple: children in underserved communities across the country.” There is a novel dystopian horror in this promise—it conjures an image of Jesuit-manqué preschool teachers walking barefoot and dehydrated across miles of Amazon warehouse floor in search of a hundred-piece counting board as, elsewhere, a child waits expectantly behind her Ring Video Doorbell, anxious to Rate Her Experience. why journalism has devolved in ideological propaganda?