34 ms·
Trapped in Silicon Valley’s hidden caste system
- txcan 5y agoOnly to be bogged down by a level higher "country-of-birth" based discrimination system for GreenCards in the US.
- pinephoneguy 5y agoCountries have borders, we invest a lot of money in our children and people and would like a return on that investment. In order for that to be possible we have to reject the people who would abuse the system.
- shitlord 5y agoAbusers like highly paid tech workers earning 10x what the average American makes?
- ToxicMegacolon 5y agoHow are the doctors, engineers who work for American companies on employment based visas abusing the system?
- nraynaud 5y agoI can't imagine the crazy headache for management, like are you going to ask your Indian teamates their cast when you suspect there is foul play in the team?
- rootusrootus 5y agoIn my experience, the answer is always some form of "there are no castes any more." They know that most non-Indians lack the ability to prove otherwise, we can't even detect it.
- known 5y ago
- mdns33 5y ago
- simmanian 5y agoI am not from India but I would like to be connected to these groups. Any idea how I can reach out? edit: I guess this is as good as it gets https://ambedkarinternationalcenter.org/join-the-mission/aic-global-connect/ https://ambedkarinternationalcenter.org/join-the-mission/aic...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rhapsodic 5y ago
- belval 5y agoTo Indian commenters on HN, how much of that is true? Do you feel threatened when a coworker asks about where you are from? It's something I do ask from time to time (not during interviews obviously, but during lunch for example) out of pure curiosity. Should I stop? I guess that I should explicitly add that I am not from India. Cross-cultural communications can be a bit difficult at times and I'd rather not make blunders like that.
- rajeshp1986 5y agoI don't find any truth in it at all not especially in Silicon Valley. These articles are a coerced effort to bring up the caste divide from India into US and divide the Indian diaspora.
- simmanian 5y agoThe article mentions there were hundreds of people who joined a Zoom call to give testimonies. In your view, is the author exaggerating?
- crate_barre 5y agoIt could be possible they are projecting the home grown issue of India onto America. Racism is traumatic, and can lead to ptsd. If you dealt with it, you will amplify it wherever you even think it could exist, eg ‘I already know what you think about me’ as an internal thought. Imagine if your whole life you were looked at as X, you will feel like X even if you are in an environment that may not be doing this to you. Severe defensiveness. Not trying to undermine testimony, but life is a spectrum. On the spectrum of all testimonies, there is without a doubt corroborating testimonies that are the result of trauma. I’ll give an example. I’m an alcoholic. There are times my shame is so great that even in random stores where I go to buy some beer, I can feel eyes on me as if the whole world knows I’m an alcoholic. It’s an intense feeling of guilt and shame. Other examples of this are imposter syndrome arising from being doubted. If you ever been doubted in any meaningful way, you can palpably feel the doubt on your skin in new situations - all from past trauma. But in reality, no one may be doubting you in these new situations.
- dang 5y agoPast related threads. I think there have been others. How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26435117 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26435117 - March 2021 (195 comments) Caste discrimination in some of Silicon Valley's richest tech companies - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24952698 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24952698 - Oct 2020 (322 comments) How India's ancient caste system is ruining lives in Silicon Valley - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24555492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24555492 - Sept 2020 (47 comments) Over 90% of Indian techies in the US are upper-caste Indians - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24552047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24552047 - Sept 2020 (613 comments) Silicon Valley Has a Caste Discrimination Problem - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24065132 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24065132 - Aug 2020 (14 comments) California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India’s caste system - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23798922 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23798922 - July 2020 (56 comments) California accuses Cisco of job discrimination based on Indian employee's caste - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23697083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23697083 - July 2020 (592 comments)
- sg47 5y agoCisco is a hell hole that attracts a particular type of employee without talent who indulge in this type of discrimination blatantly. Narrow-minded Indians (I'm speaking as an Indian myself) who bring their Indian attitudes abroad. These types of Indians put others to shame. This is another side effect of doling out H1Bs and L1s without consideration for assimilation. I'm not sure if this is endemic to Indians though. I had a North Vietnamese classmate who used to complain that South Vietnamese students did not speak properly with them or respect them. Fundamentally boils down to growing up as human beings.
- Frazo 5y ago> Cisco is a hell hole that attracts a particular type of employee without talent who indulge in this type of discrimination blatantly. I work for Cisco. Best place to work for, best salary in the market, the smartest people I've ever come across. Best work life balance. I'm not Indian though, so maybe I'm not aware of all the details.
- throwaway_dcnt 5y agoThe reason for my current user name here at hn was this exact form of racism. It is the first post I made when I created this throwaway. I was assured that my experience was unique and not widespread. I am both sad and happy to see this, sad because it exists, happy because it is getting some attention here at HN. I would like to take this opportunity to point out that everyone of us needs to be vigilant about this type of racism. One thing I recommend to my hiring managers is to not allow people from frictioned backgrounds to manage and interview people from the other side. Example problematic pairs for candidates/interviewers (not including the cast situation) include: Indians and Pakistanis, Serbians and Bosnians, Greeks and Turks, Chinese and Japanese. One way I solve this is by introducing an independent observer/participant when situations like this emerge. This is costly but it has really worked to not only address this problem but also created an amazing diversity in my teams because it takes care of some of the implicit bias we all have to some degree.
- rayiner 5y ago> Indians and Pakistanis What do you do with Bangladeshis. :D
- avalys 5y agoThe solution you propose is arguably just as bad and I suspect it might be illegal in the US. If I am a qualified manager or tech lead, and there is an opportunity to lead a new project, I would be furious to learn that I was passed over for the opportunity because someone believed I was ethnically incompatible with one of the people on the team.
- zozbot234 5y agoIt's so disappointing to see in the article that caste discrimination is still being blamed by some on the religion of Hinduism. There's no dharmic status whatsoever for "caste" in the commonplace sense. The Vedas occasionally talk about something that gets misinterpreted as caste, but it's very clear from the texts that they're talking about individual callings and aptitudes, and not any sort of immutable status. The latter were merely a historically contingent development within Indian society, very similar to those that were leading towards feudalism and serfdom in the West.
- simmanian 5y agoI think it's fair to say that the caste system is greatly influenced by the flavor of reincarnation in hinduism and vice versa. the buddha himself set out to seek enlightenment and free himself from suffering when he saw that so many people from the lower castes are suffering. it eventually led him to reject hinduism and teach that nobody suffers in this life because of something that happened in "past" lives (in fact, he almost categorically rejected reincarnation as a process where individuals are born again and again, something many buddhists today do not understand), that everyone can attain true freedom and happiness. I assume this teaching is why Ambedkar came to reject hinduism and embrace buddhism as shown in the article.
- phyzix5761 5y agoAs a Theravadan Buddhist I can say you are mistaken. There is the concept of rebirth in Buddhism and dependent origination which starts with actions that happened in the past. Including actions in past lives. In fact, there are multiple realms where one can be reborn like heaven, human, animal, hungry ghost, hell, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theravada#Core_teachings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theravada#Core_teachings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_cosmology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_cosmology
- kumarvvr 5y agoWhat are you talking? https://www.learnreligions.com/reincarnation-in-buddhism-449994#:~:text=There%20is%20no%20permanent%20essence,it%20that%20is%20%22reborn%22%3F https://www.learnreligions.com/reincarnation-in-buddhism-449... Buddhism has a similar concept, named and understood differently.
- birdyrooster 5y agoA bit off topic but, separate from Indian culture, the United States has a hidden caste system too that flows from antiquity and is given texture through American slavery. If your family was a slave or you look like a slave you are, unconscious in the minds of most, systemically bottom caste here. Sorry if it is an unsatisfying critique of America but its obvious. Go look at the wealth data, look who is thriving and has net worth or success in business.
- johntiger1 5y agofrom my understanding, the caste system is thousands of years old (in fact one of the reason islam was welcomed and later sikh religion developed). are you sure that american slavery was the origin?
- vmception 5y agoThey are talking about the US distinctly. The US caste system, which has morphed primarily into a class system as the laws no longer explicitly single groups out, despite the correlations of effects that remain.
- Sebguer 5y agoThey're not implying that the Indian caste system originated in American slavery, they're stating that America also has a caste system.
- gerdesj 5y agoPerhaps class system is a better term. The terms nearly mean the same thing but not quite. I think the caste system is closer in origin to the societal structure in the feudal system that was common in medieval Europe, than the modern class system.
- sulam 5y agoClass specifically can be changed, whereas caste cannot. You can dress better, pronounce words in an upper class style, and live in a better neighborhood but still be treated like you need to use the back door to enter your own office because of the color of your skin.
- yrgulation 5y agoThe caste system is so deeply entrenched in the culture of those abused by it that even centuries after leaving india they cant leave it behind. Romania has a considerable group of such people. The Gipsy (also know as Romani) are an Indian people that are thought to have been part of a caste and fled India hundreds of years ago. To this day they cant lift themselves up, and frankly the government of Romania is not doing much at all. To call it an injustice it would he an understatement.
- zxienin 5y agoGypsy — India connect, would be interesting TIL for me. Is there a reputed citation on this?
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoRead the history of the Roma on Wikipedia. It is commonly accepted that they migrated from the Punjab in the Middle Ages.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thowaway_2mar 5y agoFrom wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romani_people#Origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romani_people#Origin) Genetic findings suggest an Indian origin for Roma. Because Romani groups did not keep chronicles of their history or have oral accounts of it, most hypotheses about the Romani migration's early history are based on linguistic theory. There is also no known record of a migration from India to Europe from medieval times that can be connected indisputably to Roma.
- vishnugupta 5y agoIndia also has a non trivial number of nomadic groups/tribes. In my part or India they are called “Lambani”. Their lifestyle closely resembles that of Gypsy, however I’m not knowledgeable enough to comment if they are related. Here’s an article from DDG search: https://indiantribalheritage.org/wp-content/uploads/Lambanis-Origin-K_Ramalingareddy_24-7-18.pdf https://indiantribalheritage.org/wp-content/uploads/Lambanis...
- johntiger1 5y agoas a complete outsider to the caste system, say i was american-born or otherwise "white-washed". would I still be subject to this system?
- sparky_ 5y agoFellow outsider here. Got curious and did some searching; would love to hear from some real Indian folks to confirm or deny this line of reasoning. As non-Indians, it seems we exist outside the system, which could be ambiguously interpreted to either have no connotation at all, or to exist at the bottom of the social strata. [1] Anecdotally, the kind of treatment you'll get in practice depends a lot more on your race and national origin. [2] 1: https://hinduism.stackexchange.com/questions/3898/what-caste-are-foreigners https://hinduism.stackexchange.com/questions/3898/what-caste... 2: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/let-s-talk-about-racism-prejudice-of-indians-a-form-of-self-denial/story-gY8GXUuTF6SM4LeoCPkNVI.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/let-s-talk-about-r...
- akvadrako 5y agoSo, assuming there is a hierarchy and Indian are not better than all other races, it seems the conclusion must be all societies have some kind of caste system, it's just we don't see it since we don't look for that sort of thing?
- dotnet00 5y agoPrior to becoming hereditary, the caste system was employment based, so yes, in a sense every society has had some sort of caste system as someone responsible for say, cleaning shoes, was probably looked down upon in most societies compared to say, a king. However, the key point of difference is that it was more deeply ingrained in Indian society and was made into a rather rigid hereditary system. While in other places the child of a shoe cleaner might end up marrying a trader or might end up working as a trader himself, doing so would have faced more resistance from society in India. This can still occasionally be seen in villages and sometimes even towns and cities, where individuals from different castes want to get married but are murdered instead, either by the community or even their own families. This effectively forced those in 'lower' jobs like cleaning drains into that position for generations, inflicting a lot more unjust suffering upon them.
- UltraViolence 5y agoIt took hundreds of years for the tribal system to become fully abolished in North-Western Europe and I suspect it will take a similar amount of time before the caste system is eradicated.
- hemantv 5y ago
- pinephoneguy 5y agoHaving different standards for different races (especially your own race) is racist.
- jonny_eh 5y agoNobody in America has ever been racist to me, therefore racism doesn't exist.
- commandlinefan 5y agoThe converse of that is "I've never seen it, therefore it does exist". That would suggest that bigfoot, UFO's and the Loch Ness monster are all real.
- jonny_eh 5y agoExcept the article provides concrete examples of it existing.
- fdgsdfogijq 5y agoIn a well known big tech company (FAANG), I have seen many many examples of a whole layer of management from the same caste. So like under one director, every senior manager will have been from the same part of India. Sometimes this will extend to another layer of managers below them. Behind the scenes, there is a strong communication network that is often not caught or shown in org charts. This will include high ranking engineers and managers from sister organizations. It usually doesnt extend beyond that, since HR will be all over it. Often they will even go out of their way not to hire Indians as their directs, so as to deny any discrimination based hiring. But its rampant.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoI saw the same at a prominent financial services firm. 50 - 60 Indians in the same dept from the same region. A big number. I even asked a senior manager if I needed to be Indian to excel at the company. He said the very fact I asked that question is a problem, whether or not it is true.
- civilized 5y agoWas the problem your asking the question, or was the problem the apparent pattern of rampant casteism?
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoI am not Indian. Hope that helps explain.
- novok 5y agoWas he an Indian sr manager too?
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoHe was also not Indian but many of the senior managers were
- jmyeet 5y agoIt's crazy to me to see people saying "this doesn't exist because I've never seen it". Here's a good rule to live by: privilege is invisible to those who have it. Just think about that. I'm not Indian so can't speak to that experience but discrimination masquerading as "culture fit" is just as rampant in Silicon Valley as it is in the rest of the US. This includes racism, ageism, misogyny and classism. If you don't think MIT/Stanford grads in their mid 20s at Big Tech companies have more doors open to them you're crazy. There is a tendency in the West to view all minorities as somehow being the same. Like all Africans are somehow viewed the same in many ways despite their being significant cultural, religious and language differences that go back centuries. The same is true in Asia (eg a lot of Chinese in Malaysia face significant discrimination such that they end up going to university overseas because they can't locally). So a deeply ingrained caste system like India's I can totally believe doesn't magically disappear because those raised in that system now happen to live and work in the United States.
- tomc1985 5y ago> There is a tendency in the West to view all minorities as somehow being the same. Is there? While my experience comes from living in a cosmopolitan border town, it is hard to imagine anyone seriously lumping Asians in with Africans, short of the outright rascists raging against "immigrants"
- YeezyMode 5y agoThe following sentence clearly mentions what kind of lumping takes place; "All Africans" / "All Asians" etc.
- jeffy90 5y agoI think it's common of all groups to lump individuals of other groups. Someone might say "<republicans | democrats | asians | whites | blacks | chinese | americans | rich | poor> all think that <insert thing here here>". it's worth noting that those with more power have greater potential to cause damage with their haphazard lumping
- 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoOne day it occurred to me that I can tell if someone is from India, but that I'd never considered to notice more nuances than that, for such a big country with so many groups of people. I have just begun to notice, but I have no idea about the identity politics. I recall in college that some of my friends from India would fawn over certain last names, and I felt it was something to do with the caste system, but I had concluded that the people I was around in universities and in the workforce were mostly from a level of privilege that it wouldn't be possible to learn more. I always found Indian nationalism to be strange, where so many people would interject that everything is perfect. Makes it easier for me to avoid my own US nationalism, because it must be just as comical to others. In this article it mentions Dalit. How many people from that group would be in Silicon Valley, is it impossible to know since it is insensitive to ask and disastrous for them if people did know? Seems like there is a potential for solidarity amongst more vocal groups pushing for representation.
- jsnodlin 5y ago
- thowaway_2mar 5y ago^ How many people from that group would be in Silicon Valley Less that 10% Over 90% of Indian techies in the US are upper-caste Indians - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24552047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24552047 - Sept 2020 (613 comments) ^ Seems like there is a potential for solidarity amongst more vocal groups pushing for representation. Good luck, but I don't believe that's happening anytime soon considering that SV is upper-caste dominated also no politician really gives a damn unless your group has the population significant enough to win the elections. Also, do you know prop-16 was rejected by Cali, the most progressive state in the US. see https://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/prop-16-failed-in-california https://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/prop-16-failed-in-californ...
- random314 5y agoThe 10% can be split into 2 more layers - Dalits (untouchables) and Shudras. Dalits are significantly worse off than Shudras.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bishamsingh 5y ago
- zxienin 5y agoI am from “upper caste”. My experience might not be commonly heard perspective. In 10th grade of schooling, my parents changed my lastname to avoid that folks figure out the caste. Due to affirmative action (aka reservation) on steroids, upper caste were losing opportunities. My parents wanted to avoid that I lose out on selection, promotions.., where subjective discretion was involved. I do not recall ever seeing casteism at workplace. So reading these reports have been surprising to me, since these are not subtle, but rampant. I can only attribute it to my privilege driven echo chamber. Or the fact that I never worked in US. (only briefly in India). What I read in media disgusts me. I am very motivated to make sure nothing like this happens in my zone of control / influence, at work. I know casteism is deeply rooted in Indian society. I do not relate with it. Many folks I know, don’t either. On optimistic side, I hope that means with newer generations, casteism will dilute and wither away.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 5y agoI am a non-white citizen of Russia through a rather bizarre family history. My parents changed my, and their names, and surname to Slavic sounding for reasons you can understand. Out of many, lower risk of being drafted (being non-white, and living in far-east increases likelihood of draft 10x,) ease of getting into a good school, or university for me, and simply lower chances of getting into random troubles with officials. At the same time, knowing this, I am as much as discomforted by practice of meritless "diversity hire" just for the sake of putting people of colour to pass the diversity checkbox. Pretending to play a role of "smart south Asian" while yes-manning, and knowing you being a decoration is as bad as discrimination, if not worse.
- Mezzie 5y agoI'm a white American, but I'm a homosexual female with a disability and I feel the same way as you. Sometimes, it could be an advantage, but using it that way just feels wrong given I know what it's like to lose out on things due to my sex/sexuality/disability. Why would I ever want anyone to lose to me because they're male/straight/not-disabled? I do wonder if I'm hampering myself, because those aspects of myself have presented some difficulties, but who's to say a straight white man didn't have difficulties of a similar level that were ignored because they didn't tick the diversity box? (Good luck to impoverished straight white men or straight white men who are autistic or have mental health problems). And I don't know about your experience, but mine is that a lot of the diversity checkbox people are in this for their personal brand/career and they're just as slimy and backstabby as any white men have ever been. At least the straight white dudes just call me a bitch to my face. I can respect that.
- bob66 5y ago
- redtriumph 5y ago> One day, Siddhant’s older son shared a story from his own life. A teacher had asked a group of kids, who were all of Indian descent, about their family backgrounds. One by one, the kids shouted out their religion, region, and caste. How can a school teacher ask kids about religion and caste? How does this not contribute to discrimination based on <religion, caste.. >?
- cpitman 5y agoIt doesn't sound like they did. They asked about family background, which often is a way to say "tell me about where you come from?" The telling part is the kids assuming the most important part of their background is religion, region, and caste.
- monkeycantype 5y agoI've been pretty lucky with how and where I grew up, materially I lacked nothing I needed , but my father who grew up in what Americans would call 'housing projects', despite his advanced maths education and subsequent successes still carries something of that background in his appearance, speech and humour, and has imparted a certain cultural stamp on all of his children. I work in a company where I see this caste behaviour among Indians very clearly, but I also see something else. Privilege gives you a comfort with privilege, an understanding of it's language and perspective, an expectation to be able to command others. My co-workers from wealthy Brahmin backgrounds communicate more naturally with Australians from similar backgrounds than I do. I communicate more naturally with Indians from more modest backgrounds, and the company falls organically into a certain hierarchy as a result of our behaviour.
- DesiLurker 5y agoI am an indian & have been in valley for last couple of decades. anecdotally speaking between me and my friends I have never heard of the caste based discrimination until that cisco case. so much so that people would bring it up at gatherings etc. Also in case anyone is wondering, I do not belong to the upper caste and most of my friends like me are not (not dalits either). btw in my experience internet dating & marriage sites have done more to break cast barriers in india than any social or affirmative action movement. I do think that it would take another generation for serious damage to happen to the caste system because towns & villages are still very much ingrained in this shit.
- sangnoir 5y agoTo quote a saying popularized by Donald Rumsfield: "The absence of evidence is not th evidence of absence". I - a male - haven't heard of any stories of sexual harassment or assault in my social circle (or at the office), but that doesn't mean it's not happening.
- DesiLurker 5y agoyes that is clearly recognized by use of the word 'anecdotally'. the key takeaway from my comment should be the fact that this incident is considered to have enough of a 'signal' to be considered a conversation topic. Also, the fact that it comes as a surprise to everybody I speak to should not be ignored.
- ThinkingAgain 5y agoThanks for this perspective on sexual harassment. It helped me realize that eventhough I have not seen it, it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I have never seen sexual harassment but am certain it exists. I was thinking the problem is limited to India and will not get carried over to US or tech industry in India. Was not expecting to see caste system in US too and was doubting if it was real. I had heard one story where adults in US were introducing themselves with caste. This story talks about even the kids are introducing with their caste. What are we teaching kids? Every Indian should read this. It doesn't matter if you discriminate or not, the person suffering is not dealing with just you but lots of people. Even if a small percentage discriminate that is bad enough for that person to feel vulnerable for long time.
- stretchwithme 5y agoYeah, but does that stop someone from starting their own company and hiring talented people in the same boat, as countless groups have done before?
- pempem 5y agoIts real and yet it feels like 'fun' to write about the 'exotic' caste system rather than the very real visa hierarchy, hb1 strategies etc. that are in play
- manish_gill 5y agoCare to elaborate?
- pklausler 5y agoI'm not Indian, but I'd like to know how to be more sensitive to this kind of discrimination. What should I be looking out for?
- user- 5y agoMy parents are from India, im from Canada. Luckily ive never really seen any caste discrimination, but we are from a religion that specifically outlawed this hundreds of years ago (sikhism), even though it didn't exactly dissappear. I know its something that exists though, its mind boggling that people still adhere to it. Hopefully it goes away though. Here is an interesting interview type video on it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_g9EraoHbWw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_g9EraoHbWw
- screye 5y agoCaste among Sikh[1] and Muslim[2] communities is as deeply rooted as caste in Hindus. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BSN-3nmMyM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BSN-3nmMyM [2] https://theprint.in/opinion/indias-muslim-community-under-a-churn-85-backward-pasmandas-up-against-15-ashrafs/234599/ https://theprint.in/opinion/indias-muslim-community-under-a-...
- user- 5y agoThanks for these, dissapointing to hear but the more I know the better
- withinboredom 5y agoDid you just man-splain someone’s own religion/community?
- screye 5y agoI merely pointed out that their claim did not pass academic or statistic rigor. India is a big country, and we all live in our silos. I merely refuted the claim. I don't believe I did so condescending-ly or as a means of putting them down. It is one thing to say that "X is not technically a part of our religion" or "I have never witnessed X" and another other to dismiss it as a phenomenon entirely.
- barry-cotter 5y agoAh yes, no one can ever have factually wrong beliefs about their own community. The Serbs were merely defending themselves on Yugoslavia in the 90s.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoOk, so we have decades of US company policies trying (to less or more effect) to combat the black/white discrimination - quotas, tribunals, edication, Hollywood movies etc. What, besides Bollywood, should a US (tech) company do? Remove the surname field on the internal company address book? Prevent Indian nationals hiring / interviewing /managing other Indian nationals? I do ask seriously - my utterly uninformed instinct says that we are close to the equivalent of 1950s US - southern blacks left the USA to fight and came back with tales of drinking warm beer in British pubs and people being amazed by their accents not their skin colour. India is seeing a second generation leaving to work in global markets and there will be an effect. So - how do we get on the right side of history?
- exdsq 5y agoI think this is probably true of all people, no? Academically, socially, family wealth, etc... I may very well misunderstand this because I am not Indian and I appreciate it'll be more nuanced but in its most raw form is it not similar to the British class system, Ivy League vs non-Ivy League schools, etc? To me this is one of those things people really care about when they're involved and slightly better off - so someone in the upper-middle class, someone from a good school, etc - but the majority of people don't really care. The only people who care about what school they went to or what class they identify as are those slightly above average without other notable accomplishments yet. Professors at Harvard care less about their school prestige than the fresh undergrad entering the job market. So, to take this as an example, I'd assume the only people who care about the Indian caste system are young, in a caste slightly above average whatever that means, and yet to really progress in their career to have more notable accomplishments to base their identities around.
- flashgordon 5y agoWhen you are discriminated on the basis of age, caste, race and sex - how can I really pinpoint which discrimination is the most prominent?
- pansinghkoder 5y agoIf my fellow Indians are fostering this sort of hatred even after coming to US then we definitely haven't changed (and also, I am not shocked like others here).
- sumedh 5y ago> If my fellow Indians are fostering this sort of hatred even after coming to US Caste is like religion if you are brainwashed when you are kid, its almost impossible to let go even if you change countries. Hopefully the kids of these immigrants who grow up in the host country will not have the same hatred.
- thowaway_2mar 5y agoAlso, this is the reason students in their board exams (+2 / Twelfth-grade tests) were forbidden from writing their last name in the answer sheets. Teachers in India openly discriminated against students from other castes/jatis/varnas by giving them lower marks. Not just caste but discrimination based on the state-of-origin/language are often committed by identifying your group based on your last name. There are often groups in offices from some states that will ensure that folks that are not from their states don't succeed and are coerced into resigning. Folks from relatively developed states in India don't want to admit students from underdeveloped or poor states, which breeds another form of caste-language-based discrimination in India. Does caste-based discrimination exist? Yes, it does. But it depends on where you live. In rural India, it is more prevalent than in California. Is the Indian government doing anything about this menace? Yes, India has a positive discrimination system for these oppressed castes in all government universities and all governmental jobs. Today 65-75% of all seats in top Indian universities are for oppressed, underprivileged, and poor people. Is it better than now compared to when we got independence? Yes, but many want their kids not to marry into other castes, mainly lower caste.
- techie128 5y agoThis is BS. You don't write your name at all, just your student id number.
- thowaway_2mar 5y ago^ This is BS. You don't write your name at all, just your student id number. Also, this is the reason students in their board exams (+2 / Twelfth-grade tests) were forbidden from writing their last name in the answer sheets. Teachers in India openly discriminated against students from other castes/jatis/varnas by giving them lower marks. Didn't you notice the past tense? Also, this defensiveness without properly reading what I wrote is part of the problem. This maybe BS today, but it wasn't 25-30 years ago.
- nsenifty 5y agoI wrote exams 25-30 years ago. The answer script only had the ID number. We did write the name on the first page but it was torn off before it was passed on for grading.
- screye 5y agoI am an Indian who is from an OBC category. Caste related pieces in the western press miss the entire context around 1st-world-discrimination among Indians. It annoys me to no end, because discrimination is still a major problem in certain communities. But, the western media has cast it onto their agonizingly shallow concept of privilege and bigotry. I will preemptively apologize for my directness. Euphemisms dilute. I have written about it in some capacity on HN before. [1] But, I'll give you the 1 pager: 1. There are Indians and then there are Indians. The average undergrad at a UC is one of highly privileged 1st gen immigrant or 2nd gen Indian-American, both of who have no clue what caste even is. It is like trying to solve malnutrition in India, by feeding burgers to your fellow FANG engineer. In my 27 years surrounded by Indians, I have never been asked my caste, nor have my upper-caste peers made questionable comments in confidence. 2. Caste issues persist among those who pursue the hardest paths to success (eg: L1 sweat shop route) in the US. However, over the years, I have seen it develop into a 'crabs in a bucket' style circular firing squad. The more they believe in the 'zero sum nature' of an engagement, the more willing people are to stifle someone from the outgroup in an effort to get ahead. It is a dog-eat-dog world out there. 3. In truly poor communities in non-urban India, caste is a reality of life. India is a shit-hole nation (as a famous man once said). Desperate times in shit-hole places nudge good people into vile behaviors. Even past the explicit discrimination, generational poverty is crippling. On the bright side, things are getting less worse as a fast pace. But, to paint any rosier picture about this would amount to lying. 4. Sloppy affirmative action breeds resentment. (America, take notes) It hurts me to say this, but the proof is in the pudding. At my moderately-prestigious-Indian-university, I saw liberal 'general'(upper-ish caste) students turn resentfully anti-affirmative-action as they saw the bar be dropped so lower every year, in the Indian zero-sum career market. People are not judged for their caste. They are judged because their caste reveals that they got an easier path within a narrow academic structure. (This ofc, ignores the crippling poverty and social barriers these people also have to overcome. But, sociology 101 is not in our gen-eds). 5. Caste is dead, long live caste - Caste is so 1990s. The entire societal hierarchy shifted under the feet of sub-par social commenters and they never even noticed. A decent portion of 2nd generation American-Indians don't fraternize with 1st generation Indians. IITians stick to IItians. Masters H1b-OPT candidates look down on those who came through the L1 consultancy sweat-shop grind. I could write an entire book on this. It is a brutally merit status system, where merit is defined within a narrow academic context. (Indians are not unique in this phenomenon. I frequently see this among urban american communities too. Sorting into groups based on internal perceptions of status happens whenever a community reaches size threshold. If anything, it is a rather familiar social stratification) Shoe-horning the caste issue into hyper-polarized and shallow american power struggles is worsening the issue. India has been making rapid progress in terms of helping lower-caste communities. From representation in every local + national body to economic assistance to educational assistance to a harsh anti-discrimination law. In 70 years of independence, we have come a long way. The progress may be on a low base, but the delta is huge. UCs and California Liberals (with all connotations it carries) are wielding caste as a weapon for political means. Leaves a bad taste in my mouth. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30059449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30059449
- joncp 5y agoAn offer package of $450k?! Dang.
- Demonsult 5y agoIt was in the early 2000s outside of the valley. A coworker was basically held in indentured servitude by a family of a higher caste. They dropped him off at work every day, berating him the whole way there. We hired a lawyer, got all of his contracts thrown out, and hired him directly.
- qwertyuiop_ 5y agoI am from an upper caste in India but always despised my extended relatives treating people from lower castes like crap. Fortunately my parents moved to a cosmopolitan town where they converted to Christianity. Life changed for us from that point onwards. Relatives shunning us and blaming us for adopting the religion of lower castes and untouchables. Living on gov enterprise housing protected us from the discrimination of town folk I thought I would never have to face discrimination for simply being an upper caste Christian. Little did I know moving to USA made it worse. Almost all of transplants from India are upper castes and are of Hindu background. Most of them (not all) immediately categorized me as a "3rd tier Indian". I worked at the Indian Consulting Companies and when the colleagues realized I was a practicing Christian they "outed" me to their managers and I could see discrimination immediately. Not being invited to important meetings, passed for promotions and bad scores on employee reviews on and on. I even switched companies and would "accidentally" fall under Indian managers and they immediately probe where am I from etc etc. Followed by bad relationships and eventual souring. Most Indians who claim racism here in US usually come from upper/mid caste and lived decent lives in India and have seen their families and neighbors treat lower caste people like dirt.
- anon0192837465 5y agoRecent articles about casteism in US prompt me to think if there is some coordinated effort behind these articles? Have been living in US for 20+ years and never even once had any Indian mention caste. In fact, only time I was asked about my caste is by a white American lady, who thought I was of a specific caste due to my vocabulary! This happened only recently (in 20 years), which made me ponder if there is ongoing effort to malign India/Hinduism in US.
- random314 5y agoAmbedkar was an intellectual giant who wrote the Indian constitution. Glad to see him profiled here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar Jurist economist academic politician social reformer anthropologist writer
- perfecthjrjth 5y agoThe reality is otherwise. It was drafted by a bureaucrat called BN Rau. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._N._Rau https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._N._Rau
- random314 5y agoThis really goes to the heart of what casteism is all about in a modern urban "casteless" setting. Any time a lower caste does anything of significance, upper caste detractors show up to tell everyone that the good stuff was actually the work of someone else of upper castes. The lower caste made his mark only through affirmative action or other kinds of "trickery". The constitution was obviously written by several people and the team was led by Ambedkar. You can use the same website- wikipedia- to inform yourself of Ambedkars contributions to society in general and the constitution in particular. Go and pick up a book written by him too if you have the time. One of the nastier pieces of "information " about Ambedkar that an upper caste kid shared with me as a child was that Ambedkar was actually the bastard child of a Brahmin with a lower caste woman. This explains why he was so smart as all lower castes have very low IQ.
- black_13 5y ago
- thowaway_2mar 5y agoWhy can't the SV tech firms not provide affirmative action for the underprivileged lower-caste Dalits in hiring?
- sandeeps_ 5y agoFor hiring in the US?
- nirav72 5y agoAffirmative action is already very controversial in the United States and is probably couple of supreme court cases away from being gutted. At least in academia. There isn't going be any action for a group of people that represents less than 2% of the total U.S population. If anything, this is probably an issue for states to decide. You'd need a sizable lobby to influence such an action.
- giantg2 5y ago"with an offer package that totaled almost $450,000." Sounds like he went from the bottom 1% to the top 1%. That's impressive.
- fastball 5y agoSo it's not really Silicon Valley's caste system, it's India's caste system, which rears its ugly head in SV because there are so many 1st gen Indian workers.
- ryanqian 5y agoCan't image this is 21st centry currently.
- hello1234567 5y ago
- manish_gill 5y agoAs someone born and raised in India, things like this were a bit "distant" from me when I was in school (it came up but I was never a victim). But the more I got to know Indians who were more privileged than I have been, the pattern started to clearly emerge. I distinctly remember thinking - "people who are better educated than I am tend to be richer or from an upper caste background, usually both". I try to not let it get to me - I'm in a more "esoteric" position as I'm neither one of the privileged castes nor the downtrodden. My last name is still a dead giveaway to people who know. And I wonder how many opportunities I've missed because I've never been part of these subgroups (any subgroups really). I'm lucky enough that I have friends and a partner who recognise their historical privilege very well. It's why diversity is important. I love working with my Dutch, Indian, German, Turkish, Chinese, American, Brazilian etc... colleagues. When I'm in a diverse group, those feelings tend to fade away - because I know there isn't a large group that I might need to be closely aligned with. Of course, living in another country (not USA), the higher up I look at management, the less diversity I see. Same problem in a different form, I suppose. :) All of the above is just an individual experience. But data seems to confirm it.
- kumarvvr 5y ago> But data seems to confirm it. Can you share this data. I am curious.
- manish_gill 5y agohttps://www.livemint.com/Leisure/3u2QUPuXBEFPaBQXU2R8mJ/When-will-the-BrahminBania-hegemony-end.html https://www.livemint.com/Leisure/3u2QUPuXBEFPaBQXU2R8mJ/When... I'll edit this with more links later, it's 3am in my TZ atm.
- kumarvvr 5y agoAffirmative action in India is multi-fold. One, there is punishment for insult/discrimination based on caste (in public view, as per law). The law is very powerful, feared and sometimes misused. Two, there is a quota system in education and jobs, for some castes in the society. Three, once in a job that comes under affirmative action category, there is further affirmative action to move the person up through the ranks. Now, the resentments on this affirmative action (Ambedkar, who is highlighted in the passage, originally wrote that the AA will be for a period of 5 years, but has since been used as a vote bank tool) are plenty and some, IMV, are justified. One is that the current and previous generations, have seen very limited caste discriminations. Sure, events happen in a country as big and varied as India, but generally, caste based discriminations have been subdued, and mostly pushed back to silent and invisible forms (social interactions, marriages, friendships, etc). The current and previous generation kids, have hardly seen any caste based discrimination due to various reasons. It also helps that a section of political leaders are from the backward and other castes. What this brings about is the feeling of unfair punishment. A kid who is in high school now, who has friends from all walks of life, of many castes and religions (In my schooling, with high school ending in 2003, I never once bothered about caste and religion, as it was never a point of discussion) will write an exam for bagging a seat in a good college or university. Then he will discover, that the same friend who has been with him for all these years, has a similar lifestyle as him, goes everywhere he goes, does everything he does, is eligible for a seat with a lower cut-off score, buoyed by additional mandatory allotment of seats. From the perspective of the kid, he works hard and sincerely, only to be snubbed because his forefathers have insulted some castes in their days. What would you tell him? Two, the benefits of AA have not percolated throughout the society. Those who have benefitted from the initial steps, have risen to wealth and power, and continue to get the benefits, while those who really need help, often do not get it. Also, after 200 years of British occupation, India was left penniless. Couple that with decades of socialist policies, wealth generation was low and slow. This results in a huge section of population being poor. And this includes all castes and creeds. I often see negative and insulting remarks on Brahmins (considered the "highest" caste), and often they are blamed for all evils of caste discrimination (whereas, discrimination has been in the society from all sections and even within castes). However, presently, a majority of brahmins are poor or middle class. In this scenario, the only escape those who do not belong to the AA castes, is to move abroad in search of better opportunities. All this caste based drama in SV and elsewhere is the result of that feeling of unfair punishment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 5y agoI think it serves as a good reminder that racism is a thing most all races do to other races or subgroups of their own race. In tech these days there's enough racial groups that you are as likely (or more, in my experience) to end up with blatantly racist behavior from minority groups who either only hire their own or explicitly do not hire specific minorities they dislike. I remember working at a bank where the portfolio trading team was all racial group X, algo team racial group Y, and OMS racial group Z.. because the managers were... The white guys were like the generic neutral glue that could sometimes be hired into the X/Y/Z group teams. My previous fund I recall a friend telling me he started looking for a new job as soon as our new boss started as he was grilling him in their native language trying to figure out which specific racial/caste/regional sub-group he was from..
- steveBK123 5y agoI'd also add - caste being a good proxy for class generally.. This fits with a saying I've seen thrown around about our modern times, which is basically that "Class is the only remaining non-taboo bias in American polite society". Living in a very blue city in a very blue state surrounded by highly educated, "social justice warrior" types .. you'd be surprised how quickly the same people who have every type of window decal/bumper sticker/flag, march in every sort of rally you can imagine, and earnestly support every anti-racism/DEI initiative under the sun.. are willing to "punch down" class-wise, as long as the lower class people are white.
- ausbah 5y agoI don't think this is that surprising, most Americans - even if they are empirically wealthy or poor - consider themselves "middle class". seems like an implicit bias?
- jart 5y agoOne thing I've always wondered is how much if any awareness expats have of western last names. For instance, not to imply names matter, but the most famous person who shares my last name was a boxer. Great man, but he wasn't famous for being an Isaac Newton. So I'd hope no one would look at my name and think, oh she must be the kind of person who's really good at using her body rather than her brain. My experience with American culture is we only really focus on the positive aspects of names. Like if you're having a conversation with a Vanderbilt or a Rothschild it's hard to not notice that, but there's really not much awareness in terms of negative associations with names, since everyone deserves a shot, and since everyone's looking for their shot, it's the folks with prolific names who'd be more likely to conceal them.
- reactspa 5y agoA lot of upper caste indians will tell you there's no caste system any more. I'm an upper caste indian and here's my experience looking for an apartment to rent in Chennai, India, in around the year 2000. I was repeatedly asked by potential-landlords if I was a brahmin (I'm not), and told they couldn't rent to me if I wasn't. It was my first trip to Chennai (I'm from the north), and I am pretty sure it's illegal to openly ask a potential tenant if they're a brahmin. But there was simply nothing I could do about it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ralphc 5y agoThis is Hacker News, I think about workarounds and ways to hack "the system". The article talks about a pat on the shoulder to stealthily check for the Brahmin white thread. What's to prevent someone from wearing a thread under their clothes? If you have a religious problem with it, wear a color other than white, people aren't seeing it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crossroadsguy 5y agoLiving here in Bangalore (India’s so called Silicon Valley) you might miss the caste lines during your early years. It’s very easy to miss all that in the brouhaha of youth in a so called cosmopolitan city. But as you grow older you start seeing it everywhere, in everything. I see people directly referring to a candidate who didn’t do well in an interview “must have gotten admission to IIT/NIT via reservation” (reservation is something of American affirmative action; but I’m not really sure). Passing remarks behind the back of other colleagues. And then saying things like, apparently being generous, “wow, doesn’t seem like you’re from that community!” (implying as if that community is inherently weak and dumb and the individual is an exception). My name is as caste neutral as it gets. They still somehow figure it out - thousands of miles from my native place. When you tell them you never used reservation even though you were eligible - you become kinda of like them, a little. But the moment you say you didn’t use it because you didn’t need it and you wanted to leave the college seat for someone more needy and that you support reservation system - you’re thrown back away from being somewhat like them. Yes, the them and us are clear distinctions here. It comes in many shapes and forms. Landlords asking “we’d prefer vegetarians” that’s asking “we’re Brahmins and prefer Brahmin or upper caste tenants”. My friend just lied as he really liked a flat overlooking a lake and trees next to the balcony in a quiet area, he said “well, even though I’m a Brahmin I eat meat once in a while” (he wasn’t a Brahmin) and the landlord was soon saying, “of course, of course, food is a personal choice”. He left soon as the landlord politely but slyly kept trying to glean the confirmation out of his visitors including me, also tried setting him up with his niece assuming his caste. This will end up being a poorly written extremely long essay if I keep giving examples. It was very early in my pre teens that I was made aware of my caste and place in the social hierarchy. I was fully aware that I sit somewhere in the middle of the caste hierarchy and there are people above me and also below me. The power imbalance is so staggering and oppression is so deep rooted in such pervasive manner that all things might get consumed by the simmering anger and hatred one day. People who have lived mostly in cities easily fail to see this. They brush it aside saying we have jobs, we are moving on, we are getting educated. This is so ignorant and blinding that they not only miss that a far greater number that lives in villages and towns and smaller cities are unseen by them, they are not seeing what’s right in front of them in the same larger cities as well. And yes, a lot of them deliberately do not acknowledge such divides and inequalities - some with a desire to fit in, others with vested interests of historical social power. PS. Also, it’s so so different from the western notion of racism. So different.
- WheelsAtLarge 5y agoThis is very interesting. Here's a discrimination system that's completely invisible and in people's minds only. I'm sure that the highest caste has all the incentives to continue it. But I also feel that the lower caste continue it by their actions. They too feel that they are less because of the caste they were born into. Hiding is not the answer. By hiding, people signal that there is something to hide. I would even say that hiding makes it worse. It tells everyone that there is something to hide even the people uninterested in the situation. But when viewed objectively we can all see that there is nothing to hide. That it's just a bad idea that persists. How do you fix it? I suspect that by uniting and fighting against the very idea that it's a valid system is the way to fix it. In time, the whole system would eventually collapse. Bad ideas can disappear over time but people have to fight to make them go away. Specially the oppressed set. You don't fight the idea that it's an unfair system. You fight the idea that it should even exist. I know. It's easier said than done. But by fighting the very idea of its existence. It will eventually make the whole idea go away. The best example, I can think of, that is winning against a bad idea is the use of Queer in the LGBTQ community. 20 yrs ago "queer" was a horrible thing to say to an individual. The community has fought hard to change the word's meaning and now it has become a word that people like to hear. A word of pride. The whole idea has been turned on its head. Sure there are still people that use it as an insult but it's going away. 20 years from now it will just be a bad memory. Queer is and will be a point of pride. It was a genius idea in its simplicity and its effectiveness.
- saagarjha 5y ago> I'm sure that the highest caste has all the incentives to continue it. But I also feel that the lower caste continue it by their actions. They too feel that they are less because of the caste they were born into. Well…not exactly. There's plenty of situations where being of a certain caste, whether it's high or low, can confer you no benefit and sometimes even a disadvantage. So besides the general thing of people generally trying to move away from discrimination, it's not necessarily a thing everyone wants to perpetuate.
- dominotw 5y ago> For Siddhant, who now lives in the South Bay in a $2 million home, wearing his father’s Ambedkar watch reminds him of where he comes from—and where he still wants to go. Even now, whenever the stakes seem especially high, he’ll put on the watch and double-check that his shirt sleeves are long enough to conceal it. comon this is a bit over the top. Is this for real??
- rdelfin 5y agoDo you mean the home or the watch thing? Either way, it doesn't sound as far fetched. People will still judge you no matter how well you do for shit like this if they see you as inferior. It's very easy for them to explain away your success, be it affirmative action, hiding your past, or even calling it pure dumb luck. Hiding a watch with a clear symbol of the caste you belong to does seem plausible
- dominotw 5y agomaybe wearing an symbol of your caste to work on purpose puts people on the edge? also i have no idea what 'ambedkar watch' is, not sure if most people even know about this symbol of caste.
- mtalantikite 5y agoI think everyone should go read Ambedkar’s Annihilation of Caste, particularly Brahmins. It’s important for people of privilege to read his work, in the same way that it’s important for white people in the US to read Malcolm X’s autobiography. It will probably make you uncomfortable, but personal growth is often uncomfortable. The Indian Ministry of the Exterior has his work up for free [1], but I’d suggest the printed US edition of Annihilation of Caste with Arundhati Roy‘s introductory essay. [1] https://www.mea.gov.in/ambedkar.htm https://www.mea.gov.in/ambedkar.htm
- unmole 5y agoI have no trouble believing that people carry their casteist prejudices to Silicon Valley or that they act out their casteism in vile ways. But when I read stuff that is so clearly nonsensical, I start questioning what embellishment factor I should I account for. > Questions about a person’s last name or home village can be seen as invasive attempts to identify caste. A pat on the shoulder might be a friendly greeting—or a search for a sacred thread that some dominant-caste Hindu men wear beneath their shirts. There is simply no way to figure out someone's caste by their home village. The overwhelming majority of Hindu men from dominant castes do not wear a sacred thread. If someone believes that a pat on the shoulder might be checking for a caste marker, it's very likely that they'll be seeing caste discrimination where none exists.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> There is simply no way to figure out someone's caste by their home village. Most Indian villages will have multiple jatis (sub-caste groups) and it’s perfectly normal for endogamy to be so complete that people’s families speak exactly the same language and the genetic distance between them is on the order of that between Swedes and Sicilians. Indian genetics is fascinating.
- MisterSandman 5y agoYour home village might not be all you need, but it's part of the overall investigation that some Indians do to "figure out" someone's caste. I've seen it happen to my dad all the time when we're in another city or country. Stop pretending like you don't know what I'm talking about. You're either lying to yourself or being ignorant. I'm sure many things in the article are embellished, but stop reducing other people's experiences.
- unmole 5y ago> but it's part of the overall investigation that some Indians do to "figure out" A village is next to useless in terms of identifying one's caste. > I've seen it happen to my dad all the time when we're in another city or country. How? There are more than six million villages in India. Do these people maintain a distributed database of some sort? > I'm sure many things in the article are embellished How much of it is embellishment is exactly what I'm wondering. > but stop reducing other people's experiences. Maybe come up with a convincing argument rather than ask people to take your word for it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- intrasight 5y agoI don't "hide" the fact that I am Italian (couldn't if I had my mom's maiden name) but nor do I tell anyone - because a) they don't need to know and b) it's of no relevance. Honest question: why is it different with caste? Rather than "hide" it, why not have it a non-thing?
- commandlinefan 5y agoMy grandfather changed his German name in the 30's to something very non-German sounding. He never went into much detail as to why, but I have a pretty good guess.
- fay59 5y agoYou could just as well ask a racist why they don’t like black people.
- mtalantikite 5y agoBecause it could cause violence towards or the destruction of that Dalit person’s life: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste-related_violence_in_India https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste-related_violence_in_In... Caste is a very complex topic that spans back thousands of years — including the exploitation of the Manusmriti [1] by British colonists to wield their own power while colonizing South Asia — and is really not at all comparable to, say, being an “ethnic” white person like an Italian in early 20th century America (half-Irish here myself). [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manusmriti https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manusmriti
- flat-pluto 5y agoThis is a false equivalence though. Ideally it would be a non-thing. It has been a part of Indian society for a very long time, going back millennia, but it was codified in its modern form by the British. For instance: "Nicholas Dirks has argued that Indian caste as we know it today is a modern phenomenon as caste was fundamentally transformed by British colonial rule. According to Dirks, before colonial rule caste affiliation was quite loose and fluid, but colonial rule enforced caste affiliation rigorously, and constructed a much more strict hierarchy than existed previously, with some castes being criminalized and others being given preferential treatment." [1] Preferential treatment in this case means educational opportunity, administrative jobs, etc - essentially avenues of upward socio-economic mobility. Since then, it has almost become ingrained in Indian culture. So much so, that people think that one caste is "better" than the other, marrying into another caste would bring disgrace to the family and community, and so forth. Another factor to consider is affirmative action. There are few good public universities and jobs in India, and a certain percentage of them are reserved for groups who have been historically discriminated against. This kinda rubs upper-caste people the wrong way since some of them believe casteism no longer exists and that even if reservations are required, they should be based on the socio-economic status as opposed to one's caste. Overall, as you can tell by now, it's a pretty tense matter. Things are improving but by no means is it a non-thing.
- noipv4 5y agoI am surprised that India has managed to hide its caste system from the rest of the world so well; the ridiculous caste system which assigns a person's worth based on birth circumstances and cannot be changed during her/his lifetime.
- alphabettsy 5y agoHide it? We learned about it in middle school. Maybe that’s not common elsewhere in the US?
- throwaway420118 5y agoFather's name as last name and has studied in a top government college - backward caste. got it via reservation. Brown skin + studied in a top government college. backward caste. got in via reservation Fair skin + College(non-goverment quota) - probably from upper caste All these can be known from an interview by looking at the person and resume.
- steve76 5y ago[dead]
- dilliwal 5y agoI am also Indian and I mostly worked in EU. And for me, it came as a surprise, probably in EU, I am surrounded by less Indians!?
- thumbsup-_- 5y ago> A pat on the shoulder might be a friendly greeting—or a search for a sacred thread that some dominant-caste Hindu men wear beneath their shirts I'm a non-dalit Indian working in silicon valley. I know that caste based discrimination is still prevalent in India and not surprised that it continues in here in silicon valley as well amongst Indian community but I'm surprised to read this part in the article. I have never heard of someone doing a scan for sacred thread. Also, it's worth noting that most non-dalit people also do not wear this sacred thread so whoever is doing this scan isn't familiar with India or probably this part is made up in the article. That said, I know that it's much harder for a dalit person to progress in India as the society still tries to pull them behind. Indian govt has reservations in colleges and jobs for dalit community, which I believe has helped the community a lot in last 50 years or so, helping many to bring their families out of poverty. But, still there's a long way to go. Also, a long way to go for non-dalit community to abolish this discrimination. My heart goes with our dalit brothers & sisters and glad to hear that their issues are being discussed in silicon valley as well now.
- thweori234234 5y agoActually, Sai Deepak mentions that 15% of those classified as SC/STs also wear the sacred thread. Of course, we know 'Shudras' have run empires in India and have held high status before the age of colonialism. Unsuprising that the Western press and academia has the nuance of a brick, perhaps because their own history is so grotesquely checkered.
- ir123 5y agoThis is extremely misleading and a copout to suggest that even SC/STs wear the thread. Reality is that 99.99% of them don't. I wouldn't trust Sai Deepak with anything, he's a nut job who for some reason sounds eloquent to the upper class Hindus.
- pm90 5y ago> he's a nut job who for some reason sounds eloquent to the upper class Hindus. This is true for any demagogues btw. It’s why Jordan Peterson appeals so much to upper class White Americans.
- techmba 5y ago
- thweori234234 5y ago[dead]
- throwaway_281 5y agoI would like non-Indian people to know that the caste problem is not uniformly distributed throughout India. In cities like Kolkata, Chennai, and Mumbai- the problem is non-existent. The problem is much more rampant in Northern parts of India. This region is the American south without the good parts. This region ranks the highest in the country for foeticide of girl children. Because the society is deeply patriarchal. Honor killing, i.e. killing your own daughter or sibling for marrying outside caste is rampant. This region also votes in high numbers for divisive-policy holders. In other regions of India, the problem is much less visible. In Bengal, where I come from, I have never seen casteism. Inter-caste marriage is rampant. Yes, castiest assholes exist everywhere. But many don't care- or care only when it comes to marriage. I belong neither to a so-called "upper caste" nor I am a Dalit. Caste-based discrimination is minimal in here. Ambedkar is a venerable intellectual even if you completely disregard his caste identity and fights for Dalits. As a non-Dalit, I have deep respects for him- just as an intellectual, a nerd. What did away with caste mostly is colonialism. Colonialism attacks your way of living, and casteism is an Indian way of living. The places where British rule was consolidated, you will see much less casteism in those places. Casteism is not a new problem. Buddha faught against it two millenias ago. Do NOT listen to Hindus who say that casteism has nothing to do with Hinduism. Hindu scriptures such as Manu Smriti, Parashara Smriti, Yajnabalka Smriti are ripe with casteism. Even in the Mahabharata, it is said that capital punishment or holding is not apt for a Brahmin criminal. The most that can be done is banishing them. In Magadha Empire of the Mauryas, Kautilya suggests death penalty for Dalits who go to bed with a Brahmin woman. The opposite carries little punishment. And many foreigners are wondering whether asking about one's village is risky. I will say that it depends. In colonial strongholds, the villages are less segregated. And history takes place. Bengal was a stronghold of Buddhism during the Pala Empire. The staunch Brahmin Sen kingdom brought Brahmins from other Indian places and sent them to each village to "save" the masses. So, in a Bengali village, there are Brahmins as well as other people. And also local identity. Suppose, there is a village called "Mohanpur" or "Krishnagunj"- nobcaste identity here. But if there's a village called "Mahargaon", you know that it consists of Mahar sub-caste. That gives the identity away. It is also not true as many claim that most Brahmins do not wear threads. Only modern-minded, reformist kind of people give up thread. I have at least three Brahmin friends who gave up the thread. One of them is a Communist. So you get the picture! There is also a modern form of casteism due to the affirmative action policy. An SC person, no matter how rich or privileged, gets lucrative benefits. That draws hatred towards them. For example, to get in a Chemistry major course of a very prestigious college, an Unreserved caste person needed 94 in chemistry. But an SC person needed only 59 (out of hundred). That college is very expensive though. Frustrated mediocres of Unreserved caste hate on the reserved people for this. (The very good ones get in despite the reservation). In government employment or higher education, an SC person gets five fold advantage- 1. Age relaxation for five or more years. Say, 25 is the ceiling for others, but 30 for SC. 2. Cutoff marks in qualifying test is much lower. 3. Eligibility is marked off at 60% in college/HS for others, but 45% for SC. 4. Number of attempts is uncapped or much higher. 5. Even if you get through reservation, your reservation again applies when promotion is sought. All this, no matter how rich you are. This irks people. I had no such issues since I never suffered from reservation personally. But I know people who have. E.g.- a friend could not qualify for medical school despite getting 500+/720 in the entrance, but a much richer SC person got in a very good one at 400+/720. The former would need 650+/720 to get in the same school. This fuels modern casteism that I see in Bengal. I absolutely abhor the idea of caste. And just like the person in the article, I am no longer a Hindu. I despise all systems where you are marked off at your birth. Became an athiest at 16, and gave up Hinduism at 19. Many households do not care about casteism now. Many are hopeful, that with younger generations, casteism will automatically die out. But I am not so hopeful. I regularly meet young casteists. You should know that the Hindu Nationalistic BJP/RSS cabal has been trying very hard to get Dalit votes by calling them Hindus and forming a pseudo-unity against Muslims. Mass converting out of Hinduism to Christianity, Buddhism, and even Islam is common to irk the Brahmin overlords of society. You should also know that casteism is common in SC people and OBC (Other Backward Classes- a government term to classify people who are higher than Dalits in Hindu hierarchy but "lower" than upper castes). They do not like people marrying outside of their caste. You should also know that casteism is designed rather than natural. And these people in the SV are lucky. Their counterparts in North Indian villages suffer a much worse fate. I will monitor this thread, and ask me questions if you want.
- register 5y agoI am very happy for how it ended for Siddhant and pretty sure that he deserves all the best in this world. However to me a package of 450K as an individual contributor seems completely out of reality. I really don't get it. The fact that the same engineering skillset can be paid 450K in USA and peanuts in India (or any other country for what matters) seems to me a huge market distortion. Would like to understand more about why this is happening and how this can be sustainable.
- skynetv2 5y agoI have been working in SV for over 25 years now. I have never once seen anyone discriminating on caste. Having said that, I know of a couple of a people who have either completely avoided using their last names or took up new last names. I haven't seen it happening personally but people are still taking precautions to not get persecuted.
- rhuru 5y agoMost of the time you look deeply these stories are coming from Hinduphobic think tanks eventually funded by Islamist and/or evangelists. SONIA PAUL the writer is probably funded by the same Bangladeshi group that funded the fake Cisco caste lawsuite.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> He agonized, immensely, that other members of the Indian diaspora might turn on him for promoting “anti-Hindu hatred,” a term whose critics argue is a form of doublespeak—a way to use racial and religious protections to deflect scrutiny from caste. Wow, the article really called it when it comes to deflections like this.
- proshno 5y ago
- pl0x 5y agoIndians and Asians are some of the most racist people I have worked with as a trans. They are more concerned about what your genitals are than the work you can do. They are especially racist to those who identify as black, latinx, and womxn.
- rando827 5y agoThis seems to indicate discrimination is done by upper castes only. The reality is that everyone discriminates might be same for other religions in India. I am from what they call other backward caste. If you speak my relatives/community they don't like brahmins thinking as if they are superior to us. But they in turn think they are superior to other castes below them!. You don't hear much about other castes since its easy to abuse brahmins they don't have much legal power to fight back. While criticizing other castes can put you in jail.
- rramadass 5y agoJeez, this thread is a dumpster fire! The article is more Paranoia than Fact in today's context. What may have been true is earlier generations has largely disappeared in Urban areas and in particular; in the IT industry. Everybody just wants a good paying job and a decent life, nobody bothers much about Caste.
- techzerd 5y agoThe Pat on the shoulder to feel something sounded as ridiculous as it was written and I quite couldn't get myself to read the entire article. Never seen this in any place in the tech community in North America. I don't disagree that some bias may exist but the example borders on disillusional.
- foolinaround 5y agoIt is interesting that most here say they have not noticed this, when the caste system is pervasive in the US.I guess this is because it is not as egregious as it used to be, and this makes everyone feel better. Any Indian that comes to mind, and you could bet that he/she is from an upper caste. It is hidden only because it is sort of accepted, and thats not a good thing.
- xtat 5y agoFully expected this to be about SV's shitty deal /ponziesque living/vc situation but I guess Wired does Wired. (Not saying they are remotely wrong about any of this.)
- mariodiana 5y ago
- known 5y ago