8 ms·
Structurally, electrification, such as the mass production of electric vehicles, and digitalization need semiconductors, mostly of the high-end variety that can
by Animats 5y ago
Structurally, electrification, such as the mass production of electric vehicles, and digitalization need semiconductors, mostly of the high-end variety that can only be produced by the most advanced semiconductor foundries
There's nothing about electric car propulsion that requires "high end semiconductors". Auto companies have been pricing electric cars as a luxury product, and adding too much crap that has nothing to do with the powertrain to justify that to buyers.
- grogenaut 5y agoAre the power switching components similar to MOSFETs not a relatively advanced and recent device? Peoe usually think of advanced as Nvidia chips, but there are other parts.
- amelius 5y agoPerhaps, but my guess is they don't need to operate at high frequencies, which lowers the bar for complexity.
- sigstoat 5y agothe slower your power MOSFET, the more power you waste and heat you generate.
- baybal2 5y agoI am not an professional EE, but a person who professionally works on circuits from time to time. That's absolutely not the case. The higher is the switching frequency, they higher are the switching losses in a MOSFET. MOSFET is an electrostatic device, the charge needs to both go in, and out from the gate. The more switching, the more current goes through the gate back-and-forth.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoYou're talking about different things. A slow FET has a slow rise time. It spends more time crossing through the inefficient region between fully off and fully on. Switching frequency is how often you cross in one direction. Up to a point, you can decrease total converter loss by trading conduction loss for switching loss by increasing frequency and resizing components. After that point, you start losing efficiency again. There's a sweet spot.
- baybal2 5y agoYes, I see your nickname. That's the case if we go into details. I think he specifically means high-end, high-frequency power FETs, since all the rage today is about them. I would add that there is no real need for super-high-end switches in EVs, and component size for them is not a huge premium. There is no shortage of smart inverter topologies which achieve very good size, and efficiency without using any kind of fancy GaN of SiC switches. They will not be as small as them on the lower end, but around 100kw there is virtually no difference.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoIt's not a detail. It's a more complete picture. Both of your comments are different slices of the same pie. I don't see anything written above that pertains specifically to any type of FET. Your last paragraph is a new topic. It's true that Si can be as efficient as SiC and GaN, despite what the marketing usually says. But there are other benefits to new materials. They already support higher voltages with planar technology, and 3D will increase that further. Gate driving will get easier and more rugged.
- baybal2 5y ago> Your last paragraph is a new topic. It's true that Si can be as efficient as SiC and GaN, despite what the marketing usually says. But there are other benefits to new materials. They already support higher voltages with planar technology, and 3D will increase that further. Gate driving will get easier and more rugged. There are 1000V+ silicon switches today which are not as fast, but have for, for example, very good RDSon. 1000V I think is an upper limit one would go for passenger car EV motors.
- amelius 5y agoThis is true, but if you don't switch very often, then it doesn't matter as much :)
- pwr-electronics 5y agoThe do need high frequencies. It's orders of magnitude slower than digital, but the amount of power being switched presents entirely new problems. You could flip your statement around and say that digital circuits are less complex because they're low power. But that would be equally meaningless. Digital FETs are CMOS made with fins or whatever to switch as fast as possible. Analog FETs are something else to make clean predictable signals from mature manufacturing processes. Power FETs are big arrays of trenches to not destroy themselves. You can't really compare them. That would be like comparing a racecar to a passenger van to a rock hauler. They're all vehicles, but they have different purposes and success metrics.
- pstrateman 5y agoHigh power MOSFETs are definitely advanced devices... but not produced on the same process as say a CPU or GPU chip.
- kurthr 5y agoMOSFETs (both Si/SiC and more recent GaN) switching transistors may be made on special (Epi or Sapphire) wafers, but the Fabs are very old school (e.g. 2-6in vs 12in for CMOS) and the process geometries are practically neolithic (e.g. 90s). Processing equipment is more limited by the lack of desire to build or support something so old. Die sizes are also quite reasonable (e.g. 4kW/cm2) However, there is still enormous capacity for processing them around the world (both in US/EU, and around Asia). Perhaps, for the new GaN on Sapphire wafers there could be a significant manufacturing limit? Mostly, those are used for Blue LEDs today.
- greggsy 5y agoAre GaN2 and 3 more exotic, r are they just newer iterations of GaN?
- kurthr 5y agoThose appear to marketing names applied to DC Chargers. I suspect that the GaN2&3 refer to higher frequency operation. This may be due to lower parasitic capacitances, and would allow smaller components/inductors to be used at comparable efficiencies and lower cost. Certainly, the wafers and materials seem to be the same.
- deckar01 5y agoThe Ford F-150 Lightning’s extended range battery is currently only being offered as part of a $20k luxury electronics package starting at the XLT trim. The XLT is itself a mostly cosmetic $10k lighting package. You have to spend 80% over the base price to increase the battery capacity 30%.
- Casteil 5y agoYep - makes the base model F150 Lightning feel like a 'loss leader'
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Animats 5y agoStellantis is worse. The all-electric Jeep Wrangler is supposed to come out in 2024 priced around $70,000. You have to get the "Rubicon" "trim level", which used to mean differential lockers and a lower low gear, but now includes such things as "biometric owner identification". This kind of thinking is going to result in Chinese electric car manufacturers taking over the industry.
- ok123456 5y agoPeople will shell out insane amounts of money because of the Jeep brand. Clapped out, 10-year-old ones still can get $20k, even if you tried to take it remotely "off-road" it would break in 10 different ways. If people made purely rational decisions when purchasing a car, the only manufactures left would be Toyota and Honda.
- nsm 5y agoExactly! I would love to own a simple compact car like the Honda Fit or similar with an electric drive train and without leather seats, fancy wheels and various electronic assistive driving features.
- pureliquidhw 5y agoIsn't that a Nissan leaf?
- surfmike 5y agoIt is, I’m quite happy with mine and you can find leases dirt cheap. And actually their optional assistive driving system works quite well.
- FooHentai 5y agoI love our Leaf but ProPilot isn't that great, very much version 0.1 of something that might be less crap in future. The adaptive cruise control bit is fantastic but lane following only works when you're on very well marked roads that don't curve much i.e. highway driving and comes with a page-long list of times when it just won't work (driving into the sun, with wipers on, in fog, etc etc). Anywhere other than the highway it'll dance on and off every five seconds. Plus you have to weld your hands to the wheel and continuously wiggle a little or it'll turn itself off, which makes it mostly pointless. Self-park is similarly crappy. Way too slow to be of any use. Unless you're buying new though it's certainly worth getting one with ProPilot because the price difference in the second hand market is practically nothing. I dunno if the lower trim levels come with the 360 camera either but that's a great feature as well.
- Tempest1981 5y agoChevy Bolt is a similar size. Or ID.3 (non-US). Or a used eGolf.
- fragmede 5y agoTesla and BMW have, but they're hardly the entire electric car market. Other all-electric vehicles like the Nissan Leaf EV ($23k MSRP) or Chevy Bolt ($34k MSRP) are positively affordable compared to a Tesla Model 3 ($45k MSRP) or BMW i3 ($44k MSRP). Both of those are still cheap next to a Jaguar iPace ($70k MSRP) or a Tesla Model S ($95k) though. Keep in mind that even a Honda Civic starts off at $22k MSRP these days.
- tthun 5y agoI wish Tesla would cut the crap about self driving tech (which is probably driving up their margins and their stock value) and bring more affordable mass market cars to market. Clearly selling high margin cars is good for business but one can hope.
- smsm42 5y agoWhy would they do that? Being a luxury brand has a lot of advantages. No reason for them to dilute it with cheap offerings - others could pick up that market, if they want to.
- arcticbull 5y agoI strongly suspect that would be a disaster for their stock price. They remain priced at $837B market cap (even after a dramatic recent rout where Elon sold the top and is now under SEC investigation for doing so), while Toyota has a $300B market cap. Toyota makes ~8M cars per year [1]. Tesla made 400K cars last year [2]. Toyota made 20X more cars and has a market cap just 36% of TSLA. There's a few ways cultists (err, sorry, investors) justify this valuation gap. 1. Self driving cars. 2. High margins. If you give up on self-driving and you start making lower-margin cars, you start to look an awful lot like a car company, which would mean you'd have to reduce their stock price to just 10-20% of where it's at right now. From $800 to $80-160. And that's generous, leaving room for some of their fun pet projects like the always-next-year solar roof tile [3]. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/267272/worldwide-vehicle-production-of-toyota/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/267272/worldwide-vehicle... [2] https://backlinko.com/tesla-stats https://backlinko.com/tesla-stats [3] https://electrek.co/2022/02/02/tesla-supply-chain-issues-extend-to-solar-roof-stops-scheduling-installation/ https://electrek.co/2022/02/02/tesla-supply-chain-issues-ext...
- est31 5y ago> There's nothing about electric car propulsion that requires "high end semiconductors". Fundamentally, no, but that doesn't mean that these cars have been designed with chip availability in mind, so at least one of the components in the cars relies on chips that are not in supply. It's not a fundamental requirement but due to how they are being built. The article is still wrong though, namely because there is nothing special about electric cars. For ICE cars, there are supply chain issues too.
- sremani 5y agoI can put in the source -- but I read somewhere that EVs use twice the number of "chips" compared to conventional cars. edit: - here is a source -- but not the one I read in past. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chip-shortage-threatens-bidens-electric-vehicle-plans-commerce-secretary-says/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CEVs%2C%20particularly%20those%20designed%20on,Michigan%20who%20studies%20electric%20vehicles https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chip-shortage-thr....
- baybal2 5y ago> There's nothing about electric car propulsion that requires "high end semiconductors". Yes, the article is written by a person who has no idea what he is saying
- tyingq 5y agoI suppose they need things ICE cars don't usually have, to control multiple motors, a torque controller, regenerative braking, battery management, charge controllers, electric heating, and so on. But then ICE has to manage things they don't, like O2 sensors, ignition timing, etc.
- GeorgeTirebiter 5y agoI maintain that most of the car's electronic guts (minus infotainment and auto-steer etc) could be done with a handful of 8051s. The problem is almost nobody it seems knows assembly anymore. The standards of CAN and LIN were created in the days of 8-bit MPUs, even I2C is quite old. (I like assembly, but would never suggest it for a professional situation unless painted into some unforeseen corner, and assy would be the only way out.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- javcasas 5y agoIs there a 8051-based microcontroller with the usual FLASH memory and with tools to program it like a PLC? Hardware should be programmed like PLCs, we are just overcomplicating most hardware stuff by throwing OO & FP at it.
- codebje 5y agoSquillions of them. Microchip, Silicon Labs, Infineon, and Maxim all produce such µCs, like the Silicon Labs EFM8BB - up to 50MHz, a small handful of kb of program space, a smaller on-die RAM, off you go. Or pick a more specialised IC like the Cypress FX2LP family of USB controllers - they embed an 8051 core so you can apply firmware using cheap, widely available tools.
- 14u2c 5y agoAs far as I've seen the shortage as it relates to electric vehicles is due to a lack of power devices, such as high power MOSFETs, not logic ICs.
- jcims 5y agoThis is the one thing they can't do without. Pretty hard to switch 1000A at 400V 5,000 times a second.
- spacemanmatt 5y ago
- cjsplat 5y agoCompletely unclear what they mean by "high end". If you are doing a new design and estimates of area, pads, packaging and volumes are in the right place, TSMC 28nm or Intel 22nm are both very nice design points. Proven tech, single patterned mask sets, fully amortized fabs. At typical automobile volume, it is unlikely that a sub 10nm design would pencil out. (Edit : oops - Vision and/or ML engines for self-driving or driver assist might get there as long as the design is not dedicated to typical car volume)
- bluGill 5y agoAutomakers prefer low end chips because cars are an extreme environment. Cars need to start at -70c and +50c. For that latter one some of them need to work when it is sunny and they are inside the car which adds a lot more.
- seanp2k2 5y agoAlso, lots of silicon that goes into cars isn't of the high-end variety. A ton of infotainment systems, for example, run low to mid-tier chips, not always current-gen. If an auto mfg can get away with using a $3 part instead of a $5 even though it makes the UI laggy and sucky to use, they'll consider it. TV mfgs are also notorious for this, especially when it comes to under-speccing RAM.
- pdonis 5y agoNot the bare propulsion, but battery management does require sophisticated sensors and software that has to run in real time in order to carefully manage the charging and discharging of the batteries. If you don't do that, your battery life will suck. I could see that driving a need for high end semiconductors for electric vehicles.
- TheDudeMan 5y agoYou don't need to check the battery every nanosecond. Every millisecond is fine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 5y agoI didn't say "every nanosecond". Every millisecond might still need high end semiconductors.
- kube-system 5y agoBy “high end semiconductor” do we only mean small process size? There are other areas of “high end” capability, like the efficiency gains promised from using more exotic semiconductor materials.
- bgro 5y agoI saw a news video (CNBC?) on YouTube looking into how the chip supply shortage is affecting car sales. One of the car manufacturer representatives said they have had to cut features like power windows / locks, as may be expected. However, he said heated seats (and some other luxury things) are an absolutely critical feature that couldn't possibly be omitted in an emergency situation like this. They're essentially as critical as having the steering wheel or brakes.
- ISL 5y agoFor an electric car, they may be. Heating people is much more efficient than heating people by heating air.
- darnTootin 5y agoI disagree. Electrical vehicles require a larger chip area, typically chip quality is determined by degree of successful ion impregnation into the substrate. This is why die location can determine higher potential chip performance.