15 ms·
It is definitely the last one. >Last, using swift as a weapon against Russia could hurt long-term American interests. America holds sway over international fin
by ksec 5y ago
It is definitely the last one.
>Last, using swift as a weapon against Russia could hurt long-term American interests. America holds sway over international finance thanks to the dollar’s dominance and its pre-eminent role in global settlement systems. Further politicising swift would give China an incentive to bolster cips, its rival to swift for cross-border payments in yuan. It would also help China court any country with uneasy relations with America looking for alternatives.
I would imagine there are additional politics in play with disabling SWIFT. I dont how many countries will need to agree before shutting down SWIFT access, if it is at the will of US it would be more like a semi-nuclear option.
Although I am already surprised by CIPS, one eighth of transaction volume of SWIFT is not "well behind". From many POV this already seems like a battle the west are clearly losing.
- liminal 5y agoWill sanctions need to broaden to include China or other countries supporting Russia?
- lisper 5y agoSanctions only work when imposed by a stronger country on a weaker one. Ecuador, for example, cannot impose sanctions on the U.S. For this reason, it is quickly becoming unfeasible to impose sanctions on China. Imposing effective sanctions on Russia is already hard enough, and Russia's economy is much smaller than China's.
- pydry 5y agoChina has hinted before at imposing sanctions on the US. It's the first country that has been able to make that threat credibly in.... ohhh, a long long time.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThey've imposed sanctions on US weapon companies recently. Soon once their domestic airplanes are semi-competitive with Airbus, they may even sanction Boeing.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThis is what I suspected would happen once the US sanctioned Russia.
- stickfigure 5y agoWhat would that even mean? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_largest_trading_partners_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_largest_trading_pa... China is heavily dependent on trade with The West, in a way that The West is not dependent upon China. And that doesn't factor in Asian economies like Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and Vietnam that are generally likely to side against China.
- lazide 5y agoThat ship sailed awhile ago - as was quite clear during the Trump admin, the US can't effectively apply sanctions to China, and even moderate trade disagreements didn't actually go the way the US wanted it to. Additionally, if you want to see a crushing economic situation, imagine if China started to raise prices during already high USD inflation.
- bombcar 5y agoIf the EU is unwilling to stop gas shipments from Russia, so much more is the USA unwilling to stop shipment of everything from China.
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoWhy would China be willing to stop gas shipments from Russia? USA is also not willing to stop oil shipments from Russia, although Russia is the third-biggest oil exporters to the USA. Independent states usually don't do anything that would harm them directly, they force their colonies and vassals to harm both themselves and the enemies. In this case, it's the EU harming themselves and Russia with sanctions, while the USA and China being relatively unaffected.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoThe EU isn't harming itself it is protecting 70 years of peace on the continent that is now threatened by a paranoid Russian Czar. I would argue that this is less of a problem for the US than it is for Europe. China is an American problem Russia is ours.
- mortehu 5y agoIsn't it far more important to ensure that they can't use dollars, than avoiding giving them more? They already have dollar reserves. If we can make dollars worthless for them, they will have given us the gas for free from their perspective.
- sangnoir 5y ago> Isn't it far more important to ensure that they can't use dollars... It's in America's National Interest to maximize the usage of dollar reserves. Denying China the use of dollars would have a (relatively small) detrimental direct effect, and will set a precedent and likely accelerate the popularity of other reserve currencies.
- eptcyka 5y agoThat's like using high-velocity lead to remove an ingrown nail.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe more countries you cut off, the less you hurt them and the more you hurt yourself. If you sanction every country you're effectively sanctioning yourself, not that that is what you're suggesting :).
- throw_m239339 5y agoHow do you sanction China when a good chunk of western industries rely on Chinese factories? Without a collapse of western economies? Maybe the people who outsourced all our manufacturing and know how to China should have thought about all that... We're still in the middle of a chip crisis and haven't still figured out that relying on the region constitutes a threat to our way of life. Are we bringing back all these plants to the west? We aren't...
- mountainb 5y agoYes, this is the problem with sanctions and blockading without actually going to war. The chip crisis will pale compared to the steel etc. crisis in magnitude and importance. A severe reduction in size of the global economy is not necessarily a "collapse," it's just that -- a severe reduction under either direct or indirect war conditions.
- throw_m239339 5y ago> A severe reduction in size of the global economy is not necessarily a "collapse," it's just that -- a severe reduction under either direct or indirect war conditions. We have crazy levels of inflation right now among other economic problems and the FED or the EU central bank are running out of instruments to "tamper with". Anything at that point could trigger violent unrests across the west. Whatever the consequences of "sanctions" are, they won't be happening in a vacuum.
- cudgy 5y agoThe Fed’s tampering is the main reason for the inflation and the corner that they have painted the US economy into. Raise rates to proper levels to fight the inflation they created and risk recession; allow inflation and risk eventual revolt. Which choice will they make? Should they alone have the power to make these decisions is the true question.
- mountainb 5y ago
- ksec 5y agoThey wont, Which is why I said in the last sentence the west are clearly losing. US Food and Agriculture are already beholden to China. From corn, soy beans, potatoes to Pork ( Smithfield is owned by China ), Tyson has 25-30% of their business in China. If you buy Beef or Lamb from AUS you have a 25% chance buying it from Chinese Owner. Or To Tech from Intel, AMD, Nvidia, where the growth are in E-Sport or PC Gaming in China. Manufacturing or assembly where they have a contingency plan to Foxconn as ICT or more commonly known as Luxshare. RISC-V ( Nearly all Chinese startup getting on RISC-V gets much better funding ) and IMG PowerVR, ARM China. YMTC against Samsung and Micron on NAND and DRAM, BOE against Samsung and LG on OLED. If you exclude Apple and Samsung, the rest of Smartphone market are 80% Chinese Brands. Solar Panel is partially all Chinese. NBA. ( And English premier league which seems to have some following in US, they will be targeting F1 soon ). Even Amazon clothing are losing to SHEIN. Unless someone make a revolutionary leap in battery otherwise the current trajectory would be China winning the price / Whr. ( Not even Tabless Battery from Tesla / Panasonic ). They are gunning for electric car manufacturing and are also the largest customer of Boeing and AirBus. But are working on their own JET. The increasing percentage of patents on 5G to Video Codec from China. To inside influence on tech companies via employees. We have another thread about Reddit and Youtube moderation, that happened already in 2019 during Hong Kong protest. And Tik Tok I mentioned in [1], expanding financial services like AliPay and WeChat Pay via tourist influence. And all these circulate back to SWIFT and US dollar as dominant currency. I could talk about it for hours and this list is just for US, there are whole lots of other things from Japan, Taiwan, South Korea and SEA perspective. For a long time I try not to be blunt but I am sorry I have to write this out so clearly. I hope Ukraine is enough of a woke up call. I have been wondering if start up linked to certain political agenda will ever get accepted. We cant sit just here and watch. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30463767 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30463767
- rurp 5y agoI had the same thought as your last point. Regardless of what happens with SWIFT now China will keep pushing hard to reduce it's US dependencies and is clearly well on their way. Keeping your powder dry isn't so useful when it's evaporating in front of you.
- MR4D 5y agoChina has one dependency they cannot get rid of - Americans buy tons of their stuff, and if they get rid of that, China has a big problem.
- stickfigure 5y agoNot just Americans. If all 30 NATO nations threatened to halt trade, China would be in a tough position.
- dylan604 5y agoConvincing Americans to stop buy their wares is a huge task. Any political group that halts those wares from coming in would face huge upheaval. People are much more interested in their day to day comfort than something halfway across the globe (from a US perspective).
- MR4D 5y agoI agree completely. However, there are many situations where it can be reduced. For instance, I've heard chatter about people wondering about Apple's exposure to China[0] should China back Russia in the Ukraine conflict. At some point, it would be within Apple's best interest to look at reducing their dependency on a possible opponent. [0] - Obviously we can pick any number of company and country matchups for this discussion, but China is obviously the relevant discussion point to this topic, and Apple is a huge American company, so the example is much less esoteric than others. I'm not picking on Apple here at all.
- 5y ago
- rjzzleep 5y agoA lot of weapons are a lot scarier when you don't know what they are and what their impact is. You can't kick the BRICS out of SWIFT and expect the world to still take you serious. Decades of crippling sanctions have also taught China and Russia how to bypass altogether with certain countries. Short term it will probably sting, but long term its a death sentence to SWIFTs position.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIsn't the fact that the US controls it already a death sentence to it as far as Russia and China are concerned?
- dangerlibrary 5y agoYes.
- wolverine876 5y agoThey don't have the power to change it, though China might eventually. And they do benefit from it - international relations are rational, not so partisan; just because a competitor is involved doesn't make it wrong. The rules-based, US-led interational order brings enormous benefits to China and Russia.
- jeswin 5y ago> You can't kick the BRICS out of SWIFT Why would you need to kick BRICS out of SWIFT? India is a US ally on Quad, South Africa and Brazil aren't allied with Russia either. And at this point, no one is talking about kicking China out of SWIFT.
- lobocinza 5y agoBrazil is completely dependent on China for export/import. Current president is a Putin fan boy and tyrant wannabe.
- abhishekjha 5y ago> India is a US ally on Quad India has a different perspective for what does that exactly entail. India has its own UPI and Rupay systems. It sure would see SWIFT falling.
- throwoutway 5y agoI figured the sanctions would drive Russia into the arms of CIPS
- temp8964 5y agoI don't buy this logic. If China can get dominance, there is no reason for it to wait for the SWIFT to ban those bad actors. They can start their own system on the side right now.
- ksec 5y ago>They can start their own system on the side right now. CIPS is their own system.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoWhy would people trust CIPS with China in charge of it?
- cudgy 5y agoWhy not? The world trusts China to make their products and corporations entrust China with their sensitive intellectual property to manufacture goods. Even Charlie Munger and Warren Buffet (two conservative investors) trust China enough to invest in China. Doesn’t seem like a big stretch to trust China for money transfers.
- jatone 5y agothey wouldn't point is use both then you are reliant on neither.
- FpUser 5y agoThe end result is multiple payment systems so that the countries can do whatever they do without single entity being able to shut the valve. And you do not have to trust any single one. Consider it free market competition.
- maccolgan 5y agoPeople don't need "trust", they need alternatives. SWIFT is currently in a monopolistic situation right now. Any abuse of that position will lead to eroding trust.
- ren_engineer 5y agoI've been saying this for awhile, the US is screwed when the dollar loses reserve currency status and kicking Russia out of SWIFT accelerates the timeline for that dramatically. The fact India hasn't said a word about Russia and Pakistan PM is meeting with Putin right now is telling The US has been outplayed by China so badly it's almost laughable, Chess vs Checkers for decades now
- sinyug 5y ago> India hasn't said a word about Russia Why should we? When China killed 20 of our soldiers in 2020,[1] the whole world prayed for "de-escalation and a peaceful resolution." And that is what India will say in the Ukraine-Russia conflict. [1] 2020–2022 China–India skirmishes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020%E2%80%932022_China%E2%80%93India_skirmishes#International https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020%E2%80%932022_China%E2%80%...)
- ren_engineer 5y agoI'm agreeing that it is a wise decision. I put that in there because people in this thread are acting like India will blindly follow the US against Russia/China with things like sanctions. The US is in a weak position right now due to a number of dumb foreign policy decisions, going nuclear by kicking Russia off SWIFT would have even allies questioning SWIFT and cause the US to lose even more control over the financial system India is doing what's in the best interest of their people, which is what a government should do https://www.reuters.com/world/india/india-explores-setting-up-rupee-trade-accounts-with-russia-soften-sanctions-blow-2022-02-25/ https://www.reuters.com/world/india/india-explores-setting-u...
- wolverine876 5y agoEvery country in the world has suffered many such slights, but somehow we have to and we do cooperate, to our great mutual benefit. The slights are used by those who want division, in every country (and if they can't think of one, they make them up anyway). Why should India sacrifice it's larger interests to temporary outrage - never a good idea in international or personal relations. (Also, China didn't attempt to conquer India, attacking Delhi, Mumbai; annexing the south, etc. The comparison is very exaggerated.)
- DrBazza 5y agoIt's this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valeriepieris_circle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valeriepieris_circle Half the world's population lives with a 2500 mile radius circle centred over the South China Sea. There's a market.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoI really love maps like this But how's this related to SWIFT?
- rconti 5y agoOne post up. China, CIPS, strategic interests.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agois proximity to the country that owns a transaction processing system relevant in a fully digital world? Do you see India and Japan (and Vietnam and South Korea, all within the circle) joining a system controlled by China. India has its own SWIFT alternative as a matter of fact
- vasco 5y agoCountries in the proximity of other countries are more likely to have larger trade volumes between them, increasing the chances they hold each others currencies in reserves and have incentives to use a common payment network. This is why geographic proximity is relevant even in a fully digital world. At least while a significant portion of trade consists of physical goods that have to be moved across borders.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> is proximity to the country that owns a transaction processing system relevant in a fully digital world? Very much yes. Think of two people trading rice between china and the Philippians. That rice is not digital. It is traveling across a not-digital ocean on a not-digital ship. If something goes wrong with a payment they would much rather be dealing with someone in the same timezone who can address the issue before the non-digital ship gets locked down somewhere. When things go very wrong, they don't want to be shopping for a European lawfirm to help with a matter between two Asian businesses. Timezones, language and local understanding still matters for realworld trade.
- giordano-bruno 5y ago
- sam_lowry_ 5y ago> how many countries will need to agree before shutting down SWIFT access Its HQ is in Belgium, so technically, this can be a unilateral decision by Belgian PM De Croo. In practice, as it was the case with Iran, US and EU have to reach political agreement before De Croo would budge.
- chasd00 5y agoisn't it a private company? If so, it would seem they could "de=platform" anyone at any time for any reason.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoIt is a cooperative https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/toonondernemingps.html?ondernemingsnummer=413330856 https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/toonondernemingps.htm...
- eunos 5y agoHuh didn't know that there's new Belgian PM. In my mind the Belgian PM is still either di rupio or Charles Michel.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Its HQ is in Belgium, so technically, this can be a unilateral decision by Belgian PM De Croo. How does the Belgian PM have power over it? The United Nations is headquartered in New York, but that doesn't give anyone in the US unilateral power over it.
- science4sail 5y agoPresumably the PM could coerce the SWIFT staff to do some action (see the fears European countries have about the relationship between the US government and its tech companies).
- sam_lowry_ 5y ago
- lumost 5y agoI suspect that the semi-nuclear option will get pulled sooner rather than later. Ultimately we are seeing a world where the west is extending financial, economic, societal, and diplomatic infrastructure to countries which actively disagree with the security, co-operation, and economic principals required for those institutions to exist. This situation is untenable in the long run.
- bostonsre 5y agoIs it feasible to throttle swift transactions to/from a country? Wonder if that could be a middle ground between full throughput and complete disconnection..
- wolverine876 5y ago> I suspect that the semi-nuclear option will get pulled sooner rather than later. Ultimately we are seeing a world where the west is extending financial, economic, societal, and diplomatic infrastructure to countries which actively disagree with the security, co-operation, and economic principals required for those institutions to exist. There's another option, which is growing the rules-based international order (as it's called). It had been growing for decades, and despite a bad few years, it is bigger than ever from any perspective other than ~2010 - for example, consider it from the perspective of 1985. And growing it is incredibly beneficial economically, for security, and for freedom - a far better outcome. The semi-nuclear option only achieves short-term survival; it does not build a world for our future. The main obstacle to growing it is not China and Russia, but the far-right nativist, reactionary political movements in democracies, especially the Republicans in the US. They oppose it (though being reactionaries, have no solution with which to replace it).
- EVdotIO 5y agoThat is a scary paragraph you put down there.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoYeah, I am sure CIPS won't be used politically.
- hanniabu 5y ago> Further politicising swift would give China an incentive to bolster cips It's not just China, but also crypto. This can already be seen with Ukrainians using stablecoins because they don't have access to banks.
- lordnacho 5y agoBut if SWIFT is already in play, everyone already has a reason to diversify, and will do so. You can't be making threats and not expect people to try to avoid the thing you're threatening. Also you can't be hesitating on everything that seems like a one-off. Then you really don't have a lot of sticks to shake at people. This whole thing is so embarrassing for the West. We won't let Ukraine into NATO, we won't promise not to, we won't send troops, we won't send much help at all, we won't sanction all Russian nationals (yes it's heavy handed), we won't sanction a few thousand top regime officials, we won't sanction just the oligarchs, we won't stop them living in the West, we won't even stop them sending money home.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> we won't sanction all Russian nationals It would be nice to see a mass deportation of Russian mafia.
- fsn4dN69ey 5y agoWhy should dual citizens living in other countries suffer, especially if they've lived there for decades? Asking for myself.
- lordnacho 5y agoSlightly disrupt, in a pretty small way, a few thousand people connected to the regime vs a bunch of Ukrainian civilians get killed, their homes destroyed, thousands of refugees, and troops on both sides die and are horribly injured. No idea if you're connected to the regime, but it would be unfortunate to mess up your life in the west. But there's a tolerable amount of collateral damage. This goes back to hurting yourself to hurt the bad guy, it's not a western ideal to harm the innocent, but we might end up where it happens and we shouldn't be paralyzed by the possibility.
- hkt 5y agoNot exactly a convincing expression of support for people's human rights, especially those of fellow citizens with dual nationality. Wouldn't exactly be a good look. A better solution is to clean up the financial sector, especially the City of London, and to move to renewables ASAP to break the hold of all petrostates on the West.