19 ms·
Nuclear-fusion reactor doubles record for energy made from fusing atoms
- pixelpoet 5y agoExcellent news, we need this so badly, especially now in Europe with Germany shutting down its nuclear (fission) plants and NS2 being cancelled. It's astonishing to me that the world isn't pulling out all the stops on fusion development, something like the space race or Manhattan project. Unfortunately, last I heard ITER building has halted: http://news.newenergytimes.net/2022/02/21/french-regulator-halts-assembly-of-iter-reactor/ http://news.newenergytimes.net/2022/02/21/french-regulator-h...
- andbberger 5y agowe could just pull all the stops to turn the fission reactors back on. we already found a magical solution to our energy problems, like 80 years ago. how can you expect it would turn out any different for fusion?
- tsimionescu 5y agoEven if fusion succeeds in net positive energy (which is still a ways off - even ITER, planned to finish in 2030, will not actually generate energy, they didn't even add a turbine to try), there are huge hurdles to scanning it up. It's impossible for fusion to be a significant source of energy in the time left to avert catastrophic global warming. Even with the most optimistic estimates, we will at best have a handful of small plants, nothing comparable to a fission power plant.
- stormbrew 5y agoThis is a really common kind of comment to this issue, but I think it's extremely short-sighted. At this point, because we're probably well past the point that anything we can practically do is likely to get us to net zero carbon before catastrophe (it's already here, really), we're at a point where we're probably going to need to go extremely negative even once we do get there. We're (ironically) going to need a lot of non-carbon-sourced energy to do that, it seems to me. We can't just be thinking about what we'll do to stem the tide, we have to keep working on how we're going to push it back.
- urthor 5y agoWe're realistically at a very good point in time to avert some of the worst case scenarios, I fail to see your point? We definitely want to be looking at technologies that have a high ROI for emission reduction in the next 10 year span, mixed with longer term projects. Fission is a longer term project. Simple as that.
- stormbrew 5y ago> We definitely want to be looking at technologies that have a high ROI for emission reduction in the next 10 year span, mixed with longer term projects. This... is my point? So I think you do see it. "Fusion can't save us now so we shouldn't invest in it at all" is short-sighted. This is not an either-or proposition, and frankly people have completely out of whack ideas of the scale of money that's been invested in fusion. Tens of billions of dollars are nothing in what's going to be a trillions of dollars problem. We need to be building out renewables, and ideally fission too, now. We need to get to carbon zero asap. And then comes the project of getting things back to where we need to be, and we are just not ready for the energy we're going to need to do that.
- urthor 5y agoSee this is the thing. People thing 10 billion dollars is a lot of money. My view is that 10 billion dollars is nothing. My view is that the total OECD investment in fusion R&D should be 10 billion. A year. For the next 50 years. The investment in the high ROI technologies, principally solar R&D and overnight energy capacity projects like water pump batteries, should be 100 billion (across the OECD). And the investment in CapEx, installing new panels, 200 billion. Our investment in STEM R&D, as a society, is just pitiful across the Western world. The portion of our tax dollars that go to long term R&D, the primary driver of productivity growth and progress in our nation's, is scrap.
- stormbrew 5y agoI don't really disagree with any of this, so I guess that's confirmation that you did see my point. Certainly, the fact that solar and wind are sure things right now warrants massive investment. Just throwing endless gobs of money at a problem that's as-yet unsolved doesn't necessarily lead to good outcomes, it also takes directed goals and all that. That's in theory what ITER is all about, though I think the slowness with which it got started will hamper it and we'll see success on other projects before it even gets to the testing phase. It was an attempt to create a moonshot that kinda failed, but the private sector seems more interested now so it might not matter. That said I'd actually be surprised if there isn't already much more than $200bil going into building out solar capacity worldwide. It's just not easily enumerated because it's not special anymore, and a lot of it is on small scales (ie. I'm gonna install about $20k of solar panels to my home this spring and I'm not alone, but it's hard to tell how much that adds up to).
- gruturo 5y agoThe catastrophic global warming you mention is not a boolean. It can always get worse, with the planet becoming more and more inhospitable, up to the point where mankind can't survive (wet bulb temperature permanently above 35c --> everyone dies without air conditioning) - and beyond. Even if it's too late to avoid it completely, it still makes very much sense to work on not making it even worse. Suggesting to abandon efforts in something because it will anyway not be ready in time, or to stop restrictions because "anyway it's too late" is just the next step in the strategy of the deniers - or, rather, their agitators, motivated by immense profit.
- t43562 5y agoShould we build N Wind turbines or blow the money on more fusion research? I would guess that we need to keep fusion research alive but the real bulk of the money should be for things that will work now.
- rob74 5y agoWhy not do both? Unless the wind turbines are in my back yard of course (which they can't be, according to the rules where I live wind turbines have to be ~2 km away from anyone's back yard, but still).
- ncmncm 5y agoBecause money is fungible. A dollar spent on fusion is a dollar not spent on solar panels or turbines that would displace fossil fuels immediately. And, it would be a dollar wasted, because the fusion work will never produce any commercially competitive power, anyway. So, it is a choice between buying something that contributes to a solution, or just pissing it away.
- rhn_mk1 5y ago> A dollar spent on fusion is a dollar not spent on solar panels or turbines that would displace fossil fuels immediately I see this claim a lot, but what makes this true? Why would money allocation be so inelastic, and why can't it become flexible?
- belter 5y agoITER is a scientific experiment. Even if goes according to plan ( and they are already late again ) and according to their official documents, the experiment will only start in 2035.
- beowulfey 5y agoFusion vs. renewables are not zero-sum. It’s possible to research one while supporting the other. All these fusion threads bash on fusion because renewables are here now, but in actuality fusion research and renewable rollouts can come from very different budgets.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI'm not saying research into fusion should be stopped. But I also don't think it's important to increase spending into fusion power, as the comment that I was replying to suggested. Even more so, i don't think we should be blocking investment into fission power on expectations that fusion power will make it deprecated in 10 years. It's good to have fusion power in our back pockets, but we shouldn't be relying on it for our energy plans quite yet.
- DennisP 5y agoWe should really stop using ITER as the reference. SPARC uses the same plasma physics with newer superconductors, and is expecting ITER-level performance in 2025. Most fusion scientists agree with that assessment. SPARC won't have a turbine either, but with a construction time of four years, it brings us a lot closer to the next reactor which will.
- tsimionescu 5y agoITER is still the biggest and best funded project. If SPARC shows anything impressive, we'll see, but so far I'd still bet on the bigger project.
- m0llusk 5y ago> ITER is still the biggest and best funded project. Which may be the core explanation for its failure.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 5y agoFusion will not solve any energy problems we have today, and is unconnected to them. Fusion will have to, maybe, compete with solar/wind/storage in 20-30 years, and beat the prices for that 20-30 years from now. With solar+storage being cheaper than many fossil fuels today, fusion is going to have to be extremely cheap to be able to be a competitive terrestrial energy source with 20-30 years more of solar and storage improvements.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoI agree that solar/wind price points have massively gone down but how is storage a solved problem? I have only seen research projects in this field, is there anyone who has commercially deployed an energy storage solution? (other than hydro projects)
- VBprogrammer 5y agoI don't think it is correct. Offshore wind is cost competitive with fossil fuels in the UK. However, if you include storage I believe this cost balloons significantly. That said, there are significant grid scale batteries coming online. The largest of these in California is 1.2GWh. By comparison the UK has about 30GWh of pumped storage.
- otherme123 5y agoThis short read should answer your questions: https://www.energy-storage.news/battery-storage-at-us20-mwh-breaking-down-low-cost-solar-plus-storage-ppas-in-the-usa/ https://www.energy-storage.news/battery-storage-at-us20-mwh-... It seems that we are at the turning point.
- RobertoG 5y agoThese look almost there (I know, I know, "almost"): https://ambri.com/ https://ambri.com/ (liquid metal battery) https://www.hydrostor.ca/ https://www.hydrostor.ca/ (compressed air)
- ncmncm 5y agoThe only problems we have with storage are (1) determining which will end up cheapest, or has the most valuable side benefits, and (2) building out. Hydrogen, anhydrous ammonia, and liquified air all produce a valuable industrial product once the tanks are full. Used to be their round-trip efficiency was considered too low, but with solar panels getting dirt cheap, just putting up more panels accommodates almost any conceivable loss. Likewise for long-distance high-voltage transmission lines; China is even building cables to Chile (!) for winter power from desert panel farms. Factories for industrial amounts of iron-air batteries are already under construction, and will be in full production by end of next year. It turns out that pumped hydro, the most mature and efficient current method, has far more potential than generally assumed. A regular hydro power dam has to be in a river valley with a big watershed area. But for hydro storage, all you need is a penstock up to a depression in the hills, no watershed or river needed. There are millions of those. Even if you build a dam along one end, it's cheap. And you can float solar panels on it, where they will reduce evaporation and also run more efficiently. Storage is a solved problem. We don't have much of it yet just because a renewable dollar is today better spent on a panel or turbine, and because cost for storage is falling even faster than for solar panels. Wait a bit, get more for the same money.
- 4WIW 5y agoI would think about more practical ways to reduce cost fuel consumption. We are still 10-15 years away from practical fusion. We have been, for the last 50 years. As for Germany, maybe it would make more sense not to hastily shut down nuclear reactors, in favor of coal and gas, or at least until the equivalent capacity of renewable energy is online, if they really cared about the environment?
- d-gearloose 5y agoThe distance to energy production through fusion is better expressed in funding, less so in time. https://m.slashdot.org/story/167399 https://m.slashdot.org/story/167399
- phreeza 5y ago... says researcher trying to get their research funded.
- k0k0r0 5y agoThis seems to me like a comment driven by jealousy. Simply because it doesn't add any reason to it, like for example: a discussion or at least a comment about how the capital invested in fusion is needed somewhere else.
- phreeza 5y agoSorry if it sounded flippant. The point I wanted to make, and which was not clear from the comment above without opening the link, was that this statement comes from someone with a clear conflict of interest. I think the burden of proof should be on the scientist, it just doesn't seem plausible to me that fusion progress is so fungible, especially not at timescales less than what it takes to train a fusion researcher.
- k0k0r0 5y agoThank you very much for this artikel. I found the explainations in that Q&A for most parts very understandable, and felt like they actually give direct answers to direct questions. Also I perceived the questions to be a very good composition. Unfortunately, it's from 2012, if I understand correctly. Can anybody recommend a similarly braod discussion of the big questions for the 'simple (wo)man'?
- inglor_cz 5y agoI can't see the European Green movement embracing anything that has "nuclear" in it.
- markvdb 5y agoI have anecdotal evidence to the contrary: myself. In the short and medium term, it's obvious that wind and solar are going to help us avoid the worst of the climate crisis. In the long term, we might need something more to reverse climate change. Existing nuclear fission energy capacity might be a short term stopgap. It's just clearly not sustainable because inherently too risky: - military/terror/nuclear proliferation risk - uninsurable accident risk - long-lived waste risk - uranium sourcing geopolitical risk Nuclear fusion however should be able to avoid most of these risks. All of this could be moot of course if dangerous idiots like Vladimir decide to solve the problem by killing a sufficiently large fraction of humanity. I'm cautiously optimistic though that a better solution is possible.
- gmueckl 5y agoThe German green party had made it part of their program to stop all research into all kinds of "nuclear" technologies, explicitly listing fusion research as something to be stopped. I think that this passage has been removed again, but the whole thing still serves as a good indicator for the sentiments here.
- danuker 5y agoThey do not mention fusion, but they are still clearly against fission: > Wir vollenden den Atomausstieg und bekennen uns zum verabredeten Pfad der Endlagersuche mit höchsten Sicherheitsstandards bei größtmöglicher Transparenz und Beteiligung der Bevölkerung. Der Rückbau der bestehenden Atomkraftwerke muss schleunigst und ohne Zeitverzögerung auf höchstem Sicherheitsniveau erfolgen. Die Atomfabriken in Gronau und Lingen wollen wir schnellstmöglich schließen Auch in der EU werden wir den Einstieg in den Atomausstieg vorantreiben. https://www.gruene.de/themen/energie https://www.gruene.de/themen/energie Google Translation: > We are completing the nuclear phase-out and are committed to the agreed path of searching for a repository with the highest safety standards and the greatest possible transparency and participation of the population. The dismantling of the existing nuclear power plants must be carried out as quickly as possible and without any delay at the highest level of safety. We want to close the nuclear factories in Gronau and Lingen as quickly as possible. In the EU, too, we will promote the phase-out of nuclear power. I believe it is misguided. Fission is a great intermediary technology, which killed way less people than coal, oil, and gas per energy produced, including the nuclear accidents. https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy#nuclear-energy-and-renewables-are-far-far-safer-than-fossil-fuels https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy#nuclear-... Shutting down fission before finding a solution for when the sun isn't shining and the wind isn't blowing is nuts, and results in emergency fuel burning (gas and coal).
- wanda 5y agoIn the same timeframe, much more success has been found in improving the efficiency of renewable power solutions which are functional out of the box, easier to maintain/update, cheaper, and an easier sell. I agree that fusion is important to research, but comparing it to the Manhattan Project or the Space Race is to forget that the world was at war when the atomic bomb was delivered from theory to reality in, what, 27 months? The world was locked in the grip of paranoia about nuclear armageddon and the US/Russia both felt the same existential need to establish a space presence to avoid losing ground or giving so much as a hint that either side might be technologically less capable of catastrophically second striking the other. Fusion is a notion that has been actively researched and experimented with in a time of relative peace. There's less pressure on the world because no one sees climate change in the same light as nuclear war. The world still has conflicts, but in the minds of the West, the nations that are in conflict are always in conflict, it's just how it is out there. Obviously this view is absolutely ethnocentric and absurd, but that's the mindset. War's just something to report on, something people almost expect to see on breakfast TV when they go to work. It would almost be eerie for them not to see or read about a war somewhere. Thus, I would argue in the absence of existential crisis, and in the presence of the climate change narrative where words like "renewable" and "green" are easily distinguished over "less waste than fission", fusion power ultimately just lost as a business prospect to renewable energy.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat we should have actually done is build new and more fission reactors decades ago and not shut the current once down. That how we could have solved the while issue decades ago. France had green energy for literally 40 years and nobody cares. Because 'nuke = evil' attitude, specially in Germany.
- imhoguy 5y ago> and NS2 being cancelled Only the certification has been suspended. I bet it resumes before the next winter season. All in good faith ofc - to overcome the inevitable energy crisis. Which in turn results from lobbying to shutdown so many nuclear plants so quickly.
- jetru 5y agoSkeptical. This video by Sabine clearly explains why a lot of these fusion research claims are dubious with a focus on ITER and JET: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJ4W1g-6JiY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJ4W1g-6JiY
- anonporridge 5y agoAgreed. She really did a great job explaining how the progress of fusion research is regularly miscommunicated to the public as more significant or quickly applicable than it actually is. Fusion in general seems like a false hope for any of our near term energy problems.
- jve 5y agoMoreover she communicates that to achieve the desired goal, Qtotal is the one that must exceed 1, and that is harder to achieve. That is, total electrical energy generated to exceed total energy to run the system. You have losses down the road, particularly when converting heat to electricity. It doesn't take away from research that is being done/must be done, but rather how far we are today from the results.
- pyinstallwoes 5y ago> JET’s latest experiment sustained a Q of 0.33 for 5 seconds, says Rimini. JET is a scaled-down version of ITER, at one-tenth of the volume — a bathtub compared to a swimming pool, says Proll. It loses heat more easily than ITER, so it was never expected to hit breakeven. If engineers applied the same conditions and physics approach to ITER as to JET, she says, it would probably reach its goal of a Q of 10, producing ten times the energy put in. "If engineers applied the same conditions and physics..." "...probably reach its goal of a Q of 10..." So casually thrown about! Source (the OP nature article): https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00391-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00391-1
- VaxWithSex 5y agoCame here to post this. Thanks for your service. Sabine explains clearly the problems while still advocating for Fusion research to continue.
- tejtm 5y agopreviously https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30271677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30271677 1128 points | 792 comments
- john_payette 5y agoindeed this news was already published a few days ago.
- calibas 5y agoNote, the power output was about 1/3 the power needed to sustain the reaction. > JET’s latest experiment sustained a Q of 0.33 for 5 seconds, says Rimini. JET is a scaled-down version of ITER, at one-tenth of the volume — a bathtub compared to a swimming pool, says Proll. It loses heat more easily than ITER, so it was never expected to hit breakeven. If engineers applied the same conditions and physics approach to ITER as to JET, she says, it would probably reach its goal of a Q of 10, producing ten times the energy put in. This seems odd to me, nobody has reached a Q of 1 yet, and she's claiming to be able to reach 10? That's great if it's true, but it seems a little fishy...
- d-gearloose 5y agoThe good thing about fusion is that a lot of problems stem from the size of the surface area as compared to the volume. The bigger the reaction vessel gets, the favorably this ratio is. This experiment just shows that the predictions about ITER seem to be in a realistic region.
- ncmncm 5y agoBigger being better is not a plus.
- pfdietz 5y agoYou have that backwards. The bad thing about fusion is that the power has to radiate through the surface of the reactor. That means that when you are at the engineering limit of what that wall can withstand, your volumetric power density decreases as you make the reactor larger. This is unlike a fission reactor, where heat is transferred through the surfaces of large numbers of thin fuel pins, and where the surface area increases in proportion to the volume of the core.
- ahoka 5y agoQ=10 is still not enough if you actually measure the whole experimental setup. Don't forget that to goal is to make a power plant where the whole building produces more energy than it consumes, and does it economically.
- Aeolun 5y agoAs much as I enjoy reading this news. It is feels heavily sensationalized. "Smashes" the energy record. We're talking about a fusion generator here, that after 25 years of work, now manages to output 'double' the energy, to 59 MJ in 5s -like 20 MW- while requiring 180 MJ input power. Somewhere hidden in the article is the news that this could mean a input/output ratio of 10 in a full scale reactor, but that's also something we've been waiting on for decades. I find it easy to be enthusiastic about fusion, but the news and research surrounding it makes me sad.
- ncmncm 5y agoThey are forever smashing this or that record, on the verge of break-even, on track to producing free energy without nasty radionuclides. But it is always a con. If they ever do get Q high enough to make energy production conceivable -- it will need Q > 100, when said and done -- a Tokamak reactor will cost 10x much as the equal-grade fission reactor, and cost >10x as much to operate. As fission reactors are today not competitive, and get less competitive by the day, power from Tokamak fusion will not ever be lighting up your house. That is not a bad thing: solar and wind are wholly up to the task, and just need building out. The more there is, the cheaper it gets. The only reliable product of the hot-neutron fusion research industry is dishonesty. There is also aneutronic fusion, that might actually have a future, even if only in space: If we are ever to operate in the outer solar system, something of the sort will be needed. Unfortunately it gets almost no money.
- bobsmooth 5y agoAs with every fusion article, I encourage anyone interested in the space to look into General Fusion. They're using liquid metal as both the reaction vessel and as a means to extract power. Really cool stuff.
- ncmncm 5y agoThis actually looks like it could be practical. Important differences from the Tokamak concept are: 1. No enormous magnets 2. No exposure of fragile equipment to hot neutrons 3. The reaction occurs in a bubble inside molten lead/lithium, compressed mechanically. 4. None of the pipes carrying hot metal (or anything else) are exposed to hot neutrons, so need not be replaced frequently. 5. The amount of molten metal is relatively small -- not thousands of tons, but just tons (much of it lead, why?) Similarities are that the fusion energy is carried by kinetic neutrons absorbed in molten metal, and extracted by heat-exchange with another fluid, thence to steam; and the molten metal is processed continuously or periodically to extract tritium, which will serve as more fuel. Big question is if the reaction rate is high enough. It seems to depend on how much plasma can be packed into the bubble before it is compressed, and how long you have to keep it compressed before releasing and exhausting the synthetic helium. It seems like if there is any tritium left over afterward, you would want to cool and reclaim that. You get one hot neutron out per tritium in, which in a Li6/Li7 mixture might breed [0] two tritium out, plus some helium. With lead mixed in, wouldn't it steal slow neutrons you need to get above parity? I guess as long as the lead doesn't steal too many, it is OK? But what is the lead for? [0] http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/NucEne/fusion.html http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/NucEne/fusion.htm...
- ncmncm 5y agoGuessing the lead is so the ball of molten metal to make the bubble in can be not so big as to be impractical to handle.
- rndphs 5y agoSad that JET is still the premier fusion machine in existence. Forty years! Fusion is always x years away because nobody has been building anything of significance for so long. All eggs in the ITER basket. Big mistake.
- regularfry 5y agoIt's not like the reactor they're running today has had the same parts for those 40 years. In fact this experiment was partially to test an upgrade.
- rep_movsd 5y agoFusion is "sensational" science Much like AGI, "room temperature superconductors", "Mars colonization" and so on - the science is intense, the reporting hyped up and every tiny step will continue to be posted again and again as if something revolution happened. Meanwhile the world needs to many more nuclear reactors pronto if at all we stand a chance of climate change mitigation We need better web security and privacy, better engineered cities and so on But no one cares about mundane engineering that may actually work - they only like pies in the skies
- ncmncm 5y agoIf averting climate disruption depended on fission or fusion, we would be doomed. Fortunately, solar and wind are up to the task.
- panick21_ 5y agoWe would be doomed? Somebody should have told France who had a clean green grid 40 years ago. If everybody had simply done nuclear we would be 10000x better of now. The false promise of solar/wind held up by fossil-fuel and anti-nuclear people prevented green energy grids for literally decades. If anything we are doomed because it took so long to actually bring solar/wind practically into being. If we invested in nuclear and its advanced reactors decades ago, like we did in the 60s/70s we would also have high temperature reactors that could do things like provide industrial heat for chemical processes such as water desalinization, synthetic fuel production and so on. You could even do very high temperature reactors if you wanted to decarbonize even chemical process that take 1000C without going threw inefficient electricity production and heat generation. But coal plants were cheaper to build and that's why id didn't happen. Imagine a world where the US had build 100s of nuclear plants. The amount of nuclear engineers that would exists, the amount of knowledge and innovation that such an industry could have. The problem is in the 70s what mattered was price, that coal plants were horrible to human and the environments was not considered. So please explain why depending on fission would doom anybody. Germany could have replicated what France did in the 70s and simply started to build nuclear reactors when they started their green revolution 20 decades ago. In fact had Germany done so they would like be closer to fully de-carbonized now. Literally any country that wants to be 100% green can right now call South Korea and order X reactors and within 10 years all but the largest industrial nations in the world could be 100% green power.
- londons_explore 5y agoAre we actually learning new bits of fundamental science from these experiments? Are there still bits of these fusion reactions we can't simulate accurately enough due to insufficient compute? Or is it just a matter of ironing out engineering issues?
- jillesvangurp 5y agoI think given recent progress from several companies and research institutes, we might be seeing an increasing shift to solving engineering challenges indeed. Fusion has definitely moved beyond the proof of concept stage. It's no longer just a theoretical possibility. Many challenges still remain of course. But it might be a lot closer than the 20-30 years that people have historically assumed it would take. It seems there are a couple of companies shooting for working power plants a lot sooner than that that are getting a lot of funding. Maybe even this decade. From there to commercialization might still take a lot of time of course.
- willis936 5y agoIt's both in every case so far. Machines are made and operated to discover empirical data, but we invent the engineering along the way. Computation is woefully insufficient for particle level simulation. If we had a proper model of turbulence that issue would be lessened. We don't have a full grasp on plasma physics. If we did we could point to a single stellarator geometry and say "that one". The physics and engineering also interplay at many levels. Optimal decisions at every level take both the plasma physics and engineering into account.
- regularfry 5y agoIt depends where on the "fundamental science <-> engineering" spectrum you think materials science sits. Some of the thorniest problems in reactor design are "wtf do you make it out of and can such a thing exist". There's some science going on confirming material theoretical properties under reactor conditions. Mind you, insufficient compute is also a problem. Although "insufficient" is probably underselling the scale of the issue. Simulating plasma is horrid. It's all the worst bits of both fluid dynamics and electromagnetics all rolled into one: you've got a potentially chaotic fluid where all the particles aren't just interacting with the things they bounce off, they're also interacting with other particles all throughout the body of the fluid through electromagnetic effects. Everything affects everything else, and (because chaos) the details matter.
- panick21_ 5y agoFusion has no practice reason to exist compare to advanced fission. The improvements in energy density are not really relevant factor at that scale, meaning the difference from oil to fission, and oil to fusion doesn't really gain you much. Fusion fuel cost over the long term is likely more expensive then a fission fast breeder (not to mention a potential of thorium thermal breeder). Is a fusion reactor going to be cheaper to build then a advanced fission reactor? Not from anything know so far. Advanced fission concept are viable with pretty normal tubes pretty industrial steels or at most advanced aerospace materials. Any fission reactors actually consider would have waste more complex and expensive parts. The nuclear waste argument is sometimes made in favor of fusion but with the right kind of fission reactor this problem and issue that has very viable practical solutions and storage for a few hundred years is viable. Its really cool science but don't wait for fusion to solve any of our practical energy problems. Maybe at some point fusion can build really small making electricity directly (Aneutronic fusion). Then it would actually be relevant. I would prefer fusion research to focus on that problem, rather then trying to build an oversized power-plant style fusion.
- boomlinde 5y ago> this problem and issue that has very viable practical solutions and storage for a few hundred years is viable. So you mean to say that there is no practical reason for fusion power to exist for as long as you ignore the long term consequences of what you're doing?
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat consequences. That you need a parking lot full of nuclear waste that just basically stands there and does nothing? Can we not spare a single tennis court sized storage facility? What are the consequences you are talking about? We are not talking about some absurd 300000 year storage facility build into the earths core. That is not needed. Guaranteeing something for 100 years is far easier then for 300000 years. And it can be easily monitored, if one location for some reason is a an issue after 100 years, just move it to another location.
- nightgarden 5y ago
- api 5y agoBattery prices are falling like a rock. Solar and wind prices are falling like a rock. EVs are going mainstream. Fusion is showing signs of progress after years of stagnation. Oil and gas sales accounted for 68% of Russia's export revenues in 2013. That number is probably higher today. Oil and gas are between 15% and 20% of Russia's entire economy. I really wonder if Russia's behavior is related to the impending end of the fossil fuel age. The Saudis and other petrostates lack Russia's military power and so they are instead frantically throwing money at crazy future-city projects and other boondoggles to try to build a future for themselves that is not rooted in oil and gas. Russia has nukes and a lot of conventional weapons, so maybe a militaristic path seems more viable to them.
- sinuhe69 5y agoBefore reading the article, I had hoped the power ratio would be something close to 0.7-0.8 but was disappointed that it was only 0.33 Even with ITER it should be a very long way until we will get a ratio of 1:1, not to mention of greater than 1. Will the AI controlling method would help to a breakthrough?
- JackFr 5y ago> JET is a scaled-down version of ITER, at one-tenth of the volume — a bathtub compared to a swimming pool, says Proll. They either have amazing bathtubs or terrible swimming pools.
- tus666 5y agoI truly hope to live long enough to live in a fusion-powered "free energy" world. It will be truly science fiction. Along with positronic brains and anti-gravity devices, to get a glimpse of my childhood Asimov dreams again will be a fitting end to my life.
- wanda 5y agoSadly, the notion of "free energy" in a capitalist context is probably why the concept hasn't taken off.
- RandallBrown 5y agoIf you can generate the energy for "free" then you can sell it for cheap and undercut every other producer. It seems to me that it works very well in a capitalist context.
- ncmncm 5y agoThat is, indeed, the solar power value proposition. Nukes, not so much: the operating cost is very high.
- nikolay 5y agoEven if this works, it's just an experiment and we will need decades more to make it practical.
- tomohawk 5y agoHere's an interesting article that puts this into perspective and provides a lot of history about nuclear research: https://quillette.com/2022/02/21/fusion-power-is-coming/ https://quillette.com/2022/02/21/fusion-power-is-coming/ EDIT: The above article talks about some other approaches, such as: > MIT physicist Bruno Coppi proposed achieving fusion in a very small tokamak by the simple expedient of using ultra-strong magnetic fields. The magnetic field lines of a tokamak confine particles to follow them, spiraling around the chamber, with the radius of the spirals being inversely proportional to the strength of the magnetic field. Coppi reasoned that the relevant dimension of a tokamak was not its size per se, but the ratio of its size to the radius of the spiral, because it is this ratio that determines how long a particle will last before it hits the wall. Furthermore, as noted above, the higher the magnetic field strength, the faster the particle is likely to react. So if you want a particle to take part in a fusion reaction before it hits the wall (which would cool it too much for fusion), the key is just to go for broke with ultra-powerful magnets. But the problem is that the highest magnetic field it is practical to achieve with traditional low temperature superconducting magnets is about 6 Tesla, and Coppi needed 12 T. So, he designed an experimental machine called “Ignitor” using copper magnets. This could not be a practical commercial reactor, because the resistive copper magnets would use too much power. Nevertheless, if it had been built, we probably would have achieved thermonuclear fusion ignition in the 1990s. But all of the US Department of Energy funds were committed to ITER, so Ignitor was never built. But starting around 2014, an MIT group led by Professor Dennis Whyte decided to pick up where Coppi had left off, improving on the Ignitor concept by making use of high temperature super conductor magnets, which require no electric power and can reach 12 T. As a result, with more than twice the magnetic field strength as ITER, the CFS reactor, known as SPARC (for Smallest Possible Affordable Robust Compact) fusion reactor, will achieve 1/5th the power hoped for by ITER in a reactor 1/65th the volume. Furthermore, CFS aims to do it by 2025, achieving in seven years what ITER hopes to do in half a century.
- awinter-py 5y agohow many kettles this time