10 ms·
> No, that battle is lost. Cashless is easier and more convenient. Incorrect, the battle is partly won in several U.S. cities (including NYC & SF) which passed
by walterbell 5y ago
> No, that battle is lost. Cashless is easier and more convenient.
Incorrect, the battle is partly won in several U.S. cities (including NYC & SF) which passed laws to mandate acceptance of cash.
However, cash-acceptance laws were mostly motivated by the unbanked, who are now being used to justify the introduction of nation-state CBDCs. China's CBDC is two-tier and preserves retail bank competition. People close to the current admin have proposed a 1-tier CBDC that would eliminate retail banks from payment processing, perhaps relegating them to fintech data processors.
The long-term answer is both: encourage bearer currency (cash, precious metals, zero-knowledge crypto) to anchor one edge of the Overton window with an existence proof of freedom from surveillance and kill switches, AND impose regulation on digital systems to enforce constitutional rights. 99% cashless doesn't work for tyranny, because there are escape valves. We can and must defend those exceptions, while "digital due process" is slowly constructed.
Remember when e-commerce was not subject to sales tax? For more than a decade, the playing field was not level. Today, large websites are almost unusable for buying popular items at risk of counterfeiting, and there is little online price advantage over Main Street. If you have access to a local branch of Japanese bookstore Kinokuniya (https://usa.kinokuniya.com https://usa.kinokuniya.com), it's a joyful 3D curated experience vs. the chore of navigating an online bookshop with questionable reviews. The online-offline playing field is now less tilted.
Today, cashless proponents are free-riding on digital data streams whose originators lack the infrastructure for licensing or negotiation. Competition for those data streams (which feed into AI for economic advantage) is coming from {nation,city,multi}-state regulators, corporate payment networks {Apple,Amazon,Google}Pay and DRM infrastructure for data originators.
The free data ride in cashless systems, like sales tax holidays, is coming to an end.
<there's always a bigger shark.jpg>
- inter_netuser 5y agowell. If money is speech, does it mean cash is protected by the 1A?
- forty 5y agoCan you pay taxes in cash? I don't think it's possible in my country.
- Animats 5y agoThe IRS will accept cash.[1] For small payments, they have an outsourced setup with Dollar General, Family Dollar, CVS Pharmacy, Walgreens, Pilot Travel Centers, 7-Eleven, Speedway, Kum & Go, Royal Farms, Go Mart, and Kwik Trip to accept payments up to US$500. There's a US$1.50 fee. So people who have no bank account and not to pay can pay easily. For bigger payments, cash payments are accepted at an IRS Taxpayer Assistance Center, after making an appointment 30 to 60 days in advance. [1] https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-your-taxes-with-cash https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-your-taxes-with-cash
- forty 5y agoAlso as noted in the article, things like electricity, internet and other utility cannot be paid in cash either here.
- walterbell 5y agoUS Postal Service money orders can be purchased with cash and used the same way as a certified check. This works for utility payments. Mobile phone companies take cash as payments, in both their dedicated retail stores and a large network of affiliated airtime merchants. In some countries, there's a mini-economy for the trade of airtime minutes within cellphone networks, based on physical stores that can convert cash->minutes. M-Pesa was one of the earlier success stories, unifying payments and digital identity, but it was anchored in real-world ingress points for cash. Cash & digital can be complementary.
- walterbell 5y agoOn the topic of convenience: utility companies love prepayments. One post office trip per quarter: one money order per vendor, one batch of envelopes mailed. Monthly online bills will have a negative balance to indicate the credit. Zero data leaked to payment middlemen.
- reaperducer 5y agoAlso as noted in the article, things like electricity, internet and other utility cannot be paid in cash either here. In the United States you can. Almost all bills, utility and otherwise, can be paid for in cash at most supermarkets or other money-handling businesses. ("Currency exchanges" in Chicago, or whatever your local equivalent is.) Also, every utility company I've had serving my last five apartments has had a public lobby where people can make cash payments. I suspect even cell phone bills can be paid with cash at a cell phone company's retail store.
- bch 5y ago> Incorrect, the battle is partly won in several U.S. cities (including NYC & SF) which passed laws to mandate acceptance of cash. I presume this[0] is that story... If i understand correctly, federal law also requires cash to be accepted to repay a debt, which perhaps interesting to some, usually includes restaurants; you eat your meal, and incur a debt doing so. Perhaps with takeout they could refuse to hand over the bag/box until its paid w a credit/debit card, which is their prerogative (except apparently in SF, NYC, ...). [0] https://www.technocracy.news/cash-is-king-san-francisco-to-ban-credit-only-stores/ https://www.technocracy.news/cash-is-king-san-francisco-to-b...
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoOnly if the restaurant takes payment after the meal. If they require payment before (like at McDonald’s), it isn’t considered a debt.
- wrycoder 5y agoI’ve been in DMVs (dept. of motor vehicles - a government office) that don’t accept cash. Check or charge only.
- stickfigure 5y ago> Incorrect, the battle is partly won... Not in the slightest. You can mandate that people accept cash, but you can't force people to pay with it. The writing is on the wall; barring some sort of major social upheaval, cashless will be more dominant in the future. It's just too convenient. So let's figure out what kind of benign future we actually can build. "Everyone decides to use cash again" just isn't going to happen.
- bradwood 5y agoYeah. Plus 2 states in one country is definitely not 'partly won"
- walterbell 5y agoThere are a dozen EU countries whose population is smaller than the cash-mandatory population of New York City (not state).
- onion2k 5y agoThe writing is on the wall; barring some sort of major social upheaval, cashless will be more dominant in the future. That doesn't matter. If laws mandate that services must take cash then a cashless society is impossible, so people who choose not to go cashless can't be forced to give up cash. Hence the war on cash has been won, and cashless lost.
- raxxorrax 5y agoIt can be more dominant. I pay most of my stuff cashless, but really, really love cash. I would always recommend to keep some on you for emergencies and as we have seen that government is quick to freeze accounts, it seems like a very good idea.
- walterbell 5y agoWe don't need "everyone" to use cash for "everything", just some people to use cash for some transactions. It is legal in most jurisdictions to give discounts when paying with cash. That is enough motivation to use cash for larger purchases, since it saves costs for both the merchant and the customer. The only loser is the now-redundant payment processor.
- gruez 5y ago>Incorrect, the battle is partly won in several U.S. cities (including NYC & SF) which passed laws to mandate acceptance of cash. It'll be interesting to see how this battle gets affected by the trucker protests. Historically such bills seem to be largely supported from a social justice point of view[1] (ie. "we need to force businesses to accept cash because cash-only shops are exclusionary to marginalized people"). With the canadian government freezing the bank accounts of freedom convoy protesters, this push could be also associated with the (alt-)right as well. This could translate to a bipartisan push to get accepting cash enshrined into law, or a situation where cash/crypto becomes a right wing dogwhistle, eg. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/24/bitcoin-currency-far-right-neo-nazis-cryptocurrencies https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/24/bitcoi... [1] based on a unscientific analysis of this article: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/23/nyregion/nyc-cashless-ban.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/23/nyregion/nyc-cashless-ban... The relevant sections were: >because of financial circumstances, unwilling to for philosophical reasons or vulnerable to its darker aspects. >“We are reining in the excesses of the digital economy.” >But critics of cashless businesses say they discriminate against people who lack bank accounts and credit cards, while also raising the specter of hackers stealing personal data tied to digital transactions. >Bronx households, the agency said, were around twice as likely not to have a bank account. >“I worry about the real-world discriminatory effect that cashless business can have on New Yorkers, especially in communities of color,” Mr. Torres, a Bronx Democrat, said. >“I think it’s incredibly discriminatory not to accept cash because some people can’t get credit,” >“It is exclusionary,” she said, “because people without means are less likely to have a credit card.” 2 mentions of privacy/security, 6 mentions of social justice
- varenc 5y ago> the battle is partly won in several U.S. cities (including NYC & SF) which passed laws to mandate acceptance of cash In SF, despite the laws, many businesses openly had a no-cash policy once the pandemic started. "Sorry, Credit Cards Only. Touching money might transmit Covid" is too easy of an argument, even though it's essentially a non-concern now. And I haven't seen businesses go back to accepting cash as lockdowns have ended. Will be interesting to see if SF authorities actually try to enforce this law.
- walterbell 5y agoWhole Foods created a dedicated checkout lane for cash during the pandemic, in some stores surrounded by a 6-foot plexiglass walls. It was usually the fastest line. Now they are back to all registers accepting cash. > Will be interesting to see if SF authorities actually start trying to enforce this law or not. Great opportunity for a city journalist to assemble a news story. Collect footage to document their experiences across a diverse range of SF stores which do and don't accept cash. If "peer" stores accept cash, have good traffic and happy customers, then cashless competitors may reconsider their stance.
- Kalium 5y agoFor a lot of businesses, the overhead that comes with handling cash isn't worth it. Especially smaller businesses that would really rather not deal with the risk of being robbed or having a staffer mugged for the nightly drop. Credit card processors charge a processing fee per transaction, but the overhead of physically managing cash and so on isn't free. I expect many stores will decide to stay cashless for that reason, no matter what their peers decide. Being cash-friendly or cash-only is not free, even if people do tend to think of it that way. As for SF's law, I think it's worth bearing in mind that it was originally written as a shot at the Amazon Go stores.
- walterbell 5y agoBusinesses whose existence is contingent on cost management may find themselves replaced by those that can manage both top line (demand, revenue, culture, brand) and bottom line. Especially IF the economy continues to fragment into online escapism for the poor and 3D experiences for those with discretionary spending, aka "inequality".
- noduerme 5y agoBut it's really hard to get PAID any serious amount of money in cash, and it's increasingly hard to withdraw or travel with cash. Just because you can still buy groceries for awhile doesn't mean you can function for any length of time if the government and the cashless system is united in unbanking you.