16 ms·
Coinbase CEO tweets how they came up with Super Bowl ad, lied about it
- westondeboer 5y agoHa, and my friend submitted music for this commercial and did four rounds of it.
- rzw2 5y agoGot to take credit after it is successful, but if it was a flop blame the external agency.
- m348e912 5y agoKristen Cavallo (CEO of the Martin Agency who disputes Coinbase CEO) has references to a presentation but not receipts. I'm curious how much of the final product the agency pitched. (not that they don't deserve at least some credit)
- waffle_maniac 5y agoCoinbase CEO disputes Coinbase CEO.
- andrewingram 5y agoNot sure if it's what you were getting at or not, but "receipts" in the context of the post is a colloquialism for evidence, it doesn't mean literal receipts.
- colpabar 5y agoDid she post evidence though? She refers to pages of presentations that we don't have access to, so why is she more trustworthy (other than not being the coinbase guy who everyone seems to dislike)? Also, I don't know how business stuff like this works, but if a company pays an ad agency for ad ideas, aren't they paying for ownership of those ideas? How many classic commercials were actually original ideas of the company whose product was being advertised? Yet we all still consider the polar bears to be a coca-cola commercial, WAZZUUUUUP to be budweiser commercials, etc. It just seems unprofessional. Why would a company want to hire this agency now? Of course if coinbase ceo is lying then it's definitely rude not to give credit, but that seems like it's just how these things go.
- medlazik 5y agohttps://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1495820351879659525 https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/14958203518796595...
- hellomyguys 5y agoI'd hire them because they seem to be good at their job.
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoAbsolutely would not work with them now. Going right to the nuclear option is not a good reaction.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- markdown 5y agoAhh, yes. The way of the MBA. All corporate gobbledegook with filler words that suck the humanity out of every press release, statement, and public performance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- humanistbot 5y ago> Also, I don't know how business stuff like this works, but if a company pays an ad agency for ad ideas, aren't they paying for ownership of those ideas? How many classic commercials were actually original ideas of the company whose product was being advertised? Yet we all still consider the polar bears to be a coca-cola commercial, WAZZUUUUUP to be budweiser commercials, etc. To convert it to HN-speak, this is like forking an open-source software library, then branding it as your own internal original work. Then the kicker is the Twitter thread where he publicly insults the entire profession of the people they stole it from. So imagine that a company rips off an OSS library, then says something like "no OSS community would have created this." It breaks an industry-standard norm in the relationship between ad/marketing agencies and client companies. Everyone knows that client companies pay ad agencies. But agencies make their livelihood on their reputation. So everyone who matters in the industry knows that Ken Stewart was behind the Coca-Cola polar bears campaign, or that it was Bill Backer behind the "I'd like to give the world a Coke" campaign. They've been inducted into the Madison Avenue Advertising Walk of Fame, which is literally something only ad people care about. Same with number of stars on GitHub.
- digitcatphd 5y agoNobody cares, it’s Coinbase :p
- bearjaws 5y agoEven with tens (hundreds?) of millions spent advertising on the Superbowl this year, crypto briefly went green, and is now lower than Feb 13th. I believe every corner of the market has been reached and has either bought in or is not buying.
- bombcar 5y agoMakes total sense if you realize half the players KNOW it's a scam and are just trying to get out before the crash, and thing the Super Bowl ads are a great "shark jumping" indicator. Perhaps eerily similar to the last time the Super Bowl brought down a major tech craze ...
- PretzelPirate 5y agoYou can say the same about the S&P 500. Crypto isn’t immune from large world events that create uncertainty.
- dylkil 5y agopaypal down -65% since last september, it must be out of suckers to scam /s
- csee 5y agoWell a lot of that is Putin related.
- shiado 5y ago
- chrismckleroy 5y agoMaybe coin base was like hey idea and agency put into PPT and said hey look, OUR idea
- Kiro 5y agoI want to see the presentation before I bring out the pitchfork.
- dannyw 5y agoSame. It could literally be, end with a QR code but more traditional ad before hand.
- xahrepap 5y agoTangent, but I thought it was a funny commentary: I was watching the olympics with my kid (<12yo) and the Coinbase commercial came on (Didn't see it during the superbowl, but I assume they were the same?). And after the commercial ended my kid said, "was that... some kind of app for gambling or something?" Yes. Something like that. :)
- shawabawa3 5y agoThat was not the Superbowl ad The Superbowl ad was a qr bouncing around the screen with some retro music in the background. No mention of Coinbase at all except a brief 1/2 second "ad by coinbase" at the end
- xahrepap 5y agoah! Thanks for clarifying.
- jimkleiber 5y agoFWIW, when I saw the QR, I assumed it was for something like crypto or gambling.
- dalmo3 5y agoI thought my stream had gone down.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoReasonable assumption since 80% of NFL ads seem to be gambling, including crypto. And I know this proportion just having watched a few games of the playoffs.
- dehrmann 5y agoEither that or the NSO Group.
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- Gatsky 5y agoThis whole thing is weird. So much jostling to claim credit for the sheer vapidity of a floating QR code.
- autokad 5y agoI am confused here, why should I care about this whole thing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nathanaldensr 5y agoWhat, you don't want your hourly dose of dopamine-fueled rage?
- smoldesu 5y agoMy thoughts exactly. I half expect a drove of VCR manufacturers to step forward and take credit for the concept of a logo that bounces around on your screen...
- atdrummond 5y agoI identify that more with DVD manufacturers - is there a preceding VHS modal I should be familiar with?
- bombcar 5y agoVHS would blue screen (bad) or static (good) - blue screen was bad because it could burn in TVs (you can sometimes still find TVs that don't display blue well and have a faint STOP burned into the upper right). So the DVD setup was to bounce a DVD logo (specifically not standing for anything) around in a quasirandom pattern (I believe they did try to make it roughly touch the whole screen at some point).
- danuker 5y agoAnd displays, and projectors bouncing the "no signal" message forever instead of going to sleep after 10 seconds of no signal.
- ldjb 5y agoCoinbase CEO's excuse is that he sees Martin Agency as a "creative firm" not a "traditional ad agency" and he felt they "were all one team". Although it should be noted that last Tweet was posted hours after the original set of Tweets. https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1495820351879659525 https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/14958203518796595...
- espadrine 5y agoThe situation seems a bit more complex. The Martin Agency’s proposal was rejected, but the idea of the QR code that they suggested remained in some minds. The creative firm they did the ad with was Accenture Interactive, see this: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6898989146246123520/ https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6898989...
- hitekker 5y agoMore complex but still deceitful. Coinbase's own CMO gave credit to that ads agency, which the CEO of Coinbase did not acknowledge until he was criticized: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6899028049740869632/ https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6899028...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mrandish 5y agoIt's also possible the CEO didn't know that the idea was pitched months earlier to people on his marketing team by another agency because his marketing team told him they came up with the idea internally. Hogging credit is, sadly, pretty common in corporate gamesmanship.
- pm90 5y agoThat’s plausible but makes him look rather gullible at not only having bought into that lie but using the example as evidence of the supposed inferiority of ad agencies. I’m not a politically adept person but even I can see that it puts into question his decision making skills as a CEO of a crypto firm. People in leadership positions generally need to be really good at calling bullshit otherwise they get surrounded by pliant yes-men.
- nerdbaggy 5y agoNot sure why the marketing agency had to call them out. Seems like a weird choice to call out your own client that they are wrong.
- Miner49er 5y agoI would not be at all surprised if this is manufactured controversy for more marketing.
- hellomyguys 5y agoWell his tweets before that kinda disparaged their work and then claimed their work.
- greggh 5y agoThey took the idea, and went with a different ad agency to do the work.
- etchalon 5y agoThey weren't a client. They didn't win the business, so they're not risking any revenue.
- slenk 5y agoAnd here I am still not sure of what the ad was. I even watched most of the SB.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- insickness 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zLsUhOCqyU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zLsUhOCqyU
- danuker 5y agoSo much innovation! Makes me want to throw my money into anything linked to it. TL;DW: a floating color-changing QR code on a black background, with obnoxious music.
- paulpauper 5y agothe ad has just announced a series b round of funding, valuing it at $1 billion, although how this works for an ad I have no idea
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoI don't normally watch this stuff but checked out the other commercials out of curiosity. If you find this obnoxious, oh boy, they are surprisingly even worse. As for this one it's obviously designed to get people to look it up. Seems to have worked if we want to trust CNN: https://edition.cnn.com/2022/02/14/investing/coinbase-qr-code-app/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2022/02/14/investing/coinbase-qr-cod... And now HN is talking about it too. More publicity for them.
- bombcar 5y agoIt's brilliantly stupid because it buys into the whole idea that QR codes are things normal people actually ever use.
- manquer 5y agoThe idea itself is not as such that new or innovative. It is simple bouncing QR code on a screen after all. However taking that idea and running with it with the vision and conviction that it will work, staking your reputation as an ad agency and as a customer backing with $12M or more in ad spends. The customer and ad agency both part of that process, the fight seems a bit petty.
- mwint 5y agoBroadly, it seems like an _ad agency_ is one of the last groups I'd want to (evidently) lie about or otherwise irritate. That said: this whole episode did just get Coinbase on the front of HN again, and I just learned the name of an apparently good agency. I'll laugh if it turns out this was all planned between them...
- logicalmonster 5y agoIt feels like an ad agency has more to lose with appearing unprofessional in handling their clients. For better or worse, ad agencies are ridiculously highly paid to sometimes take a few punches for their clients or let their clients take the visible public credit for their work. If you're an ad agency, you have to check your ego at the door for your clients, IMO, and handle any conflict internally. I don't particular care about this kind of nuanced back and forth, he-said/she-said type of story. In any other industry, this kind of minor drama might end up as a footnote in some industry trade blog, at best. But because crypto is attached, suddenly it gains traction on HN because people can find another excuse to take pot shots at something they dislike.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hitekker 5y agoThe Chief Marketing Officer of Coinbase said they collaborated with Accenture, an Ads Agency, to produce the ad: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6899028049740869632/ https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6899028... You have the people who worked on the Ad on one side and a lying billionaire on the other. It's only a "nuanced back-and-forth" if you're afraid to call a lie a lie.
- meepmorp 5y agoAccenture has an ad agency now? The trainwreck becomes less perplexing.
- 015a 5y agoThis is an extremely weird exchange... I would interpret her tweet as, Coinbase contracted her team, they pitched ideas, they rejected the ideas, then "stole" it and developed it internally. But his later reply suggests that, no, they were partners through to the end. It does seem like he was intentionally or unintentionally building a universe where it was the "internal team" who developed it, but frankly I'm not sure that's a big enough misstep to warrant the marketing company replying like that trying to "out" him. In my eyes, that's an extremely unprofessional move on their part. We bring in outside engineering contractors all the time to work on stuff. When the feature is finished, we don't tell customers "thank you, yes we're very happy with the work our engineering team and McKinsely & Sons Contracting Firm LLC did for us". That just straight up never, never, never happens; we take responsibility for both the success and failures of our contractors. Of course, success is always nice, and when directly asked we don't hide it (on the contrary; we're happy to give them some free word-of-mouth marketing if they've done good work). There's an alternate reality here where the marketing firm maybe reaches out privately and says "hey Brian; your tweets really paint a picture that we had nothing to do with it; mind giving us a shout-out?" But that's not the direction they went, and instead they just aired dirty laundry in a public forum. Actually, its not even dirty laundry?! Its just laundry. I can say with absolute certainty that if any contractors/third parties pulled this stunt with us, we'd never use them again, period. Beyond anything else, NDAs are SOP in exchanges like this, I'd bet my life savings she absentmindedly signed one; to throw out a tweet like that isn't just unprofessional, its potentially litigable.
- beaconstudios 5y ago> It does seem like he was intentionally or unintentionally building a universe where it was the "internal team" who developed it That's a lot of fancy words to say "he lied". I can understand the sentiment if he was just waxing lyrical about the ad, but he explicitly said "no ad agency would come up with this".
- hitekker 5y agoYeah, word salad is a good smell for self-deception.
- wnevets 5y agoSo trustworthy, I can't wait to give this company all of my money.
- misiti3780 5y agoIf you put all your money in crypto your decision making is worse that the coinbase CEO at this point.
- atdrummond 5y agoThe convinces me further that Armstrong is damage controlling for an ad that got way less organic interest in both the short and long run than FTX' Larry David ad. When the ad failed to generate any sizable metrics worthy of story, Coinbase tried to spin this daring ad into a story itself.
- iambateman 5y agoInteresting take. The ad was a remarkable novelty at the time, but the lack of replay ability is probably a big deal. You can’t show a QR code ad on a phone, and potential coinbase users see a lot of digital ads.
- listenallyall 5y agoYou're right. The FTX ad was also a big mistake, for different reasons, but it did get more buzz, and it is replayable. Coinbase's QR code gimmick was something that sounded super edgy in a boardroom with people super-invested in the process... but entirely forgettable among the millions of viewers who are drunk, full, watching Snoop Dogg, betting on football, and inundated with ads featuring the Sopranos, Larry David, Scarlett Johansson, etc etc
- willhinsa 5y agoWhat reasons made the FTX ad a big mistake?
- listenallyall 5y agoFTX got the nature of Larry David completely wrong. He is an enormously successful, extremely wealthy man who, subconsciously, all of his fans love to cheer on and with whom they agree. Larry is socially awkward, but in a way people envy -- he goes right up to hypocrites and challenges them to their face. You don't stay on air for 10+ seasons without being the protagonist hero the audience wishes they could be. He is not, in any way, a buffoon or an idiot. But the takeaway impression from the ad is Larry David saying "naaah". That's it -- that's what people remember. Just throwing a tag up there, "don't be like Larry" isn't going to flip an internal emotion people have held for two decades. The affinity people have for "Larry David" the character or Larry David the person is far too large for that. Even in the focal point of the commercial itself, LD is the alpha with the office, the desk, the awards, the guy being pitched to... and FTX expects me to instead side with a random nerd with a cell phone? Oh, and the call to action is terrible -- FTX is hardly even mentioned. I would bet 9 out of 10 regular Joe's have no idea who the Larry David ad was for. postscript - the ad could have been saved, if the pitch was delivered by someone familiar, with equal stature and affinity. Because we always see Larry arguing with his closest circle -- and because they are also wealthy and successful (which, subconsciously, provides credibility). If it was Cheryl trying to get him to invest? Definitely. Leon? 100%. Jeff? Maybe. Richard Lewis? I think it would have worked great. Ted Danson? Possibly, hard to tell how that would go emotionally. Jerry, Jason or Julia? Could have been amazing. But some random guy with zero credibility? It's just a fatal error, self-imposed, no way around it.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoI'm shocked that someone in crypto was less than honest.
- thenanyu 5y agoThis seems like a silly move on the agency's part. Like... calling out your client in public. Cool, great way to get repeat business. Coinbase is trying to squeeze as much marketing from the Superbowl ad as they can. The tweet thread by Brian is part of that.
- micromacrofoot 5y agothe agency probably would have let this slide if he didn’t toss in the “agencies wouldn’t do this” dig at the end, that would have taken me from tepid to nuclear too… agencies have their work stolen all the time (the pitch process is terrible) and that’s nothing new, but to do it and then trash the entire industry is nuts
- karaterobot 5y agoThis kind of thing happened all the time when I was at a software consultancy. In press releases, interviews, etc., our clients' leadership would regularly talk about creating their new website or application entirely in house, when it was really done by contractors like me, whose relationship to the company amounted to some names in a shared Slack channel. This was product: I assume it's common in marketing as well. I always considered it part of doing business. Sometimes it was even part of the contract that we couldn't mention we worked with them. That's fine until you decide to leave, and realize you aren't supposed to include any of your best work in your portfolio!
- pm90 5y agoI wonder if they actively promote the lie of in house expertise or simply choose not to highlight your contributions? The latter case seems less unethical… still shady to not correct a wrong interpretation though.
- distances 5y ago> Sometimes it was even part of the contract that we couldn't mention we worked with them. That's fine until you decide to leave, and realize you aren't supposed to include any of your best work in your portfolio! This is the default in all consulting/contracting/freelancing isn't it? Can't even mention your client, let alone the product you were working on. It's a real battle to get the reference rights in the contract. In practice you mention in public documents something like "leading movie streaming service", and use the name in private discussions and sales.
- panabee 5y agowhether it's the coinbase CEO for misrepresenting the origin or the marketing agency CEO for lodging such an accusation, someone is in the wrong. given that reddit's QR-code commercial was the most discussed one from the prior year and that coinbase explicitly considered this inspiration [0], it seems prudent to gather more data before judging who was wrong. given the reddit precedent and the proliferation of QR codes under covid, it does not seem unreasonable for multiple people to independently conceive of commercials with QR codes. 1. when did coinbase discuss the reddit commercial? 2. how similar are the agency proposal and the final commercial? 3. did coinbase brief the marketing agency on all previously considered ideas? [0]https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1495636361889857537?s=20&t=1MvSz2d6ILM3QYE-WYheEg https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/14956363618898575...
- fleddr 5y agoI agree that it's a clumsy move by Coinbase at best, and dishonest at its worst. What I find far more interesting though is the response, which really reveals the core use case of Twitter. The people responding are having a party. Read it. This is the moment where they shine. Piling onto somebody that made a mistake or is embarrassed. Watch how much pleasure they take from it, "best thing they've seen all day". Frantically liking, retweeting, dancing on somebody's corpse. This really is the best part of their day, they've been scrolling all day without proper outrage, and this is the jackpot for their hate addiction. It fulfills them. It's a white male even, no better target than that. Let's make it a feminist and BLM issue too. The more the target is stamped into the ground, the better. And the twisted part is that these people typically signal how good and righteous they are. They're not. They're sadists that take joy from the suffering of others. Case in point, "DHH" (from Basecamp) still can't open comments on his Twitter a whopping 6 months after bringing himself into trouble. The harassment is this intense. It's not that neither of these two didn't do anything questionable, but they didn't exactly commit war crimes either. The "good" people are so relentlessly cruel. They've lost any sense of proportionality, reason, perspective, and basic human forgiveness. When you've spent some more time on (tech) Twitter, as I unfortunately have, you actually recognize the grifters. It's always the same few dozen people that have many followers. They are basically the distributors of outrage. A fresh high profile outrage? Count on them to be there in minutes, dropping their low effort hot take. They're experts in maximizing pain in the fewest characters. They live for this. How absolutely pathetic.
- daenz 5y agoPlot twist: this drama is fabricated and is part of a meta-advertising package offered by The Martin Agency.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slg 5y agoIf the CEO of a financial services company is both willing to lie to the public and is willing to have the public believe he is a liar, that is a bigger red flag than if he was just ignorant to the details of how an idea for an ad originated.
- beaned 5y agoAll this characterizing as "lying" is so dramatic. Is there literally no possibility that he misunderstood something, or that maybe the caller-out from the ad agency is themself leaving something out? People are so quick to label and name-call when we can hardly say we really know anything about the situation for certain.
- afavour 5y agoIt is, I imagine, possible that someone beneath the CEO arranged the whole thing and covered up the ad agency’s involvement. Which would also be a massive red flag.
- slg 5y agoI didn't say he was lying. I was reacting to the hypothetical in the previous comment that maybe this drama was intentional. If that is the case, I have no idea what word to use besides "lying". With our current knowledge, it can still be a misunderstanding and like I said maybe "he was just ignorant to the details of how an idea for an ad originated."
- rhizome 5y agoIt was a major Super Bowl commercial, I have to think its creative path was lit pretty brightly in everybody's minds. They didn't just pick it out of a stack of papers. At all. Of course I'm no business mercenary with experience at all levels and sizes of company, but for something like this I think we can assume they had a lot of meetings about it.
- baskethead 5y agoThis reminds me of the "Think Different" ad that Steve Jobs totally took complete credit for, but it was actually from an ad agency as well.
- kenferry 5y agoin what sense did Jobs take credit for that? Apple worked with the agency, but I've never seen anyone claim an agency wasn't involved. I've seen the reverse, the story of the long collaboration of apple and their ad agency.
- baskethead 5y agoRead Steve Jobs' biography, he took full credit. This was the "reality distortion" field that people accused Jobs of. He would walk in and tear an idea to shreds and then turn around and tell everyone that idea was his. He would do this routinely. Probably not on purpose, maybe he forgot it was someone else's idea, but he definitely did this very often.
- tyingq 5y agoWrite up on that ad campaign and working with Steve Jobs on it from Rob Siltanen, creative director and managing partner at that agency at the time: https://www.forbes.com/sites/onmarketing/2011/12/14/the-real-story-behind-apples-think-different-campaign/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/onmarketing/2011/12/14/the-real... He makes the case that some of the quotes from the Isaacson biography aren't true, like this one: "Jobs, who could identify with each of those sentiments, wrote some of the lines himself, including “They push the human race forward." Edit: Yes, I'm agreeing with you..
- baskethead 5y agoYes, this article came out AFTER the biography and after Steve Jobs passed away, to correct the information in the biography.
- listless 5y agoThis individuals timeline is a smorgasbord of cultural vomit. If she’s right, she’s been waiting for this day for a long time.
- ryandvm 5y agoOdd to see them arguing for credit over the worst ad of the Superbowl. That ad seemed like something my son would have turned in after forgetting the homework was due today.
- joelbondurant0 5y ago
- ljm 5y agoCriticism about Coinbaise aside, they basically called out the superbowl on its own terms by playing a screensaver as an ad
- rdiddly 5y agoKind of her to say "inspired by."
- mod 5y agoHow kind depends on what the slides look like.
- dontbeabill 5y ago
- comboy 5y agoWho gives a coin, if somebody rents a software team and then says he made the product is that even a problem?
- darcys22 5y agoThis is my thoughts, the business is the ultimate owner of the advertisement. While the agency adds it to their portfolio. They are both owners/creators in different ways The tweets are a CEO doing corporate speak about how good their company is and should be expected.
- paulpauper 5y agoLooking forward to the Walter isaacson book and Aaron Sorkin movie about this . Maybe Michael Lewis too will write a book about it.
- ada1981 5y agoI’m pleased with how displeased all involved seem to be.
- throwoutway 5y agoMartin Agency is ADweek's Agency of the Year, which directly contradicts Armstrong's statement that: "I guess if there is a lesson here it is that constraints breed creativity, and that as founders you can empower your team to break the rules on marketing because you're not trying to impress your peers at AdWeek or wherever. No ad agency would have done this ad." https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1495636876799397889 https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/14956368767993978...
- smoyer 5y agoFunny that people are fighting for credit for the worst ad shown during this year's super bowl.
- mcast 5y agoThere's no such thing as a bad advertisement, just one people remember and talk about and one people forget.
- phil21 5y agowhat other ads have you felt compelled to comment about? This one is at least as good as those.
- rvz 5y agoFunny how people are still unable to ignore a cryptocurrency ad and feel the urge to comment on forums about how bad it is. Sounds like the ad worked and accomplished its mission; living in their heads rent free and in the millions of people talking about it.
- anotherfounder 5y agoI'm not sure what feels more problematic, the framing of the initial thread or the last patch tweet which doesn't even acknowledge Kristen's claim and doesn't name them while trying to thank them. I was all giving him the benefit of the doubt but then the 12th tweet tanked that benefit of the doubt for me. Feels pretty unethical to take credit for someone else's creative work..
- alainchabat 5y agoOn the other hand, I appreciate how honest is Kraken's CEO (coinbase's competitor) on their platform, and how account could be frozen at any time and recommending p2p platforms[1] [1] https://twitter.com/jespow/status/1494462097161220104 https://twitter.com/jespow/status/1494462097161220104
- Railsify 5y agoThe coinbase UX is terrible. They really need some help with UI/UX, not advertising.
- andrew_ 5y agoThis site and its author are right up there with every other inflammatory and sensationalist rag that routinely gets flagged to oblivion here. Come on folks, examine the source like we're supposed to before jumping in to comment. On the content of the article; why are we debating the validity of an argument over an advertisement posted on twitter? Surely we'd all agree we'd like content here to be better than that.
- dundarious 5y agoThe post almost entirely consists of quotations from the relevant tweets. This type of writeup is often called "blogspam", but it is an incredibly common tactic for actual news outlets, who just write up PR statements and wire agency items that were created from a company PR team (so laundered PR statements). I think if there is to be any legitimate criticism of the post, it is that not that it has a tabloid quality, but that because it is mostly quotation, it could be replaced with a link to the original tweets. But I find a text post or "blogspam" like this often provides useful and concise context. So if all this post does is provide brief but useful context, I think it's a not a good example at all for your complaint about the source. And it's not unwarranted for HN to find criticism of SV/Bitcoin bombast about how "we're different/new" to be interesting.
- soheil 5y agoWhy do we care so much about petty drama here on HN all of a sudden?
- maccolgan 5y agoCrypto, there are axes to grind.
- _8j50 5y agoIs this because the guy refused to take sides on some political controversy a while back (forgot details)? He said his team was inspired by a reddit ad, the outside agency could have also been inspired by that. We don't know who was inspired first and how closley the outside agency's concept is to the ad compared to the original concept. ESH! Lol
- aaron695 5y ago
- donatj 5y agoThrowing your client under the bus seems like a bad move. I wouldn’t hire that ad agency. I understand wanting credit where credits due, but publicly scolding is just unprofessional.
- difu_disciple 5y agoBrian essentially calls the agencies incompetent, steals a concept from an agency that wasn’t hired, and minimizes the contributions of the agency was hired. That’s disrespect worth being addressed.
- mcv 5y agoI was not familiar with web3isgoinggreat.com, but this looks like the best new tech news site I've seen in a while. Great format.
- wilde 5y agoThe CMO explains that hilariously the CEO is still wrong, but it was another ad agency that gets credit: https://twitter.com/kate_rouch/status/1495929301631475713?s=21 https://twitter.com/kate_rouch/status/1495929301631475713?s=...
- gw67 5y agoCoinbase CEO has really a bad reputation online. Or just Coinbase as company.
- magicroot75 5y agoFormer fortune 100 marketer here. That was a trash ad anyway. Unlikely it did anything but drive vanity traffic for 5-10 minutes after the ad.
- kevincox 5y agoWhile I would like to believe what you are saying, and my common sense supports your conclusion, I don't think this flaim is very valuable without any evidence.
- zild3d 5y ago> Unlikely it did anything but drive vanity traffic for 5-10 minutes after the ad Based on what? Also it's been over a week now and still talking about it, hardly 5 min of fame
- magicroot75 5y agoIt's a Super Bowl ad. Of course people are talking about it. What they aren't talking about is the actual value proposition of the business running the ad. This is a huge mistake made by non technical marketer. Thinking that "any publicity is good publicity." Getting a bunch of press for an outlier ad doesn't necessarily mean anything for the bottom line. And, moreso, the default is that not much will happen just because you made a stir with an ad that doesn't actually drive interest in your product.
- T3RMINATED 5y ago
- taternuts 5y agoI thought this was clearly just a rip off of the office? It even ended when it hit the corner exactly.
- seba_dos1 5y agoThe controversy aside, just imagine the disappointment of having to reach out for your phone to scan that code just to discover that of all things it's a link to Coinbase.