7 ms·
I worked on a previous project that was sort of an ancestor to this. We used grid computing (before "cloud" was even a thing) to rapidly scale up compute- righ
by dekhn 5y ago
I worked on a previous project that was sort of an ancestor to this. We used grid computing (before "cloud" was even a thing) to rapidly scale up compute- right after an experiment, you want to recalculate the optimal parameters based on what you just learned from the experiment and then start over as fast as possible. This was well before anybody could say "reinforcement learning" or "neural network" around physicists without being pilloried.
The best part was the name of our collaborator- "General Atomics" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Atomics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Atomics
Here's a writeup, https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.588.150&rep=rep1&type=pdf https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.58...
- shmageggy 5y agoSorry, I don't see how this has any similarity to the posted project, apart from being also related to fusion?
- dekhn 5y agoI'm just an old man, pointing out that it's all been done before, and it will all be done again. The big difference is it looks like they're in the realtime controller for the plasma, rather than determining static settings for a subsequent run.
- regitempus 5y agoThis is super cool, thanks for sharing. Also, you’re right, that name is dope.
- systemvoltage 5y agoSilicon valley would name it, ahem... Atomicly. Uber for atoms.
- iSnow 5y agoSince the .com domain would be gone, it would most likely be Atomcly
- shmageggy 5y agoYours was a tools and infrastructure project, and this is about learned, autonomous control. They are completely different goals. > determining static settings for a subsequent run. AFAICT, your software didn't do that. Rather it provided infrastructure for the researchers to do that themselves more efficiently. From your paper: > The ultimate goal of FusionGrid is to allow scientists at geographically distributed sites to participate fully in experimental and computational activities... Exactly what are you saying has been done before?
- fartboi 5y agoThe guy was saying nothing, people have done computer work in fusion and they will use computers again! Profound. He was merely giving a shameless plug of whatever infra project he was involved in. Congrats - it involves computers and fusion.
- shmageggy 5y agoI have no problem with a shameless plug -- it's an interesting show of how things used to be -- but he claimed more than that > a previous project that was sort of an ancestor to this > it's all been done before implying that the current work build on his work in some way, which I don't see.
- fartboi 5y ago
- dekhn 5y agoCould you be a bit clearer why you're being critical? Much of what DeepMind does is rooted in prior projects, they just sprinkle a little more RL and have a great press team. Nobody would use their system for real in production, just like when they published how they could run Google datacenters 5% cheaper in real time- turns out, nobody actually deployed that because the settings it came up with don't make sense to humans.
- 5y ago
- peteradio 5y agoVery cool, I came several years following and we too had a grid for similar tuning work on LHC. My fondest memories were the bizarre hangups that could occur in custom stuff like this, and the way you'd find out that you done fucked up. My favorite time was when I broke a database by sending an accidental "query all the stuff", but it was really stupid, like from the console all you had to do was type a partial "ls" and it would assume a wildcard. So when the authority in my group attached me in the email and said I broke the main monitoring database I told them they had stupid defaults and never heard anything again. My second favorite memory was when I found a way to gain production access to grid resources just by naming your output datasets in a particular way. I was sat down in a hush ceremony with the Pakistani post-doc from my group and the Russian? programmer of the system and asked to keep it quiet. I kept it quiet, and am pretty sure I failed some sort of spy test that day. It wouldn't be the last time I felt like I failed a spy test, I guess that is my third fondest memory from my time in grad school.
- dekhn 5y agoPlease tell me you went on to be an SRE. Because you have the phenotype.
- peteradio 5y agoWell, my nickname in my first job out of grad school was Murphy (as in murphys law). I was essentially a dowsing rod for corner cases and it was very much not intentional and extremely distressing. You could say I have some experience.
- avs733 5y agoI've worked in a number of factories and it seems like everyone of them has a Murphy. The people who get confronted with problems that begin with everyone saying 'thats not actually possible'. I will always remember the poor guy who had to figure out the local fire department's radio repeater was rebooting ONE SINGLE piece of equipment in a factory from about a third of a mile away. I have always wondered if there is a way to detect this particular trait either using MRI or possibly smell. Once you are in a space you can usually identify them because everyone seems to slightly avoid their workspace out of fear of being infected.
- nr2x 5y agoLove the picture! I can't decide if the monitors being huge feels stranger, or people wearing collard shirts.
- nerdponx 5y agoI know this is maybe weird, but I kind of wish programmers and other "technical" people dressed up at least a little bit more for the office. It makes the work environment feel a bit tidier and more professional to me.
- ruined 5y agoyou can wear whatever you like in your home office. go ahead and dress up for yourself
- groby_b 5y agoPersonally, I consider it a mark of professionalism if people aren't blinded by trivial external markers (like what clothes their colleagues wear) And I say that as somebody who likes dressing up for work.
- Findecanor 5y agoI think it is relative, and mostly a question of balance. Every workplace has its culture and norms. Making a little effort to blend in is a question about showing respect for your co-workers. But on the other hand, how you dress is self-expression.