10 ms·
Pollution causing more deaths than Covid, action needed, U.N. expert says
- ElectronShak 5y agoAnother lockdown possibly ? /s
- hughrr 5y agoLockdown was bliss for pollution here in London. Air smelled totally different. We don’t want more lockdowns but we need to fix society so we don’t have to travel so much on a daily basis.
- go_elmo 5y agoAs a foreign tourist in london, london needs to fix its infrastructure. The amount of fine dust in the tubes is criminal.
- hughrr 5y agoYeah tube dust is nasty. I’ll give you that. I barely ever use the tube now preferring to use overground trains and walk if possible. A lot of people don’t seem to know that a lot of tube journeys can be done in a few minutes on foot.
- napier 5y agoPandemic or no pandemic, wearing a high filtration respirator (N95/FFP2 mask at a minimum) on the tube, where air pollution levels regularly exceed Beijing and Delhi, is advisable. Also sensible on inexplicably still diesel choked busy London streets above ground.
- hughrr 5y agoStreets are getting considerably better thanks to ULEZ and all the horrible busses and taxis being replaced.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tim333 5y agoWhile I'm skeptical of the UK govts 2030 ban on selling combustion engine vehicles, I think going electric may the answer to London air quality.
- hughrr 5y agoCorrect but only because people won’t be able to afford to replace their old cars with electric ones.
- ben_w 5y agoI can well believe it. While I spent the pandemic in Berlin and didn’t notice much change here, 20 years ago I was in the UK and the daily walk past the A27 was radically improved by the truckers blockading the entire UK petrol supply in protest against fuel taxes.
- BoxOfRain 5y ago'Climate lockdowns' are already an established conspiracy theory among the nuttier end of society, I really think the news industry has a moral responsibility to avoid alarmism because of its inherently destabilising effect on society. Of course, alarmism is excellent at driving engagement and ad revenue so I might as well have asked for someone to write a program that solves the halting problem. I don't know how inventives can be put in place so that the news industry is an asset to society rather than a liability but I wish I did.
- bleuchase 5y ago
- postsantum 5y agoConspiracy theory is a thought-terminating cliche, it's like offering a bumper sticker as an argument. I wish there was a neutral website that tracks fringe theories and their development
- Hnrobert42 5y agoName calling is not acceptable on this forum.
- germinalphrase 5y agoThe lab leak hypothesis is still a hypothesis. As for the best of the list - you’re being hyperbolic. I wasn’t never locked down for years, forced to get a vaccine to keep my job or go into a restaurant. Likewise, I have no idea what a “green” pass is and assuredly don’t have one. Maybe all of these things are happening to someone somewhere, but it has never been my situation. Where do you live that all of these things have happened to you?
- trevormcneal 5y agoand remember, is not a conspiracy theory if is writen by Klaus, it is a plan. if he is going to succeed or not, is another story, but he has clear plans about a different world which is greener than the actual. I can't blame him, he is so disconnected from reality that I trully believe that he has good intentions, but has no idea of the real impacts of his acts. remember that people called the great reset a conspiracy theory, this is literally stated on WEF page, on Klaus books, and on his talks. And this is a key factor for a cleaner economy, since economical control at the individual level is required to create a more strict compliance mechanism.
- bigodbiel 5y agoI’m already expecting the same protocol used for covid crisis (fear, restrictions, fines, divisiveness) will be once again applied for the impending climate crisis.
- vanviegen 5y agoIf used effectively, that may not be unwarranted...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 5y ago
- marklubi 5y agoI'm sorry, but I'm totally over this type of nonsense. "Expert says" just signals bullshit to me at this point. Clickbait. I'm exhausted at this point.
- jacquesm 5y agoThen maybe stop going to news sites? Give yourself a break and re-engage when you think you can deal with it again.
- marklubi 5y agoWe've both been on this site for a long time. I've signed off from the typical news for quite some time at this point, but it keeps seeping in. This site used to be full of enthusiasm, but it's changed.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt is what we make it. And yes, it has changed, this has been observed many times now in the last couple of months, but that's no reason why it can't change back.
- marklubi 5y agoHow do we get it back?
- jacquesm 5y agoUse your voting power, submit good articles, upvote good articles on the new page and message hn@ycombinator.com about behavior that crosses the guidelines. Also: the 'New' page has a 'more' link at the bottom, this really should be used more often, the new pages moves ever faster as more stuff gets submitted to HN so plenty of good items scroll off the new page before they catch enough upvotes to make it to the homepage, so you can have a disproportionally high impact by voting for something that is at 3 or 4 upvotes on page 2 or 3. (The 'new' page only gets a fraction of the traffic that the homepage gets.)
- Synaesthesia 5y agoWow 9 million a year die prematurely. The environmental crisis is manifold: we have the destruction of species and habitats, the global warming problem, and now also just trash - overuse of plastics is a huge problem, air pollution is pretty terrible.
- jacquesm 5y agoDestruction of habitats has been identified as a factor in previous pandemics. Global warming will also result in the destruction of habitats. All this stuff is linked.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoActually it is incomplete destruction of habitats that cause pandemics. If all the bats had been killed, then Covid would not have developed. If we can kill all the disease causing mosquitoes as well, then we will remove another huge cause of human disease.
- jimmygrapes 5y agoThis really didn't work too well for Mao
- ben_w 5y agoThat’s the first I’ve heard about Mao and environmental destruction (aimed at the elimination of a disease vector or otherwise, I’m not clear what you’re denying here), and a quick Google/Wikipedia didn’t help. What are you referring to?
- pjc50 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_campaign https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_campaign : the extermination of sparrows resulted in an explosion of locusts. (The west has also collapsed bird populations in the service of agriculture, just over a longer period and combined with crashing the insect population as well)
- severino 5y agoMaybe we can keep using masks? Now that we already got used to them, we may reduce the effects of pollution with good filtering masks. Of course this doesn't mean we shouldn't address what's causing the pollution in the first place.
- tazjin 5y agoYou can do that! No places that dropped mask mandates have made a law against wearing masks. Just leave the decision to individuals.
- skummetmaelk 5y agoA few countries in Europe ban face coverings in public. Mainly driven by fear of people wearing burkas.
- jillvs34 5y agoThis does not apply to surgical or ffp2 masks generally.
- usrusr 5y agoI'm only aware of a small subset of laws existing in Europe, but every single example of restrictions to face hiding I can think of predates Muslim presence by many decades. No, those are not driven by fear of people wearing burkas.
- usrusr 5y agoCorrection: no, the examples I was thinking of are much younger than I thougt (but nonetheless not aimed at burkas at all, aimed at leftist protesters and at reckless drivers)
- OJFord 5y ago'predates Muslim presence by several decades'? When exactly do you think 'Muslims appeared' in Europe?
- gyulai 5y agoWe're not even squarely on the other side of Covid yet, and I'm already sick and tired of the "worse than Covid" trope.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rosndo 5y agoIt’s a very reasonable comparison though. Billions of man-years have been ruined by the COVID fearmongers. It’s perfectly reasonable the much scarier stuff we aren’t panicking about.
- gjulianm 5y agoI am not sure how many man-years would have been lost if nobody had done anything regarding COVID.
- gyulai 5y agoWe will never know since we can't measure the magnitude of an outcome that never happened. Adverse effects from fearmongering, however, did happen.
- gjulianm 5y agoBut we know what happened even with actions taken. In my city all hospitals were saturated, there were so many dead people that the army had to help and move corpses to an old ice rink. And that was stopped only by a full lockdown. I don't need to measure the exact magnitude to know that without taking any measures, it would have been terrible.
- rosndo 5y agoJust because your city isn’t equipped to deal with an unusually high amount of deaths in a pretty way does not mean that the lockdowns saved more quality adjusted life years than they cost. A year of life is worth far more when you’re 20 than when you’re 80. If the people saved by lockdowns were primarily old people with a few years left to live it would be pretty clear that the lockdowns were a net negative.
- pjc50 5y agoMeta-discussion, but I think "statistical deaths" - deaths where the causation has to be inferred, rather than being completely obviously monocausal - have been a big feature of quality of life improvement in the 19th and 20th century, but are now running into an informational problem. Namely that you have to believe the statistics in order for the process to work, but it's increasingly common to lie with statistics. Is this a moral fatigue problem? People are fed up of hearing that common action X "causes" Y, regardless of how true it is? Are we going to go back to smoking, leaded petrol, and polio? After all, the evidence against those was only statistical. (There may also be diminishing returns / age effects; after all, I'm only 40, and just about remember what a smoke-filled room smells like, or the tang of leaded petrol. For the dominant 60-and-up group of voters, the air is cleaner than in their childhood, so what's all this talk of "air quality crisis?")
- londons_explore 5y agoI propose a system where deaths are statistically assigned to causes. Eg. if a person dies of lung cancer, then we roll a dice and say "theres a 1 in 6 chance that was due to pm2.5 emissions". If the dice rolls a 1, then we look around the town for sources of pm2.5, and we find that 1/6 comes from a candle factory. We roll another dice, and if that comes out with a 1, then we say "This factory emitted air pollution that killed this person". Then we treat it in law exactly the same as if the person had walked by the factory and been decapitated by a piece of roof falling off. Ie. we let the family sue. We send inspectors to see if there is negligence involved, etc.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoTrouble is that those statistics are educated guesses. It's not like we have a precise table of fractional causes that could be split up via dice rolls. The first thing the lawyers for the factory would do is challenge the probability estimates.
- londons_explore 5y agoAnd let them do that... before the death occurs. But once the death has happened and the dice have been rolled, the cause of death isn't appealable.
- qwerty456127 5y agoNot just death but also stupidity and violence.
- Zenst 5y agoQuality of air and water is and always has been the real issue that needs to be tackled. The climate is just a symptom of that and sadly allows distractors to derail constructive progress in tacking what is really an air and water quality issue that nobody can deny. Now if the focus was upon air and water quality and addressing that, all the things that would need to happen just so happen to be those that tackle all environmental aspects of the climate and we would have more people on the same page addressing the issue over endless debate about it.
- jbverschoor 5y agoMany things cause more deaths than covid.. Stop using covid for everything.. This is exactly what institutes of religion do, scaremongering with something invisible and evil..
- bleuchase 5y ago
- cloutchaser 5y agoFentanyl is a working class problem. No-one remotely close to power (journalists, influencers, politicians) really care about working class people any more. In fact as George Orwell put it, they are probably disgusted by them, and pretend to care about them to advance their own "socialist" leanings.
- s5300 5y agoThe rest of your comment is true, but Fentanyl is most definitely not just a working class problem.
- Proven 5y ago
- pcdoodle 5y agoDoes "expert" have a name?
- gfd 5y agoGiven the virality and case fatality rate we knew at the time, we were on track to lose hundreds of millions of lives from covid back then (assuming no vaccines and hospital infrastructure collapse). Even with those worst case scenarios, there was still significant pushback to taking immediate global actions. And this is no where near the same scale of a threat.
- tebbers 5y agoWe were nowhere close to losing hundreds of millions of lives to Covid. So much exaggeration.
- Robin_Message 5y agoCFR was something like 1% early on, and higher in Wuhan where there was a partial collapse of health systems. World population is >7 billion, so 1% gets you 70 millions deaths. If hospitals collapsed and treatments hadn't been found, a not inconceivable 2-3% fatality rate would get us to "hundreds of millions". (This estimate is unrealistic in other ways though, e.g. communities would begin imposing their own and hoc lockdowns if hospitals were overwhelmed, and global spread might have been slowed.)
- oneoff786 5y agoNo it wasn’t. The samples just weren’t random samples.
- gjulianm 5y agoNon-random samples get you to up to 10% fatality rate. I have the data for my region and in march-april 2020 the IFR was 10-15%. Of course, that was due because there weren't enough tests and only the ones that were really sick entered the statistics. But for the original strain, IFR was around 1% and that number was pretty consistent among a broad number of studies. Also, take into account the amount of diseases that are getting late treatments due to healthcare saturation. I don't know of any formal studies but you only need to talk with any doctor to see that they're consistently seeing diseases in later stages and therefore harder to cure.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoEveryone is jumping on the Covid comparison, in their defense U.N.'s staff have been making this point (of millions of premature deaths due to air pollution) in their reports since at least 2014. And now after the Covid clickbait non-sense people are actually discussing it.
- ck2 5y agoHow about actually stopping all leaded gas instead of pretending? Tons and tons of micro-particles of lead sprayed everywhere there is an airport. Don't spend 25 more years phasing it out, make it illegal in 2030 so the investment starts today. https://www.thedrive.com/news/42218/if-leaded-fuel-is-so-bad-why-are-airplanes-still-using-it https://www.thedrive.com/news/42218/if-leaded-fuel-is-so-bad... Then move onto Texas. Where there are knowingly, purposely, toxic pollution zones right in the population because "reasons". https://www.propublica.org/article/toxmap-poison-in-the-air https://www.propublica.org/article/toxmap-poison-in-the-air
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoHere in Bangkok when I go out I don't double mask because of covid, but because of pollution. I'll be wearing masks indefinitely outside except when it's a low PM 2.5 day
- syshum 5y agoSo let me guess, the "Climate Crisis" is now going to be used as a justification for draconian authoritarian government policy, regulation, and laws. or worse we will new see heads of State, governors etc, just declare "states of emergency" to implement "action" based on the "climate crisis" with no legislative involvement at all. We have seen this with COVID, using the justification of "saving lives" now we are seeing the foundations laid for transforming constitutional republics in to Dystopian "forever in emergency" Technocracy of "Trust the Experts" dictatorships
- peakaboo 5y agoClearly we need Pollution Passes.
- sizzle 5y agoHow much cancer is attributed to pollution?