20 ms·
U.S. corn-based ethanol worse for the climate than gasoline
- gpapilion 5y agoWay back when I read The Hydrogen Economy, the author claimed something like 4 calorie investment for every calorie we pulled out of the ground for ethanol. I think is more a criticism of the Nixon era green revolution, when large scale chemical fertilizers came into use, since these are largely petro chemical products.
- rootsudo 5y ago1. I can't believe 2005 was the rage with biofuels. 2. Many people, AV, boats, powertoys, lawn equipment (it's own pollution there but that's another article) dislike ethanol in gasoline, especially for older cars. 3. Who wins in the end? The corn farmers for the past, 17 years? 4. Why did it take 17 years for this study to be funded and published. 5. If it's economical to move back to "pure gasoline" will we? Just using pure gasoline means we are 24% more efficient on carbon: "The research, which was funded in part by the National Wildlife Federation and U.S. Department of Energy, found that ethanol is likely at least 24% more carbon-intensive than gasoline due to emissions resulting from land use changes to grow corn, along with processing and combustion." Simply incredible, back in 05, it was one a gas shock, gas used to cost $1.25'ish on average and went up quite a bit, $3 or so - https://money.cnn.com/2005/09/01/markets/gas_prices/index.htm https://money.cnn.com/2005/09/01/markets/gas_prices/index.ht... and that was in 2005 dollars. Average car MPG got 14-22mpg. 6. This was not new, even back then everyone knew: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/the-ethanol-scam-172037/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/the-etha... but not exactly how it was 24% more intensive then gasoline.
- hedora 5y agoCurrent mixes are about 15% ethanol, so are only increasing carbon emissions by 4%. The ethanol helps the gas burn a bit cleaner. But, yeah, it's definitely not on the path to a carbon neutral economy.
- consp 5y ago3$/gallon sounds so cheap to me. I'm paying almost 2.5$/liter. I'm pretty sure that will reduce emissions massively more than any change in fuel composition wherever the fuel comes from.
- bradknowles 5y agoThat’s European-style taxes for you. Sadly. You get a lot of benefits from European-style government, like socialized medicine. But then you also have to pay those taxes.
- friedturkey 5y agoOr just countries that don't subsidize fuel or cheaply produce it on their own. Taxes are just one factor in the price.
- ThePowerOfFuet 5y agoMoney well spent.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe thing is, taxes here are used as a nudge. Meaning, you have decent public transport (subsidized by said taxes) and as a result people are incentivized to commute with said public transport instead of the government having to build 20+ lanes [1] highways. [1]: https://www.cntraveler.com/story/the-worlds-widest-highway-spans-a-whopping-26-lanes https://www.cntraveler.com/story/the-worlds-widest-highway-s...
- bradknowles 5y agoTaxes are likewise used a nudge here in the US. Where allowed by the special interests, and only so far as it supports those special interests.
- baq 5y agonothing sad about being incentivized to drive less.
- graeme 5y agoGood article on ethanol as a replacement for lead in gas. Changed my view on it as an additive: https://doomberg.substack.com/p/in-praise-of-corn-ethanol?r=plftk https://doomberg.substack.com/p/in-praise-of-corn-ethanol?r=... (Though not as an alternative)
- invalidator 5y agoThis article misses a key point: Ethanol is used to oxygenate the fuel, which reduces carbon monoxide and soot emissions. It replaced MTBE in that role. It was never intended to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Producing it requires more energy than it provides, and this was known long before it was introduced. It might be possible to power the production with renewable energy, but that's just extra steps for powering cars with renewables.
- panny 5y agoThat's revisionist history, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSlNzgvogxk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSlNzgvogxk
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI'm not sure exactly what you mean, but I just watched that video and it supports what the original commenter stated. The bill introduced many things, some efficiency regulations and investments in new tech were aimed at climate change. When he introduces ethanol, he specifically calls out diversification of energy supplies and reduction of imports and not carbon.
- phil21 5y agoI agree. I can't speak to how this was marketed/pitched at a national level, but in my (midwestern) state it was a huge deal so even as a kid I paid attention to it. I don't remember much of a climate pitch at all. Everyone immediately pointed out that it cost more energy than it produced. The pitch to the public where I lived at the time was national security (energy independence), and of course the demand it would generate for the local corn industry. There was probably some greenwashing of it going on, but I certainly don't recall much.
- credit_guy 5y ago> it cost more energy than it produced How can that be? Are you including the solar energy? Well, in that case, every process out there has a less than 100% efficiency, so the claim may be true, but also vacuous. If you don't include the solar energy, then are you saying that all the energy used to make the fertilizers, to plow the fields, then harvest them, then brew the corn and distill it, is less than the energy content of the ethanol produced? I heard this type of argument before, but I find it really difficult to believe. For example the study [1] claims you need 140 gallons of fossil fuel to plant/harvest/process one acre of corn that will produce 328 gallons of ethanol. Ethanol is less energy dense than crude oil (30 MJ/kg vs 42), but overall, 328 gallons of ethanol has about 67% more energy than 140 gallons of crude. [1] https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2001/08/ethanol-corn-faulted-energy-waster-scientist-says https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2001/08/ethanol-corn-faulte...
- sparrc 5y agoSome counterpoints: - Ethanol effectively helps spread carbon emissions across a larger area. It significantly cleans the air around large cities, I guess at the expense of more emissions in rural areas? But then again I'd guess most of those rural areas are not super concerned about carbon emissions and are very supportive of corn subsidies. - Of the three goals of adding ethanol to gasoline, it seems like 2 of 3 of them are completely successful: "The policy was intended to reduce emissions, support farmers, and cut U.S. dependence on energy imports."
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoI am pretty sure that carbon emissions are only a global concern (global warming), not a local concern, while the reverse is true for other pollutants like particulate and nitrogen oxides.
- sidewndr46 5y agoHow does ethanol clean the air around large cities? It's still a hydrocarbon fuel and still requires a catalytic converter to lower the production of harmful byproducts from burning it inside of a cars cylinder.
- lobocinza 5y agoIt's a substitute for lead in gasoline. There might be other reasons too.
- sidewndr46 5y agoYou can have high octane gasoline without lead. Suggesting that ethanol replaced lead is facetious. It's also an absurd notion. Leaded gasoline to this still poisons the air of all 50 states in the form of 100LL avgas. Suggesting that a wasteful farming practice is saving us from lead is like shooting one foot off and the exclaiming that you "saved" your other foot.
- lobocinza 5y ago
- cat_plus_plus 5y agoLots of short term vs long term issues here. Some applications like air travel really rely on hydrocarbons, with no practical substitutes available. Refining technology to produce fuel by capturing atmospheric carbon is helpful even if current technology is less efficient than fossil fuels. Surely practical biofuel is more achievable than practical fusion in short/medium term.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoCorn in the US is mostly used for harmful purposes. It's used for producing fodder for intensive cattle farming (which of course produces lots of CO2). It's used for biofuel production, which as the article observes releases more CO2 than that it saves. And it's used for producing corn syrup which is an ingredient that nobody needs in their diet. The rest, which would be usage for e.g. corn bread or other staples of North American cuisine, is of course fine. Nothing wrong with e.g. organically farmed corn. It's a crop that does well under a wide range of circumstances and popular for that reason all over the world. And as a grain, it's an important part of food production. So, why does this exist? Very simple, federal subsidies to states that have become very dependent on that. Kill the subsidies and that whole industry slowly dies. That would be a good thing. Maybe repurpose the subsidies to have those farmers do something that actually is more productive and less harmful.
- demadog 5y agoIt’s a hedge for a nuclear war. If this US is in total isolation, they can grow corn, wheat, soybeans etc quickly with high output. Thinking about the geopolitical strategic layer of ag policy is fascinating!
- stjohnswarts 5y agoA huge and good compromise would be to end the ethanol subsidies and only give it for human and cattle food. Anything else has to get by on what the market will bear.
- njarboe 5y agoIowa has the first primary every year in the US[1]. Iowa produces more corn than any state[2] while being 32nd in population. Corn is very important to people in Iowa and as long as the first two facts remain the same, corn will continue to be highly subsidized and supported in other ways by the US government. [1]https://www.uspresidentialelectionnews.com/2024-primary-schedule/ https://www.uspresidentialelectionnews.com/2024-primary-sche... [2]https://www.cropprophet.com/us-corn-production-by-state/ https://www.cropprophet.com/us-corn-production-by-state/
- 5y ago
- pengaru 5y agoPetrol from corn fertilized with oil and sprayed with petrochemicals is obviously idiotic but corn subsidies are the enabler.
- assttoasstmgr 5y agoI never understood why I could never find E85 at any gas station on the west coast. It was once tersely explained to me that it was "bad for the environment". Yet, the Brazilians have been powering vehicles with ethanol since the late 70s. I have to wonder if everyone who likewise owned a hybrid or EV knew that there was a chance some child in the Congo was mining the cobalt used to manufacture the batteries. Unfortunately I don't believe we live in a perfect world. Every solution to climate issues just seems to shift the problems elsewhere. Success is declared when the issue disappears over the horizon.
- hedora 5y agoBrazilian E85 is made from sugar cane, not corn. It’s significantly less carbon-intensive.
- assttoasstmgr 5y agoCorrect. However, Brazil's gasohol program was developed as a response to shortages produced by the 1973 oil crisis. Sugar cane is plentiful in Brazil, unlike Nebraska; it was not chosen for its carbon properties.
- masklinn 5y agoThe carbon properties can be a nice side-effect of something selected for other reasons though. I have no idea about brazilian gasohol, but that’s basically the story of french nukes, they were motivated by geopolitics and economics (the 1974 “messmer plan”, the plan actually led to overbuild as electricity demand did not pick up anywhere as much as expected), but resulted in french electricity being one of the least carbon intensive in europe if not the world, and basically only beaten by countries with ubiquitous hydro.
- trhway 5y agoi always thought that ethanol from corn is just a primer, just to jump start the ethanol usage in ICE while the efficient production tech - like ethanol/methanol from biomass - bamboo grows really fast - gets developed. We didn't get that tech and instead got EVs. Not bad. For the synthetic fuel which will still be needed by the hard-to-electrify industries like for example aviation - SpaceX anyway will have to develop an efficient way to produce synthetic methane, so that will come in time.
- thinkcontext 5y agoThat was how GWB sold it but, as you say, it never happened. Now its an entrenched subsidy program and is basically unkillable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hnbad 5y agoI hate to be that guy, but the only reliable way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is to drastically reduce emissions. Switching to biofuel doesn't fix climate change because biofuel is still terrible. Switching to electric cars doesn't fix climate change because electric power is still terrible (not to mention all the damage from lithium mining, manufacturing and battery replacements). The only solution is to make neighborhoods more walkable, reduce the need for frequent travel through mixed use zoning and invest in public transit (trains and trams, buses if you can't avoid road traffic completely) so more travel happens in high density vehicles rather than cars. But that basically means public spending for public services rather than having companies sell more products to consumers and that's just too much like communism to be a legitimate answer because you don't want people to reconsider whether some aspects of socialism might actually be good. EDIT: Since HN won't let me reply, I'll just pre-empt any further replies by pointing out that the problem with "solutions" like renewables, carbon capture and electric vehicles is that while they sound great in a spreadsheet they ignore externalities, overhead and scale: yes, if we could wave a magic wand and convert all existing cars into electric and backfill the increases energy demand by turning all the now unused infrastructure into wind mills and solar panels and somehow fix the energy storage problem, the situation would undeniably be better than it is now. But that's not how we get there and even that situation would be unsustainable as long as we follow a growth mindset and promote individual transportation as a consumer product rather than addressing infrastructure as a social issue. I don't think HN is ready to acknowledge that the biggest carbon emission savings in the US don't come from carbon capture tech magic but from offloading the more emission heavy parts of the production chain behind the curtain into third world countries that don't end up on the spreadsheet. We're not going to solve climate change by stuffing all our toys into the broom closet with hopes that the regulators can't see the mess we made. We need to actually clean up the mess and stop adding to it. We can't fix a resource problem by continuing to expend an increasing amount of resources. It's called "reduce, reuse, recycle" because those are the things you can do in decreasing order of effectiveness. Carbon capture is just recycling. Going electric is not even that.
- colordrops 5y agoThis doesn't make sense. More and more electric is being generated renewably. It's not some far fetched pie in the sky thing either - I fully charge my car using solar cells on the top of my roof. My daily driving is carbon neutral. Lithium mining isn't great for the environment, but it's certainly much less of a problem than co2 emmisions.
- lobocinza 5y agoWhat about Brazilian cane-based ethanol? The sugar conversion efficiency, I'm not certain this is the right term, is significantly higher than that of corn or beet but logistics deficiencies in the country may make it more expensive and less green.
- thinkcontext 5y agoThe term you are looking for is Energy Return On Investment (EROI). This is the amount of useful energy you get divided by the amount of energy you spent to get it. The figure I've seen most often for ethanol from corn is 1.25 (though some people argue its less than one), which is not very good. When made from Brazilian sugarcane its 8 which is amazing.
- lobocinza 5y agoThanks.
- bradfa 5y agoThe octane rating of fuels in the USA is fairly standardized, a majority of gasoline cars require a minimum of 87 octane (on the US measurement system) and some even require or recommend a minimum of 91 octane. These requirements are usually for emissions and warranty/reliability reasons, but in some higher performance vehicles (which are a small subset) it's also for performance reasons. Using ethanol in a gasoline blend boosts the octane, so if ethanol is removed then something else will need to be used in its place. You can't just substitute gasoline in place of the ethanol with no other changes. Ethanol has many downsides, especially with attracting water into the fuel, but it does have its benefits, too.
- jimbob45 5y agoThe octane rating of your fuel does not in any way affect the emissions of your car[0]. You should use whatever octane-rated fuel that your manufacturer recommends. Using a higher-rated fuel will not confer any additional benefits whatsoever onto your car. [0]https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/ask-mr-green/does-premium-high-octane-gasoline-pollute-less-regular-gas https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/ask-mr-green/does-premium-...
- bradfa 5y agoBut using a lower octane fuel than specified by the vehicle manufacturer may damage the engine or the emissions equipment: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/octane.shtml https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/octane.shtml
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoBut the point is that it's (supposed to be) renewable and cyclic, instead of releasing sequestered co2 accumulated over millions of years. Who paid for this research?
- jrudolph 5y ago> The research, which was funded in part by the National Wildlife Federation and U.S. Department of Energy
- mrfusion 5y agoThe worst thing about ethanol is the huge hit to gas mileage. Ten years ago I used to happen upon gas stations that didn’t use ethanol and I’d see my mileage jump! I wonder if the epa mpg ratings tests use ethanol free gas? Now they all mark up ethanol free gas.
- evancoop 5y agoHow many products are subsidized on one and and regulated on the other? Corn is subsidized in production, but then when those subsidies yield health-hindering quantities of cheap sweetener (corn syrup), we attempt to regulate its application and consumption. Now, we'll subsidize growth again, but then regulate the greenhouse emissions on the other. It is one thing for government regulation to address externalities (good). It is another to address externalities that government helped create in the first place!
- seniorivn 5y agofrom political and management standpoint it's the same thing you as a society wanted regulatory institutions to exist and do their best, so they did. Don't like the result? Good luck fixing it without firing all those people who messed it up in the first place.
- ThinkingGuy 5y agoI don't believe it's the case any more, but for years the US government funded anti-smoking campaigns while simultaneously subsidizing tobacco farming.
- thinkcontext 5y agoIncredibly, ethanol is subsidized more than once. Corn itself is subsidized and then there's a credit to blenders. And on top of that fuel sellers are required to sell a certain amount.
- black_puppydog 5y agoPrimary source seems to be this: https://www.pnas.org/content/119/9/e2101084119 https://www.pnas.org/content/119/9/e2101084119
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spenrose 5y agoThis appears to be the source: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ac2e35/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ac2e35/... Central claim: "Their revisions most profoundly reduce predicted land use change (LUC) emissions, for which they propose a central estimate that is roughly half the smallest comparable value they review (figure 1). This LUC estimate represents the midpoint of (a) values retained after filtering the predictions of past studies based on a set of unfounded criteria; and (b) a new estimate they generate for domestic (i.e. U.S.) LUC emissions. The filter the authors apply endorses a singular means of LUC assessment which they assert as the ‘best practice’ despite a recent unacknowledged review (Malins et al 2020 J. Clean. Prod. 258 120716) that shows this method almost certainly underestimates LUC. Moreover, their domestic C intensity estimate surprisingly suggests that cropland expansion newly sequesters soil C, counter to ecological theory and empirical evidence. These issues, among others, prove to grossly underestimate the C intensity of corn-grain ethanol and mischaracterize the state of our science at the risk of perversely affecting policy outcomes."
- seiferteric 5y agoThat this is a story now is funny to me. I remember reading years ago that corn ethanol EROI was close to 1.0. Given this it is obviously pointless from an energy perspective. All that diesel/energy used growing, processing transporting etc just to make back that same energy...
- exabrial 5y agoSomething Conservatives and Democrats can agree on: Ethanol sucks. There is a rare moment where both sides could see past their differences to accomplish something here. * It makes muscle cars slower * It is terrible for engines, no matter what the lobbyists tell you * Ethanol plants smell * Corn uses a ton of ground water, depleting the Ogallala Aquifer and destroying habitats * Using diesel fuel to harvest corn which makes ethanol... is just stupid. You'd be better off just burning the diesel in cars. * The EPA was successfully paid off to implement Ethanol. They should be held accontable. I think the only sharp resistance is going to be Nebraska, but generally, everyone hates it and it needs to go.
- nickysielicki 5y agoIt also kills small engines, especially those used seasonally, which results in a lot of waste as these engines fail early. https://youtu.be/bEf9Fdvx_Sc https://youtu.be/bEf9Fdvx_Sc My theory is that the automotive industry is complicit in not fighting back against ethanol mandates because they know that it’s ultimately good for business if their cars last 10 years instead of 15.
- xyzzy21 5y agoWell yes. Because more energy is consumed (EROEI) with corn - all the diesel, pesticides, fertilizer, etc. inputs - than with simply using the gasoline/petroleum. The exact same analysis is true for electricity generated from a nat gas fired generator vs. simply using the nat gas directly, especially for heating. This is why "banning nat gas for new construction" is so ignorant and stupid!
- RickJWagner 5y ago