7 ms·
U.S. posts $119B budget surplus in January; first in over 2 years
- aseerdbnarng 5y agoGov debt is private sector savings. Title rephrased: We've reduced private sector assets by $119bill.
- cwalv 5y agoMaybe also not a bad thing, given that the real return on those assets will likely be negative for years to come.
- aseerdbnarng 5y agoI dont agree with that and here's why: Whenever taxation > spending (ignore once off liquidation of assets), the government actively destroys private sector savings (dont take my word for it, go ahead and map the transactions on the balance sheets of the pvt sector, central bank and the treasury, and you'll see the transaction reduces pvt sector assets). What you're saying is rather than risk inflation eroding the value of those assets, lets just destroy them outright. The counter-argument could be that private sector would issue more loans on aggregate (create money) if inflation were lower but that borders on tea-leafy speculation
- steve76 5y ago[dead]
- m348e912 5y agoInteresting, maybe we can inflate our way out of this crazy $30 trillion debt situation.
- jgamman 5y agoi read your comment as 'conflate our way out' and thought hhmmm sounds about right
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoIt's not like $30 trillion is a perpetual bond. Bonds have a date and the government will need access to the bond market to finance stuff. If the inflation is higher than the nominal rate on the bond, there would be fewer and fewer takers.
- missedthecue 5y agoExcept the fed can and does buy trillions of dollars worth of Treasury issuance. (Guess where they get the money to do so)
- credit_guy 5y agoThe Fed creates money out of thin air. Still, it does not mean the bonds bought by the Fed are foregone. The US Treasury still has to pay all the interest and principal on them.
- sjg007 5y ago>has to pay all the interest and principal on them. With the money they create out of thin air.
- missedthecue 5y agoFor a while now, the Treasury has been borrowing to pay the interest it owes, and everyone knows that we don't actually pay down the federal debt, we just roll it over into new debt.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoOh please let's keep the MMT and End the Fed theories to reddit. If you think Fed is creating money out of thin air, it's too far from reality and too politically coloured for me to convince you otherwise.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If you think Fed is creating money out of thin air, it's too far from reality and too politically coloured for me to convince you otherwise. The Fed is creating money out of thin air (well, strictly speaking, it's managing, through target interest rates and other levers, the ability of member banks and other actors to do so, but that's the same thing, ultimately.) That is the objective reality. And it's just conventional understanding of monetary policy, not MMT or End the Fed. (MMT points out the further fact that the Congress, by net taxing/spending decisions, also creates money out of thin air, or destroys it, and furthermore that that and it's money supply effects, not the mythical constraints of fiscal balance which are entirely applying concepts that only make sense in terms of a commodity currency whose underlying commodity supply is not ultimately controlled by the government at issue to a fiat currency to which they do not apply—which, really, is all basically conventional economics, but also conventionally ignored in a policy evaluation context because conventional economists don't like the policy conclusions it leads to; End the Fed I won't touch, because I’ve yet to see a clear, coherent, consistent argument in it beyond “Fed bad”.)
- tablespoon 5y ago> The surplus last month was the first since the $83 billion reported in September 2019 and the largest since the $160 billion in April 2019. April and September are traditionally months with high tax collections.... > The surplus for the month also was helped by the recognition of $70 billion in proceeds from a wireless spectrum auction, a U.S. Treasury official said. It seems like this is a month to month number that fluctuates widely based on one-off events and things like when people typically pay their taxes.
- supernova87a 5y ago.
- arcticbull 5y agoSpectrum licenses are hardly the furnace. No more so than the DMV recognizing the revenue from car registrations or drivers license renewals.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- foota 5y agoSpectrum auctions are one time, aren't they?
- arcticbull 5y agoLooks like they last about 10-15 years. [1, 2] [1] https://www.cooley.com/news/insight/2020/2020-08-06-fcc-rules-5g-spectrum-auction-bidding-start-december-8 https://www.cooley.com/news/insight/2020/2020-08-06-fcc-rule... [2] https://www.dwt.com/insights/2018/10/fcc-adopts-final-licensing-rules-for-35-ghz-cbrs-s https://www.dwt.com/insights/2018/10/fcc-adopts-final-licens...
- manquer 5y ago
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis isn't a meaningful number.
- Victerius 5y agoGovernment revenue and outlays vary significantly throughout a fiscal year. For example, the US government is currently operating under a continuing resolution since October 1, 2021. A continuing resolution is a legally binding act that freezes budgets to the levels of the previous fiscal year. If an appropriations bill is adopted in the next few weeks, government departments will start acting on their budget authorities set forth in the already passed Authorization Acts. The Defense Department is poised to spend $60 billion more in FY22 than in FY21. Expect the temporary budget surplus to decrease when (if?) an appropriations bill is passed. If an appropriations bill is not passed, Congress could pass another CR for the rest of the fiscal year. If neither a budget nor a CR is passed, a government shutdown happens. It doesn't happen often, but it happens more often than it should, which is never. The federal budget process of the United States is unnecessarily complicated. Congress basically has to pass the budget twice: first in an authorization bill, and second in an appropriations bill. An authorization bill is an act laying out the various spending authorities of the government for the fiscal year. But it doesn't grant the government the right to withdraw funds from the Treasury Department. An appropriations bill is that. Authorization acts are like your parents giving you a list of products they want you to purchase at the grocery store. An appropriations bill is the actual money to buy the products with.
- rgjlkjlkre 5y ago
- rgjlkjlkre 5y ago
- rgjlkjlkre 5y ago
- rgjlkjlkre 5y ago
- rgjlkjlkre 5y ago[flagged]
- 3tljl3y5 5y ago
- lumost 5y agoThis seems like a volatile number - from the article >The January receipts grew by 21% to $465 billion, boosted by a 21% jump in individual withheld income and payroll taxes that reflected higher employment and earnings due to the economic recovery. >January outlays fell 37% to $346 billion, partly as they did not include $142 billion in individual stimulus payments sent in January 2021. >The surplus for the month also was helped by the recognition of $70 billion in proceeds from a wireless spectrum auction, a U.S. Treasury official said. The trend-line is promising, I'd be curious if inflation is moving income into more taxable sources (at least on paper).
- beerandt 5y ago>January outlays fell 37% to $346 billion, partly as they did not include $142 billion in individual stimulus payments sent in January 2021. The dropoff in covid spending since congress is in a stalemate and didn't extend programs has clearly got to be the key here, right? When else have we had a YoY significant drop like that? Especially without being phased out with a taper. (No matter what everyone wants to argue about over receipts also going up. The why isn't as important because the what isn't uncommon.)
- 3tljl3y5 5y ago
- 3tljl3y5 5y ago
- 3tljl3y5 5y ago[flagged]
- 3tljl3y5 5y ago
- egerge23 5y ago
- egerge23 5y ago
- egerge23 5y ago
- deltree7 5y agoHere's what ZERO of the doomer-preppers (including smart analysts and economists) don't get about inflation. When a US citizen earns an EXTRA dollar, they pay MARGINAL Tax on it (not average tax, but MARGINAL). The left (or right) of the GDP equation is literally income. So a 7% inflation means, US treasury gets MARGINAL tax revenue on the 7% income, which mathematically means that Tax Revenue increase has a higher-multiplier effect. (A 1% inflation may result in 3% more tax revenue) So, all these scaremongering of US having to pay extra interest is actually false. Treasury will make far more Tax Revenue than the rate Federal Reserve can raise rates, which means they can easily absorb high rates. All in all, Fed is still better of erring on the inflation side than crashing the economy. Inflation eats away 7% of most people's income. A Recession will eat 100% of many people's income. Note: This Tax collection phenomenon is completely different from inflation favoring debtors, which is also another advantage for USG.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_4ever 5y agoDon't you realize that income tax brackets are adjusted with inflation? Inflation isn't increasing real taxable value.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- balozi 5y agoWhen the annualized rate of inflation is at 7.5% and growing, the Treasury Department should probably come up with a new term for whatever that $119B is. Call it anything but a "surplus."
- momirlan 5y agothere is a statistic for any argument you want to make
- encryptluks2 5y agoGlad that they are making money cause they sure have made sure that most Americans can't.
- nikitaga 5y agoNot sure how much one month can tell us. Last 20 years of annual deficits, for reference: https://datalab.usaspending.gov/americas-finance-guide/deficit/trends/ https://datalab.usaspending.gov/americas-finance-guide/defic...
- derobert 5y agoThankfully, there is no need to speculate on what the trend might be, you can just look it up. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MTSDS133FMS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MTSDS133FMS That's one convenient way to get this data series (and most other economic data, at least for the US).
- baybal2 5y agoNow you need to get an annual budget surplus.
- mempko 5y agoFor those cheering this on, I recommend you watch this video from David Graeber. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxJW7hl8oqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxJW7hl8oqM TLDR; Government debt is private sector surplus. Government surplus is private sector debt.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]