32 ms·
This story reminded me of a story written by a Czech biologist who studied animals in Papua-New Guinea and went to a hunt with a group of local tribesmen. The
by inglor_cz 5y ago
This story reminded me of a story written by a Czech biologist who studied animals in Papua-New Guinea and went to a hunt with a group of local tribesmen.
The dusk was approaching, they were still in the forest and he proposed that they could sleep under a tree. The hunters were adamant in their refusal: no, this is dangerous, a tree might fall on you in your sleep and kill you. He relented, but silently considered them irrational, given that his assessment of a chance of a tree falling on you overnight was less then 1:5000.
Only later did he realize that for a lifelong hunter, 1:5000 are pretty bad odds that translate to a very significant probability of getting killed over a 30-40 year long hunting career.
- agumonkey 5y agoI often wonder these days how it was to live in so much risk and unknowns in prehistory. Nothing was sure, understanding of the world was so limited ..
- ec109685 5y agoAlso, you're not trying to just limit falling debris on yourself, but anyone in your party since you'd hate to lose a friend that way.
- kbuchanan 5y agoIt's a great example. This is the very reason I have scaled back the amount of time I rock climb as I've gotten older -- not because any individual outing is dangerous, but there's an element of Russian roulette wherein the mere act of doing it more often dramatically changes the risk.
- kqr 5y agoAlso known as the Kelly criterion. If one possible outcome of an action is associated with a great enough loss, it doesn't make sense to perform the action no matter how unlikely the loss.
- PaulHoule 5y agoNo, Kelly is about what fraction of your bankroll you should bet if you want to maximize your rate of return for a bet with variable odds. It's essential if you want to: * make money by counting cards at Blackjack (the odds are a function of how many 10 cards are left in the deck) * make money at the racetrack with a system like this https://www.amazon.com/Dr-Beat-Racetrack-William-Ziemba/dp/0688072216 https://www.amazon.com/Dr-Beat-Racetrack-William-Ziemba/dp/0... * turn a predictive model for financial prices into a profitable trading system In the case where the bet loses money you can interpret Kelly as either "the only way to win is not to play" or "bet it all on Red exactly once and walk away " depending on how you take the limit.
- kqr 5y agoThat is a much narrower view of the Kelly criterion than the general concept. The general idea is about choosing an action that maximises the expected logarithm of the result. In practise this means, among other things, not choosing an action that gets you close to "ruin", however you choose to measure the result. Another way to phrase it is that the Kelly criterion leads to actions that avoid large losses.
- PaulHoule 5y agoActually https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion "The Kelly bet size is found by maximizing the expected value of the logarithm of wealth, which is equivalent to maximizing the expected geometric growth rate" In real life people often choose to make bets smaller than the Kelley bet. Part of that is that even if you have a good model there are still "unknown unknowns" that will make your model wrong some of the time. Also most people aren't comfortable with the sharp ups and downs and probability of ruin you have with Kelley.
- kqr 5y agoI've long found that Wikipedia article woefully lacking in generality. 1) The Kelly criterion is a general decision rule not limited to bet sizing. Bet sizing is just a special case where you're choosing between actions that correspond to different bet sizes. The Kelly criterion works very well also for other actions, like whether to pursue project A or B, whether to get insurance or not, and indeed whether to sleep under a tree or on a rock. 2) The Kelly criterion is not limited to what people would ordinarily think of as "wealth". It applies just as well to anything you can measure with some sort of utility where compounding makes sense. The best overview I've found so far is The Kelly Capital Growth Investment Criterion[1], which unfortunately is a thick collection of peer-reviewed science, so it's very detailed and heavy on the maths, too. [1]: https://www.amazon.com/KELLY-CAPITAL-GROWTH-INVESTMENT-CRITERION/dp/9814383139/ https://www.amazon.com/KELLY-CAPITAL-GROWTH-INVESTMENT-CRITE...
- HWR_14 5y ago> the mere act of doing it more often dramatically changes the risk. Kind of. However, you already know that the first N outings didn't have a disaster. So those should be discarded from your analysis. Doing it N times more has a lot of risk, doing it the N+1th time has barely any.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe "slippery slope" principle applies here though: N+1 enables N+2, which enables N+3 and so on.
- aaronblohowiak 5y agobut the risk is independent. so once you do the N+1 time safely, you are back to N and your next time is _also_ just an N+1.
- pessimizer 5y agoContinuing to do something regularly doesn't ever mean you're just going to do it once more.
- nefitty 5y agoPsychologically, behaving in a certain way makes it more likely that you'll behave in the same way in the future. That's an integral idea underpinning justice systems.
- twobitshifter 5y agoTrue but it would be incorrect to assume that you can safely keep basejumping every day in a year, just because you haven’t died in the last 50 days. Eventually the stats say you will be 87% likely to have an accident when you consider your choice at the beginning of the year. It might be day 20 or day 300, but you won’t know what case you end up in. The chance of your next jump being your last is always the same, but that doesn’t decrease the risk of repeated trials.
- JadeNB 5y ago> It's a great example. This is the very reason I have scaled back the amount of time I rock climb as I've gotten older -- not because any individual outing is dangerous, but there's an element of Russian roulette wherein the mere act of doing it more often dramatically changes the risk. Indoor climbing, and especially bouldering, can be a lot of fun at the right gym, and with dramatically reduced risk of death (though injury is still a very real possibility, I say, recalling all the time I spent nursing my sprained ankle).
- derbOac 5y ago"There are bold X, and old X, but no old, bold X." Replace X with any practitioners subject to sufficient risk as a result of their practice. I first heard it in the context of mushroom foraging.
- thehappypm 5y agoMountaineers is where I heard it.
- pugets 5y agoThis line is famous in aviation, where X = pilots
- derbOac 5y agoYeah after I read that many years ago I saw it come up in several other contexts (including aviation) and realized it probably originated elsewhere.
- timClicks 5y agoThe risks are highest when learners are at a beginner to intermediate stage. They know the basics, and have gained some confidence, but don't know enough to get themselves out of trouble. This is called Stage 1 in the Gordon Model of learning: unconscious incompetence.
- Breza 5y agoThat reminds me of when a family friend from church needed help clearing his land and thought the easiest approach would be to teach an overconfident 14 year old (me) to drive his tractor. He told me I would never be worse at operating it than the second time we went out. He was right.
- datameta 5y agoAlso known as an advanced beginner, the stage before competency. Someone who has enough knowledge to, as they say, "be dangerous".
- vincentmarle 5y agoThis is called ergodic theory, the more you repeat an action that could result in catastrophe, the likelihood of that catastrophe occuring will be close to 100% if the number of events is high enough.
- epolanski 5y agoBut that doesn't imply any higher probability. Say chance of dying when doing alpinism is one in a thousand. The 1000th time you go climbing the chances of dying are still 1/1000. If you get 100 heads in a row, the 101th time you launch a coin the chance of getting heads is still 50%.
- ska 5y agoRight, but it's easy to conflate two very things here: "What are my chances of dying in a climbing accident", and "What are my chances of dying today if I go climbing". If you are on a plane, you* have a lower risk of some kinds of cancer than the airline staff do. This has nothing to do with the flight you are both on, and everything to do with accumulated flights "you*" = for most people, i.e. barring a counteracting risk factor.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kenjackson 5y agoThis is exactly why people who do high risk think it will never happen to them.
- segmondy 5y agoI would imagine that if you scale back enough tho, you won't be as sharp. Sure the odds increase the more you do it, but not just because you do it, but often because of other variables, such as the weather, not listening to your body, over confidence, etc.
- yodsanklai 5y agoThat's the reason why I don't cycle in London. When I moved there, I thought I would be using my bike daily like I was used to. But over the span of a few years, I'm pretty sure the risk of serious injury becomes significant. For rock climbing, you're probably right. I remember training in a climbing hall, when I saw someone falling off the highest wall. The tenant of the hall didn't look surprised at all. Apparently, it happens frequently. That being said, if you serious about security, I'm sure the risk can be minimal.
- chimprich 5y agoYou can contrast the odds of getting injured with the health benefits. The cardiovascular benefits would seem to outweigh the risks of getting injured from a mathematical point of view. See e.g. https://blogs.bmj.com/bjsm/2018/12/12/pedal-power-the-health-benefits-of-cycling-outweigh-the-risks-by-far/ https://blogs.bmj.com/bjsm/2018/12/12/pedal-power-the-health...
- kenjackson 5y agoLots of ways to get even better cardio benefits with much less risk.
- e40 5y agoSame reason I sold my motorcycle when I was 30. I had a good run of not being maimed, but the odds were not good for the future.
- blunte 5y agoYou would probably be at less risk if you continued rock climbing but eschewed driving (or riding in) a car.
- zmmmmm 5y agoI took the same approach with motorcycling. I decided to do it for 3 years while at university because it had a transformative impact on my lifestyle. But I also decided the odds were way too bad to keep doing it my whole life. So I stopped and haven't done it since then.
- gilbetron 5y agoI only owned a bicycle for several years at the same age, and have since mostly used a car to get around. I've been in various, relatively minor accidents with both, and have always wanted to try using a motorcycle, but it seems to take the risks of both biking and driving and puts them together!
- hgomersall 5y ago"Climb if you will, but remember that courage and strength are nought without prudence, and that a momentary negligence may destroy the happiness of a lifetime. Do nothing in haste; look well to each step; and from the beginning think what may be the end" ~Edward Whymper
- throwaway6532 5y agoThis is why I don't drive or talk to people anymore.
- bpodgursky 5y agoIsn't this from Jared Diamond? I read this in The World until Yesterday I thought, from his time in New Guinea.
- kadoban 5y agoIs 1:5000 an actually good assessment? I'd suspect it's very much not, especially if you avoid obviously dead trees and maybe move if a storm comes.
- OscarCunningham 5y agoYou could calculate it by taking the average lifetime of a tree and dividing by the length of time slept and the number of trees in squashing distance.
- sfink 5y agoOnly if tree death is uniformly distributed over a tree's lifetime for some bizarre reason. And it isn't. The logic in the story is BS. First, you would never, ever get into a car with that logic. Second, trees just aren't that ephemeral. People who live in a forest would be very aware of when they do or don't fall (or more problematically, drop large branches.) It's not as straightforward as just avoiding storms or dead-looking trees. Sustained wet weather, especially after a period of dry weather, is a common cause. As is the opposite for some trees (eg oak trees drop limbs in sustained hot dry weather.) As for disease or other causes, an experienced hunter in a familiar area could tell at a glance. The message I got from the story is that they probably did have a very good reason. They either thought it would be too hard to communicate, or they were themselves cargo-culting the falling tree excuse when the reality was more likely to be... I dunno, snakes or nasty bugs or annoying sticky sap or whatever.
- bee_rider 5y agoI think your explanation is pretty plausible, I wonder why people are downvoting it. Like these guys probably have homes, with bedding of some sort, maybe they'd rather sleep next to their wives than some caterpillars. If I was giving somebody from a far-off place a tour of my workplace and, on the bus ride home, they suggested it was getting dark and we should camp on the sidewalk I'd probably not go for it. If they were really insistent I'd probably amplify the danger of sleeping on the sidewalk to shut them up.
- 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoGreat anecdote. The tricks in this article might work in the short term. However, over the length of a career, it's difficult to outrun a negative reputation forever. Especially in the age of the internet, people will eventually catch on to what you're doing.
- reactspa 5y agoAlso: in the version of the story I remember reading somewhere, all night they kept hearing trees fall. And that had a significant effect in affecting their impression of the probability.
- memish 5y ago
- 323 5y agoTaleb has a similar example: the difference between playing Russian roulette once for a chance of winning $10 million, versus playing it repeatedly.
- gringoDan 5y agoGreat example of a non-ergodic event. The outcome (odds of dying) when considering of one individual longitudinally is entirely different from the outcome when considering a population of individuals at a single point in time. https://taylorpearson.me/ergodicity/ https://taylorpearson.me/ergodicity/
- EGreg 5y agoI am just wondering what skydivers must think every time they do it ... given so many trials, the odds of nothing happening are going down exponentially right?
- beaned 5y agoReminds me of the fact that on overage, one out of every hundred places you know will be experiencing a once-in-a-hundred-years event. When you hear once-in-a-hundred-year event, it makes it sound quite rare. One might look around and say (for example, in relation to climate) "why are so many of these happening?" But it is unsurprising statistically. If you know just a thousand distinct geographic places, about 10 of them would experience such an event each year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hortense 5y agoNote that the size of the place is important. "highest temperature ever recorded in town X" does not mean much. "highest temperature recorded in country Y" on the other hand is more significant, especially if the country is large.
- dTal 5y agoThere's something intuitively misleading here, though I'm not sure what it is. I am looking at 100 square inches of floor right now and nothing unusual is happening in any of them.
- beaned 5y agoAre there 100-year events associated with 100 square-inch plots of floor? No... But there are with coastlines, cities, dams, forests, deserts, islands, volcanoes, etc. Of course there are other compounding factors. Not all events are one-in-one-hundred; some are one-in-ten, others are one-in-five-hundred, and with increasing scarcity by order of magnitude. Another compounding factor is that the borders for "geographical areas" are fuzzy. Does a one-in-a-hundred year event that happens in Vermont also qualify as having happened in New Hampshire? Probably depends on the type and the specific measurements and the expectation according to history. And what about aggregate events? E.g. "It's been five hundred years since we've seen this many tornadoes, which tend to happen once every ten years." And in the opposite direction of the 100 square-inch plot of ground, there is blurring in the other direction: What do they mean in aggregate if they are fewer than expected at a global scale? So my original comment was just a simple way of taking the average of all of these competing factors and stating a general truth that's somewhere in the middle. If you have X things that are expected to have 1/Y probabilities, then the probability of you experiencing any of them is not 1/Y, it's more like X/Y. (As in very likely.. that's more than 1 so obviously not mathematically correct.) But we often don't think about rare events this way - as no specific event being probable, but some collection of improbable events being almost certain. We perceive them all as 1/Y. It's just a very local way of thinking.
- robaato 5y agoJared Diamond talks about dead trees: https://www.openculture.com/2015/08/jared-diamond-underscores-the-real-risks-in-everyday-life.html https://www.openculture.com/2015/08/jared-diamond-underscore...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- toss1 5y agoYup, and the article ends with this: >>All these things are almost always true. But Heuristics That Almost Always Work tempt us to be more certain than we should of each The most important thing to realize about risk is this: The difference between [using knowledge, skill, technology, and planning to manage risk] vs. [getting away with something] If you aren't managing risk, it is managing you. And you can get away with something for a long time, but it is always a matter of until you don't, and then it is too 'effin late for you. When you are managing the risk, you can make an entire career or lifetime of doing things that will otherwise kill you in seconds, scuba diving, flying, mountaineering, building tall structures, working with molten metal or dangerous chemicals, etc., etc., etc. You can also get away with very dangerous things for at least enough time to fool you into thinking you are smart. The article discusses this at length. This is why when you need to understand and manage the risks, and also be very alert to close calls - they mean that even though you thought you're managing, you've actually gone into the land of [getting away with it], just saved by Pure Dumb Luck. Don't say "it's okay it worked", look at why, because you might not have as much PDL next time.
- rcthompson 5y agoI'd like to see the average life expectancy graph rephrased as "probably of dying today given current age". Back of the envelope calculation: Life expectancy of 72 years times 365 gives about 26k days, so your average chance of death on a given day is on the order of 1 in 26,000.
- quickthrower2 5y agoPerhaps sleeping under a tree is the "not putting on your seatbelt" of the jungle.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoAustralian here. Never ever ever park, and especially never ever ever ever camp, under gumtrees. They can and do drop large limbs at any time without warning. There are gum trees in PNG.
- jefftk 5y agoEven if you're going to do it only once it is still very dangerous compared to the risks we normally take. 1:5000 is 200 micromorts, about 25x as dangerous as hang gliding! [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort
- refurb 5y agoBut the odds aren’t additive. If you sleep under a tree 4999 times and nothing happens, that doesn’t mean the 5000 time you sleep under one you’ll get crushed. Each and every time you have a 1 in 5000 chance.
- didibus 5y agoI don't believe the odd that you get crushed once if you play it multiple times are not as good as the odd of not getting crushed when playing only one time. So you have 0.02% chance of getting crushed each time. (1 - 0.0002)^10950 = 0.1119 1 - 0.1119 = 0.8881 So the probability of getting crushed at least one night over 30 years is ~89% I think, my stats are from school over 10 years ago. This is because, for example, if you flip a coin, each time you still only have 50% chance of getting tails. But the chances that you flip it 10 times in a row and never get heads are a lot less than 50%. That's said. Another tricky bit is, what was measured when we said 1/5000 chance? This is where data can get confusing. Was that the odd of a tree falling at any given night? Or was that the odd of someone being crushed by a tree in their sleep at night? Or was it the odd of someone being crushed by a tree ever? Or the odd of a particular tree falling at night? That's often where any prediction already begins to break down. For example, sorry to use the vaccines as an example, but when we say 90% efficacy, it means, out of x number of people who got a vaccine during the trial, 90% of those didn't get covid during some period, while in the placebo group it would be some other % who got it. Reasoning about this already is tricky. You don't know the priors. What was the odd your participants were exposed to COVID? What if you'd measured over a longer period of time? What if that was just a lucky bunch?
- coldtea 5y agoDon't have to be additive to "add up". >If you sleep under a tree 4999 times and nothing happens, that doesn’t mean the 5000 time you sleep under one you’ll get crushed. No, but it means you have far more overall chances of getting crushed if you do it 5000 times, than if you do it once or twice.
- DaveExeter 5y agoJared Diamond tells a similar story about tree falls in the jungle. https://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/29/science/jared-diamonds-guide-to-reducing-lifes-risks.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/29/science/jared-diamonds-gu...
- vishnugupta 5y ago> for a lifelong hunter, 1:5000 are pretty bad odds There’s a term for this which I’m unable to recall and it’s not easy to Google. Would greatly appreciate if someone could help me out here!!
- azinman2 5y agoEffectively it’s integrating risk over time, but that’s probably not what you’re thinking of.
- animesh 5y agoIs it Micromort? I just learned about this from a comment above. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30267553 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30267553
- romwell 5y agoCompound interest? Exponential decay? Both apply here. Probability of surviving a night under a tree is (1-1/5000). 15 years of hunting is roughly 5000 nights. The chances of never getting hit by a tree over that period are (1-1/5000) for each night, which compounds to (1-1/5000)^5000 ≈ 1/e ≈ 1/2.7 < 0.4 That's to say, the odds are 3:2 (at least!) that you'd get killed by a tree in 15 years. Make it at least 5:1 for 30 years. That's to say, at least 5 out of 6 hunters who sleep under a tree every day wouldn't survive doing it for 30 years. And that, children, is why credit cards are a scary thing.
- vmurthy 5y agoErgodicity? E.g. A single player playing Russian roulette for a 100 times v/s 100 players playing it once are very different risks for the single player :)
- vishnugupta 5y agoThat's it, thank you!
- IIAOPSW 5y agoFor those curious, (4999/5000)^3650 is approx .5. Meaning your chance of dying under a tree is about 50/50 after 10 years.
- ccalloway 5y agoIt seems like 1:5000 is not an accurate probability, but just a number which he chose in order to convince himself that sleeping under a tree was not a risky activity. But he chose a bad number and later realized that an argument based on that number was not convincing. If the chance was actually 1:5000, the longevity of trees would be similar to that of hunters sleeping under them - or lower, since hunters can sometimes avoid the hazard, but trees are exposed to it every night (and all day as well). Actual data on tree mortality seems to indicate that the chances are much lower than this. Almost certainly they do not make sleeping under trees a significant risky activity.
- notahacker 5y agoTakes the whole tree collapsing to kill the tree. A large enough branch (or a coconut, if we're on Papua) should suffice for a hunter.
- ccalloway 5y agoThe hunters said 'a tree might fall on you and kill you'? This is supposed to be a nugget of ancient wisdom. Now it turns out it's actually a coconut falling out of the tree? Are you providing this extra information? Or was it somehow implicit in the original telling? Is it possible that both the original teller, the reteller and you too, are starting from the (unfounded) assumption that the hunters know what they're talking about, and are adapting the facts to fit this assumption?
- Timpy 5y agoI read somewhere that the Mongolians believed flowing water was sacred and they had a taboo about defecating near it. For the wrong reasons they accidentally prevented cholera. If avoiding sleeping under trees prevents tree falls, lightning strikes, coconut comas, snakes from dropping on you, and whatever else then it doesn't really matter why the hunters don't sleep under them does it? Not having coconuts to worry about is just a happy bonus to the survival statistics.
- NoPie 5y ago
- qazpot 5y agoTaleb also discussed this in his work. Any payoff from a trade which has even a very tiny probablity of making you go bust is zero. Because once you go bust you are not going to be doing trading anymore. He calls these Uncle Points.
- 400thecat 5y agoWhat is his name? Is he, by any chance, from the biological faculty in Ceske Budejovice?
- magicroot75 5y agoThere are more dangerous things for a Papua New Guinea hunter though.