10 ms·
How to pick a good monitor for software development
- sandruso 5y agoI tried 27" 1440p external monitor with macOS and fonts were blurry I had to sell it after 3 months. I don't recommend anything lower than 4k on 27".
- eyelidlessness 5y agoMost discussion of displays that isn’t for a highly specialized audience fails to mention panel types, I’m glad that’s well covered. I was surprised to see PLS even mentioned. I took a chance on a PLS panel years back, and I was definitely satisfied with the panel quality (tl;dr, it’s roughly on par with IPS). The only reason I don’t still use it, is its replacement… I’m surprised to see I’m not the only one here using a Comically Large Display. I also use a ~43"[1], with an IPS panel running 4k@1x. TL;DR: I laughed at myself for buying this thing for several months, and now I can’t imagine working without it. If you’re considering a large multi-display setup or an ultrawide to maximize screen real estate, it’s worth also considering a Comically Large 16:9 format. It’s surprisingly economical, even for a decent quality IPS panel. Bonus: if you’re working remote/limited for space like I am, unlike a big multi-display setup, it also makes for a pretty great TV. And it’s only/fully as “smart” as whatever device you attach to it. 1: https://www.lg.com/us/monitors/lg-43un700-b-4k-uhd-led-monitor https://www.lg.com/us/monitors/lg-43un700-b-4k-uhd-led-monit...
- jsrcout 5y agoI love your terminology of Comically Large Display and shall use it always. I keep threatening to drag our 55" Sony main TV into my office for work from home usage. I actually tried using it as a display for my Raspberry Pi once, it was fantastic. Though I hate to think of the computing power differential between the two devices. The 43" LG monitor you mention is really tempting, especially considering pricing on the 32" 4K IPS monitors I was just looking at. Do you have any advice/caveats for prospective buyers?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoMy advice/caveat is: it’s effectively the same as a massive multi-display setup, and has most of the same challenges. The display I chose is about the same pixel density as a 27” 1440p, which works great at the same arm’s reach, but it means you have a much larger area of focus. That’s ergonomically awful if you’re craning your neck. For me, this display was only half useable when I first got it, because it was elevated like my 27”. Once I set it lower on my desk, I felt a lot more comfortable using more vertical space. Even still, I ignore about 1/4 of the horizontal space because it would require too much neck rotation to use comfortably. Of course YMMV!
- robgibbons 5y ago4K @ 32" is perfection for me, I wouldn't go any larger or smaller with 4K. You get four 1080p screens worth in a single panel, without any virtual scaling going on at all. I have two identical work setups in different rooms. Different brand monitors, but both mounted to 13" ErgoTron LX (VESA robot arms), bolted to motorized adjustable desks (solid core doors for desk tops, Amazon-style). My first screen is a Dell U-Series 32" (U3219Q) and it's been fabulous for two years now. Can't recommend it enough. My second screen is an Acer 31.5" Nitro XV2 (XV322QK) which can put out 144hz. It runs at 60 Hz with my XPS 15 plugged in via USB-C, but if I hook a PS5 into it can get 120hz.
- skatanski 5y agoA friend has serious eye strain problems and his literally stockpiling old square screens. At the moment only screens, which are okey for him are Eizo IPS S1934 and EV2730Q and some of the old similar ones not produced anymore. Any square screen recommendations?
- cheradenine_uk 5y agoI have yet to find a better monitor than the Dell U3011, which is essentially the same unit as my previous 3008WFP (which itself there was a 3007wfp before it), which means it's a design that's been available approaching 15 years. 30" 2560x1600; c. 100ppi. I run the numbers on all the Ultrawide, 4K, whatever hotness and I end up knowing I'll fit less vertical lines on the screen.
- peterfield 5y ago"Then there’s the whole problem of managing windows." Ever heard of tiling windows managers?
- gnufied 5y agoDoes anyone know why manufactures don't make 34,36 inch 4k monitors? There are plenty of 32 inch 4k monitors but next 4k resolution is 42-43 inch. Nothing in-between. The whole segment of 32-40 inch monitor is dominated by ultra wide monitors.
- pottertheotter 5y agoI've wondered the same thing, and assumed it had to do with the GPU you would need to run them. I just looked and there appear to be at least a couple models: https://pcpartpicker.com/products/monitor/#r=512002160 https://pcpartpicker.com/products/monitor/#r=512002160
- zokier 5y ago120-130 PPI sounds like really awkward zone. Either you have really good eyesight and run it at 1x scale, or deal with scaling issues by running it at 1.25x without actually being as sharp as proper hidpi. In comparison, 31.5" works well with 1.5x, and 43" at 1x.
- gnufied 5y agoHeh I am running currently at 32 inch;4k at 1x. I do find it tad small and I was thinking a 36 inch will be almost perfect.
- NathanOsullivan 5y agoUltrawide are actually still quite standardized. The most common size is 34" . They are the same height as a 16:9 27" and the same amount of vertical pixels - one of 1080,1440, 2160. It is derived from the same panel as what goes into a 27", just longer. The next common size is 38" @ 3840x1600 . I haven't done the math, but these are presumably derived from 16:9 42" 3840x2160 panels, with the bottom 560 pixels cut off. I'm not aware of any '32" 16:9 but longer' ultrawide yet, but they will likely happen at some point. I think you are right that there's nothing readily available between 32" and 42", but ultrawide do not contradict that UW panels are a niche product line so they use existing panel PPI arrangements.
- rambambram 5y ago> "This will make fonts and porn…I mean professional Photoshop graphics that you design look really sharp." Author about retina displays.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoMake no mistake, good fonts ARE porn.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- salamandersauce 5y agoI would also pay attention to reviews and keep an eye out for problems like DisplayPort deep sleep. I have two monitors, one goes into DP deep sleep with no way to disable and the other doesn't. The monitor that doesn't will always wake first and all windows will end up moved onto that monitor since the DP deep sleep monitor is technically "off" for a few seconds. As you can imagine reorganizing all your windows every time you come out of sleep is a bit of a PITA. Fortunately this is one area where Windows 11 helps as they added some feature to better help laptops reconnect to external displays. It's still a problem on other OSs IME though.
- notreallyserio 5y agoHave you tried Powertoys FancyZones? I'd be curious to hear if it helps to persist window positions or at least reset them quickly if they end up in the wrong place.
- salamandersauce 5y agoNo, I hadn't heard of it. Windows 11 also sort of works around it you just have to wait a few seconds for it to rejigger the windows so I no longer need a workaround. I did use it with tiling window manager (stumpWM) on Linux but that just resulted in an even worse problem where I couldn't even use the 2nd monitor after returning from sleep.
- bsnnkv 5y agoI made a post yesterday (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30223880 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30223880) about my own twm use in Windows 11; I think it could help with the problem you are describing of application window reorganization.
- wruza 5y agoSomeone told here earlier it’s now built into w11.
- formerly_proven 5y ago
- Okkef 5y agoI recently got a 27" 4k monitor that I use at 2x scaling, and I'm never going back to fewer pixels per inch. When I now have to look at monitors with a lower PPIU it hurts my eyes. I can see the individual pixels very clearly and letters are blurry. Much less eyestrain on 4k, can recommend!
- chrisseaton 5y agoFunny I have a 27" 4k and it's low resolution compared to for example a basic MacBook Pro laptop screen.
- hyakosm 5y agoThe lack of options for 27 inch 5K monitors is disappointing. There is nothing cheaper than the old Ultrafine 5K.
- formerly_proven 5y agoThere used to be more options in that market segment but lack of interest kinda made them extinct.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoGamers and business buyers drive the market. Neither care about pixel density.
- glandium 5y agoWhat baffles my mind is that retina densities are so much better for CJK languages, and yet, we don't see more retina densities in those markets. They must like the pixel blobs for characters with large number of strokes... /s
- chrisseaton 5y agoBusiness buyers care about text... which is better with higher pixel density.
- georgewfraser 5y agoI’ve bought two monitors that I really loved: an Apple Cinema Display 27” for $2000 in 2003, which was a crazy amount of money for a monitor at the time. I used it for 12 years. And an Apple Pro display with all the options for $7k last year, which seemed a little crazy but it’s just unbelievably good, like looking through a window, and I won’t be surprised if I use it for 10 years. If you’ve got the money, a really good monitor is worth a lot.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 5y agoI'd like to hear from people who develop with a 49 inch monitor. Especially the really curvy one. I had a 34 inch ultrawide for a while, but eventually got tired of the low resolution. Switched to a 32 inch 4K and I'm pretty happy with it. But it's a bit slow starting up, the refresh rate maxes out at 60Hz, and sometimes I find myself wishing for more space. Partially because I'm getting old and my eyes thank me for scaling up the size of fonts and such, which cuts down on the effective area of the screen. I've been toying with the idea of getting the Samsung CRG9, but I've no idea if it would be a good choice for primarily software development. A big upside is that it's a single monitor, which will make my M1 MBP happy.
- anpat 5y agoGot oddessy g9 this Black Friday for ~$900. (https://www.samsung.com/us/computing/monitors/gaming/49--odyssey-g9-gaming-monitor-lc49g95tssnxza/ https://www.samsung.com/us/computing/monitors/gaming/49--ody...) Has been smooth sailing with MBP 16” Intel (2019). Really loving the extra real estate. Can not imagine going back to plain old 22-24” screens. Edit: Primarily a backend+devops role. so refresh rate or pixels don't really matter. Being able to have multi tabs open on IntelliJ is real win for dev work. (Called split tab in jetbrains world)
- lewishogan 5y agoI have an odyssey g9 (pretty much the same thing but the "gaming" version so it has a few additional bells and whistles such as 240hz and G-Sync) and I love it. I'm not sure if this capability would be available on the model you're looking at, but I typically use the Picture-By-Picture mode (with two DisplayPort cables connected from my GPU to the monitor) for work with custom resolution profiles set to enable each side to run at 120hz. I use Windows and don't have a Mac so I'm not sure if you can do that sort of thing. The PBP options for this monitor allow you to choose the split so if you want to go with an ultrawide and leftover portion, you can do that as well. The main reason I go with this setup is it allows me to go "full screen" with each half of the monitor, or if needed share a half screen over clients like Zoom if necessary. As a productivity machine, the lack of bezel and increase of screen real-estate is fantastic for multitasking, there's enough room to have the documentation off to the side in addition to the code and any messages.
- rigelbm 5y agoI went from 2 wide screens to a single ultra wide, and I'm never going back. It's like you have two screens (well, more like 1.5), but they are optimally positioned, and there's no bevel in the middle. It's worth mentioning that I use i3, which helps a lot organising all that screen real state. I can see how obnoxious it could be to use it with other desktop environments. Bonus: It's awesome for gaming. Most games support it nowadays, and it's very immersive. Edit: The monitor -> https://www.techadvisor.com/review/aoc-agon-ag352ucg6-3690414/ https://www.techadvisor.com/review/aoc-agon-ag352ucg6-369041... Edit 2: Got it at a Black Friday for £550, which was a pretty good deal. I would probably not buy it at full price.
- searchableguy 5y agoWhich ultrawide and what size? I'm confused between getting 2 27 inch 4k monitors vs a QHD (low res) 34-38 inch ultrawide.
- rigelbm 5y agoAOC Agon AG352UCG6, 35", Curved, VA, 1440p, 120Hz https://www.techadvisor.com/review/aoc-agon-ag352ucg6-3690414/ https://www.techadvisor.com/review/aoc-agon-ag352ucg6-369041...
- TacticalCoder 5y ago38" 3840x1600 (109ppi) curved ultra-wide here (since five years now). It's an old monitor so by now there are better 38". I love it for software development.
- beebmam 5y agoIt depends on the game. I much prefer 24" 240Hz+ monitors for competitive reaction-based games. But yes, ultra-wide monitors are incredible for productive tasks.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> ultra-wide monitors are incredible for productive tasks But they always seem really short? The wider they get the shorter they seem to get. Not sure why that is. Doesn't work for viewing code or text does it?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- grujicd 5y agoOn Windows I still prefer to run 100% scaling. Yes, most new software correctly handle hidpi, but you'll encounter issues here and there. That said, if you run 1080p on 24", and want to upgrade to a larger display, 1440p 32" will give you the same dpi. You can have them side by side and everything will look the same at 100% on both screens.
- karmakaze 5y agoOne thing to watch for is that macOS often uses YPbPr mode (instead of RGB) with non-Apple (or Apple-store LG) displays. I've especially noticed this with Dell's and some others. Using DisplayPort may help, but the `patch-edid.rb` was always my go-to solution.
- camhenlin 5y agoI’m currently using a 43 inch LG monitor (43UD79). I transitioned to this monitor from a 27” iMac + 27” Apple Thunderbolt Display setup, but was forced to switch to a single external monitor when work bought me a MacBook, and I wanted more real estate than the single external thunderbolt. I think the large 4k is a step down from the two nice 27 inch screens. I’d like to switch to the Apple pro display but haven’t been able to justify the price to myself as of yet.
- amiga-workbench 5y agoI've got 3 1200p IPS panels on a VESA stand, I think its pretty ideal. I really do wish 1600p 16:10 panels were more common, as I think its the ideal sweet spot for pixel density and not pissing away compute power.
- HNSucksAss 5y ago
- toastercat 5y agoI upgraded to a 1440p 27" monitor on my work PC and do love it. Kinda tempted to upgrade my personal PC (which has dual 24" 1080p monitors) but honestly have a hard time justifying it when both monitors still work just fine after 7 years of owning them.
- fuzzy2 5y agoWhy not do it? I have a gallery of three unused displays. They’re my backup now if anything goes wrong. I recently had to use one of them too, until I could repair my (also old now) 27″ display.
- toastercat 5y agoBecause I don't have space to store two unused monitors, and it's hard to quantify just how much of a productivity gain it would be when my two 1080p monitors do work fine.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoJust get a Dell P2415Q and thank me later.
- molszanski 5y agoMy opinion: today dell p2721q is a good choice.
- softwarebeware 5y agoI’ve been combining one monitor in portrait mode alongside one monitor in landscape mode for about a year. It’s a great setup for software developers. I often open code and logs on the portrait monitor. Everything else on the one in landscape. With Rectangles.app I can place two separate applications on either monitor with a key combination. I place one window in the vertical top half and one in the vertical bottom half on my portrait monitor, for example. Or one window in the horizontal left half and one in the right half on the landscape monitor. There’s lots of possibilities and great flexibility. I’d recommend it.
- digitallyfree 5y agoI wish that 4:3 monitors would come back, my personal dev setup uses a 23" 16:9 monitor in the middle with one 17" 4:3 on each side for a total of three. Three 16:9 monitors are too wide for me to work comfortably (have to turn both my body and my head) and two 16:9s have the bezel in the middle and require me to have my head skewed constantly when working. I've tried using vertically oriented 16:9 monitors on the side, but I find I need to move my head up and down too much for my tastes.
- stetrain 5y agoIt's not quite 4:3 but LG has a new 16:18 monitor coming out soon: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/329996-lg-announces-monitor-with-crazy-1618-aspect-ratio https://www.extremetech.com/computing/329996-lg-announces-mo...
- wruza 5y agoThe never ending issue with these monitors is that it’s almost always cheaper to just buy the same height and v-res 16:9 monitor and cut borders at the driver level. They try to squeeze every penny out of your non-16:9 demands. This entire x:y issue takes roots at OSes, which suck so much at window positioning out of box. Much easier and cheaper to use fancyzones or a similar tiling software and just ignore the wasted space, or use it only when needed.
- mpettitt 5y agoI've recently switched from using a 15 or 17 inch laptop along with a 27 inch curved screen to a 13 inch laptop with a pair of 28 inch 4k flat screens, and am really liking it. I run Linux, and have various gnome extensions to allow for quick placement - main browser, second browser window for Comms stuff, slack, terminal, ide, etc. Combined with a dual monitor stand allowing me to grab a screen and move it closer for particular tasks, or further away for calls, and USB webcam and microphone for calls so people aren't looking at the side of my head while I'm watching them on a bigger screen, and it's a really productive setup.
- zuwvcfxanh 5y agoAll I really want is a 96x2 PPI monitor because I'm mainly on Windows and that's what widgets look their best at. 24", 3840x2560 (for 96 x 2 PPI, 3:2 aspect ratio), 120Hz, 10 bits per color, topping out bandwidth at exactly two lanes of UHBR 20 of DisplayPort 2.0 would be my holy grail.
- jdjslskshdj 5y agoSince everyone is just using this thread to post their own experiences with the monitors they use, I'm curious a bit further...what is actually on your monitors while developing? (Interested specifically in web dev, since that's what i do). For me, I am fine with 3 windows at a time, achieved by my laptop display, and my 4k screen split vertically. Code and SO/docs on the big screen, and then the testing browser (ptobably with console open) on the laptop screen. I don't really see any use for another monitor or more screen real estate.
- rubicon33 5y ago2 32" monitors side by side. code on left monitor browser and dev tools (split vertically 50 / 50) on right monitor. separate chrome tab behind browser + dev tool, with docs, for quick CMD+~
- stock_toaster 5y agoWow, that seems like a lot of horizontal space to cover looking back and forth. Does your neck get sore at the end of the day?
- rubicon33 5y agohm, no... doesn't feel like a lot to me? :shrug:
- jonnycomputer 5y agoSimilar here. Slightly smaller monitor, but 3 of them. Only two at a time is typically used for development. The third is for me to tile apps like Slack and Spotify.
- camgunz 5y agoI've done 2 monitors and 1 monitor + laptop screen, and a single monitor, and I mostly prefer single monitor. Sometimes 1 monitor + laptop is useful for webdev--or if I'm in a particularly chatty Slack (or whatever), but I've found the less I have to swivel my body/neck the better. The most successful 1 monitor + laptop has been is when I can put the laptop beneath the screen. But these days I find I don't want to suffer the laptop keyboard (well, really lack of TrackPoint--I have a ThinkPad USB Keyboard SK8855). Maybe the only problem I have now is "webcam looks down on you", which I don't like and makes me consider 1 monitor + laptop beneath again. MBP keyboards are better now so... maybe I can suffer the trackpad? Maybe it won't give me RSI?
- rhn_mk1 5y ago> my mom thinks that a 25” 1080p monitor is going to let her fit more things on her screen than a 22” 1080p monitor. She may be right, if she can reduce the scaling factor so that individual items stay readable and take fewer pixels to display.
- marvel_boy 5y agoExactly, as mentioned up this article if full of errors.
- camgunz 5y agoLet me chime in and recommend the Lenovo ThinkVision P32U-10 [0]. Color repro is amazing, brightness is bonkers, it's matte. The only dealbreaker for some is it's 60Hz only. The reviews are pretty good and give a good idea of how it all performs [1] [2] [3]. Plus it's super cheap at Amazon right now; I'm pretty sure mine cost $700-$800 and it's down to $400. I did have to monkey a little with macOS to get color reproduction correct on a new M1 Max--which I found out isn't uncommon. Also 32" is big--they make a 27" but brightness and color reproduction suffer slightly, and it loses a Thunderbolt port. But that might be an OK tradeoff for you. [0]: https://smile.amazon.com/Lenovo-ThinkVision-P32u-10-Monitor-Black/dp/B08DKFD8DZ https://smile.amazon.com/Lenovo-ThinkVision-P32u-10-Monitor-... [1]: https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u-10 https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u-10 [2]: https://www.techradar.com/reviews/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u-10 https://www.techradar.com/reviews/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u-10 [3]: https://www.storagereview.com/review/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u-10-4k-monitor-review https://www.storagereview.com/review/lenovo-thinkvision-p32u...
- HNSucksAss 5y ago
- Gwypaas 5y agoReally missing OLED in the post. After getting an OLED tv a few years back I can't imagine myself spending money on anything with less quality. Instant pixel refresh, amazing colors and no blooming and most importantly, a glossy display. Tried the Odyssey G7 for a while, so blurry with VA and matte panel. Ended up returning it. Temporary solution is my old 2x 1440 IPS 27". They look awful next to my 15 inch 4k laptop but gets the job done for now on the cheap. Nearly got the C1 48" but it is a bit too big for easy usage. When rumors for the C2 42" started coming I decided to buy it ASAP when it launches this spring. So annoyed by the monitor market. Phones have awesome screens, TVs have awesome screens, even laptops have awesome screens. Monitors are whatever is the cheapest per unit for large corporations or an ever increasing HZ number for gamers, without even considering pixel transition time or color.... At least there's some blingy LEDs on the back.
- HNSucksAss 5y agoWait, you WANT glossy? Not sure how seriously to take you after that. I want to get work done, not stare at myself or the stuff behind me.
- nicce 5y agoThere is a reason. OLED panels are still quite bad for "staying" images (burn-in). And not only that, there has been many other issues, which makes them hard to make outside of standard 55" TV sizes. Not many manufacturing lines for them. Lenovo Yoga Gen 2 used to have OLED screen, and it was causing huge repairs. On Gen 3 it was removed and they took a long break before introducing it on other products.
- molszanski 5y agoDon’t use it as a monitor. It is insanely easy to get a burn in. There are many YT videos where people daily drived OLEDs as monitors and it was pretty much a burn in disaster. Sadly
- csdvrx 5y agoI have a thinkpad with Oled and external screens with oled too. No burn in so far. If it ever becomes a problem, I will just get new ones. The confort of oled when working at night is worth it.
- ledgerdev 5y agoHow about IPS vs VA panels for text rendering?
- cehrlich 5y agoHas anyone gone from a 27" 4k or 5k to a 1440p ultrawide? If so, how did you like it? I've been thinking about switching, but I don't know if having to run MacOS at 1x instead of 2x might be a significant downside.
- cloudengineer94 5y agoI'm currently using 3:2 displays by Huawei, they are named Huawei Mateview and feature a 4K panel from the Surface Studio. These are quite amazing to be honest and there's ton of vertical space for both VS Code and Terminals.
- yes_but_no 5y agoI'm stuck between that monitor and 21:9 34" ultrawide. Any opinions?
- csdvrx 5y agoHard disagree on the recommendations like about not bothering with 4k. I got 2x portable 4k oled displays. Great color reproduction, crispy fonts and windows 11 remember where the windows should be. Battery powered means I can easily travel with one or both and my laptop. Oled means I can work comfortably at night with a black theme or a white theme + NegativeScreen Check the InnoCn on amazon: there are others but I can vouch for this one https://www.amazon.com/15-6-Portable-Monitor-External-Consoles/dp/B098NHT123/ https://www.amazon.com/15-6-Portable-Monitor-External-Consol...
- Stratoscope 5y agoI really like my current setup, a pair of 24" 4K monitors in combination with my ThinkPad P1's 15.6" 4K internal display. I don't use an external keyboard or mouse; I prefer the ThinkPad's keyboard and TrackPoint, along with its touchpad for two-finger scrolling. I run the internal at 300% scaling and the externals at 200%. One external is directly above the ThinkPad in landscape mode with the left edges aligned. The other is in portrait mode to the left, with the bottom of the monitor an inch above the desk to allow cables to run under it. Because of my age, my eyes have lost most of their ability to focus at different distances. And sometimes I want to use the ThinkPad on its own. So I use a pair of single vision glasses corrected for the distance to the ThinkPad display, about 20". I highly recommend glasses like these. If you wear progressive lenses (as I do when I'm away from the computer), you will always be craning your neck back so you can look through the bottom of your lenses. This is a recipe for neck and eye strain, and only a small part of any monitor will be in focus at one time. The single vision lenses solve all these problems. The focus distance also determines where the external monitors go: all three monitors have to be at the same distance from my eyes. The landscape monitor sits where I can open the ThinkPad lid in front of it and have very little gap between them. The top of the ThinkPad bezel is just below the bottom of the external monitor's display area (so the bezels overlap). The portrait monitor on the left is also 20" from my eyes. All three monitors are angled so the center of the monitor is centered for my eyes: the laptop display is at a typical laptop display angle, the landscape monitor above it is more vertical (but not straight up and down), and the portrait monitor is at a more in-between angle. At my standing desk, the top of the portrait monitor is just about at eye level, and the top of the landscape monitor slightly below. Typical use is either Slack or documentation pages on the portrait monitor, or any kind of long form reading. The portrait monitor is also great for PDF files; I can view a full page without scrolling. Most coding work happens on the landscape 24" monitor. And the ThinkPad's internal display is used for whatever else I need. I run Windows on the ThinkPad in part because of its better support for different scaling on different monitors. At my work we use Ubuntu for development, so my Ubuntu virtual machine runs full screen on the landscape monitor. I use VMware, not VirtualBox, as VMware has much better display response, almost like running native. And I often run a second Windows VM on the ThinkPad display with the McDonald's Point of Sale system. (I work on a drive-thru voice agent and test it against the POS running in the Windows VM.) One reason to have the portrait monitor on the left instead of the right is that I can simply turn to the left to read it (turning my whole body, not just my neck) while having easy access to the cursor and PgDn/PgUp keys for scrolling. This doesn't work as well if the monitor is on the right. I've experimented with many monitor configurations and this has worked out by far the best for me. I tried a 32" monitor when I spent a week at a Google office some years ago, and had trouble with it because the difference in distance for my eyes to the center of the screen vs. the edges was too much. 27" monitors wouldn't work for my setup either: the top of the portrait monitor would be too high, and since the monitors are all 20" from my eyes, I just don't need big monitors. And the smaller size keeps the focus distance more consistent. A curved monitor might help with that, but it wouldn't give me the nice PDF and documentation reading that the portrait monitor provides. And most of the big curved monitors I've seen have rather low DPI compared to these 24" 4K displays. The two external monitors are mounted on AmazonBasics monitor arms. These are actually made by Ergotron and are identical to the ones Ergotron sells under their own name, but the AmazonBasics arms have a matte black finish instead of the silver of the Ergotrons. I like the black finish because it is less obtrusive visually.
- michaelmrose 5y agoI have several issues with this analysis. > Scaling support is spotty at best, and many applications simply do not support it properly. Although I admit I only use a modicum of applications on windows scaling seems to work great on anything using an even halfway modern toolkit. On Linux it works quite well for example. If you are still running some oddball app from the 90s may I submit that you ought to throw it away rather than buying your hardware based on it unless it is truly essential. > A 4k monitor technically has 4x the screen real estate of a 1080p monitor. That means if you drew a big ass rectangle and split it into a 2x2 grid, you could fit 1x 1080p monitor in each box of the grid. This is a fundamental misunderstanding. Real estate is inches not pixels. More pixels means a clearer, more realistic, and more pleasant to look at work area in the same space not more area which can only be obtained by buying more physical space. There is absolutely no reason anyone ought to use a higher resolution to squint at increasingly smaller text that they can increasingly just make out because of the higher pixel density. Indeed nobody on earth uses monitors that way. At the point of logical absurdity. There was an 8k 20" screen at CES a while back. Imagine flipping it from 1080p resolution to 8k. Nobody on earth would display a document first in full screen and then at higher resolution in a 5" diagonal. You would view the same document in the same space. > Then there’s the whole problem of managing windows. Having 1 monstrous monitor is going to make it difficult to manage individual windows. You’re going to be spending a lot of time micro managing floating windows at various sizes. People add windows based on physical real estate. Inches not pixels. Adding pixels doesn't add any complexity in window management whatsoever. > If you took a 4k monitor and scaled it up to 200%, you would end up with exactly the same screen space as a 1080p monitor. Things will look quite a bit smoother, sort of like a Retina display, but you’re not really gaining anything. You are literally gaining it looking smoother. It's the whole thing. > Physical size doesn’t constitute how much you can fit on a monitor. For example my mom thinks that a 25” 1080p monitor is going to let her fit more things on her screen than a 22” 1080p monitor. Don’t be my mom! Your mom is correct. Lets say your mom is hip and is running xterms with vim and because she knows what she likes she has an an exact character size in mm. Because physical size is what makes something pleasantly readable which is why your phone with its very high resolution doesn't have incredibly tiny pixels. Your mom can decrease her font size on her 25" monitor and have the exact same resulting physical size as your 22" and display more characters on her screen than yours. This is course at the expense of losing clarity which is why you also want a higher resolution. > I mentioned earlier that my Chromebook is 1080p at 13.3” and I can comfortably code on it with Sublime Text at a typical laptop viewing distance which is about 12 inches away. Viewing it from 24” is far too much eye strain for me. > Using this logic, I can deduce that a 27” 4k monitor at 163 PPI would likely strain my eyes a bit because the Chromebook’s PPI is 165 PPI. Yeah sure, I can technically read the text, but it takes way too much effort. It doesn't take more work for your eyes to process higher resolutions. For one the your eyeballs have better resolution than your screen for another books are generally 300ppi or better. It becomes increasingly straining because the font size that is appropriate for reading up close is increasingly small. You can simulate the same experience by trying to read a book from increasingly far away. My primary monitor is literally a 27" with 163 DPI with a 1080p screen beside it. It's scaled so that text is the same size on both displays. One isn't harder to read than the other.
- causality0 5y agoI desperately wish there were commercially available 3:2 desktop displays in the 24-30 inch range. Hell I'd even take a 16:10 2560x1600 but they're simply not available unless you want to set a thirty inch monstrosity on your desk.
- salamandersauce 5y agoHave you seen the Huawei Mateview? It's a 28" 3:2 monitor (3840x2560).
- causality0 5y agoAvailability is poor in the US and it isn't being reviewed very well. As I recall it doesn't even let you adjust the color balance.
- torginus 5y agoI can't recommend getting a 40 to 46ish inch 4k TV enough. They're crazy cheap, and are the size and resolution of 4 regular 1080p monitors glued together. And the real superpower is being able to have a double height display for code, that allows you to view twice as many lines of code at the same time, meanwhile still leaving half of the display for displaying your app/debugger/docs/git diff etc. And window management is a breeze. Windows allows snapping to a quarter or half of the display by default, Gnome shell can be configured to do the same, and Mac has an app called Magnet that does this.
- epx 5y agoPicked a ultrawide because some IDEs like XCode need a lot of horizontal real estate. My LG 34" is a bit limited in vertical size, so would buy a 38" or bigger next time. The 1080p resolution is limited but not a dealbreaker for me since I look at it 70cm away (corrective eye surgery = focus locked to infinity).
- lnsru 5y agoHave this huge Philips 436M6VBPAB/00 43” monitor. I don’t want to go back to anything smaller. Designing printed circuit board on it is a pleasure. The quality of the picture is not very good, but it does the job. Of course, I need another shelf behind my table to put this monitor far enough from my eyes. For text only tasks I would take a widescreen monitor directly on my table.
- molszanski 5y agoThere is another good article about monitors and how to configure them https://tonsky.me/blog/monitors/ https://tonsky.me/blog/monitors/
- WestCoastJustin 5y ago3 x 4k vertical. One you do that you'll never go back. Like looking into the matrix.
- eez0 5y agoI've been using a LG 27" 4k60Hz with a MBP for a few years. Recently got a 32" LG monitor from my employer, and I really tried to make it work, but it was plain impossible. It's too big, and due to scaling (which I don't need with 27"), fonts are very blurry. I ended up with my 27" again and using the 32" for my bike trainer :)
- p12tic 5y agoIt's strange when monitor costs are being discussed while they are the primary tool for software development. If software developer produces $100k/year value, then it's worth spending several thousands of dollars for every percent of increased effectiveness. This can buy almost any monitor on the market. I've found the following worth considering: - It makes sense maximizing usable screen real estate, both in terms of pixels and area. Complex problems involve a lot of information and being able to view everything at the same time makes it easier to understand them. Personally I've found three 4K 32 inch monitors work well. - OLED allows working comfortably at low lightning conditions. - Many larger higher-end monitors support picture-by-picture, which allows splitting the monitor into multiple virtual monitors for separate inputs (2x or 4x per monitor). This is useful in case of multiple external test devices which can then be integrated into existing display setup.
- ranit 5y ago> If software developer produces $100k/year value, then it's worth spending several thousands of dollars for every percent of increased effectiveness. This can buy almost any monitor on the market. This doesn't add up: 1% of $100K = $1000. You would spend _several_ $1000 for every $1000 of produced value per year. EDIT: Added "per year" at the end, thanks to Arcuru's question.
- Arcuru 5y agoHow often do you buy a new monitor?
- ranit 5y agoEvery 3-4 years.
- listenallyall 5y agoThank you for noticing this as well! Further, if a software developer produces $100k per year in value, the company is likely underwater. Very few developers cost less than $100,000, especially when taxes, benefits, tooling, etc are all factored in.
- modoc 5y agoFor me, 4k @ 32" native resolution is perfect (not pixel doubled). I drive two BenQ displays from my MBP and absolutely love the setup! I can't stand 4k or 5k at 27" as it's too small with native, but way too big when doubled.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago24" 4K or 27" 5K is ideal, though the latter are still fairly expensive if you buy them outside of getting a retina iMac. Frankly, if you develop on a mac and can choose/buy your own computer, the 27" retina iMac is a pretty sweet deal (though I'm curious how it will be refreshed this year). Dell has a 32" 8K now, but that is sort of too big and could cause neck strain if used for programming.
- Kon5ole 5y agoI got a 8k 55" tv for just under 1000 usd a while back and can't imagine spending a cent on anything less now. Maybe a 2x2 grid of 27" 4k's but I'd be annoyed by the bevels being right in the middle of my view. Unfortunately I recently discovered it was a fluke of history, prices have gone up and I can't even seem to find 55" 8k anymore. I really hope someone puts the same panel in a consumer monitor with displayport inputs soon. I'd pay out of my own pocket to have this setup at work.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoInteresting, how does it fit on your desk?
- Kon5ole 5y agoit fits fine, it's only about 4ft/120cm wide. I can touch both sides with my hands when sitting normally in front of it. Basically most of my field of view when working is available retina screen space, it's really nice. :)
- mixmastamyk 5y agoNow I need a video card to drive it, guessing my laptop won’t cut it.
- klausjensen 5y agoIn a co-working space, I am currently running 4x27" Dell screens @ 2560x1440px. Two stacked landscape + a portrait on each side. I split the screens in logical units with Powertoys FancyZones (I run Windows). For the very limited space I have there + value for money, I could not be happier. I prefer multiple monitors over a single large. Screensharing, managing windows just seems so much easier to me. Pic: https://imgur.com/a/2yJDxod https://imgur.com/a/2yJDxod
- listenallyall 5y agoDoes anyone have a non-mac laptop that truly handles 2 monitors? I had an old Dell with both HDMI and Mini-DisplayPort ports, it drove two monitors well. But new laptops only have HDMI and rely on USB or Thunderbolt for additional monitor ports. My second monitor (connected via a USB-C hub with HDMI port) works, but it flickers and is not as bright as the first monitor connected directly to HDMI.
- perryizgr8 5y agoI used to use an HP elitebook. It drove 3 1600x1200 monitors from on display port using daisy chaining. Pretty well built laptop.
- listenallyall 5y agoThe daisy chaining is built into the monitors, correct? If every monitor was set up like this it would be great, but very few are, thus the need for 2 HDMI/DP in the laptop itself.
- wjdp 5y agoI use a ThinkPad P14s running Ubuntu, runs two monitors fine: HDMI on one and USB-C to DP cable for the other. Had another ThinkPad previously with same port config also fine.
- ldiracdelta 5y ago4k, 43" LCD Tv for $300 https://www.amazon.com/TCL-43-inch-Class-Smart-Android/dp/B08P4YG1VQ/ref=mp_s_a_1_5?crid=10HTKF295G8UU&keywords=lcd+tv+40+4k&qid=1644187444&sprefix=lcd+tv+40+4k%2Caps%2C413&sr=8-5 https://www.amazon.com/TCL-43-inch-Class-Smart-Android/dp/B0... Once you go 40 inch, you can never go back.
- addandsubtract 5y agoI have a TCL TV and I've used it to work from the couch a bit -BUT- I can't recommend it to replace a monitor, because it takes ages to boot up. There's a "fast boot" option in the settings, but it stopped working after the first firmware update, so now the TV takes 2-3 minutes to boot into Android TV every time you turn it on.
- 2-718-281-828 5y agoA smart TV ... not on my shift!
- mlmartin 5y agoI'm running a couple of 28" 3:2 ratio displays ( https://consumer.huawei.com/uk/monitors/mateview/ https://consumer.huawei.com/uk/monitors/mateview/ for the exact model). The extra vertical space is great, been wanting desktop displays in this ratio ever since getting a Surface Book and I'm upgrading to a Framework partly down to the 3:2 display there too. Downside of this particular monitor is the lack of VESA mount, it could be a tad brighter (but is fine for the office), and I'd prefer 120Hz vs 60. I'm really hoping there is more choice in this 3:2 space down the road. Like if Microsoft released that Surface Studio as a monitor..
- deergomoo 5y agoIt’s nuts to me that Apple never sold the iMac 5K 27” display as a standalone monitor. There was/is the LG UltraFine, but by most accounts it’s rather unreliable and of poor build quality for the price—not to mention it seems to be totally discontinued outside of the US. It would be the perfect Mac monitor, especially with macOS’ odd scaling method making 4K @ 27” really suboptimal. It would be overpriced I’m sure, but considering it would be less than the price of the iMac that normally contains it, I think it would still have been a popular choice. Unlike the Pro Display XDR which blows right past overpriced and lands squarely into unattainable for the vast majority of people.