15 ms·
Union Pacific to buy 20 battery-electric locomotives for yard service
- snowgrove 5y agoNot the first “fireless locomotive” to see service in railyards. Historical versions ran on steam reservoirs or compressed air, replenished by a central power plant. Some are still in use today: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fireless_locomotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fireless_locomotive
- swamp_cypress 5y agoI would have thought it was easier to electrify the yard and use pure electric powered prime movers instead.
- Stevvo 5y agoSo ridiculous. Is private rail so dysfunctional that it actually makes sense to buy battery-electric locomotives in the US instead of installing overhead wires?
- mushufasa 5y agomaybe this is an incremental strategy plan: have battery power and future ability to also use wires, so that you can operate in situations where there is less than 100% coverage
- MisterTea 5y agoHow does the overhead wire adjust height to compensate for varying car heights in the case of double stacked intermodal cars? An overhead cable is a limiting factor.
- throwawayboise 5y agoIt needs to be high enough to clear the tallest cars (plus enough distance to prevent arcing), and then the pantograph pickup on the locomotives needs to be tall enough to reach the overhead wires.
- foooobaba 5y agoUP is a freight railroad and has around 32k miles of track, and about 10k trains. Also, they need to operate 24/7 in harsh conditions all throughout the US, west of Mississippi river, so very hot and cold, mountains, desert ect.
- bluGill 5y agoYes. Overhead wires make the value of the rail go up and so the taxes the railroads pay is more and thus it isn't worth it. For the busy routes it would still be worth it, but the is a lot of used just often enough to not abandon the tracks rail. Electric is all or nothing (not 100%,but close) in that if even a small line isn't electric you only run diesel engines so you can run trains one that one line. It is easier to load and unload without electric overhead. Still if the cost of diesel went to $15/gallon the us would put up those wires, but until then diesel is cheaper. Don't forget to adjust for inflation.
- jeffbee 5y agoThis is for yard traffic. It makes sense to me. Which part doesn't make sense to you? For ports where they are double-stacking containers onto well cars, overhead wiring would be challenging, and you still need all-new locomotives.
- gsnedders 5y ago> For ports where they are double-stacking containers onto well cars, overhead wiring would be challenging, and you still need all-new locomotives. That's not really a big challenge; this is something done globally on a daily basis. Typically you either have an entirely unelectrified siding and shunt in/out of it, or you have only the near end of the siding electrified and propel the cars into the siding.
- jeffbee 5y agoNo, double-stacked containers are unique to North America and nobody else does it.
- gsnedders 5y agoIndia and China would both like to disagree: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-stack_rail_transport#Outside_North_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-stack_rail_transport#Ou...
- gok 5y agoThere are around 300,000 km of active rail in the US, essentially none of which is electrified. Then there are 10s of thousands of diesel locomotives that would need to be all replaced. This would cost trillions of dollars, more than any reasonable estimate of rail revenue for the several decades. Then those overhead wires would need to be maintained, which is much more expensive than just keeping rails functional.
- dylan604 5y agoAren't they diesel-electric though? It's not like a diesel engine is turning the wheels. The diesel is just power the electric motor driving the wheels, or are these not the norm?
- gok 5y agoYes but the expensive part of the locomotive is either the diesel generator or the equipment to take power from overhead wires (on-board inverters and the pantographs). It's not generally practical to convert one to another.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- projektfu 5y agoThere's almost certainly a power law applying to which tracks are getting the most use. If you can electrify 50% of traffic you would make a great upgrade, and it wouldn't require anything near 150,000km of track.
- gok 5y agoThe operational complexity is nontrivial. You would need to attach both diesel and electrical locomotion to every train that has even a small segment in unwired territory, which would be most runs, in exchange for relatively small fuel savings.
- trothamel 5y agohttps://scag.ca.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/crgmsais_-_analysis_of_freight_rail_electrification_in_the_scag_region.pdf?1605991886 https://scag.ca.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/crgmsa... According to this study from 2012, the cost of electrifying railroads in California is about $4.8M/track mile, and according to google, there are about 140,000 route miles of freight rail in the US. I'd assume that doing this in bulk might drop the costs substantially, but we're still talking about a huge network.
- bobthepanda 5y agoIt's not necessarily doing it in bulk that would make it cheap, it's basically turning it into an assembly line capable of doing a small amount of miles every year for ever cheaper cost. American infrastructure projects tend to be super big, then don't do anything for 10+ years before you kickstart everything up again. This is a fairly poor idea if you want to keep knowledge around from the last time it was done.
- trothamel 5y agoIt's one of those things that's kind of useless if you only do a small number of miles a year though - if you don't have the ability to make the entire journey electric, you have to involve two locomotives and the cost to switch them. That might be why Battery-Electric looks good, as you only need to electrify the two stations.
- bobthepanda 5y agoNot necessarily. Amtrak is currently investing in dual-mode locomotives: https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/amtrak-siemens-finalize-deal-for-new-equipment-to-replace-amfleet-i-equipment/ https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/amtrak-sie... My understanding of how these work is that when not connected to wires directly, a diesel generator supplies electricity instead. So partial wiring is possible with these. Amtrak has some additional constraints (they can't run diesels under the Hudson River) but to some extent a lot of freight operators have similar restrictions but deal with them differently; due to ventilation concerns, most Western mountain tunnels only permit one train in them at any given time, and the crews have to carry respirators and oxygen in case the trains stall inside the tunnel. --- Britain also has trains that do this running with a program of incremental electrification: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Rail_Class_802 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Rail_Class_802 Once the electrification is complete, the equipment can be converted to full electric operation simply by unplugging the diesel generators.
- jsnodlin 5y agoYes. It’s much, much cheaper to carry power with you rather than electrify hundreds of thousands of miles of rail.
- Aloha 5y agoIndeed. Nevermind how vastly more expensive MOW costs are for electrified lines.
- gsnedders 5y agoThis depends heavily on the density of operation; globally at least for heavily used lines the total cost of operation (infrastructure, locomotion, etc.) is much lower for electrified lines, in no small part because each locomotive needs much less maintenance. From that regard, it's somewhat surprising that none of the busiest lines have been electrified.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe sheer vastness of rural America does not lend itself to using overhead wires. In Europe, a bout of bad weather will tear down the wires in multiple places and make the line unusable even though the tracks themselves are fine. It is always "fun" to commute after a night of heavy wind, but at least the countries here are mostly compact and the locations that took damage are close to one another, so a few crews can fix them in a day or so. That would be much harder in the flyover country. I am not sure how the Russians keep up their Transsib line; it is long, electrified and goes straight through thousands of miles of wilderness.
- _0w8t 5y agoMy father in Belarus in eighties and nineties used to travel few times per week about 35 milles in one direction by a local electric train with overhead wires (called "elektrichka" in Russian). Not a single time the train was cancelled. Even delays more then 10-15 minutes were extremely rare including on the days with heavy snow or strong wind. Even all maintenance were done at night and never disrupted the traffic. So if 40 years ago Soviet Union managed that, I am sure US should be capable to build electrical lines that are not destroyed by a bad weather.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIf you want to do things incrementally it makes perfect sense.
- xeromal 5y agoNot sure if you realize how huge the US is, but overhead wire would be a ridiculously expensive effort for not much benefit.
- konschubert 5y agoThe US has a much higher percentage of freight transported by rail than the EU. I would not be so dismissive of their way of operation.
- jcranmer 5y agoIt would cost hundreds of billions of dollars to string up the overhead wire by themselves, and that's using the lowest cost electrification jobs done world-wide. It would cost hundreds of billions more to actually clear bridges and tunnels for the extra height needed for catenary. Then you'd have to actually buy all of the locomotives (not even going to speculate there). And then there's probably significant extra cost in building out transmission infrastructure to the railroad tracks--I'd guess there's large slices of the West where there's nothing around nearby you could hook traction substations up to. All-in-all, you're talking about a trillion-dollar investment to do so. At the same time... the performance benefits really aren't worth it for freight trains. Remember that diesel locomotives are already an electric drivetrain--the diesel is merely fueling a generator that's sitting on board to power the drivetrain. The big savings with electrification come with weight reduction--and with freight, the weight of the locomotive is a small component of that weight--or using EMUs that let you have every wheel being powered (and with freight cars, that's again never going to happen).
- sixothree 5y agoWho are they buying them from?
- Aloha 5y agoProgress Rail
- exhilaration 5y agoDoes anyone know who's manufacturing these locomotives? I'm surprised they didn't name a manufacturing partner. I have to assume it's not a US company.
- MattGaiser 5y ago> The railroad will spend $100 million on the Progress Rail-built locomotives and other infrastructure improvements, the largest investment into the technology ever made by a Class I railroad. Progress Rail is at least building them.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoThat seems correct. Google also found this: https://www.progressrail.com/en/Company/News/PressReleases/CaterpillartoSupplyLocomotivestoUnionPacificRailroadSupportingInvestmentinWorldsLargestBattery-ElectricLocomotiveFleet.html https://www.progressrail.com/en/Company/News/PressReleases/C... > Union Pacific Railroad will purchase 10 battery-electric locomotives from Progress Rail, a Caterpillar Company.
- gsnedders 5y agoSpecifically, they are these: https://www.progressrail.com/en/Segments/RollingStock/Locomotives/FreightLocomotives/EMDJoule.html https://www.progressrail.com/en/Segments/RollingStock/Locomo...
- donarb 5y agoProgress Rail along with Wabtec (originally Westinghouse).
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWell, that at least explains why they laid off so many of their private security personnel, and then helped shaped the "LA train crime" story to their advantage. Those battery-electric locomotives are not cheap. [ EDIT: have any of you downvoting this actually read the backstory to the LA train crime story? Here are some links to the layoff part: https://jalopnik.com/union-pacific-train-thefts-started-right-around-the-tim-1848409360 https://jalopnik.com/union-pacific-train-thefts-started-righ... https://www.lataco.com/union-pacific-theft-police-laid-off/ https://www.lataco.com/union-pacific-theft-police-laid-off/ ]
- bobthepanda 5y agoThe lede is a bit buried here: > Union Pacific plans to purchase 20 battery-electric locomotives for yard service If all they're doing is moving around a yard, they're not ever very far from a charging station and they're moving at very low speeds.
- donarb 5y agoYard service is a perfect application for these types of locomotives. Diesel fired locomotives tend to sit around idling and burning fuel many more hours than they are being used every day. Diesel locos also tend to not be very fuel efficient when constantly stopping/starting around the yard.
- zeusk 5y agoAFAIK, most "diesel locos" are really diesel electric, with the diesel engine feeding a generator. Hybridization of locomotives seems like a no brainer since they can recover so much more energy with regenerative braking and can plan for braking to be recovery efficient.
- dogsgobork 5y agoAs I understand, braking occurs across the entire train, not just via the drive axles, so the hybrid regeneration method would be a considerable departure from normal operations.
- throwawayboise 5y agoYes, but diesel-electric locomotives have a brake mode where the "regenerative" current is shunted through big air-cooled resistors and exhausted as heat. Often used on downgrades to control speed without burning up the brake shoes. Recovering this into battery charge would be an easy win, though you might still need the resistors after the batteries are fully charged or if they can't absorb the charge fast enough.
- 5y ago
- deepsun 5y agoLocomotives would also have much easier time using hydrogen fuel cells. They already have fixed custom gas stations.
- _hypx 5y agoOther companies are buying hydrogen locomotives: https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/cp-to-build-additional-hydrogen-locomotives-fueling-facilities/ https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/cp-to-buil...
- KennyBlanken 5y agoSwitching to fuel cells would only achieve a slight efficiency improvement; large diesels are pretty efficient. Trying to maintain hydrogen fuel systems in railroad environments would be a nightmare; hydrogen leaks out of everything. What it doesn't leak out of, it embrittles. Fuel cells require ultra-pure source gasses, not something you really find in railroad environments. It seemed like the future 2-3 decades ago but it just hasn't matured sufficiently, and we'd have to develop an entirely new production and distribution chain for it.
- _hypx 5y agoIt's already happening: https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/cp-to-build-additional-hydrogen-locomotives-fueling-facilities/ https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/cp-to-buil... You're just outdated on your info.
- deepsun 5y agoLeaks -- yes, but it's much easier to maintain in regularly professionally maintained commercial-only bulk equipment, than in personal cars and garages. Embrittlement is a known problem, and pretty much any alloy of steel helps against it. Various coatings are used as well (e.g. organic compounds). It's a well-researched area, so it's possible to estimate and engineer around it. Re. ultra-pure source gasses, I don't know, maybe, but I don't see any difference with gasoline or Jet-A fuels. Airports aren't ultra-clean environments either.
- 5y ago
- ethagknight 5y agoSince current locomotives are diesel electric hybrids anyway, seems like US Railroads could electrify certain potions of track, maybe steep changes in grade or places where trains frequently stop/start, yielding an opportunity to cut diesel consumption 50% or more on certain routes, since maintaining speed requires modest effort. Also, while reduced fuel consumption is nice, another major beneficiary would be the environment, specifically when operating in urban centers. I’ve lived near heavy-use railways and currently a switching yard for most of my life, and some days the diesel exhaust is quite strong, depending on the prevailing winds. The engines are usually pretty clean burning for the amount of work they produce, but not always…
- tamcap 5y ago"another major beneficiary would be the environment, specifically when operating in urban centers" But you see, they don't care. If there is no incentive for them to do it, why would they? Good neighborhood-will will pay for a donation to a local charity cause, etc, but will not make meaningful expensive changes to the SOP. Ideally this is the point where a regulator (of some kind) steps in and nudges the change. We all know what the political problems behind that are - despite mounting evidence of how damaging diesel exhaust particles are to us, and our children.
- ethagknight 5y agoYou are correct, i started to make the point that the environmental argument is probably the best way for legislation to coerce Railroads to modernize where it makes sense. Rather than paint the Railroads as baddies, makes more sense to approach the narrative collaboratively, that technology and some thoughtful complexity could help them save a lot of money and save our lungs along the way.
- bell-cot 5y agoAn un-mentioned advantage for battery-electric locomotives, especially for yard duty - trains are already composed of many heavy modules (locomotives and freight cars) which are pretty quick & easy to switch in & out. If (at least to start) you put the batteries in old gondola cars (roughly, a flat car with low sides, designed to carry heavy scrap metal & such), then it'd be easy to have a few "battery cars" charging on a special siding somewhere, while the locomotive and currently-in-use battery car are working. Side note on supplying power to battery-electric locomotives from overhead wires (via pantographs): The railroad industry has a lot of experience with pantographs, overhead wires, and the infrastructures needed to power said overhead wires. That stuff is expensive to build and maintain. And if your RR depends on it, then you can be utterly screwed when a large blackout occurs. Or (say) when all the power lines in an area have to be turned off, because the wildfire danger level is too high.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoI've seen (non-passenger) railroad yards in Switzerland, and they seem to get along fine with overhead wires. But the infrastructure there is much better in the USA, I get why we can't do it here (nor in Canada or in Australia for many routes).
- CalChris 5y agoInteresting. The EMDJoule locomotives use regenerative braking. https://www.progressrail.com/en/Segments/RollingStock/Locomotives/FreightLocomotives/EMDJoule.html https://www.progressrail.com/en/Segments/RollingStock/Locomo... The batteries are 1,800 kWh or about 18,000 kilo-Teslas.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoHere's a Wabtec video [0] about their battery-electric locomotive. They are not limited to yard service; they're also marketing them as "hybrid consist" pullers, which means that if you team them with a standard diesel-electric locomotive they reduce the diesel fuel needed to pull the train and they capture some of the train's braking energy to recharge the batteries. Left unstated is whether the diesel-electric locomotive in the consist could recharge the batteries of the battery-electric locomotive as the train is rolling. I expect it could but it's probably pointless because it's more efficient to let the diesel-electric pull the train. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIgmNOxa5aI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIgmNOxa5aI
- dtgriscom 5y agoWell, if you could store electricity from the diesel to the batteries on a level run, then you could use the stored electricity to help the diesel up a hill.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoIt's almost certainly possible to create dedicated "battery cars" to extend the range of these locomotives enough to use them on long-haul trains. I expect the only downside of that today is cost, but as batteries get cheaper it will probably become a common thing.
- sandworm101 5y agoOnly if they can be charged. Many rail yards are in remote locations. A battery-powered train is useless if you are charging it using diesel generators because your rail yard doesnt have enough grid capacity.