10 ms·
FBI used geofence warrant in Seattle after BLM protest attack, documents show
- VortexLain 5y ago
- Threeve303 5y agoThis is an agency with almost little to no oversight and an equal amount of respect for your basic constitutional rights.
- temp8964 5y ago
- surge 5y agoRight, write the same article about Jan 6 and people at the Capitol Building, and few would blink an eye. In that case, I don't think any any attempts were made to burn it down, or a federal courthouse building which has zilch to do with their grievance and isn't even the right branch of government. Then people ask, how did we get here? When the past year of activism made mobbing government buildings placing them under siege for weeks and trying to burn them down the acceptable norm with little done to stop it or condemn it in the media, its not hard to see why the other extreme might think its their time to shine. The pearl clutching is amusing to me.
- sp332 5y agoIt's here https://www.wired.com/story/capitol-riot-google-geofence-warrant/ https://www.wired.com/story/capitol-riot-google-geofence-war...
- pacerwpg 5y agoHere is the hackernews entry for the linked article. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28707974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28707974 Nobody responded and I'm not entirely sure why.
- dylan604 5y ago>Nobody responded and I'm not entirely sure why. Timing probably. What else was active that day that kept the Eye of Sauron from looking in this stories direction? Lots of things can contribute.
- surge 5y agoYeah, its also framed as a good thing in the Wired article. "Helped". Only when its their political opponents is it not a concern.
- InTheArena 5y agoEveryone is convinced that bad things only happen to them, and it's a conspiracy to keep them down - while at the same time, applying the same controls to others that they may disagree with.... There are reasons for _everyone_ to be concerned about geofence warrants. It skates dangerously close to restricting freedom of association. We all know that there are bad actors - and often the chance to use extremists to paint everyone of a particular religion, sex or ideology with the tar brush of the extremists. We don't know - for example - how many people were returned here. Was it 2 devices? 200 devices? 2000 devices? If there was a parade of people in front of the building? If there was just the arson suspects? Maybe only police ones?
- syshum 5y agoThese warrants should be called what they are, General Warrants. Something that was abused in our history and deemed to corrupting that they were banned in our constitution. I do not see how strapping a set of GPS coordinates instead of a city block magically makes the warrany anything other than a General Warrant.
- DaftDank 5y agoLet me start by saying I do not condone the destruction of government buildings in any way. Full stop. If there are separate parts of a system -- but all part of the same underlying system -- do you really see them as completely different things? For example, I've heard cops, while arresting someone for marijuana, just "pass the buck" and say, "We don't write the laws, we are just enforcing them." If you are part of maintaining, propagating, and continuing a system, are you not an equal part of that system and the things done in its name?
- nradov 5y agoI see the three separate branches of government as almost completely different things. While I think drugs should be legalized (or at least decriminalized), the police aren't violating any fundamental human rights by arresting someone for marijuana possession. We need to lobby the legislature to fix the laws.
- dylan604 5y agoThe fundamental human right to be free and their pursuit of hapiness is most definitely being violated when being detained. A police officer can choose to not detain someone or they can choose to detain someone. It is within their purview.
- batch12 5y ago> If you are part of maintaining, propagating, and continuing a system, are you not an equal part of that system and the things done in its name? Yes, I think you can make this case. However, it isn't appropriate someone charged to execute enforcement of the law to ignore the laws they don't like. The only valid exception would be laws that aren't legal and therefore invalid.
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y ago>” If you are part of maintaining, propagating, and continuing a system, are you not an equal part of that system and the things done in its name?” Absolutely not, with a key emphasis on the “equal part”. It is totally wrong to assume that I, as a citizen and taxpayer who is just living my life normally, is equally as culpable as a lawmaker or a trigger happy police officer is a fallacy.
- spamizbad 5y agoThe events of January 6th involved attempting to overthrow the results of a democratic election because a certain faction didn’t like the outcome. Trying to burn down a police station is localized mob violence. They are not the same.
- syshum 5y agoThe problem is not that is was a BLM riot, the problem is that geofence warrants are effectively a modernized general warrant, something that should be viewed as plainly unconstitutional They get around it because they have slapped a modern technology workaround over the top of out constitutional protections as they often do, but a warrant under the US 4th amendment is suppose to outline the exact person, place, and object to be searched and seized. Obtaining Geofence warrant is, and should be unconstitutional any judge issuing such a warrant is unfit to be a judge
- temp8964 5y agoWhat you said has nothing to do with what I said.
- amusedcyclist 5y agoWhat he said actually addresses the article though
- rob_c 5y agoStrange, don't remember reading about that in Canada atm... It's asif there is some sort of toxic culture war going on...
- batch12 5y agoThis article has some concerning practices, but I can't help but see it as anything other than ragebait.
- deepsun 5y agoI came from a country that became dictatorship. Dictatorships never came one day, they always creep in bit by bit. So raging on each small point is the right thing to do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoAre you against warrants? Raging on each small point is the way to become a boy who cried wolf.
- amusedcyclist 5y agoWarrants on everyone in a particular geographical region purely by virtue of them being in that geographical region? Yeah I'm against that
- quinnjh 5y agoYou should research the 100 mile border rights-exclusion zone that includes most major metropolitan areas, or maybe dont...
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThey didn’t get identifying information on everyone if that’s what you think. They worked with Google to narrow it down to two individuals. That doesn’t seem like an abuse of a crazy law from patriot act. It’s not like they swatted someone’s apartment for hate speech on Twitter without a warrant, someone tried to burn down a police building.
- supreme_berry 5y ago
- stavros 5y agoThe underlying issue here is that there's an escape valve of law enforcement being ineffective enough to allow people to form organized resistance if things get too bad. With perfect enforcement, there would be no way to ever overthrow a dictatorship, so we don't want perfect enforcement, even though it's not a dictatorship just yet. Also, perfect enforcement is bad for society. Imagine where gay rights would be if we had perfect enforcement back when being gay was illegal.
- fidesomnes 5y ago
- simion314 5y agoWhy not also a warrant to Apple since there are more Apple users in US AFAIK? Or there was such a warrant but the article omitted Apple.
- hyperhopper 5y agoLikely existing agreements/backdoors/vulnerabilities that allowed them to get the data in other ways. They very likely had the capability: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/02/02/pegasus-fbi-nso-test/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/02/02/pegasus...
- isodev 5y agoApple wouldn't be able to fulfil the warrant as it doesn't collect the kind of data needed to identify users based on their historical location. Requesting the data from Google has the advantage that it can also include iPhone users who have Google apps or apps using one or more of Google's analytics products with some kind of location access.
- rob_c 5y agoOh I'd bet highly that they do and it's just that it's not advertised or really accessible...
- simion314 5y ago>Apple wouldn't be able to fulfil the warrant as it doesn't collect the kind of data needed to identify users based on their historical location. How so? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geo-fence_warrant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geo-fence_warrant search for Apple there and maybe provide a link why Apple can't find people that have maps, find my shit or other features on.
- Aaronn 5y agoThe Wikipedia article says Apple has received geofence warrants. It does not say they have provided data in response to them. I do not believe they can since Find My data and Maps search history is end-to-end encrypted. https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/law-enforcement-guidelines-us.pdf https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/law-enforcement-guidelin... https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 Find My: > Device location services information is stored on each individual device and Apple cannot retrieve this information from any specific device. Location services information for a device located through the Find My feature is customer facing and Apple does not have content of maps or alerts transmitted through the service. Air Tags: > The interaction is end-to-end encrypted, and Apple cannot view the location of any AirTag or supported third-party products
- 5ESS 5y ago
- neoromantique 5y agohttps://time.com/5886348/report-peaceful-protests/ https://time.com/5886348/report-peaceful-protests/ Maybe it's time to separate the two?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trothamel 5y agoOf course, not every characterization of a protest as peaceful was, objectively, correct: https://thehill.com/homenews/media/513902-cnn-ridiculed-for-fiery-but-mostly-peaceful-caption-with-video-of-burning https://thehill.com/homenews/media/513902-cnn-ridiculed-for-...
- aqme28 5y ago> What BLM did... Was this done by BLM or was this independent actors taking advantage of the chaos of the protests?
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoBLM as a whole was done by independent actors, so what is the distinction?
- bobthechef 5y ago
- Krisando 5y agoRegardless of how moral the goals are of the group. The reality is that BLM is a decentralized group that has actors which freely associate and disassociate fluidly. Because of this, it would be reasonable to assume that this is part of BLM as the overall group are not outing these individuals and are in fact concealing their identities. Unfortunately, the lack of self policing with the group has lead to this result.
- dannyw 5y agoThis is a warrant: 1. Issued in relation to attempted arson, which I think we all agree fits closer with "serious crime" than "civil disobedience" 2. The warrant is detailed and specifically identifies two specific subjects, identified through CCTV footage and described in the warrant. 3. Is approved by a magistrate in a federal court. 4. Is issued for a specific location and a specific timeframe (75 minutes). 5. Is for a specific record of movements during the location and time, without account details, before the FBI asks which account details they want to subpoena. Let's look at the fourth amendment: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized Is there probable cause? Indisputably. Was the application made under oath? Yes. Is there a specific place? Yes, both in terms of space, and in terms of time. Does it clearly describe what to be seized? Yes. Has a warrant been issued by a Magistrate after review? Yes. Sounds good to me. I oppose mass surveillance (fuck you, NSA), but this seems constitutional and reasonable to me.
- syshum 5y ago
- dannyw 5y ago> False, the warrant asked for data for all devices in a geographic location, they were then trying to use that data to find to individuals. Page 17: Page 17: "(a) [...] Google will not, in this step, provide the Google account identifiers (e.g. example@gmail.com) associated with the devices" "(b) [..] The government may, at its discretion, identify a subset of the devices" "(c) [..] Google will then disclose to the government the Google account identifier associated with the devices identified by government" The warrant specifically addresses Google. > The courts rarely reject any warrant requests, this should give everyone pause for concern This could also mean law enforcement generally only issues warrants when there is probable cause and legal basis to do so; such as in this case. This warrant being unsealed and public also means the public can review it. I am absolutely concerned about the encroachment of civil liberties, constitutional rights, and privacy. This specific example is not a battle I would disagree on, or fight.
- doodlebugging 5y agoAccording to the article they have surveillance camera video showing the incident. That should be time-stamped with a reasonably accurate time and their physical location should be determinable with good accuracy from the video alone. I do not see why the warrant requests data over such a long time frame. It seems likely to me that you could identify the perps from the mobile phone records by simply limiting the warrant request to 5 minutes before and 10 minutes after the event. There will be less data to sift through and the longer window after the event will allow you to track them to a vehicle or a nearby residence, etc. If the perps were carrying phones then they should be identifiable. This warrant is overly broad and will pull innocent people into the investigation including people who may not have been participants but who may have only been in the neighborhood while it was happening and just decided to stop and take a few pictures to pass on to people in their social circles. (Social media cancer sufferers unite!). A crime was committed and it is right to make an effort to locate and prosecute those responsible so that society has an opportunity to hold people accountable for their actions. Once you dig into this you find another situation where it is true that if event A had never happened, then the likelihood of event B occurring is near zero. This event is the event B and in order for justice to be served, those who were involved in event A need to be held accountable. Committing crimes in an attempt to force accountability will not improve the situation for anyone and will likely only result in someone who would otherwise have enjoyed a happy, productive life being locked up for a crime of passion that should never have happened (event B). We need technology that erodes the thin blue line serving as a refuge for cowards seeking to escape accountability for their crimes. Molotov cocktails chunked at a police station will never be that technology. I don't know what it looks like but there are some smart people on this forum who may have useful ideas to promote.
- R0b0t1 5y ago
- doodlebugging 5y agoYour reply reads like a depressing commentary on the state of our society. I don't agree that we will see a time when police are targeted in their homes and if that ever happens it is likely to be a rare event. I agree with the part about our political mechanisms since so much of the process of making things work for everyone will require political action and compromises that are likely several years, though hopefully not generations, away. The first sentence of the last paragraph has likely always been true of any town or city. Then historically, townspeople who desire a stable existence with a rigid set of rules that apply to everyone will seek to install a lawman or peacekeeper. That lawman will be given responsibility for instilling order, enforcing the law, and detaining those engaging in criminal behavior so that the justice system can be used to determine their guilt or innocence and prescribe an appropriate penalty. Crime in one form or another has been a part of human existence for too many generations to count. Societies have their own mores and define their own set of behaviors that they endorse and that they will sanction. I see targeting police as a really stupid, monumentally bad move since they are the only ones who can reliably identify the bad actors in their midst. Doing stupid shit like that will only close their ranks and put a target on every law-abiding citizen's back as police become more paranoid than they already have been trained to be. We should incentivize the reporting of criminal behavior by law enforcement officers and work to open everything to public scrutiny. I don't know what that looks like technologically speaking but there should be tools in place to allow officers to report criminal behavior and the use of those tools should protect the officer reporting the crime since their own life may be at risk. No matter how much your local police suck, handing out lollipops to reward good cops will never be enough. We need tools that are easy to use, that satisfy the needs of the criminal justice system and enable effective prosecutions. The price of or penalty for non-compliance should be high enough that reporting is incentivized more than the current system of internal whitewashings or cover-ups.
- rob_c 5y agoGood. They're doing their job. Although frankly, the solution is simple. Use 24hr burner phones and never when making outside contact with someone...
- fnalPs 5y agoI'm surprised that so many here justify dragnet surveillance (let's call the method by its proper name). By definition, hundreds of innocent persons will now be in an FBI database and will be investigated. Once you are in that database, you won't get out of it. After all, perhaps you'll be tagged in another dragnet operation. Even if you aren't interrogated or harassed otherwise, perhaps you'll be searched more often by the TSA or magically stopped more often for "traffic violations". Or perhaps you won't get that job at a government agency.
- ramoz 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- indymike 5y ago> I'm surprised that so many here justify dragnet surveillance (let's call the method by its proper name). I'd agree if it was the government that was survieling location. Instead, it's lots of people who buy mobile devices and agree to be survieled by a software company so their phone can do stuff for them. The government is asking for a reasonable amount of factual data from that non-government company. This is just bog standard police work. >By definition, hundreds of innocent persons will now be in an FBI database and will be investigated. People that were proximate to the scene of the crime will likely be questioned, but that doesn't mean they will be investigated as a suspect. The idea of a database that you can never get out of that will lead to you being targeted for enhanced law enforcement is something that shouldn't exist. But it is a different issue than a bog-standard arson investigation. Incidentally, arson is a really awful crime. It kills a lot of innocent bystanders and often destroys properties that weren't intended to be damaged by the arsonist. I've experienced this twice in my own life, where someone destroyed their property (once to prevent the bank from foreclosing, and once to get a big insurance check) with fire, and ended up killing neighbors when their house was ignited by the fire started by the arsonist.
- nemo44x 5y agoYour phone communicates over public airwaves. Therefore the government that represents the peoples interests has every right, and I’d say responsibility, to use that to help identify who was in the area of a crime when it occurred. It’s no different than asking a witness for a testimony.
- echopurity 5y ago