8 ms·
Expanded Child Tax Policy Slashed Child Poverty
- tamaharbor 5y agoI wonder how much of an impact the printing of additional money to fund this experiment had on inflation.
- weaksauce 5y agolong term probably a lot less than bombing and occupying other countries so our hegemony can be asserted all over the place... we have 330 million people and spend more than every other country in the world combined on war. A list including china that has 1,440 million people and india which has 1,400 million people. Seems when the question is war the answer is always yes but when the question is can we help our citizens the answer is how can we pay for it? The long term compounding benefits of children not being in poverty is a huge win on a society.
- josephcsible 5y agoWe bombed Nazi Germany during World War II, and then occupied much of it for a while afterwards. Did we do that "so our hegemony can be asserted all over the place"? If so, then I think asserting our hegemony is a good thing. If not, then what definition/test of it are you using that the wars you don't like count, but that one doesn't?
- likeclockwork 5y agoThat was almost a century ago. Get over it, US is not a country of warring heroes
- tehwebguy 5y agoOk but what about after uhh 1945
- josephcsible 5y agoThe criterion for whether a war was asserting hegemony is whether it happened after 1945?
- Retric 5y agoNo, the difference between creating and asserting hegemony is meaningful though. Much like how what creates a monopoly is different than what happens after a monopoly is created.
- pydry 5y ago>If not, then what definition/test of it are you using that the wars you don't like count, but that one doesn't? 1) Are they committing genocide? 2) Did they attack you?
- weaksauce 5y agothat's an excellent test.
- gruez 5y agoSo you'd be cool with the US sitting out ww2 if japan didn't bomb pearl harbor?
- wonderwonder 5y agoI think you are ignoring his first test. "Are they committing genocide?"
- gruez 5y agoWell wasn't clear whether there's a logical AND or OR between the two. In case it's OR, would you say that interventions in china[1], iraq[2], Somalia[3], Kosovo[4], Cambodia[5] would be justified? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_internment_camps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_internment_camps [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide_of_Yazidis_by_the_Islamic_State https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide_of_Yazidis_by_the_Isl... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaaq_genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaaq_genocide [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo_War [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide
- wonderwonder 5y agoFrom a purely moral standpoint, we should probably go to war with China as we are very much ignoring genocide there right now. Our response was to sanction a few provincial level officials, but we still participated in the Olympics. Pretty pathetic response on our part overall. With that said, from a real world perspective, I'm not signing up to go to war with China as we are looking at an end of the world scenario if that happens. I don't think China is our match militarily but what else do they have in their biolabs and what would they be willing to unleash if they were losing. An estimated 3% (70–85 million people) of the world population at the time was killed in WWII, how many would die in a war between us and China? Short of armed conflict though we should be doing everything in our power to disconnect ourselves economically from them. We should be prioritizing manufacturing in the US.
- weaksauce 5y agothat's a real nice strawman you have erected. > Did we do that "so our hegemony can be asserted all over the place"? no. > If so, then I think asserting our hegemony is a good thing. well that's wrong. > If not, then what definition/test of it are you using that the wars you don't like count, but that one doesn't? I don't like any war; some are needed like stopping hitler and their ghoulish goals sure. name a "war" we have won since then. hell name the last time we actually were at war since congress hasn't gone to war many times.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway6734 5y agoNo different than any other federal program. Revenue neutral versions of CTC policies have been proposed (like Mitt Romney's)
- catawbasam 5y agoThis was a pretty small slice of the stimulus.
- czbond 5y agohttps://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL Look for vertical - and you'll see it wasn't a small slice.
- bglazer 5y ago3 million children lifted out poverty but chicken wings are now more expensive. Impossible to say if it was a good policy. Seriously, how do weigh the consequences of actions like this? On the one hand you have a certainty: many children plunged into deprivation by an unavoidable pandemic. On the other hand you have an almost unknowable risk of influencing worldwide macroeconomic trends. Is the second worth more to you than the first?
- wolverine876 5y agoSorry if you are being sarcastic, but to respond literally, there is almost no inflation impact from this amount of money. Are we going to ask that for every expense? I imagine some people will - a great way to push small government and against any investment in our country. > almost unknowable We know quite a lot about economics, especially inflation and the money supply. > many children plunged into deprivation Many children were in deprivation already, and by investing in them we not only help them, we end up with more productive citizens later. Poverty can be devastating.
- neilwilson 5y ago"We know quite a lot about economics, especially inflation and the money supply." That isn't the case. There's an awful lot of beliefs and curve fitting to them. Hence why QE didn't cause the 2% inflation they believed it would.
- wolverine876 5y ago> That isn't the case. It is absolutely the case; we just don't know everything. Using modern economics, we have managed inflation and other economic phenomena highly effectively. High inflation (well beyond what is happening now - look at history and at places that ignore economics), depressions, bank runs, etc. are a thing of the past. Look at economic history before the post-war era; look at places that ignore economics and embrace ideology or political priorities instead; there is no comparison. It's trendy to attack them for their imperfections, but to suggest that economics is powerless is not only ignorant, it's yet another rejection of our human agency, of the power of knowledge, of our ability to determine our destiny, and another baby-and-bathwater attack on our institutions.
- wolverine876 5y agoProbably a lot less impact on the economy than child poverty, especially for those children.
- Galanwe 5y agoHow did you come to the conclusion that the money was printed...?
- gruez 5y agohttps://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...
- tootie 5y agoSome but supply chain is still the real killer. Inflation is global and in fact much worse in some other countries.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoExactly. How many additional children will now be in poverty because inflation put so much out of their reach. It's reverse ends justify the means. Do the means justify the ends?
- defiUs88 5y ago
- wonderwonder 5y agoThe 2008 bank bailout cost 700 billion. Almost all of that money went to rich banks and bankers. The child tax credit costs ~100 billion a year. The payments cut monthly child poverty by roughly 30%. We have direct evidence that growing up in poverty dramatically reduces your odds of graduating high school, going to college or getting a well paying job later in life. So I would posit that pulling kids out of poverty has a long term net positive effect on the economy. Also its just the right thing to do if we can. As a comparison, ~$76 billion in PPP loans were fraudulent. ~250 billion of covid relief benefits went to the rich and corporations. https://www.propublica.org/article/the-cares-act-sent-you-a-1-200-check-but-gave-millionaires-and-billionaires-far-more https://www.propublica.org/article/the-cares-act-sent-you-a-... But its the poorest of us that are causing inflation...
- refurb 5y agoThe $700B in bank bailouts were paid back and the government profited.
- toofy 5y agoSure, and most of the covid relief money the poors spent went back into the economy.
- refurb 5y agoRight, but OP’s analogy was false.
- wonderwonder 5y agoWas it? Roi may be a longer time frame but willing to bet that if allowed to continue and enough kids are lifted out of poverty; % wise the returns will be greater than what was returned in TARP.
- neilwilson 5y agoGiven that particular belief has been debunked by ten years of QE, it's not really a consideration is it. All government spending occurs by 'printing money' because that's how bank clearing works. Balance sheets expand during the day and then shrink back at settlement time - but often not quite as far as they expanded. That's how a growing economy is accommodated. When money is created, it will always either instantly pay off other loans somewhere or end up entirely in tax, unless somebody along the way doesn't spend it the instant they get it. That's because income, less tax and net loan repayments -> spending -> somebody else's income, less tax and net loan repayments. To notice "printing money", it has to have been saved not spent somewhere along the spending chain. Therefore the real question we need the answer to is why certain people believe saving causes inflation? In reality it is the deflationary drag of excess saving that is offset by 'printing money'. They are two sides of the same accounting journal.
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- DonnyV 5y agoAnd then the government stopped it and now it will go back up.
- votepaunchy 5y agoNot only that, the administration overpaid ($1500 on a $1000 increase per child 6+, $1800 on a $1600 increase per child 5 and under) so most will see a much smaller refund in the coming months.
- h0l0cube 5y agoTo phrase child welfare in terms of a capitalist mindset: if you care about expanding your business and keeping labor costs down, you care about the size and quality of the domestic labor pool, and thus you care about the access to education, the stable living arrangements, and mental welfare of your fellow country people and their families, and thus you support welfare to your poorest country people. To do otherwise, is to not just be heartless, but also foolish. There's nuance to this, like the effects of immigration and outsourcing, but with a high dollar, you need highly skilled labor to create export goods and for national security, and talent doesn't emerge in a vacuum.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoUnless your business is extracting something from the ground, like oil, diamonds or gold, without the help of the majority of the population. From "The Rules for Rulers" by CGP Grey, an adaptation of "The Dictator's Handbook" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
- h0l0cube 5y agoMining and extraction does seem to have a Baumol effect, and it's a problem for those countries to justify expenses like health, education and housing when easy money is being made.
- davmar 5y agoIf the capitalist mindset you described were accurate, then we would have the kind of society you described because we’ve had a very capitalist economy from the start. But that’s not what we see, so unfortunately what you assert cannot be true. However, you’re right that we live in capitalism. And it creates child poverty.
- zaroth 5y agoThat [some] child poverty exists in a capitalist society does not mean that capitalism creates child poverty.
- TheDesolate0 5y ago
- bandyaboot 5y agoSorry kids, Joe Manchin is concerned about entitlements.
- js2 5y agoHe’s even worse than that: > Publicly, his biggest gripes are about the cost of the bill. But privately, Manchin has told his colleagues that he essentially doesn’t trust low-income people to spend government money wisely. > In recent months, Manchin has told several of his fellow Democrats that he thought parents would waste monthly child tax credit payments on drugs instead of providing for their children, according to two sources familiar with the senator’s comments. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/joe-manchin-build-back-better-child-tax-credit-drugs_n_61bf8f6be4b061afe394006d https://www.huffpost.com/entry/joe-manchin-build-back-better...
- sofixa 5y agoSo he's assuming all poor people with children are drug users? That's not very nice.
- refurb 5y agoAccording to “two sources familiar with js2’s” comments, he feels like babies would benefit from regular doses of cocaine. See how easy it is to make things up about your enemies? Not shocked the HuffPost publishes it though.
- js2 5y agoWall Street Journal reports the same thing and it’s entirely consistent with what he says publicly. > The West Virginia Democrat has raised concerns that the no-strings attached benefit fuels opioid use, according to people familiar with his views. Some other Democrats and outside advocates have argued that the payments help prevent opioid use in hopes of changing his mind on work requirements. West Virginia has the highest rate of opioid-related overdoses in the country, according to government data. > “Don’t you think, if we’re going to help the children, that the people should make some effort?” he said on CNN earlier this month. https://archive.is/2021.09.28-163016/https://www.wsj.com/articles/democrats-debate-duration-details-of-child-tax-credit-extension-11632828474 https://archive.is/2021.09.28-163016/https://www.wsj.com/art...
- kevin__ 5y agoThe fact that this article even needed to be written says a lot about the state of politics in America. I don't think I will ever wrap my head around the fact that there are politicians who seem to sincerely believe that the best way to decrease poverty is to give tax cuts to the rich and huge corporations, instead of actions like what's described in the article.
- RALaBarge 5y agoThey don’t actually believe it though - they get paid either directly or indirectly by the rich they are giving tax breaks to.
- heavyset_go 5y agoMany of politicians are significant asset owners, and asset owners' interests typically align with those whose absurd wealth is derived from asset ownership.
- ip26 5y agoI think you are straw-man'ing a bit. Of course giving people money results in them having more money. News at 11. But it's reasonable to question whether that's a good solution, a band-aid, or perhaps a short-term hack with future blowback, etc. Direct cash transfers are not exactly some foolproof, no-brainer solution to poverty. We've made a real mess in some third world countries with the cash spigot.
- sofixa 5y ago> We've made a real mess in some third world countries with the cash spigot. Has there been a comparable scenario of direct cash transfers to poor people?
- zozbot234 5y agoGiveDirectly has studied this, and it's absolutely not making a "mess". What makes a mess is foreign aid directed at corrupt, large-scale, government- or NGO-driven "development" schemes. Giving cash just leaves the choice as to how to use the money to those who are best equipped to make it.
- supernova87a 5y agoI have to admit I'm a confused mix of beliefs right now. I agree that funding for children is among the best return on investment [1] (to the point that I think we should rank initiatives and spend on kids first before anyone else gets their turn in line for the same ROI), but I can see that purely dumping money into people's bank accounts is a rough tool to do it. In fact, our recent history has shown that any kind of allocation of money to some goal mostly leads to the thing being targeted simply getting more expensive (higher education I'm looking at you), given how practiced private equity is at exploiting these things. And the other poster above is correct, of course you're going to see some number of people previously on the edge move into positive territory as soon as you roll out any measure like this. The question is how efficient and effective can you make the expenditure of tax dollars? And how free market vs. controlling you have to be to do it? So if some service (child care, health, education) is so important and we want to be efficient about it, doesn't that call for some public entity to provide some basic level of service that people can opt out of and pay more for privately if they want? So that we don't get private enterprise just sucking at the teat of free government money, inflating prices, and at last some guarantee of us getting what we allocated tax money for? [1] https://www.impact.upenn.edu/early-childhood-toolkit/why-invest/what-is-the-return-on-investment/ https://www.impact.upenn.edu/early-childhood-toolkit/why-inv... and some other articles I've seen on the topic, will try to find and edit comment
- david38 5y agoThis is why I believe in universal food stamp cards. Have some regulations attached of course, like nutrition classes, but it takes the place of what some of the money buys, only better. Child nutrition is probably the single best ROI you can get anyway. Why everyone doesn’t have such a card is beyond me.
- throwaway6734 5y ago>but I can see that purely dumping money into people's bank accounts is a rough tool to do it. Why? We do it with social security and that seems like a well liked program. Individuals are generally pretty good at deciding what they need
- wavefunction 5y agoHow outrageous to have to advocate for the public good for children. I simply cannot reconcile any opposing stance in any way.
- MaxMoney 5y ago
- simonsaysstop 5y agoThis article looked fishy to me, so I looked into the papers it cited in the food insufficiency section. Turns out that, as always, journalists cannot be trusted to accurately summarize a paper, nor can one expect readers to bother checking it. 1) 25% reduction is a relative number. > There was a 3.7–percentage point reduction (95% CI, –0.055 to –0.019 percentage points; P < .001) in household food insufficiency for households with children present in the survey wave after the first advance payment of the Child Tax Credit, corresponding to a 25.9% reduction, using an event study specification. Difference-in-differences (−16.4%) and modified Poisson (−20.8%) models also yielded large estimates for reductions in household food insufficiency associated with the first advance payment of the expanded Child Tax Credit. For ~3 percent to be a 25% relative reduction, the starting value is about 12% households with food insufficiency. 2) What are the patterns of insufficiency rates historically? > Households with children were most affected—food insufficiency in households with children peaked at 18% in December 2020 and remained at 14% through June 2021, compared with approximately 3% among all households during 2019. I'd guess the pandemic (esp. lockdowns) did the most harm here. Note that the payments started in July 2021 (per the paper), so the fluctuations in rates of insufficiency in the period before are higher than the estimated CTC-caused reduction. 3) Disparities are because of racism? > Structural racism has shaped disparities in food insufficiency, with children in Black non-Hispanic (19.2%) and Hispanic (22.0%) households experiencing food insufficiency at almost triple the rate of children in White non-Hispanic households (7.0%) as of June 2021. Asians? What Asians? We're talking about structural racism here! They don't count because they usually screw up the narrative. 4) What is child food insufficiency? > The outcome was household food insufficiency, based on the survey item “Getting enough food can also be a problem for some people. In the last 7 days, which of these statements best describes the food eaten in your household?” We coded our outcome as 1 if respondents reported sometimes or often “not [having] enough food to eat” in the last 7 days, and 0 otherwise (“enough of the kinds of food [I/we] wanted to eat,” and “enough, but not always the kinds of food [I/we] wanted to eat”). This coding is the same as others using the Household Pulse Survey data in recent studies during the COVID-19 pandemic. Thankfully, it's more focused than the catch-all of "food insecurity." Hypothesis: News and fear over the next pandemic wave causes people to stock up. This causes temporary shortages. Then, when asked if they had been unable to buy what they need, people say "yes." *Important*: this pertains to the food insufficiency paper --- I didn't look into the child poverty reduction paper. Regarding the child poverty reduction, I also would be interested in comparisons of child poverty rates and fluctuations re. the CTC. My cynical self views it like this: 1. There is a distribution of income. 2. One threshold in that distribution is called the poverty line. 3. Give people money, and it shifts the mean of the distribution. The integral between the threshold and (threshold - stimulus) on the curve is the people 'lifted out of poverty.' Seems like a shell game to me. Less so than the EITC, though. It's not that people through the CTC are now able to climb the ladder to job and economic security and achieve the American dream (TM). My sense is that they are still treading water, albeit at a different level, all while the credentialed class congratulates itself over its magnanimity. If anyone has papers (peer-reviewed papers, not journalists' hot takes), I'd like to read them. Thanks.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoWhy not just give everyone equally? Why just give to the people earning less than $35000. I know the answer, no need to reply to me. Regardless. Give everyone equally.
- zozbot234 5y agoIt's a wash. If you "give the money to everyone equally", you'll just be clawing it right back by raising taxes on higher-income folks. Theory suggests that you'll want to phase out the aid quite aggressively as income increases (though not by anything near 100%) because this is where the tightest constraints on spending are no longer binding, so the potential benefit is not that worthwhile.
- medvezhenok 5y agoThe result is the same but the details matter. One is having to prove you are under threshold (documentation, paperwork etc) - the other, everyone gets it, so much less overhead for the poor (the overhead is on the side of the people who can afford it - the VAT tax or whatever is on the other side) It’s about who has to deal with the paperwork
- zozbot234 5y agoThis is a tax credit, so there ought to be very little paperwork involved other than filing for your taxes - I agree that this kind of arrangement makes sense. It's just that describing it as a subsidy for lower incomes is inherently fairer and more accurate than trying to make it into something "universal".