15 ms·
What Was the Ted Talk?
- light_cone 5y agoObligatory meta TED talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S0FDjFBj8o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S0FDjFBj8o Personally the TED talk I liked the most. It's funny but I actually find it interesting, showing that appearance of meaning is not actual meaning.
- junon 5y agoTEDx ruined TED, in my opinion. I worked for a person that did a TEDx talk and over the course of my employment learned they had absolutely zero authority to talk about any subject, let alone on a stage in front of a bunch of people. The integrity died in the name of views, I think. I don't miss TED.
- vaylian 5y agoI understand your frustration. But finding one bad apple does not mean all apples are bad. And this problem is not limited to TED/x.
- junon 5y agoOf course not, that wasn't my point. I've watched a ton of TEDx talks, this was my conclusion after that experience. It's a sentiment pretty openly shared by many, too.
- Doxin 5y ago"One bad apple spoils the bunch"
- pessimizer 5y agoThe most bizarre transformation of a saying in history. "One bad apple" now means the same thing as "don't throw out the baby with the bathwater."
- tdeck 5y agoSure, but if your brand is "apples worth eating" and I run across several completely rotten apoles with your sticker on them, I'm going to stop trusting that brand.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoIf you pick up a bag of apples and find one bad, do you take that particular bag home? Probably not. You would be reasonable for avoiding the bags touching that one, just to avoid the rot. The reason "on bad apple spoils the bushel" exists is because obvious rot generally means there is other rot you cannot see without further inquiry - and that those without rot will probably be tainted soon. And that's the problem: Once you find one bad speaker, you have to be suspicious of so many more. It is probably better to move onto something more trustworthy because watching nonsense means you've increased your chances of remembering and repeating nonsense later.
- barbecue_sauce 5y agoI generally pick up a bag of apples without checking if any of them are bad, and then just discard the bad ones as I come across them later.
- mayankkaizen 5y agoI too know a guy who did TEDx talk. After he did this talk, he suddenly became self-proclaimed intellectual authority on everything from Quantum Mechanics to politics to religion to what not, on his Facebook page. He couldn't write a 3 line Python program or solve a high school trigonometry problem or answer a basic history question.
- andi999 5y agoSo he is more of a 'big picture guy'?
- danrocks 5y agoMore of a C-level executive
- rgoulter 5y agoReminds me of the "company hierarchy" as discussed e.g.: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-...
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPresidential.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crdrost 5y agoIt's just more touch and go. At a TEDx I attended, wind powered beach robots dazzled, a consultant gave a powerful spoken-word poem suggesting that consultants’ reports should be written as poetry to actually drive real change... [I actually have done bug reports as poems, which was great.] Both truly wonderful and stuck in my memory. But another sticks in my head for just being a weird thing in that forum: a woman upset after her uterus crapped out after three kids, when she wanted like 6+... Normally such a talk would be about dealing with grief around broken dreams and moving on with life, or about her adventures with adoption... but rather this was how she stuck with those dreams for a biological child even though hospitals were like “you have three healthy kids why are you trying to do IVF with a surrogate?” and eventually they got the IVF done abroad but it didn't implant but they have new schemes and plans. I'm not even opposed to her goal, just it didn't seem very TED-y.
- np1810 5y agoI agree, I recently found out about Lex Fridman [0] podcast and I am very satisfied with the experts in their field expressing their history and opinions, kinda reminds me of old TED... :) [0]: https://youtube.com/c/lexfridman https://youtube.com/c/lexfridman
- bee_rider 5y agoHuh, I wonder if podcasts ate TED and TEDx talks' lunch. They can cover anything TED would, plus you get recurring hosts with fun personalities.
- hocuspocus 5y agoTo me it's been clear that the TED talk format favors good presentation skills above anything else. And I feel it's impossible for the audience to tell if an idea really matters given such a short delivery. It's much harder to bullshit your way through a 1-2 hour long podcast conducted by a knowledgeable host.
- np1810 5y ago> It's much harder to bullshit your way through a 1-2 hour long podcast conducted by a knowledgeable host. A great take, in one line... ;)
- smnrchrds 5y agoWhile I share your frustration with TEDx, it's important to note that the article is criticizing TED itself as being useless. It's not like TED has been a success, weighed down by the its association with TEDx. TED itself, according to the article, has been a disappointing failure.
- junon 5y agoWell yeah, TED hasn't been relevant in a long time. The way I see it, it failed years ago. It turns out, even seemingly smart people have a lot of sensational garbage to say.
- camillomiller 5y agoI think you’ve stopped reading the article too soon. If anything, the article says the opposite. TED has been an amazing success, just not in the way we think of it. >> TED of course can’t be held solely responsible for the increasingly eschatological pronouncements of this cohort [the tech elite]. That would be, in a way, to buy into its hype too much. But as the most visible and influential public speaking platform of the first two decades of the twenty-first century, it has been deeply implicated in broadcasting and championing the Silicon Valley version of the future. TED is probably best understood as the propaganda arm of an ascendant technocracy. It helped refine prediction into a rhetorical art well-suited to these aspiring world conquerors — even the ones who fail.
- smnrchrds 5y agoYou are right. I read the first part and added the article to my reading list to finish later. But the conclusions of the first part mirror how I personally feel about TED.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoWait, is that supposed to be uplifting? The Silicon Valley version of the future has turned out to be a dystopian nightmare.
- 5y ago
- lkrubner 5y agoMy ex-business partner inherited $2 million, then burned through all of it on various startup ideas, and when he was almost bankrupt, he dealt with the stress by smoking more and more marijuana. He also promoted himself as a visionary, someone who could put into words how the future would answer the bright hopes of humanity. As part of his effort to sell himself as a visionary, he got himself invited to give a talk to the local TEDx chapter. You can see him here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8znQZ1RUckg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8znQZ1RUckg He gave that talk during 2015, the same year that Bill Gates gave the talk about the possibility of a global pandemic. As the article above suggests, Ted Talks were at their peak in 2015, but also TEDx was ruining the brand. If anyone is curious about my ex-business partner, I talk about him, and my time working with him, in the introduction of How To Destroy A Tech Startup In Three Easy Steps: https://www.amazon.com/Destroy-Tech-Startup-Easy-Steps/dp/0998997617/ https://www.amazon.com/Destroy-Tech-Startup-Easy-Steps/dp/09...
- hycaria 5y agoWhat a strange and salty message
- guiriduro 5y agoAnd yet, surprisingly perhaps, it promotes the content of the 'salty' ex's ex rather than being whitewashed out, or being 'cancelled' that you might expect from true saltiness. Like TED therefore, its a clever trick to spice up the banal and offer it for consumption.
- hycaria 5y agoThat is part of the strange
- bobiny 5y agoTed talk was fun though
- dmix 5y agoLooks like they got a book deal out of it and that saltiness is heavily refined and packaged for public consumption.
- agumonkey 5y agoIsn't it the spirit of the era ? availability of everything to everyone ? you can all produce and distribute content, have an audience, be heard ? so that whatever group can monetize the attendence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- haasted 5y agoI agree. It's difficult to find a brand that devalued itself as much as TED did with TEDx. The vetting process for getting on stage at TEDx is vastly different, which provides for some rather ludicrous entries at local events.
- fortran77 5y agoI dislike TED as much as Oscar Schwartz (the writer of this essay). But TEDx has almost no standards. The local private High School ("Harker Academy") has TEDx talks given by high school kids who use it as just one more thing to put on their college applications to Stanford, Harvard, and MIT.
- P_I_Staker 5y agoThe core problem is with TED itself, at least that's the problem the article talks about. TEDx is a sideshow to the real issue, just like the show itself. Entities like Malcolm Gladwell and TED have done a great deal of cultural damage. IIRC Holmes appeared on TED, not TEDx. There's been plenty of hucksterism associated with the main TED. The concept itself is a bit grifty. It's sugar coated glittering generalities and idea peddling (what if xyz were true?) If it's truly for entertainment value, there's nothing wrong with TED, but it pretends to be something else. It pretends to be a beacon in society; a marketplace for the hottest new ideas. When you listen to speakers like Gladwell (who I've heard accurately described as the walking embodiment of a TED talk) they are very convincing with whatever idea they're selling. After you peel beneth the surface you find the evidence is really shaky for what he claims, but he makes it seem like such a sure thing; settled science. In some ways I think he acts as an information distortion/amplification device. He makes claims with certainty no self-respecting scientists would make. Also, this isn't talked about much, but TED has always been a gathering of the elites. You're literally not invited. I'm somewhat surprised it hasn't showed up in more conspiracies. They've been running these shows in a cult like atmosphere, too. This has never been an accessible program. It's where billionaires go to smooze and decide how to spend their money. You might as well be watching a Goldman Sac's retreat (but this is silicon valley, so it's supposed to be different for some reason)
- bloodyplonker22 5y agoTED was like clubhouse. It started out decently with good guests talking about interesting subjects, then it turned into a flurry of anyone who simply wanted to spout off.
- morelisp 5y agoYeah, it was much better when it was just Bill Gates, Ted Nelson, and Jeffrey Epstein free-associating.
- imperialdrive 5y agoHoly smokes I completely forgot about them until seeing this. They were really something - I enjoyed the heck out of watching talks the first year or so post-discovery. The moment a fake looking one appeared, that pretty much burnt the bridge.
- dusted 5y agoThe first sentences lead me on to this article being a "Look, Bill told us this would happen, and we didn't listen, we're idiots" And then it turned out to be "Look, it's kinda Bills fault that we ended up this way".. I'm not buying.
- traes 5y agoThat has almost nothing to do with the point this article is making. COVID is a mere side topic with probably 5 sentences about it in the entire article. I would suggest you actually read it, as it provides a quite fascinating breakdown of the history, development, and downfall of TED.
- dusted 5y agoJust a knee-jerk reaction, I stopped reading there, while I agree that TED is gone, I doubt it'll be for the same reason as someone who starts their article by shooting the messenger.
- yesenadam 5y agoRandy Powell's 2010 talk mentioned in the article, on "Vortex Based Mathematics" - the secret of the universe, free energy, cure for all diseases etc... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyLKY9MyUjA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyLKY9MyUjA If that wasn't enough for you (doubtful!), here's 3 more Powell talks on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUSJxzYw3OU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUSJxzYw3OU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-S39FDJtac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-S39FDJtac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVN0vFAMfr4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVN0vFAMfr4 and one by the inventor mentioned in the TEDx talk, Marko Rodin https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ic0gogjsPXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ic0gogjsPXU Sadly, it appears not to be a clever hoax but an actual Thing. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Vortex-based_math https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Vortex-based_math "Essentially, the idea revolves around a circle with nine points equidistant from one another. Number the points, and then draw lines connecting each vertex n to its double modulo 9. ...You get a vortex! Sort of. ...Rodin claims that it is the "Mathematical Finger Print of God", which is of course a perfectly reasonable assertion for a mathematical paper to make."
- ImaCake 5y agoThanks for this. I have a friend who reads this special brand of niche junk math for entertainment and I am sure he will love this.
- xarope 5y agoThe turning point for me was when I met someone at a tech conference who introduced himself as a TED talk speaker. I'm not sure I was able to walk away fast enough.
- j7ake 5y agoI recall there were many talks that have now been deleted because they were obviously frauds. For example, Elizabeth Holmes gave a TED talk. I wonder if there is a list of "deleted" TED talks over the years?
- ComradePhil 5y agoI found one such list here: https://speakerhubhq.medium.com/ted-the-banned-talks-and-what-we-can-learn-from-them-e967ae2d28d5 https://speakerhubhq.medium.com/ted-the-banned-talks-and-wha...
- ggrrhh_ta 5y agoFrom that list, Hanauer's talk on inequality might not be super profound, but I just listened to it and I cannot even understand how was it seen as partisan and banned.
- beeboop 5y agoTED talks are overwhelmingly people wanting to be successful in capitalism. To have a talk pointing out the flaws of a system people desperately want to succeed in is abrasive and probably causes discomfort for the general TED audience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 5y agoIsn't it just another poignant example of how ideas are worthless and execution is everything? When will we remove protections on ideas and let the best execution no longer be prevented by mediocre one made by the person who got the protection for the idea?
- spullara 5y agoTED has always been bad as have most technical presentations in a similar style. A much better arrangement is a discussion (not a panel) of experts in the field. At the level of most TED talks, most in the audience are unable to adequately judge the content.
- skybrian 5y agoIt seems like a TED talk might serve pretty well as a teaser for reading a book or scientific article about a subject? The problem isn't that teasers are bad, but that there's no next step, no recommended reading. The teaser is all you get and you're not expected to want more. This is anti-curious. Often memes are kind of similar in that they're basically headlines without a link to an article.
- mdp2021 5y ago> expected to want more ?! You are naturally supposed to do your homework. Normally, e.g. "desertification", finding a bibliography is not considered the issue. And when the talk is about an upcoming technology, e.g. "creating soil out of discarded garments", well yes explicit bibliography would be nice to have, but the matter is more complicated (and large parts of the matter could be in pre-bibliography state).
- ghaff 5y agoMy somewhat polarizing opinion is that, aside from tutorials/workshops, most conference talk are better around 30 minute length. I generally don't find it's a great format for really diving into a topic and 30 minutes is enough to introduce a topic and perhaps inspire me to dig deeper. Perhaps it's my modern attention span but I find a lot of things that we've traditionally slotted into hour-length period, are better handled with 30 minute ones.
- skybrian 5y agoI still think they could have been improved by thinking about what the call to action is supposed to be, other than just being inspired. It's like, okay, you got people's attention. What are you going to do with it?
- codeulike 5y agoI don't think the author of this article understands how change happens. Gates and Lewinskis talks (and others) are given as examples of talks that changed nothing, but they were both extra impetus to shifts that were already happening. Meanwhile countervailing forces push the opposite way. Like rowing against the tide, change does happen but effects can be subtle or take a long time. E.g. Maybe without that Gates talk, some butterfly effect would have meant we waited another six months for covid vaccines. Without the Lewinski talk, maybe some slightly different shift of public mood would have seen Weinstein aquited.
- suction 5y agoThe rise and success of "TED talks" as a non-American struck me as the epitome of the American "post-empire" mindset - rich and successful people cheering on even richer and more successful people for spouting ideas that only bored, rich, successful people could come up with trying to keep themselves entertained and relevant. Because most TED talks were like "hey, we don't really know what's beyond a black hole, but what if we could jump through a black hole, learn from the advanced civilisations we find there, bring back this new knowledge, and fix all our problems??"...and the audience going "Whooaaaaa this is an awesome idea nobody has ever formulated before!" All I know is the next Wozniak, the next Gates, or even the next Zuckerberg won't be at any TED talk, be it as a speaker or in the audience.
- avip 5y agoDon't throw away the baby. Some talks were very good. Khan, Dawkins, all of Ken Robinson, Reggie Watts. There's some great material there.
- uppopallo 5y agoI seriously believe that they should have stopped producing TED talks after Reggie Watts. He said everything that needed to be said. All talks afterwards were just reformulations of his core point.
- avip 5y ago100%. All of TED comes from, or converges to, that "talk". Feel not as though it is a sphere we live on
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y ago> The rise and success of "TED talks" as a non-American struck me as the epitome of the American "post-empire" mindset TED talks were limited to «rich and successful people»: there have been researchers and just experts. The rise of TED talks could have struck you as the positive potential of being able to informing a public in very condensed messages. While you see a «"post-empire" [local] mindset», others would call a worldwide-spreading virus revealed in the thirst for "inspiring". Which not only is unleashed emotion for the sake of it: oftentimes it is emotional porn, when acted on basis which are thinner than its dried-up context (when the "feel" is much larger than the facts). This celebration of the "feel" blinding the "see" may be decadent, but it is not limited to the «"post-empire"». Anderson (founder of Zzap!, for example) was and is an enthusiast, an enthusiast he remains, his creatures may naturally be consequently influenced. He had a chat with an irritated Linus Torvalds, who had to explain it that his pleasure as an engineer was to see cleverly built engines, not, well, "emotional porn" (and an unhappy Anderson greeted him at the end with a "Thank you for the Internet"?!). But mind you, good results can be an emergent side effect of enthusiasm: without Anderson, no Zzap! and no TED, and we all would be poorer. Poorer, because TED, more and more unfiltered (the selected number of issues of 15 years ago has multiplied - the quality fall is as expected), produces lots of noise mixed with the signal, but good TED talks have been had and are still produced today. The three names you threw in may indicate you check TED with an interest leaning towards colossal business enterprise; an interest towards research aimed to productive enterprise would be a more fitting target, sometimes met.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoThe real challenge for me is that truly great ideas are indistinguishable from snake oil in the format. The well rehearsed: - here is the sob story about how I got involved - here is how I toiled to come up with a solution - the solution It is emotive and would work just as well to sell someone on the latest crypto scam as it would the next big breakthrough in water treatment.
- dsign 5y agoIt is a "follow the crowd" thing. Or following a recipe for a successful story. It's not a problem only of Ted talks, read or watch any commercial fiction and they will bore you to death with the same story archetypes. The problem comes from trying to hedge the publishing risk: "see, if we are going to produce this talk/book/movie, we want some reassurances that is going to sell. So, you must follow this recipe." To make matters worse, there are like one recipe, the "hero journey", which is exactly what you described above.
- Areibman 5y agoA lot of TED talks are either window dressing or fraud, but TED Ed has consistently churned out high quality content over the years covering topics including science, history, mythology, medicine, philosophy, and more. Can’t recommend them enough https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsooa4yRKGN_zEE8iknghZA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsooa4yRKGN_zEE8iknghZA
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoIf a lot of them are frauds, how the heck are you supposed to know that these are high quality content, especially if you are being introduced to a theory and/or have little previous knowledge of the subject matter? You don't. Knowing that there is garbage peppered into everything makes it all less reliable.
- Areibman 5y agoWell, this kind of blanket statement is true for just about anything. Such an extreme level of skepticism isn’t useful. The worst TED talks are flawed largely because they were about the promoting speaker rather than the subject. (And with that, erroneous information followed). TED Ed has a dedicated team of producers and writers for each video that translates some complex ideas from a qualified educator (researcher, historian, science writer, etc.) into video form.
- Broken_Hippo 5y ago"Well, this kind of blanket statement is true for just about anything. Such an extreme level of skepticism isn’t useful." Knowing a portion of the "factual" information won't actually be factual and passing on a source because of that isn't extreme skepticism.
- jstanley 5y agoI think you may have missed the distinction between "TED" and "TED Ed". Areibman is saying that in the set of all "TED" talks, there are a lot of bad talks, but in the specific subset of "TED" talks called "TED Ed", the quality is much higher.
- danrocks 5y agoOnion Talks, a satirical view from The Onion on TED, is to me all that we need to watch to know how vapid most of TED content ever was. Enjoy: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4NL9i-Fu15hhYGB-d0hmSWD1fcIvLvn1 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4NL9i-Fu15hhYGB-d0hm...
- chronogram 5y agoThanks. “What Is The Biggest Rock? - Onion Talks - Ep. 4” perfectly encapsulates the format of interesting -> inspiring from the article: https://youtu.be/aO0TUI9r-So https://youtu.be/aO0TUI9r-So
- codeulike 5y agoThis one is a masterpiece: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CK62I-4cuSY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CK62I-4cuSY To survive in the new internet economy, you need to come up with a new service or product that people will want. Not likely, right? Using your brain to think of an idea, and your skills to implement it: Thats the old model.
- lordgrenville 5y agoThese are great. This one is a great lesson on the importance of product-market fit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpNgsU9o4ik https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpNgsU9o4ik
- jrochkind1 5y agoI'm also fond of this all-form-no-content one, that pretty much gives you the blueprint https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZBKX-6Gz6A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZBKX-6Gz6A
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chefandy 5y agoCBC Radio's excellent lampoon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZBKX-6Gz6A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZBKX-6Gz6A
- bambax 5y ago> Among the first talks posted was Sir Ken Robinson’s “Do Schools Kill Creativity?,” which has since become the most viewed TED talk of all time Here's the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9CE55wbtY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9CE55wbtY At the 7'15 point, the speaker makes a big joke about Shakespeare "being seven, being in someone's English class" and the audience rolls over with laughter -- the joke being, of course, that it's ludicrous to think anyone ever tried to teach English to the greatest English writer of all time. The speaker continues with the same idea and same joke about Shakespeare's father. But really? Isn't the logical conclusion the opposite? That Shakespeare's English teacher was the best English teacher there ever was, because (he) helped him grow into the author we know now? That his father, or his mother, or someone, probably helped him? Instead we have this idea that Shakespeare, like Jesus, was born perfect and that what he had to do was overcome the stupidity and shortsightedness (and meanness) of everyone around him, until he could explode and really be himself. This idea is a tale for little kids. But it's not just absurd, it's destructive.
- hatsubishi 5y agoIt's way faster to learn by yourself than from someone teaching you because you can go directly to what you need to understand etc. So it's more suitable for geniuses. Counterexamples to your point: Mozart, guy was copying whole compositions by memory at age 14 Adrian Lamo: didn't finish high school Einstein? And many others
- occamrazor 5y agoEinstein had a degree in Maths and Physics and did his PhD as an external student while working at the Patent Office. How is he an example of schools killing creativity?
- hatsubishi 5y agoThe 12-year-old Einstein taught himself algebra and Euclidean geometry over a single summer. Einstein also independently discovered his own original proof of the Pythagorean theorem at age 12. And more at Wikipedia. Point is geniuses learn way faster by themselves than going to a class. It's a huge waste of time to sit in a lecture of someone speaking at turtle pace, I would fall asleep. Sorry if you went through that.
- sol_invictus 5y ago
- syl_sau 5y agoThe pontification on Ted talks wouldn't be complete without a mention of Sam Hyde's prank talk "2070 Paradigm Shift": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SmicRDpS5Gk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SmicRDpS5Gk
- enriquto 5y agoI find the TED format of a talk disturbingly creepy. Yes, rehearsing and dumbing-down a bit your public talk is a good thing. But when it is done to such absurd extremes it becomes really disturbing, almost scary. It is a purely US-style thing; like exaggerated smiling and plastic-white teeth. Sure, smiling is nice and brushing your teeth is also nice. But when somebody has teeth that are unnaturally white and they show them all the time through their forced smile and uninterrupted eye contact, it becomes very scary. The stuff of nightmares. Like a TED talk.
- thinkingemote 5y agoFor the radio version of creepy, the Moth Radio Hour creeps me out so much. There's something which I cant put my finger on, it's like the real emotional stories have been produced and refined by a team to become a kind of product. Each story is told in a similar way, using hooks, pauses, climaxes, introductions, wavering voice and a personal message at the end to give maximum listening impact. They are crafted as much as a TED talk. It's creepy and doesn't feel natural because the stories are all true and personal. It's like an uncanny propaganda but where you know the content is real and true, it's just the way its being told which is weird. You can hear the persons stories have had many people working on them.
- floren 5y agoI get the same way about a lot of modern NPR shows and the podcasts that ape them... carefully scripted and produced to sound like two friends just hanging out and talking about the interesting article one read in The Atlantic. Notice how any "guest" gets their interview chopped into sub-sentence snippets with the hosts interjecting between... who knows what the original actually said before it got edited to fit the story!
- thinkingemote 5y agoYes! Completely agree! It's like the conversation is pre planned and totally unnatural as in its impossible to occur in real life. It's so off putting and weird to me.
- adrianhon 5y agoWhen I was 18, I spoke at the flagship TED11 conference in Monterey in 2001. I argued for the human exploration of Mars, a talk which in retrospect wasn't anything special other than for the relative youth of the person delivering it. TED was practically unknown back then because the founder wasn't interested in publicising it widely and because we didn't have good streaming video yet. As a result, my uni was extremely unimpressed by me taking time off to visit it (but there's a TEDxCambridgeUniversity now). It also meant there was less incentive to play to the crowd, so while there were still some "inspiresting" talks like mine, you'd also see Matt Groening show off a preview of the Futurama pilot and complain about the laughable notes he received from Fox executives. But that didn't mean there was no incentive. I arrived a day early and didn't have anything to do, so I wandered to the lobby and saw Sergey Brin and Larry Page. We went out to get a sandwich with a couple of other people and talked about games and tech and shit. When we walked back we saw Jeff Bezos in a Subway. And if I recall correctly, my talk was after a Nobel prizewinner and before Herbie Hancock. The point is that with such an influential audience, it almost seems wasteful not to hype up your shit in the hopes of getting investment or making connections or whatever. I was too young to realise this. If I had, I should've just begged the Googlers for a job and rode that rocket to the moon. But what I did get out of the experience was something far more valuable: the realisation that even the richest and most famous people are just people. And events like TED? They're fun in a way. I wish everyone had the chance to see what it's like. But there's no point in organising your life around trying to get in, as many seem to do. It's just not worth it compared to the other things you can do with your life. Even doing a successful TED talk is inferior to making a successful career or building a worthy app or writing an important book. I barely remember any of the talks at the conference. Maybe that's because I was knocked out by a deadly combination of jet lag and my first and only ever migraine, but frankly, they just weren't that impactful. What's had a more lasting effect on my life was the thing that got me to the conference in the first place: Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy and his later books, which converted me to socialism. Of course, there weren't any 18 min talks arguing for socialism at TED11.
- jrochkind1 5y agosomehow this comment reads like a TED talk
- taylorius 5y agoI think technological capitalism has fostered the idea that creative "big picture" ideas are entirely unrelated to the lower level technical skills necessary to realise them. This disconnect gives rise to a sort of ideas aristocracy, whose natural habitat is a Ted talk stage.
- amelius 5y ago> What Was the Ted Talk? A platform for self-promotion.
- aaron695 5y ago
- Toutouxc 5y agoFor me the TED video that reaaally made me raise my eyebrows was a poem [0] from Sunni Patterson. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy poetry very much and I have nothing against women-centric art, but this was so forced and out-of-place I'm getting second-hand embarrassed just watching it. [0] https://youtu.be/pnKhVpgcmFc https://youtu.be/pnKhVpgcmFc
- mdp2021 5y agoWe have a problem with precious resources available progressively drowned in a noise of low quality resources. Solution: somebody volunteers to create a platform where registered members contribute collectively in rating the single resources, and rating and clustering mechanism over the reviewers are implemented to evaluate those ratings.
- ghaff 5y agoThat sounds more complicated than necessary. Pretty much every conference has a conference committee of some sort that picks talks and reaches out to speakers if they want something that hasn't been submitted. (I imagine TED does more outreach relative to waiting for the abstracts to come to them.)
- mdp2021 5y agoNo, I meant that we need well conceived and effective rating mechanisms. There are a thousand items in that set (e.g. 4500 conferences in TED)? We need a rating system that works - this involves for example rating and clusterizing the rating agents themselves. Which is very complicated, but achieve a system that does not promote the horrendous and does not hide the precious - this is a key indicator in the goal - is not impossible. (Sorry for the delay)
- lbriner 5y agoThis reminds me of Paul Graham's famous quote that ideas are free but execution is everything. The same applies to Ted talks. Sure, there are safe high-capacity batteries that would change everything from mobile phones in the developing world to high tech in the developed world but there are millions of miles from A to B which are not usually brought up in the talks. I think we miss this fact because we often listen to people who might already be successful so we treat their ideas as unique or special but they are just as cheap. Bill Gates might have a special interest in pandemics but the truth is there are probably a million people who have the same fears as him but who wouldn't be on a Ted talk because they wouldn't be impressive. There is one thing that I think is great though about Ted talks (some of them) and that is they can encourage and inspire in general. William Kamkwamba's talk about building windmills from scrap in Malawi inspires people that you can have so little but with passion, you can change the world.
- atdrummond 5y agoI disagree Gates' talk didn't have an impact. Prior to COVID, the US and others conducted multiple novel coronavirus "war games" such as Clade X. The results of these events helped inform the European and American vaccine development efforts (an absolute success) and their disease mitigation efforts (granted, a much more mixed result). I think this is about the best impact one could hope for from a pop science speech series.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoI actually found Ted talks to be good for teaching English. You get great subtitles in real time, along with transcripts, so I teach English my way: students and tutor take turns reading out loud, then we play the Ted speaker. Practices reading, speaking and listening.
- Dave3of5 5y agoTed talks seemed like a form of Hero worship. Everyone loves a Hero and to stand up and yap on about something for an hour like you are changing the world you'll get someone to rally behind you, even if you are Elizabeth Holmes. Hopefully they are gone for good.
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- streamofdigits 5y agoThe largest collection of talks that never walked
- hemmert 5y agoI gave a TEDx talk in 2009, which was very popular on YouTube back then, and it was chosen by the TED editors to be put as a ‚proper‘ TED talk on the TED.com website. It‘s quite interesting to see how they shortened the video even further down, and what they cut out - half sentences that I repeat for clarification, and so on, cutting out 40 seconds from the 4:39min (already edited) original: YouTube version (4:39 mins): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCmsvXgxdDY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCmsvXgxdDY TED.com version (3:58 mins) https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_the_shape_shifting_future_of_the_mobile_phone https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_the_shape_shifting_... Reputation-wise, it was life-changing (literally hundreds of emails coming in) and I am thankful for that. It was also challenging that this is something you can almost certainly never repeat (including the media attention, overnight ‚expertise’ and all the associated dopamine in your blood). Today (well, in 2018), TED ‚features‘ TEDx YouTube talks on their site, but it doesn‘t seem to edit them like they did back then: YouTube version of my 2018 TEDx talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LNjVmcVF68 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LNjVmcVF68 TED.com version (identical): https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_protecting_our_creativity_from_the_side_effects_of_technology https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_protecting_our_crea... Here‘s a 2011 ‚recap‘ of how the talk ended up on TED.com (a plead for blind optimism!): https://tedx.tumblr.com/post/6981020824/how-ted-impacted-my-life-my-name-is-fabian https://tedx.tumblr.com/post/6981020824/how-ted-impacted-my-... Ah, well. Good times!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hemmert 5y agoFor some time after the talk, TED would send updated speaker agreements to sign, as they expanded the distribution channels for the talks – I remember signing an updated agreement for distribution via ‚on-demand DVDs‘ that people with insufficient internet connectivity could order for free, and also for in-flight entertainment on planes.
- spython 5y agoDid it influence your life/ professional career in a meaningful way?
- robertlagrant 5y ago> Fortunately, though, there are solutions to each of these problems, and the solutions have been formulated by extremely smart, tech-adjacent people. For their ideas to become realities, they merely need to be articulated and spread as widely as possible. This doesn't seem right. The Gates Foundation funnels billions into research. I think there are people who think that them complaining is what changes things, and perhaps that does need addressing, but personally I've observed that less from the extremely smart, tech-adjacent crowd.
- jordanpg 5y agoI associate TED talks with inserting a certain fantasy into the minds of people aspiring to be rich and famous, especially in the tech world. The fantasy is: being on stage, a thought leader. Dressed ever-so-slightly-casual. Holding the clicker. A nearly invisible headset and mic, the little foam ball hovering. Hands raised, arms parallel to the ground. And... saying profound things. At some point, conference keynotes started to look like TED talks. It became a burning, hidden desire of many: to be up on that stage, saying those profound things. Witness the number of LinkedIn profile pics that look like they were taken from TED talks. Thought leader! Public intellectual! So smart! /s
- dmix 5y agoWhy sarcasm? The thoughtleader thing has been a meme for at least 5-6yrs now. I remember Twitter accounts making fun of them from long ago. Not a new critique. There’s been a ton of parodying (and I believe self reflection) of the SV culture from the 2000s era. Edit: the Onion talks parodying TED posted by another commenter were from 9yrs ago
- wintermutestwin 5y agoDamn - does this mean I have to pull "thought leader" from my resume now? How else do I imply that I am more knowledgeable and intelligent than my corporate leaders? This is half-serious, half "I would have gotten away with it if not for these meddling kids!"
- danielscrubs 5y agoIt's awful but I know three of them that do basically that and they are earning quadruple the salary the PhD:s I'm working with.
- duxup 5y agoI feel like so many are just: “If this one thing can overcome all these hurdles for no apparent reason then all these other things will happen for no apparent reason. Wouldn’t that be great?”
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIn Neal Stephenson‘s book Anathem, the monk-like students are punished by having to memorize incorrect mathematical proofs, because they know it takes years to extricate the false information that is affecting their thought processes. A cruel punishment indeed. In the wake of the replication crisis, TED Talks kind of remind me of this, because now we are uncertain which of the 50% of talks are fake and which are true.
- mFixman 5y agoI miss the times TED talks were cool, back when Internet sites like HN were good to find the best ones on a lot of random topics. Now that a thread about them is full of people linking the ones they _did not_ like, which is the opposite of what I want from this forum.
- xemdetia 5y agoTo me this is just the classic HN experience. If anything I hope there is some motivated founder that sees this problem and the post-pandemic lack of conference/user group talks with TED production values and starts innovating on the concept.
- mFixman 5y agoI think it's a generational thing: in the last 10 years we all became old and grumpy. For all I know, there's might be a perfect HN replacement on TikTok which is incomprehensible enough that Zoomers get to participate.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI enjoyed a number of the early TED talks, but, for the last few years, I haven't found many worth watching. I was pleasantly surprised at Dolph Lundgren's TEDx talk, though[0]. I didn't know he had that side. He's never been my favorite actor. At some point, TED[x] became a marquée brand, with people practicing TED talks, in every video they make, getting headshot photos with flesh-colored headpiece mics, and timing all their work to be 18 minutes long. Basically, the old maxim, that once something becomes a commodity, it loses its lustre. It's like when punk became a fashion statement, and you could buy ripped and stained jeans for $150. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNOE0dZpHcY&t=1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNOE0dZpHcY&t=1s
- fortran77 5y ago> People are still paying between $5,000 and $50,000 to attend the annual flagship TED conference. I went to one TED conference back in early 2000s. (This was before the TEDx franchise.) I was working for a Fortune 50 company directly for its CTO. He was invited to attend and didn't pay. Neither did I, and our company didn't pay a sponsorship (though I suspect TED hoped the invitation would result in future support). Most of the "important" people in the audience there didn't pay a nickel (and as I learned over my career, wealthy people never pay for anything). I don't think anyone--except for random suckers who really, really, want to attend TED--pays that money. (Of course, I don't expect speakers to pay; I'm talking about the audience.)
- ghaff 5y agoTo be fair, while not at those levels, this is true of a fair number of conferences that are covered by sponsorships. There's a price tag but there are plentiful complimentary passes for the taking if you're in the industry and do just a bit of looking.
- tailspin2019 5y agoWhile I find some of the points this article is making to be valid, I also find its deeply cynical take hard to swallow. I would prefer to look for the nuance, the diamonds in the rough, and not write off a vast body of (in my view) highly valuable content, just because in later years the output quality of the platform deteriorated. (The latter point being one I don't disagree with). Firstly, too much weight seems to be being given to the "ideas" part of "Ideas worth spreading". The best TED talks are not just about ideas. Many of the most engaging and inspiring talks are retrospectives on what individuals and teams have done. In fact I'd argue that the most valuable TED talks are about conclusions formed from decades of research, or exciting technological advancements made through thousands of hours of deep work and experimentation. In other words, they are often talks about about consistent, dedicated execution, as much as they are about ideas. Like all new ideas, some will have potential and continue to develop, others will not. Some things will come to fruition sooner, others will take vastly longer than expected. This is the nature of progress. The author seems to think that just because someone presents an idea, or some work that they've been doing, that this somehow constitutes some form of "promise" that can be broken or not delivered on in the future. And if that assumed promise is subsequently broken, this invalidates the whole work and renders the originator of that idea a charlatan. Rather I prefer to think of it like this; we are watching people who are excited and passionate about their work, who have a sense of belief and conviction in the value of what they're doing. Every truly great (and truly bad) idea throughout time has been presented in this way. Some ideas have legs, others don't. As consumers of content, whether books, online talks, articles, we are not meant to be passive and switch off our critical thinking apparatus. When consuming such material, we should be cognisant of the fact that - of course - the speaker, or author is going to be the strongest, most vocal evangelist for their work. No one would do anything if they didn't believe in what they were doing. Some specifics from the article: > Of course, Gates’s popular and well-shared TED talk — viewed millions of times — didn’t alter the course of history. Neither did any of the other “ideas worth spreading”.. I find the writing off of Gates' pandemic talk baffling. Whatever you think of Gates, I don't really understand the conclusion the author is leading us to here. Are we saying that Gates shouldn't have bothered doing such a talk? That the 43M viewers of that talk left it with their thinking about the risk of worldwide pandemics totally unchanged? Perhaps they would have been better off spending that 10 minutes watching American Idol? > including Monica Lewinsky’s massively viral speech about how to stop online bullying through compassion and empathy How to stop online bullying through compassion and empathy. Are we suggesting that fewer people talking about this would be better? > it feels like we are living in a reality that is the exact opposite of the future envisioned that year. A president took office in part because of his talent for online bullying. In my view, the logic (or lack of) behind this flow of arguments is rather nonsensical. I think there is some truth in what the author is saying elsewhere in the article, but for me it's marred by the somewhat irrational points like the above, and difficult to therefore take seriously as a whole. I could say more about why I think we shouldn't write of TED talks fully and unequivocally, but instead, here are some of my all time favourites. Each one of these are superb and well worth watching. The nature of the medium means that the talks can't go deep into their subjects, and are generally a means to introduce people to ideas and concepts that they may want to follow up on and research further, if so inspired. There are many more than the few listed below. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi - "Flow, the secret to happiness" https://www.ted.com/talks/mihaly_csikszentmihalyi_flow_the_secret_to_happiness https://www.ted.com/talks/mihaly_csikszentmihalyi_flow_the_s... Chris Hadfield - "What I learned from going blind in space" https://www.ted.com/talks/chris_hadfield_what_i_learned_from_going_blind_in_space https://www.ted.com/talks/chris_hadfield_what_i_learned_from... Martin Seligman - "The new era of positive psychology" https://www.ted.com/talks/martin_seligman_the_new_era_of_positive_psychology https://www.ted.com/talks/martin_seligman_the_new_era_of_pos... Carol Dweck - "The power of believing that you can improve" https://www.ted.com/talks/carol_dweck_the_power_of_believing_that_you_can_improve https://www.ted.com/talks/carol_dweck_the_power_of_believing... Malcolm Gladwell - "Choice, happiness and spaghetti sauce" https://www.ted.com/talks/malcolm_gladwell_choice_happiness_and_spaghetti_sauce https://www.ted.com/talks/malcolm_gladwell_choice_happiness_... Tim Urban - "Inside the mind of a master procrastinator" https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_urban_inside_the_mind_of_a_master_procrastinator https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_urban_inside_the_mind_of_a_mas... Stephen Hawking - "Questioning the universe" https://www.ted.com/talks/stephen_hawking_questioning_the_universe https://www.ted.com/talks/stephen_hawking_questioning_the_un... Reggie Watts - "Beats that defy boxes" https://www.ted.com/talks/reggie_watts_beats_that_defy_boxes https://www.ted.com/talks/reggie_watts_beats_that_defy_boxes Tim Ferriss - "Why you should define your fears instead of your goals" https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_ferriss_why_you_should_define_your_fears_instead_of_your_goals https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_ferriss_why_you_should_define_...
- barrenko 5y agoTed Talks have the same kind of issues as LinkedIn.
- sebastianconcpt 5y agoTL;DR: TED is probably best understood as the propaganda arm of an ascendant technocracy.
- albertTJames 5y agoMeh. The article makes unsubstantiated statements in a matter-of-fact style, rendering the whole piece useless. Among those, the key statement: TED talks ideas do not impact our world, is, in my view, completely false, and would at least deserve a closer examination. What does the author expect ? That in the months after Bill Gates makes a dramatic intervention countries all over the wolrd have prioritized his ideas, devised new contingency plans, voted on them, and implemented them ? How fast is fast enough ? Those things take time, and changing minds is only the first but crucial step in a long series of changes in the cultural, political, and legal domain. Changing opinions and improving cognitive flexibility around stale issues is high impact.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jrm4 5y agoYep, not really thrilled with all the hate here. It's easy (and lazy) to throw rocks and people trying to share good ideas in new and interesting ways. Probably a good argument that TED talks are filling in a hole that "Academia" is supposed to be doing, but is presently not very good at.
- ctrlp 5y ago> "At the start of the pandemic, I noticed people sharing Gates’s 2015 talk. The general sentiment was one of remorse and lamentation: the tech-prophet had predicted the future for us! If only we had heeded his warning! I wasn’t so sure. It seems to me that Gates’s prediction and proposed solution are at least part of what landed us here. I don’t mean to suggest that Gates’s TED talk is somehow directly responsible for the lack of global preparedness for Covid." It seems more probable that Gates' enthusiasm for preparing for and preventing this future did indeed hasten it. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) is a kingmaker and gatekeeper for biomedical research worldwide via its massive network of associated NGO funding agencies. Gates is one of the primary sponsors of the GAVI initiative to push vaccine research. The development of vaccines is, ironically, a primary motivator for gain-of-function research. The connections between NIH and gain-of-function at the WiV are pretty well-established at this point. And the connections between BMGF and Dr. Fauci are also on the public record. Bill Gates is also an important player in the extremely influential globalist institutions, the WHO and the WEF (among others) and his 'war gaming pandemics' was absolutely something that was funded and organized by these supranational organizations. This is relevant here because there is the pandemic (the pathogen) and the Pandemic (the response). In this Pandemic there was a coordinated set of policies distributed via the WHO and WEF to its partner nation states for implementation. If you ever wondered how so many different countries in different places with different populations could respond almost in lockstep, checkout Operation Lockstep, one of Gates' beloved "war games". Without attributing to any one person too much power to affect the world, Gates in particular is a meddlesome, megalomaniacal billionaire who seems to pop up in all the places where global governance by technocratic elites is pushed on an unsuspecting population. It's hard to resist the impulse to attribute his obsession with viruses to some kind of psycho-drama going back to his Microsoft days working in vain to secure Windows from software viruses. Let us hope at least some of his more ruthless business instincts are safely in the past.
- taterbase 5y agoWhatever your views might be on TED talks, this article is incredibly well written and thoughtful. Great read.
- johncessna 5y agoI used to binge watch Ted Talks and then ran across How to sound Smart in your Ted Talk[1] Ted Talk where William Stephen spent 6 minutes talking about nothing. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S0FDjFBj8o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S0FDjFBj8o
- bryanrasmussen 5y agowhen they say >I watched those articulate, audacious, composed people talk about how they were building robots that would eat trash and turn it into oxygen, or whatever that 'whatever' makes me suspect that they never actually watched a Ted Talk about trash eating robots so >, and I felt hopeful about the future. But the trash-eating robots never arrived. Seems sort of unfair. I'm pretty sure some of the stuff that I've seen Ted talks about has progressed significantly, to talk about something that people working on arriving, and to be complaining about a pandemic fighting idea as not having succeeded six years after it was being discussed seems to be the province of someone not familiar with getting things done on a big scale in the real world.
- camillomiller 5y agoWell, the people that talk at TED never mention that the idea they claim to be behind the corner could actually be years and million of dollars of investments away, and therefore has a very high chance of never materializing.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agothe original TED talks I saw had people in the audience I felt were reasonably able to understand how much investment would be needed to achieve a particular idea.
- camillomiller 5y agoThen they started uploading the talks to YouTube
- bryanrasmussen 5y agowell in our present world potentially everything communicated has a global audience, but it would seem a losing strategy to try to make every prerequisite of every idea understood by everyone who might ever encounter your communication because you would never get to the idea itself but instead be stuck in one of those silly comedy routines where someone says start at the beginning and the protagonist says "so, first I was born..." on edit: in other words, just because something might end up uploaded to YouTube there's no obligation to dumb it down.