15 ms·
There Is a Much Larger Problem Than the Great Resignation
- michaelrhansen 5y agoI am sure someone already said it but, bus driver / janitor? The age can’t be higher bc they CAN’T AFFORD to retire or leave their jobs. They have been doing it forever and likely depend on more years to solidify a pension.
- newbie789 5y ago
- trhway 5y ago>Real estate agents: 49.1 years old automation/online will change it a lot once the older generations of agents and clients leave the scene. > Automotive mechanics: 47.4 years old EVs need them less. Also dealership model got to go. > Bus/Shuttle drivers: 55.6 years old Autonomous. > Housekeeping/Janitorial: 50.1 years old > Home health aides: 47.2 years old for both - immigration and automation. >Electrical trades: 46.8 years old given the low efficiency of the labor here and the high cost of it the area seems to be ready for technological disruption, though honestly i have hard time imagining anything feasible short of human level robot.
- plugger 5y ago>Real estate agents: 49.1 years old automation/online will change it a lot once the older generations of agents and clients leave the scene. IDK about that. I'm a pretty online person but I don't think I would have mortgaged roughly half a million dollars in my name on an online ad alone. I distinctly remember being very excited about a house when were looking to buy only to realise it was hobbit sized in real life. It's pretty hard to know that based off photos alone. > EVs need them less. Also dealership model got to go. Tesla has notorious build quality. Batteries need replacing. > Autonomous. No > for both - immigration and automation. damn, that's cold on multiple levels
- wombatpm 5y agoAnd Technology. Used to be you needed to know how to solder pipe to work on plumbing. Now with the PEX systems, you push on connections and you are done. Gave serious thought to redoing my father's house in PEX. Then I learned that mice love the plastic. For a house in the woods, that made me stay with copper.
- f6v 5y ago> for both - immigration Yes, let some county train those guys and we’ll just get them for free.
- cbg0 5y agoFree? You still have your own citizens that will need a job.
- bagacrap 5y agoIn my experience, real estate is often a second or third career. The barrier to entry is very low, the potential pay is very high (also potential for very low pay, but the high ceiling attracts those who feel they're playing catch up), and in the job is all about getting strangers to trust you, which is easier if you're older. For all these reasons people seem to like coming to it relatively late in life.
- smsm42 5y agoFor real estate, don't expect automation change anything for the next couple of decades. Yes, all the goodies like online forms, video tours, etc. are already there and RE agents are using them all the time. But it's not the bulk of the work, it's helping people to find what they need at the price they need, and that's much harder to automate. There's a lot of local and domain specific knowledge there that is very hard to capture. As for manual trades like electrical or plumbing - there's nothing even close to "technological disruption" happening there, in fact, if anything, it's going backwards - with time, the gadgets we have become more complex, the regulations pile on, the infrastructure ages, and it becomes harder and harder to do those jobs. And there's absolutely no signs any automation is even on the horizon there.
- strken 5y agoDeclining birth rate and older workers who can't afford to retire likely play a big role.
- kelnos 5y agoI was thinking the latter: I know a lot of people whose parents are older than 65 and are still working. Some of them even by choice, not financial necessity.
- dleslie 5y agoI'd like to point out that the problem is being discussed, and the problem isn't unique to the USA; but I'll agree that the discussion is mostly on the fringes of academia and the more esoteric geeky channels on YouTube. Anyhow, have a look at a number of mini documentaries on it: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=demographics+crisis https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=demographics+cr...
- jdlshore 5y agoThe article is basically a rah-rah piece for working in the trades (electrician, general laborer, etc.). It complains that the author’s fellow millennials went for college education and white collar jobs rather than blue collar, and now the workers are disproportionally old on average. The author is in construction management, so I take their comments with a grain of salt. Some people in the trades do well for themselves, but my understanding is that it’s also very hard on your body. It may be needed, but I’ll be encouraging my kids to pursue white-collar STEM jobs nonetheless.
- diob 5y agoYeah, it's one of those where a few make it out into management, but the rest end up with broken bodies.
- beebmam 5y agoIf labor is in short supply for blue collar jobs, shouldn't wages rise significantly? Doesn't make sense to me
- WalterBright 5y agoIt seems whenever I've had to hire someone to do electrical work, roofing work, water heater replacement, etc., the bill is fantastic. I watch them work, and it doesn't take that long or seem so difficult. Someone is making pots of money off of it. (I've watched the cable guy, the plumber, etc., at work. Next time I needed a similar job done, I did it myself. I even bought the same tools the cable guy was using. The guy replacing the water heater noted that it had a new pressure relief valve in it. I said yeah, it started leaking a month prior and I replaced it. He was shocked, and I said all it was was unscrewing the old one and putting it a new one with a bit of teflon tape. The whole job was $27, for the new valve from Amazon. I'm pretty good at sweating pipes, too!)
- skinkestek 5y agoA friend of mine who has done well for himself in retail and later real estate said at one point that if he were to start over he'd consider plumbing: Getting a good plumber in his area was hard so those who were could both be picky and expensive. Of my other close friends friends those who did best so far did by doing well in sales (graduating to running their own), blue collar mechanic (team lead -> manager -> get some spre time, starts investing and building his own) and a number of people going the carpentry to real estate route. One of those who has done well has gone via college/university.
- tasha0663 5y ago> Mechanics, electricians, stonemasons, general laborers: these are all trades that allow the world to keep on humming. We can’t rely on the older half of Gen X and the younger half of the boomers to build everything for everyone in perpetuity. Another thing Gen Y got handed to them: the removal of shop classes.
- wtfpost 5y ago
- paxys 5y agoThere's a long line of young people who would love to get into the trades or other professions mentioned in the article. What the author didn't mention is that all of them also have a huge amount of gatekeeping that keeps younger workers either miserable or out entirely. All the money in these seemingly lucrative professions is going to older workers with seniority while young people who join are doing the toughest, shittiest jobs and still struggling to survive. Licensing organizations have become cartels that artificially restrict supply to increase profits for existing members. There's no wonder young people are choosing to look elsewhere.
- luka-birsa 5y agoI fully agree that the author of the piece should volunteer for a low paid job of a janitor. They are becoming the elderly population, if somebody doesn't sacrifice themselves what oh what will happen? Sure, there is a lack of young workers for janitorial positions, but not everybody is a boomer with a home and family that can afford (let alone thrive) to be janitor. There are only three possible scenarios: either the wage goes up, the job gets automated (eg robots) or the job ceases to exist. Stop making op-ed pieces from your pedestal, screaming there is an issue, when you're directly responsible for the issue, hoping that somebody else will bail out your ass. Op is a lender and a banker, work with the companies you're financing to increase the wages and make the jobs attractive. Thought so.
- Apocryphon 5y agoTitle is clickbait. Article is about the aging of the American labor force, which is worth talking about, but has nothing to do with the present phenomenon of the Great Resignation.
- tompccs 5y agoHe's saying the workforce is being drained by people retiring, not resigning. Hence the headline.
- fdgsdfogijq 5y agoI think the younger generation, 22-27, has caught on to what a scam working is. By that, they fully understand that getting an office job and a mortgage means they will be chained to a desk with little chance at getting rich or escaping that life. I am a bit older, but have been seeing this mentality all over the place on the internet, but also in the real world. Its everywhere, young people trying to hustle money through odd job sales, youtube channels, online ecommerce. Whatever they can do to not get started on a career. And its completely rational, money printing has destroyed the value of the dollar, real estate is too expensive, and corporations extract too much value from their workers. An even more interesting point is the loss of status of having a good job when young. There is absolutely no shame, and its even cheered on to not be working a serious job. Making 200k at 24 is impressive to no one, and is instead met with disdain, "why spend your life working"
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- whateveracct 5y agoMaking 200k at 24 is a sweet deal tho..
- musha68k 5y agoI’m not an economist but afaik if minimum wage would have kept pace with productivity it would be at USD ~50k at this point. So if we talk about skilled labour of any sort USD 200k would be somewhat normal across industries.
- thow-58d4e8b 5y agoUS minimum wage reached $1/hour in 1956, or $10.25/h in 2021 dollars Since 1956, inflation adjusted GDP per capita increased by +218% All things equal, this would mean ~$66k / year for a 9-to-5 job paying minimum wage
- trabant00 5y ago
- gtsop 5y agoIsn't it funny that the piece presents a sense of socital need to have some people work in some particular jobs? It's as if the invisible hand of the market doesn't handle this corner case (esle why would one appeal to the will of some indoviduals)... It's as if there needs to be some dose of central planning for the economy that involves everyone... Hmm... Hmm.. scratches head
- ivalm 5y agoOr it could be that the article is… wrong.
- alexb_ 5y agoWhat model are you trying to talk about? What "central planning" do you think would improve society, somehow magically without any central corruption that comes with said central planning...
- tompccs 5y agoThis problem _is_ a result of central planning. Government backed loans have over inflated the price of degrees and created an oversupply of graduates with little attention paid to the skills employers actually want. In a free market kids would have to finance their careers with bank loans, and I can guarantee they would not lend you 6 figures to study Fine Arts.
- xtracto 5y agoThis is a very good take. If the government or some non-profit entity wants to fund fine arts, they should do it through scholarships. They are not professions for which they should expect repayment of loans...
- gtsop 5y agoListen to yourself. Government back loans inflate price of degrees? Is that some sort of unescapable physics here or do the corporate parasites increase the price of degrees because their friends in government are backing up the loans? Dont distort reallity Also, the current form of government is in no shape or form "central planning".
- goldnugget92 5y agoThe real 'problem' is the economy. Young folks are fed up of working 60 hour work weeks while their wages decrease (compared to inflation) and their rent increase (thanks to inflation). Any sensible young adult realizes that owning a home is impossible and affording children is improbable.
- kennywinker 5y agoThis article is unhinged. > Now once you’ve blown $100,000 or more on your education, it’s only natural to feel that you shouldn’t have to work a “manual” job. People who have sunk 100k into their education feel they need a job that pays well enough to pay down their debt. After four years of school and 100k debt what are you supposed to do, borrow another 30k and go back to school to get a plumbing certificate? Manual jobs that pay well also need years of school or apprenticing. I tuned out after that… if you don’t understand people well enough to see that I don’t think your opinion counts for much.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> After four years of school and 100k debt what are you supposed to do, borrow another 30k and go back to school to get a plumbing certificate? No point going to extremes. It's not unhinged, and plumber wasn't the only job listed. Imagine instead of being told you should go to uni, and feel like a failure if you didn't get in/couldn't afford it, you were also told that at 16 becoming a plumber is a great career and you started an apprenticeship at 16 and were fully qualified with no debt by 25. That's the idea behind the article (although with various jobs). Not exactly unhinged.
- kennywinker 5y agoI have no problem with more respect being paid to trades. I have a problem with blaming people for doing the thing you’re supposed to do to succeed. Until good jobs stop generally requiring a degree, college will always be an enticing gamble on your future - one that from an individual standpoint makes sense to go for (for most people). On a societal level, it’d be great to offer people other bets they can make, like apprenticeship programs, and make those bets more appealing (both financially and in their societal respectability)
- robertlagrant 5y agoThe article isn't blaming them. It's blaming the people who gave then that mentality.
- deleted 5y ago
- modriano 5y agoIf only there was some way for markets to attract more suppliers when demand outstrips supply. But alas, short of increasing the price of scarce resources, I don't see any way to avoid catastrophe.
- trabant00 5y agoIt's the same problem in EU as well. But it's a lot more complicated than "everybody wants to go to college". That's just an effect of economic and social causes. Money being thrown in ridiculous amounts in the tech bubble makes the choice seem like a no-brainer. Media aggressively pushes the narrative that digital is the future and we'll all eat bits and put a roof over our head with bytes in the near future. People believe AI and robots taking over physical jobs is just around the corner. And the financial digital bureaucrats who do the sharing take the lions share for themselves so of course everybody wants to join that league. Unless governments intervene to stop this sick trends the west will end up even more unable to provide its basic physical needs - food, shelter, energy, clothes, etc. But the governments are made up of bureaucrats who live in a bubble isolated from physical trades which they think are to be performed exclusively by low class slave-like individuals. And it works for a while, first with local poor classes, then with immigrants, but it crashes at some point, or at least it did historically. Could last centuries, decades or years.
- arpa 5y agoOld man yells at cloud. Younger people don't want to do jobs their parents/grandparents perceived as lesser and told them to avoid by going to college. Now they make a surprised pikachu face: janitors are generally old! All your own damn fault, boomer. All your own damn fault.
- lambdasquirrel 5y agoThe stuff in the beginning of the article, is rather glossed over. Stuff like the bubbles and the economy, and the crippling national debt, you can't just ignore that and then wonder why kids have been told that we need a college degree (and then we believe it). The reality is that between our deficit spending and the various bubbles in the economy, our younger generations (i.e. most of us 45 and under) will not have an easy path to retirement, if we ever can at all, and that's even assuming that you get a nice FANG job (unless both partners have one). There is simply no easy way through e.g. homeownership that doesn't seriously mess with our economic mobility, for the vast majority of us. There isn't really a way to financial security. And that is why most folks aren't opting for trade jobs. In the end, the folks with the trade jobs probably don't end up worse off than the folks with the college degrees, simply because college was so expensive. Or at least that's my take living in the Bay Area where e.g. construction workers get paid decently. So, everyone's kind of a little screwed, no matter what they did. Some of us who were lucky enough to e.g. get into tech before it got big are at least comfortable, but that's not that many of us. I don't think that e.g. going back to a gold standard would necessarily fix the problem of deficit spending. There've been many rulers in past history who inflated their currencies even though they were ostensibly fixed to some standard. If we want change, we need to start caring about economics – progressives including. And not just the populist stuff. In some other countries (like cough Germany cough) they are terrified of things like inflation, and for good reason. It's not to say that the German model would work for the U.S., but some of those sensibilities would at least have mitigated the asset bubbles that we're in in the U.S. In some ways we're victims of our own success. If the U.S. weren't successful in the past, then there wouldn't have been this idea that we could deficit spend to wage wars, and then deficit spend to cover the infrastructure gaps that we should've been paying attention to instead of bombing places that probably would've been better taken care of with more peaceful means. The countries in Europe didn't have the luxury of spending so big in these last few generations. The Euro still isn't quite the reserve currency the dollar is. But that's also probably why the rent in Paris or Berlin is less than the rent in New York or San Francisco. You pump all that money out over so many years, and it's going to have to end up somewhere. And that's why e.g. stuff like trade jobs don't look attractive enough.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago
- kodemager 5y agoIs the USAs debt really “crippling”? It’s enormous and looks dangerous on a graph, but if the country wanted to, it could pay it off in a couple of hard years considering it’s “only” around 100% of its GDP. Hardly crippling in any real economic sense when you zoom out to the nationwide macro level. Are millennials less productive than previous generations? In my country, we sure aren’t. We’re building more things and we’re building them faster, more efficient and with higher profits than ever before. Not just “creator” businesses, in my city alone we have torn down and build new buildings at such a pace that the previous two years of covid alone have seen more “work building houses” jobs (sorry my English isn’t up to task, construction jobs?” than we did in the entirety of the 80-90’s combined… take that gen X! (Or something). A lot of millennials went and got themselves a higher education in my country. Probably even more so than in the USA because in Denmark you can get any university degree you qualify for while being paid to study, since we handle that stuff collectively and through taxes to give everyone equal opportunity. Has the fact that we too scorned craftsmanship professions throughout the 90ies and 00s has a negative impact? Sure. Are millennials who went to university migrating to become plumbers; electricians and so on? Absolutely. The real difference between my millennial generation and my parents generation is what we are paid for our efforts. I work a high paying job, I work a second job as an external examiner for CS students which twice-four times a year pays me an extra months worth of my primary job as salary. Yet to see the same wealth increase my parents saw from simply owning a house, I’ll need to do some hardcore investment and saving, or hope that real estate continues rising (which it won’t). My parents saw their house increase from 200k to 4 million Danish KR. I do own my own apartment, and it is in an area that’s fairly sure to increase in value, but to see the same increase, it would need to go from 3 million to around 50 million. Adjusting for inflation, a realistic estimate will be that I can sell it for maybe 6 million if I’m lucky. So despite being more productive, more efficient and more financially great for the over all economy, I will benefit less than my parents did. Not only that, but they got to retire at 60, I currently get to do so at 73 unless I pay for all of the pre-73 years myself. Should you loathe your own generation like the author does? Fuck no. Try to understand them instead and you may just realise why people are fed up with wages that haven’t increased without getting eaten by inflation for 30 some years. I’m lucky enough that I can chose and pick where I work, I can’t image how not being able to do so as a millennial or below must frustrate.
- noduerme 5y agoWhat's "up" isn't strictly generational, but a question of who's fallen into a black hole where they waste their time on social media and have no work ethic because they've never felt the slightest need or pressure to scrub toilets or bus tables. I'm thankful to be from a generation where we had to do grunt work, from well before 16, and where friends were people you hung out with in real life when your job was done. What we're really seeing is the halo effect of pampering and coddling of kids - via helicopter parenting in the '00s and then social media complaints about life going forward. This is different in a fundamental way: If anyone had complained they were too good to do hard work in the '90s, you would have risked being seen as an elite rich snob. In fact a lot of my friends rejected college and went into trades or trucking because it was "HONEST WORK"... because they were embarrassed to be the kind of lazy people who would put on a tie and sit at a desk. I always thought that was a little stupid and selling themselves short, but it was at least an honest emotional response to the idea of people who seemed to sit on their ass all day and make money by doing nothing. What's changed here is that the entire basic concept of that - the conceit that led to it - still revolved around an idea that making money was essential to having a complete life. That's been obliterated by a tidal wave of political viewpoints you're supposed to adopt about capitalism and labor, which you can spend your time scrolling through and parroting on Twitter while they sell you ads to spend (presumably your parents') hard-earned cold-eyed capitalist money on toys, instead of facing the reality of showing up for a job that isn't "good enough for you". The boomers did a real bad job of raising their kids.
- secondaryacct 5y agoIm at an age when people talk of my age group like that, and my age group talk of young adults like that. I started working at 14 carrying furnitures on the weekend and im a pampered millenial :D In fact, I read a little essay wrote during the 18th century by a grumpy old guy that, if modernized a little bit, could pass for your little essay. I think your reaction is an effect of aging more than an objective view of the world. It's probably very similar to what a pre WWII adult would say of the pampered boomers born around the 40s: children are treasured by their parents, fathers want their child to surpass them and parents are disappointed by the new path their offsprings carved, on average. Basically, your comment is as useless to trigger change in the youth as it is interesting to study aging. Instead of wondering how to whip the youth into aging faster, I d ask you: how to comfort the elders into aging slower ?
- PicassoCTs 5y agoDo tell. Well, this is when a whole generation develops "Hacker-Mentality". Do not brute force your way into prosperity, instead do it like the upper-crust, by parasiting away on the ever fewer hard-working idiots below. When even the fleas have fleas and the last dog dies, we will find out whether one can eat business majors. We will also have gone full circle.
- tpoacher 5y agoClickbait. Again.
- cbogie 5y agoi was asked by my parents, “do you want to dig ditches or collect garbage? no? go to college.” so i did, majored in whatever, had a career in tech doing whatever, and ever since the pandemic i’ve found a lot of fulfillment helping drive trucks filled with construction debris to the transfer station. go figure.
- derobert 5y agoErrr, we're off to a good start! > "The population under 16 (not working) and population over 65 (more likely to be retired) are roughly equivalent right now, which means our workforce age should hew pretty close to our overall median age." Yeah, except: 1. Many in the 65+ group are working. So you can't cancel that out with the under-16 crowd where basically none work (and it is—with a few exceptions—illegal for them to work, especially the younger ones). 2. Many in the 16–24 range aren't working, because they're full-time students. Especially the 16–18 crowd. So you'd expect the median worker to be older than the median person.
- ultrasaurus 5y agoAgreed, looking at https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-particip... it seems like it's just the media age of workers. There are almost as high a % of 65+ workers as 16-19 and more 45-54 year olds than 20-24. And 10% of the 75+ year olds are working, I sincerely doubt we have 10%+ participation in the <6 year old bracket. Overall it looks like a demographic shift of more people going to school for longer (which is well known) and fewer students working.
- lucas_membrane 5y agoSo sad this has all come to prevail as it seems like all businesses are cast in the mold developed my Walmart and Milton Friedman, obsessed with maximizing stock price, minimizing costs, and forever squeezing their own workers when they cannot be jettisoned. The ironic reason it is sad is that just as most workers and potential workers are now way below average in income and upward mobility, inequality between businesses is similarly casting a dismal shadow on the prospect of prosperity for most enterprises. The single-winner phenomenon and the emergence of dominant firms in so many sectors has led to a situation where the typical start-up or median mature firm now looks forward to going out of business (being acquired) on terms of its own choosing; the mortality rate among venerable but average firms is high, and these regrettable conditions convince firms to follow the very strategies that cause the conditions.
- RickJWagner 5y ago"The world needs ditch diggers, too." - Judge Smails Seriously. The world needs mechanics, electricians, etc. We need people who perform these valuable jobs. They don't need degrees. The problem is that too many people take the loans and go to college, when they really aren't going to find a degree-requiring job after. This is the problem-- unmet expectations after graduation. These poor folks have borrowed and spent, then won't get the jobs to pay off the loans. It's not your fault, and not mine. Taxpayers shouldn't bail them out. There needs to be more warning about the risks/reward.
- spicyusername 5y agoSupply and demand will easily solve this problem once demand for those trades increases. Eventually the pay will rise to a level that makes the physical trade-off of working those professions worth it for more people.
- agumonkey 5y agoThe grade inflation and college promotion happened in other countries. It was a naive political progressive trick that failed.