27 ms·
Wait. I'm not letting anyone off the hook for not knowing the above if they put $5 into something, let alone $500k. But even as a coder and someone who was deep
by noduerme 5y ago
Wait. I'm not letting anyone off the hook for not knowing the above if they put $5 into something, let alone $500k. But even as a coder and someone who was deeply involved in crypto at one point (2011) I find it hard to make heads or tails of wtf this means. All I hear are a lot of acronyms and bizarre edge cases upon edge cases. It sounds like those arguments you'd hear between kids in junior high over magic cards or pogs or something. If this is the level of magical knowledge required to deal with these tokens, it sure seems like a sucker's market.
- footlose_3815 5y ago[dead]
- ALittleLight 5y agoThis is one thing that really confuses me about crypto. Whenever I've worked on a website there is an underlying idea that things need to be simple and intuitive because users aren't going to struggle to figure out how to use your site - they'll just bounce. It's hard to reconcile my experiences with trying to get users to understand and use relatively simple things with the inscrutable nature of the crypto space. Crypto is overflowing with unwieldy acronyms and punishing rakes to step on. And yet, people are putting massive amounts of money into this?
- RaiausderDose 5y agoI would not really call a "one way only exchange contract" magical knowledge.
- afidrya 5y agoIn simple words, he should have called a smart contract's function which would withdraw his tokens and send real ETH to his address. Instead, he sent tokens to smart contract's address and they will stay there forever, not associated with any account. This complexity should be abstracted away by wallet's UI. Users don't have to call APIs directly. Also, this whole situation could be prevented by trying to send a smaller amount first.
- noduerme 5y agoI've written middleware APIs for accepting currency in carts and casinos that interfaced with / polled bitcoind and other daemons. Why on earth would this person be calling APIs directly, and why would the daemon not just reject the transaction if it's an unexpected kind of token? Or if he added funds to the contract why not be able to remove them to the same address? I never dealt with smart contracts but even allowing this to happen without an error seems like a crazy, terrible design.
- jazzyjackson 5y agofrom the reddit comments, similar question, apparently every instruction adds gas fees to running the contract, so if you're going to use the contract a lot, you leave out any kind of validation. >> Wow why didn't the contract creators think this through and block requests to the contract > Because adding that check would increase the cost of every user transaction. All AMM swaps would be done with WETH so it’s the right call to not have it in there
- XorNot 5y agoI really can't think of an expression other then "lol" to sum up my response here for just how incredibly stupid this is, as a "platform of the future". A design which actively discourages robust programming and error handling in financial software. Wow.
- ljm 5y agoIt's like a libertarian utopia. Literally everything is an individual responsibility with no wider recourse. Want validation? Other people don't want to pay for stuff they're not validating... so it's on you to be careful. Accidentally fuck up? Not our problem, that's on you for not calling the right API. Want your money back? We're not paying money to cover for other people's mistakes. You're on your own bud.
- zo1 5y agoAgreed. Some people are super careful, like myself, when transferring money between personal (normal bank) accounts I always test with a small amount. Even if the bigger amount is like $200. And that's after triple checking the account number before clicking transfer. I can't imagine what I'd be doing with these exotic crypto accounts and smart contracts.
- sshine 5y agoWhen I do money transfers on bank accounts, I read the 10 digits 4-5 times. If the person that I'm transfering to is in the room, I ask them to read aloud their account number as I follow. The fact that you have to get 10 digits right and that a typo can result in sending the money off somewhere unknown, disturbs me a lot. It's amazing how cryptocurrencies mimicked that part about existing digital money to perfection. Give me a QR code, or wire my wallet up with an address book.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoAccount numbers have checksums. An „off by one“ typo cannot occur.
- hashimotonomora 5y agoDo you know how account numbers work in every bank in every country?
- zo1 5y agoI wouldn't trust all banks to have such things in their account numbers. Especially in the tech age where they seem to think they're beyond physical keyboard typos and OCR errors.
- ciupicri 5y agoWhat are you talking about? IBAN account numbers have not one, but two digit checksums.
- Gareth321 5y agoThis is indeed the level of knowledge required for even just transferring ETH to another person/wallet. There are different kinds of ETH, and if you transfer to the wrong kind of wallet, you lose everything. Despite the protestations of advocates, this kind of thing is a major hurdle to adoption.
- xtracto 5y agoI'm a cryptocurrencies/blockchain advocate in general but this wETH/BnbEth/sETH/stETH and similar crap is just crazy and stupid.
- capableweb 5y agoIt's not really edge bases, it's how contracts works, and how this contract works. There is nothing magical here. It's a bit like avoiding the checksums that IBAN has, and then complaining that IBAN is broken. Most people interact with WETH via UIs, but for some reason this user chose not to, and got severely burned because of it. Things that require expertise usually requires one to know acronyms and how things works underneath, the cryptocurrency space is no different. Now I don't know what you do for a living, but it certainly isn't cryptocurrencies. I'm sure there are more industries you don't work with on a day-to-day basis, and when people who are in those industries talk with each other on a technical level, you'll see the same amount of jargon. That's just part of expertise in a subject. For example, two of my friends are chemists, and sometimes they talk chemistry stuff when we're having dinners and stuff. Of course I don't understand most of the stuff they are saying, but I'm not gonna claim "chemistry" is "magical knowledge" just because I don't understand it, so I'm not sure why you would about cryptocurrencies.
- kuhewa 5y agoCurrencies don't come with a prerequisite of intimate knowledge of industrial jargon that requires use on a daily basis to be proficient enough in to not lose everything.
- nicbou 5y agoI've been paying attention to this whole thing for a few years, and I still can't tell how I could send coins to a friend if I had them.
- noduerme 5y agoAlso, chemistry sets come with a lot of graphic warnings.
- aniforprez 5y agoDo we need a "hot coffee is hot" warning label on every crypto transaction? And yes I'm aware the lady in the case suffered and it's terrible. I'm just being facetious
- t8e56vd4ih 5y ago"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." but yes, I find myself thinking the same with many things. especially when the disciples seem irritatingly proud of their "knowledge" which actually is just a collection of arbitrary and anti intuitive rules.
- e12e 5y agoPerhaps it's time to coin (sorry) a new phrase: "Any sufficiently advanced smart contract system is indistinguishable from Magic the Gathering (tm)."
- erikbye 5y ago
- sanderjd 5y agoI think this is a symptom of the general problem of calling everything "cryptocurrency", which anchors people on the mental model of Bitcoin. You were involved in "cryptocurrency" 2011 when everything was Bitcoin or essentially just a fork of Bitcoin and all of the stuff in the comment you replied to was a few years away from existing. I think it would be like writing "applications" in the early 90s in Visual Basic and then reading something about web applications and saying "I was involved in applications and none of this makes sense to me". That's because it's a different domain, with some similarities but many differences. Edit: Changed "crypto" to "cryptocurrency" to differentiate from a different general problem with how the shorthand already had a different meaning.
- throw0101a 5y ago> I think this is a symptom of the general problem of calling everything "crypto", which anchors people on the mental model of Bitcoin. Or those of us who immediately think of AES, RSA, and Diffie–Hellman. Anyone around tech in the 1990s may also remember: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars
- tata71 5y agoMany of the same teams in this round.
- sanderjd 5y agoRight you are. I just edited to differentiate from this other general problem with the nomenclature in the space. I actually think this one leads to less confusion though, because the people who are familiar with "crypto" vis cryptography universally have enough expertise to differentiate it from "crypto" vis cryptocurrency. Whereas I would estimate that at least 99% of people who have heard of both Bitcoin and Ethereum have no idea that there are important differences in their capabilities and technology. All the smart but non-technical people I know or read commentary from talk about cryptocurrency as a single thing, where that thing is just different flavors of Bitcoin.
- 5y ago
- rco8786 5y agoAgreed this is all nonsensical
- hedora 5y agoFrom what I can tell, the underlying issue is that everything is spaghetti code written in a dynamically typed language. Ignoring that, it's nuts that the best practice is "send a little money, and see if it works". Apparently they don't even have a working transaction simulator that just runs the relevant logic on your laptop so you can see what it will do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kylebenzle 5y agoHow can you be so naive about this topic yet confident enough to add your 2 cents? There are been test nets from day one and running one yourself is trivial.
- anthonygd 5y agoRealistically if you just want to try out someone else's contract in a safe environment, the existence of the test nets is entirely irrelevant. The contract is going to be at a different address, all the accounts involved are entirely different, the state of the contract is different. Even proving a contract at one address is the same as the contract at another address is non-trivial. Pretending the existence of a test net proves anything is a lot like pretending the availability of source for your OS, compiler and dependency stack proves something. Maybe possibly for a professional with unlimited time, but that's it.
- Zababa 5y ago> Ignoring that, it's nuts that the best practice is "send a little money, and see if it works". That's what I did the first time I did a bank transfer between two of my banks accounts. Maybe that's just me being paranoid but when sending money I like to test it first.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoThe underlying issue is that everyone wants to make money. And the quickest way to make money in crypto is to create a new coin, token, smart contract, NFT, web3, whatever. Thus ever increasing complexity.
- hogrider 5y agoSame. That top reddit comment that crypto is not ready yet is absolutely right. This feels like a small bu2ow er trting to digitalize their whole operation on 1978 micro computers and getting burned for it.
- norswap 5y agoThat's disingenuous. These are really basic concepts in the space (where space = smart contract blockchains). If you're going to slush a cool half mil around, you should really have absolutely basic litteracy of how this stuff works -- just how you should have the same litteracy about the banking system if you're going to half a mil there too. Or hire people who do.
- magicjosh 5y ago> It sounds like those arguments you'd hear between kids in junior high over magic cards or pogs or something. "Just as trying to think up startup ideas tends to produce bad ones, working on things that could be dismissed as "toys" often produces good ones. When something is described as a toy, that means it has everything an idea needs except being important. It's cool; users love it; it just doesn't matter." From http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html