6 ms·
The US already identified a plausible site but for mostly political reasons, it was rejected and now most waste is stored in several pre-existing locations in t
by dekhn 5y ago
The US already identified a plausible site but for mostly political reasons, it was rejected and now most waste is stored in several pre-existing locations in the country and the rest is stored onsite at existing reactors. Both of those options are fairly risky compared to the planned repository but are more politically expedient.
It seems not unreasonable to expect many countries will follow Sweden and Finland and actually proceed with burial, and eventually some catastrophe in the US (pig farm manure pit wall breaks, sweeps plant's storage tanks into a major river) will make Yucca a possibility again. Or, we coiuld just give Nevada $50B and ask them to take on the risk for the next 100kyears.
- sidewndr46 5y agoIt's entirely possible that Finland and other countries are positioning themselves to become the biggest "exporter" of nuclear waste disposal. There are plenty of countries around the world with no actual plan for waste disposal, including the US. If Finland is willing to accept the risk in exchange for a certain amount of financial compensation, then it seems likely wealthy countries would make that choice.
- dekhn 5y agoThat's a fascinating concept. Do the people of Finland get a direct vote on that, and can they change it in the future? I'd be wary of taking on such an enormous risk [edit: see terminology correction below] even if the probability of catastrophe is very low.
- admax88qqq 5y ago> enormous risk even if the probability of catastrophe is very low. That's not really how probability works. If the probability of catastrophie is low then it's not an enormous risk. Honestly I think the risk of nuclear storage is really low. Most challenges are focused om how to keep it safe for thousands of years. The next several hundred years are no problem.
- KMnO4 5y agoRisk = probability * loss So even though the probability is very very low, the loss (consequence) is extremely high (say an order of magnitude) which makes this a high risk.
- RealityVoid 5y agoWhat are the risks here more exactly? Yes, there is nuclear waste buried... sooooooo... what can happen?
- dekhn 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-time_nuclear_waste_warning_messages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-time_nuclear_waste_warnin... More seriously, there are a wide range of problems associated with long term waste storage, from known knowns to unknown unknowns. Some of the risks can't even be reasonably anticipated.
- admax88qqq 5y agoYou can claim unknown unknowns for literally anything and claim it's high risk as a result. There are unknown unknowns about 5G, therefore it's too risky to build and use.
- nicoburns 5y agoEven they were storing large volumes of waste, then I assume they'd be non-trivial risk during the transport before the waste was buried.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThe most obvious danger is ground water contamination. That already happened at some locations where mines where used as a temporary storage. Some have to be salvaged which will cost billions.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe potential loss here is not extremely high. Crack open a physics textbook. Waste can either be highly energetic or long lived. You can't pick both. And I think it's fair to say that unless they dump it down an active volcano it won't get spewed airborne Chernobyl style. Nuclear waste isn't particularly noteworthy compared to all sorts of other nasty chemicals that humanity stores in large volume.
- Maxion 5y agoThere's been no talk publicly about accepting nuclear waste from other countries. ONKALO is financed through fees gathered from electricity generated by nuclear energy in Finland. This facility is meant to hold Finnish spent nuclear fuel. I highly doubt Finland would accept fuel from other countries.
- Manuel_D 5y agoHow is spent fuel buried deep into bedrock "enormous risk"? I've read your thread and I still fail to see how this is anything but hyperbole. Even in the event of a container breach, the waste is buried under hundreds of meters of bedrock. What is the threat model for how this waste results in harm to society? Even if this uranium were somehow brought to the surface and dumped it into drinking water supplies, it would be detected. Drinking water is monitored for uranium, because naturally occurring uranium in grounder is sometimes above safe limits.
- pm90 5y agoNevada became politically important due to its Senator being the Majority Leader (Ie the leader of the US upper house, the Senate). With him gone (retired and recently, rip) I think it might be much easier to convince them. It’s such (excuse my language) bullshit. The facility is incredibly safe. It would be so much safer than leaving spent nuclear fuel on site all across the country. It’s unbelievable that there is resistance to it.
- datavirtue 5y agoPeople resist everything. Just ask for forgiveness.
- egeozcan 5y ago> People resist everything Perhaps it causes a positive bias in the natural selection or is the side effect of something that causes a positive bias?
- reedjosh 5y agoI'd generally agree with this mentality when individuals are trying to get something done, but definitely not when it's my government doing it.
- rurp 5y agoNevada is a swing state though, so it's going to have disproportionate national influence until that changes, which could be a long time. I'm not sure why the approach of giving the state piles of money in exchange for hosting the storage wasn't tried initially. Or maybe it was, but was downplayed enough that it never comes up. Nevada isn't a very populous state so billions of extra dollars would go pretty far. It has also been trying to diversify its economy for a while now, with pretty mediocre results.
- panzagl 5y agoNevada could pay a dividend like Alaska or New Mexico.
- godelski 5y agoI wouldn't call it risky. We can safely sit in top of the material for a few hundred years. Assuming we have no technological advancements in that time then yeah we should move to a collective long term storage. But the storage problem isn't nearly as difficult if you only plan for a hundred years and only concern yourself with the waste of a single plant (or a few).
- cameldrv 5y agoThe U.S. already operates a disposal site -- the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant in New Mexico. This is where all of those markers that say things like "This is not a place of honor" come from. It's just not accepting waste from commercial reactors for political reasons.
- surfsvammel 5y agoThe US plan, if I’m not mistaken, is for 10k years, not 100k.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> Or, we could just give Nevada $50B and ask them to take on the risk for the next 100kyears. I wonder what the reasonable risk-adjusted cost of burying this waste in Nevada would be. The odds of a failure are probably pretty low, and the odds of a failure that leeches into the water system in some significant dosage seems super low (how much of Nevada's water comes from deep reservoirs versus surface supplies and how integrated are these systems?). Also, how does that stack up against the death toll due to fossil fuels ("well we want to switch to renewables eventually" <- meanwhile people are still dying at a rate of tens or hundreds of thousands per year).
- pydry 5y ago>Also, how does that stack up against the death toll due to fossil fuels ("well we want to switch to renewables eventually" Took about ~4 years to build hornsea. Will end up being about ~20 to build hinkley point. For 2-3x the cost you get 80% load capacity factor rather than 60%. If you're in a hurry... that huge pile of money used to ~~keep nuclear skills and industry accessible to countries with nuclear arsenals~~ save the planet might be put to better use elsewhere.
- liketochill 5y agoWhere is the 80% number from? With nuclear you also get to choose when the power output is 100% and when you want to take an outage for maintenance.
- polishdude20 5y agoStoring above ground has benefits of being visible. You can inspect for damage, you can see that it's there every year. It never leaves society's kno ledge because it's out there.