11 ms·
Naomi Wu seems to upset a lot of people. She makes things, and was accused by the publisher of "Make" magazine of being a fake, with some guy doing the actual w
by Animats 5y ago
Naomi Wu seems to upset a lot of people. She makes things, and was accused by the publisher of "Make" magazine of being a fake, with some guy doing the actual work. She replied by posting long, detailed videos of her making stuff. An hour of cutting aluminum extrusions with a chop saw and putting together a frame. Soldering PC boards. Eventually, the guy apologized.
One of the useful things she's done is to put up lots of videos of her running around Shenzhen. There aren't enough ground-level videos of the working parts of Chinese cities. There's extensive coverage of Tokyo, by comparison. It's interesting to see the high-density housing blocks and street-level activity. (The "let's increase housing density" crowd from Strong Towns should watch those videos.) People who've met her report that she knows Shenzhen very well, down to the back alley level, where some unmarked door leads to an important factory. She's toured the electronics markets of Huaqiangbei. (I miss the days when Silicon Valley had electronics parts stores.)
She's done some nice technical work. Her main thing is 3D printing, and she came up with the first angled 3D printer that worked reliably. The print head moves in a plane 45 degrees from vertical, and the base surface is a belt, which advances the workpiece one layer at a time. So it can produce objects continuously, or very long objects if you add support rollers. Others had made prototypes of such machines, but the properties of the belt and print head are touchy to make that work right. She got it all working, and it's now a product, with her picture on the box.
At various times she's pushed on GPL compliance, mask quality, and other issues of interest to the tech community.
She wears skimpy outfits sometimes. So what? That's most of Instagram. Unlike most Instagrammers, Wu has something original to say. Sometimes with a biting wit. I gather that it's more biting in Cantonese.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 5y agoI don't really support to ban anything that could be seen as sexual, but if you put it out, some people will always judge you on that merit. It will also net you attention and can overshadow your other feats. Should she be condemned for that? I don't think so. But the engineering feats alone will never be the focus as a consequence.
- badRNG 5y ago>but if you put it out, some people will always judge you on that merit. It will also net you attention and can overshadow your other feats. This is actually a common apologetic in defense of Burqas and similar objects of "modesty" for women.
- rob74 5y agoOf course, once you are at the stage of Burqas, any feats that women may achieve will be strictly limited to their household...
- alfiedotwtf 5y ago> some people will always judge you on that Guess what - some people will judge, or even attack, just because she was a woman. Another example is Australia's political climate the past two days. Naomi is a cool person, and she should be celebrated for doing cool things regardless of how she looks.
- SexyCyborg 5y ago>But the engineering feats alone will never be the focus as a consequence. There's a line between "never be the focus" and "we will erase you". This sort of thing is constant- but I'll give you a recent example- NPR recently ran this story: https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1047691984/decades-after-polio-martha-is-among-the-last-to-still-rely-on-an-iron-lung-to-br https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1047691984/decades-after-poli... About an American lady who needed some parts for her iron lung and how no one would help her. Only the thing is, they knew I already had: https://youtu.be/4VKZTmTP7oY https://youtu.be/4VKZTmTP7oY I'd fabricated the collars in Shenzhen, mailed the first batch, revised them and needed someone on the US side to to the final fitting. Martha told them this, a quick search told them this, hundreds of people told them this- did NPR revise the story to correct the omission of "oh by the way this problem we were talking about was solved by this female engineer". No of course not. I mean, it's NPR, you think they are going to get smut on their fingers writing about someone who looks like me? Never going to happen. Then the Razer mask story, I was central to it and some outlets gave me credit: https://www.pcgamer.com/razer-rows-back-after-zephyr-face-mask-safety-rating-confusion/ https://www.pcgamer.com/razer-rows-back-after-zephyr-face-ma... Others like the Verge flatly refused to mention my involvement- even jumping through some pretty crazy hoops to avoid it: https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/10/22876303/razer-zephyr-mask-n95-grade-air-purifier-change-marketing https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/10/22876303/razer-zephyr-mas... Again, hundreds of people called them out. But they did the math and decided that the stigma of mentioning someone who looked like me was worse. That's just the last few months- this has been a constant for years. I fully Open Sourced the best selling 3D printer on the planet, have the first five Open Source Hardware Association certifications granted in China- which people said would never happen, have brought multiple Chinese companies into GPL compliance, I'm the only women to have brought a 3D printer to mass-market- a game changing design for small scale manufacturing- the list is long, but somehow, none of it is "appropriate" to cover- just because of how I look. We're well beyond- "does my appearance detract from my work". Of course it does. We're at "does my appearance justify not just complete erasure of my work but constant attempts to deplatform and defund me" I don't think it does.
- mike_h 5y agoMy favorite talent of hers is galvanizing people so crisply into “decent” vs “self-important and looking for an easy target on the internet”.
- Foobar8568 5y ago
- varjag 5y agoOh right, she has good command of English which is checks notes the most widely spoken language on the planet Earth. No way to learn decent English unless you are a communist party agent. That must be how I learned mine!
- Foobar8568 5y ago
- varjag 5y agoNever been to mainland but I've spent a month working on Taiwan. You ain't going to find perfect English among the sellers on Hsinchu street markets perhaps but many industry professionals have it as good as it gets. What kind of point is that really? Do you think they teach English especially well for CCP members or what? Or is it more along the lines that an attractive foreign female shouldn't be able to speak English well?
- Foobar8568 5y ago
- meheleventyone 5y agoJust shows how casually misogynist the world still is. Some of the replies here are pretty shocking
- _kulang 5y agoAs far as I thought, that’s why she does this, her technical skills and her appearance don’t align only if you have a preconceived notion about how she should look
- kragen 5y agoYeah, IIRC on Twitter she's pointed out that it's really common for rebellious teen girls to rebel by "dressing sexy", and for women in general to be interested in fashion, and she would really like those girls and women to feel welcome in technically innovative spaces; hopefully if I've gotten that wrong she'll chime in to correct me. Also, though, it isn't really practical for her to get her breast implants removed just because woke "feminists" at Google and NPR are uncomfortable with the sexualization of women's bodies.
- gurkendoktor 5y agoYet, when people make jokes about dongles it's also misogynist, because sexuality at the workplace makes women feel uneasy. From a European standpoint, the simpler explanation (in this particular case) is that the US tech scene is incredibly, fascinatingly prude. It feels like even HN users would rather post their DNA and a list of illegal drugs that helped them pass an exam before they'd talk about their sex lives, for better or for worse.
- blueflow 5y ago
- whybother1 5y ago
- chii 5y agoIt's because other people stir shit up with her as the topic, either for fun/trolling, or they truly feel she's somehow threatening (their masculinity and world-view).
- pdkl95 5y agoWhile some people certainly seem to subscribe to "feeling their masculinity/world-view is threatened" interpretation, the fundamental problem that q lot of people don't seem to understand is that the internet changed the mechanics of fame. The best explanation I've seen - and possibly the most important video on youtube - is "This Is Phil Fish"[1] by Innuendo Studios. It's not really about Phil Fish; it's about everyone who isn't Phil Fish acted when they decided he became "famous". In the past, being "on tv" or "in a band" or other traditional examples of fame required some amount of buying into fame. Becoming famous required media access that was controlled by gatekeepers. You had to work with those gatekeepers if you wanted to be "on tv" or whatever, and because you had to choose to participate, people often see the decision to become famous as also accepting some amount of responsibility to "act like famous people are supposed to act". This internet fundamentally changed the mechanics of fame, because the internet IS media access. Now it is possible to become famous - to become a "celebrity" with a "responsibility" to act in a certain way - simply by being yourself in your normal everyday life. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w
- blueflow 5y ago
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stavros 5y ago> She makes things, and was accused by the publisher of "Make" magazine of being a fake, with some guy doing the actual work. That's fucked up. Why would someone accuse anyone of being a fake, just because they didn't look a certain way? Detestable.
- bayindirh 5y agoThat event brought down "Make Magazine" a dozen notches permanently in my mind in an instant. I respect her a ton for doing what she's doing, and if I remember correctly, she had to install a very elaborate and advanced security system at her home to feel safe. Sad.
- numpad0 5y agoMake: is Make:. Once they set up an isolation ward for nerds away from main exhibit in Maker Faire Tokyo to keep unsightly EE/HAM nerds away from handsome Makers. They made huge contributions to their Maker movement and gave me $9 Pro Micros, and I’m thankful of it, but I won’t forget that they always are like that.
- kragen 5y agoProbably most of us reason from stereotypes a lot of the time. I'm ashamed to admit I've recommended not hiring a guy I interviewed for a sysadmin job basically because he showed up wearing a suit and tie.
- tromp 5y agoReview of the slanted 3D printer "Creality CR-30": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VvSbcUowlNU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VvSbcUowlNU
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jach 5y agoA user (I'll leave them unstated) deleted a reply with a metaphor along the lines of "what do you expect if someone wears a clown suit when speaking at a technical conference?" Well, here's her speaking at a tech conference, in "context-appropriate" attire that is neither skimpy nor a clown suit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mt1OLgGIqhc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mt1OLgGIqhc In "She wears skimpy outfits sometimes", sometimes is really the operative word.
- WesternWind 5y agoIf you have the skills, it generally shouldn't matter what clothes you wear. Even if you don't have the skills, it generally shouldn't matter what clothes you wear. Like don't strap knives to your arms, and do wear a good mask, but generally we spend a lot of time policing other folk's bodies and attire, and for what?
- albertzeyer 5y agoIt depends maybe on the circles you interact with, but in some circles, people are not taken seriously which try too much to adhere to the conservative business dress code by wearing a suite with tie. This is actually a common meme: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/fbwnd0/im_in_this_picture_and_i_dont_like_it/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/fbwnd0/im_... https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/ajthjb/this_is_how_programmers_dress/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/ajthjb/thi... https://www.quora.com/What-do-people-think-good-programmers-dress-like https://www.quora.com/What-do-people-think-good-programmers-... How developers dress really depends on the company and the culture there. E.g. in Germany in many of the conservative older companies, wearing a suite is mandatory, and esp also in all those consulting companies. Also in many of the privatized companies like Deutsche Post, Deutsche Bahn, etc. But then, in other more modern software companies, people would make fun of that. The idea that you must adhere to some clothing dress code rules is really against the open-minded principles of software developers.
- WesternWind 5y ago
- kragen 5y agoI wonder what fraction of people here commenting disapprovingly about her choice of wardrobe think YouTube should demonetize videos of bodybuilding competitions, male rock stars, or boxing. Because apparently those are super sexy, though I think the bodybuilding thing appeals to more gay men than to het women. Also apparently a lot of male gamer Youtubers are considered sexy, even though they don't have exaggerated secondary sexual characteristics like giant muscles, and I've never heard of them getting demonetized for it: https://ar.pinterest.com/madelineulatows/logan-paul-sexy/ https://ar.pinterest.com/madelineulatows/logan-paul-sexy/ https://ar.pinterest.com/ktatianalima203/rubius-sexy-3/ https://ar.pinterest.com/ktatianalima203/rubius-sexy-3/
- ausbah 5y ago
- aspaviento 5y agoI think you haven't heard about the new trend of naked yoga in youtube.
- seoulmetro 5y agoThis sounds like you don't understand nudity or context. Which are core principles to this discussion...
- richardfey 5y ago> The "let's increase housing density" crowd from Strong Towns should watch those videos. Perhaps there is a good balance that we can reach?
- Animats 5y agoShenzhen went from 30,000 to 16 million people in three decades without turning into a mess like Mumbai or Rio. That's impressive.
- caskstrength 5y ago> There's extensive coverage of Tokyo, by comparison. It's interesting to see the high-density housing blocks and street-level activity. (The "let's increase housing density" crowd from Strong Towns should watch those videos.) Hmm, visiting Tokyo (which is even better than watching videos) didn't make me change my opinions about high-density housing. Quite the opposite, in fact.
- torginus 5y agoWhy is it a problem that she employs people to help with her work? Putting out novel and high quality videos at a constant rate is hard. Despite a lot of popular youtubers giving off the vibe of being one-person shows, most employ production assistants and editors. Besides, (old) Top Gear was one of the most beloved shows of all time, which constantly featured segments where the Clarkson-Hammond-May trio was implied to make various contraptions, which were clearly made by the production staff. Not once did I feel like that it detracted from the enjoyment. So as long she puts out high quality content, no one should mind that what she does is 'movie magic' in part.
- kragen 5y agoHistorically though she's done her builds herself, and she's been careful to call out the exceptions where a friend wrote some firmware for her or something. Not sure about video editing, I think she does that herself too. I don't think it's accurate to accuse her of "movie magic".
- torginus 5y agoI have to admit I haven't checked out her recently, but I'm not accusing her of anything - I'm just saying that even if she delegates a part of her work (which is what all successful business people do) it is not a cause for condemnation.
- kragen 5y agoAside from the wankers, people don't watch her videos because she's a "successful business person", but because she's a maker or because she's demonstrating the capabilities of newly available machinery. The Make Magazine guy's erroneous accusation was that she wasn't really a maker, just a successful business person. He was wrong about that. That's the context in which it would be reasonable to read your comment as an accusation, and, as far as I know, a false one.
- torginus 5y ago
- junon 5y agoGreat summary. She's also one of the only people to help create more parts for someone living with an iron lung[0]. Unlike a lot of people, she seems to actually 'give a shit' about things happening in the world. Her "skimpy outfits" are part of lesbian culture. One of the lesbian archetypes she enjoys being a part of entails her clothing choices and physique. I don't think that's any different than other cultures. Her content was never branded for children anyway, I don't understand what the issue Youtube has. The crazy shit she's had said to her on social media makes me gobsmacked over and over again. You always hear people say they get these sorts of comments but she seems to get them a lot more, and a lot worse. It's really heartbreaking. I've learned a lot from her, enjoy her videos, and yeah. This is just another example of how broken Youtube and Google are. [0] https://archive.org/details/youtube-4VKZTmTP7oY https://archive.org/details/youtube-4VKZTmTP7oY
- JimDabell 5y agoDon’t forget about the year she spent asking Signal to put a warning in place for Android users that have third-party keyboards. Apparently an extremely common thing in China and something that totally undermines Signal’s security without people realising. Signal put the warning in, of course, after she got enough white men to repeat her request. Until the right people reported the problem, the only response she got was Moxie blocking her and dismissing the issue. I don’t see how that isn’t an operational vulnerability a mile wide for Signal: security problems go ignored if people from the wrong demographic report them.
- gompertz 5y ago>>Naomi Wu seems to upset a lot of people. You mean; seems to get upset by a lot of people.
- seoulmetro 5y agoAs someone who loves her videos, her physical appearance turns me off watching for any period of time. I would do the same if it were a half naked man showing me tech too. >so what? that's most of Instagram. I don't like watching the same physical appearances on places where they belong like TV, Movies or Instagram.... so no that's not "normal". If you merge making erotic cakes and cake baking on YouTube, expect a lot of cake baking lovers to not want to watch. It's just logic. It just feels forced and is an ugly stain on otherwise awesome videos. But I understand that others might enjoy it. Reminds me of the guy uploading math videos to a porn site, technically we should rate his work based on the math problem solving and teaching skills but you would be a fool to not recognise the problem of it being only reachable by being on a porn site.
- mbrodersen 5y agoIf you disagree with her looks then simply stop watching. Same for the people who try to stop her from doing what she does just because they don’t like how she looks. There is plenty of stuff out there I don’t like. But that doesn’t mean that it is OK to ban/stop them.