14 ms·
3.5%-5% increase in performance at more than double the wattage, for a chip that is not in consumers hands against a chip that basically hasn't changed and was
by dijit 5y ago
3.5%-5% increase in performance at more than double the wattage, for a chip that is not in consumers hands against a chip that basically hasn't changed and was released 14 months ago~
This is not the victory that the title implies.
It's also a _little_ bit funny that the i9 laptop was double the price, given people usually rant loudly about how expensive Apple computers are.
- chii 5y agothe fact is, apple hardware is not _that_ expensive relative to what you get for the money. Their supply chain is super optimized, and it's hard to beat them on price if a competitor decides to try (at the same quality that is).
- fartcannon 5y agoYeah but it's locked down, unupgradable future e-waste.
- crims0n 5y agoI would argue the opposite, still using my 2012 15” MacBook Pro… a decade later. Go to Walmart and look at the laptops on display, and tell me any of those are capable lasting near a decade.
- addicted 5y agoThat’s not true of the current Macs though. I still have a 2011 era MacBook that I can use, and was very pleasant to use until an OS update a couple of years ago. But that was because I was able to upgrade the RAM, the SSD, and replace the battery. None of those things are possible with macs from the last few years, so their longevity is much more likely to resemble phones than older macs.
- BoorishBears 5y agoThe secondary market simply doesn't agree with the weird obsession with calling Apple's hardware future e-waste just because you can't change out an SSD. Mac hardware holds value because it's well built, supported for a long time, has specs that are enough for a wide range of users... - For every power user running through battery cycles every day, there's people who just need a solid well built machine and won't feel the need to upgrade just because their machine gets less battery life, or a given IDE needs more RAM. Those people don't replace hardware because it's broken, they replace it because it feels old. Design wise, materials wise, etc. Not having crummy bloatware slowly accreting gigabytes of junk and a dozen extra startup items. Compare a sub $1000 M1 Air to any other sub $1000 laptop coming out today. You'd be incredibly hard pressed to find anything even half as well designed... that's how you get people to keep their hardware.
- vbezhenar 5y agoI bought Dell 3410 for $600 and upgraded it for another $200 to 16 GB/500 GB SSD. It's a perfect little beast. Air with those specs will be around $2000 in my country.
- nkellenicki 5y agoI bought my 2013 MacBook Pro with a 1TB SSD and 32GB of RAM, with the highest specced i7 at the time. I sold it last month to pick up a new 2021 MacBook Pro M1 Max. I bought it with 32GB RAM and a 1TB SSD because I don't need anymore, 8 years later. And the i7 I had still beat out last years base model on Geekbench.
- filmgirlcw 5y agoNot to take anything away from how long you got to use your computer, but you couldn’t get 32GB of RAM in an Apple laptop until 2018. You likely had 16GB of RAM in 2013 if you had a 15” retina MacBook Pro.
- nkellenicki 5y ago
- jeswin 5y agoI used a 2011 Core i7 Asus N53SV till last year - full hd and had 4 ddr3 slots. I was able to run the latest Linux, and the latest Windows on it. Apple meanwhile has dropped support for 2014 macbooks. There are apps which won't run on them today, and Apple will stop supporting Catalina this year.
- imwillofficial 5y agoTo act like your experience extrapolates out to the wider market is disingenuous at best.
- febrianrendak 5y agohmmm thinkpad?
- nickpeterson 5y agoSomeone will buy an old MacBook, good luck ebaying your old Lenovo…
- echelon 5y agoYou're underestimating the hobbyist Thinkpad community.
- nickpeterson 5y agoI’m not, I’m sure for every modder that puts a new motherboard and mech keyboard in, there are 100000 that just get pitched
- broodbucket 5y agoThey're also not purchased at the volumes that Macbooks are, I do think you're underestimating how well they hold their value. You picked an unfortunate laptop line to make your point, especially since this is in no way a recent phenomenon. I'm sure people chuck away their Macbooks instead of reselling them too.
- Jcowell 5y agoMore like put it in a drawer. I question the notion that laptops are thrown away as opposed to put in storage. Especially when they’re used for sensitive information and not normally wiped if they’re not used for resale.
- onphonenow 5y agoCompletely false. If you do any volume purchasing the resale value of old Acer laptop or asus ones is so bad they really do become w waste quickly. Folks w macs use them forever. And then resale market isMUCh better for apple
- acomjean 5y agoWith the cpu change I suspect os support to be dropped in a couple of years, and resale values to drop. My friend had a pretty expensive g5 PowerPC that wasn’t worth much and had an end of life much sooner than the hardware should have had.
- onphonenow 5y agoI'm curious how Apple's competitor Microsoft is handling ARM - I actually always thought Apple did a MUCH better transition / management of these types of tech variations. Can I really run everything windows runs on windows ARM offerings? Be good if MS has solved things this time around. Some of us still remember Microsoft's "Plays for Sure" campaign against Apple.
- pschastain 5y agoBoth my wife and I had 2011 MBPs that were only replaced last year. I upgraded the RAM & replaced the HDDs with SSDs over the years, which is reasonable imo. I'd say 10 years is a pretty good run for a laptop. YMMV
- MBCook 5y agoNote that the PC that pulled off these numbers cost almost double what the Mac did. $2500 vs $4000. It includes the GPU (not cheap these days) but still a big difference.
- newaccount74 5y agoThe PC comes with 32GB of RAM and 4TB SSD. A similar specced Macbook Pro costs $4100, not $2500
- Gigachad 5y agoWhat gives people the perception of apple being expensive is that other OEMs play tricks to boost numbers on a spec sheet that the common person checks while cheeping out massively on parts that don’t show on the spec sheet. I know someone who got an MSI laptop recently and it’s complete garbage. The screen casing cracked from the force of the hinge within months, the trackpad is borderline unusable, wifi is spotty, the paint on the keyboard started flaking off within months, and it’s a general piece of junk. But on the store page it looks like an extreme bargain because it has the same ram, GPU and cpu as much more expensive laptops
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> What gives people the perception of apple being expensive is that other OEMs play tricks to boost numbers on a spec sheet that the common person checks while cheeping out massively on parts that don’t show on the spec sheet. Yep! Like with dell: non-standard power supply size, non-standard motherboard size. And with most of the companies: a motherboard that uses whatever the cheapest USB, sound, SATA chipsets were in the bin that week. The boards are designed and reworked constantly by the factories...as opposed to Apple who pour enormous engineering effort into refining, testing, etc each revision.
- sorry_outta_gas 5y agoIt's really the cost of capability and addons, I'm not sure about that MSI model but you're able to get a ton of storage and a good gpu for under what apple charges if you want one or two tb of storage and decent ram you're looking at $3,000+ after taxes
- Gigachad 5y agoI think this still ties in to the point. People laugh at the apple user mentality of “I just know it’s going to work if I buy Apple”. But then you have windows OEMs where you have to do careful research because the product line is full of scams and traps.
- salamandersauce 5y ago
- lmm 5y agoIf the exact combination of specs that you want is one of their handful of available configurations, apple hardware pricing is fine. But if you start from what you want to do, most of the time the cheapest mac that does what you want (which will probably be vastly overpowered in some area you don't care about) will be much more expensive than the cheapest PC that does what you want.
- NoPicklez 5y agoRealistically, I think that the argument of Apple being way more expensive is simply now outdated. It was true in the past, but I don't think it's the case anymore.
- throwaway473825 5y agoIt's still true outside the US.
- ajmurmann 5y agoI think one thing that creates that impression is the costs for beefier options in the Apple store. Everytime I configure a Mac and add RAM I feel ripped off. The price difference between the upgraded Mac and what you'd pay on Newegg is just so large. I'm still a happy customer, since I still get so much lasting value, but in the moment it certainly hurts.
- newaccount74 5y agoIt's Apple's way of price discrimination. They want to offer computers at every price point, but they don't want to build a dozen different models. So their entry level machines are a great deal -- you get the quality of a 5000€ machine for just 2500€ if you can live with limited storage. But if you want enough storage, you're paying the full price... I'm not a fan of their policy, because the result is that lots of people get computers that are artificially crippled by low storage. But there's no way they could keep their entry level prices as low if they charged a fair price for upgrades.
- The_Colonel 5y ago> So their entry level machines are a great deal -- you get the quality of a 5000€ machine for just 2500€ if you can live with limited storage. It sounds really weird to talk about 2500 EUR laptop as "entry level". > They want to offer computers at every price point They don't offer anything under 1000 EUR.
- newaccount74 5y agoIt's the entry level configuration of that model. Apple is doing the same as car companies: Make the base price of each model as low as possible and then charge ridiculous sums for extras.
- qwytw 5y agoApple charges what the market will bear (and their guessing, mostly accurately, that people who want an extra 16 GB of memory would rather pay an extra $400 than switch to another laptop manufacturer). Claiming that they are selling their entry levels models at a discount is just silly, Apple has considerably higher margins than other manufacturers. I'm not sure what are their exact margins on laptops, but the 2500€ is more close to being an 1300€ machine than a 5000€ one (since their margins on storage and memory upgrades are almost definitely above 100% this gets worse the more upgrades you get). Not that I'm trying to blame Apple, they've done a great job and it would be irrational for a company to not take the free money (I'd do the same and it's not that their competitors are better, high end PC laptops have similar margins it's just that less people want them so Dell, Lenovo etc. tend to sell them at massive ~50% discounts eventually (same with Android phones) which Apple never does, since their prefer to sell at relatively low volumes but with huge margins). However their prices for ram/storage are objectively predatory and the only reason they can get away with it is because there is no viable competition, it has nothing to do with "subsidizing" entry levels Macs. If they wanted to they could easily cut their prices by 500-1500 across the entire 14/16" mbp range and still remain more profitable than all the other laptop manufacturers.
- spoonjim 5y agoApple's base spec is super price competitive -- no $1000 laptop is even in the same universe of quality as a Macbook Air. But when you start upgrading the memory and storage is where Apple really takes you to the cleaners.
- gpm 5y ago> was released 14 months ago The M1 Max was only released 3 months ago... (Your other points stand though)
- kitsunesoba 5y agoThe CPU cores on the Max are identical to those of the original M1, though.
- mmmBacon 5y agoSame processor really just a yield thing.
- WatchDog 5y agoThere are 3 M1 series chips, the M1, the M1 Pro, and the M1 Max. The M1 is a different die to the M1 Pro and M1 Max. I believe the Pro and Max are the same die binned differently as you alluded to.
- mehrdada 5y agoM1, M1 Pro, and M1 Max are all distinct dies, with M1 Max being quite a bit larger, with a larger cache, and more I/O compared to its M1 Pro sibling. The 24-core M1 Max, however, is a binned die of the 32-core M1 Max. There are lower core bins of M1 Pro that are only available on the cheaper 14-inch MacBook Pro. M1 is also available in two forms, one with a 7-core and the other with 8-core GPU.
- marcan_42 5y agoSpecifically, the M1 Max has twice the memory controllers, and each one comes with a cache block, and hence has twice the cache. It also has twice the GPU cores, an extra ProRes core, two extra display controller cores, an extra AVE (video encoder) block, an extra scaler block, an extra PMGR (power manager, including some PLLs and such) block and extra bus fabric branches to drive it all, and two things Apple won't talk about: an extra ANE (Neural Engine) (disabled on all shipping machines) and die-to-die interconnect. This is all in the lower chunk of the die, such that they could basically cut the design on the dotted line for the M1 Pro (not literally, but almost; they definitely didn't redo much if any P&R, as the shared portion is identical by all visual and logical appearances).
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y agoAs someone who used to despise Apple-- the M1 chip has been such a pleasure to use. Completely silent, cold, and I haven't had any issues in my personal workflow.
- washadjeffmad 5y agoI ordered an M1 Max at launch at work and use an M1 Pro, and I've been so impressed with the M1 Air that I bought... a $150 Chromebook. It's complicated. My next mobile purchase (or build, I'm into cyberdecks lately) will have a different form factor display, like 4:3 or 3:2, and I hope Apple makes it. I really thought the Framework might be it until I used one, but it felt like they're only making laptops as an experiment in opex minimalism, and that they're planning to sell off as soon as they establish the value of the "overpriced semi-open eco-conscious DIY laptop" market. I've talked two people into buying M1 Airs and one M1 Mac Mini from Costco on sale. I haven't recommended anyone buy a Mac since 2014, but these things are fantastic.
- baq 5y agoyes, the M1 Air is the best laptop since... the original Air? it might be the best laptop in terms of value for price ever. I've never had a mac before, but this thing is objectively the best there is for the price.
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y agomy experience with any intel mac is that they are louder than a jet engine and hotter than motorcycle exhaust pipes in texas it's a very strange feeling, they actually burn so much that they itch
- p1necone 5y agoThis article is benchmarking the CPU alone but measuring the wattage of the whole machine, including a dedicated 3080ti which is obviously not relevant to a CPU benchmark. It would make more sense to do this benchmark on a laptop with an integrated GPU.
- MBCook 5y agoPerhaps that isn’t available yet, or maybe no one will ship the high end Intel chip w/o a discrete GPU because they don’t think anyone would want that combo.
- anuragsoni 5y agoKnowing intel and PC manufacturers you most likely won't find this CPU in a laptop without a dedicated GPU. I gave up the last time I was looking for a new laptop (I ended up with a MacBook Air), but it was surprisingly hard to find a laptop that had a beefy CPU but no discrete GPU. Lenovo had a couple of think pads that had some offerings but they would make you jump to the intel CPU with vPRO and that would come with a huge price increase.
- p1necone 5y agoYeah - I think it's a question of what the different target markets are willing to pay. A lot of people want gaming laptops, so systems with big GPUs and big CPUs and not so great size/weight/battery life can be had relatively cheap. But most people that want big CPUs and good battery life but don't care about the GPU so much are people who need the system for their job, so manufacturers can get away with pricing those systems higher.
- 8192kjshad09- 5y agoOut of curiosity what jobs need a good CPU but also can't take advantage of a good GPU? It seems like most of the high performance numerical computing software today is GPU-accelerated. If performance for your job is super important, why isn't your software GPU-accelerated? I might just be naive but it's honestly hard for me to imagine why anybody would need a good CPU and not also want a good GPU.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoIntel is a process node behind When you normalize for that, isn’t the power usage they equal?
- JoshTko 5y agoWhat is your point? Intel failed to execute on their own Fabs? That intel needs to use TSMC's fabs to get parity? That Intel can't get access to TSMC's best fabs? The end result is the same. Intel has chips that are 3 years behind in power efficiency.
- jayd16 5y agoWell the point is that they're neck and neck while being a fab behind. If the fab catches up they might be greatly ahead. Its a big if but it adds context.
- na85 5y agoThe power consumption is a critical issue on a laptop, unless you're one of those laptop users that never works on battery in which case you could get a lot more bang for your buck with a desktop.
- JoshTko 5y agoWhat reputable chip analyst expects Intel's fabs catch up to TSMC in the next 3 years?
- MBCook 5y agoNot only that but the Apple GPU is around double the strength of the Intel integrated GPU. Obviously the 3080 smashes the Apple GPU but that comes at a huge power cost.
- olliej 5y agoSeriously why can’t Intel make a decent igpu? My understanding is that the M1 GPU is just “ok” and isn’t competing with AMD or nvidia?
- wmf 5y agoIntel refuses to go beyond 128-bit memory which starves the iGPU.
- kitsunesoba 5y agoThe M-series GPUs are pretty great for what they are. I haven't tried a ton of games on it, but my 16" M1 Pro handles WoW about as well as a desktop with an RTX 2070 or so, and does it without the machine turning into a jet turbine. It's not destroying discrete video cards or anything, but it's universes beyond your typical integrated offering.
- MBCook 5y agoI believe they are somewhere between equal to and a quantum leap over what Apple was shipping before depending on the task/machine. But as we all know what Apple is/was shipping and the best you can get in a PC laptop are very different things.
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoI have a M1 in an entry-level Macbook Air I bought for $1000. Is Intel really having to compare its top of the line i9 to this chip now? Wow, I knew they were a bit behind but this is incredible. Price-wise, like you said, i9's are expensive. Worse, the Microsoft ARM SQ1 in the Surface Pro X performs like 1/3rd the benchmark performance as the M1. I know synthetic benchmarks aren't very meaningful but we have some X's at work and I've played with them and they are all unusually and annoying slow while my Air feels like I'm using a high-wattage desktop. The value of the M1 Macbook Air is pretty wild right now. The only thing keeping Intel's stock price above water is that Apple will never license this out to Windows laptop makers and Windows has monopolistic lock-ins so not everyone can just switch to Apple, especially businesses, so Intel is safe in the Windows world for now.
- wmf 5y agoNo, we're talking about Intel i9 vs M1 Pro/Max which is much more expensive.
- Eric_WVGG 5y agoI don’t think this is going to happen, but: It would be extremely funny if Apple strapped a heavy copper heatsink and a turbo fan to an M1 and just overclocked the ever-lasting crap out of it. The crazy thing about using a Macbook Pro (with an M1 Pro or M1 Max CPU) is that, in single-threaded performance, it's really no faster than a dippy little Macbook Air. And at the end of the day, single-thread performance is more effective than multicore! TBH I think this tradeoff is the right one (that is, not overclocking Macbook Pros), but when the iMac Pro and the Mac Pro roll around… why not? Just go for it.
- bserge 5y ago
- gjsman-1000 5y agoApple (if they were willing to expose a more wild side) should make an "M1 Pro Max Unlocked" board (or something like that) and just sell it as a bare, microATX board. It could cost exactly the same as the Mac mini for all I care, but if PC builders could use it in crazy cases and with liquid (or even liquid nitrogen) cooling, that would be so cool.
- vbezhenar 5y agoJust rip the board from Mac Mini?
- barkingcat 5y agoI bet Woz would totally do it, and he has the clout to do it too - as a retro-mod calling back to the Apple I or II
- devin 5y agoThis will never happen.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoNope, it won't, Apple will never be willing to show a more wild side. I'm just dreaming.
- never_a-pickle 5y agoNot to mention that M1 can run at those speeds on battery. The intel certainly would need to be plugged in to beat it by 5%.
- adam_arthur 5y agoBut the Intel chip is a fab generation behind. Not apples to apples
- qbasic_forever 5y agoOk, it's Apples to Intels then. :)
- barbacoa 5y ago>3.5%-5% increase in performance at more than double the wattage The 100 watts mentioned in the article is the whole laptop power. Google tells[0] me the power consumption of the i9-12900HK is 45 with boosts up to 86W. Intel's 12th gen i9 is built on 7nm, Apple's M1 max is build on 5nm. Rule of thumb, is about 30% power saving at same performance for a new node. So assuming max performance of M1 Max is 40W and i9-12900HK is 86W, adjusted for process node we are looking at 40W vs 60W. [0]https://wccftech.com/intel-core-i9-12900hk-alder-lake-is-a-power-hungry-beast-of-a-notebook-cpu-up-to-29-faster-than-amd-ryzen-9-5900hx/ https://wccftech.com/intel-core-i9-12900hk-alder-lake-is-a-p...
- matthewfcarlson 5y agoThat’s just marketing fluff in terms of measurements. Most agree that in terms of gate size, intel’s 7nm is similar to TSMCs 5nm. So you could say that Intel moving to 5 would give them a 30% boost but the TSMC goes to 3nm.
- barbacoa 5y agoIntel renamed their nodes, "Intel 7nm" is what they were previously called "Intel 10nm". So the node numbers are now (semi) compatible between Intel and TSMC.
- Macha 5y agoTo be clear, the node formerly known as Intel 10nm is now called Intel 7. There's no unit attached, which is probably for the best, as what was being measured in nanometers previously was super subjective and varied per manufacturer.
- zucker42 5y agoFor one, the only power numbers in this article are from a benchmark where the i9-12900hk has a 29% performance advantage (and the power numbers weren't even measured under controlled conditions using consistent methodology). Second, you can't extrapolate from the numbers in the article to a fair comparison, since performance scaling with extra power is non-linear. You must compare the systems at iso-power or iso-performance, or even compare them over the whole power/performance range. Probably a more fair comparison of the architectures will be between the M1X and the i7-1280p, since they have similar power specs. It wouldn't surprise me if the M1X comes out on top since it's on a superior process node (TSMC 5nm vs Intel 7) and on-chip memory is faster, but I think they'll definitely be comparable.
- speed_spread 5y agoAt least this CPU can run more than a single OS.
- philistine 5y agoGive it a couple more months and Linux will boot on Apple Silicon. Give it a couple of years and Microsoft will wisen up and start licensing Windows for Apple Silicon too. Then we'll be back to where we were before the architecture switch.
- marcan_42 5y agoLinux already boots on Apple Silicon and has for almost a year; give it a couple more months (if that) and we'll have a reasonably user friendly installer for it and enough hardware working to be worth using ;) (Basically I'm going to make battery stats work, polish up the install process, re-do the CPU frequency scaling driver, and ship it)
- cehrlich 5y agoIt’s obviously not valid for all use cases, but Windows already runs great in Parallels. If I give it half the CPU cores and RAM of my M1/16GB Air, it benchmarks around the same as an Intel Quad Core 13” Pro.
- marcan_42 5y agoIntel know Apple has the ability to strap two M1 Max dies together, right? Right? It's all over the architecture and drivers. It's designed for that. The damn interrupt controller has an unused second half. Rumors are it'll be used on the iMac Pro, but who knows, they can throw it into a 16" laptop if they really want to, it'd still be quieter and lower power than the old Intel MacBooks. Do that, same wattage, less than twice the price, twice the performance. Now what, Intel?
- dathinab 5y agouhm, twice the chip twice the power usage if used for twice the performance...
- hnburnsy 5y agoGo and try to build your own rig with the M1. I'll wait right here for your report on its performance and power usage. (Not picking on anyone, just annoyed at the incessant power usage comparisons between apples and oranges IMO)
- Jansen312 5y agoI was reading up a lot of reviews on these alder lake, either those reviewers are paid or simply Intel fanboy, they all seems to downplay the power consumption and giving Intel glowing reviews (and quickly skim over power issue). I wouls year end and see how 13th vs Ryzen 4 will battle out.
- coldtea 5y ago>3.5%-5% increase in performance at more than double the wattage Which would be throttled to death at that point on a nimble laptop anyway! Why do they even bother? >It's also a _little_ bit funny that the i9 laptop was double the price, given people usually rant loudly about how expensive Apple computers are. They ususally don't do an Apple to Apple comparison, else the price differential for similar features, construction, etc. and some uniques that you only get from Apple is either zero or around $100-$200, when you pile in the extra options. Instead they check things like that an extra 1TB of SSD is X on the Applestore but half or less on the street...
- brian_herman 5y agoYeah, even AMD with their 5800X3D can't keep up.