18 ms·
Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
- dzhiurgis 5y agoPeople like to make fun of Slack memory use, but right now Message app uses 1.5GB of memory. Also, listening to voice messages, especially when some bluetooth device is connected is infuriating experience.
- squabble 5y agoText messaging on cell phones worked fine until Apple got involved. Now when I send a message to a relative, their response goes to my Macbook. (I have an Android phone, they have an Apple phone)
- LesZedCB 5y ago> While blue-bubble FOMO is certainly real, suggesting that it’s the reason people want iPhones is A-grade, uncut “people only buy Apple products because they’re status symbols” kind of delusion. ~ Macworld.com yeah, ok... > Since Apple made that choice not to support Android, though, it’s probably safe to say that Apple never actually intended for iMessage to compete for instant-message domination over the rest of the world apple has made exclusive decisions over and over and over again. and i think everybody outside of the apple bubble knows that its because Brand Prestige is a HUGE part of apples branding.
- netizen-936824 5y agoBlue bubble FOMO isn't real though, at least I've never heard of it outside these few articles claiming its a thing
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoWell, I've heard of it. And frankly, I have it myself, too.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoWell, admitting you have a problem is the first step
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colinmhayes 5y agoGreen texts are objectively worse. It's hard to have text conversations with iPhone users as a none iPhone user because they refuse to use messaging apps and sms takes like 20 seconds. Not to mention degraded media quality and lack of all the other features iMessage has.
- knaik94 5y agoI have yet see a meaningful difference between Whatsapp and iMessage. The degraded media happens because Apple like to use non standard formats for media and the framework of iMessage is based around compatibility with MMS and SMS. MMS is pretty limited even in the age of 5g. Apple could easily allow iMessage to work on android but they don't because they know people will buy iPhones for iMessage.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colinmhayes 5y agoWhatsApp is just as good as iMessage. The problem is almost no iPhone users in the US use it in my experience. Everyone is happy with their iMessage.
- pmontra 5y agoWhat do people with Android phones use, SMS? In Europe not only Android is dominant but people use WhatsApp or Messenger. iPhone owners must use them too as their primary messaging app. I guess they have their iMessage full with SMS from banks and other notifications, like my Android SMS app.
- technothrasher 5y agoI had never heard of it either until I switched to an iPhone for unrelated reasons. Half my contacts suddenly were congratulating me on being "blue". It was... weird.
- zelphirkalt 5y agoSounds like a cult. It is very creepy, to have many people message you after you install a messenger too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 5y agoTo be fair this is something I would do ironically because I'm a millenial and that's how my humor works. Though I would also not be surprised to find people who felt this genuinely.
- jakelazaroff 5y agoAlso a millennial, have seen people say this both in jest and in earnest.
- democra 5y agoAre you really going with "I've never really heard of it, so it isn't real."? It's not how it works.
- vineyardmike 5y agoanecdata: I heard about it a lot. ESPECIALLY when i was in high school and college. Definitely heard girls (with iphones) gossip and discussing prospective men and say "but his texts are green". Its not code for "he isn't rich" - I went to a private school and hung out with sorority girls so everyone was well off, but something more ambiguous. Something makes blue bubbles feel better. Maybe its just that iMessage is a more rich form of communication vs SMS, and people hate needing another app to check for that one android user in their life.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoYeah, I use Signal for a few of my friends and I try to get others in so we can all be in the same chat group on PC and phone, the responses I get would make you think I asked them to feed their children to piranha.
- martimarkov 5y agoSome of my friends are refusing to join solely on all my signal contacts get notified I’m on signal now. Which I agree to an extent and there is actually no way to disable it.
- netizen-936824 5y agoOr perhaps we shouldn't trust apple with our communication data and move everyone to something lime signal But yea, I wouldn't want to date someone who thinks like that anyhow. Their values are obviously too different from my own if they value iMessage over security, privacy, and the ability to modify my own devices
- Nextgrid 5y agoBesides its E2E, Signal has all the downsides of iMessage; it still relies on phone numbers as identity, is a centralized walled garden hostile to third-party clients and the desktop client is an Electron pile of shit.
- 5y ago
- nr2x 5y agoSwitching from iphone, which all my friends and family use, to a pixel caused so many issues with texting I almost went back to iOS solely because I was causing headaches for others. FOMO is real for sure, but plain old inconvenience is also at play. If your entire family and social circle is on iOS, it's a massive pain to leave. This is by design.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nrmitchi 5y agoI completely understand what you mean by this, and what bothers me the most is that this is problem should be entirely avoidable. Pleaes correct me if I'm wrong, but I can't think of a single technical reason why "a non iphone in a group chat" has to cause such infuriating levels of inconvenience for everyone involved. Someone had to put explicit effort into making it as unbearable as it is. The only reason I can think of is Apple using a dominant position in a network in order to sabotage alternatives.
- notriddle 5y agoRCS is great. They should have done it ten years ago. Sure, ten years ago it probably didn’t seem to matter, but the iPhone 5 already bumped the screen size from 3.5in to 4in the rear camera was already 1080p, and “phablets” were already a term in 2012. It was totally foreseeable that MMS size limits where going to be a problem, if they weren’t already! What a great case of skating where the puck is, instead of skating where it’s headed. RCS existed as a spec, just not implemented by carriers. The fact that Apple, and even Google, are routing around their MMS servers is totally their fault.
- giantrobot 5y ago> Pleaes correct me if I'm wrong, but I can't think of a single technical reason why "a non iphone in a group chat" has to cause such infuriating levels of inconvenience for everyone involved. SMS/MMS is the lowest common denominator for non-Messages devices. So including a non-Messages device in a group chat means the whole chat needs to be downgraded to SMS. Even if Apple added support for RCS tomorrow, group chats would need to downgrade to it and lose E2EE and rely on the participants carriers to deliver messages just like with SMS. There's no good way for Apple to integrate the shit show of non-Messages protocols in a sane way. Carriers made a mess of RCS in the design, implementation, and deployment. Google has had to run their own RCS backend to allow Android users to actually use RCS thanks to the carriers' bungling and meddling. Even they haven't helped the situation with a decade of half-starts in messaging apps. Blaming Apple is a bit ridiculous. They're not going to spend a billion dollars fixing the problems created by carriers and Google when they already have their own messaging system.
- ideamotor 5y agoOh it's real. It's very frustrating to text people who can't receive live photos, videos sent are reduced in quality by a significant degree, can't receive replies to specific comments, and can't receive link previews. People don't click links without a preview, period. So no use sending a video or live photo via icloud link either. I have absolutely minimized texting android users due to these issues. It probably helps that 80% of the folks I text regularly (or have at some point) are apple users.
- smcleod 5y agoThat's not iMessage / Apple's fault - that's a limitation of the SMS and MMS technologies.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIf only there were a more modern standard, it could be called RCS
- mehrdada 5y agoRCS is an inferior anti-user unencrypted "standard" to iMessage; too little, too late, and driven by Google who effectively bribes carriers to get behind it by providing backend servers to them and sell out the user. No user wants additional say from carrier and potential opportunity for billing. The only reason RCS has even become a thing and Android is playing that game is Google intended to force Apple's hand by ganging up on them with carriers. They failed and now they whine. What they are asking iMessage is to basically fold their pocket ace hand and join and be a lower-class participant in a Google-controlled messaging world. No wonder Apple will always say fuck you.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIf iMessage is such a pocket ace then perhaps they are abusing their market position.
- uxp100 5y agoIt gets talked about a lot (I've seen many articles talking about it over years), so I guess I think it must exist. Never ever heard of it in real life. Maybe just Wealthy Zoomers? People from New York? Teenagers? I have no idea, but things keep telling me it is real. Like, I know more people with android than not, I have an iphone, I think I've never been in a group chat that was "blue bubble." MMS isn't as bad as it used to be, however. Less regions have service that is too poor for MMS to work but SMS works fine I think.
- thmorriss 5y agoblue bubble fomo is very real. It is the main reason ~5 of my friends have switched to iphones in my age group (~21) in the last two years
- specialp 5y agoOn TikTok there's a lot of GenZ videos about green bubbles being ugh. It is definitely a thing with younger people. I got an iPhone after never thinking I'd buy one ever, but decided Apple is the lesser of 2 evils, and everyone I text that has an iPhone immediately recognized the blue bubble. Also, it sucks if you want to send a picture or video to a green bubble.
- jacobmartin 5y agoI saw a guy on tinder once say not to even bother if your texts are going to be green. It really rocked my world to realize there are real people actually like that out there
- netizen-936824 5y agoHonestly I wouldn't want to date someone who thinks like that anyhow, so good. It filters them out because their values obviously don't line up with mine.
- colinmhayes 5y agoYou can't really have text conversations between iMessage and android because SMS is so slow. It's like having a conversation where each person can only say two sentences a minute.
- herbst 5y agoThis again seems a regional issue, SMS is so underused around here I am regularly impressed how fast they arrive. Way faster than the typical android notification takes to show up (since heavy battery saving was made standard) for any IM app
- Nextgrid 5y agoThis could actually work as a decent filter if you don't want to waste endless hours doing tech support and fixing up their stupid Android full of malware.
- mcast 5y agoI imagine blue-bubble FOMO is more popular within the US because most younger Americans use text messaging instead of WhatsApp/Telegram like you would find in Europe or South America (aside from occasional group chats or college teamwork)
- Bayart 5y agoIn France, SMS is still the most common message medium. It's free, it works, there's no app needed. Messaging app are wildly dependent on social circles and age groups. I'm forced to use 5 of them...
- howinteresting 5y agoMost younger Americans (and people of many other countries) use Discord.
- herbst 5y agoFor daily messaging to friends and family?
- howinteresting 5y agoFriends, yes, and family if they're on Discord as well. The IRC style of group communication genuinely works better than a ton of different group chats.
- kaesar14 5y agoLol completely untrue outside of a demographic of people online. Maybe the people in computer science majors at universities, not your average young American
- howinteresting 5y agoTalking about 13-17 year olds here, people who aren't old enough to be in universities.
- skavi 5y agoIf that’s the case, I am fairly confident in saying you were never an American teenager for this past decade.
- cbm-vic-20 5y agoI was never an American teenager in this century. IDGAF what color my "bubble" is, and neither does anyone else I care to communicate with. That said, even in the olden days as a teenager there was a lot of social pressure for things that just don't matter.
- stnmtn 5y agoYes, it might not exist for you and your age group, but saying that it "doesn't exist at all" is just wrong. It does matter, and it is a factor for certain age groups. You can disagree with it, but that doesn't make it not real.
- nhumrich 5y agoIt's a peer pressure thing. I know people who have legitimately bought iPhones because they kept getting left out of group chats.
- celestialcheese 5y agoIt wasn't FOMO for me, but rather a exhaustion from interoperability between the two platforms. Group chats become impossible with iphone users, so you stop being invited. Texts were constantly dropping, so people would think I was ignoring messages. Just switched from android to iPhone after 12 years of owning and working with android as a developer. I just got tired of fiddling. Most of my social group and family uses iPhone and there's no way the non-technical folks in my life are switching, so... If you can't beat, join. So now least you've now heard of it from someone other than these articles :shrug:
- pmontra 5y agoA success for Apple's strategy. It can't work in all the other countries were the primary messaging app even for iPhone users are WhatsApp or similar apps.
- parineum 5y agoThere's no FOMO here but when iPhone users bitch about it like it's my fault and not Apple's, I think less of them. It's a shame so many people are allowing themselves to be manipulated by Apple to peer pressure their friends into buying Apple products.
- sidlls 5y agoI can't disagree that Brand Prestige is a big part of their marketing and branding. I used Android phones and linux or MS operating systems on PCs exclusively for my entire life, until the last 2 years or so. I was also quite zealously anti-Apple and anti-Apple-fanboy, and I considered their 1984 ad to be incredibly ironic. Once the fifth android device in a row bricked on me I made a decision to try an iPhone 11. I couldn't be happier. It just worked, never crashed, and certainly didn't brick during the time I used it, just under 2 years. I recently upgraded to an iPhone 13 and am still thrilled with it. I never had an Android phone that lasted longer than a year before issues started to surface, and I never had one make it 2 years ever. The performance of the iPhone made the take the plunge to try a MacBook Pro for my personal use. Couldn't be happier with that, either: it offers a linux-like experience on the command line, and provides a mostly great UI (I don't care for Finder--but I haven't any other real complaints). Edit: my Android phone purchases were top-of-the-line models: Nexus and Pixel phones purchased off Google directly.
- knaik94 5y agoI am not sure what budget range you were choosing for these Android phones you mentioned. If you spent the same amount of money that you spend on an iPhone 13/11 on an android, it wouldn't brick. My Samsung Galaxy Note 2 and S2 are still working. They aren't fast but they could be used if I was desperate. I am glad iPhones worked out for you, but I have to say I haven't had any problems with the Androids I have used. I also like that I can root and customize the OS at a deep level. I have an iPad mini and iPod touch. I am familiar with both ecosystems. My iPad mini 4 has crashed on me and it is getting worse with every iOS/iPadOS update. Ram seems to be the limiting factor.
- acchow 5y agoWait, people outside the Apple bubble believe that Apple users buy Apple products because of "Brand Prestige"?
- Biganon 5y agoNah, the 99% of law students in my classes who went for shiny macbooks instead of absolutely any computer that allows its user to take notes and search the web obviously did so after carefully weighing the pros and cons of every solution. Not because they felt compelled to fit in the group.
- llampx 5y ago99% of developers that don't develop for Windows also seem to use and prefer Macbook Pros, so the argument "the law students don't know squat" doesn't really hold water. If my Thinkpad was not a solution, I would have continued using a Mac even with their lack of ports and upgradability.
- Biganon 5y agoDevelopers need much more in a computer than the average law student. Heck, I would consider buying a macbook myself, they're obviously very good computers. All I'm saying is, let's not downplay the insane trendiness effect that goes with Apple products. There are numerous stories on reddit of kids who get bullied if they have an android phone instead of an iPhone. Teenagers crying when they receive the last Samsung phone instead of an iPhone. Etc.
- zelphirkalt 5y ago> 99% of developers ... What? In what world? I think that is a bubble in itself right there. Software devs are among the most aware groups of people (which still is not too aware, sadly) about limitations, configurability, free software, and open source software on their devices. You cannot even test websites you develop properly on MacOS (including what happens with blocking solutions in place, as MacOS limits their capabilities). Also browsers do not have the same right like on other systems. Only Safari has, which is not what you should test with. It is ill suited at least for web development.
- lwkl 5y ago> Brand Prestige is a HUGE part of apples branding. I agree it is certainly part of their branding. An iPhone is an iPhone no matter the price you pay. The iPhone SE for $400 doesn't feel any less premium as the most expensive $2000 iPhone. There isn't really a obvious design element that tells you it's the cheap iPhone (except the notch and the camera, but it could just be that you didn't buy a new one) and this is also true for the hardware. Other manufacturers definitely have a much worse customer experience for people that buy their low-end models. This is understandable because they don't have the margins Apple has. But pretending that people buying Apple just do so because they are held hostage and they are missing out on a better user experience is delusional. Android and iOS both are trying to lock you into their ecosystem and try to sell you additional services which increase your lock-in. I'm not conviced that they deliberately design their products in a way to increase the lock-in. It probably comes naturaly if you don't have any open standards and interopability as a design goal. People on here talk about RCS for example but if you look at the Wikipedia page about RCS [1] you can see that carriers started implementing RCS in the last 4-5 years. For my country there is only one carrier listed and they implemented RCS less than 2 years ago. Sure RCS was a standard when Apple released iMessage but at the time most providers were still charging outrageous prices for SMS/MMS. Good luck convincing them a standard which would remove a revenue stream. So iMessage was a good solution to offer a better experience for iPhone users. It just works, no configuration required and you can always fallback to SMS/MMS. They probably could've made iMessage an open standard or made an Android app. But would've other manufacturers and Google participated in this standard (mind you it would've been centralized, there was no Signal protocol) or would everyone using iMessage be better than what we have now? I think a lot of the criticism today is hindsight. We know a lot more today and a lot of stuff was in it's infancy when it was released and tried to solve different problems than what we see today. Sorry for the rant. This post went a bit overboard but I had a lot of thoughts on the topic that ended up in this post. And I'm interested if someone has something to add or disagrees with my assesment completely. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services#Status https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services#St...
- FredPret 5y ago>Let’s start with the obvious: the only people having this conversation about iMessage are Americans That makes it important. A large section of 300 million of the richest people on the planet want blue text bubbles rather than green ones, and will buy the expensive phone to get it. Fortunes have been made on much less.
- nr2x 5y agoThis exact same reason why GDPR matters to tech companies yeah: Europeans are rich.
- hffftz 5y ago
- after_care 5y agoApple has >1billion active units worldwide, or one for every three and a half people on the internet. While the USA market is highly profitable their operational scope is much larger.
- WoahNoun 5y agoUnits is not the same as actual people. I have a work phone and a personal phone both of which would be considered active Apple units.
- badwolf 5y agoI've a work iphone, work macbook, work ipad, personal iphone, personal macbook, personal ipad, apple watch. I am 7 "active units" but 1 person.
- FredPret 5y agoYou’re a living example of the profits to be made when your focus is delighting the customer
- foolfoolz 5y agothis is a dumb take, implying you must have chat presence on every phone in the world to not be a failure. imessage isn’t that product. i think for iphone owners the messages app is still the preferred solution for all messages. you’ll use others if needed, but you’d rather not. it’s a great app because most people use it naturally without even thinking. apple business chat is going to bring in a lot of revenue for apple. i message has a strong future
- arvinsim 5y ago> i think for iphone owners the messages app is still the preferred solution for all messages. Only applies to iPhone owners in the USA
- jandrese 5y agoThis article basically echos what the Google report said. If you are talking about US teenagers then iMessage is king. If you are looking at the rest of the world then it is kind of a flop because in a lot of the rest of the world SMS is a complete rip off so a message system that falls back to SMS is useless, hence people in those countries use cross platform messaging that eliminates SMS on their phone.
- orev 5y agoIf you want to avoid using SMS in iMessage, you can just turn it off in the settings. Very easy for anyone who wants to avoid it.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThen you can't talk to non-iPhone users?
- justsomehnguy 5y agoAnd this is clearly shows how Americans percieve the thing. You can't send iMessage to non-iPhone user then. You still can send SMS/MMS to non-iPhone user. But because Apple intentionally bundled SMS/MMS messenger app into iMessage you are thinking iMessage == SMS/MMS. To give you an idea why are conflating them - you don't actually need a phone number for iMessage/FaceTime. Because the primary ID for it is your Apple ID, not your phone number.
- r00fus 5y agoIs it possible that Apple simply doesn't want to dominate messaging? I mean, if they do, what do they gain? (more revenue, more lock-in, more success) What do they risk? (regulatory/anti-trust implications) Apple can easily be understood by trying to avoid becoming IBM/AT&T. They don't want to be ubiquitous because that has its own regulatory challenges.
- mypalmike 5y ago
- timbit42 5y agoLemmings.
- ggm 5y agoChildren. Never underestimate the role of perceived peer-pressure. Real or imagined "wrong brand of sneakers" has been going on forever.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoIt's the kid version of keeping up with the Jones's
- endisneigh 5y agoAn iPad is what, 200 for the old model? If you want blue bubbles it’s cheap
- danuker 5y agoOld devices get slower due to mandatory updates.
- m-s 5y agoYou need an iPhone to link your phone number though.
- endisneigh 5y agoCan’t you mix Apple account with phone numbers if everyone is using iMessage? And if everyone isn’t on iMessage it would defeat the purpose and might as well use an android, no?
- alimov 5y agoYou don’t need to link to a phone number for blue bubbles
- clpm4j 5y agoClearly there are some people who value iMessage, for whatever reason. I have to imagine there are also plenty of people like myself who have been using the iPhone since version 4 simply because it's the best phone I've ever used, period. And the user experience of my iPhone + Macbook + Airpods just makes my life easier and more enjoyable in a lot of ways. And I use iMessage because it's how I 'text' people, similar to how I used to text people on my Blackberry and my Razr and my Nokia before chat apps were a thing. I don't want to download chat apps - I just use what's convenient which is iMessage and it works great for my use case.
- arbirk 5y agoAgree. + I don't want to support use Facebook #meta products and I can't get my friends to use Signal
- after_care 5y agoYou dropped so many brand names I’m starting to think there is something to this status symbol theory.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- truculent 5y agoI'm not trying to snark, but how else are they supposed to report their comparisons?
- after_care 5y agoThere is the personal story told of “I use to use Nokia and Razer and they were good, but I’ve been using Apple products for the last 11 years and I like them a lot” which is a story about brand loyalty developing in an article about an article about Apple developing brand loyalty in American teens. Combine that with the ~9% brand name usage in the textblock and the whole thing stuck out to me.
- technojunkie 5y agoRCS sucks, but it's the best path to cross-platform messaging that can (and should) be end-to-end encrypted (RCS already supports the Signal protocol for E2EE). I'd love to see a better privacy/security messaging standard, but let's get something in there incrementally like RCS. On a side note, can Google allow Android devs to implement RCS in other apps than Google Messages and Samsung Messages, please?
- colinmhayes 5y agoBlue texts are definitely most of the reason I have an iPhone. It's just not possible to have conversations over text with SMS speeds and 90% of my friends refuse to get messaging apps. I could care less about the prestige, but most of my communication happens over text. Other big reason is how well iOS works with airpods.
- Lamad123 5y agoThis article does not mention the word 'security' even once.. Weird, considering the recent scandals and that company's reluctance to fix them on time.
- duxup 5y agoI just assume iMessage is a polished messaging app that Apple made for their phones…. All these “world domination or bust” ideas I think are silly.
- nextos 5y ago> It works. It’s better than anything Google has attempted. The problem is, it’s not good enough. This is wrong. Google had a very good messaging system, Google Talk. It worked really well, was based on open standards, supported federation, video/audio calls and was making its way into smartphones. For example, the Nokia 770-N9 series supported Google Talk as early as Q2 2006. Calls based on an open standard in a smartphone, already in 2006... However, internal politics at Google led to the discontinuation of Google Talk in favor of a long stream of confusing and half-finished attempts: Google Chat, Hangouts, Duo, Spaces, Allo and Meet. I've lost track of how many different services they have come up with. Apparently there's more of them I didn't even know about [1]. It's comical and sad, since the first one was great and had tons of users thanks to being embedded into Gmail. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/21/22538240/google-chat-allo-hangouts-talk-messaging-mess-timeline https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/21/22538240/google-chat-allo...
- vondro 5y agoOh Google Talk was sweet :) Also about Duo - even though I agree that it's kinda half-assed, strange interface app, it consistently has lower latency and better video quality than WhatsApp or Signal. I use it wherever my contact has it.
- marticode 5y agoI'll second that. I have found it to have the best quality of all video calling alternatives and handle low bandwidth situations the best too. The interface is weird but focusing on just one thing and doing it well feels like a good choice.
- waffle_maniac 5y agoYou can walk out of your house and the call seamlessly switches from WiFi to cellular. Try doing that with WhatsApp or Signal.
- paganel 5y ago> with WhatsApp I don't know about Signal because I don't use it but WhatsApp is also pretty good at that job. It also helps if one lives in a country/on a continent with a decent mobile internet service, I guess the US is not the best in that domain. Also, who still prefers to make a call in this day and age? You only do that if there's something urgent, text is the way.
- more_corn 5y agoThe author ignores strong evidence suggesting that iMessage brings people (especially young people) into the apple ecosystem, locks them in and lands and expands. iMessage is the killer app for iPhone and integrates flawlessly with the desktop app. I hate to disparage the intelligence of the author in general, but in this specific case they are wrong and startlingly ignorant of the market they pretend to understand at an expert level.
- bern4444 5y agoAgreed. It's similar to how BBM was a killer feature for blackberry and brought so many people into that ecosystem. It may not be enough to keep a company going forever - apple has many other ways of propelling itself - but its powerful enough to get people in the ecosystem
- yoz-y 5y agoHm. But as stated this is mostly a US thing because of critical mass. Most people I know already use at least two or three services so honestly they don’t really care what service you are on. I remember that in uni people who didn’t have messenger were “annoying” because it was the service which almost all of the group had (while everybody had also others like WhatsApp, hangouts, kakao and whatnot)
- knaik94 5y agoThe only group I have seen care about iMessage colors and see it as a status symbol is high schoolers. Once I got to college, no one cared. People just wanted to be able to talk easily. It was annoying to set up cross platform group messaging at first, but it hasn't been a problem for at least 6 years. The biggest thing pulling people to iMessage now is convenience and not wanting to figure out a different mutual platform. A large portion of the current generation of kids are actually tied to Discord. I expect Discord to start dominating more and more as time goes on. Hackathons are organized and held on there. Clubs at my university have moved to Discord. There's a specific to my university Math discord and a separate CS one where even teachers interact. A lot of online streamers have set up their own branded discord for their community. I have heard some companies like Amazon even have a new hire Discord. Slack, iMessage, Whatsapp, and Messenger all lack things Discord provides. I believe Discord is the endgame for group messaging. The way you can organize conversations in to categories and channels is a killer feature that no other service gets quite right. The way Discords use roles to help categorize people into groups and have granular permission control for who can access what content is so useful. It's a matter of when, not if Discord is the best service. There is one big caveat to Discord right now and that's the lack of End to End encryption. Whatsapp and Signal are the only two messaging services I trust for privacy sensitive communication. I don't really care if government agencies snoop on the fact that I was playing Rocket League for the last two hours though. iMessage is E2E as well but only if you communicate with others that are also tied to the Apple ecosystem which makes it useless for me because a lot of my international friends aren't. I have an ipad that has my contacts synced so I can see who else has iMessage.
- fomine3 5y agoDiscord lacks multi account feature on mobile (some desktop support had come recently). It enforces use my "gamer" profile to all other community. Slack did it well from very beginning.
- knaik94 5y agoI have to disagree, I can setup a profile and name per discord. I strongly dislike Slack's method of having different accounts tied to a single email but each can potentially have a different password. I hate having to switch and log out and log into different Slacks and there's no clear way to see an overview of all of the ones I am in efficiently. It feels like a UX thing more than a functionality thing. Discord's UX for managing notifications and what communities I'm part of is very pleasant. I am only a "gamer" in the gaming related Discords. There's no cross talk between two Discords unless the other people also share in being a part of both communities. People in a music related discord don't ask about the game I am playing unless they happen to be interested in it.
- faangiq 5y agoIs “writing blatantly wrong headlines for clicks” a thing now?
- throwaway7033 5y agoYellow journalism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism) has been a thing since at least the 1890s.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sys_64738 5y agoWeChat is a China based app and most of the rest of then are hoovered up by Facebook Inc. Do you really want an ad company to be greping through all your allegedly secure message? China based apps speak for themselves in the current climate. iMessage seems like a fine solution to me when I want to send IMs. I'm not interested in all the chaff associated with recent IM enhancements. They all seem pretty irrelevant to the main function: text and photos sending.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paxys 5y agoPeople use iPhones because they are the best phones. High iMessage usage is the effect, not the cause. I personally don't know any iPhone user who doesn't also have an alternate messaging app installed on their device. Remember that there was a time when Blackberry had 100% platform lock-in with BBM. I myself got one (including a pricey service plan) just to be able to message my friends in college. Yet everyone left the app (and ecosystem) overnight because there was a better device available. There was a time when ICQ was unbeatable, and it seemed like people would be using it forever, because how do you move off of a platform that everyone you know is on? Then came AIM. Then MSN Messenger. Then Skype. The Google Talk. Then Facebook Messenger. Then WhatsApp and iMessage. It will be something else tomorrow. There is no such thing as network lock-in for messaging apps, simply because costs to switch to a new one are negligible, and you can use as many of them as you want at the same time.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> I personally don't know any iPhone user who doesn't also have an alternate messaging app installed on their device. 90% of the people I know with iPhones don't have any messaging apps other than iMessage. I've tried to get them on Signal or WhatsApp, complete refusal.
- alphabettsy 5y agoYou don’t know anyone with Snapchat or Facebook? They’re both used pretty heavily for messaging.
- colinmhayes 5y agoFacebook uses a separate app that most people don’t have. Snapchat isn’t really for having conversations since it disappears so quickly.
- alphabettsy 5y agoThe Facebook messenger app is ranked higher in the iOS App Store than WhatsApp or Snapchat. I don’t believe I know anyone who doesn’t have it, even people who don’t use FB like myself have it. You can also message through the Fb app without using the Messenger app.
- holler 5y agoWhy can't I delete a message for both sides in iMessage in 2022? This is why I feel like Telegram is a superior product. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251966734?answerId=253750006022#253750006022 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251966734?answerId=2537...
- bern4444 5y agoYou shouldn't have total control over a shared message. You have no right to delete something that you sent to someone else from their device. Same reason you can't delete an email you sent to someone from their inbox or burn a letter you sent via mail. This is a bad take.
- holler 5y ago> You shouldn't have total control over a shared message. I don't think we should be beholden to the mechanics of snail mail or email (almost 30 years old) when we're designing technologies in 2022 and beyond. It's impossible to send hundreds of mail envelopes, and would be hard to send hundreds of emails in a minute, and both take deliberate action to accomplish. But I can easily send 100 chat messages in a minute, and in that mode of communication with its web of connections, mistakes are easy to make and speaking for myself I appreciate the ability to correct them. With that said using telegram has been a breath of fresh air (and I hear whatsapp has it too)
- bern4444 5y agoWe're not beholden. They are simply good ideas that extend beyond the medium (letters, telegrams, and emails included). It mimics life, you cannot unsay something. If someone is hostile in a message towards me, and then deletes that message, in a situation where this eventually goes to court or some other formal proceeding, I need evidence of their action for my own defense. > mistakes are easy to make and speaking for myself I appreciate the ability to correct them. Mistakes can be corrected - spelling, factual, or otherwise. Followup messages, staring to correct a spelling mistake, talking on the phone, leaving a voicemail etc.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI think the biggest problem is not the green bubbles but the damn group chats. There’s no way to have a group chat with multiple iPhones and androids without it turning into a mess. I don’t know where to point the blame it that situation but it does make you want to stick to the dominant platform.
- alimov 5y agoWhat kind of a mess are we talking about here? I haven’t had any group chat issues (android and iOS participants) for the last few years.. I do remember it would bug out on occasion but I just haven’t seen any of that in a long time. I have a 3 and a 10 person group chat that has both android and iOS users… dont know if there is some threshold before issues start cropping up.
- greatgib 5y agoI can't understand why anyone would like to use iMessage, when you can use Telegram, whatsapp,... except stupidly for status signal. In non apple world, I think that people almost never use sms anymore. Except for first contact with someone you don't know, or receiving advertisements, one time pin codes,... For RCS, it is going nowhere because most of the users are not interested to let mobile carriers get back control over any of our non encrypted communications. They want to be more than a pipe to abuse of it for financial gain, we want them to be just a pipe.
- eropple 5y ago> I can't understand why anyone would like to use iMessage, when you can use Telegram, whatsapp People don't use iMessage, we use Messages, and iMessage is one of the protocols that it supports. And I use Messages preferentially because I know everyone will have iMessage or a SMS fallback and it Just Works. I don't have to think about it. I don't have to go to one of four apps to talk to somebody (I have Signal because of That One Friend but I don't open WhatsApp or Telegram ever despite having both). They're all in this one, and it's good enough. (Messages also works on my laptop without me having to install anything, which is minor but handy if I want to dash off a longer message--and just like Messages on iOS it'll send as a SMS or as an iMessage and I don't have to care which is which. And no, nobody I know socially uses email.) I'm sure WhatsApp is a great alternative if you live in a country where Everyone Has It, but I do not.
- knaik94 5y agoSignal, Telegram, and Whatsapp all have very feature rich desktop apps. I personally love Whatsapp and the fact that I can go to a webpage, scan a QR code on my phone and have a functioning desktop experience regardless of where I am. iMessage doesn't "just work" if there's degraded functionality for people outside the Apple ecosystem. I'm not sure what good enough means, that's really specific to the features you need. I actually strongly dislike how terrible sharing files between an iOS and Android user is if you choose to stick with iMessage. What's worse is the poor file system structure that iOS exposes where you can't manipulate and share files directly. If I want to share a song I have saved on my phone through a message, I should be able to share it like I would a picture. Having iMessage and sending to another iMessage user doesn't help in that situation. I'm also not sure what country you live in where you imagine everyone has a single messaging platform. Most people I know just use multiple apps and are willing to put in the effort it takes to switch apps.
- mrintellectual 5y agoI feel like the core premise of the article is wrong. Google's problem is not a lack of innovation, but the complete opposite - there's _too much_ of it. Great Google products come out very often but few get "long term" treatment. Part of it is engineer churn/turnover, but a bigger factor imo is culture.
- rodgerd 5y agoHangouts was, for a time, fantastic. Integrated SMS/rich messaging (like iMessage). Seamless video calling. Spot on. Then they started gutting bits of it with no apparent reason beyond supporting empire building by other teams.
- User23 5y agoWas anyone else’s first response to this submission something along the lines of, “wow, MacWorld is still around?” I remember when they started muscling in on MacUser with a frankly inferior product, but were so successful that they crushed it. And then MacAddict tried to be the scrappy underdog.
- unstatusthequo 5y agoIt’s less about blue bubbles and more about functionality. I don’t want WhatsApp as my main messaging app. And I can’t get critical mass on Signal. And sure as shit not FB Messenger or Telegram or Snapchat…. Even if Apple made all chat bubbles blue, I’d still get ultra low shitty videos from my “Android friends” sending a clip and not thinking about SMS limits. Maybe it looks fine on their end. On my end, get the magnifying glass out. Or having too many people on a text thread? Wtf? Is this 20 years ago? I also don’t get the hard core Google defensiveness thing. This is a company that mines everything they can get from you to sell ads to you…Who notoriously cancels services or fails to execute fully on them. Google Chat/Talk/Voice was confusing. Which do we use? And what about that bizarre email experiment? Voice is my favorite Google product by far. I don’t use Chrome for privacy reasons, but admit I’m stuck on Gmail. I tried to de Google my email, and then realized that having my email off of Google was cool except so many people I email were on it, so they have it anyway… I don’t really care if your chat bubble is green or blue or red. I just want it to work with whatever I’m sending and be encrypted. SMS isn’t. Carriers retain. Why subject myself to that?
- bern4444 5y agoThis article is a bit pretentious. I had an Android phone when RCS was rolling out. It never worked. Well before then, iMessage - like most message platforms - already did everything that RCS did and far better. Thank gosh Apple (and other message apps) decided to keep improving instead of waiting on telecom companies to build and support this standard. No other messaging app is as simple and easy to use as iMessages. I have no inclination to use FB/WhatsApp (though it's popular especially for international cases). I'm never going to convince all my friends to download and switch to something like telegram/signal. iMessage is simply the best SMS/Rich messaging platform that, like a lot of what Apple does, Just Works. I will never trust a google messaging service to last and be around in 5 years. They have a massive graveyard here.
- what_ever 5y agoI think you are missing the point - quite a bit. No one is asking Apple to give up iMessage and replace it with RCS. The ask is to replace SMS fallback with RCS fallback. When you message someone without an iPhone, you currently use SMS. Even though you are using the iMessage app, the message is sent using SMS. With RCS instead of SMS, iMessage will continue to "Just Work" as it does right now. iOS<->iOS will still happen over iMessage. > I had an Android phone when RCS was rolling out. It never worked. It has rolled out now though. No one asked iMessage to support RCS back then. They are being asked now. So it's not relevant what happened with you whenever you had Android phone. > Well before then, iMessage - like most message platforms - already did everything that RCS did and far better. iMessage did that for iOS<->iOS communication. Not for messages sent over SMS. > No other messaging app is as simple and easy to use as iMessages. This won't change with RCS. > I will never trust a google messaging service to last and be around in 5 years. The protocol should stay there as the SMS one is still around. If G gives up support, the fallback for RCS is... SMS which is anyway supported by iMessage already. Disc: Googler but nowhere close to Android, RCS, any messaging app.
- hocuspocus 5y ago> It has rolled out now though Not really. Google is giving the middle finger to carriers who implemented Universal Profile on their own rather than use Jibe. And we now have fragmentation even before there was time for significant adoption. That said, your points about iMessage are right. I believe RCS support might actually help iMessage in some markets, since SMS fallback is precisely the reason people won't use it.
- karmasimida 5y agoAny company has a better messaging software than Google. Why? Because Google didn't even have one. Bingo, none of their offering is going to work reliably for whatever purpose and that is not user's fault, and frankly speaking, it is 2022, there is no room for them anymore.
- pcdoodle 5y agoI hate both companies for offering zero promise I can have a private conversation.
- alimov 5y agoAfaik iMessage chat is encrypted, unless you have iCloud backups enabled for messages.
- kylehotchkiss 5y agoJumping between iMessage, telegram, WhatsApp, and slack, the big missing feature in iMessage for me is the inability to delete messages. It’s way too easy to select the wrong photo or text the wrong person and have to awkwardly wiggle your way out of it. WhatsApp shows the message was deleted and has (had?) a timeout for the delete which feels like a nice implementation. Telegram’s deletion functionality of your and the recipients messages without leaving a trace might be overkill for iMessage.
- firecall 5y agoThey might have all lost to Discord and they just don't realise it yet! My kids / tweeners and their friends all use Discord. They all have iPads and iPhones too. All they iMessage for is to message me and ask for food Discord is fun and encourages community and exploration, as well as one on one messaging. I can't see why they'd move to iMessage. And before you claim it's just for gamers... it's not, they are all on it! Boys and girls. Even the parents who organise for kids to get together k ow to share their children Discord ID! iMessage is the Facebook of the messaging world. Used be billions but yesterdays news.
- lostmsu 5y agoDiscord is terrible for privacy though. No sane parent should encourage use of Discord for that reason alone. They collect literally everything they can get their hands on.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- asdff 5y agoThey will use imessage again when they aren't sitting in their rooms chatting. Waiting for a discord to load on a spotty mobile connection is no fun. Meanwhile imessage, either through its own channels or via sms, just works, and is still the best way to get a hold of people you know in real life, since the audio fallback is just as reliable too.
- bee_rider 5y agoDiscord is just the current iteration of the free messaging app treadmill. They aren't (or at least weren't, last I checked) profitable. Eventually they'll be bought and have to monetize somehow, which everyone will hate, and then we'll all move on to some other platform. As long as they are spending investors' money, though, they'll be great!
- AniseAbyss 5y agoiMessage being incompatible with different platforms makes it pretty shit compared to other apps that work on everything. Outside of the US iPhone users have other messaging apps on their phone. But I don't think Apple ever really wanted to corner this market anyway and don't really care. Same way they never wanted to beat Windows or Lenovo with their Macs.
- a-dub 5y agoit will be like the subways in new york. BMT, IND... it will eventually be centralized and run by the government as a public service.
- skc 5y agoIt's somewhat mind boggling to me that the default messaging app for everyone that I know is WhatsApp. Everyone uses it from old people to young people to businesses. Doesn't matter if you're using iOS or Android or Windows or MacOS. We communicate via WhatsApp and it's just second nature. But of course, I'm outside the US.
- weberer 5y agoIn Finland, Telegram seems to be the dominant messenger nowadays, at least among university and tech workers.
- CRConrad 5y agoAmong everybody else, it's Whatsapp. Some tech workers too, BTW.
- Doctor_Fegg 5y agoI hear this a fair amount on HN and it doesn’t chime at all with my experience (I’m in the UK). WhatsApp is popular with parents of school-age kids but even then there’s no “second nature” expectation that you’ll use it - I don’t and no-one bats an eyelid. I don’t know any older people who use it at all. Facebook Messenger is popular too, and SMS/iMessage is the default for “I just want to contact someone”.
- ajvs 5y agoStrange, I'm in the UK as well but everyone I know and meet uses WhatsApp. Got a few friends who are on Signal and Telegram also, but those are only in my more technology-oriented circles.
- tomduncalf 5y agoLikewise, I’m in the UK and everyone I know uses WhatsApp aside from one or two who use iMessage for whatever reason (but I am sure are also on WhatsApp). I’m quite happy with it, it works well, shame it’s a Meta product
- teekert 5y agoHmm, I don't get it, my messages are all dark. Ah it's my own messages that are green (took me a while to find one). Ok, so I think I used iMessage at some point, not sure though. Have to admit that that green bubble feels a bit dated, so perhaps it's on purpose? Anyway, nobody uses iMessage here, I don't remember ever seeing a blue bubble in the messages app, it's al Whatsapp here, which is actually worse, at least iPhone users seamlessly switch between sms and iMessages, in Whatsapp you're left out with a dumbphone (and I know people with dumbphones still). Then again, they may avoid Whatsapp on purpose.
- jl6 5y agoNone of my acquaintances use iMessage, so I don’t use it. If they did, I would. The actual qualities of the app are a distant second consideration. “Competition” doesn’t quite work as expected when network effects are in play.
- scaglio 5y agoI live outside U.S. and I had a few iPhones in the last years… I almost never used iMessage. Mostly because 50% of my contacts use Android or other apps on iOS (WhatsApp). About the apps, I am forced to use WeChat because some of my friends live in China and that is the only communication channel they have… but it is the worst experience I ever had. Even Viber was better. And in China it’s heavily controlled. Among my contacts in Europe, Telegram is widely used and becoming almost “a standard”… only a very few use Signal.
- thom 5y agoIt’s for sending text messages. Please can we have some apps that just remain simple and don’t have to metastasise into social networks mining our thoughts? You know what app I never use on my phone? The phone app. Is there any actual anxiety about this? Does it need to morph into a Clubhouse-style swamp of dark patterns trying to turn audio in money? No. It just needs to sit there for when I might need to phone someone.
- nottorp 5y agoInteresting US only problem. In Europe people use whatsapp. In China they use <whatever's in fashion in China, iForgot the name>. It's been ages since I've had less than unlimited text messages. I'd still rather not use those because they're crippled, and any "improvement" made by the phone providers will still be crippled compared to what a tcp/ip based app can do. For example, I'm 100% sure any SMS "improvement" will still be tied to the phone. Even whatsapp is slowly moving away from that. There's exactly one useful feature in iMessage compared to whatsapp. It recompresses your photos less. I use it when I want to send photos to a family member and that's all.
- wruza 5y agoAnother big article over a simple thing. Reading these feels like people (not only the author) are focused on problems and not on solutions, and they mix everything together into the political drama. If the problem is green bubbles being ostracized for some teen-idiotic reason, would you like to know what to do? Make them all the same color. Yes, iMessage is SMS. The color is there for you to see if a message will be sent over SMS or over the internet, because SMS may cost money. Specifically, there are two colored things: a message itself and a "send" button, one shows the past, other shows the future. Leave the coloring of the button and own messages intact, and make all incoming bubbles blue. Or green, if you feel funny. There's a reason to see how you send, but no reason to see how it was delivered. That's it. No more issue. End of story.
- oxplot 5y agoI'm too old (mid 30s) to waste time chasing apps. If it comes with the OS, namely the default SMS messaging app, I use it. When I was on Android, that's all I used and I could contact everyone. Same on iOS now. If anyone was annoyed at sending me SMS, then it meant their comms wasn't important enough — automatic filtering.
- caskstrength 5y agoIs this an American thing to be so hung up on phone's builtin messaging software? Here in Eastern Europe everybody just use third-party messaging providers (Telegram and, unfortunately, Viber) that are available on every (major) platform.
- zwkrt 5y agoThe vast majority of people in the US don’t use a 3rd party app for messaging. Why this is I can only speculate. My guess is that we were marketed SMS as a “killer feature” of phones and phone plans during the pre-internet days of cell phones
- h0nd 5y agoHere in Europe, SMS used to be so expensive that nobody used them anymore when alternatives such as WhatsApp came up. In the meantime unlimited SMS are included in most contracts at no extra cost (or no choice) and still very few people use it anymore.
- CRConrad 5y agoMaybe in your corner of Europe. Must be a different one than mine.
- lwkl 5y agoI kind of agree with this article. I think Apple doesn't think a lot about their competition in a sense that they solely focus on the user experience of their products and don't worry with trying to push for interopability with other products. But the whole bullying thing because of the background colour seems laughable. I also think that they have a big advantage because they have a narrow range of products (there aren't 50 different iPhones) that they can sell at a high volume giving them a lot of leverage with suppliers. Additionally they control the whole stack and probably should be able to offer a superior product compared to their competition if they execute right. I'm not sure if this warrants intervention from regulators. As a consumer I see potential for a great product that simply isn't possible if multiple companies design different elements of the stack. There are much bigger conflicts of interest and you may be using the same software and parts as your competitor so they will never be as specialized. I'm not sure if these advantages are fair. Should a hardware manufacturer not be allowed to develop an operating system for their hardware? Should the developer of an operating system not be allowed to develop and integrate services into their operating system? I guess I could extend this thinking to the overall centralization in the tech space. Which is convenient and really worrying at the same time.
- yessirwhatever 5y ago> The world has spoken > Let’s start with the obvious: the only people having this conversation about iMessage are Americans. In most of the world, iMessage is an afterthought. Platform-agnostic chat apps like WeChat, WhatsApp, and Facebook Messenger dominate, though the particular apps in question vary from country to country. Excuse me? Anyone using an iPhone and messing someone with an iPhone is using iMessage. I'm in an EU country and I have specifically made an effort to notice what sort of messaging platform people use and by far if they're on iOS they're using iMessage. Such a bold and impudent statement to make! It's baffling how they can even write such a title and paragraph.
- tomcat27 5y agoI used whatsapp exclusively for years before moving to iMessage. This post misses the point just how much Apple users like iMessage. The reason iMessage is not popular in other countries is: Ubiquity trumps everything. iPhone is a unaffordable luxury good outside a few rich countries. Apple pricing is horrible. imo, and most likely all Apple users: iMessage UX is better than WhatsApp
- hammyhavoc 5y agoEverything should just be Matrix protocol at this point. 40m users so far. A long way to go until it is anywhere approaching as ubiquitous as email, but I hold hope.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The theory goes that in most countries, people fled traditional text messaging faster than in the U.S., due to more onerous per-message fees–and Apple was just too late to the party. Whose theory? Feels bogus: Here (and in most of Europe AFAIK), SMS has been free-unlimited since Idunnowhen, and hundreds included back when there were still limits shortly after the turn of the century. Pretty much all the whining about limits I can recall has been from Americans. And that's not to mention the Gruber article they link to as "proof" of the iPhone's general superiority... Say what you want about that "fireball", but for a supposedly independent and critical Apple observer, he doesn't feel all that "daring"... That was the most revoltingly gushing piece of Appleologia I've seen in a long while.