8 ms·
One of the most famous Victorian dishes is a hilarious lie
- irrational 5y agoThe highlights for me: “People don’t like it when you challenge their beliefs. … It’s so small and unimportant, you don’t bother to investigate it. It makes you wonder: how many things do we believe that if we were to look into them, we’d find they were complete nonsense?”
- jahnu 5y agoThey/we really don't! :) A guy I used to know was telling about a British children's TV show where all the characters names were actually double entendres. It just so happened that I had recently read the fascinating story about how this wasn't true at all, despite the press writing that it was and so on and it was just a successful urban legend. He said no it's really true, he'd seen it himself on TV. I later sent him over email the article describing the legend. Anyway he got really mad at me for just saying that and went round telling people I was an asshole for destroying this story for him. I was really surprised that someone could be so upset by that. http://doyoupunctuate.com/captain-pugwash-dirty-pirates/ http://doyoupunctuate.com/captain-pugwash-dirty-pirates/
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoAh, the old Captain Pugwash urban legend! I think I used to believe that a long time ago. I can understand why he got upset though if you rained on his parade in front of other people. It was probably a pet story he enjoyed telling. Something I have also been guilty of!
- jimmytidey 5y agoHowever 1950s BBC radio was full of double entres that the higher up management didn't understand. Round The Horn in particular.
- dcminter 5y agoI adore the wordplay in RtH. On a similar note, however, a colleague tried to shock me (he thought I was more straightlaiced than I am) by asking if I'd heard Cardi B's WAP. I took great pleasure in retaliating with the song "My Girl's Pussy" from 1931 which is what you might call a great deal of entendre without very much double.
- jimmytidey 5y agoThanks - not heard this before! Impossible to imagine how this could go over people's heads. Says something about how narrow many people's cultural horizons were in the 1930s I guess. According my parent's retelling of the RtH story, the humour is a result of posh people (who get to make BBC comedy) being exposed to working class while serving in WW2, although there is obviously gay subculture in there too.
- kevinwang 5y agoAdditional context (some of which Hughes might disagree with) on Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windsor_soup https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windsor_soup
- Freak_NL 5y agoThe relevant part from the article: > Hughes has spent years challenging the Victorian roots of brown Windsor soup—“I keep trying to correct the Wikipedia page, but I’ve given up”—and has faced considerable fury for his efforts. Once Wikipedia decides something is a fact, it can be hard to alter it; no matter the sources you bring. If something stood there in an article for over a decade and the article is guarded by a certain type of editor, just give up.
- pwagland 5y agoAs I mentioned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29969166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29969166, it is unclear what they were trying to "fix" given that the article has said for the last nine years that Brown Windsor Soup doesn't appear to exist before 1950, (later updated to 1920) and appears to have been a joke.
- Freak_NL 5y agoThe article is conflating 'Windsor soup' (referring to a number of soup recipes created by Windsor chefs) and 'Brown Windsor soup' in one article, and even starts of with both terms in bold in the introductory paragraph. The second sentence literally states: > While commonly associated with the Victorian and Edwardian eras, the practice of calling it 'Brown Windsor' did not emerge until at least the 1920s, […] The article is written around this vague 'it'; a soup that according to Wikipedia has Victorian origins, but wasn't called brown Windsor soup until the 1920s. If Hughes was right, than the article shouldn't treat brown Windsor soup as synonymous with 'Windsor soup', but clearly mark it as a special case with a curious history that doesn't seem to go back further than the 1920 at the earliest.
- pwagland 5y ago
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoThis seems like a general issue with how information travels without modern internet. IMO, its just a matter of multiple groups of people around the world making similar dishes and with multiple sets of definitions of what that particular dish is. And at some point, it all collided and mashed together individual histories. Maybe it was just their version of a meme.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoIt doesn’t seem specific to traveling with or without the internet. But it is nice to remember that misinformation isn’t just the internet’s fault.
- mbg721 5y agoThose meatspace-memes did exist. My parents grew up on opposite ends of the US, and knew the same childhood parodies of the theme songs of short-lived TV shows.
- milliams 5y agoInterestingly, as a Brit I've never in my life heard of "Brown Windsor soup". Admittedly I've never watched the Goon Show but it's hardly "deep...into the British psyche". Perhaps it's a generational thing (I'm in my 30s)?
- JulianMorrison 5y agoYup, same, I'm 45 and I never heard of the stuff. At a guess, you had to be in the generation that actually watched the Goon Show.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoSame, I've never head of it either.
- Veen 5y agoI'm in my early 40s and have never heard of it either. Maybe it's a Southern thing.
- YawningAngel 5y agoI'm from the South, it isn't. Ironically, the notion that Brown Windsor Soup is famous itself appears to be a hilarious lie
- glassneedles 5y agoI’m Scottish but moved down to Sussex as a kid and have been here for almost 3 decades. I’ve never heard of it either. Seems a generational thing as both my parents were familiar with it as an old dish.
- darrenf 5y ago47, lived in Surrey my whole life, never heard of it.
- cm2012 5y agoIt's more of a Utica expression
- laputan_machine 5y ago“Everybody in England was brought up believing in brown Windsor soup,” says Glyn Hughes, author of The Lost Foods of England. “What is really, really strange is how deep this is into the British psyche. Walk up to anyone in the street and ask them about brown Windsor soup, and they’ll say that it was terrible and horrible but everybody ate it in the Victorian era.” I have never heard of Brown Windsor soup until today. An article that's debunking a myth itself contains a myth.
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoNever heard of it either.
- IshKebab 5y agoMe neither, nor my girlfriend. Seems like they are vastly exaggerating the number of people that have heard of this!
- 692 5y agoI suspect from the fact it was mentioned in the program "Hancock's Half Hour" in the fifties. you probably have to be 70/80+ to know about this. it's totally new to me
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> you probably have to be 70/80+ to know about this Not necessarily. "Hancock's Half Hour" and "Goon show" episodes were sold on vinyl records at the time (and are still to be found on the big internet retailer on Vinyl, CD and MP3). If the media were in the house, years later, kids would play them for amusement.
- interstice 5y agoI grew up listening to the goon show (parents were fans) and also do not know about brown Windsor soup.
- hprotagonist 5y agoNo love for the Toast Sandwich?! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toast_sandwich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toast_sandwich
- episode0x01 5y agoYeah I mean I unironically like doing this at times. Texture contrast is great!
- vr46 5y agoNever heard of it, and whoever Glyn Hughes is, is talking poppycock, balderdash, utter claptrap, absolute piffle when he states, “Everybody in England was brought up believing in brown Windsor soup,” says Glyn Hughes, author of The Lost Foods of England. “What is really, really strange is how deep this is into the British psyche. Walk up to anyone in the street and ask them about brown Windsor soup, and they’ll say that it was terrible and horrible but everybody ate it in the Victorian era.” Complete bollocks.
- derefr 5y agoGlyn Hughes died 11 years ago, aged 76. And even then, he said "was brought up", not "is." He was presumably speaking about people brought up around the time he himself was — in the 1940s.
- vr46 5y agoA labour of love by the poor man rather than an exhaustively-researched magnum opus, and clearly the interesting focal point is how resilient complete nonsense can be.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gfd 5y agoSounds like a case of Mandela effect: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandela_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandela_effect
- pessimizer 5y agoThe "Mandela Effect" is the dumbest of all meme "Effects." It should be renamed the "I didn't pay attention to apartheid or notice when or how it ended" effect. Until you linked me to the wiki page, I hadn't realize it was coined by a "paranormal consultant."
- notahacker 5y agoReminded me of how someone once summarised the Mandela effect to me "Remember when Nelson Mandela died in prison? No, neither do I" I've never heard of brown Windsor soup, never mind been brought up believing in it.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoInterestingly if you search for "Brown Windsor Soup" in 19th century books on google there's quite a few hits. Click through and view the highlighted text - and its always "Brown Windsor Soap" - SOAP not SOUP. Presumably Googles AI enhanced OCR has misread. 1. https://www.google.com/search?q=%22brown+windsor+soup%22&biw=1440&bih=789&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A1800%2Ccd_max%3A1899&tbm=bks&sxsrf=AOaemvKufgwHcy_Alxb6K6XaOE48zsNznw%3A1642437423986&ei=L5vlYefrO9aVxc8P8Ye6wAg&ved=0ahUKEwinv-OZnLn1AhXWSvEDHfGDDogQ4dUDCAk&uact=5&oq=%22brown+windsor+soup%22&gs_lcp=Cg1nd3Mtd2l6LWJvb2tzEANQ2wJYkAxggA5oAHAAeACAAWuIAeYDkgEDMi4zmAEAoAEBwAEB&sclient=gws-wiz-books https://www.google.com/search?q=%22brown+windsor+soup%22&biw...
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoThe article mentions the soap: it was real, it was popular at the appropriate time period, and it's possible the "brown Windsor soup" was a combination of Windsor soup (a white soup) and brown Windsor soap to make it seem more horrible to the audience.
- cja 5y agoIs this article an early April fools joke?
- GrumpyNl 5y agoIn 80 days around the world, the main character Phileas Fogg, eats it all the time. Serie is now on the BBC.
- gadders 5y agoImagine if we brought a Spartan back to life and he told us Black Broth was a similar made up soup.
- hinkley 5y agoEvery time I play Civ VI, Sean Bean tells me, “History is the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon.”
- veltas 5y ago> It’s really, really weird, this mass hallucination going on. Honestly, all things considered, it's not that weird.
- evancox100 5y agoFor anyone interested in a great cookbook of classic American desserts with meticulously researched background and origin stories, I highly recommend “Bravetart” by Stella Parks. Some of the recipes can also be found on the Serious Eats website, but the historical background material is largely reserved for the book.
- giantg2 5y agoFirst thing that came to mind about food lies is city chicken. Obviously wrong time frame and location, but definitely seems like a big food lie, and possibly problematic for people of some religions if they actually think it's chicken.
- mbg721 5y agoIf you invented a soup that has thoroughly-researched period-appropriate ingredients and a much older cooking method, then the only lie is the name, right? If Britons at the time would just have called it "soup", then...mission accomplished?
- coldcode 5y agoElvis did not have bananas on his bacon sandwich, but blueberries? I will never believe such poppycock. Actually I have never tried either, so maybe either works!
- Daimanta 5y agoOk, so this peaked my interest, so I did some googling. If this soup were to be genuine, references to it should exist. In the 1968 'Report on soups' by the British Ministry of Agriculture (https://archive.org/embed/op1268165-1001 https://archive.org/embed/op1268165-1001), there is a reference on page 19 to this exact soup (called 'Windsor soup', 'Brown soup' or 'Eton soup'). It even lists the a basic list of ingredients. So this means this soup indeed exists. Now some further digging. Are there old references to either 'Windsor soup', 'Brown soup' or 'Eton soup' in non-fictional media? The 1892 'The encyclopædia of practical cookery' does not list this soup, although it is quite sparse on soups. The 1844 'A New System of Domestic Cookery' list a large amount of soups, none even vaguely hinting at the same name. However, the 1906 'High-class cookery recipes' (https://archive.org/embed/b21528597 https://archive.org/embed/b21528597) lists a 'Windsor soup' which should have a 'brown colour' as the basis. I think that should qualify as a 'brown roux' basis which at the very least lends some credence to a brown 'Windsor Soup' although I cannot verify the color myself. Anyway, that's the result of about 15 minutes of googling. At the very least, it makes me a bit sceptical of the article.