14 ms·
In my opinion, there shouldn't be. Documents like these shouldn't be automatically processed, they should be reviewed by humans. Reducing someone's life histor
by jeroenhd 5y ago
In my opinion, there shouldn't be.
Documents like these shouldn't be automatically processed, they should be reviewed by humans. Reducing someone's life history to a list of educational institutions and employers feels robotic even for a software developer's mindset.
I understand that there are real life problems because companies do use automated processing on applications, but that kind of behaviour shouldn't be encouraged.
- gingkoguy 5y agoAlso having this it will give you the User to make 1 resume and apply to millions of jobs. It’s a win / win situation
- selimthegrim 5y agoUnless you’re the employer being deluged
- stemlord 5y agoThere is maybe 1 in 50 jobs that I'd actually want, so I imagine bulk applying to would guarantee I land something awful.
- lethologica 5y agoNot everyone has the luxury of choice though when it comes to employment.
- drivingmenuts 5y agoDownside is when you have to make slight changes each time to better emphasize some aspect of your experience, depending on the job applied for. Recruiting agencies often do this to sex up their candidates chance of winning the job lottery.
- ravenstine 5y agoI wonder if there's any advantage in using fonts and layout that are adversarial to automated resume processing, as in if something fails to scan then perhaps a human is more likely to actually look at it. But perhaps HR just throws those out.
- viraptor 5y agoDoes anyone OCR? The systems I've heard of just extract the text from PDFs/docs. Then if some bits cannot be extracted, I was asked to type them myself.
- dpeck 5y agoQuaint to think so, but no. If a system is using automated scanning and the document doesn’t scan correctly the recruiter is not going through the ones that didn’t work. I’d wager in many cases they aren’t even aware of an failure to process a resume occurring.
- redisman 5y agoAlso in the eventual human review if you have made yours illegible on purpose, you probably lose any advantage you gained with passing te very low bar of automatic filtering
- pyrale 5y agoSome people do add an emoji in their name on linkedIn to know whether they are being contacted by someone who read the page, or by a bot.
- b112 5y agoAwesome! I may adopt this. Thanks
- brunellus 5y agoIndeed if there were a standard format, there would be competitive advantages to using other channels to showcase your experience
- snek_case 5y agoThat's already the case. You're much more likely to get hired if you know someone on the inside, if you've been recommended. If you apply through the official channels, you might not even get a response. But I think an official format for CVs might not work so well because CVs in different fields aren't formatted in the same way. A programmer isn't going to put forward the same kinds of things as a musician or a professor in psychology.
- xwdv 5y agoAs a hiring manager you’d be inclined to disagree. If resumes could be standardized and easily searchable for information it would help find candidates much more accurately and quickly without having to read. Even better would be if there was a verification standard where you could get a blue checkmark on your resume meaning all the information is accurate and not made up bullshit, then you could limit searches only to verified resumes and do less investigation or third party background checking. It pushes industries forward.
- pyrale 5y ago> If resumes could be standardized and easily searchable for information it would help find candidates much more accurately and quickly without having to read. I see how that can be useful from the recruiting side of the table, but fail to see how the candidate benefits.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoThink back to the first time you wrote a resume. For me and all of my college buddies at least, it was super stressful, because we had no idea what it was supposed to look like and nothing but vague rumors to go on. If there were a straightforward canonical answer for how my resume should be formatted it would have saved me quite a bit of work and quite a bit of stress that I was doing it wrong.
- jrockway 5y agoA standard requires people to agree. When I was in college, I was told that a resume was a list of buzzwords and past jobs. 1 page max. That got me quite a few jobs. When I interviewed at Google, people were like "this is it?" when looking at my resume (not that it mattered). I started doing interviews and saw the resumes that ended up at Google and they were all multi-page affairs with details about all the projects you worked on at a job. I started doing that, only to be told "wow, that's a really long resume". (Hint: if your role requires 10 years of experience, applicants are probably going to have a long resume!) The key point here, I guess, is that a lot of people have told me my resume is in the wrong format, but I still got the job. What's the right format for one employer is the wrong format for another employer. So there is no way to win. I now have no clue how to write a resume, but it also doesn't seem to matter. (Still bitter about how few people ever look at my Github, though. People put that as a custom field in their automated system, and then the interviewers have nothing to say about my projects!)
- moralestapia 5y ago>Documents like these shouldn't be automatically processed, they should be reviewed by humans. That's very nice to think about but in the real world if people don't match some exact keywords they get thrown away. HR is looking for "node.js" but you wrote it like "nodejs"? Though luck pal, bye. HR wants a "computer scientist" but you have a degree in "computer science"? Same, automatically discarded. If anything, a standard format would at least allow people to classify themselves/others correctly and without ambiguity.
- WalterBright 5y agoI asked a tech recruiter once how long he looked at a resume before deciding to trash it or file it. He said 2 seconds. He said he looked at about 1000 resumes a week. After a while, you can tell in 2 seconds if it is worth pursuing or not.
- mcenedella 5y agoThis is not really an issue. Most resume ATSs enable fuzzy searching on stems and similar keywords.
- dahart 5y agoYour argument makes the case for human reviewers. The examples are a stretch though. I've never heard of anyone losing an interview due to their spelling of nodejs or computer science. I don't buy that's something that happens often enough to spread FUD over.
- zopa 5y agoSo what? You're looking at it one job at a time, and for any one given job it might indeed suck. But collectively, the times when you're unfairly tossed out are balanced by the times when other people are, and you benefit from being in a smaller pool. If you spell it "nodejs," surely some HR person somewhere does too. It's random, and not based on any job-relevant differences, for sure. But hiring is always going to be pretty random so long as we're pretty bad at predicting who'll be good at any given job. So long as there's no systemic bias, it's fine, and selection by idiosyncratic spelling is at least much less biased than a lot of other irrelevant criteria that get used in hiring.
- laumars 5y agoUnfortunately the lack of a standardised format hasn’t stopped technology from being developed which automatically reviews CVs before they hit a human. The tech is already out there. The problem we have currently is that some CVs fail that review because they’re in a format that the tools cannot parse. If you’re CV is strong but you’re seeing fewer responses despite having a prettier CV compared to your peers, then that might be the reason. So from your stance standardisation might actually help the industry rather than harm it.
- indymike 5y ago> The problem we have currently is that some CVs fail that review because they’re in a format that the tools cannot parse. My company (we have software for responding to applicants in real time... think apply... instant conversation with a human recruiter) did a study of about 1,200 resumes and found that 14% of resumes had inaccuracies that would cause them to be screened out... and about 9% of resumes were in a unparsable format. A lot of the screening we see out there is really bad - mostly text search looking for key phrases like specific colleges, specific employers or specific skills. If you are imagining indexing resumes with elastic search and making queries, that may actually be better than state of the art which is usually something that turns into a SQL query.
- laumars 5y agoGiven a lot of these tools cannot even parse CVs with inlined tables, the tools I’m imagining aren’t sophisticated in the slightest. But they are depressingly common.
- mcenedella 5y ago10 - 15% are typically unparsable, typically PDFs encoded as graphics, and to a lesser extent, Linkedin exports. 14% with incomplete information also sounds right. And I also concur with you on the screening being pretty basic, not ES level of sophistication at all.
- indymike 5y ago
- HPsquared 5y agoCurrently they are automatically processed - poorly.
- tqi 5y ago> Documents like these shouldn't be automatically processed, they should be reviewed by humans. Human review is fraught with bias. A lot of attention and column inches are devoted to algorithmic bias these days, but let's not confuse that for evidence that human review is perfect or even better. It's just harder to audit.
- dahart 5y agoI don't think anyone is confusing algorithmic bias for evidence that humans are better. It's the other way around -- the argument has always been that algorithms are biased because humans are biased. Having a systemic bias that masquerades as neutral seems worse than having people in the loop. When submitting my resume and interviewing for jobs, I'd certainly prefer to be subject to: 1) multiple people with different biases, 2) humans that can change their mind and/or recognize their biases, 3) humans that can explain their rationale, and 4) humans that can grasp and weight eccentric and non-conforming experience. I'm not interested in being ranked in a standardized way, because I'm not interested in being a pure cog in wheel. I also think people who want standardized resumes and automated processing are vastly underestimating the SEO effect it will have on hiring. If resumes are automated, then many people more aggressive than you will game the system to the Nth degree. The same thing that happens to Google and the internet will happen to jobs: the loudest and spammiest will win, and the good content will go mostly unnoticed and unrewarded.
- plafl 5y agoI think resistance to algorithms is about failure modes. If an algorithm becomes standard and you are an edge case then you are in trouble, much the same way you are in trouble today with companies that have automated customer support and make it hard to contact a human being. Losing your email account is annoying but not being able to have a job is worse. Automated systems are designed to avoid mistakes but are bad at correcting mistakes. I would argue that even with humans involved the hiring process is harder to some people, even discounting bias, just because it is more or less standard but at least they have hope in the variance that remains.
- skittleson 5y agoI've seen thousands of resumes... it would be nice to have a baseline of requirements for specific positions. An RFC style guide for human parsing . Too many resumes miss what is important.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoKnowing life, the end result would be multiple competing standards and weird clans would form along with studies proving that, statistically speaking, standard X people are different from standard Z people. Edit: Humans are weird. I guess current ecosystem is not as bad as it could be ( even though it does suck ).
- curious_cat_163 5y ago" Reducing someone's life history to a list of educational institutions and employers feels robotic ... but that kind of behaviour shouldn't be encouraged." Reviewing CVs is boring. They should be made easy for the human who is reading. Imagine being a person in a human resources department going through 100s of these... If there was a good portable format, that process becomes far more efficient and interesting. A good interview after the resume has been accepted would go into precisely what you are advocating for -- the life history and interpersonal context.
- PakG1 5y agoWhether or not it should happen doesn't answer the question of why it hasn't happened. The fact is that the very companies that do automated processing of applications probably would welcome resume standardization, so why didn't they do it yet? It's in their power to propose a standard, settle on it, and require it. I suspect the answer as to why it hasn't happened is simply because most laypeople applicants would find it too difficult to do something like LaTeX or whatever other thing would be necessary to make this a reality, and also, firms in general suck at adopting new technology.
- julian_sark 5y ago> laypeople applicants would find it too difficult > to do something like LaTeX or whatever Those people where a CV and certificates matter, they already construct a CV in the closed system of LinkedIn or Monster's websites. Nobody needs to use LaTeX, there will be websites where anyone can do it, if anything that's an additional business opportunity. No, I suspect the actual reason is: Nobody will do it unless the big players (LinkedIn etc.) will adopt it. And the big players don't do it because interoperability, and a CV that can be migrated anywhere, isn't in their interests.
- mcenedella 5y agoA really great resume gets beyond the company names and educational institutions to demonstrate, with concrete numbers, how you improved things at your employer. Reduced latency by 350 ms Increased engagement by 18% Reduced AWS spending by 23% Scaled from 13 to over 300 virtual machines That sort of specificity and numerical quantification is what makes a great resume stand out.
- tomcat27 5y ago> educing someone's life history to a list of educational institutions and employers feels robotic even for a software developer's mindset. that's a flawed view imo. there could be plenty of catch-all sections to maintain "descriptions" resume content expectations are largely driven by industry. i've not heard of someone reading resume more than 10s. the whole job posting industry dug themselves into a meaningless, needless task: parsing resume pdfs. heck, some even use "AI" for it.
- vfulco2 5y agoI totally agree but we are fighting the tide (ran a resume, linkedin profile, and interview prep shop for 6 years). Everything in the process is being analyzed, parsed and benchmarked using AI, soon to a more granular level. I even came across some interview analysis software which measured the angle of the person's head along with tone and a bunch of other factors!
- aparticulate 5y ago> I understand that there are real life problems because companies do use automated processing on applications, but that kind of behaviour shouldn't be encouraged. Ignoring the web, we already do some formatting with the common Education/Work experience trope. We could arrange resumes arbitrarily just to mess with employers, perhaps? They are already pretty easy to parse.
- black_puppydog 5y agoI agree they should be read by humans, but (and I feel most comments are missing that point) a standard format would help with that. Having been reading resumes a lot lately, I always breathe a sigh of relief when people hand in the standard latex template, with maybe only the colors changed. The structure is immediately familiar and easy to navigate. I could use a client app that presents a hypothetical standard data format in such a way. My colleagues in sales or customer success on the other hand seem to prefer other formatting styles; they could look at their candidates in that way.
- pithon 5y agoWhat do you mean by "the" standard LaTeX template?
- jjgreen 5y agoModernCV? https://ctan.org/pkg/moderncv https://ctan.org/pkg/moderncv
- black_puppydog 5y agoExactly. That one. Example: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/56/Moderncv_classic_green.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/56/Moderncv... Note that I'm not arguing that this it the best presentation possible for a CV. I'm just arguing that having a uniform presentation between CVs reduces the mental burden of filtering through them. (And if you want to get into that, might reduce bias, especially if you don't include the image in the presentation)
- colordrops 5y agoWhat about recipes though
- barankilic 5y agoYet, companies use AST tools, which automatically processes the CVs and resumes. One person that is developing such a tool recommended collage students not to add too much links to their CVs because otherwise, their CV will be flagged as a malicious document.
- zeepzeep 5y ago> I understand that there are real life problems because companies do use automated processing on applications I'll always remember but never find the post, where someone just hid tons of keywords in a joke resume and got interviews with an alarmingly high success rate.
- throwaddzuzxd 5y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/qhg5jo/this_resume_got_me_an_interview/ https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/qhg5jo/this... It might be this one?
- julian_sark 5y agoThey should. You are correct on that. Reality is, however and in my experience, that more and more HR departments fall for promises of AI snake oil. Virtually every employer I apply with has it's own portal, often times asking you to construct your CV anew on their website (often with drop downs that don't include the actual job title or skill). Preferably with a five minute web session and no submit confirmation. Couple this with companies increasingly not responding at all due to fear of being sued, and you'll spend hours on an application and won't even know whether the non-response is due to you, or due to the website trashing the submission. As for CV parsing, this has gone so far as to a big news site over here posting helpful articles on how to beat the system. "Favorite" tidbit: Submit two CV - one for humans, one for dumb algorithms. Oh and btw, I'm applying at non-tech companies increasingly. Maybe humans isn't perfect either. I mean, I submit proof of 25 years of high grade enterprise IT experience, just for some HR person to ask me where my certificate as an "IT technian" is: they don't know what any of that "weird stuff" means, but to them I lack a generic "IT technician" certificate in early career. A thing that didn't even exist back then! But the latter may just well be a quirk of my own, bureaucratic country. But overall, this is a hot mess already, and I have often times had the same thought: Why can't we have some sort interchangeable format, much like "geek code", just for all the possible job titles, universities, locations, and companies; with some format-dependent, but free text fields because one can never catch all of them in a fixed list?
- 7952 5y agoI guess you could have a pdf with a hidden text layer full of tags and keywords.
- pqb 5y agoCV or resume analyzed by non-human? Or in an universal format? I hope this will never happen. How "automatized" way could help there? Unifying the CV/resumes for certain company? Sure, if they are have some form - could be stupid Google Form or more sophisticated like Teamtailor [0] - go ahead. You will have a nice databases or resumes and profiles similar to mini-LinkedIn. While I am fan of automation, I don't see any special incentive here that will profit HR team. I know hundreds of examples, where CV nor initial job interview didn't exactly has shown how good someone is. Also, I personally had experienced a situation I have completely matched the job offer but after talk during interview, I knew it would be waste of time and mentally it will be a bad choice for next year(s) to join their Acme corp. Do the JSON databases of applicants will help anyhow to solve the human relation job to find out the best candidate for the position? I am highly skeptical and in my humble opinion it will just "dehumanify" the whole process. Maybe, it is good if you are looking for some warehouse worker like Amazon? /s [0]: https://www.teamtailor.com/en/ https://www.teamtailor.com/en/
- noneeeed 5y agoI think you might be underestimating the number of applicants that some companies deal with. I used to work for a firm that did analytics and surveying for the recruitment industry. While applicant to hire ratios in the tech industry might be 10 to 1, in many jobs you can easily be looking at 100 to 1. At those scales companies are using automated CV scanning tools and outsourced humans to whittle them down to a set that hiring managers can actually cope with. This is why many companies insist that you enter all the information into a structured form. My basic rule of thumb is that the more structured and formal the CV submission process is, the worse the applicant to hire ratio will be, and so the more people you are up against. For those of us in the tech industry, especially later in our careers, that probably isn't an issue, but in many other jobs, and earlier in your carreer, then it's going to be an issue. I remember having to re-enter my CV into ATSs back in 2001 for the big companies hiring graduates because they had so many to get throught, smaller companies just wanted your CVs.