16 ms·
DSLRs are dead, and lenses are never going to be the same
- voisin 5y agoI would love to buy an adapter to connect my iPhone to DSLR lenses. I have no idea if this is possible. I hate the workflow on DSLRs.
- melissalobos 5y agoIt looks like a whole bunch of people have done this, if you search for "phone dslr lens diy", you can find videos like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FOtctDtdo44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FOtctDtdo44
- frostburg 5y agoIt is possible but the iphone has a tiny sensor with other lenses on top that you can't easily remove. You would also have issues with lenses that use electronic aperture control. Overall not really practical.
- blagie 5y agoIt's a really, really, really bad idea. dSLR lenses are designed for sensors which are 24mm x 36mm. Cell phone sensors vary, but a largish one might be around 6x8mm. That's not to mention issues like autofocus. There were a few attempts to bridge this gap, which attach a large sensor to your phone. The best-known ones are the Sony QX1 and the Olympus Air. They never took off. I think that was due to very poor execution. I though the Olympus Air was close, but had a few complete showstopper issues which made it unusable. A v2 might have done well, but instead, Olympus gave up. A few cameras are getting improved workflows with interfacing to cell phones, so perhaps we'll get there another way.
- frostburg 5y agoHonestly smartphone workflow are just bad for different reasons. The best UX in digital photography is found in Leica rangefinders and Hasselblad / PhaseOne detachable medium format backs (not really the mirrorless medium format Hasselblad or Fuji cameras which have the usual awful menu systems).
- blagie 5y agoIt depends on what you want out of a workflow. As I'm getting older, I'm finding I like taking photos, viewing photos, and I hate editing photos. For 99% of what I do, cell for workflows would be great, if not for the privacy issues. Google takes my photos, and sometimes shows me "this day 3 years ago" or a nice montage. I like that. I like having raw files for that 1% of photos I will edit, but that's a much less important use.
- frostburg 5y agoOf course, yes. My issue with phones (besides the limitations in acuity, DR, etc.) is that they unpredictabily decide a lot by themselves in an opaque fashion.
- blagie 5y agoMy preferred workflow would be: - Camera unpredictably decides a lot by itself in an opaque fashion. I get useful automation for family photos. - I get a RAW file if I want to decide something different or if I'm printing and framing a photo 99% of the photos I shoot fit in the former category, but the 1% in the latter is about equally important (1 framed photo is worth a lot more than a random cell phone snapshot).
- sudosysgen 5y agoRAW+Jpeg with a modern mirrorless in Aperture priority and vivid presets does that for me. Send off all the pics into Amazon Photos or Google Photos, put the RAWs in my NAS, and edit them whenever I want to.
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoBack in the day, hobbyists looking for a cine look would hook up a kind of adapter to use SLR or cine lenses with a consumer camcorder. Of course the camcorders had tiny sensors behind fixed lenses, so what was happening was the adapter had a bit of vibrating ground glass onto which the external lens was projecting its image, like a viewfinder, and the camcorder recorded that. The effect looked very good. Manual focus of course but this was considered desireable. I'm not suggesting this as a commercial solution, I just thought it was very inventive.
- alexashka 5y agoNope. Lenses are designed for a specific sensor size. Phones have tiny sensors.
- voisin 5y agoOk, I get that. In that case, it would be fantastic if someone created professional lenses for smart phones. The nearest I’ve seen are nowhere near the capabilities for telephoto.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe thing is, if you wanted to get a 200mm lens with equivalent quality to the main lens in the iPhone 13 Max, it would need to be 8 times wider and 8 times longer. That's around 5cm long and 3cm wide. Just doesn't work.
- petre 5y agoNot practical because of physics. It would ruin phone ergonomics and you'd end up with a brick. Or maybe requirea cumbersome adapter and lens assembly. New flagship phone camera assemblies are big and ugly enough as it is. Phones with 3 or 4 cameras because the consumer demands it.
- pomian 5y agoA cool trick, although takes practice to get it right, is shoot with camera through a binocular lens. Can do that with SLR lenses too, similar issues: light leakage, stability, edge effects, etc. But it's fun.
- cletus 5y agoI get why this is happening but it still makes me sad. There's really no better experience than being able to look through the viewfinder, track the target and have a pretty good idea of the composition (the viewfinder is typically 95-99% of the frame). Any mirrorless system has limitations on low light and latency (of reading the light and then displaying it on a separate screen). This has gotten better but it can never really compete with the sensitivity of a human eye and low latency of passing through a prism (or mirror). The article mentioned compatibility and flange distance but didn't really explain why this is the case. Take the two big 35mm DSLR players of the 20th century Nikon and Canon. Nikon introduced the F mount in 1959 [1]. These were manual focus lenses. Autofocus came much later. Nikon chose compatibility to the point that you can buy a DSLR and a manual focus F mount lens from 1960 and it will work. Canon OTOH had a number of lens mounts (eg FD). When Canon introduced autofocus they bit the bullet and broke backwards compatibility to introduce a new mount, the EF [2] in 1987. Oddly, this situation kind of reminds me of how Java and C# introduced generics, each with a different philosophy. But the point is that Canon learned from its "mistakes" and corrected them with EF and benefitted from it. None of this really explains why DSLRs are dying though. This chart [3] does. Digital cameras in part funded DSLR development and phones killed the digital camera market (~85% drop in sales from the peak). I like digital cameras. Generally speaking picture quality is better, optics are better, framerates are better and the form factor allows things that phones can't do (eg waterproof to 40m, shooting 1080p at ~1000fps, 100x optical zooms). But they're a pain in the ass to use. I think this is a failing of camera manufacturers not to integrate seamlessly with phones. Like why can't I pair a camera with my phone and have photos just transfer to the phone automatically? I end up never using digital cameras because I simply can't be bothered with the steps required to do something with that photo. Phones solve that so much better. Lastly, it's worth pointing out that at this point only two companies produce digital camera sensors at any kind of volume: Canon and Sony. Sony literally produces almost everything else. This volume and market hold gives them economies of scale that no one can compete with. But Sony also makes phone camera sensors so Sony really doesn't lose anything if you buy a camera instead of a phone of vice versa. This probably contributed to manufacturers not caring at the smartphone revolution that literally destroyed that industry. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikon_F-mount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikon_F-mount [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EF_lens_mount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EF_lens_mount [3]: https://www.statista.com/chart/5782/digital-camera-shipments/ https://www.statista.com/chart/5782/digital-camera-shipments...
- geerlingguy 5y agoNot dead, so much as not being made anymore, in the same quantities as before. I still shoot Timelapses with my Nikon D700 and use it as a backup camera for some event photography. I often use my old Nikon 60mm f/2.8 macro lens I picked up years ago for a song. I figure many people will be able to purchase amazing lenses (maybe not the legendary ones, those will always be collectible) for a very good price as more of the (admittedly shrinking) photographers of the world switch systems and get tired of adapting their old lenses.
- cruelty2 5y agoNot a day too soon. This is probably caused by dwindling accidental buys and the user realizing how much of a pain they are to use
- nullifidian 5y agoI would add that lenses are never going to be the same in that the latest mirror-less full frame lenses, even the higher-end ones (which cost $1000-2500 and more) are increasingly made out of greater proportion of plastic than the DSLR lenses (Canon EF, Nikon F). Even the mount is attached with screws that first go through a plastic frame, which consequently contains at best a partially metal assembly, which was fully metal previously. I'm not familiar with how well do modern plastics age, but suspect that it's not as well as the old metal lenses (50ies onwards) which are still usable. So it's more of a planned obsolescence trend in my opinion. And the increasing reliance on digital post processing for correcting optical aberrations like distortion and chromatic aberration. Some Micro Four Thids lenses' raw files are downright unusable without such corrections.
- IdontRememberIt 5y agoSoft plastics on my nikon are an issue. I have noticed that they tend to deteriorate quickly on beach holidays. I suspect it is a combination of Sun, residues of solar cream on the hands and the salt in the air.
- petre 5y agoYou mean the grip? Nikon rubber grips are notorious for falling apart. Which is part of why I sold all my digital Nikon gear when they were tone deaf and peddalled dSLRs and the dumbed down 1 system. Went with the m43. It's not an open standard but it's considerably more open than others.
- formerly_proven 5y agoDo you mean the "rubber textured" plastic on the D50, D70 etc.?
- petre 5y agoYes. And the D700, D800 etc. It isn't so much of a problem now with 3d printing and so many materials being available.
- yardie 5y agoNo talk of the micro-4/3rds? I found them to be technically superior to dSLRs and way more compact since they don't need prism and shutter.
- cthalupa 5y agoThey're not really even in the discussion when it comes to being real replacements for DSLRs. Their sensor size is significantly smaller than even a crop frame dslr/mirrorless camera, and roughly a quarter of the size of a full frame camera. This smaller sensor size means they're not going to be used at the prosumer or pro level, and that in turn means a limited selection of high end lenses, etc.
- LegitShady 5y agomicro 4/3 is just a mirrorless sensor format. It is competing with other mirrorless sensor formats, many with full size sensors. I have mirrorless cameras with APS-C or larger sensors, so the micro 4/3 format is just a smaller sensor.
- petepete 5y agoAnother factor working against them is that we're starting to see bodies that are very comparable to M43 ones. Sony's full frame A7C is 124 x 71 x 60 mm. For comparison a Panasonic GH5 is 138.5 x 98.1 x 87.4 mm and an Olympus's OMD em10 120 x 83 x 47 mm.
- perardi 5y agoIt's not clear how much longer that'll be a thing. Olympus divested its camera operations to some third-party holding company. I am skeptical they'll have the capital and expertise to really be competitive. (https://www.dpreview.com/news/0412395347/olympus-finalizes-deal-with-jip-to-sell-its-imaging-business https://www.dpreview.com/news/0412395347/olympus-finalizes-d...) And Panasonic doesn't seem to really be in it anymore, save for their video-focused cameras. They have a new full-frame mount now.
- nottorp 5y agoOk silly non specialist and even non hobbyist question. The only reason I own a DSLR (the cheapest Nikkon I could find) is because I hate looking at a LCD. With how (d)slrs are set up what I see in that view finder is what i get in the photo. Mirrorless cameras only have the LCD right? Is there any option that fixes that? Note that there may be a camera category that I don't know about that fixes my problem. If yes, please tell me which it is :)
- frostburg 5y agoLeica M cameras and Fuji X-pros have optical viewfinders.
- Lio 5y agoFuji’s specialist X100 series actually have both optical and electronic viewfinders. I’ve had a few. First generation I mostly used the optical finder. Over time they’ve improved enough that I mainly use the electronic one now. I like that you can see how the film simulation and exposure will look before you take the shot.
- mulmen 5y ago> I like that you can see how the film simulation and exposure will look before you take the shot. This is an important insight. Optical viewfinders show you what will hit the sensor. Electronic viewfinders show you what you get.
- sudosysgen 5y agoNot even, actually. Optical viewfinders have a different optical path, and you will see a different image. For example, you'll get incorrect behaviour at large apertures.
- Lio 5y agoThat’s true for rangefinder style cameras but not for SLRs. Most optical viewfinders will allow you to stop down for preview at the correct aperture. There’s a useful feature on the X100 series to give you the framing offset.
- formerly_proven 5y agoSmall differences in flange distance are less important than is often thought in the photo-tech-gawking sphere because it doesn't per se limit the back-focal distance of a lens design; note how in most non-tele lenses the back element is inside the mount or protudes out of the lens mount. Flange distance is merely a property of the mechanical interface, not an optical property. E.g. some people argue that Canon RF has to be worse than Nikon Z because the flange distance is 2 mm longer, but if you look at the available designs both have lenses with a BFD of 10 or 11 mm. The article mentions image-side telecentrism for reduced aberrations. This is another talking point often brought forth; "the big mount allows a rear element so big that it can cover the image sensor with a near-telecentric swath of rays". Again, if you do a reality check here you'll notice that the chief ray angle (the angle between the chief ray of a ray bundle on the image circle to the image plane; chief rays are those crossing the center of the aperture) in actual lens designs is nowhere near 0° and is instead somewhere between 35-50°. Part of that equation is certainly that microlenses are offset as you leave the center of the sensor, so essentially sensors are designed for a particular range of CRAs and will not do well if you go way out of that range. Like the wide-angle rangefinder primes usually did: putting these on a digital camera results in strange color shifts towards the edges of the frame.
- azalemeth 5y agoI'm moderately convinced that this is all about manufacturing costs. SLRs are complex beasts with mechanical parts that need to be made to very tight tolerances and eventually wear out. The physicist in my knows that numerical aperture, the various inevitable trade-offs made in lens design and ultimately sensor size are really what limits optical performance. Going mirrorless means that you can spend the budget on these components rather than the mirrorbox and pentaprism / pentamirror on the top and the associated electronics with the viewfinder. It's not necessarily a bad thing, but it is above all a business decision and not really a scientific one. I personally like my [pentax] dSLR a lot -- the batteries last for ever as a consequence of the fact that most of the time all the power-hungry electrical components are off. The optical compensation with the viewfinder and my eye works perfectly, and I like the fact that, unlike an EVF, it will give me a human representation of how bright or dark a scene is. Put a long telephoto lens on, and watch everything get darker. I very much "feel" that the process of pressing the shutter button connects me with the physics of what I am doing in a very visceral way.
- Aardwolf 5y agoExcuse me for this very uninformed question, but (D)SLR, as far as I can tell, is about using a prism to split light, to allow having a viewfinder. Why does a digital camera need a prism for it, can't the digital sensor directly show the image on screen (or viewfinder, do photographers still look through a viewfinder?) Or does DSLR stand here for any camera with exchangeable lenses? Does the article mean professional cameras with exchangeable lenses are dead?
- Lio 5y agoYep totally possible, that’s what a mirrorless camera like micro-4/3 does. Many DSLRs also let lock the mirror up and just view via sensor. In theory running the sensor continuously generates heat that can lead to image noise. Realistically though the sensors are now so good that you don’t need to worry about it.
- frostburg 5y agoDigital cameras don't really need it but DSLR cameras needed the apparatus for phase detection autofocus anyway. This isn't really a concern anymore.
- tticvs 5y agoWhat you are describing is called a "mirrorless" camera which is what the article says will be the future. They also have interchangeable lenses, but there are less constraints on the design since they don't have to interface with another optical system, just the digital sensor, which is the main point the article is trying to make.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> can't the digital sensor directly show the image on screen A bunch of them do - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_viewfinder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_viewfinder - but a screen or viewfinder isn't going to have the same kind of resolution as your eyes when you're trying to judge focus/DoF/etc.
- hylaride 5y agoA digital camera doesn’t need a prism…anymore. When DSLRs first came to market two decades ago, they didn’t do video. Even if they did, the batteries at the time wouldn’t have held up for long shoots for weddings, sporting events, etc if they were showing video in the screen. As the article states, the move to mirrorless cameras is now pretty much a given. Canon announced their latest DSLR will be the last.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoSo by removing the mirror, you remove the lag in the camera systems making future camera's become more like human eye capture units which then has implications for AI development.
- aparticulate 5y agoThe largest market of photography dilettentes (like me) switched to phone. Most people just want a shitload of bokeh (real or software), sharp wide angle without a lot of distortion and ability to zoom without losing too much detail. Besides, most Good Photographs are 90% technique/framing/instinct/editing NOT hardware. (Just get closer to your subject.) "The camera you have with you..", too. So, that only really leaves Pro wedding, sports, and, journalists and that just isn't nearly as big a market as the golden age of late 00s DSLR Flickr hobbyism
- devbas 5y agoPersonally I really enjoy doing analog photography. As the feedback loop is very long, technique is important. Also, since the number of pictures is limited, I always have to ask myself the question: is there actually a picture here?
- aparticulate 5y agoAnalog has all the tactile aspects I miss from DSLR and more, I definitely take more analog than I used to. I also think there's a noticable gulf between fake analog and real, even on screen. The most skillful photoshop creations still looks totally off to me. Phone + an old analog camera is an incredible setup imo
- noahtallen 5y agoDefinitely true. I did photography as a hobby, but phones match or exceed the performance in many cases now. For example, low-light mode on phones outperforms older entry-level canon DSLRs (T3/T6) by default without having to twiddle with the settings. Of course, you could get better pictures with these cameras, but it takes time and a really good lense! So in other words, it’s just not ideal for quick pictures around the house. I think there are two areas where phone cameras have a lot of room for improvement: sharpness and landscape. By sharpness, I mean that if you zoom into any phone picture, it falls apart very quickly. There is a lot of software optimization hiding how a small sensor can’t actually do that well in the details. By landscape, I mean if you take a picture of a mountain or object in the far distance, you’ll barely be able to see it in the phone because the lenses are so wide. It really makes nature pictures underwhelming :)
- ur-whale 5y agoI think the camera industry has yet to realize the amount of processing power that's available in modern chips. Once they do, the very concept of lenses as we know them is likely going to evolve drastically: at the end of the day, the signal captured by the physical CCD needs not in any way to look like the finished product (the final photo). They've realized that for color already (CCD captures a signal that's heavily processed for color before final delivery, eg debayering + color correction). Wait till they realize they can pull off the same trick with geometry, the entire discussion in this thread will become moot in a heartbeat.
- mmaunder 5y agoYou still need the data. And most pro film and still shooters shoot raw which is either pre debayering or partially debayered as is the case with BMD.
- ur-whale 5y ago> You still need the data. You're entirely missing my point. The "data" as you call it can come in all shape and forms, as long as it contains enough information to rebuild what the camera "saw" The "data" could come from 150 sensors arranged in a geometric pattern that completely alleviate the need for a traditional lens (see telescope arrays).
- lm28469 5y agoPhysics > algorithms. Just look at iphone bokeh (background blur), it's utterly disgusting. Nothing beats real world light rays hitting a large sensor, the larger the better (that's why 4x5 cameras still shit on modern 150mpx sensors). CCD aren't used btw, they all migrated to CMOS
- ur-whale 5y ago> Just look at iphone bokeh Does the human eye have bokeh? Or are you just enamored with an artifact produced by existing sub-par technology after having been exposed to it for long enough that you now have Stockholm syndrome?
- mmaunder 5y agoClarification on Canon discontinuing EF lenses: https://petapixel.com/2021/04/22/canon-clarifies-discontinuing-26-ef-lenses-series-optimization/ https://petapixel.com/2021/04/22/canon-clarifies-discontinui... Not that several camera makers make EF mount cameras and third party lens makers make EF mount lenses, like Yongnuo, Samyang, Schneider, Sigma, Tamron, Tokina, Cosina and Carl Zeiss. Be very careful investing in lenses that have a short flange focal distance. In other words, where the distance from the mount to the sensor is short. We went big on Sony E mount primes for shooting video. When we moved to Blackmagic Design Ursa and pocket cine cameras with Canon mounts we couldn’t adapt the lenses and had to get rid of them. The general point here is that as you grow as a shooter your needs will change and you’ll be far happier if you can adapt your old lenses somehow. You can, for example, put an EF mount lens on a Sony E mount camera, but not the other way around. What my media dept has done is to standardize on Canon EF mount lenses. We now have a great collection of L series and cine lenses that will work on everything from our 5Ds to BMD Ursa 12K to our pocket cine cameras. Don’t get vendor locked in and make sure you retain a few options.
- petre 5y agoDo the EF lenses retain the autofocus capability on cine cameras or do you even need it in cinematography? The only drawback with longer flange is more complicated designs for wide angle lenses. That didn't stop Canon from making a rectilinear 15 mm EF lens.
- starky 5y ago>Not that several camera makers make EF mount cameras and third party lens makers make EF mount lenses, like Yongnuo, Samyang, Schneider, Sigma, Tamron, Tokina, Cosina and Carl Zeiss. They are being discontinued at these manufacturers as well. I was looking into validating a range of EF mount lenses for a specific application a couple years ago and for every vendor we talked to, they indicated that some of their lenses were either newly discontinued or soon to be discontinued. No matter what the lens manufacturers are saying, I'm confident that they will slowly be discontinuing their DSLR lines over the coming few years.
- rileyphone 5y agoOne of the nicer parts of mirrorless cameras the article touches on briefly is the reduced focal distance makes it easy to adapt older lenses with just a cheap tube. Combine with focus peaking in viewfinder and sensor image stabilization and you have a great platform for messing around with cheaper vintage glass like the classic Helios lens. I’m hoping to get a Sony A7 II as it has all these features, but it is hard to stomach watching the price go up over time on a 7 year old camera!
- sudosysgen 5y agoI have an A7ii, and I did the same with cheap vintage glass. It is quite amazing! Eventually I upgraded to older canon EF lenses with a Metabones adapter I found on local classifieds for 100$. The AF isn't amazing, but it's good.
- biztos 5y agoI can’t quite RTFA because I have an ad blocker, but I will say — Full-frame mirrorless is a revolution in cheap lenses for anyone serious about artistic photography. Which I hope would include most cinematographers. Last summer I bought a 40-year-old lens in so-so condition on Etsy for $20 and have made wonderful photos with it. I plan to spend more on old glass. This is only possible because the mirrorless systems allow adapting these lenses where most DSLR systems did not. And a lot of the old glass makes nicer pictures — not sharper, but nicer. Just search eBay for “canon FD lens Japan” and you will find the tip of this wonderful iceberg.
- themodelplumber 5y ago(I tried reading the article without an ad blocker. When I was nearing the end, a full screen modal popped up. Closing it caused the browser to instantly return to the top of the article. Sigh...) That's interesting about the old glass. Personally I'm into portable superzooms lately, because of the usual distance to fauna in my area, and also it's fun to ID and capture the big passenger jets at sunset. But I'd really like to explore the kinds of lenses you mentioned someday. You can definitely see a difference with the lens changes.
- spekcular 5y ago"And a lot of the old glass makes nicer pictures — not sharper, but nicer." I hear this a lot, and every time I grow more skeptical. On every conceivable technical measure, new lenses are superior to older ones. The single advantage of old lenses is, as you say, they are cheap. (I got a metal Nikon 50mm f/1.4, manual focus, for less than $100 on eBay!) Unless you can point to some objective property of older lenses in general that assists them in taking better pictures, I'm forced to conclude that this claim is just a photographic superstition. For certain lenses, like the old Nikon 105 2.5, you might be able to do this! But for old lenses in general I think not. (Another thought: maybe you find the extra distortion and tint of old lenses pleasing?)
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoI think you're onto something at the end there! The commenter was almost certainly talking about subjectively "nicer" photos that have been made more interesting by the use of flawed lenses. And this isn't an uncommon idea either. It is the idea behind lensbaby, Lomography, and the slightest resurgence of Polaroid.
- Helmut10001 5y agoNot sure about the lenses in the title - they state that most lenses will remain compatible with newer mounts and some vintage lenses even increase in popularity. So, this is like it has always been: Buy expensive lenses, to keep them over 30+ years. Buy cameras every 5-10 years, to get the new features. I have 15k worth of lenses and they stick with me across camera upgrades. I am not as far as attached to my cameras.
- dylan604 5y agoCamera bodies have pretty much become annual upgrades like phones. There's nothing wrong with the one you have, but the new one just has that "one more thing" to them.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI disagree. There has been basically no improvement in image quality (a tiny bit) since the Sony A7r2, which is now 7 years ago. The image quality of phones still improves a lot every year, though they are approaching their limit.
- Helmut10001 5y agoIt is less about image quality but more about what you can do with the cameras. Smaller? 60fps? 120fps? 360°? AI? 40MP? 100MP? All of this _can_ be an argument to upgrade, even if image quality has improved zero.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe A7r2 can do 42MP. It's not really practical to have any more megapixels. The rest of the things are useless to 99.9% of people, so it's just a gimmick or convenience update. That's where we're at for cameras. Phones however still see big image quality improvements, and you could take pictures that were previously impossible as they added and improved suppmentary cameras.
- zwieback 5y agoGeneral trend in technology during my 55 years on the planet: moving parts get replaced once the replacing tech is good enough, at that point looking back is just nostalgia.
- smiley1437 5y agoIME the remaining advantage of SLRs is the speed of phase focusing over contrast focusing - moving subjects are much easier\faster to track with phase focusing. Has contrast focusing caught up yet?
- klodolph 5y agoFrom the reviews I've read, it sounds like contrast focusing is damn fast these days. A mirrorless system won't beat a DSLR under all conditions, but under most conditions, at the same price point.
- gaudat 5y agoPhase detection AF on the image sensor had been here for more than a few years. I remember the 5D2 (or 5D3) has a "Dual pixel AF" system that does phase detection. My A7m3 does phase detection if there is enough light and it is practically as quick as the DSLRs I used before.
- nikita2206 5y agoMirrorless cameras are using both contrast and phase detection these days
- nullc 5y agoModern mirrorless cameras (and some DSLRs) use phase detecting image sensors. E.g. on Canon R5 every pixel on the sensor is microlensed into two sub-pixels, one that sees the left half of the aperture and one that sees the right half. The difference between the two is the phase information for auto-focusing. The use of the image sensor for auto-focusing also means that the camera can use ML object detection to refine the focus point (e.g. eye-detection) and the camera can use optical flow for servo of moving subjects tracking. Without a viewfinder prism in the way the focusing sensor also receives more light, and it's not interrupted while a photo is being taken. So even though the on-sensor phase detectors are less good than the ones used in DSLRs there are a lot of offsetting benefits. The camera can even preserve the dual subpixel info in raw files, though there isn't yet much software to make use of the info in post-processing. In manual focus mode the camera can highlight the portion of the image that's in-focus according to the phase detection. It's pretty @#$@ amazing, especially when using a tilted lens.
- mancerayder 5y agoI used to be a big photography hobbyist and I'm slowly getting back into it. My interests were a) street photography b) portrait lighting / controlled lighting with remote strobes (a.k.a. strobist). I've owned Canon EF gear for decades, and the 'most recent' which is now old, is a 6D, and my best lens is a 35mm 1.4L from the early 2000's which I love. A few years ago I invested in Fuji gear, including the X100series and a XT-4 with two prime lenses. A couple of points. 1. DSLR's have big sensors and lenses. The 6D with lenses like the 35 1.4 which I have, and the 85 1.2 which I rented, have INSANE bokeh and low light performance. I don't claim to have a science background, but it's pretty well established that a bigger sensor size (the 6D has a 35mm size sensor) and a large aperture contribute to low light performance - the bigger aperture because you have a faster lens (it needs less light/you get away with a [edit] faster shutter speed) and less noise (the larger sensor has less noise artifact happening). This gives you a fair amount of creative flexibility in your settings. I thought about selling the 6D and the 35 but I'm having trouble 'letting go' even though I haven't used them in a while (and they are huge and heavy) 2. DLSR's have a hella lotta weight to them. When traveling, I used to travel with the 6D and a bunch of lenses (some I now sold including a 70-200 F4L with which I took pictures I'm proud of and want to keep forever). Well the stress of filling 30-50% of your luggage space with camera gear and nervously waiting your suitcase in the airport conveyor belt is one thing I don't miss, nor having to pick and choose which lenses on a hike. 3. Mirrorless has unlimited shutter speed, practically, since it's electronic. If you want to shoot against the sun, and turn your shutter speed so high that the world is dark, and you have controlled lighting with a probe, you can't do that with a 6D due to the slower shutter speed, since it's made up of physical curtains. This gets cool effects outdoors. 4. Mirrorless are obviously better street cameras, since they fit in your pocket / hand and aren't as visible. Once I got into a concert where no cameras were allowed, because the rule was, no cameras where the lens is removeable are allowed (that's only for paid pros in the concert). 5. Subjectively: I'm having a LOT of trouble steering myself away from the DSLR mindset, I'm finding myself reluctant to use the XT-4 for portrait type work. And I think I'm selling the X100F since I prefer 50 EFL instead of 35 EFL for the street.
- tristanperry 5y agoThat's an annoying blog. I was half way through reading when a full page "enter your email address" pop-up appeared. I closed it, and was sent to the top of the page again. (Samsung S20, Chrome).
- pwg 5y agoUblockOrigin, with default deny all JavaScript mode turned on, prevented any 'half way through popup' from appearing for me.
- djkoolaide 5y agoIf a website treats me this way, I close the tab without finishing the article.
- felubra 5y agoI recommend you installing Samsung Internet browser and using the Adblock Fast software to block ads. This browser has built-in support for blocking ads using the Adblock Fast. And if this not works, most of the time I just use the reading mode to bypass the paywalls and ads.
- anyfactor 5y agoI think there was a peak in hobby photography after the introduction of consumer grade DSLR cameras, which in my opinion is slowly fading away. The bulkiness of having a dedicated camera to take pictures, stopped making sense to me. For special photography needs I can rent or borrow a friends camera like my parents used to do in the SLR days. Like most other things in life we are progressively choosing convenience over features and photography just reached it's limit to add new and useful features.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> I think there was a peak in hobby photography By "hobby photography" it sounds like you mean SLR hobby photography. Of course, hobby photography has boomed off the charts with phones. Meanwhile, professional photography is nearly an extinct profession. Over the last 20 years, as print publications were replaced by online, the professions of journalist and press photographer declined to the point where they now hardly exist.
- anyfactor 5y agoSay you are buying a car at pre-tesla days. There is plenty of competition in the market and there is no clear market leader. You need to buy because you have to buy a car. The features never add much to anything and you make your decision based on recommendation and the reputation. Now, you are making cars and you want people to buy more car. How can they do that? Upping the speed of your average consumer vehicle? Making it more mobile? Making generic upgrades in comfort features? Essentially adding units to existing features isn't a viable sales strategy. They can do nothing to have an uptick in car sales by just adding units to the features they offer. Now you have the entire camera industry. Since the advent of decent mobile photography, you don't have to buy camera, so the manufacturer are already in a bad position. Then as far as innovation they are just adding units to existing features. More megapixels, better low light capabilities, higher FPS and that's about it. There isn't any effort or innovation in delivering something that is featurewise a new concept. There isn't anything that warrants someone to buy and carry it.
- zygy 5y agoWhat's the tech advancement/invention that pushed mirrorless cameras past DSLR?
- WithinReason 5y agoI'm guessing fast enough digital processing of the image
- sidhuko 5y agoIntegrated sensors really. Things like AF would work on different sensors in DSLR. Sony removed the mirror and put everything on the sensor. Fast AF tracking, shorter distance between sensor and lens so better low light capability.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rythie 5y agoI think it’s a number of things. Interchangeable lens cameras now all have video features and increasingly most of the improvements are in that area. When SLRs are used for video the mirror needs to be flipped up and auto-focus system that is used for photos can’t be used, so the camera need another one on the sensor. In this case the mirror is redundant and the viewfinder can’t be used. Tracking of fast moving subject is difficult with a SLR, the SLR cannot see the image in viewfinder mode only a focus module can, which likely only has a few hundred focus points (or less) and those points often don’t reach the edge of the frame. Additionally mirrorless cameras are able track a subject eye using AI and keep that in focus. A SLR cannot do this in the viewfinder mode as the focus sensor does not have nearly enough resolution to recognise small item like an eye or to know that it is an eye. Burst shooting is also difficult on a SLR, for each shot the mirror needs to flip up and down and the focus module use a brief period to change focus. Canon is/was the leader in sports photography cameras. The highest end Canon SLR camera can do 16fps with autofocus, but 20fps with the mirror up. The Sony a1 (mirrorless) can do 30fps. These fast shooting rates are only possible with mirrorless cameras.
- abdullahkhalids 5y agoI want to use a RPi to take pictures of objects within 1-6 inches of the lens? Does anyone have any recommendations? The smaller the lens, the better.
- vmception 5y agoThis isn't about killing off interchangeable lens cameras that look like DSLRs, its about killing off actual DSLRs Theyre just getting rid of the inferior mirror technology, the thing that flips in front of the sensor, not conceding to phones The entire sony a7 line, for example, is still going to be made its kind of a troll discussion but its a good thing to happen because SLRs have been associated with a look or form factor too long and its time for that ambiguity and term to die.
- perardi 5y agoI'm going to dispute, a little, that mirrors are inherently inferior. 1. It's only recently that the very best mirrorless cameras (Sony A1, Nikon Z9) have really reached the autofocus capabilities of the best SLRs…and arguably, they still aren’t quite there. It's close, but a Nikon D6 is still a bit better—but certainly not worse. The dedicated phase detection sensor is powerful. If only because you get more phase separation. 2. A DSLR, used like a film camera, has what feels like a perpetual motion machine inside of it. Just wild battery life. My old Nikon D700 had wayyyyy better battery life than a current camera, beacause if you kept the screen off, you were hardly touching the electronics in the camera. The imaging sensor was almost always asleep, and drawing next to no power. Obviously mirrors have drawbacks. Phase detect sensor/imaging plane alignment issues, and they are big and clunky, but they have benefits.
- vmception 5y agoYes, I agree with all except the drawbacks weigh much more heavily, to me. The wear and tear and sensitivity to brunt force of the mirror mechanics make them inferior to me.
- sudosysgen 5y agoDisagree. The best mirrorless cameras, say A7iv/A1, are a lot better at focusing than any DSLR. Not only do they focus accurately, but they have eye-detection AF. Yes, it will take slightly longer for them to give you the AF confirmation in some scenarios, but that's because they only give focus confirmation when it's actually perfectly sharp on the sensor. No DSLR can do that, because of the way dedicated phase detection sensors work. As far as battery life, you're right, but now that battery banks are a thing I don't think it's a real issue for those days you're going to be shooting for 4+ hours, and otherwise they're just so convenient to charge by usb-c
- rfreiberger 5y agoI started with SLR's in high school photography and loved how you could see just what the camera was doing. Using the Pentax K1000 with a 50mm 2.0 lens (at the time was a super cheap combo kit) just inspired me to really learn more about photography. When I moved to DSLR's later, it was even better, I could now see the images and taken nearly endless amount photos. But I started to get bogged down trying to take a full bag of lenses and large DSLR to social events or traveling. I found that I was spending more time behind the lens with the technical side vs spending time capturing the moment. Sold off my kit and went with a Fuji X100T, fixed length compact camera. It's not great for action but worked wonderfully capturing the kids and with the fully silent mode, very well for weddings. Once my phone camera quality started to approach my camera, I stopped using the Fuji as much and followed the rule of "the best camera you have is the one you carry". While I love having that dedicated camera, just having the live cloud backup, apps to edit, made my next decision to be an upgraded phone over a camera. It's hard to hear the news about Canon especially, the 70-200mm F/2.8 IS lens is simply amazing and I rented a 85mm f/1.2 which is the lens for portraits.
- alistairSH 5y agoLikewise, when it came time to upgrade my camera drawer, I decided spending a bit more on the iPhone Pro made more sense then a new body or lens. Glad I did, as it’s always in my pocket. I do still have a pair of Olympus u4/3 bodies and ~5 lenses for special occasions. Vacations, wildlife, etc.
- rfreiberger 5y agoThe biggest reason why I held off on the camera was missing the fisheye lens, once that became a common feature, I was pretty much sold going with the phone over a camera.
- alistairSH 5y agoMy use case for the camera are wildlife (reach), low-light (phones can’t beat a moderately priced f1.8 lens), and macro (haven’t tried an iPhone 13 Pro yet).
- propter_hoc 5y ago> vintage glass has become a lucrative option for filmmakers and creatives alike Can someone explain to me what this means? How does one make money with old camera lenses? Buying and selling them online?
- kjkjadksj 5y agoThey are saying less of their budget goes to equipment when creating the art they sell for a living.
- 5tefan 5y agoI used to be an avid photographer. Then got drowned in an overkill of technology since then. I preferred the look of AA filter sensors. Modern lenses and modern cameras are so tack sharp that to me photos feel like they are beyond reality. Too much of everything. I have difficulties to connect to the image itself. Much more of an craft you learn than art you explore. Keeping a piece of the world to carry with you to revisit and to remember or to cherrish. Only Ricoh managed to have a line up that keeps me interested. Seems if the photo bug bites again I'm happy with old gear.
- akpa1 5y agoI'm a rather frequent photographer myself, but I shoot solely 35mm film and Fujifilm instant photos. There's still a thriving market for film and there are plenty of labs around to develop your films at. You can pick up various old cameras and lenses for fairly small amounts of money on eBay and similar (or you can spend a ridiculous amount, your call haha). Film has a certain quality to it that I adore. You don't get insanely crisp images like you describe, you don't get to edit your photos, you just get what you pointed your camera at. And you get something meaningful and physical that you can pick up and hold when you're done. It's wonderful.
- Springtime 5y ago> you don't get to edit your photos, you just get what you pointed your camera at There's still the whole aspect of developing and printing film, which itself can be an artform and very much change the end result. See for example how much the analog dodging and burning were used to change the tonality of an image, drawing attention to some aspects and reducing others. These final results are typically what we think of when we see classic film photography.
- snapetom 5y agoI have three cameras that I use - a Canon R5, Canon FT QL, and a Zenza Bronica S2A. The first one is a joy for many reasons and I use it for the things the later two can't do very well - action and very low light. However, the later two offer an incredible experience to shoot. They're not forgiving, and film gives you a hazy look that is still poorly reproduced by software.
- londons_explore 5y agoDSLR's are dead because they can't do the stuff phone cameras can do on the software side. No DSLR can take 100 raw frames inside 100 milliseconds and do optical flow and stacking to get a higher resolution, reduced noise, nobody-blinks photo. None have 3 lenses like an iphone to be able to generate a depth map and use it for smart stuff like software-adjustable focus after taking the photo. Best you can hope for with DSLR's is 10 raw frames in 100 milliseconds, and a lot of effort in lightroom or photoshop to manually overlay and select frames with the least motion blur and best face of each person.
- sudosysgen 5y agoActually, mirorless cameras CAN generate a depth map from their phase detection sensors. They also can take multiple frames and stack them automatically, either for higher resolution or lower noise. But the thing is, there's no reason you would want 100 raw frames in 100ms (which no phone can do, that's 168Gbps of bandwidth, the sensor interface can only do around 8-12 Gbps), instead of a single 20ms exposure from a large, high resolution sensor. A 35mm sensor will, in that 30ms exposure, accumulate around 20 times as much light in the best conditions for the phone (normal focal length) taking 100 pictures in 100ms. If you're using the wide angle or the "telephoto" lens, now the big sensor is now accumulating anywhere from 40 to 200 times more light. The big sensor can have three times the resolution or more, and actually make full use of that resolution. At that quality, no amount of image stacking can improve the resolution unless you have a 2000$ lens and a tripod to use sensor shift mode - which a mirorless camera can also do. In the end, even if your algorithms are perfect, you will always have a much lower resolution and much higher noise on the phone, no matter how much image stacking you do. At that point, you improve by using AI to replace the imperfections with plausible looking generated replacements. You can also do that well on a computer, but in most cases this only makes it worse, because there aren't the imperfections to begin with. If you decide to remove frames without motion blur and imperfect faces, now you go from 100 pictures to stack to maybe 10. At that point, the critical parts of your picture will only have 8ms or so of actual exposure vs 20ms on the MILC. But the 20ms exposure also has 50-300x more light in it, so now your phone camera is way behind. So it ends up being better to just crank up the shutter speed to 1/200 and get a 5ms full sensor exposure, as the critical parts of your picture will have more light, less noise, and more detail than the stacked version you take on your phone.
- sandGorgon 5y agoHas someone managed to do video conference calls (zoom, etc) with functioning Bokeh without dslr ? Cos I thought that the entire market was moving to video calls. I don't think there's really any other way except to use a dslr right ?
- shagie 5y agoIn order to have nice bokeh (a function of the aperture of the lens), you also need to have a shallow enough depth of field at a fairly close range. As the sensor gets smaller, and the field of view remains constant, the depth of field increases and so the opportunity for bokeh disappears. For pleasant bokeh in a video call, you're going to need a larger sensor than the ones used in camera phones or laptop screens - probably significantly so. Additionally, the lens is going to be quite a bit larger to have good illumination across the entire sensor. From a cost perspective, the cost of the sensor has to do with the yield of the wafer. It costs about the same to make a wafer no matter what you put on it (with certain caveats of the complexity of what you put on it). https://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/53826/why-does-increasing-sensor-size-necessarily-lead-to-lower-silicon-wafer-utilizat https://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/53826/why-does-inc... If you're working from a full frame sensor, you can at best fit 24x 24mmx36mm chips on a standard 8" wafer. Going to a 13.2mm x 8.8mm sensor you can put 244 of them on the same wafer. Then there's the yield on top of that which further reduces it. This gets it to the point where "to have a nice depth of field for a video call, you're going to need a camera that has similar costs and dimensions of a good digital camera." Adding that to a phone or laptop screen isn't possible. That said, I wouldn't be unhappy to find an affordable usb capable video camera with a nice lens on it (and maybe paired with a ring light or off axis hot lights)... but that's probably easily in the $300-$400 range.
- nullc 5y agoThe replacement for the DSLR isn't tiny cameraphone sensors, ... it's mirrorless cameras like the Canon R-series. This cameras look and function like DSLRs but the the viewfinder is electronic, not optical-- running the sensor like a video camera. IMO, it's much better than a DSLR and not just for the lens design reasons mentioned in the article with about the only downside being battery life. I use one for teleconferencing, with the camera in a teleprompter: https://files.catbox.moe/5p2p55.jpg https://files.catbox.moe/5p2p55.jpg
- anta40 5y agoSooner or later, I think DSLR is fundamentally "dead". To understand my PoV, perhaps we need to go back into 1940/1950s. Practically the most camera used at this time is a rangefinder (including Leica), which was a mirrorless. Rangefinder is compact, but limited to shorter primes, like 50mm and wider. SLRs don't have such limitation. You want longer lenses like 200mm, 300mm? No problem. Or a zoom lens? why not. In the 1960s, pro journalists started to adopt SLR and there's a decline in rangefinders usage. Now we are living in the digital world. Why do we still have to keep extra space for mirror box, which makes the camera body bigger? After all, there's no issue using tele or zoom lenses on mirrorless. Please don't understand this as "yet another anti DSLR post". No. My main camera is a Nikon Df, equipped with some AI and pre-AI lenses. I'm happy with the result, it suits my shooting style. That said, if I have some cash for another camera system, it's obviously going to be a mirrorless. Probably medium format mirrorless :D
- snapetom 5y agoI was vehemently anti-mirrorless up until maybe a few months ago. I went on a big wildlife trip and realized I had to finally upgrade my Canon 70D. The first thought was to jump to a 90D, but I had to review what mirrorless options were. I tried to find every reason in the world to go with the much cheaper 90D than mirrorless. In the end, I couldn't. For my primary use cases (wildlife, night cityscapes, and sports), the Canon R5 has so many game changing advantages, I couldn't ignore it. I lose nothing with the lens adapters, and they mostly solved or mitigated the issues with the first gen.
- berkut 5y agoBattery life when using the EVF (vs viewfinder in SLR) seems to be the only downside currently with Canon (I think Sony's is better). Hopefully over time this will improve.
- snapetom 5y agoThat's really the only disadvantage I came up with. I was also really nervous about lag and blackouts, but once I actually used one, even in the older R, I realized it was a non-issue. It's still an incredibly strange concept for me, and admittedly I'm not sure I'll ever be fully comfortable with it. However from a practical standpoint, there's really no issue.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI worked for decades on software for DSLRs. I completely agree that they need to go away, and that new lens tech needs to appear. But I think that we are -just now- starting to get to the point where we can have truly excellent mirrorless cameras that actually can replace (and will surpass) DSLRs. A lot of it has to do with on-chip computational photography. All the camera companies are coming up with custom image processing chips, and these are what makes the difference. Lag time needs to be in the single-to-mid-double-digit ms range. I don't remember what the number was, but the company that I worked for, did some research, on what the maximum allowable lag time on a viewfinder could be, and I think it was like 50ms. That means that you need to expose the chip, scan the image from it, do the A/D conversion, demosaic, gamma correct, color correct, denoise, vignette correct, distortion manage, remove chromatic aberration (because cheap lenses), and all the rest of the image processing, then, display it on the screen, continuously, within 50ms per frame, while also not draining the battery. Also, pixel density has a big impact on this performance. More pixels, more milliseconds; more battery drainage. Not a simple task. You can do tricks like scale down the image early on, and eschew some of the finer image processing tasks, but you still need that viewfinder image to be right on the money, and to the standards of a very picky photographer. Also sensor physical size has a lot to do with the image quality, bokeh, and what-have-you. A big issue with smartphone cameras (and point-and-shoot cameras), is that small sensors mean that there's little control over DoF (Depth of Field). Apple has introduced artificial bokeh, with their software. Sensor size, and the length of the optical path, are what really drive lens size. They discuss that, in the article. Hasselblad and Phase One (if they still do that stuff) cameras have these monster sensors. They still need big lenses.
- omegalulw 5y ago> That means that you need to expose the chip, scan the image from it, do the A/D conversion, demosaic, gamma correct, color correct, denoise, vignette correct, distortion manage, remove chromatic aberration (because cheap lenses), Can you explain what's the difference in gamma correction and color correction? New gamma correction uses perceptual mapping right (e.g. Dolby vision) - doesn't that already put you into a standard color space? > then, display it on the screen, continuously, within 50ms per frame That's 20 fps. Don't you need at least 24 to capture cinematic footage?
- mkhpalm 5y agoThe almost exclusive reason I never bought a DSLR is because nobody ever saw the reason to add a GPS chip to encode exif data into the pictures being taken. Sure, you could sometimes buy another device and plug it into your already large device you have to lug around to get that metadata. I just never wanted to deal with all that for something so fundamental to digital photography in my mind. I could however see the trade-off of the larger form factor for the lenses. I was not going to lug around and keep plugging in a GPS module though. To me, going back 20+ years now I have been convinced that the metadata is as important as the images themselves. I just got tired of looking into it every few years, getting disappointed, and trying to remember to go look again next year. Seemed like phone cameras could deliver more of that baseline for digital images should be underneath the lenses. When I look back on my images I don't want to guess where they were taken or hope that the timestamps were right. Using a DSLR was too risky to me. Too much information about an image was lost like the most critical bits of coordinates and accurate timestamps.
- vmladenov 5y agoI was bothered by this too, but this app works well enough for me to where I don’t miss the lack of a builtin module https://www.geotagphotos.net/ https://www.geotagphotos.net/
- densh 5y agoCanon 6D was one of the few DSLRs that had built-in GPS support, but the feature wasn’t that successful since most people preferred to keep it off to save battery life.
- epivosism 5y ago100% support this. It's unbelievable that my 100k+ DSLR photos over 15 years are not connected to their location when it would have been so easy. (I would have gladly carried a multiple pound extra battery to support always-on GPS).
- nayuki 5y agoFor starters, consult the list at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cameras_which_provide_geotagging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cameras_which_provide_... . Most photographers I talked to have the opposite stance as you - they care about grouping photos by event (vacation, portrait session, hiking, etc.) but don't care about the exact street. As you are in the minority, I can see why the cameras are not reliably released with geotagging features. I've used several cameras with geotagging capabilities and I'd like to describe their quirks: * Canon EOS 6D: Built-in GPS receiver. Drains a lot of battery, especially if you set the update interval very short (1 second, 10, 60, etc.). Takes unreasonably long to first acquire location (easily 2~10 minutes). The weak receiver struggles with urban canyons and airplane windows - phones have much better receivers. Sometimes calculates completely wrong coordinates that are ~10 km away. As a result, some photos don't have geotags (slow acquisition) and some are wrong. But the extra transfer step is mildly annoying. * Canon EOS M6: Make sure camera has the correct time set (can't be off by hours and days). Run the "Canon Camera Connect" phone app and enable continuous location logging. After shooting (e.g. end of day), use Wi-Fi to connect phone and camera, and use the app to apply geotags onto the photos after the fact. My phone is extremely accurate (GPS+GLONASS) and supports indoor geolocation through Wi-Fi, so essentially 100% of photos get tagged and mistagging is rare. * Canon EOS RP: Use Bluetooth to pair the camera with the phone. Must run the "Canon Camera Connect" phone app in the background while shooting. Periodically check that the phone OS didn't evict the app due to inactivity, quite annoyingly. Every time you turn on the camera, wait 2~10 seconds for it to connect to the phone, and then you'll get geolocation data at the time of shooting. If the connection failed for whatever reason, you cannot go back and add geotags to photos after the fact. Even though the Canon app can connect to all 3 aforementioned cameras over Wi-Fi, their geotagging functionalities are completely non-overlapping. You cannot send geotags to the 6D at all. You cannot geotag the M6 in real time. You cannot send geotags to the RP after a photo is shot. By contrast, when you shoot a photo on a phone, it gets geotagged automatically with no fuss. The phone's accurate GPS+GLONASS+WiFi sensors are used (unlike the slow and inaccurate 6D), you don't have to do manual actions after shooting (unlike the M6 synchronization), and you don't need to wait because the phone geolocation service is always ready (unlike the 6D and RP).
- indymike 5y agoA few years back I bought a middle of the road Lumix micro four thirds camera instead of DSLR. The reason I went with the MFT camera is it could shoot 4k video without the sensor overheating. At that time, DSLRs would overheat in 10-15 minutes and 4k capable DSLR bodies were 2x more expensive than the MFT Lumix. I really liked the mirrorless better than the last DSLR I owned. MFT sensors can't deliver as much bokeh as a 35mm DSLR, but the trade off was the body and lenses were a lot lighter and more compact. I'll often grab the Lumix when I would have left the bulkier DSLR home... and it really is a better camera than any mobile phone I've used. Compared to the phone (Samsung Galaxy S20), shots are much more color accurate, it's easier to focus on exactly what you want, and you get better lines in wider angle shots. That said, I'm usually pretty happy with the phone, but I love being able to change lenses and the precision of the camera (compared to the phone).
- epivosism 5y agoSoftware support for moving photos from SLR => disk/gphotos is nonexistant. Huge miss that DSLR companies haven't made this work. They just gave up and ceded the market for "take a picture and conveniently share it on social media" See this question: https://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/128140/setup-to-have-photos-automatically-loaded-to-the-computer https://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/128140/setup-to-ha...
- Thomaschaaf 5y agoThe Camera Control API (CCAPI) which Canon provides is actually very good it allows our company to create software which grabs the pictures of the camera and put it where we like.
- epivosism 5y agoThat's interesting, found details here: https://dphacks.com/how-to-canon-camera-control-api-ccapi/ https://dphacks.com/how-to-canon-camera-control-api-ccapi/
- epivosism 5y agoDSLR manufacturers also actively resisted improving features on phones to enable market segmentation. Open source hacked DSLR replacement operating systems like Magic Lantern prove they are just market manipulators. example: every canon dslr is intentionally software limited in features like time lapse support, shorter exposure times, motion detection, bulb activation, and many more. In general the product space was undeveloped for years for them to keep their for short-term profits from massively marked up high end bodies; unlike the phone world where every phone has the best features it possibly can, and there is no 2k, 5k+ USD iphone which "really" has the best features. Canon/others did not innovate and this is what they should get. It's a shame considering what they might have been. https://magiclantern.fm/ https://magiclantern.fm/
- elxr 5y agoEntry level DSLRs also only had 1 control wheel for a long time. This was always one of my biggest issues when looking for a decent, affordable DSLR. It really kneecaps usability. When in aperture priority, having only a single wheel for F-stop, exposure compensation, and ISO is an exercise is frustration.
- epivosism 5y agoOr how even on 2k+ DSLRs you cannot specify "auto ISO limits" - i.e. AUTO means 50-400 but do NOT go over that. So you can't build in your requirements for photos - after verifying that quality up to a certain ISO is okay for your purpose, and above it is NOT okay, you have no way to force the camera to match your requirements.
- andrewaylett 5y agoMy Canon EOS 550D has a "maximum auto ISO" setting that lets me pick anything from 400 up.
- zoomablemind 5y agoThe smartphone photography reminds me of TV-VCR combos of days bygone. It works ok for both purposes, it's convenient... yet it speeds up the obsolescence. Eventually, you're on the market again for either one or both components. Unlike with the dedicated devices, which may retain their use for longer (even if relegated to drawer life) due to their specialization by design.
- starky 5y agoIn practice the true effect of mirrorless cameras and their new lens mounts are in how they affect the optical formulas that manufacturers are choosing. No longer does an optical designer have to make the same compromises when they can assume that distortion, vignetting, etc. can all be corrected in camera and in software. The shorter flange distance gives more options for optical designs that may allow for smaller or more efficient designs. The other interesting development has been with the use of linear motors for moving lens elements which is allowing for significantly improved autofocus speeds on lenses that would traditionally have been expected to focus slowly.