15 ms·
Goldman Sachs invests $250M in compressed air energy storage
- ck2 5y agoWhy not use spare energy to lift -really- heavy object(s) and let gravity power the generators when there is a shortage? Million tons of concrete isn't going to suffer any maintenance expenses over decades.
- nkurz 5y agoThat's a really popular idea on the internet because it's very easy to grasp, but the numbers don't work out well. The weights you can actually lift aren't much compared to the volume of a reservoir of water, and the heights you can lift them are but a fraction of the thousands of meters being discussed here. Yes, the concrete isn't going to require much maintenance, but the gearboxes needed are a significant engineering challenge. Pumping water or compressing air are a lot easier, and batteries are going to be hard to beat.
- toss1 5y agoExcept it is already being done by multiple companies [0], Energy Vault in Switzerland [1], Gravitricity in Scotland [2], New Energy Lets go [3], and Gravity Power [4]. All have raised substantial funds and are building. Sure, pumped hydro has advantages, but has serious geographic limitations - you need a fairly ideal site. The key is that these can be built almost anywhere. [0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/gravity-energy-storage-will-show-its-potential-in-2021 https://spectrum.ieee.org/gravity-energy-storage-will-show-i... [1] https://www.energyvault.com/ https://www.energyvault.com/ [2] https://www.gravitricity.com/#about https://www.gravitricity.com/#about [3] https://n-e-l-g.de/ https://n-e-l-g.de/ [4] https://www.gravitypower.net/ https://www.gravitypower.net/
- nkurz 5y agoGood point, and good examples. Excited online discussion about companies like those are what I mean when I say it's popular on the internet. It's not impossible, it's just not the technology I would be betting on. To get a sense of what one is up against, you can work through the math comparing gravitational potential energy to electrical potential in typical batteries. I can't find a good link right now, but what I remember finding is that (in the ideal) a typical lead acid car battery has enough stored energy to lift itself into space! Conversely, if you wanted to store the same amount of energy as in a typical car battery, you'd need to be dropping that amount of weight from the top of the atmosphere all the way to the ground.
- ted_dunning 5y agoSee also the rail-based gravity storage: https://aresnorthamerica.com/gravityline/ https://aresnorthamerica.com/gravityline/ But the point about little progress by these companies still holds. ARES has been around for 11 years now and has one 50MWh project to talk about that covers 20 acres.
- ccvannorman 5y agoI knew Danielle Fong from Lightsail Energy, folded in 2016, and at that time compressed air seemed like a great solution especially for LatAm that needed robust low cost batteries for critical infrastructure (like hospitals) on an unreliable power grid. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danielle_Fong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danielle_Fong Would be great to see this technology reach maturity!
- mikeyouse 5y agoShe's on HN, curious what her thoughts are: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DaniFong https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DaniFong
- DaniFong 5y agohttps://twitter.com/DanielleFong/status/1481339424730497025?s=20 https://twitter.com/DanielleFong/status/1481339424730497025?...
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThat wikipedia page answers everything you need to know about compressed air energy storage. In 2018, the tech couldn't compete against lithium ion, and the price of lithium ion continues to fall 10-20% per year. Compressed air and that concrete-block-stacking nonsense that keeps getting press are just magnets for uneducated investors.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThat wikipedia page says: > Compared to traditional batteries, CAES systems can store energy for longer periods of time and have less upkeep. Sometimes the cost per MW/hr or equivalent is not the only metric worth thinking about.
- tradesurplus 5y agoPlus, always a good idea to hedge: against lithium shortages / gouging and battery supply chain disruptions.
- eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 5y agoWhat is the expected efficiency of this?
- rikkipitt 5y agoI too was wondering that as the ideal gas law states that PV = nRT. When you compress a gas it gets hotter, conversely, allowing it to decompress cools it. I assume they store the heat energy... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed-air_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed-air_energy_storage
- Mvandenbergh 5y agoYes, their website says they have a thermal store.
- mirekrusin 5y agoThey should do free ice maker on the other end.
- dragontamer 5y agoCAES has lower efficiency, probably closer to 70% and only if you use something to reheat the air. (Compressed air loses temperature and needs an external source of heat to restore it to full volume) Even if you use natural gas as a reheating element, the compressed air stores a significant amount of energy and is doing the majority of the work.
- konschubert 5y agoWhat matters is efficiency per dollar: Efficiency / cost I am worried that the cost is the driving factor here...
- EricE 5y agoIf you ignore efficiency then you stop making a profit pretty quickly. You can solely focus all you want on cost; sooner or later efficiency will make you pay. Goldman wouldn't be making that kind of an investment if they didn't have a handle on both parts of the equation. Indeed efficiency (dealing with losses from seepage) have been the nut that hasn't been cracked with compressed air storage; these guys seem to have an economical (efficient) way to deal with that problem. If true, then they really are worthy of Goldman's investment.
- 0898 5y agoThis brings to mind the other post about the Amish that's on today's front page. I believe the Amish sometimes use compressed air as an alternative form of power.
- wongarsu 5y agoAlso quite popular in mines because it doesn't create sparks.
- MisterTea 5y agoI read an article in a woodworking magazine about how one Amish woodworking shop was built to avoid using electricity. The whole shop ran off a stationary diesel engine driving a shaft in a floor trench and belt drove the larger stationary machinery like band saws, table saws, planers, drill presses, joiners and so on. But what about hand tools? A large belt driven air compressor off the diesel engine handled a myriad of air power tools like drills, orbital sanders, buffers and all that. Really neat setup.
- lostapathy 5y agoAlso adds a ton of pollution from using (often old and poorly maintained) Diesel engines in the name of avoiding the electric grid. Adding to that, compressed air is a much less efficient source of power than using electricity directly.
- toss1 5y agoYes, but air tools can be really nice to use,esp for grinding, cutting, sanding operations. For one, you can press/dig hard enough to bog or stop the tool and nothing hapoens - you just pick it uo and it speeds back uo again - do that with an electric tool and you'll have a dead motor paperweight real soon. Air tools can also be lighter and no worries abt damaging the cord or carrying the battery. Many good air tools can also have a better feel, especially if you can control the air flow trigger. (I don't have a bias either way, use both in my shop, but just wanted to point out that both have advantages)
- nkurz 5y agoInteresting. There's a good video describing the operation here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOWjwwKSR78 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOWjwwKSR78 After watching it, I now understand that they aren't flooding the entire borehole, but rather are building a smaller high-pressure chamber at the bottom. The chamber is connected to pipes to a surface reservoir. When air is pumped into the chamber, it displaces water up toward the surface. When generating, the water flows back into the subsurface chambers, forcing out the high pressured air.
- mirekrusin 5y agoI wonder what is the loss/recovery %age.
- epistasis 5y agoI don't have specific numbers, but in other batteries of this type, the length of storage time before discharge affects the efficiency. Heat stored from compression is lost over time.
- ehnto 5y agoI was curious about that as well. I think it's best application would be to compensate for large amounts of rising and falling generation from solar grids, that way the cycle is daily. Being quick to come online and meet demand makes it good for maintaining grid stability at a much lower cost as well, like the Hornsdale Power Reserve facility https://hornsdalepowerreserve.com.au/ https://hornsdalepowerreserve.com.au/.
- keewee7 5y agoWhat goes into building and burying large scale underground structures like those air caverns?
- mschuster91 5y agoNot much, technologically this is a conventional mine project, only that you mine air volume instead of rock and have to take care of the cavern being reasonably airtight afterwards.
- reedf1 5y agoGiven it's GS, $250m is peanuts.
- woofcat 5y agoI see that you've been down-voted however they have 40 billion in assets under management.
- WHA8m 5y agoI didn't dv, but that'd be .63%. That's not peanuts I'd say...
- 1-more 5y ago> Goldman Sachs agreed and invested $250 million from its private equity division. Maybe they're referring to Goldman Sachs Capital partners which has 39.9B[0] under management which means this is 0.62% of their portfolio. In a totally chalk and cheese comparison that would be having 200k in your 401k and taking a $1,250 position in a stock, which isn't nothing but is a pretty small bet, I agree. Curious though if I'm guessing the part of GS correctly; I have no idea how they're structured and just spent like three minutes searching. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldman_Sachs_Capital_Partners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldman_Sachs_Capital_Partners
- boringg 5y agoGS isn't known for their scientific prowess - signal that they believe there is money in large scale ESS. Not sure if it's validating the technology at all though. Compressed air has been around for a long time at this point.
- objektif 5y agoWho is known for their scientific prowess? A16z and with sprawling investments in web3? Capital is capital. We should be cheering on these types of investments regardless. Electric motors have been around for a looong time as well..
- boringg 5y agoThe VC and investment world in energy technology is quite different then the A16z and traditional VC world or financial heavyweights. Having had GS invest in companies in the energy tech space in the past and having not particularly great success - I wouldn't think this is a strong signal. More that the financial heavyweights think there is action and they want to get in.
- objektif 5y agoGoldman has army of analysts that are covering the field. Many many more than Even VCs that specialize in it. I would definitely write them off when it comes to smart investing.
- boringg 5y agoFinancial analysts != energy technologists with a scientific background. Its small money on a broad industry bet thats all in an economy with very few quality investments available. Don't read too much into it.
- EricE 5y agoSo you think it's in GS's best interest to make uninformed decisions on a continual basis? Seriously?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 5y agoWould energy storage not be a good use of that money? Society is facing a large problem: climate change. One way to reduce the impact of climate change is to use renewable energy like solar and wind. Solar and wind have a big problem; they can't be turned on and off. That means to displace fossil fuels, we need to store energy when it's sunny and windy, and release that energy when it's not. Hence, things like compressed air energy storage. This is the kind of technology that can prevent entire cities from disappearing over the next 100 years. Seems pretty valuable to me.
- thomaslangston 5y agoSmall nitpick. Wind can be turned off. The turbines can be equipped with brakes to stop power generation in case of oversupply, in addition to other uses.
- jrockway 5y agoI guess turning it on is where the problem comes from.
- axg11 5y agoDoes this technology only work in select places or are underground caverns fairly commonplace?
- nkurz 5y agoAppropriate natural caverns do exist, but are not common. One of the main differentiating factor between this approach and others is that they drill a man-made borehole rather than depending on finding a pre-existing cavern.
- throwawayboise 5y agoNear where I live there is a large underground natural gas storage field using natural caverns.
- dylanz 5y agoIs this similar to a trompe? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trompe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trompe
- CarbonCycles 5y agoThis isn't new...I recall grad students working on this as far back as 2010. Some citations from an article: “Bottled wind could be as constant as coal.” Wired Magazine. Retrieved 7/15/2010, 2010, from http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2010/03/compressedair-plants/ http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2010/03/compressedair-plan... 59 Cavallo, A. (2005). Controllable and affordable utility-scale electricity from intermittent wind resources and compressed air energy storage (CAES). Science Direct.
- rplnt 5y ago> This isn't new... Well, yeah, this is in the opening of the article: > It updates a long-standing technology that never took off for electrical storage. There is/was plant operational since 1970s in Germany[1], which looks similar to the Wired article, but different from some other solutions posted in comments. Missing some parts perhaps to be viable. 1. PDF: http://www.fze.uni-saarland.de/AKE_Archiv/AKE2003H/AKE2003H_Vortraege/AKE2003H03c_Crotogino_ea_HuntorfCAES_CompressedAirEnergyStorage.pdf http://www.fze.uni-saarland.de/AKE_Archiv/AKE2003H/AKE2003H_...
- belorn 5y agoHow does the economics of this look like, and how do they intended to get back the investment. If its to buy low when wind/solar production is high and sell when production is low, what will the cost per watt be? If its subsidies, how much will this cost the government? The article seem to mostly describe this as a technology project to test the technology at scale, but they do also mention profits. Is the basic premise of buy low sell high, exclusively on renewables, enough to offset the cost from energy conversion, building, staff and other costs, and if so, by what degree compared to other method to produce energy? When is it estimated to have paid its initial investment?
- EricE 5y agoEnergy storage if you want to rely solely on renewable energy sources is THE KEY to making that even remotely feasible. Current solar and wind renewables are NOT predictable nor reliable for sustained power generation. With Coal, Natural Gas, Nuclear and Hydro you can generate power on demand, no matter what the environment is doing. Well, Hydro in the west is getting dicey with the drought - but even that is far more stable than wind/sun which can vary wildly week to week, day to day or even hour to hour. That's why technology like this is so exciting. If you can look at the average production of a renewable over a month, then within a year the peak month, then look at the worst months, then have enough storage to cover a percentage of a peak month based off the hedge of the worst month then you are getting to a point where a solar farm isn't just an opportunistic source of power based on how much the sun is shining, but a reliable energy source that can be counted on whether the sun is shining or not. Same for wind farms. Energy storage is crucial if we seriously want to transition to renewables and hence the investment from Goldman Sachs. If this company is even remotely successful in actually delivering then $250M is a pittance to what they will receive back in the long term. There are also a lot of unused/abandoned underground structures - from various wells that are now dry of the resource they were originally drilled for to mines that are no longer productive. The problem has been sealing them from seepage so you don't loose your stored air - this article was light on details but that seems to be this companies claim to fame. They seem to have found economical ways to deal with those issues - enough to convince the boffins at Goldman Sachs they are worthy of investment. I guarantee you Goldman is not just tossing out money willy-nilley without performing some significant due diligence!
- Giorgi 5y agoI really enjoy learning about quirky ways to "store" energy, there is also one case that allows "storing" of energy by pushing massive concrete blocks uphill and when energy is needed, blocks simply slide down and generate energy. Not sure if this can be called "Storing" though.
- konschubert 5y agoThe more efficient version of this idea looks like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricit...
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't know that this is always the case. I think that solid mass gravity storage projects have quite high efficiency. there is no rule that water+ turbines is more efficiency than Solid mass + alternators.
- EricE 5y agoIt's only efficient if you have the right environment for it to work (enough space, enough of an elevation gradient, etc.). If you can't build it where you need it, then efficiency doesn't really matter now, does it?
- terpimost 5y agoInteresting, I guess the water freeze isn’t a problem in those places
- RyEgswuCsn 5y agoI was wondering the same. Although they can somewhat mitigate that by adding some antifreeze additives to the water perhaps?
- jesperlang 5y agoThere is a great post on compressed air energy storage (CAES) over at Low-Tech Magazine: https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/history-and-future-of-the-compressed-air-economy.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/history-and-future-o...
- tomcooks 5y agoFinally someone mentioning this, it's a gem of an article in a gem of a website
- smoyer 5y agoCuriously there's a second article discussing compressed air energy on the front-page of Hacker News at the moment - it's about the Amish and their hacker mentality [0]. There's a beautiful discontinuity between one of the more tech-savvy old-guard banks and the technology-careful Amish adopting the same technology. 0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288
- gjvc 5y ago"Workers descend to hollow out a cavity, which the company then floods." reminiscent of The Day Today https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTGE9153VFE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTGE9153VFE
- ds 5y agoCan someone explain their revenue to me? They claim 1m in revenue from their existing product which is: "1.75 megawatts (MW) of peak power output; a 2.2 MW charge rating; and 10+ megawatt-hours (MWh) of storage capacity" How does that equal 1m in revenue? You have to pay to charge your air-battery during low-cost hours and then discharge it during high cost hours to make the difference in revenue. The issue is, you can buy 2 megawatts of power 24/7 at average datacenter energy pricing (~5c/kwh) for $2400/day or 876k/year. Who is paying more than that for less energy and only at certain hours? Is there some energy company somewhere that sells power during the day at like 50c/kwh and 1c/kwh at night???
- 323 5y agoWhile I don't know about their numbers, having a "grid level battery" is definitely something people (or gov subsidies) will pay for.
- _delirium 5y agoThese kinds of utility-run storage facilities usually buy and sell on the wholesale spot market, which swings much more than retail prices do. Somewhat similar economics to gas "peaker" plants, which only fire up when supply is tight and prices spike, making it economical to run a higher-cost generator. The Hydrostor plant is in Ontario. Here's an archive of hourly spot-market electricity prices there (in dollars per MWh): http://reports.ieso.ca/public/PriceHOEPPredispOR/ http://reports.ieso.ca/public/PriceHOEPPredispOR/. So far in 2022, prices have been as low as $0.00/MWh (during a few hours overnight on Jan 5) and as high as $230.87/MWh (during the morning of Jan 11). In 2021, hourly average prices even exceeded $1000/MWh ($1/kWh) twice, on March 28 and October 10.
- ds 5y agoI would need to see the math, because nothing adds up to even 1/10th of their claimed revenue. Best case, they bought 10mwh on jan 5th and sold it at the perfect time on jan 11th. This would give them 2k in revenue in 6 days. Wheres the rest? And what about if you cant nostradamus predict the best times to buy and sell?
- rdtwo 5y agoIn the 80s my grandfather used to do this for the former Soviet Union. Long story short they were pressuring a salt mine at night for energy storage and somebody failed to report a water leak during the day. They tried to depressurize the mine but it ended up blowing up anyway killing a couple people in The process. This shit can be really dangerous if done incorrectly.
- slingnow 5y agoCan you name a method of large scale energy storage that isn't dangerous if done incorrectly?
- karmakaze 5y agoI think the comment is more about being easy to do incorrectly/dangerously. Pumping water up into a reservoir seems easier/safer.
- WJW 5y agoLots of water in a reservoir is not particularly safe in itself. For example, in December 2000 at the Grande Dixence a high-pressure pipeline from the dam burst, causing a landslide that wiped out a small hamlet and killed three people. It's also not hard to find reports of massive amounts of casualties and/or property damage from dams that just outright fail.
- Choco31415 5y agoAn underground reservoir of water though should still be safer. Only the operator(s) on site might be impacted by a failure.
- rdtwo 5y agoYeah a large pressure vessel is basically a bomb. No matter how many layers of protection you add on the technology always wants to go too a rapid critical failure. Using statistics and layers of protection you can always show it to be safe to handle anything but when you get to such low probability your models be always be off and variables that you think are independent are actually linked (bad maintenance practices being one)
- photochemsyn 5y agoIt's probably some kind of hedge strategy for energy crises like the recent Texas disaster (which appears to have been very profitable for GS [1]). Having this capacity around when other sources go down means they'll be able to provide power in similar situations and so reap massive profits. Climate chaos == $$$ I guess. > Bloomberg March 5, 2021 > Goldman Sachs Group Inc. could gain more than $200 million from the physical sale of power and natural gas and from financial hedges after spot prices surged across much of the U.S., according to people with knowledge of the matter. Morgan Stanley’s gains could come in under $200 million, according to a person with familiar with the matter, and Bank of America Corp. stands to rake in profits as well... > The historic cold that battered the central U.S. last month led to sweeping blackouts as ice formed on wind turbines and pipelines froze, forcing oil and gas wells to shut. As traders and power suppliers struggled to find fuel to meet obligations, prices skyrocketed. In Oklahoma, gas traded at more than 300 times normal levels, while electricity in Texas surged to $9,000 per megawatt-hour. Full article: [1] https://www.investorvillage.com/smbd.asp?mb=5028&mn=126049&pt=msg&mid=21782400 https://www.investorvillage.com/smbd.asp?mb=5028&mn=126049&p...
- qeternity 5y ago> Having this capacity around when other sources go down means they'll be able to provide power in similar situations and so reap massive profits. Climate chaos == $$$ I guess. I understand that people don't like when others profit from a crisis, but this is also how we solve these problems. Having more generation capacity than we otherwise would have is a good thing, even if Goldman make money on the back of it. I'm not arguing there isn't more to be done, but when people say "greed is good" this is what they mean.
- _xnmw 5y agoThis is where capitalism goes off the rails. Instead of investing $250m into making the power grid more secure and reliable, they choose to invest in profiting off disaster.
- jvanderbot 5y agoproviding instant-on, scalable energy capacity to the grid is both potentially profiting off disaster and investing 250m into making the grid more reliable and secure.
- throw1234651234 5y agoHeh. This ties in with the "Amish Hackers" article here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288, which states that the Amish use compressed air to store electricity.
- nemacol 5y agoI would like more detail on the "Thermal management system" and how long it could store the heat it captures. One of the benefits they touting is "Long duration energy storage" I would think the limiting factor would be the ability of the thermal management system to retain the energy it captured to reheat the compressed air. Am I thinking about this correctly?
- themanmaran 5y agoOn that note do you have a good explanation for why the air needs to be reheated? I didn't quite understand that from the video.
- tristor 5y agoAir pressure is strongly correlated to temperature. Cooling the air after compression reduces pumping effort during storage, reheating it increases turbine head pressure during generation.
- usrusr 5y agoIn other words: gas compression storage suffers from temperature losses. The compressed gas is hot, the heat dissipates from storage and that energy won't be coming back. But if you extract that heat during compression you can put in a separate storage, one that is much easier to insulate than the compression tanks, and "mix it back in" during recompression, avoiding a large part of those losses.
- tristor 5y ago> In other words: gas compression storage suffers from temperature losses. Yes, and you can also compress air further when it's cooled (this is why there is an intercooler on turbocharged cars, as an example), this means your density per volume of storage is higher at a given pressure. The reality though is that this is likely less efficient than many other storage mechanisms. Additionally, this may require some sort of additional energy input for reheating if the heat storage is not capable of holding long enough to fully reheat the air on release to get the highest turbine efficiency.
- aaron695 5y agoIt will be fake But Goldman Sachs can blow their money however they wish. Although no doubt governments will also throw bad money into this, but I guess if people want their government to fake their lives, so be it. It seems that's living in The Jetsons future HN idolises. Why it is fake - "Why is adiabatic compressed air energy storage yet to become a viable energy storage option?" - https://www.cell.com/iscience/pdf/S2589-0042(21)00408-9.pdf https://www.cell.com/iscience/pdf/S2589-0042(21)00408-9.pdf The Australian project has no go ahead - Hydrostor seeks clarity over compressed air-energy storage facility in Broken Hill - https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-12/hyrdostor-seeks-clarity-on-compressed-air-energy-at-broken-hill/100749252 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-12/hyrdostor-seeks-clari... And yes as part of this fake world, Goldman Sachs has not put 250M into this company, it's in tranches. Fake worlds built on top of fake worlds.
- PBnFlash 5y agoAir is kind of a shitty working fluid. I always kind of dismiss compressed air storage because of that. I saw a video recently that pumped water into tanks and used used the air as a spring. Just dip a pipe down and use the air to move the water. Extracting energy from a hyrdo generator. https://youtu.be/sBF5EnK9MPs https://youtu.be/sBF5EnK9MPs
- u320 5y agoIsn't that just pumped hydro? You would need similar masses of water.
- PBnFlash 5y agoI imagine it will get better performance from high pressure water instead of the few psi of a small elevation change.
- ted_dunning 5y agoIt is pumped hydro, but you don't have the same mass of water because of the dramatically different pressures involved. Smaller water mass is the advantage to this, but the problem of managing heat is the downside that pumped storage doesn't face. This general technique is known as "liquid piston".
- PBnFlash 5y agoThanks for the search term. I am not a huge fan of the "advanced polymer" wank of that video but liquid piston seems very practical compared most of the "air powered car" nonsense compressed air systems that show up.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoHas anybody considered building flywheels into each wind turbine?
- lbriner 5y agoI'm not sure how that would help? If you had a flywheel and you didn't need the energy, what do you do with it? At least without a flywheel, you can easily stop the turbine. Also, any flywheel that would add significant difference would probably weigh hundreds of tonnes, which would make construction massively more expensive and difficult.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoIf you don't need the energy you just let the flywheel spin freely. It's a mechanical battery. I agree with your second point though- it would add considerable mass to the hub assembly of the wind turbine and there is no clear way to transmit the mechanical energy to ground level.
- buryat 5y agoflywheels storing a lot of energy are very dangerous, if something happens it's a flying thing that destroys everything on its way
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoLike a giant rotating wind turbine?
- buryat 5y agoi agree, wind turbines do rotate but not at high speeds, disintegration of one doesn’t lead to catastrophic outcomes. Flywheels on the other hand are meant to rotate at high speeds and hold lots of energy, so destruction of the spindle would lead to some pretty big bad results
- 5y ago
- epistasis 5y agoGrid storage is going to be big business in the future, on the order of size of storage for electrical vehicles. (And these will certainly not be mutually exclusive markets! Vehicle to grid tech will become widespread, as is already seen in the new F150 Lightning truck). Lithium ion will dominate for the foreseeable future, as the industry has scaled to massive sizes and already, and has the advantage of being currently unstoppable in the EV space. Batteries with a design that can decouple the energy from the power ratings, like this one, will be able to address parts of the market that lithium ion cannot. And if the cost per MWh of additional energy is cheap, and round trip efficiency stays above 50% or so, that sort of battery will have a huge edge in a part of the market that currently has no clear winners. There are many competitors in the non-lithium ion storage space, but one of the top contenders to watch is Form energy, which has a rust-based battery, and is rumored to have a cost as low as $20/MWh, about a tenth of that of lithium ion.
- octo_t 5y agoSeems like everyone wants to make everything in Rust these days! /s
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> one of the top contenders to watch is Form energy, which has a rust-based battery. Form is still in the cell prototyping stage, as best I can tell - maybe not even that. There's zero information on their website about where they are in the development process or really anything substantial about their design. ESS on the other hand has a design they've had out testing in the field for a couple years ( https://essinc.com/ess-inc-to-deliver-two-energy-warehouse-systems-in-germany/ https://essinc.com/ess-inc-to-deliver-two-energy-warehouse-s... is one such location) and has been shipping actual product: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20211115006337/en/ESS-Inc.-Announces-Third-Quarter-2021-Financial-Results https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20211115006337/en/ESS... and they've been pretty open about their design, though some of their old whitepapers have been removed from the site. Competition in the market is certainly a good thing, but Form needs to do more than just have a shiny website, a screengrab of a zoom employee meeting, and a blog with 'industry insight' posts (because they have nothing to show for tech/product.)
- Murkin 5y agoCan someone explain why this is better than just using pumps to pump water up from the reservoir and extract the energy with when the water returned back?
- tristor 5y agoIt requires less surface area, both due to compressibility and due to hydrodynamics. Additionally, water is a strong erosion source, air is not, so this can make use of existing excavations much easier and deep excavation is very very expensive.
- Murkin 5y agoBut they already fill the underground containers with water when there is low air pressure. (thats what the reservoir on top is, no?)
- hannob 5y agoPumped water only works if you have the right conditions. I.e. you need a certain altitude difference and enough space to have an upper and a lower water storage facility. Pumped water storage is very efficient and an established technology, so when it's possible it's a good choice, but it's not possible everywhere.
- Murkin 5y agoFrom what I gather in their explanation, they use air pressure to push water out of an underground container. The energy is reclaimed when the pressure is released (i.e. water can fall back and fill the container). How is the energy density different that what is provided by the water's static energy due to gravity?
- reincarnate0x14 5y agoIt's not, but it doesn't require a giant reservoir next to a 100m+ elevation change. Almost all of the really good locations for dams already have them, and their water discharge rates are driven by a lot more than just power generation.
- hannob 5y agoInteresting. The German energy company RWE has announced a while ago that they want to build a compressed air storage facility. However the project went nowhere and was silently buried at some point.
- EricE 5y agoPreventing air leakage is frightfully hard - air molecules are a lot smaller than liquid molecules :) Apparently these guys have found an economical way to deal with it. If true then I can easily see why Goldman jumped on them.
- mk81 5y ago
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoIn early 20th century in London there was an alternative hydraulic "power grid" with plants (aka pumps), storages and an underground distribution network of pipes. A building, for example, could connect to high pressure water mains and use it to power elevators. Electricity eventually won, but it's interesting to see an idea coming back. Zeppelins next! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Hydraulic_Power_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Hydraulic_Power_Company
- samstave 5y agoThere also used to be "central turbines" whereby there was a central spinning rod that one could attach belts to in order to spin a thing to get work out of it... called line and shaft https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7qt5tltnvF8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7qt5tltnvF8
- cjrp 5y agoReally cool, sort of like how an ICE drives ancillaries
- spenczar5 5y agoCool indeed, but pretty dangerous and difficult to reconfigure. Electric wires and motors are so much smaller, and easier to protect, and more interoperable, so you can see why they won out.
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoThat was one of the reasons behind having factory whistles: all workers take their places, the whistle, then the whole thing is started. While it's running people are not supposed to move around.
- snalty 5y agoThere's a cool working example of this at Kelham Island Museum in Sheffield, England.
- technicalbard 5y ago
- MPSimmons 5y agoThat sounds dangerous.
- sauwan 5y agoThe round trip efficiencies for these compressed air storage have typically been terrible (<50%). That's mostly because compressing air is super inefficient (lots of wasted heat). Are they able to harness that waste heat in some productive way? ETA: Just saw the video. Looks like they store the heat to boost generation on the return trip. This [1] says they get ~60% efficiency. [1] https://www.inceptivemind.com/hydrostor-build-largest-compressed-air-energy-storage-system-california/18798/ https://www.inceptivemind.com/hydrostor-build-largest-compre...
- arnaudsm 5y ago60% is great! That's much better than hydrogen, but still far from lithium. Let's hope the $/kWh is decent.
- danans 5y agoIt's not quite lithium ion efficiency, but it serves a different duration energy storage market (up to 24 hours vs single hours for lithium ion battery storage), and it has a much longer service life (50 years), so the levelized cost of storage might be lower than lithium ion battery storage.
- sokoloff 5y agoThe lithium ion batteries in my car store energy for weeks on end with losses around 1-2% per week (after an initial couple percent rapid drop).
- danans 5y agoWhat I meant is that current grid scale lithium ion battery storage projects are designed for at maximum a few hours between charge and discharge. They are mostly for shorter window grid stabilization, not to store energy for days or weeks. LiIon grid scale batteries are still very expensive as a long term energy storage solution, they are sized to provide higher value grid ancillary services, like frequence regulation.
- 5y ago
- surfmike 5y agoThis made me wonder what happened with LightSail energy, and found this takedown: https://www.greentechmedia.com/squared/letter-from-sand-hill-road/lightsail-energy-storage-and-the-failure-of-the-founder-narrative https://www.greentechmedia.com/squared/letter-from-sand-hill... Compressed air still seems like a promising idea to help solve the scale of energy storage we need, so I’m happy to see more companies taking a crack at it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- escapecharacter 5y agoAh, FartTech
- trembonator 5y ago
- jl6 5y agoI think the video said the system runs a cycle within a period of around 24 hours. What would it take to store energy in compressed air for ~6 months? This is what high-latitude dark-winter countries need: the ability to over-generate in the summer and draw down on stored energy in the winter.
- marvin 5y agoPumped hydroelectric storage is an obvious choice for the countries that have the geography, in effect meaning that most of the infrastructure for doing it is already in place. Hydroelectric reservoirs allow storing energy more or less indefinitely. Of course, the capacity will rarely have been dimensioned for keeping 6 months of usage on hand, but combining pumped storage with over-provisioned wind energy would allow for living through months of unfavorable sun, rain or wind conditions.
- robomartin 5y agoBased on my reading, these systems are, at best, in the order of 60% efficient. To state the obvious, this means that fully 40% of the energy they pull from the grid will be wasted. Burned. Never to be recovered. How is that a good idea? Solar? Well, solar isn't free energy. What's the comparison to grid scale batteries for storage? That process is far more favorable, with efficiency exceeding 80%. I have to admit not understanding how this kind of an investment happens. I don't see this as viable technology at scale. We are far better off building nuclear power plants (talk about dense energy storage!). Here's a good article on pumped thermal energy storage systems and how they compare to alternatives. The authors cover thermal storage in some detail. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2020.00160/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2020.0016...
- EricE 5y agoYou are spot on - the real answer is readily available: nuclear. We have reactor designs that if the active systems fail the reactors shut down naturally instead of running away. We have designs that can be burning all that "spent" fuel we are currently trying to bury for 10,000 years (!). Modular reactor designs in particular have incredible promise to provide for infinite scaling (just add more modules as needs increase), deal with the inefficient building, maintenance and decommissioning costs of todays light water reactor designs, and being modular provide far more granularity in power delivery further negating the need for energy storage to smooth out spikes and troughs in demands; allowing energy producers to far better match generation to power requirements. Sadly I think it will be far more feasible to develop energy storage technologies than hope we can ever get enough people to be rational about nuclear. I mean how asinine is it for Germany to have turned off perfectly working and economically viable nuclear plants to then be dependent on RUSSIA for natural gas? How dumb do you have to be to be to think that's a REMOTELY good idea? Yet here we are (thankfully France seems to be far more rational - you don't hear them even suggesting they plan to be equally idiotic). Many battery storage studies don't account for replacement/maintenance, or the infrastructure that would be required to sustain replacement/maintenance at grid scale, let alone the resources required to scale up to handle initial deployment of batteries in sufficient quantities to support the entire grid. Where are we going to get the manufacturing capacity, let alone materials? The scale here is pretty mind boggling if you start to do the math. Our current battery tech is nothing more than a transitory technology - they are far from sustainable long term. Personally I think super capacitors will be our ultimate solution, but in the meantime if these guys really have dealt with the seepage issues of compressed air, this is are next best bet for MASS energy storage at scale. You only have the privilege of worrying about efficiency if you have a working system. Wood driven steam sucked, but it drove the industrial revolution because there was literally no other viable alternative at the time that could have remotely scaled in the same way. Remember grid scale solutions require MASSIVE energy capabilities. The scale here is ridiculous compared to home or vehicle energy requirements. If you don't think Goldman Sachs took all of this into account before they made their investment - well, you are grossly mistaken. You don't get to be their size by continually placing bad bets.
- tonke90 5y agoThere is already something like this in Germany, it even also talks about saving the heat: https://www2.ipp.mpg.de/ippcms/ep/ausgaben/ep200801/0108_speicher.html https://www2.ipp.mpg.de/ippcms/ep/ausgaben/ep200801/0108_spe... (German)
- mwattsun 5y agoFrom another link on the front page the Amish use the term "Amish Electricity" so this would be an Amish Battery Amish Hackers https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29905288
- smm11 5y agoI had a huge burrito last night, and I am as I type, a massive compressed air storage device.
- nabla9 5y agoJust cheeked some levelized utility scale costs for the US: Advanced Nuclear is of $72/MWh. Wind onshore $30/Mwh Solar photovoltaic (PV) $30/Mwh Lithium-ion battery storage is roughly $180/Mwh. At the moment, if you want to provide baseload better than nuclear using renewables, the cost must of storage must not exceed $30-$40/Mwh. (grid baseload is the minimum level of demand on an electrical grid over a span of time, something unvarying power plants are best suited for. Renewables require storage and advanced grid to provide baseload.)
- treyfitty 5y agoI remember reading this article a few years ago that Goldman Sachs. It's paywalled but the basics was that GS stores energy during the night, and uses the energy during the day. I thought it was neat, but they're obviously not new to this concept. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-08-01/goldman-s-icy-arbitrage-draws-interest-to-meet-epa-rule https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-08-01/goldman-s...
- Melatonic 5y agoI think this is a great idea if you have systems that also use compressed air to function. If you need to convert compressed air to electricity the inherent losses in that conversion seem like they just would not be worth it as battery tech increases. Would love to see DC to DC grids become a thing again and it looks like they may - crazy to think that SF still has a fully operating DC grid powering all kinds of stuff.
- seedragons 5y agoNot a single "hot air" joke? Not sure to be impressed everyone's more mature than me or disappointed.
- reacharavindh 5y agoI’m not an electrical engineer. But, thinking about the power storage/retrieval problem with a computer engineer’s lens, I can draw a parallel to data storage/retrieval. L1/L2/L3 caches - expensive, small, but fast. RAM - mid tier, still fast, bigger than cache, less expensive than cache, but limited in capacity compared to disk/flash based storage. SSDs… Disks…. You get the point. Would it be the same with the grid? Several power sources - nuclear, solar, wind, hydro, hopefully not coal and gas. Banks of Lithium batteries acting as first level(efficient and immediate but limited capacity storage). Whatever excess is directed to longer term, non immediate storage - pump up water to generate power later, molten salt, air compression etc. Even more left? - spin up production of time insensitive materials that would be used anyway later - sea water desalination plants, green hydrogen generation, sewage treatment etc. At large scale such tiered ecosystems would be very cool and super useful.
- loceng 5y agoI've wondered if putting an compressed air energy storage system under certain types of buildings would work. Any thoughts on that? E.g. Apple's Ring HQ is already on a floating system to counter earthquakes, so why not add a layer of air? Unnecessary? Much more expensive than other options? Else?
- beders 5y agoStanford researcher Mark Z. Jacobson makes a similar case but with renewables and storage only: https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/WWSBook/WWSBook.html https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/WWSBook/WWSBook...
- stcredzero 5y agoLook into natural gas trading and scheduling. There's already an entire body of knowledge around storing energy, and sophisticated automated contracts, financial instruments, laws, and regulations. "Pools" are just energy storage, and the same geologic features used for those facilities could be used for compressed air storage. (EDIT: I used to do this software!)
- trompetenaccoun 5y ago
- hinkley 5y agoDave Borlace (Just Have a Think) has been covering this space a bit. There's a whole space in power storage that also overlaps with carbon capture that I suspect will probably end up being the winning play because cogeneration can often double system efficiency, making unprofitable things profitable. One way we can reduce carbon intensity is to stop using fossil fuels to generate industrial CO2. There's a kind of metal-air battery that actually absorbs CO2 while charging, and emits it while discharging. There is also air liquification as power storage, in which you can separate the oxygen, carbon dioxide and nitrogen into different containers.
- NotChina 5y ago