17 ms·
Two Years Is Long Enough
- sharmin123 5y ago
- jelsisi 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220112002320/https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/i-want-my-life-back-fear-covid/621214/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220112002320/https://www.theat...
- noahmbarr 5y agoI, and many people I know, are of similar thinking. I’m actively recovering from what appears to be Omicron. I cannot A/B test my experience as an unvaccinated person, but it feels like a light seasonal cold. We don’t get time back. IMO I want my life and city back.
- alisonkisk 5y agoSo there are actual stats on hospitalizations and deaths. Omicron is less severe, but also more widespread, so the overall effect is as bad as delta and alpha.
- jameskilton 5y agoOne should also caveat here that unvaccinated are far and above the ones ending up hospitalized, and dying, with Omicron. Those who are vaccinated and hospitalized very often have other underlying conditions that Omicron is exacerbating. Everyone else who is vaccinated is just getting sick, like a strong flu or cold. GET VACCINATED. At this point, it's the only way this pandemic will end.
- mythrwy 5y agoI didn't know the unvaccinated were dying of Omicron. The things you learn on hacker news.
- rolha-capoeira 5y agoNot defending the original comment because no source was provided, but I didn't know this was up for debate. It stands to reason. Now, how much more unvax vs vax are dying could be debated, but to say they are dying at the same rate would be to claim that the vaccine has no affect whatsoever.
- jonhohle 5y agoI would take that bet.
- dham 5y agoGet vaccinated yes, but that's not how the pandemic will end. It will end when most people have had this thing. Essentially it's probably over now but the media is going to hold on to it for a little while longer.
- jonhohle 5y agoI’m not sure why you think that or what data you are looking at, but current daily reported case count is 3x the same time last year (250k vs 800k) while reported deaths are half (4K vs 1.6k).
- rolha-capoeira 5y agoIsn't that what they said? Less severe, more widespread.
- jonhohle 5y ago> so the overall effect is as bad as delta and alpha I took the overall effect to mean deaths. Based on CDC statements, it seems like they are finally trying to divide hospitalized “from” vs. “with”. I’d expect a more contagious variant to show up more in hospitals for people who have come for unrelated reasons.
- cableshaft 5y agoBut hospitalizations are higher than last year's winter peak, so hospitals are still slammed (not everywhere, but in a lot of places). Also there's been a lot of doctors and nurses that have left the profession this past year from burnout (and not enough people champing at the bit to take their place...for obvious reasons) so many places were short-staffed to begin with.
- dwaltrip 5y agoOmicron does seems to be less severe. But don't forget deaths are a lagging indicator. They usually trail case counts by a few weeks.
- gitanovic 5y agoNot according to the data I saw, and for sure not in the countries I spend most of my time...
- gitanovic 5y agoSame here, I don't care about numbers and statistics any more. I want my life back NOW I've had more than enough with 8 quarantines, and all of us already had COVID, we are vaccinated, and we are FED UP with rules and restrictions It is pointless to be alive and well if you are not allowed to enjoy life
- cableshaft 5y agoWhere do you live that there are still any restrictions really worth a damn? In the US about the only thing I'm aware of is vaccination mandates for certain jobs and activities and indoor masking in certain states. Otherwise you can do pretty much whatever you could before the pandemic. Indoor dining, bars, theaters, gyms, flights, cruises, sporting events, offices for work, whatever. Unless, of course, the business is short staffed and has to close for a while, which is not a "rule and restriction" but a fact of life right now, which doesn't go away just because you or the government wills it to be so.
- gitanovic 5y agoI live in Germany, and the problem is a bit more subtle. At the moment is the 2g+ regulation, which basically means the if you are twice vaccinated of recovered + 1 vaccine dose you need to do a test every 24h to have a social life. Tests are free, but you have to queue outside and spend time to get them. Tests are not needed if you "boosted", i.e. if you had a 3rd dose (or second if you had only one), or as in my case you also recovered despite having 2 doses. Also there is a social craziness, where schools can close because there are cases, kindergartens also can close etc. and there are limits in the number of people can enter a venue, you have to book everything online, and there are very few places always fully booked... this de facto limits your life quite a lot. All this despite the numbers are comparable with a seasonal flu
- acdha 5y ago> I cannot A/B test my experience as an unvaccinated person, but it feels like a light seasonal cold. I think that's a key point and it really needs to be frankly communicated that way: vaccination mandates are what makes it safe enough to re-open safely. The U.S. has relatively low vaccination rates thanks to a well-funded political movement but as soon as there are personal consequences for those decisions most people do the right thing.
- woudsma 5y agoI try to understand the current restrictions but the numbers don’t make sense to me anymore. In my country there have been around 21k deaths from COVID (officially). 0.9% of those deaths were people that were between 0-49 years old. That’s ~200 deaths, in two years. The age group 0-49 represents 59% of the population in my country. I wish we’d get some numbers that we can work towards, in terms of when we can open up society again. This is a very hopeless situation.
- mettamage 5y agoThe problem that should be prevented is the healthcare system from being clogged. It wasn't pretty to begin with before COVID started, and now things are just ugly (i.e. waiting lists, rescheduling vital operations). I guess as I say this, the real question will be what's the excess mortality going to become if we let COVID run unchecked? What's the excess illness going to be (e.g. depression, untreated diseases, etc.)? I don't have good data on this unfortunately. > I wish we’d get some numbers that we can work towards, in terms of when we can open up society again. This is a very hopeless situation. I'll give you a number that is kind of pulled out of thin air, but it gets the point across: 95% fully boosted.
- dariusj18 5y agoI'm confused, are you saying that because only a certain subset of society is at risk of death that everyone else should just go about their days, even though going about their days WILL put that subset of people at further risk?
- bananapear 5y agoIsn't that an accurate description of how life used to work pre-2020?
- dariusj18 5y agoYou mean before there was a pandemic? Sure, it's all a matter of risk factors though. When there is a pan/epidemic that puts a large group at a 5-25% risk of mortality, that is a special circumstance.
- michaelrpeskin 5y agoThe narrative is changing quickly. Hold on as everyone backs away from the authoritarian rhetoric. https://www.coffeeandcovid.com/p/-coffee-and-covid-monday-january-caf https://www.coffeeandcovid.com/p/-coffee-and-covid-monday-ja...
- politician 5y agoWell, that article would be instantly flagged off HN if it were submitted here, but it makes an interesting case and paints an optimistic picture. Thanks.
- tasogare 5y agoWell, everyone except Macron, that probably see it as his only way to win the upcoming election. Anyway I hope the whole thing won't be memoryholed and that a special tribunal will judge the people involved in stripping citizens rights (undue lockdowns and vaccine pass) and forcing a dangerous and ineffective product on the people. One can dream...
- alYla 5y ago
- commandlinefan 5y ago> Once Omicron subsides, Biden will take the credit I'm even more cynical than you. We have to be "back to normal" (one way or another) by midterm elections next November, or the democrats will be wiped out.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThat isn’t cynical. The party in power will always take the blame for anything that isn’t going right. And COVID not ending as a pandemic is definitely one of those big things not going right. It doesn’t even matter that every other country is having the same problem, Americans expect their governments to solve it or they will “vote the turkeys out.” Cynical is “the Democrat hoax virus will disappear two weeks after the election.” If only Trump were right about that, but alas COVID wouldn’t disappear so easily. The cynics were optimists in that regard.
- ghaff 5y agoYou're describing pretty much every country with more-or-less free elections. What is true is that, whether people in the US look around their own country or look across the pond at Europe overall, it's increasingly difficult to lay everything on one political party and one politician in particular. Or indeed to argue that most policies/interventions (other than vaccinations that tend to prevent serious outcomes) make a huge difference at all.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThe policies and interventions have been fairly uniform in developed countries, with fairly uniform results. The only conclusion we can make is that barring very authoritarian zero COVID polices (like in China) or being a literal and figurative island (New Zealand), we can’t stop the pandemic with just vaccines and masking.
- Clubber 5y agoWhen this thing started, I did some quick research on the Spanish Flu. It lasted about 3 years or so, so I had a baseline of what we were in for. When (insert government entity) said "2 weeks of lockdowns to get this under control," or "we'll be COVID free by Independence Day," I knew that was overly optimistic. Anyhow, keeping that 3 year baseline helped me whether through it better mentally I think. Based on that, I'm still prepared for another year of this stuff. I also think of Smallpox, something everyone dealt with for at least 3000 years and had a 30% mortality rate and was more contagious than COVID. I'm glad it isn't that.
- DonnyV 5y agoSame here, not sure why anyone thought this was going to be over in a couple months. Especially here in the US which at this point is a failed state. Our government can't even provide basic services.
- escapedmoose 5y agoYep, my SO and I have aligned our expectations with the Spanish Flu since the start of all this. And while I can't say it's an encouraging comparison, I feel like it's at least helped to keep our expectations grounded in reality, which has saved us a lot of disappointment that others seem to be going through.
- mercy_dude 5y agoYeah when the Atlantic says it’s long enough, you know Americans are no longer buying the cheap propaganda and hysteria their outlets been selling for last two years continuously. Or they are trying to do some damage control to redeem the leftover credibility that their so called journalists might have.
- wayoutthere 5y agoThis sort of “glass half-full” analysis is often coming from white collar workers. The actual problem is that blue collar workers aren’t getting paid enough to risk getting Covid. So as much as you might want to go out and re-create a feeling of “normal”, that doesn’t work if people aren’t showing up to work because they’re sick. The lockdowns let us blame the government, but individuals are making decisions about their own health and service levels suffer as a result. And in many cases, the risk of getting sick and permanently disabled (yes omicron still has long-term side effects) is not worth $10/hr. We still effectively have lockdowns with many stores and restaurants closed, they’re just driven by low customer traffic or worker call-outs. Never mind that a lot of people’s buying habits have changed to purchasing more online and via delivery — it’s convenient enough I don’t think we’re ever going back. Same with remote work; city centers are never going to open back up the way they used to be if the wealthy parts of their workforce are working from home. Remote work is here to stay. It is the norm already and companies trying to force workers back are having extreme turnover issues. Unless you’re planning to compel workers back to their jobs at the end of a gun, we’re probably not going back to the version normal we had in 2019 ever again. We’ll eventually hit another island of stability, but given the political situation and immediacy of climate change effects, we will probably be jumping from crisis to crisis for the rest of our lives. Get used to it.
- Levitz 5y ago>Unless you’re planning to compel workers back to their jobs at the end of a gun, we’re probably not going back to the version normal we had in 2019 ever again. Maybe another version of OWS is coming, hopefully one that actually results in change and doesn't get co-opted by stupid identity politics this time around.
- wayoutthere 5y agoThe next OWS will be armed. The left is seeing the way the right operates and is understanding that non-violent confrontation doesn’t work. For better or worse, the way the laws in America are written, violence is the way we deal with problems. When someone who desires an outcome can use violent means to get you there, the second amendment ensures you have violent means to resist them.
- originalvichy 5y agoNordics already tried not caring about infections but rather hospitalizations. That didn’t help for long. The simple reality seems to be that too many sick at the same time not only fills up the healthcare system, it also punches holes into the labor force. New people to work in hospitals isn’t enough because the amount of ones leaving are making the net effect zero. The disease and overwhelming numbers of people sick burned them out. Nothing that I can say is new. Either we slow burn through this with restrictions while keeping a medium level of services available to society or burn fast while allowing many services to simply fail to deliver. I for one would rather not visit a late night bar for months rather than worry about where I could get food to cook at home for weeks. If you didn’t experience the empty shelves due panic buying in the beginning of covid then I wouldn’t wish it on people. As a person who also needs regular medication I don’t want to think how many weeks worth of meds I need my local pharmacies have left if logistics chains would suffer from shockwaves of too many workers out sick at the same time.
- gitanovic 5y agoThat was in a very different scenario: the beginning of the pandemics with a much more dangerous variant of the virus, and nobody vaccinated. So I don't think that what the Nordics attempted is applicable at current situation
- pupppet 5y agoThere’s still enough unvaccinated for the weaker strains to be a problem. Plus delta is still out there.
- andrewclunn 5y agoAt home taking care of my daughter. She has covid, and now so do I. I mean when this is all said and done, I will be what the vaccines (falsely) claimed they would make me: immune... at least to this variant... for a while. If it's endemic, mutates faster than even rushed through emergency medical interventions can stop, and is now so infectious that all our present restrictions aren't holding it back, then what is the point? Never mind discussions about the costs; where's the benefit in this cost benefit analysis?
- frafra 5y agoVaccine were never meant to make people immune; they have been approved and evaluated based on their effectiveness to reduce severe cases and deaths. We have been lucky enough that they have also been effective to reduce the spread. Even now, they are still very effective with respect to their main goal: reducing the number of people getting into the hospital because of COVID. After ~1 year of vaccinations and ~2 of COVID, I hoped that would have been crystal clear for most people, or, at least, for most of HN users.
- andrewclunn 5y agoWasn't sure which of these responses to shoot down, but prior to the definition change of what a vaccine was (which happened last year, well after the release of these "vaccines") that was precisely the definition. And all these claims now that no medical authority ever claimed the vaccines were going to make you immune... I understand that the "memory hole" is a real thing, but gosh, this is seriously not difficult to find: --- https://www.axios.com/coronavirus-pandemic-vaccine-herd-immunity-08e6e1ce-a6fe-4a8d-b339-79dcff6610e8.html https://www.axios.com/coronavirus-pandemic-vaccine-herd-immu... > "If you have 75%–80% of the people get vaccinated, you create an umbrella of herd immunity — that even though there is virus around, it is really almost inconsequential because it has no place to go, because almost all of the people are protected," Fauci says. --- I mean they're even now just distorting the term "immunity" to mean something new, but still pushing it in relation to vaccines: https://www.news-medical.net/news/20220111/Third-dose-of-mRNA-COVID-vaccine-induces-strong-immunity-in-older-adults.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20220111/Third-dose-of-mRN...
- fasteddie31003 5y agoI had Omicron and it was easier than the common cold for me. It's over for me until we get the next variant. I honestly feel bad for our government health officials. They failed. I think "science" is going to take a little bit of a loss, unfortunately.
- acdha 5y agoAre you vaccinated?
- fasteddie31003 5y agoYes with J&J
- acdha 5y agoI think that's probably the key part: the vaccination discussion has generally conflated two parts — neutralizing antibodies are what help you avoid getting sick at all but those wane over time, whereas the T cell response which helps you quickly fight off an infection lasts far longer. That has been very poorly communicated because a lot of the public health people have been focused on containing spread and T cells do not keep you from being contagious but that's really what we should be communicating: get vaccinated and this becomes a lot more similar to influenza.
- s5300 5y agoCould you pleeease go tell all of the people that have overflowed the ICUs of the nations hospitals that they’re overreacting & should just go home with their common cold symptoms. Because there’s currently like 2500+ national guard members deployed to hospitals in my state alone, all elective procedures are cancelled in the major hospitals of multiple states (anything that won’t literally kill you in 3 days is elective, even end stage cancer surgeries), other types of appointments are backed up for months, and quite frankly - for the appointments I and acquaintances have had - providers are burnt the fuck out from two years of this. Like, seriously. When thousands of national guard members have to be routed to civilian hospitals to keep them running - I don’t think “science” is taking a loss. It said this was going to happen, all of you “it’s just the common cold” people made everybody rage against science and not care, and now nobody can get meaningful healthcare because the person the nurses & attendings are referring to as “the walking dead” just have to be kept alive & filling an ICU bed for 3+ weeks stuffed with a ventilator they’re never going to have removed until they’re dead.
- seneca 5y agoI believe what we're seeing here is the left-media machine beginning to try to change the narrative about covid for the run up to the mid-terms elections in the US. They've hung their hat on the authoritarian approach until now and utterly failed to actually do anything, and seem to want to avoid being punished for it. There are too many of these about-face articles appearing at once to seem organic and not an attempt to manufacture consent, so to speak.
- causalmodels 5y agoI share your distrust of the media, but I think there is an even more cynical answer at play. A bunch of my personal friends work for these publications. Almost all of us got covid in December, ironically many from the holiday parties of these publications, and came face to face with the reality that we have sacrificed almost two years of our 20s to a virus that was pretty mild. The thing we were trying to avoid came for us, so the idea that we would continue to live in fear of an event that already happened is absurd.
- tootie 5y agoThis attitude is so grossly irrational. Disasters don't end when you get bored with them. They end when they end. This kind of article is basically saying "I have reset my expectations so that I accept a higher risk of death so I can go to the movies". You can argue and end to restrictions on the merits of changing reality (ie vaccines, treatments, relative mortality of Omicron) but not "I'm out of patience with nature taking it's course". Personally I think the Omicron wave is still extremely serious and we need to wait a few more months. And if a new variant emerges it'll be longer.
- black_13 5y ago
- maxerickson 5y agoI'm on board with doing more than nothing to deal with Omicron (and future variants), but risk of death for recovered and vaccinated people is factually much lower than it was prior to vaccination or recovery. The situation is changing.
- Supermancho 5y ago> This kind of article is basically saying "I have reset my expectations so that I accept a higher risk of death so I can go to the movies". Correct. This is a rational stance, even if you disagree. Over the decades, I've observed that US society starts to break down when there is a danger of an unknown origin or bounds. People become irrational and panic, resulting in all sorts of defensive behavior in the face of uncertainty (some of these rituals are helpful, some not). This is true at both the macro and micro level; eg fear of getting sued, fear of computers, fear of selling collectibles. US society has an expectation of informed consent. Crossing the street has inherent dangers. Juggling chainsaws has inherent dangers. Skydiving has inherent dangers. If US society has been largely convinced that there is codified information that both sets relative-risk and laws regarding liability exist, activities are considered "normal life" with whatever inherent dangers are "known". I would call this known state, a narrative, but it's more like the meta-narrative across all areas. There are constant changes to these qualities, over time and space, so this affects it; eg It used to be illegal for a vehicle to turn right on red in some areas of the US, without prohibitive signage. Is that still true? The meta-narrative says that laws between states are kooky and you might want to look it up. Spoiler: it's legal in all 50 states since 1980ish. edit: not in NYC, among other cities as tootie has pointed out. For now the meta-narrative around COVID has stabilized to: We know it's a virus. We know it's communicable by air. We know the risk groups (or can look it up). We know the defensive protocols. et al. > Personally I think the Omicron wave is still extremely serious and we need to wait a few more months. This doesn't require a retooling of society, reaffirmation of doubting the science, or theorizing about potential worst case scenarios. A large portion of the US public is done with the handwringing and fearmongering. You can wait as long as you want. It won't change anything about the world you adopt as the new normal. Life is more dangerous than it was a few years decade ago because there's a new vector. There is no end, much like if you get cancer or lose a limb. Life is just harder now, for everyone for the foreseeable future.
- jccalhoun 5y agoI'm in a small city in the midwest and if you went to a store today you would think there was no covid. It isn't like my state was declared the least safe for covid or anything. I went to see Spider-Man at a 4pm matinee -the first movie I've seen in a theater since this all started and I was the only person in the theater wearing a mask. And my state attorney general is going on tv saying he doesn't believe the statistics and the state legislature is says that teachers need to be impartial when teaching about nazis... And people wonder why I'm such a misanthrope.
- andrewclunn 5y agoThose evil nazis and their matinees! If Spiderman has the decency to wear a mask, then they should too! But really, I'd almost assume that was a sarcastic post you made... if it weren't that NOT conforming to a "papers please" mentality now got you labelled as a "nazi" by the good boys and girls who do what the authorities tell them.
- colpabar 5y agoJust for clarification, do you mean the actual flag waving nazis from ww2, or the "nazis" that exist today?
- beardedetim 5y agoIf this is in the US and it's One Of Those States, I wouldn't be surprised if it was Flag Carying WW2 Nazis and not "cancel culture" ones. I grew up in One Of Those States and we talked highly about Slave Owners, Pinkerton, and other obviously bad people.
- jccalhoun 5y agohttps://www.indystar.com/story/news/education/2022/01/06/nazi-scott-baldwin-indiana-facism-education-teachers/9123302002/ https://www.indystar.com/story/news/education/2022/01/06/naz...
- tfandango 5y agoMy wife is a 2nd grade teacher, also in the midwest. 200+ kids out today with covid or b/c of a family member. Over a dozen teachers out today in a small school. There are no subs and they are asking parents who aren't sick to come "supervise" classes. The janitor quit and nobody is cleaning the bathrooms or classrooms. Yet the superintendent says schools need to be open, we are taking all the best safety precautions, etc, etc... completely ignoring the reality on the ground which I'm 100% sure he knows about. At some point reality has to set in here? right? maybe?
- hnuser847 5y agoIt's pretty interesting seeing a complete about-face from the corporate media after beating the fear drum incessantly for the past two years. They've enthusiastically supported every lockdown, every school closure, and every mask mandate. They vilified people for wanting to do totally normal human things, like going to parties, seeing family members over the holidays, eating at restaurants, or going to work. Why the sudden change in perspective?
- andrewclunn 5y agoGotta get those economy numbers up before the delayed State of the Union address in March, in order to not lose horribly in the midte... oh perhaps I'm being too cyncial? Nah.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- escapedmoose 5y agoIn the US, I remember the "fear drum" dying down considerably once vaccinations got more widespread, and then ramping up again once Delta started hitting hospitals hard, then moreso with Omicron. It seems to follow peaks in infection rates/hospitalizations.
- bwf93 5y agoI would like to go to olive garden. If some of you need to die to make that happen so be it.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't do this here.
- tekchip 5y agoThere seems to be this one or the other mentality. Why not both? At some point previous pandemics are now endemic. Sure we all want this thing to end but why is it either right now, or never? Let's continue cautiously to work at striking a balance between restriction and freedom until we get a good handle on how we do yearly boosters, and have enough of an understanding of how this thing changes to keep it in check through "normal" societal processes. For those who want "freedom now" we all do. Just hang in there a bit longer until we work this out friend.
- jgwil2 5y agoIt seems to me that we now face two options: we can prolong the pandemic by continuing to enforce basic safety measures like lockdowns and mask mandates, in order to reduce the load on the healthcare system, or we can just say fuck it and try to accelerate endemicity by trying to give everyone Omicron... I know that "prolonging the pandemic" sounds bad and like the opposite of what we should be striving for, but a controlled transition to endemicity may lead to a lot less of the kind of economic and social disruption that we're seeing right now with empty shelves, canceled flights, and classrooms without teachers. In other words, we can have a shorter, more miserable end to the pandemic, or we can have a longer one with less chaos. Am I missing something here?
- Ancalagon 5y agoI think the big fear is that an omicron variant will emerge far more lethal if you allow it run rampant. Even though it kind of already is so maybe thats a moot point now.
- benpiper 5y agoEnough with the cultlike devotion to vaccines that have proven unable to bring an end to Covid. Rags like The Atlantic are profiting from pushing health disinformation just because it gets clicks.
- vb6sp6 5y ago