13 ms·
New‐onset autoimmune phenomena post‐Covid‐19 vaccination
- The_rationalist 5y agoIts a crime that third dose is obligatory in france despite lack of scientific data regarding the propensity of the strength of imflammation and oxidative stress following a third dose. I will coadminister an antioxidant to my forced injection in order to diminish risk of accellerated ageing. claimer: I have expertise in pharmacology
- raxxorrax 5y agoThe problem I see is that it is applied to everyone. Children have an extremely low risk profile and the potential side effects might surpass a covid infection by some magnitudes.
- jalino23 5y agois anyone able to explain this in plain english please ?
- dtech 5y agoI'm not an immunologist, but skimming through this it seems to describe patient cases who developed auto-immune disorders after - not necessarily because of - a mRNA covide vaccine, and describes possible causal chains in the immune system. Since these cases emerged within a month, it seems to describe extremely rare side-effects rather than anything widespread but as of now yet unknown.
- rsfern 5y agoOne thing to note - they cover case reports following six major vaccine platforms, not just the mRNA ones. The review seems pretty good about differentiating when summarizing, but a lot (maybe a third?) of their descriptions of the individual case reports don’t specify which vaccine was given so you have to jump to the cited report in those cases.
- ggm 5y agoIt's a catalogue of potential side effects. What they don't state is frequency, and variance from normal population. Nor do they discuss viral risks of the same diseases. Basically it's saying "this can happen" and that's useful but it would have helped enormously if they had said how many instances in what size cohorts.
- creshal 5y agoThe individual studies they're referencing do that. Overall, there's a risk, but it's negligible with sufficient monitoring.
- creshal 5y agoThis meta-study summarises various studies that look into reported cases of auto-immune problems after vaccination. Most of these are in the order of 1-2 cases per million vaccine doses, and often close to the natural background rate of these problems manifesting in otherwise healthy individuals: If you look at 100,000 people for a year, you expect 2 of them to contract Guillain–Barré syndrome naturally, 1 to develop blood clots, etc. pp. So the various studies also determine if there even is a statistically significant increase or not, which there sometimes is, sometimes isn't. The meta-study summarises all that. And even taken together, all the various problems are not significant enough to counterindicate any of the vaccines, given just how much more dangerous covid infections are: > Although allergic reactions to vaccines are rare, as vaccination programmes are being rolled out globally, many vaccine-related side-effects are being reported. Importantly, we do not aim to disavow the overwhelming benefits of mass vaccination with COVID-19 in controlling COVID-19 pandemic and preventing COVID-19 morbidity and mortality. We encourage and support COVID-19 vaccination globally to create an immunity barrier among population.
- novaRom 5y agoAnyone knows if it's common practice in China to write scientific papers first in Chinese and then translate into English? This paper is very good written!
- throw8932894 5y agoIt was probably assembled by professional editor. It is great job for digital nomads, and many bright people in line for this type of work. And paper has a good budget, there is an ad on first page :)
- raverbashing 5y agoAnyone that's worried about autoimmune phenomena after vaccination should look at autoimmune phenomena post Covid infection
- odiroot 5y agoIsn't cytokine storm in the late stage of corona infection exactly that?
- raverbashing 5y agoKinda, but I'm not sure if it fits the autoimmune definition or just a runoff immune response (but still against the antigens)
- robrorcroptrer 5y agoWhat if I got infected before being eligible to be vaccinated?
- raverbashing 5y agoThen most likely you're not amongst the ones that suffer a reaction
- yunohn 5y agoBut you can get COVID after vaccination too? How exactly does your argument sway someone either way? Just saying that both the disease and the vaccine cause the same side effects is not much of an argument… Disclaimer: I’m fully vaccinated.
- robbiep 5y agoBut they aren’t in the same magnitude - for example, incidences of peri/myocarditis is 30x (at a minimum) greater in someone who has COVID vs someone vaccinated; and vaccination leads to shorter milder breakthrough infections which (should - I can’t claim to have seen a study) lead to a lower incidence compared to someone who was unvaccinated and infected
- alexmcc81 5y agoI'm in this boat. I'm worried I now have a life long disability before 35. I'm waiting for an appointment with a Rheumatology consultant and I have been told by my doctor they have been inundated with people with post COVID vaccine side effects. Edit: I would like to hear other people's experiences if they are willing to post them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 5y agoWe need more independent open-source data collection and analysis to supplement the limited reporting in VAERS (https://vaers.hhs.gov/data.html https://vaers.hhs.gov/data.html, https://medalerts.org https://medalerts.org, https://www.howbadismybatch.com https://www.howbadismybatch.com, https://openvaers.com/covid-data https://openvaers.com/covid-data). Oct 2021, https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/covid-vaccine-injury-claims-mount-recourse-is-lacking-those-harmed-2021-10-19/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/covid-vaccine-injur... > More than 1,300 COVID vaccine-related injury claims are now pending before an obscure government tribunal ... Lawyers tell me the vaccine is so new that there’s virtually no definitive research on injury causation to cite ... In the meantime, people like McFadden face a strict one-year deadline from the date of vaccination to file a claim with the CICP. 2021 news reports on heart issues in athletes (missing baseline numbers for prior years): https://airtable.com/shrbaT4x8LG8EbvVG/tbl7xKsSUIOPAa7Mx https://airtable.com/shrbaT4x8LG8EbvVG/tbl7xKsSUIOPAa7Mx
- robbiep 5y agoI’m sorry to hear about your issues. With respect, I’ll take a stand against your claim of there being a tsunami of patients with vaccine injuries innundating rheumatologists - I am in the field and continue to ask colleagues if they are seeing anything of the sort and no-one has seen anything like this. However, if it is happening, we will surely see it in the data. Australia is almost fully vaccinated (but also more recently vaccinated than say the US) so maybe what you’re saying is still coming, but I think it is important to remain skeptical of large numbers of vaccine injured until there is reasonably robust data
- ageitgey 5y agoThis is a pretty non-controversial paper and doesn't contain anything shocking or previously unknown, but the title has the potential to cause controversy. Here's my quick summary: - Previous vaccines for HPV, Hepatitis B and Flu are known to (rarely) trigger or worsen autoimmune diseases such as Guillain-Barré syndrome. - Lots of new Covid vaccines have been created globally using a wide variety of technologies (mRNA, Adenovirus vector, inactivated virus, etc), so it stands to reason they could trigger rare side effects and different technologies might be associated with different side-effects. - It seems wise to research how different side-effects might happen with each type of vaccine. - These side-effects are so rare that it has not been proven they are caused by the vaccines - "However, whether the association between COVID-19 vaccine and autoimmune manifestations is coincidental or causal remains to be elucidated." But given the timing of them occurring in large populations post-vaccination, it's worth researching the possible mechanisms to figure out why they happen and see if they can be prevented. - Even when side effects do occur, they can typically be treated using the standard protocols for each condition. But the more we know about them, the better we would be at treating them and at predicting which patients would be more likely to be at risk of developing them. - The risk of rare side effects does not mean that populations shouldn't be vaccinated, because the risks of COVID-19 itself are higher - "We encourage and support COVID-19 vaccination globally to create an immunity barrier among population." - But we should monitor for side-effects and learn about the mechanisms at work so we can prevent them, possibly by screening patients most at risk - "Systematic monitoring and ongoing follow-up of autoimmune events will be critical in identifying potential associations between autoimmune manifestations and COVID-19 vaccination, specific mechanisms of diagnosis and risk stratification for future vaccination." So in short, let's all be grown ups and study the rare side-effects of vaccines so we can make them every more rare through better prevention and/or treatment. Here are the specific conditions they theorize might be (in rare cases) triggered or worsened by the two most common types of vaccines in the West: mRNA (Pfizer, Moderna) - Vaccine-induced immune thrombotic thrombocytopenia (i.e your blood won't clot well) - Immune thrombocytopenic purpura (bruising caused by low platelets) - Autoimmune liver diseases - Guillain–Barré syndrome - IgA nephropathy (i.e. kidney problems) - Rheumatoid arthritis - Graves' disease (i.e. thyroid problems) - Type 1 diabetes mellitus Adenovirus vector (Johnson & Johnson, AstraZenica) - Vaccine-induced immune thrombotic thrombocytopenia (i.e your blood won't clot well) - Autoimmune liver diseases - Guillain–Barré syndrome - Rheumatoid arthritis - Systemic lupus erythematosus (i.e. Lupus) The paper also summarizes how these might be caused, but that's way beyond a summary. Just read the paper of you are interested.
- walterbell 5y agoI wish we could have a disclaimer on every article/study about vaccine side effects, something like: "This is not an attack on vaccines, pharmaceutical interventions, associated stakeholders or policy makers. This is not a statistical assessment of risk for specific audiences. Please focus feedback and resources on specific treatments for the living human beings who have been injured. Even one in a million is of little consolation when you are the unlucky lottery winner. If we can keep the focus on actionable treatments for helping those few who have been injured, we can improve pre-treatment screening to reduce those few injuries even closer to zero. Let's aim for one in ten million or less."
- alexmcc81 5y agoThanks you for this thoughtful response. I chose to be vaccinated and unfortunately have suffered serious consequences like a very small number of other people will statistically. It's been pretty disheartening to see that sharing anything negative about vaccines, even those warned about by medical officials, leads to very negative reactions from people (being told to shut up, being censored/downvoted online etc). I honestly no longer discuss why I'm sick or why I can't do certain things with friends or co-workers.
- core-utility 5y agoThat is awful to hear. I unfortunately think this entire debacle will leave a lasting distrust of our medical providers and institutions. Vaccine hesitant are already distrustful, and I believe in the coming months/year as more stand up to the censorship of these real issues, a growing number of vaccinated will feel mislead and lied to (whether justified or not). The only recovery path I can see is the return of a strong level of informed consent between patient and provider, and big tech getting out of the healthcare game.
- mauvehaus 5y agoA good first step might be making sure the population is educated sufficiently to identify and weigh the risks between a 1 in 1,000,000 side effect, the disease the vaccine protects against, and the pure bullshit peddled by fear mongers. Right now, we have people in the US who still believe that Covid is no worse than a bad case of the flu. All the evidence (at least for the pre Omicron variants) suggests that the reality, as viewed by death rate, is orders of magnitude more bleak.
- dwd 5y agoThe other issue not mentioned are the reported post-vaccine reactions where the person previously contracted Covid-19. Q-Vax (registered for use in Australia only) vaccinates for Q Fever and has strict pre-screening to avoid vaccinating someone who had already contracted it.
- robbiep 5y agoThis is because of the specific immunological response the body mounts to Q Fever (which would happen with a repeat infection) if a person already has antibodies, not because vaccinating someone who has already had the condition being vaccinated against has some inherent triggering effect that is detrimental. There is no good reason to perform a similar screening in the case of SARS-CoV-2 and there is good reason TO vaccinate because the vaccine is more consistently protective against hospitalisation and death compared to an infection of the same
- c7DJTLrn 5y ago
- junon 5y ago> you need to know every possible side effect beforehand This is impossible and this stance comes from a complete misunderstanding about how vaccine studies work. Science has, in fact, prevailed here.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoIf it‘s impossible to iron out side effects, do not make vaccination obligatory then.
- jtc331 5y ago
- junon 5y agoEmergency use does not mean tests weren't carried out. It just means the entire process was given the highest priority at every step of the chain. There were quite a few other companies that submitted vaccines for review that were denied, but nobody seems to want to talk about them. Studies weren't "cut short". They're still ongoing. Dozens of independent auditors checking the efficacy, safety, and side effects of the vaccines constantly with incoming medical information. It's naive and misinformed to think we're just sticking shit into our arms without understanding it.
- feistypharit 5y agoDon’t forget the placebo effect works both ways. All the antivax people that got the vaccine even though they may not have wanted to, are going attribute everything weird that then happens to the vaccine. This is all going to take years to sort out and figure out what’s real and what’s not. And we’ll never know 100%. The bigger issue is whether we’ll be able to trust our present or future leaders to let science do its job.
- taf2 5y agoOne thing IMO - that would help our leaders is if they recognize “science” is not a person or a thing… it’s a process. Away if thinking that allows for the discovery of both positive and negative outcomes. It is a process. /2cents
- giantg2 5y ago"This is all going to take years to sort out and figure out what’s real and what’s not." It shouldn't have to if the system actually works. The problem is VEARS sees significant under reporting. In theory, you should report every little thing that has an unknown cause. Then researchers can view the data and eliminate symptoms by comparing them to the population baseline occurrence.
- foxhop 5y ago
- PickledHotdog 5y ago
- foxhop 5y ago
- joshuahughes 5y agoIncredibly disappointing to see foxhop's comments flagged and dead, while pickledhotdog's snark lives on. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html is worth a read. "Don't be snarky." "Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." "When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names."
- elif 5y agoThey should have some kind of "can't remove from headline" disclaimers for papers like this to keep them from fueling idiocy. This paper lays out in it's intro that it will make no attempt to find causation, yet in media this headline will be used almost exclusively to prove that point.
- jtc331 5y agoAnd yet also it’s standard medical practice to assume causation (for the purpose of not causing harm) when there exists correlation of adverse events with new treatments until proven otherwise.
- native_samples 5y agoIf you read the paper it discusses causal mechanisms extensively. Reality is you can't get a paper about vaccine side effects out, or keep it out, unless you grovel in the intro and state that vaccines are wonderful, safe and everyone should take them. Skip the obligatory morality disclaimer at the start and you'll see lots of case studies where causality is obvious, along with discussions of how it works, e.g. "A 67-year-old patient from Hispanic had petechial rashes on her legs and chest 2 weeks after receiving the first dose of COVID-19 vaccine (Pfizer-BioNTech). Then, she received the second dose of the vaccine two days prior to developed bleeding in her gums, a rapid rash covering her body and a subconjunctival haemorrhage in the right eye" ... "There are several putative mechanisms by which COVID-19 vaccine triggers immune thrombotic thrombocytopenia (ITT). First, Greinacher and colleagues considered that COVID-19 vaccination causes a rare ITT mediated by activation of antibodies against PF4 that stimulate platelets through their Fcγ receptors" ... "First, an interval of 1–3 weeks between vaccination and the onset of symptoms supports a temporary causal relationship" ... "For instance, a 30-year-old man, without family history of kidney disease, developed fevers, headache and brown-coloured urine, coupled with new-onset haematuria and proteinuria 1 day after vaccination, eventually diagnosed with IgA nephropathy"
- juanani 5y ago
- callmeal 5y agoI must say I'm surprised at most of the comments here. Whatever happened to "corelation does not imply causation"?
- patricko123 5y agoHow much of this can be explained by pure statistics? When you have vaccination rates of 60% and above, you're going to see very rare diseases and disorders show up in the treated population. Correlation doesn't imply causation. It would be great to see what the prevalence of diseases in treated population is compared to that in the previously (pre-covid) untreated population, I expect that comparing against the currently untreated population could be problematic due to the higher incidence of covid in this population. I feel that the paper (from a scan admittedly) is more a anecdotal listing of cases so I don't get a feel for whether the needle has shifted or not wrt autoimmune case incidence. While I think it's a great idea to look into the effects of the vaccination on folks, I also fear that the downside effects of anti-vaxxers waving this paper around out of context saying you see you shouldn't get vaccinated because you're going to have all these autoimmune issues.
- codeflow2202 5y agoDownplay or pretend that side-effects do not exist will only exacerbate the already high distrust on medical institutions. Acknowledgement, sincerity and the will to improve is the only way to fix the huge distrust that has been built in the last couple years (or maybe decades).
- benpiper 5y agoMany people don't realize that antibody production is not necessarily a good thing. In a strep infection, antibodies are what actually cause rheumatic fever. That's why antibiotics are so important to kill off the infection before the adaptive immune system kicks in.
- sauwan 5y agoWould these people have had a similar issue had they contracted COVID? In other words, is it the spike protein or the delivery mechanism that is causing these problems?
- tommiegannert 5y agoI'm starting to think 100% vaccination is a weird goal. There have been examples of drugs that only caused issues years after taking it. Thalidomide (called "Neurosedyn" in Sweden) is one. Even if issues arise right away, it may take years to gather statistical data to agree on the risk factors. In the meantime, to any one doctor, it may look random. Injecting every person on Earth with one of only a few, new, vaccines seems dangerous. This has me wondering about two things: 1) Isn't it good to have an unvaccinated control group? 5-10%? Not just based on people who for some reason cannot take any vaccine, but healthy individuals. 2) Shouldn't we only use a single vaccine for every dose per person? To narrow the population affected by potential unknown side-effects. Has anyone heard any officials/domain experts discuss this? (I'm not against vaccination per se, and am myself on the third dose already. I'm just worried we're blinded by one danger, and willingly heading into another.)