19 ms·
TSMC’s Arizona Culture Clash
- lettergram 5y agoSo, the fab isn't opened at all -- this is speculation. Intel has many fabs, texas instruments has many fabs, etc There wont be an issue here. IMO this reads more like a hit piece or something indicating that they want to back out of the Arizona deal or get more money. It's not really clear.
- j_walter 5y agoIt's not open, but many of the new engineers are currently training in Taiwan. The engineer in question is simply seeing what his TSMC counterparts are doing. The Taiwanese culture is very hard working and that is why TSMC is ahead of Intel and Samsung now. You are correct though, there won't be an issue because this hard work atmosphere will weed out the weak and breed the strong.
- emodendroket 5y agoThis seems like total nonsense. Korea's work culture is not exactly Scandinavia and even the US is tough by the standards of other high-income countries. Plus, like, how did Dutch ASML get ahead, did they get some sort of special dispensation?
- j_walter 5y agoThey cornered the market...they literally have a monopoly and it's impossible to compete against at this point. AMAT is also impossible to compete against despite how shitty they are because they just buy competitors and make them shitty to. If you have seen how TSMC works on the inside you would understand the culture and the drive to succeed. They don't care about political correctness, they could care less about having a diversity program...they want the best person for the job. They hired a former Intel HR director for the AZ plant and the first thing he asked was about their diversity program...after multiple issues with him he is no longer at TSMC AZ.
- emodendroket 5y agoI doubt Samsung has much of a diversity operation in Korea either. I am rather incredulous that those positions (which, frankly, do not actually have that much influence on the running of the business day-to-day) make that much of a difference to the success of one company or another.
- j_walter 5y agoYou would be surprised how much impact a poorly directed HR department can have...not just on new hires but on senior people as well.
- JaimeThompson 5y ago"They hired a former Intel HR director for the AZ plant and the first thing he asked was about their diversity program" Do you have a source for that?
- mrkstu 5y agoFound this[0] link showing the hiring at least: "TSMC this year hired Benjamin Miller, a 25-year Intel veteran, as its head of human resources in Arizona." [0] https://www.reuters.com/technology/exclusive-tsmc-looks-double-down-us-chip-factories-talks-europe-falter-2021-05-14/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/exclusive-tsmc-looks-doub...
- j_walter 5y agoI've spoken directly with the person he said that to.
- atty 5y agoWhat? No. The reason they got ahead was because their business model got them volume production on a scale that let them tweak and improve their process faster and more efficiently compared to the competition. And Intel shooting themselves in the foot and skipping EUV for their last few nodes was a big factor too. Also, suggesting people are “weak” or “strong” based on the number of hours they’re willing/able to work is… problematic at best.
- analognoise 5y agoBecause we're all done with that "grind culture" bullshit, 100%, and we're finally calling it out for what it is.
- chrisjc 5y agoWho's "we're"? There will always be those willing to embrace the "grind culture". Whether it's new grads eager for experience, those that have experienced life without opportunity and "freedom" or just those desperate to make ends meet.
- analognoise 5y agoSee? It's out in the open now. Hustle culture exploits the young, the economically disadvantaged, and the desperate. It's basically poison, and there are enough people finally saying the quiet part out loud. I guess "we" is whoever doesn't believe in exploiting the young, economically disadvantaged, or desperate. I guess some people love exploiting vulnerable groups though, you're right. I just assumed nobody would want to be associated with that kinda toxicity.
- j_walter 5y agoExactly this...there are always those willing to work their ass off to succeed. Those who are willing to do so get rewarded...but finding out who those people are takes time and generally that's not something you can see on a resume. The engineer in this story may not fit the bill...
- deepnotderp 5y agoGiven that Intel had undisputed process leadership until 10nm it seems that the "Taiwanese work culture advantage" works in mysterious ways.
- necovek 5y agoIt's not mysterious at all: since they are shorter on average and thus have smaller hands, their work culture advantage only appeared at processes smaller than 10nm!
- Bahamut 5y agoSamsung (and Korean companies in general) isn't exactly known for work-life balance either (source: uncle was an exec and a sibling was a senior engineer there).
- heleninboodler 5y agoI agree that it reads like a hit piece and leads the reader to believe that it's already a disaster there. Is it possible that Intel is so worried about the talent vacuum that they'd pay someone to write this kind of story?
- q1w2 5y agoIt is entirely possible that the article was commissioned by the competition. This sort of thing is cheap and done all the time.
- th0ma5 5y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gung_Ho_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gung_Ho_(film)
- schappim 5y agoTL;DR in three lines: >> “The work culture in Taiwan is really different than in the U.S.,” said a person identified as a TSMC Arizona fab equipment engineer on Glassdoor >> “The reality for people from Taiwan is that they are doing even more than 12-hour days often". >> “TSMC will have to change to an eight-hour work day five days a week.” ... well yes!
- black_13 5y ago
- otherotherchris 5y agoBullshit article. Intel rosters it's staff onto 12 hour shifts in their fabs too.
- radiator 5y agoAbout the last line, I am surprised it is mentioned. One would think that TSMC might have known about this small issue, before deciding to build a plant in the USA.
- j_walter 5y agoThis is not their first plant in the US, and working >8 hour days is the norm for most engineers there.
- radiator 5y agoYes, I see now in your and others' comments that I had some false impressions about working conditions in american factories.
- j_walter 5y agoThe working requirements in 24/7 manufacturing facilities is different than most 8-5 jobs. When you have $30B invested into a facility you have to maximize output and that means keeping all of the equipment up and running.
- PKop 5y ago12 hour days. Sounds pretty dystopian. Guess there's a reason Taiwan has the lowest birthrate in the world. Working themselves into oblivion.
- Karupan 5y ago> 12 hour days. Sounds pretty dystopian And quite common in certain industries. I have relatives in oil rigs and aircraft maintenance who work 12 hour shifts 4 days a week. But they do usually get 3 day weekends and other perks.
- Beldin 5y agoAround here, in certain areas, full-time is 36hrs. You can arrange to do 4 days of 9 hours each and have 3-day weekends. 12 hour days may be reasonable in certain situations, but "3 day weekend" doesn't sound like nearly enough of a perk.
- arethuza 5y agoIn the UK North Sea, two weeks on and two weeks off certainly used to be standard on the rigs, fisherman would often be at sea Sunday evening to Thursday or Friday every week.
- gspr 5y agoBut this is clearly not what the GP post was getting at.
- dehrmann 5y agoYou know about 996, right?
- josephcsible 5y agoI thought 996 was a mainland China thing.
- MangoCoffee 5y ago
- rjzzleep 5y agoVery interesting. Yeah labour is cheap in Taiwan. Even highly qualified, specialized labour. That's why talent leaves to China, USA and Israel. But about the factory itself, American Factory was quite interesting[1]. Chinese company, but similar culture clash. It is interesting however that from what I have seen Europeans that wouldn't lift a finger on a weekend would expect Taiwanese to have results on Monday morning, when they themselves only send information about their requests on Friday end of day. So in the middle of the Friday night for the Taiwanese. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Factory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Factory
- random12345678 5y agoThe level of entitlement from Westerners is unreal. "You can't have your cake and eat it too"
- chad_stevens 5y agoYes we can ;)
- rStar 5y ago
- anonAndOn 5y agoWhat's the point of a cake if they can't eat it?
- kingTug 5y agoLot of troubling quotes, yikes. These workers need to push for a union from the onset.
- siva7 5y ago“Our analysis software has been passed down since the establishment of the company [in 1987]. There may have been some slight improvements in the software along the way, but the interface remains almost the same. This seems shockingly outdated. They should hire an UX Expert and rewrite the whole thing with React
- j_walter 5y agoYes, the company that has overtaken the other Semiconductor giants like Intel and Samsung must be doing a poor job with their internal tools. Not every company uses Matlab or Mathworks to analyze data...they take the simple stuff that works and form it into something no frills and useful. A brand new engineer out of college may not realize it, but there are reasons why they do what they do.
- heleninboodler 5y ago> “That’s a lot of the work day. Some of the solution may be in software. Most of these meetings could be automated. The engineer who last worked with the equipment would record tool status and changes and make recommendations” to the next shift. ... since 1987. This process sounds like a liability to me. If you're having daily hours-long meetings for humans to communicate information to other humans, who then have to manually incorporate that information into their operations, and people who know the process say it could be automated, this sounds like a massive inefficiency (and opportunity for error) that only exists because labor has always been cheap enough to allow it to continue. Why wouldn't you spend a little money trying to optimize it?
- j_walter 5y agoIt sounds like inefficiency to those that don't understand the process. These engineers are working on equipment that costs $10M-150M each. Having a long meeting in person meeting to discuss ongoing issues is not a liability. A brand new engineer probably doesn't realize the value in having face to face communication. Also...they didn't say it hasn't been changed since 1987, it's just the same system (like saying I have been using Windows since 1995).
- cppjim 5y agoI thought it was common for fab operators to work a 11 hour shifts in the US. Also, if Samsung can figure out how to work with Americans, I'm sure TSMC can too.
- j_walter 5y agoFab operators and technicians generally work compressed shifts yes, but not usually engineers which is what the glassdoor reviewer is. Engineers work M-F usually and generally 8-5, but when the fab needs them they are there. That may entail the occasional 12 hour day, but that is what comes with the job (and the pay).
- deepnotderp 5y agoNone of this makes sense. 1. Long shifts are normal for fab operators in the U.S., eg Intel. 2. Certain engineers are always on call if an emergency happens, also true at Intel. 3. Samsung, not exactly the “live slow and enjoy life” type of culture as an employer operates fabs just fine in the U.S.
- kurthr 5y agoAgreed, and it's been that way since the 80s. The building & equipment has always cost more than staff & engineers. The "R&D Fab" is in Taiwan. These are going to be exempt employees. What's the agenda here?
- mlindner 5y agoIntel has people work "more than 12-hour workdays" often?
- mjevans 5y agoProbably yes. Major manufacturing sites are often CONTINUOUSLY (24/365.25+) staffed with "12 hour" shifts that include overlap via a lunch and normal breaks making those at least 13 hours of on site time long. One body slot takes 4 people to fill that way, but that leaves zero slack for vacation, sick days, etc.
- imgabe 5y agoI'm also confused. It's not like the US doesn't have factories that run 24/7. I spent a summer working swing shifts 12 hours a day, 3 days on, 3 days off.
- dehrmann 5y ago> Our analysis software has been passed down since the establishment of the company [in 1987]. I almost miss those old DOS UIs.
- hbcondo714 5y agoArizona employees are mainly recent graduates who have zero working experience...Most of them probably have never been to Asia Going to Asia would be a fantastic opportunity for these employees. I hope TSMC takes some to their corporate headquarters in Taiwan.
- avirut 5y agoThey already are - looks like a super cool opportunity, too, 12-18 months in Taiwan! https://tsmccareers.com/entry-level-engineer-training/ https://tsmccareers.com/entry-level-engineer-training/
- PaywallBuster 5y agotl;dr labor in taiwan is cheap enough that they've continued to use the same old software with lots of manual steps filled in by the labor
- rdtwo 5y agoIf you pay for 8 and work people 12 then labor is cheap
- hnburnsy 5y ago>Moving 1,000 employees from Taiwan to Arizona won’t work, she added. Fab employees must be part of the local culture. That strategy may have some shortcomings, however. Arizona employees are mainly recent graduates who have “zero working experience,”according to Gao. “Most of them probably have never been to Asia. So cross-cultural communication and collaboration is very important.” AZ has 10 semiconductor plants in AZ across 6 different companies not including the new TSMC one. There will be plenty of employees to recruit who have experience. I am sure this was a primary reason for selecting the site in AZ. >The biggest may be moving the entire supply chain of test-and-assembly companies and materials suppliers to the U.S., according to the principal engineer in Taiwan. ASML, Applied Materials, LCY, Chang Chun Group, and Nova have or are building facilities in AZ. There will be plenty of suppliers and experience for TSMC to choose from. How can the article be so poorly researched as to not mention this?
- j_walter 5y agoThey don't want experienced people from other fabs. That's the whole point...forming a former Intel engineer to the TSMC way is extremely difficult and the success rate is extremely low. A recent grad is malleable and they don't have preconceptions about how they did things at the last place they worked (that fell behind in the technology race).
- disillusioned 5y agoHell, the semiconductor industry is what brought my family out to Arizona in 1993. My dad was transferred as a packaging engineer for Olin Chemical when they opened their high purity doping chemicals plant in Mesa, Arizona. At the time, I believe they were supplying to Motorola which eventually became On Semiconductor and Freescale/NXP. Oh, and Intel has had a fab in Chandler since 1980, and the massive Fab 12 site since 1996. And they're building two new fabs for $20B. If there's literally anywhere in the US equipped for the semiconductor supply chain... it's here in Arizona.
- rbanffy 5y ago> Arizona employees are mainly recent graduates who have “zero working experience,” But, hey, they are much cheaper and tolerant to long hours.
- sverhagen 5y agoSo, they spoke with one anonymous staff member, and then sourced, wait for it... Glassdoor. I'm not saying these claims are untrue or that they even seem untrue, but it's still squeezing an article out of... not a whole lot. Glassdoor doesn't have a reputation (in my circles) for "balanced opinions".
- sdoering 5y agoWhen looking at or using platforms like Glasdoor one always has to take the "selection bias" into account. People posting on a platform selfselect. And it is often when something is wrong, that one tends to feel the need to communicate that. When all is fine there often just is no need to communicate that. So using Glasdoor without taking this into consideration is at least an interesting editorial decision.
- wolframhempel 5y agoOn average, reviews tend to the extremes, whether on Glassdoor, Amazon, or anywhere else. People with balanced experiences feel less of a need to voice them than people who are elated or furious about a job or product.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThat's exactly it, a lot of people will only leave a review if they have something negative to say, be it Glassdoor, App Store, webshops, etc. This is why apps prompt you to leave a review (sometimes offering rewards, often encouraging you to leave five stars), because without that prompt, content or happy people wouldn't leave a review.
- ksec 5y agoThe "exact" same comment has been circulating since late 2020 before it even appeared on Glassdoor. I mean I even wrote about it on HN [1] twenty days before hand. And my knowledge of it didn't came from Glassdoor. At first I thought it could be some sort of smear / PR campaign. But given the time it took to MSM media this doesn't seems to be the case. And yes work culture is quite different, you are expected long hours in TSMC ( It is well known within Taiwan ), but it is not "that" much different to working in Samsung or Intel Foundry. As deepnotderp pointed out in the current top post. You want to catch up to the world's leading edge TSMC foundry? You work hard! You dont want Intel and Samsung to catch up to TSMC, you work harder. In many cases, I found people often dont appreciate the pathetic small amount of money they paid for something that is at the leading edge of science and engineering. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29583206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29583206
- blueblisters 5y agoSomewhat similar/relevant: Taiwan’s Tech Giants Are Being Hit by India Culture Shock (https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/taiwans-tech-giants-are-being-hit-by-india-culture-shock/2022/01/03/e75563c6-6ced-11ec-b1e2-0539da8f4451_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/taiwans-tech-giants-...)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _ht0b 5y agoI work at another semiconductor manufacturer in the US. You could find and replace TSMC with my employer and write the exact same article. Re: giving PhDs menial tasks and working a lot/odd hours I've spent a lot of time thinking about it and it actually makes a certain kind of sense. From an engineering standpoint, there can be a lot variability in the amount of work needed. Some days you are on fire solving issues with the tools and some days there is almost nothing to do. Better to hire one PhD who is used to that kind of variable pace and pay them a relatively high, fixed salary, rather than 2-4 bachelors covering all shifts who will eat up more payroll, have lower peak effectiveness, and have even less to do per person. The pointless, excessive meetings likely exist to fill up the extra downtime and are easily skipped when you have real work to do (or if, realizing they serve no purpose, you come up with schemes to get out of them). If TSMC is doing the exact same thing on this front, I am even more convinced the so-called headcount shortage will never be fixed.
- jve 5y ago> Some days you are on fire solving issues with the tools and some days there is almost nothing to do Being programmer/sysadmin, I've never ever encountered such a day. A day with very low productivity? Yes. But not that the task list is short. Are there really days when you have nothing to do within any engineering job? Ofcourse, different jobs etc, but I suspect when everything is working, you still have to do maintenance. If not, you may fill your time by learning new/effective ways of doing your work, etc. > Better to hire one PhD... rather than 2-4 bachelors... Speculation? Having PhD in title really makes you more effective? For sure, it's a proof you had research in some niche topic. Good if they can utilize that at work and be more effective. Non-PhDs can also do research that brings fruits to your labor.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoMy experience with PhDs (at least without years of relevant industry experience) is that they are, unsurprisingly, good at research and developing early prototypes but not so good at engineering and at getting commercial products done. So it really depends on the job and individual skills, indeed. For software dev (which is what I know best) I would definitely choose to hire several smart, down to Earth bachelors rather than one PhD.
- poxwole 5y agoI actually worked in TSMC Fabs. It made me suicidal. 14 hour days 7 days a week
- guard0g 5y agoLabor costs are probably the major reason why US chip firms went fabless in the past few decades. Chip production in the lower 48 makes rational sense for national security but not necessarily economic sense. The higher labor costs will be passed through to the supply chain ultimately to spendthrift consumers. Note the comparison to Wall Street investment banking culture, where you work 14+ hrs a day 7 days a week (and you wanted to).
- stunt 5y agoI thought everyone already knew this! Labor cost and work conditions in East Asia is very different.
- djohnston 5y agoHot take - this story is a plant and completely fabricated. A journalist using an anonymous tip on Glassdoor just screams bullshit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sbolt 5y agoI highly recommend the documentary American Factory which highlights similar culture clashes in a windshield factory in Ohio. Trailer: https://youtu.be/m36QeKOJ2Fc https://youtu.be/m36QeKOJ2Fc
- mizzao 5y agoWhen did this fab start getting built? Was it a response to concentration of semiconductor manufacturing in Taiwan and the risk from China?
- neonihil 5y agoIt’s like: People: We want stuff cheaply, immediately and in immense volume! Production: Moves to Asia People: We want jobs! Production: Opens a new factory in the USA People: We don’t want to work that much! Production: increases pay, which increases product cost People: this is too expensive. Can we buy from overseas cheaply instead? Production: Closes USA factory, moves back to Asia. People: we want jobs…
- avs733 5y agoor... "we want reasonable jobs that allow us to have a life and do not functionally make us the property of a corporate entity that does not share sufficient amounts of the gains of our labor with us and labels requests to be treated with respect as unintelligible" States/those with power claiming things are 'unintelligible' when in fact they just don't like them or want to treat them as valid is a classic form of control.
- bravo22 5y agoThe power they have over the "corporate" entity is a function of what they have to offer relative to everyone else. A few decades ago when US corps made everything and the rest of the world bought them they could demand high paying union jobs and get them. The cost of this was subsidized by buyers from around the world and cheap input material and energy corps could get due to US's geopolitical position. That ship has sailed. Now they have to be more in line with the rest of the world. What the "corporation" can offer and survive or stay ahead of the pack is a function of choices available to it. Which are different now than decades ago. This myth that Americans can demand better things that the rest of the world can't needs to die. If they want to work less, great! They can. They need to become more efficient and produce more goods with less labor. Otherwise people in other countries will not want to trade with them. That is reflected to the American worker through the set of jobs and work conditions available to them.
- colinmhayes 5y agoWorkers have to compete with everyone else in the world. If a company employs American workers who demand high wages to do the same work that international workers do for less pay that company will fail. The economy is a competition, companies can't just give away money.
- taubek 5y agoThis has reminded me of the movie American Factory (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9351980/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9351980/).
- gigatexal 5y agoFrom the article: “TSMC will have to change to an eight-hour work day five days a week.” They could have paid me a few thousand bucks as a consultant to tell them that's standard operating procedure around the US ... they could use hourly employees and offer overtime but they can't expect it. Do multiple shifts -- day and night shifts. How did nobody do due dilligence before setting up fabs in the US?
- bllguo 5y agoyou talk like TSMC and Taiwan wanted to set up US fabs in the first place It's almost amusing, force them to come open a plant and then castigate them for not accommodating US culture
- gigatexal 5y agoI mean fabs are billions of dollars. Even if forced to open one they’re too expensive to do so poorly. Best to find a way to make it profitable than to throw a hissy fit about it and pout.
- jmpman 5y agoI’ve known many Intel process engineers who’ve worked 80 hour weeks for years on end. This 48 hour TSMC demand would be a relief. Unfortunately, while TSMC moved to AZ, the moved to the other side of Phoenix from the existing Fabs. An Intel engineer isn’t going to just wake up one day and decide to change jobs to TSMC. They’re an hour and a half away from each other during the morning commute. So now, the engineer needs to sell their house, move their kids to a different school. Ridiculous. It’s going to be a rare Intel engineer that’s willing to make that jump. They’re going to get the engineers who are running away from Intel, not the good ones.
- mywittyname 5y agoI feel like your post is incongruent. Intel engineers wouldn't be willing to endure a 10-14 hour longer commute to save 32 hours of working time? Moving an hour down the road isn't a big deal. I've done so many times. You don't even need special moving companies and looking at houses isn't a huge deal if you batch them up.
- jmpman 5y agoThe barrier to move an hour and a half is less than moving across country, but it’s not insignificant. Your kids are changing school/school districts. You’re finding a new church. Your friends who you met for dinner each Friday - not going to see them but once a month now. Your relatives that you invited over for dinner every Tuesday - you’ll see them on birthdays and the holidays. The distance is too far to comfortably commute for more than a year. I did roughly half that same commute for 2 years and it was mentally taxing. And no, the engineers who are working 80 hours a week aren’t “normal” people who are all of a sudden going to start working just 48 hours a week. Btw, the Intel engineers in Chandler aren’t the cause of Intel’s process woes. They’re world class. TSMC is hiring fresh new hires, from a generation that doesn’t yet know or celebrate hard work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CookiesNCream23 5y agoMore insight from me. First, the structure. TSMC will have tool owners who manage the tool on their side. The tool suppliers will have engineers who maintain the tools from their side. A tool is a piece of equipment involved in the manufacturing process. This relationship is interesting. The tool owner's performance is heavily dependent upon their ability to maximize availability. This mainly involves managing relationships with the suppliers and fighting for more resources from the supplier's engineers to fix the tools. Supplier sign availability contracts to provide maintenance for the tools. There is a lot of pressure and politics involved. Second is hiring. Onboarding is a big problem. Training a college grad from scratch requires 1.5 years, a lot of domain knowledge. It is a huge investment to fly them around the world to different training sites and to give them opportunities to practice on the tools. Lastly is culture. TSMC pushes their guys and their tools to their limits. They work in high pressure environments and are expected to proactively step up. In Taiwan, the managers often yell at their workers and the workers have little room to negotiate. TSMC tool owners know a lot more about how the tools work than their competitors, sometimes even more than their suppliers. TSMC tool owners often step in and do things themselves. TSMC will also not be able to hire the same quality of talent as in Taiwan. TSMC in Taiwan pays more and has higher prestige. This is not the same in Arizona. They will also have trouble convincing "target school" talent to relocate to Arizona. Now what does this amount to? First, the supplier's engineers will have options to work for Intel and Samsung and will probability prefer to work at those sites. Intel has the best work culture. Quality, safety, etc. This will force TSMC to make changes. Second, TSMC will have trouble keeping talent if they push phds to work as tool owners, as the job market provides better opportunities in the US. This will result in the new fab to staffed with more inexperienced workers. This is very problematic because domain knowledge from experience in this field is key. The inexperience will result in availability issues (5-10 percent) affect production. So what should TSMC do? What TSMC must adapt to the local culture and lower their expectations. They must be able to convince experienced engineers to work at their site. They can also push this to their supplier's side in terms of availability contracts. They need to relocated some experienced process engineers and tool owners from Taiwan or the throughput and yield will drop. If they do hire new talent, they have a great opportunity to break industry norms. This industry is filled with bad practices from older engineers. These habits are incredibly difficult to break. If they train new engineers correctly, they can outperform the older engineers. End of the day, the fab will come up, it will run. The question is how many chips will they be able to produce in the first few years.
- hourislate 5y agoAmerican Factory. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9351980/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9351980/ >In post-industrial Ohio, a Chinese billionaire opens a factory in an abandoned General Motors plant, hiring two thousand Americans. Early days of hope and optimism give way to setbacks as high-tech China clashes with working-class America.
- jagtesh 5y agoThis reminds me of the documentary titled "The American Factory"[1]. The teams at TSMC would do well to learn from their experience. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Factory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Factory
- specialist 5y agoObjections over long hours? Unlikely. Assuming TSMC (and their contractors) pays overtime... I want quotes from actual people doing the work. My bestie was a welder working on fabs in the 80s and 90s. In Phoenix. Lax regulation, lax oversight. He loved the work, loved the pay. And he locked horns with mgmt. Every single day. Mostly over safety issues. Cutting corners, skipping steps, providing the necessary training. And all of his employers were USA corporations. Even back then, operational fabs make millions of dollars per day. Clock is ticking! Every day, hour, minute the fab isn't running is pure waste. The pressure to "get 'er done!" is immense. They couldn't fire my welder buddy, much as they wanted to, because specialists like him were so scarce. This is not a "cultural" mismatch. Please. This is straight up mgmt vs labor. As old as history. Lather, rinse, repeat.